Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in

Transkript

Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in
Lack of Uniform Application
Regarding Transfer of Property
in International Sales Contracts
with Particular Regard to
Retention of Title Clauses
Asst. Prof. Dr. Ahmet Cemil YILDIRIM
Istanbul Kemerburgaz University School of Law*
Introduction
The Vienna Convention on International Sale of Goods1 [hereafter
CISG] was adopted in Turkey in 20102 and entered into effect as of the 1st
of August 2011. Since that date, Turkish judges consider ex-officio3 the
application of the CISG into disputes that arise from international sales
The author wants to express his sincere gratitude to Prof. Dr. Franco Ferrari for his valuable suggestions and generous support in the elaboration of this article.
1
United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods adopted on 11 April 1980 http://www.uncitral.org/uncitral/en/uncitral_texts/sale_
goods/1980CISG.html
2
Official Gazette No. 27545 dated 07.04.2010
3
On the ex-officio application of the CISG see Société Muller Ecole et Bureau v. Société Federal Trait decision of the French Cour de Cassation of 26 June 2001, available at http://
cisgw3.law.pace.edu/cases/010626f2.html and http://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=
1&do=case&id=717&step=FullText
*
190
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
contracts. Therefore, since seven months, Turkish lawyers and judges
discover the scope of application of the CISG, the issues that are covered
by and excluded from this Convention. In this paper I will examine an issue that is not covered by the CISG despite its importance; I will attempt
to illustrate the interaction between the CISG and domestic laws and I
will evaluate a current practice on the basis of the main objectives of the
uniform law.
By definition a sales contract is “a contract in which ownership of
property is transferred, or will be transferred, from a seller to a buyer for a
fixed sum” 4. Consider a Turkish judge who is in charge of a case involving
a dispute regarding the transfer of the property of the goods sold under
a contract to which the CISG applies. Since a sales contract is defined
by the transfer of the property, the judge would probably and rightfully
expect the CISG to deal with this issue; and he will definitely be disappointed seeing that this issue is clearly excluded from the scope of this
Convention. According to article 4(b) of the CISG
“… except as otherwise expressly provided in this Convention, it is
not concerned with; …
(b) the effect which the contract may have on the property in the
goods sold.”
That is, there is a gap intra legem in the CISG regarding the passing
of the property.5
Black’s Law Dictionary, Bryan A Garner, 6th Ed., 2006. It is worthy to mention that the
CISG does not bring a definition of sales contract.
5
The fact that this issue is not covered by the CISG has been criticized by many authors.
See, among others, FERRARI, Franco, Abstraktionsprinzip, Traditionsprinzip e consensualismo nel trasferimento di beni mobili. Una superabile divaricazione?, RIVISTA DI DIRITTO CIVILE 729, 756-757 (1993), BENEDETTI, Giuseppe, Commento all’Art 4 della
Convenzione di Vienna sui contratti di vendita internazionale di beni mobile, Nuove leggi
civili commentate, 1989, p. 10, VISSER, Evelien, Favor Emptoris: Does The CISG Favor
the Buyer? University of Missouri, Kansas City Law Review (1998) 77-92 http://www.
cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/Visser1.html#b31 pp 79-81, BOGHOSSIAN, Nayiri, A
Comparative Study of Specific Performance Provisions in the United Nations on Contracts for
the International Sale of Goods, Pace Review of the Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, Kluwer (1999-2000) 3-78, pp. 73-76 <http://www.cisg.law.
4
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
191
In this paper, first, I will question whether there is any substantive
rule of international character to fill this gap. Second, I will study the
views on the reasons for which the CISG did not regulate the transfer of
the property. Then, I will briefly study the case law already established
in other CISG countries on this issue. In the light of my findings, I will
attempt to provide for prospective application in Turkey in this regard. I
will conclude by evaluating how the rules of domestic law can be applied
in order to comply with the uniform law’s primary objectives.
I. The Transfer of the Property as a Banned Subject
of International Trade Law
The CISG is not the only text of international trade law that does
not cover the issue of the passing of the property. In The Hague Convention of 1964 relating to a Uniform Law on the International Sale of
Goods [hereafter ULIS], the situation is quite the same. Turkey is not
a party to the ULIS, however, we should mention that this Convention
can be considered as the ancestor of the CISG. Article 8 of the ULIS that
corresponds to Article 4 of the CISG also excludes the passing of the
property. This article states that
“The present Law shall govern only the obligations of the seller and
the buyer arising from a contract of sale. In particular, the present Law
shall not, except as otherwise expressly provided therein, be concerned
with the formation of the contract, nor with the effect which the contract
may have on the property in the goods sold, nor with the validity of the
contract or of any of its provisions or of any usage.”
Soft law rules may, in some cases, complement the CISG. If the
parties agreed upon an Incoterm in their contract, this might be a hope;
pace.edu/cisg/biblio/boghossian.html; THANG, Tran Quoc, Passing of Property Under Contracts for the International Sale of Goods: Should the CISG Regulate the Transfer of
Property?, Thesis, University of Durham, 2004 http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/thang.html, WESIACK, Max, Is the CISG too much influenced by civil law principles of
contract law rather than common law principles of contract law? Should the CISG contain a
rule on the passing of property?, Thesis, University of Sydney, 2004 http://www.cisg.law.
pace.edu/cisg/biblio/wesiack.html, WIRES, John, Retention of Title Clauses in International Trade Law, September 11, 2009, p. 6 http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1471990
192
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
however, in Incoterms 2010, as is the case in its precedents, the passing
of the property is not dealt with.6 As for the UNIDROIT Principles7, they
govern not only sales contracts, but all types of international commercial
contracts. Not surprisingly, they do not contain a provision on such a
specific issue. If we look at the Principles of European Contract Law
[PECL]8 we will see that their scope is even broader. These principles
govern not only commercial, but also civil contracts. Therefore, they do
not contain a provision on the passing of the property either. The situation is no different with the recently published proposal for a “Common
European Sales Law”9, even though this proposal aims at covering crossborder sales transactions within the European Union.
In lack of a substantive rule governing the passing of the property in
international sales contracts, a judge may want to check whether there is
any private international law rule of international character that governs
the passing of the property. He would look at the Convention of 15 June
1955 on The Law Applicable to International Sales of Goods of The
Hague Conference on Private International Law. This would not help,
not only because Turkey is not a signatory to this Convention (to date
there are only eight signatories to it), but also because in Article 5(3) of
this Convention it is expressly stated that “this Convention … does not
apply to the issue of the transfer of ownership”.10
This was also made clear in St. Paul Guardian Insurance Co., et al. v. Neuromed Medical Systems & Support, et al. U.S. District Court, S.D., New York, 26.03.2002: “INCOTERMS, however, only address passage of risk, not transfer of title.” http://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=730&step=FullText In this decision the Court
referred to DEBATTISTA, Charles, Incoterms and Documentary Practices, in Incoterms
2000: A Forum of Experts 63, 2000, p. 86.
7
UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts 2010 http://www.unidroit.org/english/principles/contracts/principles2010/blackletter2010-english.pdf
8
Principles of European Contract Law http://frontpage.cbs.dk/law/commission_on_
european_contract_law/Skabelon/pecl_engelsk.htm
9
Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on a Common
European Sales Law, COM (2011) 635 (final), 2011/0284 (COD) http://ec.europa.
eu/justice/contract/files/common_sales_law/regulation_sales_law_en.pdf
10
The original text of Article 5 of the Convention of 15 June 1955 on the law applicable
to international sales of goods of the Hague Conference on Private International Law
reads as follows:
6
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
193
Another Convention by the Hague Conference on Private International Law, Convention of 22 December 1986 on the Law Applicable to
Contracts for The International Sale of Goods would not help very much
either. Because, although this Convention went one step further from the
Convention of 15 June 1955, it does not bring a direct rule for determining the law applicable to the transfer of ownership, just puts in article 5(c)
that “the transfer of ownership … [is] governed by the law applicable to
the Contract under the Convention”. That is, the judge has to determine
anyway the applicable law for property effects of the contract of sale11.
Conventions and soft law rules that might be expected to regulate
the passing of the property, or the law applicable to this issue, are not just
silent. Some of them expressly state that they do not deal with property
issues, as does the CISG. A Turkish judge might think that the issue of
the transfer of property is a banned subject and no one wants to bring
a substantial or even a procedural rule that might help him to resolve a
property issue.
II. Why Does the CISG Not Govern the Passing of the
Property?
There are two views about the reason why the CISG does not govern the passing of the property. The first view is the one adopted by the
UNCITRAL Secretariat in their Commentary on the 1978 Draft of the
CISG. According to this view there are two main reasons for ULIS12 and
“La présente Convention ne s’applique pas:
1. à la capacité des parties ;
2. à la forme du contrat ;
3. au transfert de propriété, étant entendu toutefois que les diverses obligations des parties, et notamment celles qui sont relatives aux risques, sont soumises à la loi applicable
à la vente en vertu de la présente Convention ;
4. aux effets de la vente à l’égard de toutes personnes autres que les parties.”
11
We should also add that Turkey is not a signatory neither to this Convention and there
are only two signatories to it.
12
TUNC, André, Commentary on the Hague Conventions of the 1st of July 1964 on International Sale of Goods and the Formation of the Contract of Sale, http://www.cisg.law.pace.
edu/cisg/text/tunc.html
194
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
CISG to not to regulate the passing of the property: first, it is difficult to
provide a uniform rule on this point because of the divergence among
various national legal systems; and second, it is not necessary to do so
as both ULIS and CISG already regulate the consequences linked to the
passing of the property13. According to the Secretariat Commentary on
Article 4 of the CISG:
“It was not regarded possible to unify the rule on this point nor was
it regarded necessary to do so since rules are provided by this Convention for several questions linked, at least in certain legal systems, to the
passing of property; the obligation of the seller to transfer the goods free
from any right or claim of a third person; the obligation of the buyer to
pay the price; the passing of the risk of loss or damage to the goods; the
obligation to preserve the goods”14
Professor André TUNC’s view that he explained in his commentary to the ULIS is in
the same direction. As there is no significant change between the provisions of the ULIS
and those of the CISG on this issue, his commentary to Article 8 of the ULIS is still
valid for Article 4 of the CISG. In his words: “Now it was clear from the beginning of
the discussions relating to the Uniform Law that whilst it was vain to hope for a uniform
rule on this question which was deeply involved both in historic traditions and in the
regulation of credit and bankruptcy, on the other hand unification was not necessary
if, taking a more direct and practical view, rules were merely provided for three types
of questions linked, at least in certain legal systems, to the passing of property: the obligation of the seller to transfer the property in goods free from any right or claim not
accepted by the buyer (Articles 18, 52 and 53), ­the passing of risk, regarded in a number
of legal systems as the essential consequence of the passing of property (Articles 96 to
101), the obligation to preserve the goods and to bear the cost of preservation, which
are subsidiary aspects (Articles 91 to 95).” For other opinions in the same direction see
HONNOLD, John,“Documentary History of the Uniform Law for International Sales,
the studies, deliberations and decisions that led to the 1980 UN Convention with introductions and explanations” (1989) Kluwer Law and Tax Publishers, Deventer, p. 407;
KHOO, Warren, Article 4, in BIANCA, Cesare Massimo / BONELL, Michael Joachim
(eds.), “Commentary on the International Sales Law: The 1980 Vienna Sales Convention”, 1987, p. 46.
14
The UNCITRAL Secretariat Commentary (closest to counterpart to an Official Commentary) http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/text/secomm/secomm-04.html#1> The
Secretariat quotes also the views of Professor Roy GOODE in this commentary: “The
Vienna Sales Convention has been criticised for not dealing with the passing of property
or with priority conflicts between the seller/buyer and a third party. Why were these
important topics omitted? First, it would have made the project too large (as it is, the
13
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
195
On the other hand, according to Professor Alan Farnsworth, the
reason for which Article 4(b) leaves the issue of the passing of the property to national laws is that this was the “price paid by the Convention’s
sponsors for its acceptance by the adopting nations.”15 This latter view
is based on a political observation and it seems to be quite realistic. It
should also be mentioned that according to some authors, a uniform rule
is possible, although difficult, in the field of the passing of the property
by the adoption of the delivery principle.16
Both views agree on the difficulty in providing a uniform rule governing the passing of the property. The former view addresses to technical aspects of this difficulty, whereas the second view refers to political
difficulties in making such a uniform rule. It may not be very easy to
Convention runs to 101 articles). Secondly, it was felt that on issues of property law
differences in legal policy and approach created a chasm too large to bridge. A particular
stumbling block is the significance of possession as a deteminant of property rights. In a
number of legal systems there is a presumption that the property in identified goods is
intended to pass on the making of the contract, in others, only on delivery. The effect of
an unauthorized disposition by a party in possession who has not yet acquired ownership also raises acute differences in approach. In particular, common law systems start
from the position nemo dat quod non habet, civil law systems from the principle en fait
de meubles la possession vaut titre. Both sets of systems have moved towards each other
but a gulf remains. There is the additional problem that conflicting claims to tangible
movables raises issues going well beyond sales law and that conflicts arising from sales
transactions cannot sensibly be dealt with in isolation.” GOODE, Royston Miles, Reflections on the Harmonisation of Commercial Law, 1 Unif. L. R. (1991) pp. 61-62.
15
“Articles 4 and 6 create a tripartite hierarchy, with domestic mandatory law on top, the
agreement of the parties in the middle, and the CISG at the bottom. This was the price
paid by the Convention’s sponsors for its acceptance by the adopting nations.” FARNSWORTH, Alan, Review of Standard Forms or Terms Under the Vienna Convention, 21
CORNELL INT’L L.J. 440, 1988, p. 441.
16
DROBNIG, Urlich, Transfer of Property, in HARTKAMP, Arthur et al. (eds.), “Towards
a European Civil Code”, 1994, p. 360; VISSER, supra 5, p. 91; FERRARI, Vom Abstraktionsprinzip und Konsensualprinzip zum Traditionsprinzip, in Zeitschrift für Europäisches
Privatrecht 52, 53-59 (1993); D’AMICO, Giovanni, Contratto di Compravendita, Effetto
Traslativo e Problemi di Armonizzazione in NAVARRETTA, Emanuela (ed.), “Il Diritto Europeo dei Contratti fra parte generale e norme di settore”, 2007, p. 517; WITZ,
Claude, Analyse critique des règles régissant le transfert de propriété en droit français à la
lumière du droit allemand, in MARTINEK, Michael et al. (eds.) “Festschrift für Günther
Jahr 549”, 1994, p. 549.
196
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
provide a uniform rule on the passing of the property and to convince
states to adopt such a rule. However, we should doubt the validity of the
second argument of the former view according to which a uniform rule
is “not needed.”
The case-law so far demonstrated that there is a strong need for such
a uniform rule. The lack of uniformity in the practice of retention of title
clauses [hereafter ROT clauses] best illustrates the crying need for a uniform rule on this subject. These clauses are often used in international
trade and have a very significant function. They serve as a security for
sellers on their own goods and protect sellers that sell goods on credit
and by installments. Under a ROT clause the parties agree that the property of the goods sold remains with the seller until the payment has been
made in full. In particular, when the buyer becomes insolvent before
paying the last installment, these goods are exempt from the insolvency
proceedings and the seller can get the goods back.
Despite the fact that the use of ROT clauses in international sales
contracts is a well established practice,17 the case law on Article 4(b) of
the CISG demonstrated that the validity of these clauses is left to the
rules of domestic laws that vary significantly from country to country.
III.Current Practice of the Courts
Let us assume that in the case brought before the Turkish judge there
is an international sales contract that contains a ROT clause and to which
the CISG applies. By this contract a seller from a CISG country sells and
delivers some goods to a buyer in Turkey. The Turkish buyer goes into
insolvency before paying the purchase price in full. The buyer has also
other creditors in Turkey, a bank for instance, that expect that the goods
sold under the contract become subject to liquidation procedure. The
seller, however, requests the return of these goods to it from the judge on
the grounds of the ROT clause. In such a case the Turkish judge will have
For instance, Article 7 of “General Conditions” of the ICC Model International Sale
Contract is a ROT clause. To give effect to this clause, parties have to thick “yes” in Article 6 of the “Specific Conditions”.
17
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
197
to determine whether the ROT clause is valid and whether the property
in the goods passed to the Turkish buyer.
Article 4 of the CISG simply says that the CISG “is not concerned
with the validity of the contract or of any of its provisions” such as the
ROT clause in our illustration; and with “the effect which the contract
may have on the property in the goods sold”. This being the case, how is
the Turkish judge expected to resolve a dispute regarding the passing of
the property in an international sales transaction? More broadly, how is a
judge expected to fill a gap intra legem in the CISG?
Although in Article 7(2) of the CISG the way in which gaps praeter
legem will be filled is defined, it is evident that this article cannot apply
to gaps intra legem.18 The Turkish judge has no other choice than to resolve property issues according to the relevant applicable law to be determined.19 This is also confirmed by the case-law already established in
other CISG countries and by the UNCITRAL’s Digest on the Case Law
on the CISG.20
On the other hand, according to Article 7(1) of the CISG
“Of course, matters the CISG does not govern at all are to be solved directly by having
recourse to the applicable national law, i.e. without first having to look into whether
general principles exist.” FERRARI, Gap-Filling and Interpretation of the CISG: Overview of International Case Law, 7 Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law
& Arbitration (2003), pp. 90-91 http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/ferrari11.
html; FERRARI, CISG’da Yorum ve Boşluk Doldurmaya ilişkin Meseleler in ATAMER,
Yeşim (ed.), “Milletlerarası Satım Hukuku”, Istanbul, 2008, p. 69; BONELL, Article 7,
in BIANCA/BONELL (eds.), supra 13, pp. 74-75. http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/
biblio/bonell-bb7.html
19
LOOKOFSKY, Article 4 Issves Excluded from Convention Scope: Validity, Property and
Delict in “ International Encyclopedia of Laws- Contract” Suppl. 29 (December 2000)
1-192, p. 43, http://cisg3.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/l004.html
FERRARI PIL and CISG: Friends or Foes? in ŞIPKA/YILDIRIM (eds.) “Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri - Sales Contracts under the New Turkish
Code of Obligations and the CISG” p. 99.
20
“[T]he effect of a sales contract on the property in the goods is left to the applicable
national law, to be determined by the rules of private international law of the forum. The
Convention does not govern the validity of a retention of title clause” UNCITRAL’s
Digest on the Case Law on the United Nations Convention on the International Sale of
Goods, p. 18. http://www.uncitral.org/pdf/english/clout/digest2008/article004.pdf
18
198
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
“In the interpretation of this Convention, regard is to be had in its
international character and to the need to promote uniformity in its application and the observance of good faith in international trade”.
To ensure the uniformity in application, courts in CISG countries
are expected to take into consideration decisions previously made in other CISG countries.21 Therefore, the case law already established in other
77 CISG countries became of crucial importance for Turkish judges. If in
other CISG countries a uniform application has already been established
regarding the passing of the property, this may be a hope for the Turkish
judge in charge of this case. So, it may be appropriate to take a closer look
at the case law.
One of the earliest decisions22 regarding the validity of a ROT clause
in an international sales contract is the Australian decision in the Roder
case.23 In this case Roder, a German manufacturer of tents for public func Courts are also expected to interpret the CISG “autonomously”, that is, refraining from
relying on their own national laws where possible, but by referring to the practice already established in other CISG countries. See FERRARI, Applying the CISG in a Truly
Uniform Manner: Tribunale di Vigevano (Italy), Uniform Law Review (2001-1) pp. 203215; FERRARI, CISG Case Law: A New Challenge for Interpreters?, 17 Journal of Law
and Commerce (1999) pp. 245-261; DIEDRICH, Frank, Maintaining Uniformity in International Uniform Law via Autonomous Interpretation: Software Contracts and the CISG,
8 PACE INT’L L. REV., 1996, p. 303.
22
See, for instance, Case No 5 U 534/91 by the Oberlandesgericht Koblenz of 16.01.1992
http://www.unilex.info/case.cfm?pid=1&do=case&id=30&step=FullText. In this case
a Dutch manufacturer sold and delivered a cruise to a German company and negotiated
retention of title of the cruise until the payment is made in full. However, the German
buyer went bankrupt before paying the whole price. The seller brought an action before
the German Court and asked for the return of the cruise to it as the proper owner. The
German Court, without examining whether this contract is within the scope of application of the CISG, ruled that the CISG does not apply to the validity of the retention of
title clause and German law applies as lex rei sitae. The Court concluded that the seller
was not entitled to have back the cruise as the retention of title clause was not validly
incorporated.
23
Roder Zelt- und Hallenkonstruktionen GmbH v. Rosedown Park Party Ltd. (1995) 57 Fed.
Ct. Rep. (Austl.) 216-240, CLOUT No. 308 (Fed. Ct., S. Austl. District, Adelaide Apr.
28, 1995). http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/950428a2.html. For
the comment of Jacob. S. Ziegel on this decision see http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/
cisg/biblio/4ziegel.html
21
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
199
tions, agreed to supply Rosedown in Australia with some tent equipment.
According to their contract the price was to be paid in instalments. The
contract contained a ROT clause according to which the property in the
equipment would remain on Roder until the payment has been made in
full.
Rosedown fell in serious financial difficulties before making the full
payment to Roder, became insolvent and appointed a new administrator
for restructuring its debts. Subsequently, other creditors of Rosedown approved a Deed of Arrangement for this purpose. Roder avoided the sales
contract, brought an action in Australia and claimed the return of the
tent equipment on the grounds of the ROT clause.
The Australian Court first examined which law should apply, and
found that the sales contract was governed by the CISG as both parties
had their places of business in signatory countries. However, as regards
the validity of the ROT clause and therefore the passing of the property,
the CISG is silent. In this case, the Court applied Australian law as it was
the law of the country where the goods were located (that is lex rei sitae).
Relying on the case law established in Australia24 the Court held the ROT
clause valid. Roder could get back the tent equipment.
In a subsequent decision in the United States, the approach adopted
in the Roder case was confirmed. The Federal District Court of Illinois
also applied domestic law in the Usinor case25 that also related to the
validity of a ROT clause in an international sales contract governed by
the CISG. However, this time the domestic law did not give effect to the
ROT clause.
The Court referred to decisions in cases Aluminium Industrie Vaassen BV v Romalpa Aluminium Limited (1976) and 1 WLR 676, Armour and Another v Thyssen Edelstahlwerke
AG (1991) 2 AC 339
25
Usinor Industeel v. Leeco Steel Products, Inc. 209 F.Supp.2d 880 N.D.Ill.,2002. March
28, 2002. http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/020328u1.html. For
Natasha Turner’s notes on this case see TURNER, Natasha, 17 New York International
Law Review (Winter 2004) 103-109 http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/turner.html
24
200
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
In this case, a French supplier of steel (Usinor) sold steel plate to
an American buyer whose place of business is in Chicago (Leeco). The
contract contained a ROT clause and the French law was chosen as the
applicable law. According to the contract, the disputes relating to the
contract would be resolved by a French Court.
The American buyer, Leeco, granted a security interest in the steel
in favour of a third party bank that granted a credit for the purchase of
the steel. The buyer then failed to make the full payment and became
insolvent. The French seller, Usinor, started court proceedings in Illinois,
as the steel plate sold was in that State, and requested the return of the
possession of the steel relying on the ROT clause.
The Court found that the contract was governed by the CISG as
both the United States and France are signatory countries. However, as
in the Roder case, a domestic law had to apply to evaluate the validity of
the ROT clause.
If French law applied, the clause would be valid and the seller would
be entitled to get back the property. The Court, instead, held that the law
of the state where the goods sold are located at the time of insolvency (lex
rei sitae) is the most appropriate law to apply to this issue.26 It is important
to note that the U.S. Court based its decision on the Australian Court’s
decision in the Roder case.27 Therefore, the Court applied the Uniform
Commercial Code [U.C.C.].
The relevant part of the Usinor decision reads as follows: “Under the “most significant
contacts rule” of the Restatement (Second) which [seller] asks the Court to apply, and
the UCC choice of law provision which [buyer] argues should be the governing test,
the Court finds the same result: Illinois law applies.… Here, the goods are located in
Illinois. Therefore, the most significant contacts are in Illinois.”
27
The relevant part of the Usinor decision reads as follows: “Looking to domestic law to
determine the effect of [seller]’s retention of title clause in light of a third party claim is
also consistent with the Australian court case, Roder Zelt-un Hollenkonstruktionen GmbH
v. Rosedown Park Party Ltd., (No. S6 3076 of 1993; FED No. 1049/95; BC 9501975)
(Federal Court, South Australian District, April 28, 1995) in which the court held that
it needed to look to domestic law to determine the validity of the retention of title provision. While this case is far in distance from the present jurisdiction, commentators on
the CISG have noted that courts should consider the decisions issued by foreign courts
on the CISG.” It is possible to observe that the Court applied the interpretation rule of
26
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
201
According to § 9-103 of the U.C.C. a ROT clause in an international
sales contract has to be registered to be effective28. As Usinor did not know
of this requirement, it had not registered its ROT clause. The creditor
bank’s security interest, on the other hand, was perfected. Therefore, the
Court held that the creditor bank’s security interest has priority over the
seller’s right and the French seller could not have back the steel plate29.
Since this decision, exporters that sell goods on credit to the United
States care more about registering their ROT clauses. This is because it
is now apparent that in the United States and in some other CISG countries, such as Canada30 or Switzerland31, the creditors of insolvent buyers are protected more efficiently than foreign sellers who supply them
under ROT clauses.
In most, if not all, other jurisdictions courts and arbitral tribunals
went on to apply their own domestic laws as lex rei sitae to determine
the validity of ROT clauses in international sales contracts governed by
the CISG32. It is interesting to observe that courts and arbitral tribunals
28
29
30
31
32
the CISG set forth in Article 7(1) to an issue expressly excluded from the scope of the
CISG.
§ 9-103 U.C.C. http://www.law.cornell.edu/ucc/9/9-103.html
The Court referred to, among others, HONNOLD by reaching this decision: “John
Honnold writes in Uniform Law for International Sales § 444 (3d ed. 1999) that ‘[t]he
seller’s right under the Convention to recover the goods is subject to practical limitations. This remedy is of special importance when the buyer is insolvent; in this setting
the rights of creditors are likely to intervene by levy of execution or by the designation
of a receiver or trustee in bankruptcy. The Convention will not override the rights of
creditors, purchasers and other third persons granted by domestic law; under Article 4,
the Convention ‘governs only ... the rights ... of the seller and the buyer ...’.”
Article 9 in the new Québec Civil Code of 1994 See also CULLEN, Canada in VON
ZIEGLER, Alexander et al. (eds.), “Transfer of Ownership in International Trade” 2nd
Edition, 2011, pp. 63 et seq.; WIRES, supra 5, pp. 11-13.
Articles 715 and 716 of the Swiss Civil Code of 1907 http://www.admin.ch/ch/f/
rs/210/a715.html
See Decision 4861/2006 of the Court of Appeals of Athens (Automobile catalyst case)
http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/060000gr.html
Serbia 15 July 2008 Foreign Trade Court of Arbitration attached to the Serbian Chamber of Commerce (Milk packaging equipment case) http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/
wais/db/cases2/080715sb.html
202
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
base their decisions on previous court decisions in other CISG countries
on the same subject relying on the interpretation rule of the CISG set
forth in Article 7(1).33 Therefore, it is possible to foresee that courts will
continue to apply their own domestic laws in such cases.
IV. Prospective Application in Turkey
A. Substantive rules of Turkish law as lex rei sitae
Going back to our hypothetical case, under the light of the above,
will the Turkish judge apply Turkish law to determine the validity of the
ROT clause? As the goods sold by the foreign seller to the Turkish buyer
are in Turkey, lex rei sitae is Turkish law. Considering the case law established on this issue in other CISG countries, applying the substantive
rules of Turkish law as lex rei sitae seems to be the first option. In this case,
who will be protected; the Turkish creditor bank that granted a credit to
the insolvent Turkish buyer or the foreign seller?
In this regard, Turkish law, as Swiss law does, brings the duty to
register ROT clauses in notary public office of the place of business of
the buyer.34 This duty is set forth in Article 764 of the Turkish Civil Code
of 200135. It is worthy to mention that the duty of registration was not
reminded in the New Turkish Code of Obligations. A foreign seller that
studies only the Turkish Code of Obligations risks omitting this duty
Besides Usinor studied above, also in the award in Milk packaging equipment case the Sole
Arbitrator referred to the Roder decision for the sake of uniform application according
to Article 7(1) of the CISG: “This position is in accord with foreign judicial practice,
which should be taken into consideration for the purpose of achieving uniform application of the Convention, pursuant to Article 7(1) of the Convention. For example, the
Australian Federal Court for South Western Australia decided to apply the Vienna Convention to a contract for sale of goods which contained a provision on retention of property over the delivered goods until the complete payment of the contractual price in
the case, Roder Zelt- und Hallenkonstruktionen GmbH v Rosedown Park Pty and Reginald
Eustace ((1995) 57 FCR 216, 240 (FCA)).”
34
For detailed information on the issue see ERDEM, Ercüment, Les nouvelles fonctions de
la propriété in ERDEM, Ercüment, “Milletlerarası Ticaret Hukuku ile İlgili Makaleler”,
Istanbul, 2008, p. 303.
35
Article 764 of the Turkish Civil Code of 2001
33
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
203
of registration because of the misleading language in the new code. In
Article 253 of the New Turkish Code of Obligations, it is stated that in
installment sales of commercial goods, the contract has to be made in
writing and if there is a ROT clause, it must be laid down in the contract36. This wording gives the impression that to be made in writing is
enough to give effect to a ROT clause. A reference in this article to the
provisions of the Turkish Civil Code that relate to ROT clauses might be
quite useful. The New Turkish Code of Obligations was an opportunity
to remind this duty to sellers, but unfortunately, this was not done and
this opportunity is missed.
Let us assume that in our example, the foreign seller omitted to register its ROT clause in the notary public office. In this case, its interest
may not be protected and the buyer’s other creditors, such as its bank
in Turkey, will be happy for that. Therefore, foreign sellers that supply
Turkish buyers under ROT clauses have to be very careful and not omit
the duty of registration. Otherwise, we may witness other Usinor cases in
Turkey.
B. Can the application of lex rei sitae be considered as
“uniform application” in the sense of Article 7(1) of
the CISG?
We have seen that the courts and arbitral tribunals in other CISG
countries apply their own national laws as lex rei sitae to evaluate the validity of ROT clauses. While doing so, some courts and arbitral tribunals
even expressly refer to Article 7(1) of the CISG. This practice and the
Article 253 of the New Turkish Code of Obligations titled “Installment Sales” reads as
follows: “In case if the good is sold within the commercial activity of the seller, the following shall be laid down in the contract:
…
9 If provided, contract clauses regarding retention of title or transfer of claim for the
purchase price.
[Taksitle satış…Malın satıcının ticari faaliyeti kapsamında satılması hâlinde, sözleşmede
aşağıdaki hususlar belirtilir:
9. Öngörülmüşse, mülkiyetin saklı tutulmasına veya satış bedeli alacağının devrine
ilişkin anlaşma kayıtları.]”
36
204
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
references by the courts to previous judgments in other CISG countries
give the impression of a uniform application of Private International Law.
However, should this practice necessarily be considered as a “uniform
application”? As appears from the title of this paper, my opinion is that
the answer is no. This is because of three reasons:
First, considering the legal consequences, applications of different
national laws bring to very different solutions that are not predictable.
If a seller supplies different buyers in different countries, it will have
to examine whether its ROT clause has to be registered in every single
country. This is not practical, neither cost-efficient37. If it does not register its ROT clause, an unregistered clause will have different effects in
different jurisdictions. It will probably be held valid in Australia, France,
Serbia and Greece, whereas it will be invalid in the United States, Québec, Switzerland and Turkey. It is difficult to call this situation a “uniform
application” and this situation is obviously not what was aimed by the
uniform law.
Second, to reach the solution of lex rei sitae, some courts correctly
apply their rules of private international law. This being the case, for
countries whose rules of private international law lead to lex rei sitae there
would remain no practical difference in this regard between referring and
not referring to Article 7(1) of the CISG.
Third, although the practice of the courts has been different so far,
from a procedural point of view, it is possible to argue that Article 7(1)
of the CISG cannot apply to issues expressly excluded from the scope
of the CISG. More precisely, in the text of the CISG there is nothing to
justify these references to Article 7(1) in cases that relate to the passing
of the property. This being the case, this practice may even be considered
as “running wild with the CISG”.38
This was one of the arguments of Usinor in the Usinor case. See http://www.cisg.law.
pace.edu/cisg/wais/db/cases2/020328u1.html
38
LOOKOFSKY, Joseph, Not running wild with the CISG, 29 Journal of Law and Commerce (2011), pp. 141 et seq.
37
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
205
Considering all these, it may be more appropriate to evaluate the
references by the courts and arbitral tribunals to Article 7(1) of the CISG
and to previous decisions made in other CISG countries as a part of the
“homeward trend” in favor of the lex fori, instead of a uniform application.39
Besides, it should be emphasized that the attempt by national courts
to fill the gap intra legem in Article 4 of the CISG by means of a uniform
application is highly encouraging. I find this particularly important because this practice of the courts may be a gateway to unify also the field
expressly excluded from the scope of the CISG.
C. Turkish rules of Private International Law to
determine the validity of ROT clauses
If we do not consider lex rei sitae as a uniform application, this leads
us to a second option: The Turkish judge may have to determine the applicable law through Turkish conflict of laws rules. In this case, the result
will be quite different from the practice in other CISG countries.
Let us assume that in our hypothetical example, the parties did not
make a choice of law in their contract. In this case, the Turkish judge may
apply Article 24(4) of the Turkish Code of Private International Law of
2007, according to which in the absence of a choice of law by the parties,
the law most closely connected to the contract will apply.40 Moreover, in
the Turkish Code of Private International Law there is a more specific
provision that relates to real rights and to the property right in particular.
According to Article 21(1) of the Turkish Code of Private International
Law “Right to property and other real rights in movable and immovable
On this point see FERRARI, Homeward Trend and Lex Forism Despite Uniform Sales
Law, Vindobona Journal of International Commercial Law & Arbitration (1/2009)
pp. 15-42, available at http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/ferrari17.html ;
DIEDRICH, supra 21, p. 304
40
Article 24 (4) of the Turkish Code of Private International Law reads as follows: “In
case if the parties did not make a choice of law, the law most closely connected to the
contract shall apply to the relationship arising from that contract. [Tarafların hukuk seçimi yapmamış olmaları hâlinde sözleşmeden doğan ilişkiye, o sözleşmeyle en sıkı ilişkili
olan hukuk uygulanır.]”
39
206
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
properties are subject to the law of the country where goods are situated
at the time of the transaction”41. In a sales contract, this law is very likely
to be the one of the country of the seller.
If, in our hypothetical example, the judge opts for this second option and the law of the country of the seller gives effect to an unregistered
ROT clause, the foreign seller may have the right to get its goods back.
However, if the law of the country of the seller requires ROT clauses to
be registered, it is difficult to foresee the effect of such requirement on
the goods sold and exported to the buyer’s country.
In the New Turkish Code of Obligations there is another new article
that is worthy of mention: according to Article 262 of the New Turkish
Code of Obligations “Buyer whose place of domicile is in Turkey can neither derogate from the jurisdiction of the court of its place of domicile,
nor make an arbitration agreement with regard to disputes arising out of
installment sales contracts to which it is a party.”42
This provision should aim at protecting weaker parties, consumers
in particular, from disadvantages of installment sales. However, this is not
the meaning that we get from the wording of this article. This article is
drafted in such a broad manner that its application to even international
sales contracts seems possible. Especially, the expression of “buyer whose
place of domicile is in Turkey” seems to imply that this article applies to
international sales contracts too. In our hypothetical example, if the seller
supplies industrial machinery equipment, for instance, to a buyer in Turkey, will they not have the right to settle their disputes in arbitration?
My opinion is that this article should be interpreted narrowly to apply to
domestic sales contracts only.
This article reads as follows: “Taşınırlar ve taşınmazlar üzerindeki mülkiyet hakkı ve
diğer aynî haklar, işlem anında malların bulunduğu ülke hukukuna tâbidir.”
42
The original text of Article 262 of the New Turkish Code of Obligations reads as follows:
“Yerleşim yeri Türkiye’de olan alıcı, tarafı olduğu taksitle satış sözleşmesinden doğacak
uyuşmazlıklar konusunda, yerleşim yerindeki mahkemenin yetkisinden önceden feragat
edemeyeceği gibi, tahkim sözleşmesi de yapamaz.”
41
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
207
V. Is This Result in Conformity With the Purposes of
the Uniform Law?
We have seen that these two options may lead us to opposite results.
None of these two options dominates in absolute terms and they bring
two major problems. The first problem is unpredictability of any result
and lack of uniformity in application: as the property issues are left to
domestic laws, it is difficult to foresee which rule will govern the validity
of a ROT clause and the only thing that is certain is uncertainty. Maintaining legal certainty and creating uniformity were among the main
objectives of the CISG.43 However, as regards the passing of the property,
these objectives have obviously not been achieved.44
The second problem is that both options may lead to an unjust result: If the Turkish judge adopts the first option, and applies substantive
rules of Turkish law as lex rei sitae, there is the risk that a ROT clause in an
international sales contract may not be effective, being contrary to the will
of the parties. If the judge adopts the second option and applies different
domestic laws to different sales contracts, there is the risk that some of the
creditors of the same buyer are protected while others are not.
These problems basically stem from the inconsistency of the rules
of domestic laws to govern international transactions. What the courts
apply in the absence of a uniform rule is the rules of domestic laws, which
are drafted for the purposes of domestic trade. The requirement of reg On this point see, among others, ZELLER, Bruno, “CISG and the Unification of International Trade Law”, 2007, pp. 19 et seq.; CUNIBERTI, Gilles, Is the CISG benefiting anybody? Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 2006. Available at SSRN: http://
ssrn.com/abstract=1045121; TAKAWIRA, Admire, Departing from mere compromise:
Reformulating the remedy of specific performance under the Convention on the International
Sale of Goods (CISG) in line with the Convention’s underlying goals, November 2007, Available at http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/biblio/takawira.html
44
VISSER criticizes that the property issues are left to national laws and argues that this is
not in conformity with Article 7(1) of the CISG: “In the case of Article 4(b) CISG, for
instance, the Italian system of the transferring ownership must be used, when the rules
of private international law of the forum lead to the applicability of Italian law. Of course,
this is not in conformity with the basic idea behind the drafting of CISG, which is creating uniformity. This can be derived from Article 7(1) CISG.” VISSER, supra 5, p. 81
43
208
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
istration of ROT clauses may be meaningful for protecting third parties
in domestic transactions. However, expecting foreign sellers that sell on
credit to buyers in Turkey or in the United States to comply with this
requirement is not realistic. This rule is of domestic character and does
not answer to the need of protecting foreign parties to international sales
contracts. If Turkish judges apply this requirement to foreign sellers, this
will definitely not help to protect international trade.
On the grounds of the above, it is possible to say that the gap intra legem in Article 4(a) and 4(b) of the CISG has not yet been filled
by a uniform application despite the efforts of the courts. Instead, the
more the case law on this issue develops, the more the need for a fair and
predictable uniform application is felt. For these reasons, the validity of
ROT clauses in international sales contracts should be subject to another
regime than the rules of particular domestic laws.
Conclusion
The reason for which the gap intra legem in Article 4 cannot be filled
in an efficient manner is the absence of a substantive rule of international
character on the passing of the property in international sales contracts.
We are still quite far from having such a rule in the context of a convention
or a model law. We have seen that application of domestic laws does not
always lead to satisfactory solutions. Thus, it would be more appropriate
not to insist on filling this gap by the rules of domestic laws where the
result is likely to be unsatisfactory.
As a result the question still remains: what rule shall the Turkish
judge apply in evaluating the validity of a ROT clause in an international
sales contract?
Although Article 21(1) of the Turkish Code of Private International
Law deals with property issues, it does not bring a direct answer to how
the validity of ROT clauses in international sales contracts should be
evaluated. Article 764 of the Turkish Civil Code deals only with ROT
clauses in domestic sales contracts. Therefore, at least as regards the validity of ROT clauses in international sales contracts, Turkish judges may
Lack of Uniform Application Regarding Transfer of Property in International Sales
Contracts With Particular Regard to Retention of Title Clauses [Yıldırım]
209
consider that there is no rule in the domestic law to fill the gap of Article
4 of the CISG. According to Article 1(2) of the Turkish Civil Code, in
case of a gap intra legem the judge shall decide according to the customs
and usages45. In our case, the judge may examine whether there is an international trade usage to fill the gap in question.46
The most commonly used model sales contracts may be an indication
for judges about the existence of an international trade usage on the use of
the ROT clauses. In the ICC’s Model International Sale Contract, for instance, Article 6 is a ROT clause.47 In this Model Contract, if you thick the
box next to YES in this article, the seller keeps the ownership of the goods
until the full price is paid. This Article reflects a practice established in international commercial contracts and is aimed at becoming a transnational
rule48. Therefore, it seems appropriate that judges evaluate the validity of
ROT clauses in international sales contracts in the light of this practice and
in a way to give effect to what was intended by the parties.
While deciding on the validity of a ROT clause in an international
sale contract, it may also be useful to refer to general principles of law,
such as good faith and fair dealing. This solution would be also in line
with Article 7(1) of the CISG. In the lack of a relevant uniform rule, a
reference to a generally recognized principle of law or to international
trade usages may create a chance for a prospective uniform application
on this subject. As regards all other issues that relate to the passing of
the property, it appears that judges have no other option than applying a
The original text of his article reads as follows: “In the absence of an applicable provision
in law, the sudge shall decide according to customs and usages; in the absence thereof,
according to the rule he would establish if he were the legislator. [Kanunda uygulanabilir
bir hüküm yoksa, hâkim, örf ve âdet hukukuna göre, bu da yoksa kendisi kanun koyucu
olsaydı nasıl bir kural koyacak idiyse ona göre karar verir.]”
46
BİRSEL, Mahmut, Ticari Örf ve Adet, 2 Ankara Barosu Dergisi 205, 1968, p. 208.
47
Article 7 of “General Conditions” of the ICC Model International Sale Contract reads
as follows: “If the parties have validly agreed on retention of title, the goods shall remain the property of the Seller until the complete payment of the price, or as otherwise
agreed”. To give effect to this clause, parties shall thick “yes” in Article 6 of the “Specific
Conditions”.
48
On contribution of ICC Model Contracts to lex mereatoria, see ERDEM, Ercüment,
ICC Model Contracts in ERDEM, supra 34, p. 517.
45
210
Yeni Türk Borçlar Kanunu ve CISG’e Göre Satış Sözleşmeleri
domestic law to be determined according to the relevant rules of Private
International Law.