Price stability and the inter-industry propagation of
Transkript
Price stability and the inter-industry propagation of
Price Stability
and the Inter-industry
Propagation
Stochastic Impulse:
Formulating dynamic price equation and
an application of the Langevin equation
Hitoshi
Hayami
July 2001
KEO Discussion
Paper No. 62
of
Price
Stability
and the Inter-industry
Propagation
of
Stochastic Impulse:
Formulating dynamic price equation and
an applicationof the Langevin equation*
Hitoshi
Hayami
Keio Economic Observatory
Keio University
July 2001
*This research
Economic
is supported
Observatory
paper is preliminary,
by Seimei -kai fund.
for their encouragement.
please do not quote without
i would
like to thank
my colleagues
Any errors remain the author's
the author's
permission.
responsibility.
of Keio
This
Abstract
Dynamicprice equationhas a feedbackeffectfrom the capitalgain/lossof
its user's cost of capital. Hayami[1993]developedthe model which endogenously determinesthe capital goodsprices,and this paper investigatesmore
generalcharacteristicsof the system,and extendsit intoincorporatingstochastic fluctuationdue to the totalfactorproductivity(TFP).Thelatterextensionto
stochasticsystem has beendevelopedby Hayami [1999]. In a deterministic
model,the system's stabilitydependson the degreeof out-sourcingof capital
goods, relatively higher out-sourcing causes the system into saddle point equilibrium. This paper presents all the possible steady states in the dynamic price
equation, and draws their phase portraits.
Key words: propagation, impulse, capital goods, price equation, nonlinearity, multi-sectoral, total factor productivity.
1
Introduction
Very rapid price decrease of semi-conductor and of its products such as PC has been
common phenomena in recent years.2 These products are capital goods, because
they are durable and used in the industry sectors. The price of capital goods has not
only instantaneous effects on the economy, but also has persistent effects through
the installed equipment and the opportunity costs.
This paper investigates the fluctuation of prices including prices of capital goods
through the inter-industry propagation mechanism. The most comprehensive data
that are designed to incorporate the inter-industry propagation mechanism is the
Leontief's input-output table. Leontief [1970] proposed the dynamic inverse model
within the constant input coefficient matrix. I extend the Leontief's dynamic inverse
model into the model consistent with the growth accounts.3 Hayami [1993] studies
the two sector model using a numerical method, here I presents the general formula
classifying characteristics of price fluctuation and its steady state .
The early attempts to investigate economic fluctuations through the inter-industry
transactions are by Frisch [1933] and [1934]. Frisch [1933] summarises three types
of propagation problem: (1) the time lag between production and completing the
production of capital goods. Aftalion [1913, 1927] investigates this propagation
system. (2) Accumulation of erratic shocks. Slutzky [1927] and Yule [1927] derived several stochastic processes that have oscillation. (3) The innovation as an
impulse and its reaction. Frisch sites Schumpeter's business cycle model.
2Theprice of PC decreasedat over -17% pa. as Hulten[1990]refers.
3The growthaccountsare one of the most common indiceson prices and quantity
, becausethe
Divisiaindex satisfieswith the conditionsof Fisher's tests for the ideal index numbers, Richter's
invarianceaxiom, and Hulten'spathindependency.
1
T
Frisch [1934] considers cycles caused by a random impulse, e.g. Norway's
lottery using a transaction model between shoe makers and farmers . But the model
assumes fixed prices or given prices under the business cycles.
There are a lot of contributions on multi-sectoral economic dynamics in the last
half of 20th century.4 I proposes the model with observable variables. "Observable", I mean, it is ready to obtain the parameters or the data from statistical survey .
More precisely, I construct on the bases of the growth accounts equality, the Divisia
index, which is now commonly used to calculate the total factor productivity. The
most difficult data that I assumed is capital goods and the depreciation. I would like
to avoid all the difficulty concerned with measurement of capital and depreciation,
thus I adopt the simplest formulation though it is not enough to link the actual statistics with the model.5 I assumed that capital is a bundle of commodities that can be
used over the period, and that the same commodity such as glass, or computer: can
be utilised as capital goods, intermediate inputs and final demand.
2
Definitions
and
the growth
accounts
In the introduction I point out that a rapid growth of the total factor productivity in
a sector may give rise to the increase of unit cost for another sectors through capital
loss of the installed equipment, and this may cause volatile price fluctuation in the
economy as a whole. In this section, I present a basic equation to show how the
prices transmit across the sectors. It is not necessary to provide an optimal control
model in order to describe the price interdependency between sectors, but some
justification of the definition on cost of capital that I use may be necessary. First I
show one of the possible explanation of the cost of capital, and next introduce the
price equations based on the growth accounts of cost.
Consider a cost minimising production sector using materials, labour inputs and
capital goods. The producer of a commodity x will minimise the cost C over the
planning period (0, T) with a discount rate r.
C`
0
c(t)e-'tdt,
(1)
where c(t) is an instant cost and defined as the sum of labour, material and invest4For example , Leontief [1970], I will show the difference from our model lately,describes using the input-output tables. Goodwin [1953] proposed linear multi-sectoral model, and recently
Antonello [1999] described Goodwin's model in terms of an optimal control problem. Nishimura
[2001] surveys non-linear dynamics using optimal growth model with multi-sectoral capital goods.
5Hulten [1990] surveys problems associated with the measurement of capital
, and Diewert [1980]
surveys aggregation problems on the capital.
2
ment
costs:
c(t) = w'l -}- px'x -}- pI'xI,
(2)
where w, px, pI denotes nL wages, n material prices , and n prices of investment
goods respectively. 1, x, xI denotes nL types of labour, n kinds of materials, and
n kinds of investment goods respectively. There are n kinds of commodity in the
economy, each commodity can be used as either material , investment or consumption.
The producer is subject to the current production technology , which is described
as
f(y,1, x, k) =0,
(3)
where y denotes an output commodity (or commodity vector) that this sector produces, and k denotes capital commodity vector that forms into the sector's equipment and the other durables.
The producer minimise eq (1) subject to eq (3) and a capital formation equation (4)
lc = xI -- Sk,
(4)
where k denotes the time derivative of capital goods vector dk/ dt , and S denotes
a diagonal matrix of depreciation for each capital goods.6
51 0 •••
0 b2 •••
0
0
0
bn
S=
0
•..
The first order (necessary) conditions are derived from either the calculus of
variations or the dynamic programming, expressed as follows:
bG
W-aaf
=
bl
SG
of
e-rt
bx
bG
=
bk
=0
al
e-rt
Px - Ax`
a bPi - A of
ak
(5)
=0
)-
(6)
d
dt
ae-rtc(t)
ak
6See Hulten and Wykoff [1981] and Hulten [1990] for problems of the f
ormulation. Several other
types of depreciation and aggregation formula have been proposed, but many economic theorists do
not consider these problems seriously, see for example Nishimura [2001].
3
e-rt
(6pi
--Aak +e-rirPi- dt
e-rt
((TI
+b- n)p1
--Aof =0,
of
d
ak
(7)
where A denotes the Lagrange multiplier, I denotes the identical matrix of n x n
dimension, it denotes the diagonal matrix of n x n dimension, the diagonal element
is capital gain from each capital goods pIj/pI.
7C=
dlnpit
d
t
0
o
...
0
dlnP[z ...
dt
0
0
...
d~Pln-
Equations (5)-(7) show that this first order condition is interpreted as static cost
minimisation with 1, x, k, if the cost of capital is defined by (rI + b - ir)pI .
The total cost can be defined with the user cost of capital as follows:
C = w'1 + px'x + {(rI + b - 7r)pt}'x1.
(8)
Assume the producer minimise the cost (8) with respect to 1, x, and k subject to
the production technology (3) under the given input prices w, pX, r, b and PI.
The same system of equations as eqs. (5)-(7) can be obtained from the first order
condition.
The user's cost of capital is not necessary to be derived from the dynamic programming/the calculus of variations, because the user's cost is actually an opportunity cost of capital goods for a unit of period. The opportunity cost consists of
the interest earnings from the same amount of investment for securities rpik, the
physical depreciation of the capital bplk, minus the capital gain from selling the
capital k at the end of a period pik, assuming the existence of a complete capital
market for simplicity.
There are a lot of criticism about the formulation of optimisation, and the production functions incorporating capital stock. As Leontief [1982] criticised the transcendental logarithmic production function, its parameters still have "not be identified with those directly observable in the real world". In this paper, I would not
say that the production technology (3) has directly observable parameters. But I
would like to mention the equivalence of the total cost whether it is derived from
an optimisation with a production function or from a definition of opportunity cost
user's cost of capital.
Leontief dynamics [1970] is the system of equations that describes physical
balance of demand and supply.
xt - Axt - Bt+1(xt+i - xt) = ct,
4
(9)
where At denotes the input coefficientmatrix at t, and Bt+1 denotes the capital
coefficientmatrix,"capitalgoodsproducedin year t are assumedto be installedand
put into operationin the next year t+l", and ct denotesfinal demandvector.
Leontief [1970] proposes the followingassociated cost accounting, which is
dual to eq (9).
Pt = Atpt + (1 + rt-i) Btpt_1 - Bt+iPt + vt,
where
a vector
rdenotes
the annual
of the value added
money
rate of interest
per unit of its output.
prevailing
This equation
(10)
in that year , and vt
can be rewritten
as
follows:
Pt = Atpt + (rt-iI -~it)Btpt_1 - (Bt+t - Bt)Pt +vt,
This system of equations
(11)
implies that the price of output pt is equal to the sum of
the unit cost of materialsAtpt, the valueadded per outputvt, whichincludesemploymentcost and depreciation,and the user's cost of net capital (rt_i I-it) Btpt_1,
minusthe technicalchange (Bt+1-- Bt)pt.
The similar procedurecan be applied to the total cost (8), but I take the total
derivativesof logarithmsof the totalcost to decomposeper cent changeof the total
cost into per cent change of the inputs, the input prices and the total productivity
change.
First take total derivativeof logarithmof the total cost C:
dln C = SL' (dlnw + dlnt) -+-sx' (dlnpx + dlnx) ± SK' (dlnpK + dlnk) ,
(12)
where SLdenotesthe labour's cost share vector of its elementwilt/C , sx denotes
the material's cost share vector of its element pxixi/C, SKdenotes the capital's
cost share vector of its elementpKiki/C, and pK denotesthe user's cost of capital
(rI + S i- it)pI.
Next introducethe total factorproductivity(TFP)that is the total outputper unit
of the total inputs,and its growthrate is definedas follows:
dlnTFP = dlnX-- (sL'dlnt+sx'dlnx+sx'dlnk),
(13)
where d In X denotesthe total outputindex that is usually expressedin differential
form as
dlnX= sy'dlny.
sY denotesthe valueoutputshare vectorof its elementpiyi/
the output vector as before.
7Leontief
[1970]
, andreprinted
in Leontief
[1986]p.295.
5
p;y3, and y denotes
Using the definition of the total factor productivity, the equation (12) becomes
as follows:
d In C =
din C/X
=
sL'd In w + sx'd In px + sK'd In pK + d In X - d In TFP
sL'd In w + sx'd In px + sK'd In pK - d In TFP.
(14)
This simply implies that growth rate of the unit cost per unit of output is equal
to the sum of growth rate of the wages, the material prices and the user's cost of
capital, minus the growth rate of the total factor productivity.
The growth rate of the user's cost of capital is expressed as the sum of growth
rate of its components. Since rI, S, and 7r are all diagonal matrices, din pK can be
expressed using :
d In pK
dln(rI+6-ir)pj
n
(r + & - din p11/dt)pI1
(r+ b2 - d In p12/dt)p12 di
(r+ 5 - d In p1n/dt)p1n
dln (r+ 61 - dlnpl1/dt) + dlnp11
din (r+ b2 - dlnp12/dt) + dlnP12
din (r + 5, . - d In p1n/dt) + d In p1n
dlnr+dln61-d2 1np11/dt '' d1npI1
r+6i-dlnpl1/dt
dlnr+dlnb2-d21np12/dt
+ di
r+62-dlnp12/dt
n P12
dlnr+dln5n-d2lnpln/dt
r+6
, -dlnp[n/dt
+ di
n p111
(rI + b -ir)-1 ((drI + db)1 - d2lnpl/dt) + dlnpI, (15)
where 1 denotes the column vector of 1.
Before inserting eq (15) into eq (14), remember that the above formulation is
for a sector, which is to be considered as the j-th sector, and introduce the following
assumptions for simplicity.
Assumption: Average cost Average cost of production C; /X5 for the j-th sector
is equal to the output price of that sector p5.
C--=p5 , (j = 1,..., n.).
6
Assumption: No joint production
for all j.
The j-th sector produces the single output X;
Assumption: Notation of the commodity Each output can be used as a material
and also as a capital goods, there is n kinds of commodities in the economy. Prices
for investment goods pI, for materials px, and for outputs p are no longer to be
distinguished.
P=Pi=Px
Using these assumptions, the balance between input cost and output price is
written as follows:
d Inp; = sLid Inw + sxid Inp
+sx~(r;I + b; - rrr1 ((dr;I + db;)1- d21np/dt)
+sK;dlnp- d1nTFP;, (j = 1,.. .,n).
Divide
both
the growth
side of the equation
by dt, then the equation
is expressed
in terms
(16)
of
rate per unit of time.
dlnpi
d
t
_
! dlnw
SLj dt
! dln _
+ Sx7 dt
+SKj
(rjI+sj-~)_1((vi +) 1- da
(17)
i d1n - dInTFPi
In the economy as a whole, the above system of equations are described as
follows:
dln
dt
= Sx dln + SKdln - Srd2 `~
+SL dInW
dt
dt d In~p
(18)
dt + (pSr + Sd) 1 dt
Eq (18) of the growth account equations corresponds to the Leontief's price equation (11).
Definitions of the matrices are as follows:
SL11 SL21
SL12 SL22
SLnLI
SLnL2
SL1
SL2n " '
SLn1n
SX11
SX12
SX21
SX22 ...
SXn1
SXn2
SXIn
SX2rL ...
SXnn
SL=
Sx =
7
d
at
0
0 ...
0
dt
0
...
P=
00...
dt
SK2t
dln~
1+S21- dt
SK22
1
dinpz
2+522- dt
SKtt
SK 1
r1+Sn1dt
SKn2 _
r2+62_:
nd
llia
r
dt
Sr =
_
_S_K 12
T2+S12-dlnpl dt
SKIn
n+bin--dt-~
__2r. SK----d
T
Inp 2
n+b2ndt
d Inp r
SKttddb ~-
Sd=
,,,
-_
SKnn
1+&d Inpn
S
dbnl
KnI __dt ...
T1+b
d ln~Tl
n1dt
_SK21_dh
r1 +b21d
dl"p~ r
1+b11- dt
SK 12 bs13~
di _.
ng 1
2+51 2T d
_
S_K
22ddbdinp~
dt
z 12+S22...
di
dbt~
----51C
ln dt
dlnp
Tn+bin- dt
SKnndd ri.
...--
Tn+bnn-d~~.
rn+b2n_dlnp
SK11
SK21
'
SK12
SK22
'
SKIn
SK2n
•
SKn1
SKn2
SK
Definitions
of the vectors
SKnn
are as follows:
dlnpl
dIn
din p
dt
dt
d~Pn
dt
dlnw~
dlnwz
dt
din w
dt
dlnwnL
dt
_dIn TFP1
d 1n'P,
dt
din 1FP
dt
d In TFPn
-at
8
SKn2 d 2
T2+bn2- d In
dtUn
_
d21n
d2Inp
d
p
t
.
dt2
d21npn
d ~t
The other
definitions
of variables
Stij
are as follows:
_____ ,
Sxi = pjXij
SKI; = SKI;= p C
pt
dinp.
Ci
stl; is the i-th labour's cost share in the j-th sector, likewise sxl; is the i-th material's
cost share in the j-th sector, and sKI;is the i-th capital goods' cost share in the j-th
sector. There are nt types of labour.,n types of materials and capital goods.
In eq (18), transpose the terms with d In p/dt to the left hand side, the system
becomes as follows:
Srd2dt
-}-(I - Sx -- SK) dPdt
=
d~nTFP
®SL alnw
_ (pSr -I- Sd)1.
dt
dt
(19)
I investigate this system of equations, which is non-linear with respect to din p/dt,
because Sr includes d in p/dt, even if all the cost share matrices are assumed to be
constant.8 This system is homogeneous degree zero in prices, because the equations
does not change if all the prices grow at A > 0, Ap, Aw, when
(I--Sx-'SK-SL)1
=0.
If wages w adjust to cancel the effect of the total factor productivity fluctuation,
while the interest rate and the depreciation keep unchanged, the system becomes
autonomous.
3
An autonomous
system
of the price
propagation
In thissection,an autonomous
systemof the priceequationeq (20)is investigated.
For simplicity,assumethatall thecost sharesareconstantthroughthispaper.
8Hayami[1993] proposed the same equations as a different form
. Although my previous formulation contains errors of notations, the two sector model in that paper is exactly the same as this. As
to nonlinear dynamical systems see for example, Guckenheimer Holms [1990].
9
z
Assumption:
time.
Constant
cost shares
The cost shares Sx, SK, SL are constant over
Srdd' + (I - Sx- SK)aap = 0.
(20)
This is, in fact, a first order differential equation system for the rate of price changes .
The system is non-linear, since Sr depends on d in p/dt. Let z denote d in p/dt
for simplicity, and the system is expressed as follows:
Sr(z)a
=
dln
(I-Sx-SK)z,
_
(21)
dt - Z
There are two special cases to be remarked. One of them is the singular matrix
Sr (z) . If the matrix Sr (z) is singular, the system cannot describe price changes.
The other is that price change of a sector z;, is equal to r; + E. In this case, one of
the elements of the matrix Sr(z) becomes infinitely positive or infinitely negative.
The behaviour of the price changes around these points may change drastically.
Except for these cases, the system has a fixed point z = 0. And the behaviour
of the price changes around the fixed point can be described using the eigenvalues
of the following Jacobian matrix of first partial derivatives at z = 0.
J(z)_ -DZ(Sr(z)_1
(I--Sx--SK)
z),
(22)
where DZ denotes a vector partial derivative operator [a/azi} that operates a vector
valued function.
Ja with parameters c may have a zero eigenvalue at the fixed point z = 0,
the point (0, c ) should be a bifurcation point. But the following discussion shows
that this system does not have a bifurcation phenomenon. The matrix Sr (z) -1
(I--Sx-S)
can be expressed by W(z) in general.
1W1i(z)z;
~~ t W2i(Z)Zi
W(z)z
L-j=1Wni(z)zi
DZ (W(z)z)
_
DZ
1W1i(z)zi
L=1 W2i(z)z;
1Wni (z)zj
10
DZ (W(z)z)
=
+w11
n
aW2
~1=1 a
1as'~-z;
+ W~2... ~n 1aw2j+ ~/1n
+ W21 ~--;=1az2 + W22 ... i:;n=1 aazn~
ZZ7+ W2n
~ =1as ~;+ Wnl ~g 1as2n;z;+ Wn2... ~nJ l awn;
aZn,~ + Wnn
Thus the Jacobianmatrixat z=0 is
DZ(W(z)z) Iz=o =
W11(0) W12(0) ...
W21(0) Wu(0) ...
W1(0)
W2n(0)
W1(0)
Wnn(0)
Sr(0i
Wn2(0) ...
(I - SX- SK),
(23)
The determinant of a product of two n x n matrices is a product of two determinants
of n x n matrices suggests.that
IDz (W(z)z) IZ..oI -
ISr(0)-111I - SX - SKI
(24)
The determinants II - SX ---SKI does not become zero because of the HawkinsSimon's condition, and the determinants ISr ( 0)_i i is a reciprocal of ISr (0)1. ISr ( 0)1
is possible to be zero, but not infinity large, unless both the interest rate and the depreciation rate are equal to zero.
3.1
The two sector case
To illustrate the eigenvalues of the Jacobian matrix Ja(z), I derive the two sector
system explicitly. The equation system can be described as follows (Hayami[1993]):
1 _ r+&1-z1
r1+521-z2
) (1`~X11
- K11
'~X21
K21
Z
Z2
SK11
"_
S_Ki2
r2+612-zl
SK21
-1
Sx22
r2+&22-z2
-SX12 - SK12
1 - SX22 - SK22
X))Z2
Z1
(25)
11
}
or
Z
_
i2
- -D(z)
1
~SX_12_+SK1~~SK~1
r2+622-z2
rl+b21
-z2_) Z1
~(1`SX11-SK
11)SK.z2.
+
\ (l-SX22-SK~2)SKZt_
~$K ) z 2
tl+b21
`z2 ,+., ~SXZ1+$K21
r2+622-z2
,
- i (l-$X11-SK11)SK12,~. (SX12+SK-1,i
K_11 z
r2+612-z1rt+61
1-z1
)1
+C(1-SX22-SK22)SK2j
T
r1+61
)SK
1-zl ($X21+SK21
r2+612-z1
) z2
1
where D is the determinant
(26)
of Sr,
_ SKi1SK22
_
SK12SK21
~(Z)- (r1+511
- zl)(r2
+522
- 22) (r1+521
- z2)(r2
+512
- zl)•
3.2
Behaviour
around
the fixed point
z= O
Eq (26) is still complicated to calculate the Jacobian matrix, but substituting z=0
into the Jacobian matrix makes all the derivatives related with fractions disappear .
J a(o)
1
D(O)
((1-SX11-SK11
)SKI
+($X+SK12)SK1(
(1-SX11`SK11)SK12
(SX12'}"SK~_~SK1.~
+121"
r2+612 r1+b1
t
(1-SK22
+ ($X21
±SK21)SK22
(27)
C
11+621
12+622
- ((1'_$X22-SK.22)SK1-1
)SK12,
rt+61
1 +($X21_+SK21
r2+612
)
r2+622
11 ±621
D (O) is defined as
D(0)
SK11SK22
SK12SK21
- -(
--- , --- --- Ti +611)(r2+5)
(r1 +521)(r2+612).
(28)
The system has two real eigenvalues due to the fact that product of the off diagonal elements of the Jacobian matrix Ja (0) is positive.9
9Theeigenvalues
ofa 2x 2 matrixA canbe derivedas follows:Adenotesaneigenvalue
of A.
It can be shown that the determinant of Ja (0) is
IJa (O)I _
D(Q)2
1
x
(1-SXiI"-SK
12+622
11)SK22, (SX±SK12)SK21
11+621
(1-SX12-SK22)SK11,
(SX?1'~SK21)SK12
1+611
12+612
(1-SSKZ 2)SK21
„+ (SZ1r2+622
j S.K22
rl +621
x ((1-SX11-SKJ
)SK
12+(SX12+SK12)SK~]
r2+612
11+611
--
D(o)IA
where
IAl =
(1 - SX11- SK11)(l
SX22` SK22)-" (SX12+ SK12)(SX21
+ SK21)•
(29)
Thus, the sign of the determinant IJa (0) I depends on the sign of the determinant
D (O), while IAIis positive because of the Hawkins-Simon's condition'°
The following classification of the system can be obtained.
1. If IJa (0) I > 0, i.e. D(0) > 0 the system has a fixed point of stable.
2. If IJa (0) I <0, i.e. D(0) < 0 the system has a fixed point of saddle.
3. The eigenvalues are diverge, when determinant D (0) is zero.
D(0) > 0 can be rewrite from eq (28) as:
SK11
SK22
S
> (rl + 611)(r2+ 622)
K12SK21 (r1 +621)(T2+612)
This inequality implies that relatively large input coefficient of own capital goods
than of the other sector's capital goods compared to its relative cost of the own
capital goods to cost of the other sector's capital goods. That is, given the relative
cost, if the economic system starts to be relied more heavily on outsourced capital
goods than before, the system may hit a bifurcation point that shows saddle point
instability. Substitute the definition of SKL~
into the condition, it yields the condition
in terms of capital goods quantity:
k11
k > k12
21 k22
1OThe
Hawkins
-Simon'sconditionfora twosectorinput-output
modelis as follows
, whereA is
a input-coefficient
matrix:
1-a11
-(112
--a21 1 - a22 >0.
Theconditionimpliesthesystemoperatesin positiveproductionforallthesectors.In thiscase,the
inputsarenot onlymaterialinputsSx,, butalsoincludescapitalgoodsSKI,.Thesumofbothinputs
needsto be in productionpossibility.
13
This
again
instability
shows
that the relatively
The previous
classification
3.3
own
can be interpreted
1. If S
sK
> (r,±6„)(r2±622)
K1221
SKor
(r1 +621)(r2+612)
2
large
capital
input
implies
saddle
point
of the system."
k21
Ll>
as follows.
k22 , the system
has a stable
If sK'-'sue
S
<
K12SK21
saddle.
(r1+611)(r2+622) or k11. <
(r1+&21)(r2+612)
k21
k1Z , the system
kz2
3. If 1S
s K 1sdi K12SK21
verged.
(r, +6, ,) (r2+622) or
(r1+621 )(r2+612)
k21
k22
Checking
another
fixed points
fixed point.
has a fixed point
of
of the system
is
the eigenvalue
i = 0
Set Eq (26) equal to 0, there may be another fixed points in the system . Similar discussions to the Jacobian matrix at z = 0, it can be verified that the matrix
Sr (z) -1(I ® Sx - SK)must be singularto hold the equilibriumwith z 0 . Because of II -- S,~-- SKI> 0, it shouldbe Sr (z) -1 = 0. This is impossibleunless
Sr(z) is singular.I shall show next that there are many singularpoints.
Nonethelessit is necessaryto solvethe equilibriumequationsto show the phase
portraitsof the systems. Solvethe next equationsfor z1 and z2:
i1 - 0
Z2 --- 0
(30
)
That is
(1-Sil-SK1
_)SK22,(S12+SK12~SK21 (1-s22-SK22)SK21
(S21+SK21)SK22
r2+622-z2
+ r,+62,-z2
) Z1
- ( r,+621
-Z2 + r2+622-z2
Z2
=0
((1-st,-SK11)SK12
r2+b,
2-z, +(S12+SK12)SK11
r,+6
t1-z, Z1+((1-S22-SK22)S1K11
rt+61
,-zi (S21+SK21)SKi~
r2+612-z1
) Z2
=0
(31)
There are two asymptotes in each equation. One of these is a vertical or horizontal line.
Z2 -
z
The
other
(1-S11-SK11)SK2_(rl+b21
(1-S11-SK11)SK2
)+(S12
~SK12)SK2l
(r2+622)
+(S12+SK12)SK21
(~_-S22-SK
22
)SK
1
1
(r2+61+(S21
+SK21
)SK
12
(rl +611)
(1
dzl = 0
for dt
dz
-S22-SK22)SKll+(S21+SK21)SK12 for d = 0
is a straight
or the depreciation
rate.
line of which
gradient
does
not depend
But the line is too complicate
on the interest
to describe
in terms
rate
of the
11Benhabib and Nishimura [1998] assume single interest rate and single depreciation rate
, but
introduce externality. They obtain indeterminacy, i.e. multiple equilibria in the two sector model .
14
original parameters in the system S,. or SKij. It can be shown that eq (31) can be
arranged into the following form:
z1
=
d z2 -i
d
z
Z2
~z
d~
dz
c~
- +
z
d~ (c1-d1zz)
+ (aZd?-bzcz)~2
d2 (c2-d2z2)
.
for ---- = 0
dt
for
=0
dt
,
where we temporally introduce the parameters at , bi, ci, di (i = 1, 2).
al
b1
C1
dl
a2
b2
C2
d2
=
=
=
=
==
=
=
=
(S21+
(S21+
(S12+
(S12+
(S12+
(S12+
521+
(S21+
SK21)SK22(rl+ 621)+ (1 - S22- SK22)SK21
(r2 + 622)
SK21)SK22
+ (1 - 522- SK22)SK21
SK12)SK21
(r2 + 622)+ (1 - S11- SKll)SK22(rl + 621)
SK12)SK21
+ (1 - S11`SK11 )SK22
SK12)SK11
(r2 + 612)+ (1 -511 - SK11)SK12(r1
+6) )
SK12)SK11
+ (1 - S11- SK11)SK12
SK21)SK12(rl+611)+(1 `_ S22` SK22)SK11
(r2 + 612)
SK21)SK12+ (1 - S22- SK22)SK11
If a,.d,. -- bici = 0, the second type of asymptotes disappears. Instead, equation
dzi/ dt = 0 becomes a straight line through the origin, and its gradient does not
depend on the interest rate or the depreciation rate. The gradient is determined by
the constants (here I assume that they are technological factors) Sij, and SKij.Thus,
the determinants aid,. ---bici = 0 are another important factors in the system, and
it can be shown as:
al dl - b1 c1 =
a2d2 - b2c2 =
where
IAl =
(r2 - rr + 622-' 621)SK21
SK22IAI
(r1 -T2+611 -- 612)SK11
SKI2IAI,
(1-S11 -SK11)(1 -S22-SK22)
-(S12 +SK12)(S21+51(21)
The sign of IAl is again positive because of the Hawkins-Simon's condition in
terms of the cost share, and each SKij is positive. The sign of adi -- bici = 0 is
determined by the magnitude of the interest rate and the depreciation rate.
3.4
Classification
of the autonomous
system
Summary of the above discussions provides the general classification of the two
sector system. First, the system is stable at the fixed point, or saddle at the fixed
point. Second, the sign of intercept of the asymptote for each equation it = 0 and
Z2 = 0, there are four cases. The other factor that is not considered here is the
magnitude of gradient of the asymptote.
There are at most four set of solutions for z1 and z2 including O.The other solutions are from the 3rd order polynomial equation, and the determinant vanishes at
15
the points. This situationcan be shownthe points, where three curvesintersectin
Figures3.4-3.4.
Case I The systemis stableat the fixedpointz = 0. The two asymptotesfor i~ = 0
and z2 - 0 both have positiveinterceptsto the other axis: a1d1 ---b1c> > 0,
a2d2---b2c2 > 0. An economicmeaningof theseconditionsis as followsthat
the nominalcost (interestrate and depreciation)of capitalgoods is higher in
the own sector's investmentthat the othersector's.
Case II The systemis stableat the fixedpointz = 0. The two asymptotesfor ±1=
0 and i2 = 0 both have negativeinterceptsto the otheraxis: a1d1- b 1c1 <0,
a2d2 - b2c2 <0. The nominalcost (interestrate and depreciation)of capital
goods is lower in the own sector's investmentthat the other sector's.
Case III The system is stable at the fixedpoint z = 0. The asymptotefor ±1= 0
has positiveinterceptsto z2 axis: a1d1- b1c> > 0. The asymptotefor i2 = 0
has negativeinterceptsto z1 axis: a2d2-b2c2 < 0. The nominalcost(interest
rate and depreciation)of capitalgoodsis higherin the own sector's investment
that the other sector's for the commodity2. The nominalcost (interestrate
and depreciation)of capitalgoodsis lowerin the own sector's investmentthat
the other sector's for the commodity1.
Case IV The system is stable at the fixedpoint z = 0. The asymptotefor ±1 = 0
has negativeinterceptsto z2 axis: ai d1-b1 c1 <0. The asymptotefor z2 = 0
has positiveinterceptsto z1 axis: a2d2-b2c2 > 0. The nominalcost (interest
rate and depreciation)of capitalgoodsis lower in the own sector's investment
that the other sector's for the commodity2. The nominalcost (interestrate
and depreciation)of capital goods is higher in the own sector's investment
that the other sector's for the commodity1.
The sameclassificationcan be applicableto the systemof saddlepoint.
Case V The systemhas a saddlepointat the fixedpoint z = 0. The two asymptotes
for ±1= 0 and i2 = 0 both have positiveinterceptsto the other axis: a1d1 b1c> > 0, a2d2 - b2c2 > 0. An economicmeaningof these conditionsis as
followsthat the nominalcost (interestrate and depreciation)of capitalgoods
is higher in the own sector's investmentthat the other sector's.
Case VI The system has a saddlepoint at the fixedpoint z = 0. The two asymptotes for i~ = 0 and i2 = 0 both have negativeintercepts to the other axis:
a1d1 - b 1c 1 < 0, a2d2 - b2c2 < 0. The nominal cost (interest rate and
depreciation)of capitalgoodsis lower in the own sector's investmentthat the
other sector's.
16
0.6
i
0.4
i
//
0.2
4:L
z2
0
i
-0 .2
i
-0 .4
-0.2
Eigenvectors
±1=0
z2=0
D(z)=0
i
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
zi
Figure
1: Case I: Stable
fixed point
at z = 0
Case VII The system has a saddle point at the fixed point z o 0. The asymptote for
z1 = 0 has positive intercepts to z2 axis: ai d1 -- b1 c> > 0. The asymptote for
z2 = 0 has negative intercepts to zi axis: a2d2 - b2c2 < 0. The nominal cost
(interest rate and depreciation) of capital goods is higher in the own sector's
investment that the other sector's for the commodity 2. The nominal cost
(interest rate and depreciation) of capital goods is lower in the own sector's
investment that the other sector's for the commodity 1.
Case VIII The system has a saddle point at the fixed point z = 0. The asymptote
for z~ i 0 has negative intercepts to z2 axis: a1 d1--b1 c1 <0. The asymptote
for z2 = 0 has positive intercepts to z1 axis: a2d2 -- b2c2 > 0. The nominal
cost (interest rate and depreciation) of capital goods is lower in the own sector's investment that the other sector's for the commodity 2. The nominal cost
(interest rate and depreciation) of capital goods is higher in the own sector's
investment that the other sector's for the commodity 1.
Parameter sets for the numerical illustration can be shown in Tables 1-2.
17
Table
8x11
Sx12
8x21
8x22
SK11
SK12
SK21
SK22
rl
V2
511
512
521
b22
Eigenvalue
Eigenvector
at z =0
Eigenvalue
Eigenvector
at z = 0
1: Parameter
Case I
a1 d1 - b1 C1 > 0
a2d2 - b2c2 > 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.42
0.12
0.15
0.40
0.05
0.05
0.25
0.15
0.15
0.25
0.0540706
-1 .22028
0.731968
sets for the stable
Case II
a1 d1 - b1 C1 < 0
a2d2 - b2c2 < 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.42
0.12
0.15
0.40
0.05
0.05
0.15
0.25
0.25
0.15
0.01915
-0.529053
0.726971
fixed point
Case III
al d1 - b1 C1 > 0
a2d2 - b2c2 < 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.42
0.12
0.15
0.40
0.03
0.06
0.15
0.15
0.25
0.25
0.0283218
-0 .71621
-0 .538918
0.681339
) 0.686668
)
-0 .0443101
-0 .0361967
0.615461
l
-0 .788167
/
0.610981l
-0 .791646
/
at z = 0
0.842358
-0 .039544
0.627869
0.778319
Case IV
a1 d1 - b1 C1 < 0
a2d2 - b2c2 > 0
I) (
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.42
0.12
0.15
0.40
0.06
0.03
0.15
0.15
0.25
0.25
0.0302222
-0:747259
-0 .59224
0.805762
-0 .0404441
0.61659l
0.787285
This table shows that the system has a stable fixed point at z = 0
The difference between cases I-TV comes from the interest rate and the depreciation rate. The technological parameters are common for all cases.
a1 d1 - bl c1 = (r2 - rl + b22 - &21)SK21
SK22IAI
a2d2 - b2c2 = (rt - 12+&I1 -- &12)SK11
SKI2IAI
a1 d1 - b1 c1 implies the difference of nominal cost of capital goods 2 between
the own sector 2 and the sector 1.
a2d2 - b2c2 implies the difference of nominal cost of capital goods 1 between
the own sector 1 and the sector 2.
J(0) I denotes the Jacobian at the fixed point z = 0: positive means stable around
the fixed point.
`Eigenvalues' are of the solution 11for the eq
uation, IA! - Ja(0)I = 0.
`Eigenvectors' are the associat
e vectors z* with each eigenvalue, Ja(0)z* = Az*.
18
/
Table 2: Parameter
Sx 11
Sx12
Sx21
Sx22
SK11
SK12
SK21
SK22
Ti
r2
b11
612
621
622
IJ«(a)I
Eigenvalue
Eigenvector
atz=0
Eigenvalue
Eigenvector
atz = 0
Case V
a1 d1 - b1 c1 > 0
a2d2 - b2c2 > 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
. 0.14
0.32
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.05
0.25
0.15
0.15
0.25
-0 .351
1.73559
0.508159
-0 .861263
-OZ02237
0.560947
-0.827852
sets for the saddle
Case VI
a1 d1 - b1 c1 < 0
a2d2 - b2c2 < 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.14
0.32
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.05
0.15
0.25
0.25
0.15
-1.99964
8.77869
0.502609
point
at z = 0
Case VII
a1 d1 - b1 c, > 0
a2d2 - b2cz < 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.14
0.32
0.15
0.10
0.03
0.06
0.15
0.15
0.25
0.25
-0 .648356
3.13194
0.380055
Case VIII
a1 d1 - b1 c1 < 0
a2d2 - b2c2 > 0
0.04
0.29
0.19
0.20
0.14
0.32
0.15
0.10
0.06
0.03
0.15
0.15
0.25
0.25
-0 .589276
2.87207
0.358354
k-0.864514
) -0.924964
) -0.933586
)
-0 .227783
-0 .207014
0.566327l
0.564695
l
-0 .824Y81
/
-0 .8253
-0 .205174
--0 .540816
-0 .841141
This table shows that the system has a saddle point at z = 0
The difference between cases I-IV and cases V-VUI comes from the technological parameters, especially from SK.
Cases V-VIII shows larger capital goods input from the other sectors than own
sectors.
Out sourcing of capital goods implies saddle point instability, as I explained in
the text. The difference between cases I-IV comes from the interest rate and the
depreciation rate. The technological parameters are common for all cases.
a1 d1 - b1C1 = (r2-r1 + 622 - 621)SK21
SK22IAI
a2d2 - b2c2 = (r1 - r2 + 611 - 612)SK11
SKI2IAI
a1 d1 - b1 c1 implies the difference of nominal cost of capital goods 2 between
the own sector 2 and the sector 1.
a2d2 - b2c2 implies the difference of nominal cost of capital goods 1 between
the own sector 1 and the sector 2.
IJ«(0) I denotes the Jacobian at the fixed point z = 0: positive means stable around
the fixed point.
`Eigenvalues' are of the solution A for the
equation, (AI - Ja(0)I = 0.
`Eigenvectors' are the associate vectors z* with each eigenvalue
, Ja(0)z* = Az*.
19
i
0.6
0.4
0.2
zz
0
-0 .2
vectors
i1 = 0
iz = 0
(Z) =0
-0 .4
-0 .2
-0 .1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
zi
Figure 2: Case II: Stable fixed point at 2 = 0
0.6
1
I
0.4
i
i
0.2
i
Z2
0
i
-0 .2
Eigenvectors
i1 = 0
i2 = 0
I7(z) - 0
i
-0 .4
I
-0.2
4
i
-0.1
i
0
1
0 .1
0.2
0.3
- -=
1
0.4
11
Figure
3: Case III: Stable
20
fixed point
at z = 0
0.5
0.6
i
0.4
I
i
0.2
Z2
0-
i
-0.2
i
Eigenveetors
Z~ =0
z2=0
-0.4
-0 .2
-0.1
I
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
-~
0.4
0.5
Figure 4: Case IV: Stable fixed point at z == 0
0.6
4
0.4
F4
0.2
i
Z2
0
i
-0.2
i
igen
ctors
-0
D(
=0
i
-0.4
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
z1
Figure 5: Case V: Saddle point at z = 0
21
0.5
/
0.6
i
0.4
i
0.2
Z2
0
i
-0.2
Eigenvectors
ii = 0
Z2 = 0 D(z)=0
--
i
i
-0
.4
-0.2
-0 .1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Zi
Figure
0.6
6: Case
I
VI: Saddle
point
I
at z
0
f
I
0.4
i
0.2
i
Z2
0I
i
-0 .2
Eigenvectors
z1 = 0
Z2 = 0
D(z)=0
i
i
-0.4
I
-0 .2
-0 .1
I
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
z1
Figure
7: Case
VII: Saddle
22
point
at z
0
0.5
~T
0.6
i
0.4
i
i
0.2
i
z2
0
i
Eigenvectors
±i=0
0
-0.2
i
i
-0.4
D(z)=0
-0 .2
-0.1
0
Figure
4
Price
In this section,
tivity.
tial equations
two sector
4.1
introduce
0.2
8: Case VIII:
variation
It is very difficult
0.1
Saddle
Langevin
a stochastic
factor
to solve the system
and stochastic
factors.
First,
0.3
point
0.4
0.5
at z = 0
equation:
A simple
in fluctuation
of the total factor
which
incorporates
take a single
equation
non-linear
case
producdifferen-
and next consider
system.
One sector model
The definition of variables are the same as before, the rate of (aggregate) price
change is denoted as dlnp/dt = z, a denotes a = (1-Sx--SK)/SK, SX = pxx/C
the cost share for the intermediate input, SK = pLK/C the cost share to the capital
goods input. PK = p (r + b - z) the user's cost of capital, r the interest rate, &the
depreciation rate.
Assume that the cost shares are constant as in the previous sections. The productivity change din TFP/dt includes a drift term p.-rFp
and the Langevin term L(t),
which is a source of stochastic fluctuation.
Assumption: Total factor productivity (TFP)
din TFP
dt
_ MTFP
+ L(t).
23
Using the above stochastic productivity specification, the one sector model for
eq (19) can be expressed as follows:
_~. '
d In TFP
d In w
$
S K-- '
r+b-z Z - (1-" SX- SK)Z -d - - $ Ldt- -' r&-zy r• - r+&
-z s
Z - a(r + s - Z)Z = r+&-z
d1nTFP
- S~dlnw
S
r+sK z (Ndt
S K dt
TFP+ L(t)) - SK
jd dt
1nw - r - b
$K
Assume
that the average productivity
change
µ-rFP is allocated
into the wage
increase, the interest rage change, and the depreciation
change , that is
1
-E--SK
where
E is assumed
Using
(r+b)µTFP"SL dlnw
at ---SK(r+b)
~
to be close enough
this equation,
rewrite
to zero .
the system as follows:
Z- a(r+ b- z)z = rSKZL(t)-. E
Assumption: L(t) the Langevin term
(32)
Introduce the assumption on the Langevin
term:
< L(t) >= 0, < L(t)L(t') >= rs(t where the notation < o > denotes taking expectation, r denotes variance of L(t),
b(t ---t') denotes Dirac's delta function.
The Langevin equation has multiple interpretations .12 One of the most famous
interpretation is due to Ito, who interprets the time derivative eq (32) as derived
from the following integral:
z(t + tit) -z(t) = f t+°ta(r + s - z(s))z(s)ds
+{r+s
SK
- z(t)
SK}Jrt+°t
t L(s)ds+e[.1t
t+°t
It
+
{a(r + s - z(s))z(s) + E}ds
r+b-z(}
SKt) t+°t
J't L(s)ds.
(33)
The other famous interpretation is due to Stratonovich , who interprets the time
derivative of the left hand side of eq (32) as follows:
z(t + fit) -z(t) = f t+°ta(r + b - z(s))z(s)ds
+{r+s
SK
-~
z(t+_°t)+z(t)
2S
K }J'1
t+°tL(s)ds+EOt
= f tt+°t
f {a(r + s - z(s))z(s) + e}ds
t)+z(t)J ft
t+°t L(s)ds.
+ r+b
SK
- z(t+i
- 2SK
12This part of the paper depends on van Kampen [1992]
24
.
(34)
2
The interpretation on the coefficient of L(t) differs from each other. Ito's interpretation assumes that z has determined before L(t) has some value, therefore the
integral can be taken as if z is a constant. But Stratonovich's interpretation assumes
that z moves while L(t) takes into action, therefore the integral has the averaged
coefficient. The solution of the system significantly depends on the interpretation
taken into account.
Here I assume that a lot of productivity changes occur microscopically, and it is
under given macroscopic price variation z. And introduce the distribution of L(t)
as Gaussian.
Assumption:
z
Assume no immediate feedback or no reaction from L(t) to z.
Assumption: L(T) Assume L(t) obeys Gaussian process.
Under these assumptions, the Ito's integral eq (35) is equivalent to the FokkerPlanck equation (36).
t+ot
z(t + Lt) - z(t) =
t+ot
A(z(s)) ds + C(z(t))
t
L(s) ds
(35)
t
aP(z,
t) -a (A(z)P(z,
t))+r2 a2(C(z)2P(z,
t))
at
az
az2
(36)
This equation can be expanded as follows:
apa,-t) = {-A'(z) + r (C"C+ C'2)}P(z
, t) + (2rCC' A)ap(Z,t)
+ PC a P(zt)
r
az
az
(37)
Introduce new parameters a and (3as follows:
a(z) = VC(z)2
(3(z) = rC(z)C'(z) - A(z)
f3 (z) = r(C (z) + C(z) C "(z) - A (z) )
(3(z) + a'(z) = 2rC(z)C'(z) - A(z).
(38)
Eq (37) is rewritten to
aP(z,t)
= R'(z)p(z,
t) +.(x'(z)+ (3(z))
apai,t~
+ a(z)ZZ
a2
ap(Z,t)_ a(R(Z)p(Z,t)) ______ t~}
at aZ
+
aZ
25
(39)
2
Apply these relations to eq (33), the following equations are obtained:
A(z) = a(r + b - z)z + e
C(Z) - SK
-
__
a(z) - r2 ____
sK
13(z)
_ --rrSK2zZ
- a(r b Z)Z(3'(z) =
(40)
-- a(r + b) + 2az
13(z)
+.'(z) = _2rTS-; -- a(r+ b- z)z- e.
Thus, eq (33) is equivalent to the following Fokker-Planck equation.
aP(
z,t) a{(a(r
+b- z)z
+e)P(z,
t)}ra2{(rz)2P(Z,t}
+bsK
at
- -
az
+ 2
- --
)
az2
The solution for this equation can be obtained by numerical calculation. Strict
solution has been found only for the very specific case, see for example Rogers
[1997].13
4.2
Stochastic
formulation
for the n sector
model
In the multiple sector model, introduce E for unallocated productivity gain:
E1
e
EZ
=
-
En
~-'
µTFP1-- L.n
Lll
i.=1
dlnw - L.I .TFP2
SLj24-"_-~
n.
j
1
dt
i1
ia1
(
µTFP2- LLj SLj2dlnwi
dt -n
r1+&1-r.
1 -Lei
i=1 r2+bt2-z;
Sxtz_ T2
djnTFP1
=1
r2+6SKt2
2-zt T2- ~ni=1
r1+51-
~
Sxt2 bit
bil
T+62-Zt
~ni=1 r2+biz
Sxi2
-zt b~
(41)
N
TFP1+ L1(t)
dInTFP
1fTFP2
-+L2(t)
dt -=' dd1n.TFPn
=f NTFP2
NTFP
(42)
11+ Ln(t)
-- ____
- -dt
13Finding strict solutions for the Fokker-Planck equation see for example
, Nariboli[ 19'77],Hill
[1982], and Zwillinger [1998]
26
In general, the dynamic price equation system can be expressed introducing e,
the Langevin term L (t) and z as follows:
Srz+(I--SX-SK)z=L+e
4.3
(43)
The system around the fixed point z= O
First, investigate the system around the fixed point z = 0,
Sr(0)i + (I - SX -RSK)z = L + e.
(44)
In this case, the system can be expressed as
dz(t)_= -Sro-1{(I - SX - SK)z(t) - e}dt + Sro-1 dL(t),
(45)
where Sro = Sr(0).
To solve the equation, take the following autonomous matrix equation first,la
dz(t) = -Sro-1{(I - SX - SK)z(t)}dt
It has a solution 4'(t, to) corresponded to an initial condition.
The non-autonomous equations can be rewrite as follows:
dz(t) = -Sro-1{(I---SX- SK)z(t)- e}dt+ Sro-1dL(t)
Using the solution 4(t, to), the solution for the non-autonomous equations are
given as follows:
z(t)
= (t,to)(z(0)
+Jt (s)-'
eds
++Jt (s)-'
Sro-'
dL(s)
to
to
Stability of the system depends on the eigenvalues of the matrix --Sro-1 (I SX -- SK). The condition is the same as that of the non-stochastic model that I have
explained.
Solution method of the non-linear stochastic system is not yet investigated. But
the Fokker-Planck equations for multiple variables can be determined from eq (43).
And there are many numerical methods to solve the non-linear partial differential
equations, see for example Zwillinger [1998].
Assume L (t) obeys Gaussian process and has the covariances < L(t)L, (s) >
T'L;
b (t - s), eq (43) become equivalent to the multivariate Fokker-Planck equation.
Thus the Fokker-Planck equations for eq (43) can be shown as follows:
i4Following partof thissectiondependson Hon[1977].
27
apa2'ti=
((Sr1(I-Sx-SK)z+e)P(z
,t))
+2L..i,l=t
aziaz(.QP(z,t))
~" n
a2
where
S2 = 2Sr-1 (z)rSr-1T(z).
Sr-i T denotes transpose of the matrix, r denotes n x n matrix of the covariance of
L(t). These equations remains to be investigated.
5
Concluding
remarks
This paper constructs the classification for the general two sector model based on
the price equations for growth accounting. As a result, degree of out-sourcing on
capital goods is an important factor for the stability of the system. If each sector
out-sources their capital goods for investment extensively, the fixed point of the
system becomes a saddle point, rather than asymptotically stable point .
But as the phase portraits show, the system includes large instability area , which
is separated by the locus of singularity of the system's matrix Sr. When the prices
come across this singularity locus, the fluctuation explodes drastically . This is why
my previous paper shows that the prices change numerically very fragile.
In this paper, I can correct two mistakes in my two previous papers . Although
none of them are serious, the corrections have helped understanding the dynamic
price fluctuations, is
As to stochastic model, there are a lot of problems to be solved. The non-linear
stochastic equation system is extremely difficult to solve, but it is necessary to derive
the distribution of prices. That will explain how frequent the price changes go into
unstable. region, such as deflation spiral, or hyper inflation. For that purpose , I have
derived the general partial differential equation system for future investigation .
1SIn Hayami [1993]
, the n sector model has errors in the notation. But the other part does not
change at all. Hayami [1999] includes also minor proof reading errors, but I should reconsider the
last part of the solution. At the moment, I have not yet verified the solution that provides the price
distribution.
28
References
[1] Aftalion, A., "The theory of economic cycles based on the capitalistic technique of production," Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 9, no. 4, 1927,
pp. 165-70.
[2] Antonello, P., "Simultaneous adjustment of quantities and prices: An example
of Hamiltonian dynamics", Economic Systems Research, vol. 11, no. 2, 1999,
pp. 139-162.
[3] Benhabib, J. and K. Nishimura, "Indeterminancy and sunspots with constant
returns," Journal of Economic Theory, vol. 81, 1998, pp. 58-96.
[4] Dempster, M. and Pliska, S. R. eds., Mathematics of derivative securities,
Cambridge University Press, 1997.
[5] Diewert, W. E., "Aggregation problems in the measurement of capital", in
Usher, D. ed., The measurement of capital, NBER Studies in Income and
Wealth vol. 45, University of Chicago Press, 1980, pp. 433-528.
[6] Frisch, R., "Propagation problems and impulse problems in dynamic economics," in Economic Essays in Honour of Gustav Cassel, George Allen &
Unswin Ltd, 1933, pp. 171-205.
[7] Frisch, R., "Circulation Planning: Proposal for a national organization of a
commodity and service exchange," Econometrica, vol. 2, July 1934, pp. 258336.
[8] Goodwin, R. M., "Static and dynamic linear general equilibrium models"
1953, reprinted in Goodwin, R. M. Essays in Linear Economic Structures ,
London, Macmillan, 1983, pp. 75-120.
191 Guckenheimer, J. and P. Holms, Nonlinear oscillations, dynamical systems,
and bifurcation of vector fields, 3rd printing, Springer-Verlag, 1990.
[10] Hamaguchi, N., "Structural Change in Japanese-American Interdependence:
A Total Factor Productivity Analysis in an International Input-Output Framework," Keio Economic Observatory, Occasional Paper, E. no. 4, 1985.
[11] Hayami, H., "Dynamic properties of inter-industry wages and productivity
growth," Economic Studies Quarterly, vol. 44, no. 1, 1993, pp. 79-92.
29
[12] Hayami, H., "Random factors in propagation and impulse problem: an application of Langevin and Fokker-Planck equations into the dynamic price equation;' (Propagation to impulse mondai ni okeru randam youin: Langevin to
Fokker-Planck houteishiki no dougakuteki kakaku houteishiki heno ouyou)
Mita Shogaku Kenkyu, vol. 42, no. 5, 1999, pp. 135--166, (in Japanese).
[13] Hill, J. M., Solution of deferential equations by means of one-parameter
groups, Pitman Advanced Publishing Program, Boston, London, Melbourne,
1982.
[14] Hulten, C. R. and Wycoff, F. C.. "Measurement of economic depreciation,"
in Hulten, C. R. ed., Depreciation, inflation, and the taxation of incomefrom
capital, Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute, 1981.
[15] Hulten, C. R., "The measurement of capital", in Berndt, E. R. and J . E. Triplett
eds., Fifty years of economic measurement, The Jubilee of the Conference on
Research in Income and Wealth, University of Chicago Press, 1990, pp. 119158.
[16] Kuroa, M., Yosioka, K., Shimizu, M., "Economic growth; Factor analysis and multi-sectoral interactions,"(Keizaiseichou:
youinbunnseki to tabumonkan hakyu) Hamada, K., Kuroda, M., and Horiuchi, A. eds, Macroeconomic analyses on Japanese economy(Nihonkeizai no makuro bunseki), Tokyo
University Press, 1987, pp. 57-95. (in Japanese)
[17] Leontief, W. "Dynamic inverse", in Carter, A. P. and A. Brody eds., Contribution to input-output analysis, North-Holland Pub. Co., 1970, reprinted in
Input-Output Economics, 2nd ed. 1986, pp. 294-320.
[18] Leontief, W. "Academic economics", Business week, 18 January 1982 ,
pp. 124, reprinted in Essays in Economics, 2nd ed. New Brunswick and Oxford, Transaction Books, 1985, pp. ix-xii.
[19] Nariboli, G. A., "Group-invariant solutions of the Fokker-Planck equation,"
Stochastic Processes and their Applications, vol. 5, no. 2, May 1977, pp. 157171.
[20] Nishimura,
time models,"
K.,
"Equilibrium
Japanese
growth
Economic
and nonlinear
Review,
dynamic
vol. 52, no. 1, March
in continuous2001,
pp. 1-
19.
[21] Rogers, L. C. G., "Stochastic calculus and Markov methods," in [4] pp. 15-40.
30
[22] Slutzky, E., "The summation of random causes as the source of cyclic pro-
cesses," Econometrica, vol. 5, no. 2, 1937, pp. 105-46. Reprinted from The
Conjuncutre Institute Moskva ed. Problems of economic conditions, vol. 3,
no. 1, 1927.
[23] van Kampen, N. G., Stochastic Process in Physics and Chemistry, revised and
enlarged ed., North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1992.
[24] Yoshioka, Kanji, The productivity analysis on Japanese manufacturing in-
dustry and finance(Nihon no seizougyou kinyuugyou no seisansei bunseki),
Toyokeizai-shimposha, 1989, (in Japanese).
[25] Yule, G. U., "On a method of investigating periodicities in disturbed series,
with special reference to Wolfer's sunspot numbers," Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, A, vol. 226, 1927, pp. 267--298.
[26] Zwillinger, D., Handbook of differential equations, 3rd ed., Academic Press,
New York, 1998.
31