- iBrarian

NATION-STATE FÜRMATİON:
STUDY OF T H E T U R K I S H
RtVOLUTION
GULALPf
HALDUN
N.
DEGREE
UMI
DATE:
Dissertaton
Services
1991
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
v
INTRODUCTION
l
CHAPTER
1. CONFLICTING THEORETICAL
PERSPECTIVES
Statemenr of Che Thesis
Aiternative PerspecCives
Conceptual Framework
CHAPTER
7
U
24
2 . CAPITALISM AND THE STATE
Incroduccion
The Marxian Theory
The Weberian Theory
Underdeveloped Capicalism and che Scace
State as a Formal Institution
CHAPTER
26
31
40
49
57
3. THE MODERN NATION-STATE AND THE OTTOMAN
EMPİRE
Introduction
The Rise and the Structure of the Modern State
Nacions and Nacionalism
The Globalization of the Nation-State
The Ottoman Empire and Non-Colonial Transformation
CHAPTER
4 . THE CLASSICAL REGIME OF THE OTTOMAN
EMPİRE
Introduction
The L a n d Regime: Feudal or Asiatıc?
The Adminiscrative Structure and Social Classes
The Dissolucion of the Classical Regime
CHAPTER
5. THE TRANSFORMATİON
OF THE OTTOMAN
63
64
71
79
.. 88
93
94
.... 105
113
EMPİRE
Introduction
Aiternative Theses
C l a s s e s and che Transformation of che State
C l a s s e s and che Transformation of Identity
120
122
137
166
CHAPTER 6. THE KEMALİST "REVOLUTION" AND THE
OF THE TURKISH NATION-STATE
Introduction
T h e War of Liberation
Bourgeois Revolution?
Antı-Imperialist Revolution?
Principles of Kemalism
FORMATİON
179
184
194
202
213
CHAPTER 7. CONCLUSION
220
REFERENCES
227
vi il
REFERENCES
Ahmad,
Feroz (1969), The Young T u r k s : The Committee of
Union and Progress in Turkish Policics. 1908-1914.
Oxford Universıcy Press.
Ahmad,
Feroz (1980), "Vanguard of a Nascenc Bourgeoisie:
The Social and Economic Policy of the Y o u n g Turks,
1908-1918" in 0. Okyar and H. Inalci)^, e d s , Social
and Economic Historv of Turkev (1071-1920) , Ankara,
1980.
Ahmad,
Feroz (1984), "The Late Ottoman Empire" in Marian
Kent, ed-, The Great, P o w e r s and the End of the
Ottoman Empire, London: George Ailen £ Unwin, 1984.
Ahmad,
Feroz (1988), "War and Society Under the
Turks." Review. 11 (2): 265-86.
Young
Akat, Asaf S. (1983), "iktisat ideolojisi Üstüne D e n e m e " in
A.S. Akat, Alternatif Büyüme Stratejisi, istanbul:
iletişim.
Aksin,
Sina (1977), "Osmanli-Türk Toplumundaki S i n i f
Üzerine Bir Deneme," Toplum ve Bilim. 2.
Yapisi
Alavi, Hamza (1972), "The State in the Post-Colonial
Societies: Pakistan and Bangladesh," New Left
Review. (74) : 59-81.
Alavi,
Hamza (1975), "India and t h e Colonial Mode
Production," The Socıalist Register.
of
Alderson, A.D. (1982), The Structure of the ottoman
Dynasty, (first published in 1956 by O x f o r d
Üniversity Press), Greenwood Press.
Amin, Samir (1976), ünegua1 Deve1opment.
Review Press.
New York:
Monthly
Amin, Samir, Giovanni Arrighi, A n d r e Gunder Frank and
Immanuel
Wallerstein (1982),
Jynamics of Global
Crisis. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Anderson, Benedict (1983), Imagined Communities:
Reflections on the Origin and Soread of
Mationalism. London: Verso .
227
Anderson, James (1986), "Nacionalisn and Geography" İn
J. Anderson, ed., The Rise of the Hodgrn State.
NJ: Humanicies Press International, 1986.
Anderson, M . S . <1966) , The Eastern Ouestion. 1774-1923,
York; St. Martın's Press.
Anderson, Perry (1974), Lineages of the Absolutist
London: NLB.
New
State.
Antonio, Robert J. and Ronald M . Glassman, eds, (1985), A
Weber~Marx Dialogue, Lavrrence: üniversity Press of
.Kansas.
Aricanli, Tosun, Raci Bademli, and ilhan Ugurel (1974),
"The Abolition of Asar," Mimeo, Cambridge, KA.
Armağan, Servet (1978), "Memleketimizde Ilk Parlamento
Seçimleri" in Bahri Savci, ed., Kanun-u Esasi'nin
100• Yili (Armağan). Ankara: A.U. SBF Yayınları,
1978.
Arthur, Chris J. (1974), "Editor's Introduction" in K. Marx
and F. Engels, The German Ideology. (ed. by C.J.
A r t h u r ) , Lawrence & Wishart, 1974.
Avcioglu, Doğan (1969), Türkiye'nin Düzeni, Ankara: Bilgi
Yayinlari.
Avineri, Shlomo (1972), Hegel's Theorv of the Modern State,
Cambridge: Cambridge Üniversity Press,
Aydemir, Şevket Süreyya (1968), inkılap ve Kadro,
published in 1932), 2nd printing, Ankara:
Yayinlari.
Aydemir, Şevket Süreyya (1974), Tek Adam
istanbul: Remzi Kitapevi.
(first
Bilgi
(3 V o l s ) ,
Aydemir, Şevket Süreyya (1976), ikinci Adam
istanbul: Remzi Kitapevi.
(3 V o l s ) ,
Bailey, Anne M. and Josep R. Llobera, eds, (1981), The
Asiatic Mode of Production, London: Routledge &
Kegan P a u l .
8acque-Grammont, J-L. and Paul Dumont, eds, (1983),
Economie et Societes dans l'Emoire Ottoman, Paris:
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique.
Baer, Gabriel (1969), "The Development of Private Ownership
of Land" İn G. Baer, Studies in the Social Historv
of Modern Egvpt. Chicago: Üniversity of Chicago
Press.
228
Baran, Paul (1957), The Political Economy
York: Monthly Review Press.
oc Growth. New
Barkan, Ömer Lütfi (1938), "Türkiye'de Toprak Meselesinin
Tarihi Esaslari" in O.L. Barkan, Türkiye'de Toprak
Meselesi, istanbul: Gözlem Yayinlari, 1980.
Barkan, Ömer Lütfi (1940), "Türk Toprak Hukuku Tarihinde
Tanzimat ve 1274 (1858) Tarihli Arazi Kanunnamesi"
in O.L. Sarkan, Türkiye'de Toprak Meselesi,
istanbul; Gözlem Yayinlari, 1 9 8 0 .
Barkan, Ömer Lütfi (1956), "Türkiye'de 'Servaj' Var m i y d i ? "
in O.L.
Barkan, Türkiye'de Toprak Meselesi,
istanbul: Gözlem Yayinlari, 1980.
Barkan, Ömer Lütfi (1980), Türkiye'de
istanbul: Gözlem Yayinlari.
Toprak Meselesi,
BendİK, Reinhard (1964), Nation-Building and Citizenship.
New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Berberoglu, Berch, ed,, (1989), Power and Stability in the
Middle East. London: 2ed B o o k s .
Berkes, Niyazi (1964), The Development of Secularism in
Turkey, Montreal: McGill Üniversity Press.
Berktay, Halil (19B3), "Tarih Calismalari", Cumhuriyet
Dgnemi Turkive Ansiklopedisi. V o l . 9, pp.2456-74,
istanbul: iletişim Yayinlari.
Berktay, Halil (1907), "The Feudalism Debate: The Turkish
End — Is 'Tax-vs.-Rent' Necessarily the Product
and Sign of a Modal Difference?," Journal of
Peasant Studies. 14(3):29l-333.
Bernstein, Henry (1971), "Modernization Theory and the
Sociological Study of Development," Journal of
Deve.lopment Studies. 7{2):141-l6l.
Bernstein, Henry (1979), "Sociology of Underdevelopment
versus Sociology of Development?" in D. Lehmann
(ed.), Development Theory: Four Critical Studies,
London: Frank & C a s s .
Bettieheim, Charles (1972), "Theoretical Comments" in
Arghiri Emmanuei, Unegual Exchanqe. London: New
Left Books, 1972.
Black, Cyril
(1980), "A Comparative Approach to the
Preconditions of Ottoman ModernizaCion,"
International Journal of Turkish Studies. 1(2); 2 5 37.
229
Blaisdell, Donald C. (1929), Şuropear. Financial Control in
the Ottoman Empire, New YorJc: Columbia üniversity
Press.
Bloch, Marc (1961), Feudal Society, Chicago: The üniversity
of Chicago Press.
Boran, Behice (1968), Türkiye ve Sosyalizm
istanbul: Gün Yayinlari.
Sorunlari,
Boratav, KorJıut (1988), Türkiye iktisat Tarihi.
istanbul: Gerçek Yayinevi,
Bottomore, Tom (1985), Theories of Modern
London: Ailen and Unwın.
1908-1985,
Capitalism,
Braude, Benjamin and Bernard Lewis, eds, (1982), Çhriştians
and Jews in the Ottoman Empire, V o l . 1, New York:
Holmes and Meier.
Brenner, Robert (1977), "On the Origins of Capitalist
Development: A Critigue of Neo-Smithian Marxism,"
Hew Left Review. (104): 25-92.
Breuilly, John (1982), Nationalism and the. State,
Manchester: üniversity of Manchester Press.
Brewer, Anthony (1980), Marxist Theories of Imoerialism: A
Critical Survey, London: Routledge s Kegan Paul.
Carnoy, Martin (1984), The State and Political Theorv.
Princeton: Princeton Universıty Press.
Carr, E. H. (1945), Nationalism and After,
Macmillan.
London;
Cin, Halil (1985), Osmanli Toprak Düzeni ve 3u Düzenin
Bozulması, istanbul: Boğaziçi Yayinlari.
Connor, Walker (1984), The National Ouestion in M a r x i s t Leninist Strategy, Princeton: Princeton Üniversity
Press.
Cunningham, A. (1968), "Stanford Canntng and the Tanzimat"
in w.R. Polk and R.L. Chambers, e d s , Beginnings of
Modernization in the Middle East, Chicago;
Üniversity of Chicago Press, 1968.
Curtin, Philip (1966), "Nationalism in Africa,
Review of Politics. 28(2):143-53.
1945-65,"
Danilov, V. I. (1981), "Kemalism and World Peace" in E.
Ozbudun and A. Kazancigil, eds, Atatürk:,, Foupder o:
a Modern State, London: C . Hurst and Company, 1981.
230
Davison, Roderic H. <1963), Reform in the Otcoman Empire,
1856-1876, Princeton: Princeton Üniversity Press.
Davison, Roderic H. (1964), "Environmental and Foreign
Contributions: TurScey" in R.E. Ward and D.A.
Rustow, eds, Political Modernization in Japan and
Turkey. Princeton: Princeton üniversity Press,
1964.
Davison, Roderic H. (1968),
Prentice-Hall.
Turkev,
Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Davison, Roderic H. (1977), "Nationalism as an Ottoman
Problem and the Ottoman Response" in Haddad, w.w.
and w. Ochsenwald, e d s , Nationalism in a NonMational State: The Dissçiution of the Ottoman
Empire, Columbus: Ohio üniversity Press, 1977.
DaMn, Ernest (1973), From Ottomanism to Arabism,
Üniversity of Illinois Press.
O'Encausse, H.C. and S.R. Schramm
liOndon: Al len Lane.
Urbana:
(1969), Marxism and Asia,
DevereuK, Robert (1963), The First Ottoman Conscitutignal
Period. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press,
Divitcioglu, Sencer (1969),
Toplumu, istanbul.
Asva üretim Tarzi ve Osmanli
Dobb, Maurice (1963), SCudies in che Development of
Capitalism, (first published in 1 9 4 6 ) , New York;
International Publishers.
Drabkin, I.S. and B.F. Porshnev (1974), "Bourgeois
Revolution" in Great Soviet Encvclopedia, vol.4,
pp.44-46, London, New York: Macmillan.
Dyson, Kenneth F.K. (1980), The State Tradition
Europe, Oxford: Martin Robertson,
Elicin, Emin T. (1965), Kemalist Devrim
istanbul: Ant Yayinlari.
in western
ideolojisi,
Engels, Frederick (1384), The Origin of the Familv, Private
Procertv and the State, New York: International
Publishers, 1972.
Engels, Frederick (1895), "Introduction" to K. Harx, The
Class SCrugales in France, 1848-1850, New York:
International Publishers, 1976.
Evans, Peter, Dietrich Rueschmeyer and Theda
231
Skocpol,
eds, (1985), Bringing che State Back In.
Cambridge: Cambridge üniversity Press.
Findley, Carter v. (1980), Bureaucratıc Reform in the
Ottoman Empire: The Sublime Porte. 1789-1922.
Princeton: Princeton Üniversity Press.
Findley, Carter V. (1982), "The Acid Test of Ottomanism:
The Acceptance of Non-Huslims in the Late Ottoman
Bureaucracy" in B. Braude and B. Lewis, eds,
Christıans and Jews in the Ottoman Empire, V o l . 1,
New York: Holmes and Meier.
Foster-Carter, Aidan (1974), "Neo-Marxist Approaches to
Development and Underdevelopment" in E. de Kadt and
G. Williams, eds, Sociology and Development.
London: Tavistock.
Foster-Carter, Aidan (1978), "The Modes of Production
Controversy," New Left Review, (107): 47-77.
Frank, Andre Gunder (1967), Capitalism and Underdevelopment
in Latin America, New York: Monthly Revlew Press.
Frank, Andre Gunder (1969), "Sociology of Underdevelopment
and Underdevelopment of Sociology" in A.G. Frank,
Latin America: Underdevelopment or Revolution, New
York: Monthly Review Press.
Friedman, Milton (1982), Capitalism and Freedom, Chicago:
Üniversity of Chicago Press.
Fromm,
Erich
Row.
(1976), To Have or To Be?, New York: Harper &
Geliner, Ernest (1964), Thought and Change,
Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
London:
Geliner, Ernest (1983), Nations and Nationalism.
Basil Blackwell.
Oxford:
Gerber, Haim (1987), The Social Origins of the Modfrr^
Middle East, Boulder, Colorado: Lynne Reiner
Publishers.
Gerth,
H.H. and C.W. Mills, eds, (1946), From Max Weber:
Essays in Sociology, oxford üniversity Press, 1946,
Giddens, Anthony (1981), A Contemporarv Critigue of
Historical Materialism. London: Macmillan.
Giddens, Anthony (1985), The Nation-State and Violence,
Polity Press.
232
Giddens, Anthony (1991), Introduction co Sociology,
Yoric: W.W. Norton « Co.
New
Goldstone, Jack (1986a), "Introduction: The Comparative and
Historical Study of Revolutions" in J. Goldstone,
ed., Revolutions: Theoretical. Comparative and
Historical Studies, New York: HBJ Publishers, 1986.
Goldstone, Jack, ed., (1986b), Revolutions: Theoretical,
Comparative and Historical Studies, New York: HBJ
Publishers.
Gordon, Alec (1973), "The Theory of Che 'Progressive'
National Bourgeoisie," Journal of Contemporarv
Asia, 3 ( 2 ) : 192-204.
Gramsci, Antonio (1971), Selections from Prison Notebooks,
(ed. by Q. Hoare and G.N. Smıch), London: Lawrence
and Wishart.
Gülalp,
Haldun (1983), Gelişme Stratejileri ve Gelişme
ideolojileri, Ankara: Yurt Yayinlari.
Gülalp,
Haldun (1987), "Capital Accumulation, Classes and
the Relative Autonomy of the State," Science and
Society. 51 (3): 287-313.
Gülalp,
Haldun (1968a), "Nationalism, Statism and the
Turkish Revolution: An Early 'Dependency' Theory,"
Review of Middle Sast Studies. ( 4 ) : 69-85.
Gülalp,
Haldun (1988b), "Capital Accumulation and the
State" in M. Williams, ed., Value, Social Form
the State, London: Macmillan.
Gürsel,
and
Seyfettin (1983), "Osmanli Toplumsal Yapisi ve
Kapitalizm," Yapit. (1): 19-35.
Helmreich, Paul (1974), From Paris to Serves: The Partitlon
of the Ottoman Empire at the Peace Conference of
1919-1920. Columbus: Ohio Üniversity Press.
Heper,
Metin (1976), "Political Modernization as Reflected
in Bureaucracic Change: the Turkish Bureaucracy and
a 'Historical Bureaucracic Empire' Tradition,"
International Journal of Middle Sast Studies. 7 ( 4 ) :
507-521.
Heper, Metin (1979), "Patrimonialism in t h e Ottoman Turkish
Public Bureacracy," Aslan and African Studies.
13(1) : 3-21.
Hill, Chriscopher (1976), The English .Revolution. 1640.
London: Lawrence & Wishart.
233
Hobsbavm, Eric J. (1962),
Mentor Books.
The Age of Revolutıion.
1789-1846,
Hobsbavm, Eric J. (1975), The Aoe of Capital, 184B-1875,
New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
Howard,
Harry N. (1931), The PartiCıon of Tur-cey: A
Piplomatic Historv. 1913-1923, Norman: Üniversity
of Oklahoma Press.
inalcık, Halil (1964), "The Nature of Traditional Society:
Turkey" in R.E. Ward and D,A. Rustow, eds,
Political Hodernization in Japan and Turkev,
Princeton: Princeton üniversity Press, 1964.
Inalcik, Halil (1971/73), "The Periods of Development of
the Idea of Republic in Turkey," Cultura Turcica.
(8-10): 6-9.
Inalcik, Halil (1977), "Centralization and Decentralization
in Ottor.an Adminıstration" in Thomas Naff and Roger
Owen (eds), Studies in Eighteenth Century Islamic
Historv, Carbondale: Southern Illinois üniversity
Press.
Inalcik, Halil (1980), "Military and Fiscal Transformation
in the Ottoman Empire, 1600-1700," Archivum
Ottomanicum, VI (Reprinted in: Halil Inalcik,
Studies in Ottoman Social and Economic Historv.
London: Variorum Reprints, 1985).
Inalcik,
Halil {1985a), "The Emergence of Big Farms,
Ciftliks: State, Landlords and Tenants" in H.
Inalcik, Studies in Ottoman Social and Economic
Historv, London: Variorum Reprints.
Inalcik, Halil {1985t), Studies in Ottoman Social and
Economic Historv. London: Variorum Reprints.
Inalcik,
Halil (1987), "When and How British Cotton Goods
Invaded the Levant Markets" in H. Islamoglu-Inan,
ed., The Ottoman Empire and the World-Eccnomv,
Cambridge: Cambridge Üniversity Press, 1987,
Ilslaraoglu)-inan. Huri (1983), "Osmanli Tarihi ve Dünya
Sistemi: Bir Değerlendirme," Toplum ve Bilim. (23):
9-39.
Islamoglu-Inan, Huri (1987a), "Introduction: 'Orientai
Despotism" in World-System Perspective" in H.
Islamoglu-Inan, ed., The Ottoman Empire and the
World-Economv, Cambridge; Cambridge üniversity
Press, 1987.
Islamoglu-Inan, Huri, ed.,
(1987b), The Ottoman Empire
234
and
the World-Economv,
Press.
Cambridge: Cambridge
Isiaraoglu, Huri and Cağlar Keyder
Ottoman History," Review.
Üniversity
(1977), "Agenda for
1 ( 1 ) : 31-55.
Issawi, C h a r l e s (1982), "The Transformation of the Economic
Position of the Millets in the Nineteenth Century"
in B. Braude and B. Lewis, eds, Christians and
J e w s in the Ottoman Empire. Vol. 1, Kew York:
Holmes and Meier, 1982.
Issawı, Charles, ed., (1966) The Economic Historv of the
Middle East. 1800-1914. Chicago: Üniversity of
Chicago Press.
Issawı, Charles (1974), "The Ottoman Empire in the European
Economy, 1600-1914" in K. Karpat, ed., The Ottoman
State and its Place in World Historv. Leiden: E.J.
Brill, 1974.
Issairfi, C h a r l e s (1980), "De-Induscrialization and R e Industrialization in the Middle East since 1800,"
International,_Jpurnal of Middle East Studies.
12 (4) :469-79.
Jessop, Bob (1978), "Capitalism and Oemocracy: The Best
Possible Political Shell?" in G. Littiejohn, et.
a l . , eds, Power and the State. London, 1978.
Jessop, Bob (1982), The Capitalist
Robertson.
State. Oxford: Martin
Karai, Enver Ziya (1981), "The Principles of Kemalism" in
E. Ozbudun and A. Kazancigil, eds, Ataturlc: Founder
of a Modern State. London: C. Hurst and Company,
1981.
Karal, Enver Ziya (1982), "Non-Muslim Representatives in
the First Constitutional Assembly, 1376-1877" in 8.
Braude and B. Lewis, eds, Christians and Jews in
the Ottoman Empire. Vol. 1, New Y o r k : Holmes and
Meier, 1982.
Karpat, Kemal (1959), Turkev's Politics. Princeton
tJniversity Press.
Karpat, Kemal (1968), "The Land Regime, Social Structure
and Modernization in the Ottoman Empire" in W.R.
Polk and R.L. Chambers, eds, Beginnings of
Modernization in the Middle East. 1963.
Karpat, Kemal (1972), "The Transformation of the Ottoman
State, 1789-1908," International Journal of Middle
East Studies. 3 ( 3 ) : 2 4 3 - 2 8 1 .
235
Karpat, Kemal (1973), An Ingulrv into the Social
Foundations of Nationalism in the Ottoman State.
Princeton Üniversity, Center of International
Studies, Research Monograph, No.39.
Karpat, Kemal {1974a), "The Stages of Ottoman History" in
K. Karpat, ed., The Ottoman State and Its Place in
World Historv. Leiden: E.J. Brıll, 1974.
Karpat, Kemal, ed,, (1974b), The Ottoman State and Its P l a c e
in World Historv, Leiden: E.J. B r i l l .
Karpat, Kemal (1977), "Some Historical and Methodological
Considerations Concerning Social Stratification in
the Middle East" in C.A.O. Van Nieuwenhuijze, ed.,
Commoners, Climbers and Hotables, Leiden: E,J.
Brill.
Karpat, Kemal (1982), "Millets and Nationality: The Roots
of Incongruity of Nation and State in the PostOttoman Era" in B. Braude and B. Lewis, eds,
Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire, Vol. 1,
Ne» Yorlc: Holmes and Meier.
Kasaba, Reşat (1987), "Incorporation of the Ottoman
1750-1820," Review. 10(5/6): 805-847.
Empire,
Kasaba, Reşat (1988), The Ottoman Empire and the World
Economy, The Nineteenth Century, Albany: SUNY
Press.
Kasaba, Reşat (1988a), "Was There a Comprador Bourgeoisie
in Mid-Nineteenth Century Western Anatolia?, "
Review. 11 (2): 215-228.
Kay,
Geoffrey (1975), Development and
London: Macmillan.
Underdevelopment,
Kay,
Geoffrey (1988), "Right and Force: A Marxist Critigue
of Contract and the State" in M. Williams, ed.,
Value. Social Form and the State, London:
Macmillan.
Kay,
Geoffrey and James Mott (1982), Political Order and
the Law of Labour, London: Macmiİlan.
Keane, John (1988), Democracy and Civil Societv,
Verso.
London:
.Kedourie, Elie (1956), England and the Middle East: The
Destructıon of the Ottoman Smo-re, 1914-1921,
London: Bowes î Bowes.
Kemp,
Tom
(1967), Theories
of Impç^ialism,
236
London.
Keyder, Cağlar (1976), "The Dissolution of Che Asiatic Mode
of Production," Economy & Societv. 5 ( 2 ) : 178-196.
Keyder, Cağlar (1979), "The Political Economy of Turlcish
Democracy," Hew Left Review, (115): 3-44.
Keyder, Cağlar (1980), "Ottoman Economy and Finances (18811918)" in O. Oîcyar and H. Inalcilc, eds, Social and
Economic History of TurHev (1071-1920). An)cara,
1980.
Keyder, Cağlar (1981), The Definitıon of a Peripheral
Economy: Tu rkev. 1923-1929. Cambridge: Cambridge
üniversity Press.
Keyder, Cağlar
Verso.
(1987) , State and Clasş
in Turlçey,
London:
Keyder, Cağlar (1988), "Bureaucracy and Bourgeoisie; Reform
and Revolution in the Age of Imperialism," Review,
11(2): 151-165.
Kiernan, Victor G. (1980), State and Society in Europe,
1550-1650, Oxford: Basil Blac)cwell.
Kili,
Suna (1978), "1876 Anayasisi'nin Çağdaşlaşma
Acisindan Değerlendirilmesi" in Bahri Savci, ed.,
Kanun-u Esasi'nin 100. Yili (Arnagan) , A n k a r a : A.U.
SBF Yayinlari, 1978.
King,
Roger (1986), The State
Macmillan.
in Modern Societv.
London:
Kinross, Lord (1965), Atatürk: A Biography of Mustafa
Kemal, Tather of Modern Turkev. New York: William
and Morrow Co.
Kongar,
Emre (1977), "Devletçilik ve Günümüzdeki Sonuciari"
in riTIA Mezunları Derneği, Atatürk Döneminin
Ekonomik ve Toplumsal Sorunlari Semineri, istanbul.
Kushner, Oavid (1977), The Rise of Turkish
1876-1908. London: Frank C a s s .
Nationalism.
Kuran,
Ercümend (1968), "The Impact of Nationalism on the
Turkish Elite in the Nineteenth Century" in W.R,
Polk and R.L. Chambers, eds, Beginnings of
Modernization in the Middle East. Chicago:
üniversity of Chicago Press, 1968.
Kucük,
Yalcın (1978), Türkiye Üzerine Tezler. 1908-1978.
istanbul: Tekin Yayinevi.
Kücükömer,
Idris
(1969), Düzenin Yabancilasmasi: Batilasma.
237
istanbul: Ant Yayinlari.
Laciner, Ömer
34 .
(1975),
"12 Mart Üzerine," Birikim.
Laclau, Ernestc (1971), "Feudalism and Capitalism
America, " M e w Left Review. (67) : 19-38.
2(8): 14-
in Latin
Ladas, Stephen P. (1932), The £xchanqe of Minorities:
Bulgaria, Greece and Turkev, New York: The
Macmillan C o .
Lall, S.
(1975), "Is 'Dependence' a Useful Concept in
Analysing (Jnderdevelopment?/" World Development,
3 (11/12) .
Landen, Robert G, (1970), The Emergence of the Modern
Middle East, New Yorit: Litton Educational
Publishing Inc.
Lenin, viadimir I. (1917), The State and Revolution,
(various e d i t i o n s ) , New Y o r k : International
Publishers.
Levis,
Bernard (1968), The Emergence of Modern Turkev, 2nd
ed., Oxford Üniversity P r e s s .
Lichtheim, George (1971), From Marx to Hegel, New York:
Herder and Herder.
Littiejohn, Gary, et.al, e d s , (1978), Power and the State,
London, 1978.
Löwith, Kari (1982), Max Weber and Kari Marx (first
published in 1932 - translated by Hans Fantel;
edited by Tom Bottomore and William Ouchwaite),
London; George Ailen and Unwin.
Löwy, Michael (İ976), "Marxists and the National
tJew Left Review, (96): 81-100.
Ouestion,"
Löwy, Michael (1981), The Politics of Combined and Uneven
Development: The Theorv of Permanent Revolution,
London: NLB.
Macpherson, C . B. (1964), The Political Theory of Possessive
îndividualism, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Mardin, Şerif (1969), "Power Civil Society and Culture in
the Ottoman Empire," Comparative Studies in Societv
and Historv. 11: 258-281.
Mardin,
Şerif (1971), "Ideology and Reiigion in the Turkish
Revolution," Ipternational Journal o f Middle East
Studies. 2 ( 3 ) : 197-211.
238
Mardin, Şerif (1973), "Center-Periphery Relations: A Key to
Turkish Politics?," Daedalus. 102(1): 169-190.
Mardin, Şerif (1981), "Reiigion and Secularism in Turkey"
in E. Ozbudun and A. Kazancigil, eds, Atatürk:
Founder of a Modern State. London: C. Hurst and
Company, 1981.
Marx,
Kari (1894), Caoıtal. vol.3, N e w York:
Publishers, 1976.
Marx,
Kari and Frederick Engels (1848), The Communist
Manifesco. New York: International Publishers,
1983.
Marx,
Kari and Frederick Engels (1974), The German
Ideology, (ed. by C.J. A r t h u r ) , Lawrence & wishart.
Marx, Kari and Frederick Engels
Moscow: Progress.
International
(1974a), On Colonialism,
Masters, Bruce (1990), "The 1850 Events in Aleppo: An
Aftershock of Syria's Incorporation into the
Capitalist World System," International Journal of
Middle East Studies. 2 2 ( 1 ) : 3-20.
HcGowan, Bruce (1981), Economic Life in Ottoman Europe.
Cambridge: Cambridge Üniversity Press.
Moore, Barrington (1966), Social Origins of Dict^t;orship
and Democracy. Boston: Beacon Press.
Mortimer, Edward (1982), Faith and P o w e r : the Politics of
islam, London: Faber and F a b e r .
Naff, Thomas (1977), "Ottoman Diplomatic Relations with
Europe in t.he Eighteenth Century: Patterns and
Trends" in T. Naff and R. Owen, eds, Studies in
Eighteenth Century Islamic Historv. Carbondale:
Southern Illinois Üniversity Press.
Naff, Thomas and Roger Owen, eds., (1977), studies in
Eighteenth Century Islamic History. Carbondale:
Southern Illinois Üniversity P r e s s .
Nairn, Tom (1975), "The Modern J a n u s , " New Left
(94) : 3-29.
Review.
Navari, Cornelia (1981), "The Origins of the Nation-State"
in L. Tivey, ed., The Nation State: The Formation
of .Modern Politics. Oxford: Martin Robertson, 1981.
Nimni, Ephraim
(1985),
"Great Historical Failure: Marxist
239
Theories of Nationalism," Capical and Class. (25):
59-83.
Okyar, Osman (19801, "Ottoman Economic Growth During the
16th Century"
in O. Okyar and H. Inalcik, eds,
Social and Economic Historv of Turkev (1071-1920).
Ankara, 1980.
Okyar, Osman (1983), "A New Look at the Recent Political,
Social and Economic Historiography of the Tanzimat'
in J-L Bacgue-Grammont and ?. Dumont, eds, (1983),
Economie et Societes dans l'Emoire Ottoman, Paris:
Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1983
Okyar, Osman and Halil Inalcik, eds, (1980), Social and
Economic Historv of Turkev (1071-1920), Ankara.
Orcayli, Ilber (1987), imparatorluğun En Uzun Yuzyili. 2nd
ed., istanbul: Hil Yayinlari .
Owen, Roger (1981), The Middle East in the World
180,0-1.914, London: Methuen .
Ökcün, Gündüz, ed., (1968), Türkiye.iktisat
— izmir. Ankara: SBF Yayinlari.
Önder,
Economy,
Kongresi,
1923
izzettin (1981), "Aşarin Kaldiriimasi," Toplum ve
Bilim, 13.
Ozbudun, Ergun and Ali Kazancigil, eds, (1981), Atatürk:,
Founder of a Modern State, London: C. Hurst and
Company .
Palma, Gabriel (1978), "Dependency: A Formal Theory of
Underdevelopment or a Methodology for the Analysis
of Concrete Situations of Underdevelopment?," World
Development. 6 ( 7 / 8 ) : 881-924.
Pamuk, Şevket (1987), The Ottoman Empire and European
Capitalism, 1820-1913, Cambridge: Cambridge
Üniversity Press.
Pamuk, Şevket (1988), "The Ottoman Empire in Comparative
Perspective," Review, 11(2): 127-149.
Pelczynski, Z.A. (1984a), "Introduction: The Significance
of Hegel's Separation of the State and Civil
Society" in Z.A. Pelczynski, ed., The State and
Civil Societv: Studies in Hecel's Political
Philosophv. Cambridge: Cambridge üniversity Press,
1984 .
Pelczynski, Z.A., ed., (1984b), The State and Civil
Socj.etv: Sgudies in Hegel's Political y'hilosophv,
240
Cambridge: Cambridge üniversity
Perincek, Dogu (1979), Kemalist Devrim.
Aydinlik Yayinlari.
Press.
2nd ed.,
istanbul:
Perincek, Dogu (1986), Osmanli'dan Bugüne Toplum ve Devlet,
istanbul: Kaynak Yayinlari .
Petras, James and Stephen Gundle (1982),
Structuralist State Theorizing,"
Crises, 6 ( 2 ) : 161-182.
"A Critigue of
Contemporarv
Petras, James and Morris H. Morley (1981), "The U.S.
Imperial State" in J. Petras, Class, State, and
Power in the Third World. London: Zed Press.
Pflanze, Otto (1966), "Nationalism in Europe, 1848-1871,"
Review of Politics. 2 8 ( 2 ) .
Phillips, Anne (1977), "The Concept of 'Development',"
Revıew of African Political Economy. 6.
Phillips, Peter D . and Immanuel Wailecstein (1980),
"National and World Identities and the Interstate
System," Mimeo: Fernand Braudel Center, State
Üniversity of New York at Binghamton.
Poggi, Gianfranco (1978), The Development
State, London: Hutchinson.
of the Modern
Polanyi, Kari (1944), The Great Transformation,
Beacon.
Boston:
Polk, Nilliam R. and Richard L. Chambers, eds, (1968),
Beginnings of Modernization in the Middle East,
Chicago: Üniversity of Chicago Press.
Poulantzas, Nicos (1973), Political Power and Soci^al
Classes, London: NLB.
Poulantzas, Nicos
NLB.
(1974), Fascism and Dictatorship.
London:
Poulantzas, Nicos (1976), The Crisis of the Dictatorships.
London: NLB.
Puryear, V. J. (1969), International Eçonomics and
Diplomacv in the Near East, Archon B o o k s .
Ouataert, Donald (1979), "The 1908 Young Turk Revolution:
Old and New Approaches," Middle East Studies
Association Sulletin. 1 3 ( 1 ) : 22-29.
Ouataert, Donald (1980), "The Commercialization of
Agriculture in Ottoman Turkey, 1800-1914,"
241
Incernacional Journal of Turkish Studies, 1 ( 2 ) : 3855.
Ouacaert,, Donald (19B3) , Social Disincegracion and Popular
Resistance in the Ottoman Empire, 1881-190,8:
Reactions no European Economic Penetration. New
York: NYU Press.
Ouataert, Donald (1988), "Ottoman Handicrafts and Industry
in the Age of Imperialism," Review, 1 1 ( 2 ) : 169-178.
RoKborough, lan (1979), Ttıeories of
London: Macmillan.
Underdevelopment,
Russell, James w, (1985), "Method, Analysis, and Politics
in Max Weber: Disentangling Marxian Affinities and
Differences, " Historv of Political Economy, 17 (4) :
575-590.
Saba, Paul (1989), "The Armenian National Question" in
Berch Berberoglu, ed., Power and stability in the
Middle East, London: 2ed Books.
Said, Edward w.
Books.
(1978), Orientaiism,
New York:
Pantheon
Sarc, Ömer Celal (1966), "The Tanzimat and O u r Industry" in
C.
Issawi, ed., The Economic Historv of the Middle
past, 1800-1914. Chicago : Üniversity of Chicago
Press, 1966.
Savci, Bahri, ed., (1978), Kanun-u Esasi'nin 100. Yili
jArmaganl, Ankara: A.U. SBF Yayinlari.
Savran, Sungur (1985), "Osmanli'dan Cumhuriyet' e:
Türkiye'de Burjuva Devrimi Sorunu," 1 1 . Tez, ( 1 ) :
172-214.
Schmoller, Gustav (1884), The Mercantile Svstem and its
Historical Signifİ,cance, Augustus H. Kelly, 1967 .
Seton-Watson, Hugh (1964),
London: Methuen.
Nationalism and
Communism,
Seton-Watson, Hugh (1977), Nations and States,
C o l o : Westview Press.
Boulder,
Shaw, Stanford J. (1968), "Some Aspects of the Aims and
Achievements of the Nineteenth-Century Ottoman
Reformers" in W.R. Polk and R.L, Chambers, eds,
Beginnings of Modernization in the M i d d l e East,
Chicago: Üniversity of Chicago Press.
Shaw, Stanford J.
(1971), Between Old and New: The Ottoman
242
Empire Under Sultan Selim III. 1789-1807.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard üniversity Press.
Skocpol, Theda and Ellen K. Trimberger (1977-78),
"Revolutions and the World-.4istorical Development
of Capitalism," Serkelev Journal of Sociology.
(22): 101-113.
Skocpol, Theda (1979), States and Social Revolutions.
Cambridge: Cambridge Üniversity P r e s s .
Skocpol, Theda (1985), "Bringing the State Back In:
Strategies of Analysis in Current Research" in P.
Evans, D. Rueschemeyer and T. Skocpol, eds,
Bringing the State Back In. Cambridge: Cambridge
üniversity Press, 1985.
Smith, Anthony D . (1971), Theories of Nationalism,
Duckworth.
London:
Smith, Anthony D. (1983), State and Nation in the Third
Wojrld. Brighton; Mheatsheaf B o o k s .
Soboul, A. (1977), A Short Historv of the French
Revolution. 178 9-1799, (translated by Geoffrey
Symcox), Berkeley: Üniversity of California Press.
Stokes, Gale (1979-80), "Dependency and t h e Rise of
Nationalism in Southeast Europe, " International
Journal of Turkish Studies, 1 ( 1 ) : 54-67.
Sunar, ilkay (1987), "State and Economy in the Ottoman
Empire" in H. Islamoglu-Inan, ed., The Ottoman
Empire and the World- Economy. C a m b r i d g e : Cambridge
üniversity Press, 1987.
Tekeli,
ilhan and Gencay Saylan (1978), "Türkiye'de
Halkcilik ideolojisinin Evrimi," Toplum ve Bilim.
6/7.
Therborn, Göran (1977), "The Rule of Capital and the Rise
of Democracy," New Left Review, (103): 3-41.
Therborn, GÖran (1978), What Does the Ruling Class Do When
It Rules?. London: NLB.
Tigar, Michael E. and Madeleine R. Levy (1977), Law and the
Rise of Capitalism, New York: Monthly Review Press.
Tilly, Charles (1975a), "Reflections on t h e History of
European State-Making" in C. Tilly, ed., The
Formation of National States İn Mestern Europe,
Princeton: Princeton üniversity Press, 1975.
243
Tilly, Charles, ed., (1975b}, The Formation of Naçional
States in Western Burope, Princeton: Princeton
üniversity Press.
Tilly, Charles (19851, "War Making and State Making as
Organized Crime" P. Evans, D. Rueschemeyer and T.
Skocpol, eds, Bringing the State Back In,
Cambridge: Cambridge üniversity Press, 1985.
Timur, Taner
(1986), Osmanli Kimliği, istanbul: Hil Yayin.
Tivey, Leonard (1981), "Introduction" in L. Tivey, ed., The
Nation State: The Formation of Modern Politics,
Oxford: Martin Robertson.
Toprak, Zafer (1977), "Halkcilik ideolojisinin Oluşumu" in
IITIA Mezunları Derneği, Atatürk Döneminin Ekonomik
ve Toplumsal Sorunlari Semineri, istanbul.
Toprak, Zafer (1982), Türkiye'de 'Milli iktisat'
1 9 1 8 ) . Ankara: Yurt Yayinlari.
(1908-
Trimberger, Ellen K. (1978), Revolution From Above:
Militarv Bureaucrats and Development in Sgvpt,
Peru, Turkev and Japan. New Brunswick: Transaction.
Trimberger, Ellen K. (1986), "A Theory of Elite
Revolutions" in J. Goldstone, ed., Revol,utions_:
Theoretical, Comparative and Historical Studies,
New York: HBJ Publishers, 1986.
Tucker, Robert C , ed., (1978), The Marx-Enqels Reader, Mew
York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Tuncay, Mete (1978), Türkiye'de Sol Akımlar
3rd ed., Ankara: Bilgi Yayinlari.
(1908-1925).
Turner, Bryan S. (1974), "islam and Ottoman Decline" in
B . S . Turner, Weber and islam: A Critica,!, Ştudv.
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
VİeuK, Steve (1988), "Containing the Class Struggle:
Skocpol on Revolution," Studies in Political
Economv. (27): 87-111.
Hallerstein, Immanuel (1974), The Modern World-Sv5tem I,
New York: Academic Press.
Wallerscein, Immanuel (1980), "The Ottoman Empire and che
Capitalist World-Economy: Some Ouestions for
Research" in O. Okyar and H. Inalcik, eds, Social
and Economic Historv of Turkey (1071-1920), Ankara,
1980.
244
Wailerstein, Immanuel (1982), "Crisis as T r a n s i c i o n " in
Samir Amin, ec.
al., Dynamics of Global Crisis,
New York: Monthly Review Press.
Wallerstein, Immanuel <198'1) , The Politics of the WorldEconomy, Cambridge: Cambridge Üniversity Press.
Wallerstein, Immanuel (1989), The Modern World-Svstem III,
New York: Academic Press.
Wallerstein, Immanuel and Reşat Kasaba (1963),
"Incorporation into the World-Economy: Change in
the Structure of the Ottoman Empire, 1"Î50-1839" in
J-L. Bacgue-Grammont and P. Dumont, eds, Economie
çt Societes dans l'Emoire Ottoman, Paris: Centre
National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1 9 8 3 .
Ward, Robert E. and Dankwart A. Rustow, eds, (1964),
Political Modernization in Jaoan and Turkev,
Princeton: Princeton üniversity Press, 1964 .
Warren, Bili (1980), Imperialism: The Pioneer of
Capitalism, London: NLB.
Warriner, D . (1966), "Land Tenure in the Fertile Crescent"
in C. rssawi, ed., The Economic Historv of the
Middle East, 1800-1914. Chicago: üniversity of
Chicago Press, 1966.
Weber, Max (1946), "Politics as a Vocation" in H.H. Gerth
and C.W.
Mills, e d s , From Max Weber: Essays in
Sociology, Oxfocd üniversity Press, 1946.
Weber, Max (1946a), "Class, Status, and Party" in H.H.
Gerth and C.w. Mills, eds, From Max Weber: Essays
in Sociology, Oxford Universıcy Press, 1946.
Weber, Max (1946b), "Structures of Power" in H.H. Gerth and
C.W. Mills, eds, From Hax Weber: Essays in
Sociology, Oxford Üniversity Press,
Weber, Max (1958), The
Protestant Ethıc and the Spirit of
Capitalism, (translated and edited by Talcott
Parsons), New York: Charles Scribner's S o n s .
Weber, Max (1978), Economv and Socyetv. (ed. by G. Roth and
C. Wittich), Berkeley: üniversity of California
Press.
Weber, Max (1978a), "Bureaucracy" in M. Weber, Economv and
Societv, (ed. by G. Roth and C. H i t t i c h ) , Berkeley:
üniversity of California Press, 1978.
Weber, Max (197ab), "Patriarchalism and Patrimonialism" in
M. Weber, Economy and Societv. (ed. by G. Roth and
246
C. Wiccich}, Berkeley: üniversity of California
Press, 1978.
Weber, Hax {1978c), "Feudalism, Standestaat and
Patrimonialism" in M. Weber, Economv and Societv.
(ed. by G. Roth and C. Wittich), Berkeley:
üniversity of California Press, 1978.
WicJtham, Chris (1985), "The Uniqueness of the East,"
Journal of Peasant Studies. 12{2/3) : 166-196.
Hiley,
Norbert (1987a), "Introduction" in N . Wiley, ed.,
The Marx-Weber Debate, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
Publications.
Wiley,
Norbert, ed., {1987b),
The Marx-Weber Debate.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage Publications.
Williams, Michael, ed., (1988), Value. Social Form and the
State, London: Macmillan.
Wolpe, Harold, ed.,
Production,
Wood,
(1980), The Articulation of Modes of
London: Routledge i Kegan Paul.
Ellen M. (1981), "The Separation of the Economic and
the Political in Capitalism," New Left Review,
(127): S6-9S.
Horsley, Peter (1967), The Third World. 2nd ed., Chicago:
Üniversity of Chicago Press.
Worsley,
Peter (1981), The Three VJorlds. London: Weidenfeld
and Nicolson.
Wright, Erik O. (1978), "Bureaucracy and the State" in E.O
Wright, Class, Crisis and the State. London: NLB.
Wright, Erik O. (1980), "Varietıes of Marxist Conceptions
of Class Structure," Politics and Societv. 9 ( 3 ) :
323-370.
Yerasimos, Stefanos (1987), "The Monoparty Period" in I.C.
Schick and E.A. Tonak, eds, Turkev in Transition.
New Yor)c: Oxford üniversity Press.
Ziemann, W. and M. Lanzendorfer (1977), "The State in
Peripheral Societies," The Socialist Register.
143-177.
Zubaida, Sami (1978), "Theories of Nationalism" in G.
Littiejohn, et. al., eds, Ppwer and the State,
London.
246