mentalKLINIK-biograp.. - Louise Alexander Gallery

Transkript

mentalKLINIK-biograp.. - Louise Alexander Gallery
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
:mentalKLINIK
Founded in 1998
:mentalKLINIK is an artist duo
Yasemin Baydar and Birol Demir live and work in Istanbul
Education
Yasemin Baydar (1972, Istanbul, Turkey)
1990-1994
Mimar Sinan University, Faculty of Fine Arts, Istanbul / Turkey
Birol Demir (1967, Ankara, Turkey)
1990-1992
M.A. Mimar Sinan University, Faculty of Fine Arts, Istanbul / Turkey
1986-1990
Mimar Sinan University, Faculty of Fine Arts, Istanbul / Turkey
Exhibitions
2015
Solo Show, Porto Cervo, Sardinia, Italy
2014
Plurivocality, Group Show, İstanbul Modern, İstanbul
2014
Thank You For Your Cooperation, Gallery Isabelle Van Den Eynde, Dubai
2013
MAGMAONTHEMOUNTAIN, İstanbul Modern, İstanbul
Performative Dinner
2013
FreshCut, MAK NITE Lab @MAK Columned Main Hall MAK- Austrian
Museum of applied Arts / Contemporary Art, Curator: Marlies Wirth,
Performative Installation
2012-13 Encounter, The Royal Academy In The Middle East, Katara Doha Qatar,
Curator: Kathy Battista
2012
TerriblyJolly, İstanbul
Real-time Sculpture
2013
MAGMAONTHEMOUNTAIN, Paris France
Performative Dinner
2012
HappilyDizzy, Paris
2012
İstanbul Modern-Rotterdam, Boijmans Van Beuningen Museum,
Rotterdam / Netherlands
2011
That’s Fucking Awesome, Galerist/ Hasköy Istanbul
Curator: Jerome Sans
201130 Et Presque-Songes, Maison Revue Noire, Paris / France
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
2010
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
Silence_Storm, Port İzmir2, International Triennial of Contemporary Art,
Izmir / Turkey, Curator: Necmi Soenmez
2010
From İstanbul They Come, Kappatos Gallery Athens / Greece
2009
A Survey of Turkish Art, Cuadro Fine Art Gallery Dubai
2009
rABBIThtOLE, Galerist, Istanbul / Turkey
2009
PuFF, Art Basel 40, Art Unlimited Basel / Switzerland
2009
TagCloud, :mentalKLINIK, Istanbul / Turkey
2008
TagCloud, :mentalKLINIK, Istanbul / Turkey
2007
BinaryOccupations Phase1. Surface, :mentalKLINIK Istanbul / Turkey
2007
Converted01, X-CUBE© locker, Tokyo / Japan
2007
Give Joel a Gift, You Will Be Gifted, 30 and Almost-Dreams Exhibition,
Antanarivo / Madagascar
2007
Frozen45, Tomorrow Now Exhibition, MUDAM, Luxembourg
(Musee d’Art Moderne Grand-Duc Jean), ExpoVente
Curators: Alexandra Midal & Bjorn Dahlström
2004
self01, in collaboration with MUDAM, Luxembourg
(Musee d’Art Moderne Grand-Duc Jean), ExpoVente
Curator: Marie-Claude Beaud
2003
[copy], :mentalKLINIK, Istanbul / Turkey
2001-02 {game}, :mentalKLINIK, Istanbul / Turkey
2000
(sleep), :mentalKLINIK, Istanbul / Turkey
2000
:mentalKLINIK was founded and opened its own space in İstanbul
Yasemin Baydar
1997
Karanfilköy, Right to Shelter, Kültür Group,
5th International Istanbul Biennial, İstanbul / Turkey
1996
A Gender Project from İstanbul, Kültür Group,
Shedhalle, Zurich/ Switzerland
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
1994-1995 Co-Founders of Artist Run Space ‘Devlet Han’
1994
Contemporary Artists, Painting and Sculpture Museum, İstanbul / Turkey
1993
Contemporary Artists, Painting and Sculpture Museum, İstanbul / Turkey
Birol Demir
1994-1995 Co-Founders of Artist Run Space ‘Devlet Han’
1993
Group Exhibition Urart Gallery, Ankara /Turkey
1992
Group Exhibition Urart Gallery, Ankara /Turkey
1991
Group Exhibition Maçka Art Gallery, Ankara /Turkey
1992
San-Art Exhibition, Ankara /Turkey
1991
Solo Exhibition Urart Gallery, Ankara /Turkey
1991
Solo Exhibition Çanakkale Gallery, İstanbul /Turkey
Teaching / Lecturing
2009 Obscure Object, Workshop, Ecole Speciale d’Architecture, Paris / France
2009 Undisciplined State of Mind, Ecole Speciale d’Architecture, Paris / France
2009
Present Future, Tent, Rotterdam / Netherlands
2008
Undisciplined Designing; the Theory and Practice of :mentalKLINIK, Studium Generale Rietveld
Academie, Amsterdam / The Netherlands
2008
:mentalKLINIK, DAI-Week, Dutch Art Institute, Enschede / Netherlands
2008
Çağdaş Sanat Konuşmaları 2, Çağdaş Sanatta Sivil Oluşumlar ve
İnisiyatifler, Yapi Kredi Cultural Center, Istanbul / Turkey
2008
Non-Detail, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul / Turkey
2008
Non-Detail – Workshop, Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul / Turkey
2008
Bir Çalışma Biçimi Olarak Tasarm, İstanbul Modern, Istanbul / Turkey
2008
Güncel Sanat Tartışmaları: Bağımsız Bünyeler, Mimar Sinan University,
Istanbul / Turkey
2007
:mentalKLINIK Statement, Dreams Of Art Spaces Collected, The International Gesellschaft Der
Bildenden Künste (IGBK) in co-operation with Deutscher Künstlerbund, Berlin / Germany
2004
Chat at Mudam Camp de Base, Musée D’Art Moderne Grand-Duc Jean / Luxembourg
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
Publications / Bibliography
That’s Fucking Awesome, 2012 ISBN: 978-97592510-9-3
Designed by :mentalKLINIK, Published by GALERIST
156 Pages, Istanbul, 19,5 x 26cm
(uyku) sleep isbn: 9758614002
editor: birhan keskin , book design: didem ateş photography: ömer kokal illustration: kazumi yamomoto
takaya
colour
seperation:
grafik
film
printing:
ohan
matbaacİlİk
printing
date:
mayİs,
2001
publisher::mentalKLINIK
{oyun} game isbn: 9758614010
editor : tül akbal süalp authors: tül akbal, ayşetül demirbaş, haziran düzkan, ömer süalp, gökçe algan,
meral özbek, ali akay, zerrin yanİkkaya, nurçay türkoğlu, fuat erman, süheyla kİrca, selim eyüpoğlu,
burçak madran, selahattin özpalabİyİklar, birhan keskin, marsel, ethem özgüven, melis zararsİz, enelmare
printing stil matbaacılık date of publication: may, 2002 publisher: :mentalKLINIK
[kopya] copy //unpublished
editor : Ali Akay authors: Ali Akay, Giray Pultar, Pelin Çayİrlİoğlu, Olcay Akyİldİz,Serkan Özkaya,Melih
Başaran, Nermin Saybaşlı, Levent Çalıkoğlu, Jan Hein, Selahattin Özpalabİyİklar, Murat Odabaşİ, Ethem
Eldem publisher::mentalKLINIK
self 01
editor: birhan keskin date of publication: september, 2004
publisher: :mentalKLINIK / MUDAM
wanting book odd notebook isbn: 9758614029
authors: birhan keskin, özen yula, tül akbal süalp translation:liz amado (eng), esra özdoğan (fr)
design:mentalKLINIK graphic operator: esra atila printing: ofset yapİmevi date of publication: ekim, 2004
publisher: :mentalKLINIK/MUDAM
contents isbn: 9758614037
project: yasemin baydar, birol demir photography: ahmet elhan editor: tül akbal süalp research: eren
pultar translation esra özdoğan, cem akaş design:mentalKLINIK graphic operator esra atila printing ofset
yapİmevi date of publication: ekim, 2004 publisher: :mentalKLINIK / MUDAM
Çağdaş Sanat Konuşmaları 2 isbn: 978-975-08-1178-4
- Çağdaş Sanatta Sivil Oluşumlar ve İnisiyatifler
Category :Art editor: Levent Çalkoğlu publisher: YKY
Sanatın ve Sosyolojinin Ruh Hali
author : Ali Akay Category Theoria-2 publisher: Bağlam Yayıncılık
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
Musée D’art Moderne Grand-Duc Jean 2000-2004 ALMANACH isbn: 2-919923-01-3 director : Marie-Claude
Beaud date of publication: october, 2004
publisher: Foundation Musée D’art Moderne Grand-Duc Jean
Luxembourg
User’s Manuel, Contemporary Art In Turkey 1986-2006 isbn: 978-3-86588-392-6
editor Halil Altındere, Süreyya Evren Category: Art date of publication:September 2007 publisher: art-ist +
revolver books
5. Internatıonal İstanbul Biennial, On Life, beauty, Translations and Other Difficulties isbn: 975-7363-03-0
curator: Rosa Martinez editor Emre Baykal date of publication:1997 publisher: : İstanbul Foundation For
Culture and Arts
+++5. Internatıonal İstanbul Biennial, On Life, beauty, Translations and Other Difficulties isbn: 975-7363-03-0
curator: Rosa Martinez editor Emre Baykal date of publication:1997 publisher: : İstanbul Foundation For
Culture and Arts
Kültür ein Gender - Projekt aus İstanbul isbn: 3-907829-06-9
curator:
Ursula
Biemann
editor
Emre
Baykal
Category
publication:1997 publisher: : Shedhalle Zürich, Die Autorinnen
Kunst-Feminismus-Migration
date
of
LOUISE ALEXANDER GALLERY
!
!
web: www.louise-alexander.com
email: [email protected]
tel: +44 7809030121
docu:mentalKLINIK issues
:mentalKLINIK duo has founded docu:mentalKLINIK in 2002 as a form of documentation.
1.
TENEZZUL (condescension),
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.2, June, 2002
2.
BELLEK (memory),
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.3, July, 2002
3.
HAL (state of being)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.4, August, 2002
4.
DEFO (flaw, defect)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.5, September, 2002
5.
ALTÜST/TERSYÜZ (upside-down/inside-out)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.6, October, 2002
6.
SİMYA (alchemy)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.7, November, 2002
7.
HİÇ (nothing)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.8, December, 2002
8.
REKLAM (advertisement)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.9, January, 2003
9.
SAVAŞ (war)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.10, February, 2003
10.
FOTOĞRAF (photography)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.11, March, 2003
11.
VİRUS (virus)
Trendsetter, Vol.1, No.12, April, 2003
12.
BİRİKTİRMEK (to collect)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.1, May, 2003
13.
ALKIŞLAMAK(to applaud / to clap)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.2, June, 2003
14.
YELLENMEK(to fan/ fanning)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.3, July, 2003
15.
TASVİR (description)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.4, August, 2003
16.
SURET (appearance, copy)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.5, September, 2003
17.
INDEKS(index)
Trendsetter, Vol.2, No.6, October, 2003
18.
_ccidRnt
Colophon 2007
19.
Image / Imagine
Fashion Shoot for Nico Magazine, Sping/Summer 2007
20.
agorophobia ]control initiative[
art_ist dergisi
!
INTERVIEW
WITH JÉROME SANS
2011
J.S.
When did you start your collaboration and why?
:MK
You might not recognize it at first but we are very different from each
other, both with an unusual disposition. It was the anticipation of an
uncanny outcome that triggered us to collaborate.
We started working together in 1995 during the first project we
realized in Devlet Han which was used for exhibitions as well as
functioning as a studio on Istiklal Street. After the collaboration in
1995, our individual works and production styles started gradually to
converge and engendered a common ground. In 1998, the inception
of :mentalKLINIK as both an idea and an actual space, followed. We
decided as a duo to start up a space where we would be able to
develop our art practice as well as art theory in an interdisciplinary
setting. We never limited things to only one form; on the contrary we
were interested in the multiplicity of forms.
…we are aiming to
achieve what one
might define as the
third position while
working as a duo.
This is perhaps where
our idea of plurality is
grounded.
22
Actually, since the beginning of our collaboration we are aiming to
achieve what one might define as the third position while working as
a duo. This is perhaps where our idea of plurality is grounded.
J.S.
What did each of you produce separately before you met each other
and started to work together?
:MK
We were both working as individual artists before we started
collaborating. Birol had many solo and group exhibitions. Yasemin,
besides working as an individual artist, participated with the
“Kültür Group” to a project in Shedhalle, Zurich and to the 5th
Istanbul Biennial curated by Rosa Martinez. Gradually, Birol’s passion
for material contaminated Yasemin while her interest in theory
contaminated Birol.
J.S.
Besides your life as a couple, what brought you to a shared artistic
collaboration?
:MK
A couple? That is something we tend to forget quite often…
During our past experiences of collaborating with each other, we
worked together even as we conceived of an idea, much before the
23
processes of presentation or construction. Thus the structure almost
always automatically formed and flowed. Yet the form identified
and defined itself as if autonomously, and in that process of flow we
became a duo.
We don’t simply complete each other; rather we produce and create
while deconstructing one another’s work. We provoke each other.
There is almost always something like an error within our work,
something reminiscent of a defeat. At times we each try to negate
one another as we work. For example in our last work, we even tried
to eradicate both our signatures. To erase, to efface attracts us both.
Sometimes Birol starts with a material and Yasemin objects to it; then
the material disappears and a new one replaces it. Actually there is
almost always an initial phase where we construct in our minds by
just talking. And in that phase everything finds its own material, its
own construction and deconstruction processes. Then, the end result
is always more than, beyond the sum of the two of us; it is always a
third. Very rarely what we end up with is something we started with. It
always transforms on the way…
We provoke each
other. There is almost
always something
like an error within
our work, something
reminiscent of a
defeat… To erase, to
efface attracts us both.
J.S.
From 1998 to 2000 you opened a space named Boutique éphémère.
What was the concept?
:MK
What we aimed at during that early phase of :mentalKLINIK was to
eradicate institutionalization and hierarchy. We invited participants
from different disciplines. This enabled us to equalize them in a way,
not in the sense of identifying them with each other but in terms of
refusing to place them within a hierarchy. We were trying to move
beyond our own institutionalization as well as trying to break free
from the institutionalization of art and culture in general.
Actually, the name you refer to “Boutique éphémère” was the title
of our friend Joel Andrianomearisoa’s exhibition, a fifteen days
boutique, which we hosted in our space. In any case the idea of an
ephemeral boutique was something that we had been utilizing in
our projects. For example Marie-Claude Beaud, director of MUDAM
who commissioned the ~self01 project, called it “Expo Vente.” All the
projects we realized then pointed at the idea of ephemerality within
24
the anxiety of contemporary art; they created their unique behavioral
attitudes.
Our exhibition space had a cloud of suspicion around it. We have to
admit that we love this state of causing doubt and suspicion, this state
of dubiousness. Although the space did not apparently invite anyone
in once someone entered inside, its ambience kept him/her captive.
Our exhibition
space had a cloud of
suspicion around it.
We have to admit that
we love this state of
causing doubt and
suspicion, this state of
dubiousness.
J.S.
How did the activity you had at the Boutique Ephemere evolve into
the artistic team you became thereafter?
:MK
We had a very productive and enriching process but we knew that if
we continued on the same we would start repeating ourselves and
become institutionalized - exactly what we were trying to avoid! We
did not want the whole thing to become a signature. We could foresee
that if we continued, the form would be established, finalized.
After the first MUDAM experience we had a more introverted phase
up until 2007. Then, in 2007, we were invited to participate in the
“Tomorrow Now: when design meets science fiction” exhibition at
MUDAM curated by Alexandra Midal and Björn Dahlström. We started
to work and create as Yasemin Baydar and Birol Demir, and Frozen 45”
was our first creation with which we participated to the exhibition.
That same year we went to Madagascar for participating in Joel’s
special birthday exhibition “30 and almost-dreams”. In addition to
all these, we realized another ephemeral, one-week long exhibition
Binary Occupations in our space.
J.S.
Why have you chosen to work under the generic name
:mentalKLINIK? What does this term mean for you?
:MK
It has a reference to our early phase when we also contemplated on
the concept and phenomena of clinic; what does it mean to work on
a case? What does it mean to gather a group of people around a case
and discuss the matter in hand with them?
It also represents something where theory and practice coexist, like
the ‘mental’ referring to the mind and the ‘clinic’ to the practice. Last
25
but not the least, it was the catchiness of the name which interested
and attracted us the most. Rather than using two separate artist’s
names we wanted an anonymous name which would also be catchy.
We should not forget that the therapeutic effect is a part of our work
from time to time as well!
We might talk of
something where the
idea and the object
are superposed,
overlapped.
J.S.
Why have you placed the punctuation of a ( : ) colon within your
generic name :mentalKLINIK?
:MK
Because we are a duo since the beginning! And because, we are
always saying something, stating something. The colon implies
that something is just about to follow while it also builds up an
expectation. When we start speaking what always follows at first is
:mentalKLINIK. We always pronounce :mentalKLINIK in the beginning.
The (:) also enables us to take the first place when in an alphabetical
order.
J.S.
Why mental is in small letters and KLINIK big ?
:MK
We are not conservative about it anymore… Sometimes we use only
small letters and at other times only capital letters. We don’t care
either way as long as it somehow subverts the meaning…
J.S.
Is this an affirmation that your art is about ideas rather than
marketable objects and that your work is a reactionary form of
open laboratory, a think tank that you develop together?
:MK
26
We might talk of something where the idea and the object are
superposed, overlapped. Since the beginning, even when we started
first with a concept, we let the objects develop always in relation
with the concept, the idea. We let the participants produce and
create something rejecting the preliminary concept if they wished.
Sometimes the ideas transformed the objects and sometimes the
other way around. The process was never too strict. At the end of the
day what we strived for was to produce the traces which would appeal
to the various senses of the audience. Therefore the objects and the
ideas constantly collided with each other; the energy thus created
carried things beyond the five senses. :mentalKLINIK’s theory and
practice is never meant to explain one another; only when they are
brought together do they create anew.
We can talk of openness in the sense of breaking down the strict
boundaries of disciplines. Not in the sense of being an open
laboratory, open to anyone’s participation. It was always with our
initiation first that we started to collaborate with people. We opened
up a laboratory space within the concept, the subject we were
interested in. That space assumed an open quality once we invited
people into that space. Besides, all our work including the most recent
ones is open-ended.
:mentalKLINIK’s theory
and practice is never
meant to explain one
another; only when
they are brought
together do they
create anew.
The fact that we work as a duo might also contribute to the sense
of openness in our work. The idea of being crowded, populous,
especially when you work within arts and culture, as well as the fact
of being within Turkey’s geography might at times breed very tiring
processes. Even if we praise ways of creating collaboratively, it still
is a very difficult process and has the inclination to tend towards
something where egos clash. However we address the notion of
crowdedness as polyphony. It is not singularity but polyphony which
interests us. Like in the ~self01 exhibition, even if things seemed to
have a singular style on the surface they created a polyphonic nature
of their own.
J.S.
Who are the patients of your Klinik?
:MK
They are variable. However we can definitely talk about a therapeutic
effect. Anyone who visits an exhibition of ours always leaves with a
particular state of mind beyond only seeing the works.
We now work with Galerist but we still have a group of young
:mentalKLINIK followers visiting the gallery. Galerist gained a new,
different group of audience. It is difficult to define our followers
either in terms of age or profession; they are really variable. Our work
sometimes touches upon everyday life and if someone is interested
in a piece from everyday life then s/he can relate to our work. What
we are trying to say is that it is not necessary for him or her to have an
intellectual background or to be related with contemporary art.
27
J.S.
How would you define your work?
:MK
We don’t like to define it but we might talk about it. We don’t like
definitions…
21st century brought about a distinctive model of artistic existence.
As artists of this generation we create open-ended works which
don’t subject an art work to exact definitions. There is simultaneity
between the materials used and the techniques employed. As an
artist duo we work to open up unfamiliar dimensions, new spaces
and unknown senses. The aesthetics of design, new technologies and
new media are all among our inspirations. :mentalKLINIK’s aesthetic,
rather than create a visual style, stimulates various senses. We present
the audience with a new visuality which they have not consumed
before. We use the materials of today and the language of today. We
are interested in the present moment, in the “now”. And we expand
this present moment. We look for the ideologies behind everything
that stimulates us; we are under an immense bombardment in the
extremely short duration of the moment. These ideologies provoke
the suspense and anxiety in our works. There came first a generation
who wanted to dominate nature and now our generation wants to
make peace with it but in a utilitarian manner. Along with this attitude
come many anxieties. The electrification in the body and the state of
mind this anxiety generates provides the vibrancy and the ambiguous
aesthetic of our works.
The electrification in
the body and the state
of mind this anxiety
generates, provides
the vibrancy and the
ambiguous aesthetic
of our works.
28
J.S.
What are your art and cultural references?
:MK
We are influenced equally by a concept, an artist, an art movement,
fashion, an emergent culture, architecture, biochemistry, a new
technology or philosophy of science. Art is not necessarily our primary
source of inspiration. All those disciplines which shape us and all the
gaps within their relationships to culture influence us and provoke
us to create. At the same time we have a very skeptical approach to
culture and history since the beginning. Or, a suspicious approach
more precisely. The more we see of how history is recorded and
transferred, how it is made up of many layers and how there is an
abundance of distorted, deceitful histories, the more we become
suspicious. We think that geography is a given. The geography we
occupy generates many expectations as the third world. Yet we never
were interested in or responded to those expectations. However, we
should admit that the presence of those expectations provoked us;
the orientalist gaze, the exotic perception. Even if avoiding these
expectations directed us towards minimalism it also created ruptures
with our geography.
The more we observe
how history is recorded
and transferred, how
it is made up of many
layers and how there
is an abundance of
distorted, deceitful
histories, the more we
become suspicious.
J.S.
Have you ever thought of referring to artists’s groups from the 8Os
working under generic names such as GroupMaterial, Information
Fiction Publicité, General Idea…?
:MK
For example we have a lot in common with General Idea and there
are many things parallel in our working methods. However we did
not yet know of them when we formed our own method of work;
we discovered them only later. We did not take any of them as a
reference but now we identify the similarities retrospectively. There
are similarities with them in terms of our desires and the reactions we
gave to our era.
J.S.
Why did you entitled your glass series-pieces Sliver? Does this have
a connotation with slicing or cutting, something of an element of
danger, like art
:MK
Cutting and slicing; these are the elements of danger which mankind
has been subject to for ages. Fragmentation and the severance of
the relations with the general network paved the way for the “uniperson” to emerge. Under these circumstances one cannot gather
together the pieces of “uni-person” who is consoled by the stories
of individualism and personalization. The ruins of history and the
fragmentation of mankind come into play in our works as a project
of networking rather than as a reason for complaint. We have so
many materials at our disposal …. We create a surface and that
surface breaks into pieces the image of the onlooker and the space
occupied by him. It transports him and the space into a suspicious,
suspended dimension. The process also subjects him to a kind of
violence and thus transforms him. His comfort zone is threatened as
29
Where we stand in
time and space, we
seek to break down the
borders and surpass
the categories. We like
to imagine that all
these categories get
emptied into the sea
and meld with it.
he is confronted with a surface which constantly reflects back to him
his image. It is a moment of confrontation for the on-looking subject
with his own fragmentation. What we propose is not nature itself but
man-made nature.
J.S.
Many of your ideas are born in series of unique pieces that you call a
« set ». How does this function?
:MK
The world is violently crowded!
J.S.
Your work seems to have a twist on minimalism of a Donald Judd. Is
this reference intentional? What does minimalism mean for you?
J.S.
Your production has multiple facets, not a single visual vocabulary.
How do you link all your pieces, from Superhero to robots…?
:MK
We like the works of Donald Judd but we don’t work referencing
directly a particular artist or an art movement. From time to time
art history is a reference for our various works, however not more
or not less than many other areas which also become a reference
in our works. The reductionist approach of minimalism might be
visually related to our work but on the other hand it has served
also as a contrast for our work semantically. Our attitude renders
visible the invisible, the ideological, in opposition to minimalism’s
approach which foregrounds objectivity. We are interested in invisible
ideologies, in the fact that what you see is not actually what it is. What
is seen is only a partial view of the façade. In the age of augmented
reality, image and objectivity have lost their plausibility. Today time
and space lapses create new mediums, and the virtual world is
superimposed on the physical world.
:MK
We create our own vocabularies; material vocabulary, sound
vocabulary…all sorts of sensuous vocabularies. We build our story by
associating these various parts and vocabularies within a network.
Linear narrative is a pretty straight line or there are some zigzags. We
regard our narrative as a network, a web. There are very emotional
pieces as well as robots next to each another since our present day
accommodates them all. Today it is impossible to talk of a single
thing, a linear approach to history. After all these fractures, we now
have fragmented identities. And what we are doing is like archeology;
we are like the archeologists of today. Thus our narrative is always
fragmented and interwoven.
The Western rationale prescribed categories. Art movements got
categorized within these categories. Where we stand in time and
space, we seek to break down the borders and surpass the categories.
We like to imagine that all these categories get emptied into the
sea and meld with it. So that new relationships, new aesthetics
can emerge in the most unexpected moments; and this is the fluid
modernity of the 21st century after postmodernity. That’s very exciting
and inspirational…
30
J.S.
What is your Relationship to design?
:MK
Design is an integral, an inseparable part of our lives and therefore it
is also ideological. It dictates all of our lives…this ideological aspect of
design provokes us and provokes the ideals!
And what we are doing
is like archeology;
we are like the
archeologists of today.
Thus our narrative is
always fragmented
and interwoven.
Besides the teddy bears today are not hand-sawn; they are probably
manufactured in factories operated by robots. The inhuman and the
emotional stand overlapped, or face to face. A very inhuman thing
can dwell in a humanly place or next to a humanly thing where such
an encounter, confrontation is taking place. On the other hand all
these robots are produced by humans to enable more leisure time.
Technology is progressed for the benefit of mankind and that benefit
is oriented towards the notion of leisure time. In the same process
we observe also the robotification of humans. The tension in our
works stems from such an anxiety. The applications of biochemistry
and biotechnology in interaction with the human body, is a sort of
robotification process. We are in a gap where the robot enters into
the human body and where the human might transform into a robot.
In the past there was such a binary opposition; the mankind and the
nature. The man produced and improved technology looking at the
nature. Today the robots are manufactured looking at men or animals.
It is funny that all those robotic movements of the robots, barely freed
of the organic quality of human movements, are very primitive for the
31
time being. Once they start uniting with our bodies they will become
invisible. By using robots we point at this ongoing process. It is also
probable that what is emotional is getting robotic. How much does
what we define as emotional today, resemble what was defined as
emotional a hundred years ago?
J.S.
There is no longer
a contrast between
nature and man; these
binary oppositions
have collapsed. Such
reflections determine
our aesthetics.
Emotional is natural
and robotic at the
same time…
:MK
Fear, Affect, Liar, some of your Works have emotional connotations
next to others which are devoid of any human characteristics such
as robots, slivers,… Why this extreme balance?
This extreme balance reveals the disappearance of the borders
between the human and the non-human; there is a tense relationship
between the object and the human in our age, they are equalized
as both are datafied. There is no longer a contrast between nature
and man; these binary oppositions have collapsed. Such reflections
determine our aesthetics. Emotional is natural and robotic at the
same time…
J.S.
Why your SuperHero is dressed as a teddy bear? Does it mean that
the real hero today is the one who brings comfort and calm to
society?
:MK
The type of a leader who could provide comfort and calm to today’s
society is a totalitarian one; this is enough of a reason for uneasiness
and anxiety. On the contrary, we are after not comfort and calm,
but chaos. We believe that only the awkward and bizarre attractions
within chaos can achieve to establish a new system.
Teddy bear represents a transitional object like a security blanket;
only by means of the teddy bear does one separate from the mother
figure which at another level evokes the separation of society from a
totalitarian system.
J.S.
32
Whiff, Double Cherry and Moet both have a hedonistic appeal which
on the surface can be read as festive and glamorous but when you
look a bit closer there is an underlying violence which denotes an
after party or a creepy beginning of the end. Is this intentional?
When disgusting and
beautiful coexist there
is a new aesthetics,
a fresh definition
of beauty; you also
render the violence of
beauty more violent.
:MK
We always celebrate the beginning of the end! New aesthetical
excitements and body language, the visual codification of pleasure
brought into our agenda by long lasting foreplays, the sexuality
of a generation who can never achieve a complete orgasm find an
embodiment in our inviting but distant aesthetics. We provoke our
audience to experience the underlying violence once they enter into
the world of this vicious glamour.
J.S.
Like the title of this exhibition you often use oxymorons (figure
of speech that combines contradictory terms) in your works with
language (He is disgustingly handsome/ She is awfully beautiful) Is
this a reflection on the inevitable paradox of life… death ?
:MK
We don’t celebrate life or its beginning by our works, we celebrate
death. We celebrate the end; we celebrate because it is over. For
example we celebrate when a movement comes to an end. It is the
ending of something rather than its beginning which we celebrate.
As for the oxymorons, we use them as amplifiers, enhancers. They are
oxymorons but also intensifiers at the same time. We propose that
perhaps today we are under the domination of language more than
ever. It is no longer enough to call someone beautiful. The way you
employ language sets apart that someone’s particular beauty from
the others, and also reveals the difference of today’s notion of beauty.
When disgusting and beautiful coexist there is a new aesthetics, a
fresh definition of beauty; you also render the violence of beauty
more violent.
There is an element of violence in our works; that is maybe why we
celebrate death… actually it is not death but more properly said the
end, the finale. We take the celebration of the end in the service of a
new beginning. It is not life we celebrate but the ending of present
systems and this paves the way for a fertile ground on which new
things can grow.
We are always aware of the paradox of life and death but it is new
possibilities we celebrate by our works.
33
We don’t use language
to explain things; in
fact we use it to blur
things. We might use
it also to blur what
it points at. There is
always a dynamic
relationship.
34
J.S.
What is your Relationship to language, to words?
:MK
Language is one of the vocabularies of our aesthetics. We search
for diversified means of expression. Language comes into play in
our works as it is shaped within our aesthetics. When we write an
independent text we want it to create a new meaning as it interacts,
collides with other works. We don’t use language to explain things; in
fact we use it to blur things. We might use it also to blur what it points
at. There is always a dynamic relationship. We say what we want to say
by distorting it. Besides we defeat it once more by our aesthetics as we
say it. To blur meaning, to make it awry, to open up a space for a new
meaning to emerge; these are what inform our work.
J.S.
Do you feel related to conceptual art?
:MK
We build our art on conceptuality but not on conceptual art.
Conceptualism resides in everything but conceptual art is the name
of an art movement of a particular period, a period that is again
categorized….
J.S.
Why do you use carpets? Was it a way to play with clichés about
Turkey?
:MK
Carpets are a new means of expression, a new language. They are like
a text; that’s how we regard them. We create a new language with
them and they speak in different dialects. They speak in a forbidden
dialect. The staples on them refer to their urban disobedience. The
carpets are produced using traditional methods, but the staples
embedded on them are sharp, hard and pain-inflicting; they indicate
violence. They bear on them the narratives of various centuries and
regions but they also pierce the gaze of the observer. The staples
bring in a distance; this distance also avoids any sort of an association
with either orientalism or self-orientalism. We live in an age which has
already moved far beyond these issues…
J.S.
How do you see Turkey in the globalized time?
:MK
In a globalized age Turkey is carried away with the idea of progress.
We believe that it follows the path of progress. However this notion
of progress, of development is the continuation, extension of the
western thought of the 20th century. Progress is placed always before
and above everything else since Turkey has not experienced the
process of modernization in a healthy way or like western societies;
therefore it sometimes stands in the way of many things. It bears a
destructive potential.
Turkey is also politically very rooted and therefore it embraces
with enthusiasm all impacts of globalism be it from the east or the
west. This is maybe why it constantly changes directions. It faces
all directions and is influenced by them all. If there would be a pill
whose effect would make you experience a century, Turkey would be
the first one to swallow it. It has multiple anxieties like catching up
with today’s technologies and it is a very anxious country due to the
problems it encountered during the process of westernization, as well
as due to the desires and pleasures coming from its empirical past.
The nomadic roots of its society still persist in the states of mind of its
members.
If there would be a pill
whose effect would
make you experience a
century, Turkey would
be the first one to
swallow it.
J.S.
Who are the artists of your generation that you feel close with their
attitudes?
:MK
When we started mentalKLINIK we had affinities with relational
aesthetics but we usually found it over-optimistic. Our approach was
to move beyond criticizing the present times and beyond drowning
in the hole of criticism; we aimed at expanding chasms which bear
new possibilities and at weaving new web of relations. Of course, we
paid attention not to over-idealize it either. We reflex by reflecting
our times. We emphasize the meaninglessness, futility of anxieties by
rendering them visible. When we think of the artists of our generation
Douglas Gordon, Ugo Rondinone, Martin Creed and Doug Aitken are
the ones that comes to our mind.
J.S.
Why not creating a real Mental Klinik space that would be a kind of
factory of ideas that you would share with others?
:MK
If you have a space, welcome, we’d do it! Perhaps we will rent out
Andy Warhol’s factory once we make enough money; or better, do you
know of any studios for sale in China?
35
Actually we would love to work in and occupy such a space
temporarily if somebody wishes to lend it to us for a while. We really
fancy the idea and all proposals are welcomed!
Actually more than
changing lies into
truth or fake into real,
our work generates
a sense of playing a
poker game; you never
know if your counterpartner is bluffing or
not, if what s/he says is
true or not…
36
J.S.
Two of your works Cheater and Liar are dealing with falsification. Do
they have to do with the emotion of Poker games? Is art about the
alchemy of changing lies into truth or fake into real?
:MK
In our opinion art has its own reality. We never refer to such a
transformational power of art. But we rather regard it as an area
where it is possible to create a reality of its own. We always examine
the tension between imagining and realizing something and that is
what we did also in our works like Cheater and Liar. To experience
falsification many times in that process and to create works with the
aesthetical elements conditioned by it… our works were the result of
a very long process which had many fluxes and refluxes… To subvert
one another…When we work as a duo we subvert each other and this
subversion informs our process.
Actually more than changing lies into truth or fake into real, our work
generates a sense of playing a poker game; you never know if your
counter-partner is bluffing or not, if what s/he says is true or not…
and the tension in the game, even the game itself feeds on that
ambiguousness...
37