وووووووو.luohqglو`پq\d
Transkript
وووووووو.luohqglو`پq\d
ìëæ0DNLQDODUçæ0KHQGLVOHULæ%LUOLéLæ'HUQHéL ìêæ0$.ì1$/$5,æ0h+(1'ì6/(5ìæ%ì5/ìèìæ'(5*ì6ì ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾ 7ROXNS]VO\S ,S\VSâS cKc¾X Y\QKX¾N¾\ ov KcNK LS\ cKc¾XVKX¾\ ,661æ æ0D\çVæ6D\çæ <D\çQæ.RPLV\RQX ._\KX 5+<+k+C 7_]^KPK =½6:+»+< ,Kc\KWKVS 5n=+ 7_RS^^SX ,o5/< 7_\^KdK ,?<1+D =OVKWS k+63¿5+8 2KVSV 965+8 0KSU =9C6? ½VcK] >/5½8 /\NSXv 03<+> 1VNO\OX nk7/8 7 +USP nD <D]çëPDæ$GUHVL ?dKcvKâ¾ -KNNO]S 8Y$ ! 9]^SW +85+<+ >OV$ " !" # 0KU]$ " !" # ZZZLVPDNLQDODUçRUJ HSRVWD S]WKUSXKVK\S*^^WKSVMYW HSRVWD S]WKUSXKVK\S*S]WKUSXKVK\SY\Q *UXSHSRVWD S]WKUSXKVK\S*cKRYYQ\Y_Z]MYW *UXSæHSRVWDæ\HOLNæDGUHVL S]WKUSXKVK\S]_L]M\SLO*cKRYYQ\Y_Z]MYW 7DVDUçPæYHæ%DVNç ,SdSW 1\_Z ,K]¾WO`S =OVKXSU -KNNO]S " 5¾d¾VKc +85+<+ >OV$ " ! 0KU]$ "" " OZY]^K$ SXPY*LSdSWQ\_ZMYW^\ aaaLSdSWQ\_ZMYW^\ *UDILNæ7DVDUçP 2K]KX /<5+8 <OdKX >+8<3@/< <D\çQçQæ7U CO\OV %DVçPæ7DULKL 7Kc¾] ,_ NO\QS cOVO\SXO SVQSVS U_\_W `O U_\_V_ÀVK\K M\O^]Sd YVK\KU NKâ¾^¾V¾\ CKc¾XVKXKX cKd¾VK\NKUS ]Y\_WV_V_U cKdK\VK\¾XK SVKXVK\NKUS ]Y\_W V_V_U SVKX `O\OX U_\_W `O USÀSVO\O KS^^S\ CKc¾XVKXKX cKd¾VK\K M\O^ NOXWOd CKc¾XVKXWKcKX cKd¾VK\ QO\S SKNO ONSVWOd ÖNSÖZ 6 Trençer Teknolojisi 12 ì00%æ$GçQDæ6DKLEL ._\KX 5+<+k+C 6RUXPOXæ<D]çæìëOHULæ0GU ,Kc\KWKVS 5n=+ 4 +DYDæ<Déæ$\çUçFçæ Filtreler 20 Dizel Otomobillerde <DNçWæ6LVWHPL 30 <NVHNæ$ìçQPDæ'D\DQçPOçæ%RUæææ dHOLéLæ3URILOL 36 %DVLWæ8\JXODPDODUæLOHæææææææææ 0DNLQDQçQæê\LOHìWLULOPHVLæYHæ (QHUMLæ7NHWLPLQLQæ$]DOWçOPDVç 46 Lastiklerin Tamir Edilmesi 52 5HQJLQHæ*|UHæ<DéçQæææææææææææ 'XUXPXQXæ'HéHUOHQGLUPHN 56 0DNLQDODUçQæ7DVDUçPçæYHæææææ êPDOLæLOHæêOJLOLæ7HPHOæ6DéOçNæYHæ *YHQOLNæ.XUDOODUçæ 72 6HOæYHæ.RUXQPD 76 <HQLæ.XOYDU 80 %L]æ%\GNæYHææææ 82 86 .LUOHQGLæ'Q\D 'RéXGDQæ'RéDQæ'HVWDQ Etkinliklerimiz ve Haberler 5HNODPæìQGHNVL $/)$7(.æ $/3(0æ $1$'2/8æ(/(.75ì.æ $1$'2/8æ)/<*7æ $1ìê0$.ænX]d 5K\À¾]¾æ $1.20$.æ $6æ.$<1$.æ $7$%(5.æ %2;(5æ %2='$èæ0h+(1'ì6/ì.æ &(1*ì=æ0$.ì1$æ d(6$1æ d8.8529$æ=ì5$$7æ (%(5æ0$.ì1$æ (5æ0$.ì1$æ )25'æ *h5$/3æ9ì1dæ +$.0$.æ +ì'520(.æ½vSXNOUSVO\ 5K\À¾]¾ +06(6$æ ì0(5ææ/7æ ì00%æ .2=0$.6$1æ 1852/æ0$.ì1$æ+\UK 5KZKU ½vS 2.85æ0$.ì1$æ 20æ0h+æ+\UK 5KZKU ½vS 5K\À¾]¾ g=%(.2è/8æ g=d(/ì./(5æ g=.$5'ìê/ìæ 3(1$æ0$'(1æ 3(7/$6æ 3ì00$.6$1æ 306æ.$3/$0$æ 32/7$êæ 5$6ì0æ0$.ì1$æ 6$1.2æ0$.ì1$æænX 5KZKU ½vSææ 6(56$1æ 7(.)$/7æ 7(.120$.æ+\UK 5KZKU 7(06$æ*/2%$/ænX 5KZKU ½vS 5K\À¾]¾ 7ì7$1æ0$.ì1$æ :,57*(1æ <2/æ0$.ì1$æ Önsöz gQV|] 'XUDQæ.$5$d$< ì00%æ<|QHWLPæ.XUXOXæ%DëNDQç .OâO\VS 9U_\VK\ .XcKX¾X OX LcU SÀ WKUSXK]¾ P_K\¾ dOVVSâSXS ^KÀ¾cKX `O 7XSR· ^O v c¾VNK LS\ cKZ¾VKX %DXPDæ # ?V_]VK \K\K]¾ ½XÀKK^ 7KUSXKVK\¾ ½XÀKK^ 7KVdOWO]S 7KUSXKVK\¾ 7KNOXMSVSU 7KUSXKVK\¾ ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾ `O ½XÀKK^ +VO^VO\S ½R^S]K] 0_K\¾ # 8S]KX ^K\SRVO\S K\K]¾XNK cKZ¾VN¾ 0_K\ LKÀVKWKNKX XMO ^W VUOVO\NO YVN_â_ QSLS >\UScO NO NO UK^¾V¾WM¾ `O dScK\O^vS YVK\KU SVQS ]^ NdOcNO SNS `O ^OWZYV_ LS\ RKd¾\V¾U `K\N¾ +XMKU ½dVKXNK NK ZK^VKcKX cKXK\NKâNKX cKc¾VKX UV L_V_^VK\¾ +`\_ZK 2K`K ]KRK]¾X¾ YV_W]_d O^USVOWSÀ _v_ÀVK\ cKZ¾VKW¾cY\N_ 2K`K KVKXVK\¾XNK cYVM_VK\ ]^\O] `O UKcQ¾cVK LOUVScY\VK\N¾ ½À^O L_ ÀK\^VK\ KV^¾XNK # 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO ,K_WK P_K\¾ Kv¾VN¾ 5K^¾V¾WM¾VK\ `O dScK\O^vSVO\ P_K\K _VKÀWKU SvSX UK\K `O NOXSd _VKÀ¾W¾XK cXOVO\OU ^KU]S Y^YL] ^\OX QOWS XO L_V_\VK\]K LSXSZ LS\ KX XMO +`\_ZK·X¾X LS\ UOX^SXO Y\KNKX NK 7XSR·O _VKÀWKcK vKV¾À¾cY\VK\N¾ ,_ WMKNOVOcS cKÀKcKXVK\¾ SdVO\UOX LSd NO L_ ]¾U¾X^¾c¾ XK]¾V KÀKMKâ¾W¾d¾ NÀXcY\N_U 8S]KX ]KLKR +XUK\K 7XSR _vKâ¾XK LSVO^SWSd `K\N¾ K\UKNKÀVK\VK RK`K KVKX¾XK QS^^SU >\UScO NOX 7XSR·O RK^^K +`\_ZK cK QX N\ cKZ¾VKWKcKX _v_À SZ^KVVO\SXSX UKVN¾\¾VN¾â¾ SVU _vKUVK 7XSR·O _v^_U ?vKU LYÀ^_ LYÀV_â_X XONOXS SZ^KV YV_\ OXNS ÀO]SXS N_cKXVK\¾X NSâO\ _VKÀ¾W K\KvVK\¾ SVO QS^WO]S `OcK NXÀ^O ]¾U¾X^¾ vOUO\Sd OXNSÀO]S SVO QSNSÀS SZ^KV O^WO]S SNS 2K `KNK ]ScKR ^Yd L_V_^VK\¾X¾X UYc_ Q\ScO NXWÀ RKVVO\SXS ]Oc\ONO\OU 7XSR·O _VKÀ^¾â¾W¾dNK UK\À¾VKÀ^¾â¾W¾d K\UKNKÀVK\K ]KLKR _vKUVK QOVNSâSWSdS KXVK^WKU^K dY\V_U vOUScY\N_U ì00%æ1HGLU" ½77,% ½À WKUSXKVK\¾ UYX_]_XNK _dWKXVKÀW¾À WKUS XK WROXNS]VO\S ^K\KP¾NKX ##" c¾V¾ +â_]^Y] Kc¾XNK U_ \_VN_ 0K\UV¾ ]OU^\VO\NOX SXÀKK^ PS\WKVK\¾ WKNOX PS\WKVK \¾ SÀ WKUSXK]¾ \O^SMSVO\S SÀ WKUSXK]¾ ^OW]SVMSVO\S `O ]O\ `S]VO\ QOVOX Z\YPO]cYXOVVO\SX Y\^KU KWKvVK ^YZVKXN¾â¾ LS\ NO\XOU^S\ ì00%ªQLQæ$PDFçæ1HGLU" ,K_WK NK vOÀS^VS VUOVO\SX SWKVK^VK\¾ cOXS ^OUXYVYTS WKUSXKVK\¾ SXMO VO\UOX cKXVK\¾XNK VUOWSdSX SWKVK^v¾VK\¾X¾ NK Q\WOU^OX Q_\_\VKXN¾U oVUOWSdNOX NYU]KX SUS SWKVK^v¾ PS\WK UOXNS cKZ¾WVK\¾ YVKX \XVO\S XS P_K\NK NXcK ZKdK\¾XK ]_X_cY\VK\N¾ CO^WSÀ PS\WK NK UK^¾VKWKW¾À ^¾ /`O^ L_ N_\_W `XVOMOU LS\ UYX_ KXMKU% QOVOMOU P_K\VK\K ^OU XYVYTS]S `O UK^WK NOâO\S NKRK cU]OU \XVO\VO UK^¾VWKVK\¾ SvSX ]OU^\ PS\WKVK\¾W¾d¾X RO\ cXcVO ^OÀ`SU ONSVWO]S QO\OU^SâSXS NO LS\ UOd NKRK `_\Q_VKWKU S]^O\Sd ,_ P_K\NK QdVOWVONSâSWSd LS\ UYX_ NK PS\WKVK\¾W¾d¾X +`\_ZK WK\UKVK\¾X¾ ]K^¾X KVWK K\KÀ^¾\WKVK\¾ cKZWK]¾ SNS 7K\UKVK\¾X ]K^¾X KV¾ X¾Z SWKVK^VK\¾X¾X >\UScO NO cKZ¾VWK]¾NK ]KXKcSWSdS QOVSÀ^S\WOXSX LS\ LKÀUK cYV_ YVKLSVS\ ½77,·XSX KWKM¾% vYâ_XV_â_ S^RKV \XVO\ YVKX SÀ WK USXKVK\¾X¾X ^KX¾XWK]¾X¾ _V_]KV ]O\`O^SWSd YVKX L_ \O^SW WKUSXKVK\¾X¾X ScS SÀVO^SVWO]SXS `O OUYXYWSU W\VO\SXSX `O\SWVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]\N\VWO]SXS ]KâVKWKU^¾\ ,SVSXOX WK\UKVK\¾X >\UScO WWO]]SVVSUVO\SXNO Q\O`VS K\UKNKÀVK \¾W¾d NK Y\KNKcN¾VK\ =Kâ YV]_XVK\ ROZ]SXSX ]¾MKU SVQSVO\ScVO Y\KNK NK UK\À¾VKÀ^¾U 0_K\¾X ^KWKW¾X¾ QOdWOU SvSX v QXX cO^WONSâSXS NO ]cVOWOVScSW +WKM¾W¾d% `O\SWVSVSâS ]KâVKcKMKU LSVQS UKcXKUVK\¾XK OX U¾]K ]\ONO _VKÀWKU L_ UKcXKUVK\K SR^ScKv N_cKMKU XS^OVSUVS SX]KX ZY^KX]ScOVSXSX Qv LS\VSâSXS YV_À^_\WKU^¾\ ,_ LSVQSVO\SX ^OUXSU KV^ UKN\YVK\K _VKÀ^¾\¾VWK]¾cVK NK OX cKcQ¾X ÀOUSVNO ZKcVKÀ¾W¾X¾ ]KâVKWKU^¾\ nXWdNOUS Kc # RKdS\KX ^K\SRVO\SXNO " ?V_]VK\K\K]¾ ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾ cKZ¾ /VKWKXVK\¾ `O ½XÀKK^ >OUXYVYTSVO\S 0_K\¾ +8597+5 ½] ^KXL_V· NK cKZ¾VKMKU =OU^\Wd SvSX L_ P_K\ NK VUOWSdNO XOW VS LS\ P_K\ YVWK dOVVSâSXO ]KRSZ ½77, YVK\KU P_K\NK UOXNSWSdO KS^ LS\ ]^KXN SVO YVKMKâ¾d ½77,% ocOVO\SXO RO\ c¾V NdOXVS ]OWSXO\VO\ `O\WOU ]_\O^ScVO cOVO\SXSX LSVQS NdOcSXSX cU]OV^SVWO]SXS ]KâVK WKU^KN¾\ ,_ ]OWSXO\VO\ KcX¾ dKWKXNK ]OU^\NOUS SX]KX VK\¾X LS\ K\KcK QOVO\OU ^KX¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾ ]KâVKWKU^KN¾\ US L_ NK QOVSÀSWS S`WOVOXNS\WOU^ONS\ ½VO^SÀSWSX `O UKcXKâK _VKÀ¾W¾X OVOU^\YXSU Y\^KWNK vYU UYVKcVKÀ^¾ â¾X¾ LSVScY\_d +XMKU P_K\VK\K SVQSXSX NO RSv KdKVWKN¾â¾X¾ Q\cY\_d½R ^S]K] P_K\VK\¾XK UK^¾VWKX¾X `O dScK\O^ O^WOXSX ROW PS\WKVK\¾X ROW NO vKV¾ÀKXVK\¾X `SdcYXVK\¾X¾X QOVSÀWO]SXNO LcU PKcNK ]KâVKcKMKâ¾ UK X¾]¾XNKc¾d ½77,·XSX SX^O\XO^ Y\^KW¾XNKUS Q\_Z WKSVSXNO cO VO\ SR^ScKvVK\¾X¾ Q\_LK N_c_\WKU ]_\O^ScVO cK\N¾WVKÀWK c¾ ]\N\WOU^ONS\ ,+?7+ P_K\¾XK UK^¾VKX `O +8597+5 P_K\¾XK NK UK^¾VKMKU YVKX WWO]]SVVO\O PS\WKVK\K `O dScK\O^vS K\UKNKÀVK\¾W¾dK ½77, YVK\KU LK ÀK\¾VK\ NSVO\Sd .O\XOâSX RO\ v KcNK cKc¾XVKN¾â¾ ½77, NO\QS]S SVQS VS U_\_WVK\ ÀS\UO^VO\ `O LS\OcVO\O M\O^]Sd YVK\KU QXNO \SVWOU^ONS\ =KcQ¾VK\¾W¾dVK ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Trençer Teknolojisi 5KXKV 2KP\ScK^¾ cX^OWVO\S OVO KVN¾â¾W¾dNK L_XVK\¾ QOXOV YVK\KU KXK LVWNO ]¾X¾PVKXN¾\KLSVS\Sd 1. :K^VK^WK UKdWK cUVOWO SVO cKZ¾VKX RKP\ScK^ 2. /U]UK`K^\ `O U¾\¾M¾ U_VVKX¾VK\KU cKZ¾VKX RKP\ScK^ 3. >\OXvO\ U_VVKXK\KU ]O\^ UKcK dOWSXVO\NO NO\SX `O ]\OUVS UKd¾ SVO cKZ¾VKX RKP\ScK^ /X QOVSÀWSÀ cX^OW YVKX ^\OXvO\VO\S vOÀS^VS ÀOUSVVO\NO ]¾X¾PVKXN¾\WKU WWUXN\ KWK RKP\ScK^ cKZ¾VKMKU dOWSXO Q\O ]¾X¾P^K ^KX¾WVKX¾\VK\% 6 1. >YZ\KU ^\OXvO\S c_W_ÀKU dOWSXVO\NO RKP\ScK^ SvSX cKZWKU \^ RKP\ScK^¾ cKZWKU KWKvV¾ U_VVKX¾V¾\ 2. +â¾\ RSdWO^ ^SZS ]O\^ UKcK dOWSXVO\NO NO\SX `O ]\OUVS RKP\ScK^ SvSX .D\Dæ]LQFLULæRO\ ^\V dOWSX UYÀ_V_XNK NO\SX UKXKV RKP\ScK^¾ cKZWKU SvSX U_VVKX¾V¾\ >\OXvO\VO\NO PK\UV¾ ^SZ UKd¾M¾ OUSZWKX U_VVKX¾VWKU^KN¾\ ææ .D\DæWHVWHUHVL vYU ]O\^ dOWSX UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK XS]ZO^OX NK\ `O NO\SXVSâSX vYU PKdVK YVWKN¾â¾ Y\^KWVK\NK U_VVKX¾V¾\VK\ .HSoH ]O\^ ² Y\^K ]O\^ dOWSX UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK NO\SXVSâSX PKdVK YVWKN¾â¾ Y\^KWVK\NK U_VVKX¾V¾\ .D\Dæ WDPEXUX vYU QOXSÀ KWK vYU NO\SX YVWKcKX UKXKV RKP\ScK^¾ ,_ UKd¾M¾ OUSZWKXVK\ QOXOVNO PK\UV¾ _cQ_VKWK KVKX¾XNK U_VVKX¾V¾\VK\ ,_XVK\% .DEORæG|ìHPHæPSLO\ YZ^SU UKLVY RK^VK\¾ `O Qv RK^VK\¾ SvSX U_VVKX¾VKX ^O]^O\O `O UKcK dSXMS\S ^\OXvO\VO\ %RUXæG|ìHPH ZO^\YV LY\_ RK^VK\¾ Qv RK^VK\¾ `O ]_ UKXKVSdK]cYX SXÀKK^VK\¾XNK U_VVKX¾VKX UKcK dSXMS\S `O UOZvO ^\OXvO\VO\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý §.D\Dæ7UHQoHUL¨æìOHæ§3DWODWma + Kazma/Yükleme” KarëçODëWçUPDVçæ .D\Dæ WUHQoHULæ ND]çVçæ ^OU QOvSÀ^O RO\RKXQS LS\ dOWSXNO UO]SX^S]Sd UKd¾ `O cO^O\S UKNK\ RKP\ScK^ SVO vYU NdQX UKXKV UKd¾]¾ cKZWKU SvSX WSXSW_W dKWKX U_VVKX¾\UOX KcXS dKWKXNK ^\OXvO\ RKP\ScK^¾ QO\S NYVN_\_W `O cK^KUVKWK WKVdOWO]S YV_\ 3DWODWPDææ.D]PDæ<NOHPHæND]çVçQGDæLVH; ZK^VK^WK ]YX_M_ UKd¾ cKZ¾VKMKU dOWSXNO `O O^\KP^KUS cKZ¾VK\NK vK^VKUVK\ YV_À_Z QOXOV cKZ¾cK dK\K\ `O\S\ .dOX]Sd UKXKV UKd¾]¾ cKZ¾V¾\ NYVKc¾]¾cVK PKdVK RKP\ScK^ QO\OU^S\NSâS SvSX `O\SW]Sd cK`KÀ^¾\ 1O\S NYVN_\_W `O cK^KUVKWK SvSX Kc\¾MK N¾À WKVdOWO QO\OU^S\NSâS SvSX ZKRKV¾ LS\ _cQ_VKWKN¾\ 5KXKV¾X vUWO \S]US vYU PKdVKN¾\ +DIUL\DW QOXSÀ UKXKV UKcK UKd¾]¾ ^KÀ YMKâ¾ RKP\ScK^¾ ^K\¾W]KV UKd¾VK\ `O K]UO\S _cQ_VKWKVK\NK U_VVKX¾VKX UKcK ^KWL_\_ ^\OXvO\VO\NS\ >\OXvO\VO\ vO`\O]OV PKU^\VO\O LKâV¾ YVK\KU QO\vOU^OX ]¾\K N¾À¾ dY\ _cQ_VKWKVK\ SvSX \O^SVWSÀ Kâ¾\ RSdWO^ ^SZS WKUSXKVK\N¾\ 2O\ ^\V OâSWNO K\KdSNO `O RO\ ^\ UKcKNK vKV¾ÀKMKU ÀOUSVNO NSdKcX ONSVWSÀVO\NS\ >W RSN\YVSU cKU¾^ cKâVKWK ]Yâ_^WK ]S]^OWVO\S L_ QO\OUVSVSUVO\ QdXXNO L_V_XN_\_VK\KU \O^SVWSÀ^S\ .D\Dæ WUHQoHULæ LOHæ (NVNDYDW|Uæ æ NçUçFç ]S]^OWSXS UK\À¾VKÀ^¾\N¾â¾W¾dNK KNO^ ^\OXvO\ Y\^K]O\^ UKcK dOWSXNO /U]UK`K^\ U¾\¾M¾·cK ]O\^ UKcK dOWSXNO ! /U]UK`K^\ U¾\¾M¾·cK `O vYU ]O\^ UKcK dOWSXNO dO\SXNO /U]UK`K^\ U¾\¾M¾·cK NOXU RKP\ScK^ cKZKLSVWOU^ONS\ 6SXOO\ >\OXvO\ UKd¾VK\NK ]KNOMO UKXKV LYc_^_ UKNK\ UKd¾ `O RKP\ScK^ cKZ¾V¾\UOX OU]UK`K^\V UKd¾VK\NK QO\OU- ]Sd cO\O NKRK PKdVK UKd¾ `O RKP\ScK^ cKZWKU QO\OUS\ >\OXvO\ ^K\KP¾XNKX v¾UK\¾VKX RKP\ScK^ QO\S NYVQ_ WKVdOWO]S YVK\KU ]O\SVOLSVS\ `OcK U_W cK^KUVK\¾ `O LY\_VK\¾X RK^VK\¾X `O UKLVYVK\¾X \^VWO]SXNO U_VVKX¾V¾\UOX OU]UK`K^\ UKd¾VK\¾XNK L_ WKVdOWOVO\SX N¾ÀK\¾NKX ]KâVKXWK]¾ QO\OUWOU^O^S\ ,S\ LKÀUK ]^X dOVVSU YVK\KU ^\OXvO\ ]KNOMO LS\ ÀO\S^^O vKV¾ÀK\KU ^\KPSâS OXQOVVOWOdUOX U¾\¾M¾ ^KÀ¾cKX UvU LS\ OU]UK`K^\ LSVO ^\KPSâS OXQOVVO\ 5K\KcYV_ ]^ vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾XNK UKXKV KvWK SÀVOWSXNO >\OXvO\ 5KXKV +v¾M¾ K]PKV^¾X UO]SVWO]S SÀSXS NO cKZK\ `O WWUX YVKLSVOMOU OX NK\ `O Nd K]PKV^ UO]SWSXS QO\vOUVOÀ^S\S\ >\OXvO\VO\ 5KXKV +v¾M¾ NSUOc cXNO UKXKV Kv^¾UVK\¾ SvSX ´@µ ^SZSXNOUS OU]UK`K^\ UKXKV UKd¾]¾XK Q\O NKRK Kd QO\S NYVQ_ WKVdOWO]S QO\OU^S\S\ .YVKc¾]¾cVK ROXNOU \O]^O\K]cYX_ vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾ OU]UK`K^\O Q\O NKRK UYVKc `O NKRK RO]KZV¾N¾\ +c\¾MK QO\S NYVQ_ WKVdOWO]SXSX NKRK ]¾U¾ NYVN_\_VKLSVWO]S WWUX YV_\ LcVOMO O\YdcYX `O vUWO \S]US KdKV^¾V¾\ ,S\ >\OXvO\SX SÀVO^WO QSNO\VO\S Y\^K ]O\^ ]O\^ `O MYU ]O\^ UKcK UYÀ_VVK\¾XK Q\O LOVS\VOXS\ >\OXvO\ UYX`OcY\ LKX^ K^KvWKX¾ SVO v¾UK\^^¾â¾ RKP\ScK^¾ UKWcYXK NS\OU^ YVK\KU cUVO\UOX UYX`OcY\ LKX^¾X _dO\SXO ^KU¾VKX dOV OVOU ]S]^OWS SVO kO`\OMS `O ^OWSd UKd¾ cKZWKU WO^\O cU]OUVSU^O Y-·NO `OcK Y-·NO vKV¾ÀWKU ! WO^\O NO\SXVSU^O ]O\^ WK]SP UKcKNK UKXKV KvWKU ^\OXvO\VO\ SvSX vYU XY\WKV _cQ_VKWKVK\N¾\ kYU cU]OU ZO\PY\WKX]^K cU]OU RKP\ScK^ \O^SWSXS Kd ]Kc¾NK ^\OXvO\ SVO ]KâVKWKVK\¾ XONOXScVO +d LKU¾W QSNO\S .ÀU WYLSVSdK]cYX QSNO\S +d OVOWKX WK]\KP¾ SVO vYU MSNNS K`KX^KT ]KâVK\VKr 7 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý v¾UKX RKP\ScK^ S]^OXOX SXMOVSU^O Kc\¾À^¾\¾VK\KU UKV¾X `O SXMO YVK\KU UKXKV LYc_XMK cO\VOÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ +DIUL\DWWDæ oçNDQæ NDOçQæ PDO]HPHæ GROJXæ PDO]HPHVLæ RODUDNæ NXOODQçOçUæLQFHæPDO]HPHæGHæ|UWæPDO]HPHVLæRODUDNæNXOODQçOçUæ75(1d(5æ'2/*8æ 0$/=(0(6ê1êæ 9(æ g57hæ 0$/=(0(6ê1êæ.(1'ê6êæh5(7ê5 Kaya Trençerindeki (QægQHPOLæ.RPSRQHQWOHU 7DKULNæ VLVWHPL 1OVOXOU]OV ^KR\SU ]S]^OWSXO ]KRSZ LS\ ^\OXvO\NO WY^Y\ NO`\SXO N_cK\V¾ LS\ U_WKXNK ]S]^OWSXO ]KRSZ RSN\Y]^K^SU NO`\O L_V_X_\UOX LS\ UKcK ^\OXvO\SXNO KU¾VV¾ ^KR\SU NOXOX M\OOZ MYX^\YV ]S]^OWS L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ ,_ ]S]^OWNO WY^Y\ ]KLS^ NO`S\NO ^_^_V_\UOX UKd¾ dSXMS\SXSX NXÀ R¾d¾X¾ `O U_``O^SXS LOVS\VOcOX RSN\Y]^K^SU NO`\O ZKVO^VO- 8 \SX vOUSW QMcVO NYâ\_ Y\KX^¾V¾N¾\ CKXS UKd¾ cKZKX dSXMS\ RSN\YVSU ]S]^OWNOX RO\ dKWKX WKU]SW_W QM KV¾\ +c\¾MK L_ ]S]^OWO LKâV¾ YVK\KU WOUKXSU LS\ \ONU^\ NSÀVS U_^_]_ SVO KXS dY\VKXWKVK\ SvSX KXV¾U OU]^\K UYZK\^WK QM OVNO ONSVS\ <ONU^\ `S^O] U_^_]_ R¾d¾ NÀ\Z ^Y\U_ WKU]SW_WK v¾UK\^K\KU UKd¾M¾ WSVSXNO YV_ÀKX KXV¾U ^Y\U dS\`OVO\SXS ]O\LO]^ L¾\KU¾\ ,cVOMO KXV¾U OU]^\K UO]WO `O UYZK\WK QM OVNO ONSVS\ 1vV WY^Y\ 6WDELOL]DW|UOHU 9^YWK^SU `SL\K]cYX OWSMS ]^KLSVSdK^\VO\ UKd¾M¾ K^KÀWKXVK\¾X dO\SXNO YVKX ^S^\OÀSWVO\S `O ÀYUVK\¾ KVK\KU WKUSXKX¾X ]\OUVS SVO\VOWO]SXS ]KâVK\ 5YX`Oc\ LKXN ]S]^OWS .D]çæ GLìOHUL 5Kd¾ cdOcSXS UKZ]KcKX NSÀ ]S]^OWSXNO OX cU]OU UKd¾ `O\SWVSVSâS SvSX XOWVS YVKX ^OU\K\ O^WOcOX Kv¾VK\ WSXSW_W NSÀ UKcL¾ `O ]O\^ UKcKNK cU]OU UYZK\WK QMN\ 5Kd¾ NSÀVO\SXSX UYX_W `O Kv¾VK\¾ UKd¾ cdOcSXSX X UKZ]KcKMKU ÀOUSVNO YVWKV¾N¾\ ¿OUVOX ´MRO`\YX ^SZµ O LOXdOcOX L_ cKZ¾NK RO\ NSÀ ]¾\K]¾ Kv¾]¾ UYX_W_ LS\LS\SXNOX PK\UV¾ YVWKUVK LS\VSU^O UKd¾ cdOcSXS UKZ]KWKU^KN¾\ ndO^VO LS\ UKcK ^\OXvO\SXNO YVWK]¾ QO\OUOX dOVVSUVO\ À_XVK\N¾\$ 7Y^Y\ NO`\SXO N_cK\V¾ RSN\Y]^K^SU ^KR\SU ]S]^OWS +â¾\ RSdWO^ UKd¾ SvSX _cQ_X UKd¾ ^KR\SU ]S]^OWS 5Kd¾ cdOcSXS WKU]SW_W UKZVKcKX UKcK UKd¾]¾XK _cQ_X NSÀ ]S]^OWS @SL\K]cYX OWSMS NOXQO ]^KLSVSdK^\VO\S +c\¾À^¾\¾M¾ OVOU ]S]^OWS 2UNXQæ$OWXéæg=781$ Jeoloji Yüksek Müh. Karun Genel Müdürü ZZZNDUXQFRPWU ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ½À `O SXÀKK^ WKUSXKVK\¾XNK LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KX¾X U_VVKX¾W¾ QOvWSÀ^O cKcQ¾XV¾U UKdKXW¾À^¾ 2SN\YVSU _cQ_VKWKVK\¾X¾X K\^¾À¾ O]US]S UKNK\ YVWK]K NK LKd¾ _cQ_VKWKVK\NK `KdQOvSVWOdVSâS NO`KW O^WOU^ONS\ ,K]¾XvV¾ RK`K \O^SWSXNO XMOVO\S ZS]^YXV_ UYWZ\O]\VO\SX U_VVKX¾W¾ ^O\MSR ONSV]O NO NOLS `O LK]¾Xv NOâO\VO\SXSX K\^¾À¾XNKX NYVKc¾ `SNKV¾ `O ZKVO^VS UYWZ\O]\VO\SX U_VVKX¾W¾XK cXOVSXWSÀ^S\ ndOVVSUVO `SNKV¾ UYWZ\O]\VO\ QO^S\NSâS U_VVKX¾W UYVKcV¾â¾XNKX NYVKc¾ WKNOXMSVSU `O ^XOV _cQ_VKWKVK\¾XNK ^O\MSR ONSVS\ RKVO QOVWSÀ^S\ HK`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\SX NO^Kc¾XK QS\WONOX XMO LS\ `SNKV¾ RK`K UYWZ\O]\XX vKV¾ÀWK]¾X¾ SXMOVOWOU^O PKcNK `K\N¾\ .¾ÀK\¾NKX OWSVOX RK`K PSV^\OVO\NOX QOv^SU^OX ]YX\K `SNK XS^O]SXO QOVS\ `O ]¾U¾À^¾\¾V¾\ @SNK OVOWKXVK\¾X¾X LS\LS\SXO ]\^XWO]S SVO YV_ÀKX `O NO ]¾U¾À^¾\¾VKX RK`KX¾X \O^^SâS ¾]¾X¾X KV¾XWK]¾XNK RSN\YVSU cKâ¾XNKX PKcNKVKX¾V¾\ 2SN\YVSU cKâ¾ WOUKXSU ]\^XWOXSX KdKV^¾VWK]¾X¾ `O NO U¾]WOX `SNK LYc_XMK RK`K RK\OUO^S O]XK]¾XNK `SNKVK\ SVO Q`NO K\K- ]¾XNK ]¾dN¾\WKdV¾U ^O]S\S NO ]KâVK\ =Yâ_^WK `O cKâVKWKc¾ ^OWSX ONOX RSN\YVSU cKâ `SNK RKdXO]SXSX UK\^O\ U¾]W¾XNK NOZYVKX¾\ 2SN\YVSU cKâ¾ RK`K UYWZ\O]\XX LOVS\VOXWSÀ LS\ ]¾MKUV¾U K\KV¾â¾XNK vKV¾ÀWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ @SNKNKX LK]¾VKX LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K `O cKâ UK\¾À¾W¾ RK`KcKâ Kc¾\WK PSV^\O]SXSX L_V_XN_â_ RKdXOcO QSNO\ ,_\KNK MOL\S cXVOXNS\WO `O PSV^\O dOVVSâSXNOX NYVKc¾ RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OXSX N¾À cdOcSXNO cKâ¾X LcU LS\ U¾]W¾ LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KNKX Kc\¾À¾\ `O RKdXOXSX NSLSXO vUO\ ,K]¾XvV¾ RK`K SVO ^KÀ¾XKX LS\ U¾]¾W cKâ S]O PSV^\OXSX SvO\S]SXNO ^KLKXK Kc\¾À¾\ `O ]S]^OW LK]¾XM¾XNKX NYVKc¾ SXMO LS\ RK^^KX `SNKcK Z]U\^WO cKâ¾ YVK\KU NXO\ CKâNKX K\¾XN¾\¾VW¾À LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K S]O U_VVKX¾W cO\SXO QSNO\ 2K`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ RKdXO]SXSX KV^¾XK vUOX cKâ L_\KNKX cKâ ]¾MKUV¾â¾XK LKâV¾ YVK\KU cK NYâ\_NKX `OcK cKâ ]Yâ_^_M_]_ dO\SXNOX RSN\YVSU PSV^\OcO Y\KNKX NK `SNK XS^O]SXO NXO\ kKV¾ÀWK LKÀVKXQ¾M¾XNK ]Yâ_U YVKX RSN\YVSU cKâ ]Yâ_^_M_]_XK QS\WONOX NYâ\_NKX `SNK UK\^O\SXO NXO\ RSN\YVSU cKâ ScSMO ¾]¾XN¾U^KX ]YX\K S]O RK^ ]^XNOUS ^O\WY]^K^ KX NYVKc¾ cKâ ]Yâ_^_M_]_XK cXVOXNS\SVS\ @SNKV¾ `OcK ZKVO^VS RK`K UYWZ\O]\VO\SX ]¾RRK^VS vKV¾ÀWK]¾ SvSX XOWVS R_]_]VK\NKX LS\SNO PSV^\O LKU¾WVK\¾X¾X NdOXVS `O _]_VXO _cQ_X cKZ¾VWK]¾N¾\ ,K]¾XvV¾ RK`K \O^OX L_ UYWZ\O]\VO\NO LKU¾W¾ SVQSVOXNS\OX v vOÀS^ PSV^\OVOWO `K\N¾\ 12 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý YV_Z PSV^\O WKVdOWO]SXNOUS LK]¾Xv UKcL¾ Δ: ! ² LK\ N¾\ 2K`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\SXSX vKV¾ÀWK W\ XY\WKV ÀK\^VK\NK SVK ]KK^ K\K]¾XNK NOâSÀS\ ,K]¾XvV¾ RK`K UYWZ\O]\VO\SXNO U_VVKX¾VKX RK`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\ S]O ^K]K\¾W O]K]VK\¾XK Q\O SUScO Kc\¾V¾\ /VOWKX ^SZS +^YW ^SZS ,_ PSV^\OVO\ 2K`K PSV^\O]S 2SN\YVSU cKâ PSV^\O]S 2K`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\SNS\ 2K`K PSV^\O]S ]¾U¾À^¾\¾VKMKU N¾À RK`KX¾X ^Yd `O US\VO\NOX K\¾XN¾\¾VWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ /XN]^\ScOV _cQ_VKWKVK\NK ZKXOV ^OU UKNOWOVS PSV^\OVOWO `O SÀ WKUSXKVK\¾XNK S]O SUS UKNOWOVS Kâ¾\ RSdWO^ ^SZS PSV^\OVO\ U_VVKX¾V¾\ 2SN\YVSU PSV^\O]S S]O UYWZ\O]\NO U_VVKX¾VKX RSN\YVSU cKâ¾XNKUS ZK\vKM¾UVK\¾X PSV^\OVOXWO]SXNO U_VVKX¾V¾\ `O RSN\YVSU cKâ¾X¾X `SNK OVKWKX¾XK NXN\V\UOX PSV^\ONOX QOvS\SVO\OU ^OWSdVOXWO]S ]KâVKX¾\ 2SN\YVSU cKâ¾X¾X US\VOXWO]SXO LKRS] UYX_]_ YVKMKU ZK\vKM¾UVK\ WOUKXSU ]\^XOX `SNK OVOWKXVK\¾ Q`NO \_VWKXVK\ `KVPVO\ `OcK ]Yâ_^_M_NKX UYZKX ZK\vKM¾UVK\ `OcK OWWO RK`K]¾ SVO QOVOMOU ^YdVK\N¾\ .SâO\ cKXNKX cKâ¾X ^O\WKV LYd_XWK]¾XNKX YV_ÀKX UK\LYX `]NS\ 2K`K ² CKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\ S]O LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KNKX RSN\YVSU cKâ¾X¾X Kc\¾À^¾\¾VWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ ,_ Kc\¾À^¾\¾VKX cKâ `SNK Q`NO]SXNOUS cKâ UK\^O\SXO NXN\V\ ,K]¾XvV¾ RK`K S]O U_VVKX¾WK ]O`U ONSVS\ =¾RRK^VS vKV¾ÀKX RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVOWO]SXNOX ]YX\K LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KNK UKVKX cKâ WSU^K\¾ ZZW·S QOvWOWOVSNS\ kKV¾ÀWK ]¾MKUV¾UVK\¾ " Y- K\K]¾XNK Eleman tipi: ,_ ^SZ PSV^\OVO\ LS\ LK]¾XvV¾ RKdXO SvSXO cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀVO\NS\ @SNK Q\_L_XNKX QOVOX LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K cKâ UK\¾À¾W¾ RKdXOcO QS\NSâSXNO RK`K ² cKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVOWO WKVdOWO]SXNOX XMO RSN\YVSU cKâ¾ LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KNKX ]K\WKV RK`K RK\OUO^S SVK Kc\¾À¾\ +c\¾ÀWK PSV^\O WKVdOWO]SXSX N¾À cdOcSXNO NO NO-Eleman tip -Atom tipi `KW ONO\ 2SN\YVSU cKâ¾X¾X Kc\¾ÀKWKcKX U¾]W¾ PSV^\O WKVdOWO]S LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K SVO QOvO\UOX PSV^\O WKVdOWO]SXSX MKW OVcKP ² WSM\YQVK]] dOVVSâSXNOX NYVKc¾ cKâ NKWVKM¾UVK\¾ RK`KNK Kc\¾VK\KU LS\LS\S SVO LS\VOÀO\OU NKRK S\S NKWVKVK\¾ YV_À^_\_\ `O L_XVK\NK RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O Sv U¾]W¾XNK RKdXOXSX KV^¾XK NYâ\_ SXO\ ,_ U¾]¾WNK LS\SUOX cKâ WO`M_^ LK]¾Xv ^O]S\S SVO `SNK cKâVKWK cKâ¾ YVK\KU Z]U\^WO RK^^¾XNKX `SNK Q\_L_XK QOVS\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\ NO\SXVSâSXO ]dWO Z\OX]SLSXO Q\O vKV¾À¾\VK\ /VOWKX ^SZS PSV^\OVO\ ]K\WK `OcK ZSVOVS ^SZ cKZ¾V¾\VK\ ,_ PSV^\OVO\SX WKVdOWO]SXSX Δ: ! ² LK\ NOâO\SXO ]KRSZ YVWKVK\¾ LOUVOXS\ 2K`K UKZK]S^OVO\S ]K\WK ^SZVO\SXNO W NKUSUK ZSVOVS ^SZVO\NO S]O W NKUSUK N¾\ 1OXOVNO cU]OU UKZK]S^OVS UYWZ\O]\VO\NO U_VVKX¾V¾\ 13 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ONSVWO]S QO\OUS\ 2K`K OWSÀ PSV^\O]SXNOUS US\VO^SMSVO\SX U¾]K NO`\O LcZK]] UKvKUVK\¾X QO^S\NSâS ^YdVK\ RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OcS ^¾UK\ =Y\_X_X UKcXKâ¾ ]_ S]O$ =S]^OWSX vYU ]Yâ_U vKV¾ÀWK]¾ `OcK UYWZ\O]\NOX v¾UKX LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K ^O]S]K^¾X¾X U^ NÀOXWO]SNS\ =_ US\VSVSâSXSX Q]^O\QO]S RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O dO\SXNO ZK] Q\VWO]SNS\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O ]YX\K]¾XNK cKâ PKdVKV¾â¾ Q\VcY\]K L_X_X W_R^OWOV XONOXVO\S YVK\KU KÀKâ¾NKUS R_]_]VK\ Q]^O\SVOLSVS\ Atom tipi: 5YVKc WYX^KT `O UYWZ\O]\ vKV¾À¾\UOX NOâSÀ^S\SVWO dOVVSUVO\SXNOX NYVKc¾ ]YX ]OXOVO\NO \KâLO^ Q\WOU^O `O XS]ZO^OX UvU UKZK]S^OVS UYWZ\O]\VO\NO U_VVKX¾VWKU^KN¾\ 7O^KV LS\ vKXKâ¾X SvSXO cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀ ZSVOVS OVKWKXNKX YV_À_\ +c\¾ LS\ PSV^\O RKdXO]SXO SR^ScKv cYU^_\ ,S\ LKâVKX^¾ ^KLVK]¾XK NSU cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀ PSV^\OcO QS\OX LK]¾XvV¾ RK`K ² cKâ UK\¾À¾W¾ NO\SXVOWO]SXO ]dWO cKZKX UK^WKXV¾ PSV^\ONOX QOvO\UOX cKâ OVOWKX PSV^\ONO KXVK^¾VKX Kc\¾ÀWK Z\OX]SLS SVO cKâNKX Kc\¾À^¾\¾V¾\ ! LK\ vKV¾ÀWK LK]¾XM¾XNK ² W NKUSUK RK`K UKZK]S^OVO\S Δ: ² LK\ N¾\ 2K`K SVO LS\VSU^O ]\UVOXOX cKâ S]O WQ W ZZW WO\^OLO]SXNONS\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\ONOX XMO LK]¾XvV¾ RK`KNKX Kc\¾À^¾\¾VKX cKâ WSU^K\¾ 5YWZ\O]\ OWSÀ RK`K PSV^\O]SXMO ^_^_VKWKcKX US\ WSU^K\¾ kO`\O ÀK\^VK\¾ 5_VVKX¾VKX RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O ^SZS 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\ONO LK]¾Xv NÀWO]S `OcK Δ: NOâO\S cU]OVScY\]K L_X_X ]OLOLS RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O US\VO\NOX `OcK ]_NKX NYVKc¾ ^¾UKV¾N¾\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O US\NOX ^¾UKXW¾À S]O RK`K UYWZ\O]\XX OWSÀ RK`K PSV^\O]SXSX UYX^\YV 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\ONOX `SNK Q_\_L_XK QOVOX PSV^\O ]YX\K]¾ LK]¾XvV¾ cKâVKWK Z]U\^WO cKâ¾ NXÀ RK^^¾ ^¾UKV¾ 0SV^\O ]YX\K]¾ LK]¾XvV¾ cKâVKWK Z]U\^WO cKâ¾ NXÀ RK^^¾ _cQ_X NOâSVNS\ ,Y\_X_X _M_ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O ^KLKX¾XK _VKÀWKWKU^K `OcK VSU LS\ Kv¾ SVO UO]SVWOWSÀ^S\ @SNK Q_\_L_ cKâ RKdXO]SXNO cKâ PKdVKV¾V¾â¾ `K\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O SVO UYWZ\O]\ ]Yâ_^WK cKâ¾ LS\LS\S SVO _c_W]_dN_\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O cKZ¾À^¾\WK WKVdOWO]SXNO Kc\¾VWK 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾]¾XNK RK]K\¾X ]OLOLS _cQ_X ^YZ\KUVKWK cKZ¾VWKWK]¾ `OcK U_VVKX¾W¾XNK KÀ¾\¾ LK]¾Xv NKVQKVKXWK]¾ .D\QDNoD +DYDææ<Déæ$\çUçFçææ )LOWUHOHUGHæ$Uç]DFçOçN 7SU\YZY\ RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O L\YÀ\ 2K`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\OVO\NO ]O\`S] W\ ² ]KK^ YVWK]¾XK UK\À¾V¾U Z\K^SU^O LKdOX L_ ]KK^VO\O _VKÀ¾VKWKNKX PSV^\OVO\ U_VVKX¾W W\VO\SXS NYVN_\_\ ,_XK XONOX YVKX vOÀS^VS _X]_\VK\ `K\N¾\ 7KXX2_WWOV RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O @SNK Q_\_L_ ^KXdSWS 5YWZ\O]\NO U_VVKX¾VKX cKâVKc¾M¾ ]Yâ_^_M_ KU¾ÀUKX 14 6OaS] 0Yb RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O WKUKVO]S +^VK] -YZMY RK`KcKâ Kc¾\¾M¾ PSV^\O -YWZKS\ \QX Kâ¾ 0XVWDIDæ6ì/3$è$5 0DNLQDæ<Næ0K ì00%æ<|Qæ.UOæ%ëNæ9HN ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý %$ê/,.æ%DëOçN 'L]HOæ2WRPRELOOHUGHæ<DNçWæ6LVWHPL æ<DNçWæ6LVWHPL CKU¾^ ]S]^OWSXSX Q\O`S cO^O\VS LS\ RK`K `O cKU¾^ UK\¾À¾W¾X¾ WY^Y\K ]KâVKWKU^¾\ 2K`KcKU¾^ UK\¾À¾W¾ WY^Y\_X dO\SXNOUS cU UK\À¾VKWKU SvSX LOVVS LS\ Y\KXNK YVWKV¾N¾\ .SdOV WY^Y\_X cKU¾^ ]S]^OWSXNO LO]VOWO ZYWZK]¾ cKU¾^¾ cKU¾^ NOZY]_XNKX OWO\ CKU¾^ XMO PSV^\ONOXNKRK ]YX\K cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾XK QXNO\SVWONOX XMO ]_ Kc\¾M¾]¾XNKX QOvO\ CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ Q\_L_ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ \OQVK^\ dKWKXVKc¾M¾ `O LO]VOWO ZYWZK]¾XNKX YV_À_\ ½US vOÀS^ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ `K\N¾\$ NS]^\SL^\ ^SZ `O ]¾\K ^SZ 7Y^Y\ vKV¾À¾\UOX cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ NSdOV cKU¾^¾X¾ ]¾U¾À^¾\K\KU LO]VOWO RK^^¾ dO\SXNOX K^OÀVOWO ]¾\K]¾XK _cQ_X YVK\KU ]SVSXNS\VO\O cKU¾^¾ Z]U\^OX OXTOU^\ WOWOVO\SXO QXNO\SVS\ 20 6çUDæWLSLæ\DNçWæSRPSDVç æ0RWRUæ<DNçWç 7Y^Y\ cKU¾^¾ RcN\YTOX `O UK\LYXNKX YV_À_\ 5K\¾À¾W WO`M_^ YU]STOXVO cKX¾Z SvSXNOUS ¾]¾ OXO\TS]SXS WOUKXSU OXO\TScO vO`S\WOU^ONS\ =¾`¾ cKU¾^VK\ Sv^OX cKXWK- V¾ WY^Y\VK\ SvSX SNOKVNS\ vXU OUYXYWSU YVK\KU \O^SVNSUVO\S QSLS cU]OU ¾]¾ NOâO\VO\SXO ]KRSZ^S\VO\ UYVKcMK XKUVONSVSZ ]KUVKXKLSVS\VO\ /X cKcQ¾X \XOUVO\S LOXdSX QKdcKâ¾`O NSdOV cKU¾^¾N¾\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý dSX S]^K]cYX_ ^KXUVK\¾XNK YV_ÀKX ZK]^KX UKcXKUVKX¾\ =_ S]O cKU¾^ ^KXUVK\¾XNK cYâ_XVKÀKX L_RK\NKX YV_À_\ 'LVWULEW|UæWLSæ\DNçWæSRPSDVç æ<DNçWæ)LOWUHVLæYHæææææææææææææææææææææææææææææ 6Xæ$\UçFçVç CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ `O OXTOU^\ WOWOVO\S WW vKV¾ÀWK RK]]K]ScO^SXNO SWKV ONSVWSÀVO\ /XTOU]ScYX ]S]^OWVO\SXNO LS\vYU TO^VO\ `O UvU UKXKVVK\ L_- V_XN_â_ SvSX ^OWSd cKU¾^ K\KM¾X¾d SvSX vYU XOWVSNS\ >OWSdVSâSX QK\KX^SVOXWO]S SvSX cKU¾^ RK^^¾ dO\SXO cKU¾^ PSV^\O]S UYX_VW_À^_\ CKU¾^ PSV^\O]S LOXdSX NOZY]_ SVO UK\L\K^\ K\K]¾XNK L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ 5S\VS ZK\vKVK\ KUK\cKU¾^ ^KXUO\VO\SXNO LOX- =_ Kc¾\¾M¾]¾ ]_ SVO NSdOV cKU¾^¾X¾X PK\UV¾ cYâ_XV_UVK\K ]KRSZ YVWK]¾XNKX PKcNKVKXK\KU SUS]SXS LS\LS\SXNOX Kc\¾À^¾\¾\ =_ Kc¾\¾M¾]¾ SvSXNOUS ]_ ]O`ScO]S `O ÀKWKXN¾\K SvSXNOUS W¾UXK^¾] v_L_U KXKR^K\¾ UKZK^¾\ +cX¾ KXNK ]\M ZKXOVSXNO NO LS\ SUKd VKWLK]¾ cKXK\ PSV^\OXSX KV^¾XNK L_V_XKX ^KRVScO W_]V_â_ Kv¾VK\KU OV ZYWZK]¾X¾X NK vKV¾À^¾\¾VWK]¾ SVO ]_ ]S]^OWNOX N¾ÀK\¾ K^¾V¾\ ,Y]MR PS\WK]¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX c¾VN¾d ZYWZKVK\ SvSX \O^SVOX dOV K\K PSV^\OVO\ WO`M_^^_\ 5_^_^SZS PSV^\OVO\ ]¾\K ^SZS ZYWZK `O ^OU OVOWKXV¾ Z]U\^WO ZYWZK ]S]^OWVO\S SvSX U_VVKX¾V¾\VK\ 1O\OU]SXSWVO\SXO LKâV¾ YVK\KU vYU QOXSÀ PSV^\O UKâ¾N¾ cdOc KVKX LVQOVS ]ZS\KV PSV^\OVO\ `OcK vYU WSU^K\NKUS US\VOXWOXSX UKVN¾\¾VWK]¾ QO\OU^SâS cO\VO\NO cU]OU PSV^\OVOWO Y\KX¾XK ]KRSZ \KNcKV PSV^\O OVKWKX¾ U_VVKX¾VKLSVS\ /VOU^\SUVS OX^OQ\O PSV^\OVO\ U¾À¾X ZK\KPSX K\^¾UVK\¾XNKX NYVKc¾ WOcNKXK QOVOX ^¾UKXWKcK OXQOV YV_\VK\ ææ6Xæ$\UçFçVçæYHæêDPDQGçUD =_c_X cYâ_XV_â_ NSdOV cKU¾^¾X¾X cYâ_XV_â_XNKX PKdVK YVN_â_ SvSX NSLO vUO\ ¿KWKXN¾\KX¾X cYâ_XV_â_ S]O ]_NKX Kd KXMKU NSdOV cKU¾^¾XNKX NKRK PKdVKN¾\ ,_ cdNOXÀKWKXN¾\K NSdOV cKU¾^¾X¾X KV^¾XNKUS ]_c_X ]O`ScO]SXS ^O]ZS^ ONOX KXKR^K\K _VKÀ^¾â¾ dKWKX ÀKWKXN¾\K SvSXNOUS W¾UXK^¾] KXKR^K\¾X NO`\OcS ^KWKWVKWK]¾XK XONOX YVK\KU LS\ SUKd `O\SVWO]SXS ]KâVK\ =_c_X KdKWS ]O`ScOcO _VKÀ^¾â¾XNK LS\ _cK\¾ VKWLK]¾X¾ cKUKX LS\ OVOU^\SU ]OX]\ QOVSÀ^S\SVWSÀ^S\ 21 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ædDOçëPDVç .ÀU ¾]¾VK\NK NSdOV cKU¾^¾ SvSXNO L_V_XKX ZK\KPSX UK^¾VKÀK\KU PSV^\OcS ^¾UK\ ,_ YVKc QS\SÀ v¾U¾À XYU^KVK\¾ K\K]¾XNK LS\ LK]¾Xv PK\U¾XK XONOX YV_\ ,_ PK\U WW 2Qc¾ U:KKÀK\]K `KU_W KXKR^K\¾ UKZKXKMKU `O ¾]¾^¾M¾ OVOWKXK OVOU^\SU KU¾W¾ QSNOMOU^S\ :K\KPSX O\ScOMOU `O PSV^\O ^¾UKXWKcKMKU^¾\ ,K]¾Xv PK\U¾ WW2QX¾X U:K KV^¾XK NÀO\]O `KU_W KXKR^K\¾ Kv¾VKMKU `O ¾]¾^¾M¾ NO`\ONOX v¾UKMKU^¾\ æ%HVOHPHæ3RPSDVç CKU¾^ LO]VOWO ZYWZK]¾X¾X KWKM¾ NSdOV cKU¾^¾X¾X cKU¾^ NOZY]_XNKX vOUSVO\OU PSV^\ONOX QOvSZ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾XK LK]¾VWK]¾N¾\ CKU¾^ LO]VOWO ZYWZK]¾ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾X¾X cKX¾XK cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀ ^OU cXV LS\ ZYWZKN¾\ `O QO\OUVS ^KR\SâS cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾X¾X OU]KX^\SâSXNOX KV¾\ 7Y^Y\_ vKV¾À^¾\WKNKX XMO cKU¾^ RK^^¾X¾X RK`K]¾ KV¾XWK]¾ QO\OUScY\]K LS\ OV ZYWZK]¾ NK ]S]^OWO SVK`O ONSVWSÀ^S\ æ<DNçWæ,VçWçFçVç .SdOV cKU¾^¾ SvSXNO vdVWÀ N_\_WNK L_V_XKX `KU] ]¾P¾\¾X KV^¾XNKUS vO`\O ]¾MKUV¾UVK\¾XNK U¾]WOX UK^¾VKÀK\KU cKU¾^ PSV^\O]SXS ^¾UKcKLSVS\ ,_XNKX UY\_XWKU SvSX cKU¾^ ]S]^OWSXO LS\ cKU¾^ ¾]¾^¾M¾]¾ SVK`O ONSVWSÀ^S\ CKU¾^ ¾]¾^¾M¾]¾ LS\ ¾]¾^WK OVOWKX¾ SVO LS\ `KU_W KXKR^K\¾XNKX WOcNKXK QOVWSÀ^S\ æ9DNXPæ$QDKWDUç CKU¾^ PSV^\O]SXSX ]^XNO L_V_XKX `KU_W KXKR^K\¾ cKU¾^ PSV^\O]SXSX QS\SÀv¾U¾À LK]¾Xv PK\UVK\¾X¾ RS]]ONO\ /âO\ LOVS\^SVOXNOX NKRK PKdVK LS\ LK]¾Xv NOâSÀSWS ]d UYX_]_ YV_\]K W¾UXK^¾] v¾U¾À U¾]W¾XK NYâ\_ SVO\VOcO\OU v_L_U KXKR^K\¾ UKZK^¾\ ,_ N_\_WNK cKU¾^ ¾]¾^¾M¾ OVKWKXK OVOU^\SU KU¾W QXNO\SVS\ `O ¾]¾^¾M¾ NO`\OcO QS\O\ 22 æ<DNçWæ,VçWçFçæ(OHPDQ CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ RO\ dKWKX cO^O\VS WSU^K\NK NSdOV cKU¾^¾ SVO NYV_ YVWK]¾ QO\OUS\ KXMKU ^OU LKÀ¾XK cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ cU]OU WY^Y\ NO`S\VO\S SvSX cO^O\VS cKU¾^¾ ]KâVKcKWKd .SdOV cKU¾^¾ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾XK LOVS\VS LS\ LK]¾Xv^K QXNO\SVWOVSNS\ 1XNO\SVWO LK]¾XM¾ " SVO UQMW K\K]¾XNK YVWKV¾N¾\ YKU¾^ PSV^\O W_RKPKdK]¾ SvO\S]SXO cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀ YVKX ¾]¾^¾M¾ OVKWKX W_RKPKdKX¾X ¾]¾]¾X¾ K\^^¾\WKU ]_\O^ScVO cKU¾^¾X SvSXNOX KUWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ 3]¾^¾M¾ OVKWKX ¾]¾ NOâSÀSWVO\SXO N_cK\V¾ YVKX ]O\KWSU LS\ WKVdOWONOX cKZ¾VW¾À^¾\ ,_ ]OLOZ^OX NYVKc¾ L_ OVKWKX¾ UOXNS]S ¾]¾ K\^¾À¾ LOVS\VS LS\ ]O`ScOcO _VKÀ^¾â¾XNK OVOU^\SU NO`\O]SXS KvK\ ,_UVK]SU ^SZ ¾]¾^¾M¾ OVKWKXVK\K XKdK\KX NKRK Q`OXVS vKV¾ÀWKc¾ WWUX U¾VK\ %HVOHPHæSRPSDVçQçQæoDOçëPDVç ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý \_VK\¾ `K\N¾\ k¾U¾À LY\_]_ QOXOVNO NOZYX_X dO\SXNO `OcK cKX ^K\KP¾XNK L_V_X_\ ,Y\_X_X _M_ NOZYX_X KV^ cdOcSXNOX MW UKNK\ c_UK\¾NK ^K]K\VKXW¾À^¾\ LcVOMO NOZYNK YV_ÀKLSVOMOU `OcK ]K^¾X KV¾XKX cKU¾^VK\¾X ^Y\^_VK\ NS\OU ]S]^OWO QXNO\SVWOWSÀ YV_\ æ$YDQVæ0HNDQL]PDVç 7Y^Y\ NO`\S `O cUXO Q\O OXTOU]ScYX dKWKXVKWK]¾X¾ UYX^\YV ONO\ +`KX] WOUKXSdWKVK\¾X¾X LKd¾VK\¾ ]KX^\SP_T WO\UOdUKvU_``O^SXNOX PKcNKVKX¾\UOX NSâO\VO\S LK]¾XM¾X WY^Y\ NO`\ScVO K\^^¾â¾ LO]VOWO ZYWZK]¾ LK]WK LK]¾XM¾X¾ U_VVKX¾\ æ(QMHNW|U ææ<DNçWæ3RPSDVç CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX QXNO\SVOX cKU¾^¾ LK]¾XvVKXN¾\K\KU K^OÀVOWO ]¾\K]¾XK Q\O OXTOU^\ WOWOVO\SXO QXNO\S\ CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾XNKUS OVKWKX QS^QOV RK\OUO^S cKZK\KU cKU¾^¾X LK]¾Xv YNK]¾XK KV¾XWK]¾X¾ `O L_\KNK cU]OU LK]¾XMK v¾UK\¾VWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ CKU¾^ NKRK ]YX\K WOWO KvWK LK]¾XM¾XK _VKÀ^¾â¾ dKWKX OXTOU^\ WOWO]SXNOX Z]U\\ CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ QOXOVVSUVO cKX¾XNK L_V_X_\ DKWKXVKWK NSÀVSVO\S `OcK ^\SQO\ UKc¾À `K]¾^K]¾cVK U\KXU WSVSXNOX ^KR\SU KV¾\ ½US vOÀS^ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ `K\N¾\$ NS]^\SL^\ ^SZ `O ]¾\K ^SZ Dæ'LVWULEW|Uæ7LSæ<DNçWæ3RPSDVç ,_ ^SZ cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ LK]¾XvVKXN¾\¾VW¾À cKU¾^¾ ^W ]SVSXNS\VO\O QXNO\WOU SvSX ^OU LS\ ZYWZK OVKWKX¾ U_VVKX¾\ .S]^\SL^\ ^SZUvU LK]S^ `O RKPSP YV_Z NKRK Kd ]Kc¾NK ZK\vKcK ]KRSZ^S\ :YWZKX¾X Sv OVOWKXVK\¾ cKU¾^¾X UOXNS]ScVO cKâVKX¾\ Eæ6çUDæ7LSæ<DNçWæ3RPSDVç ,_ ^SZ ZYWZKX¾X RO\ LS\ ]SVSXNS\ SvSX LS\O\ KNO^ ZYWZK OVKWKX¾ L_V_X_\ .S]^\SL^\ ^SZ^OX NKRK UK\¾À¾U LS\ cKZ¾]¾ YVWK]¾X¾ cKX¾ ]¾\K KcX¾ dKWKXNK KcK\¾ NK dY\N_\ :YWZKX¾X OVKWKX U¾]W¾ S]O WY^Y\ cKâ¾cVK cKâVKX¾\ 24 ææ<DNçWæ%RUXODUçæ CKU¾^ LY\_VK\¾ L^X cKU¾^ ]S]^OWSXSX ZK\vKVK\¾X¾ LS\VOÀ^S\OX vOVSUNOX SWKV ONSVWSÀ^S\ CKU¾^ LY\_VK\¾ OQdYd LY\_VK\¾ ]_]^_\_M_VK\ `O WKXSPYVNNKX _dKU YVWKV¾N¾\ L_ ÀOUSVNO KÀ¾\¾ ]¾MKU^KX NYVKc¾ LYâ_VWKX¾X XXO QOvSVWSÀ YV_\ 7Y^Y\K Q`NOcO ^S^\OÀSWSX Kd YVN_â_ LKÀUK U¾]¾WVK\K SVSÀ^S\SVOLSVS\VO\ LcVOMO UO]USX UOXK\VK\¾X ]OLOZ YVKMKâ¾ KÀ¾XWKX¾X XXO QOvSVWSÀ YV_\ æ<DNçWæ'HSRVXæ ,^X WYNO\X cKU¾^ ]S]^OWVO\S cKU¾^¾ LS\ ZYWZK SVO LO]VO\VO\ ,cVOMO cKU¾^ NOZY]_ QOXOVNO K\KM¾X K\UK]¾XNK L_V_XWKU^KN¾\ .OZYX_X QS\SÀ `O v¾U¾À LY- /XTOU^\ WOWO]S LS\ WOWO Q`NO]S `O LS\ WOWO SâXO]SXS SvO\S\ /XTOU^\ WOWO]S cKU¾^¾X NdQX ^KXOMSUVO\O Kc\¾VWK]¾ SvSX QO\OUOX LK]¾Xv^K cKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾XNKX KVN¾â¾ cKU¾^¾ ]SVSXNS\VO\ SvSXO cU]OU LK]¾Xv^K Z]U\^\ /XTOU^\ WOWO]S LS\ ^\ `KVP ^S\ `O WW RK]]K]ScO^SXNO vKV¾À¾\ ,_ cdNOX WOWOXSX NOâSÀ^S\SVWO]S QO\OUOX dKWKXVK\NK ROW WOWO Q`NO]SXSX ROW NO SâXOXSX LO\KLO\MO NOâSÀ^S\SVWO]S QO\OUS\ /XTOU^\ WOWO]S NSdOV cKU¾^¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX cKâVKX¾\ 7OWO ^_^_M_]_ LKâVKWK ]YW_X_ SVO K\K ZK\vKc¾ `O WOWOcS LS\ K\KNK ^_^K\ +c\¾MK WOWO ^_^_M_]_ LK]¾Xv cKc¾X¾ KcK\VKcKX KcK\ ÀSWSXS NO SR^S`K ONO\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ædDOçëPDVç Dæ3VNUWPHægQFHVL CU]OU LK]¾XvV¾ cKU¾^ WOWOXSX KV^ ^K\KP¾XNK L_V_XKX cKU¾^ RK`_d_XK cKU¾^ UKXKV¾XNKX QOvO\OU _VKÀ¾\ Eæ<DNçWæ(QMHNVL\RQX CKU¾^ RK`_d_XNKUS cKU¾^¾X LK]¾XM¾X¾X K\^WK]¾ SVO LS\VSU^O K\^KX U_``O^ WOWO SâXO]SXSX _v cdOcSXO LK]¾Xv cKZK\KU SâXOcS S^O\ ,_ U_``O^ cKc¾X NS\OXMSXS cOXNSâS dKWKX WOWO SâXO]S c_UK\¾ UKVUK\ `O WOWO Q`NO]SXNOX U_\^_V_\ ,_cKU¾^¾X cKXWK YNK]¾XK Z]U\^VWO]SXO SdSX `O\S\ Fæ3VNUWPHæ6RQX CKU¾^ ZYWZK]¾ cKU¾^ `O\WOcS N_\N_\N_â_ dKWKX cKU¾^ LK]¾XM¾ NÀO\ `O LK]¾Xv cKc¾ WOWO SâXO]SXS LKÀVKXQ¾v UYX_W_XK QO^S\S\ ½âXO À_ KXNK WOWO Q`NO]SXNOUS cO\SXO ScSMO Y^_\W_À `O cKU¾^ UKXKV¾X¾ ^¾UKW¾À^¾\NYVKc¾]¾cVK Z]U\^WO SÀVOWS ]YXK O\WSÀ^S\ ½âXO SVO WOWO Q`NO]S K\K]¾XNK `OcK LK]¾Xv ZSWS SVO WOWO ^_^_M_]_ K\K]¾XNK LS\ WSU^K\ cKU¾^ UKVW¾À^¾\ 3VNUWPHæ|QFHVL ,_ cKU¾^ ^W ZK\vKVK\¾X cKâVKXWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ `O XSRKcO^ QO\S NXÀ LY\_]_XNKX QO\S NXO\ ½âXO `O WOWO Q`NO]S cKU¾^ LK]¾XM¾XK Q\O Z]U\^WOXSX LKÀVKXQ¾v `O ]YX_X_ UYX^\YV ONOX LS\ vOÀS^ `KVP QSLS vKV¾ÀWKU^KN¾\ æìNLæ.DGHPHOLææææææææææææææææææææææææ (QMHNW|Uæ0HPHVL =YX dKWKXVK\NK NSdOV WY^Y\VK\NK SUS UKNOWOVS OXTOU^\ WOWOVO\S U_VVKX¾VWKcK LKÀVKXW¾À^¾\ ,_ ^SZ WOWOVO\NO Z]U\^VWOU dO\O LK]¾VKX WKdY^ WOWO SvO\S]SXNOUS LK]¾Xv SUS UKNOWONO UKdKXN¾\¾V¾\ (QMHNVL\RQ ½US UKNOWOVS OXTOU^\ WOWO]SXSX U_VVKX¾VWK]¾ SVO NKRK NÀU Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ ]OvWOU WWUXN\ ,_ LSdO NÀU cUVO\NO Z]U\^WOXSX NdQXVâX ]KâVK\ KcX¾ dKWKXNK NÀU cKU¾^ WSU^K\¾ NK NSdOV `_\_X^_]_X_ KdKV^¾\UOX NKRK \KRK^ LS\ ]\À ]KâVK\ æ'L]HOæ0RWRUODUæìoLQæ6RéXNæ dDOçëWçUPDæ<DUGçPFçODUç .ÀU ]¾MKUV¾UVK\NK cKU¾^ SVO^WOcO LKâV¾ YVK\KU ¾]¾ UKc¾ZVK\¾ XONOXScVO ]¾U¾À^¾\WK ]¾MKUV¾â¾ vYâ_XV_UVK cKU¾^¾X UOXNSVSâSXNOX K^OÀVOXWO]S SvSX cO^O\]Sd UKV¾\ ,_ XONOXVO vKV¾À^¾\WK cK\N¾WM¾VK\¾cVK L_ Z\YLVOWS vdWOU QO\OUS\ ,_\KNK ¾]¾^¾M¾ PVKXÀ OVKWKXVK\¾ KVO` LKÀVK^WK ]S]^OWVO\S `O U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\S K\K]¾XNK LS\ Kc\¾W cKZ¾VW¾À^¾\ .S\OU^ Z]U\^WOVS WY^Y\VK\ ]Yâ_U vKV¾À^¾\WK UK\KU^O\S]^SUVO\S Kv¾]¾XNKX X cKXWK YNKV¾ `O ^\LVKX] YNKV¾ WY^Y\VK\K Q\O NKRK ScSNS\ 26 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý æ.ç]GçUPDæEXMLOHUL nX cKXWK YNKV¾ `O ^\LVKX] YNKV¾ NSdOV WY^Y\VK\NK OX vYU U_VVKX¾VKX ]Yâ_U vKV¾À^¾\WK cK\N¾WM¾]¾ U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\ScVO UKVOW ^SZS U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\SX ¾]¾^WKN¾\ ,_ ]S]^OWNO U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\S X cKXWK YNK]¾ cK NK ^\LVKX] YNK]¾XK cKX]¾^¾V¾\L_XVK\ OWSVOX RK`Kc¾ ¾]¾^¾\ `O ]YX\K Z]U\^VOX cKU¾^¾X L_RK\VKÀ¾Z ^_^_ÀWK]¾XK XONOX YV_\VK\ 5¾dN¾\WK L_TS]S cKXWK YNK]¾X¾ WY^Y\ ]¾MKUV¾â¾XK Q\O ¾]¾^¾\ 3]¾^WK dKWKX¾ LS\ U¾dN¾\WK L_TS]S \VO]S ^K\KP¾XNKX LOVS\VOXS\ ,_ \VO WY^Y\_X vKV¾ÀWKcK RKd¾\ YVN_â_X_ Q]^O\QO ¾À¾â¾cVK cKX]¾^¾\ 7Y^Y\_X ]Yâ_UUOX ScS vKV¾ÀWK]¾X¾ ]KâVKWKU SvSX ¾]¾^WK WY^Y\ vKV¾À^¾U^KX ]Y\K NK NO`KW ONO\ 1OXOV YVK\KU U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\S LS\LS\SXO LKâV¾ v ]K\Q¾ L_V_X_\ /X _v^K KXS ¾]¾XWK ]K\Q¾]¾ Y\^KNK LKVKX] ]K\Q¾]¾ K\UKNK S]O P\OXVOWO ]K\Q¾]¾ cO\ KVW¾À^¾\ ,_TScO KU¾W QXNO\SVNSâSXNO _v^K cO\ KVKX KXS ¾]¾XWK ]K\Q¾]¾ U¾]K ]\ONO UY\ RKVSXO QOVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ¾]¾X¾\ ,_TSXSX ¾]¾XWK]¾XK LKâV¾ YVK\KU LKVKX] `O P\OXVOWO ]K\Q¾VK\¾X¾X NS\OXvVO\S KXSNOX K\^K\KU R¾dV¾ ¾]¾XWK ]K\Q¾]¾XK QOvOX KU¾W¾ NOXQOVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO U¾]¾^VKWKcK LKÀVK\ >SZSXO LKâV¾ YVK\KU U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\S cK ]O\S RKVSXNO^OV U¾dN¾\WK L_TSVO\S cKNK ZK\KVOV YVK\KU UKVOW ^SZ LKâVKX¾\ (QMHNW|Uæ0HPHOHUL Dæ(QMHNW|Uæ0HPHæ7LSOHUL /XTOU^\ WOWOVO\S QOXOV YVK\KU NOVSU `O SâXO ^SZVO\SXO Q\O ]¾X¾PVKXN¾\¾V¾\VK\ .OVSU ^SZ WOWO ^OU NOVSUVS `O vSP^ NOVSUVS YVWKU dO\O SUScO Kc\¾V¾\ SâXO ^SZ WOWO NO U¾]¾^VKWKV¾ `O U¾]¾^VKWK]¾d ^SZ YVWKU dO\O SUScO Kc\¾V¾\ 7Y^Y\NK U_VVKX¾VKMKU OXTOU^\ WOWO]S ]OvSVS\UOX cKXWK ÀOUVS `O cKXWK YNK]¾ NSUUK^O KV¾X¾\ kYU NOVSUVS ^SZ WOWOVO\ QOXOVVSUVO NS\OU^ Z]U\^WOVS WY^Y\VK\NKSâXO ^SZVS WOWOVO\ S]O X cKXWK YNKV¾ WY^Y\VK\ `O ^\LVKX]V¾ ^SZ cKXWK YNKV¾ WY^Y\VK\NK U_VVKX¾V¾\VK\ ,S\ vYU ^SZ OXTOU^\ WOWO]S U¾]¾^VKWKV¾ ^SZ^S\ 7OWO SâXO]SXSX dOV cKZ¾]¾XK LKâV¾ YVK\KU Z]U\^WOXSX LKÀ¾XNK cKXWK YNK]¾XK vYU Kd LS\ WSU^K\ WKdY^ Z]U\^V\ :]U\^WOXSX ]YX_XK NYâ\_ Z]U\^VOX cKU¾^¾X WSU^K\¾ R¾dVK K\^K\ .HQGLæçVçVçQçæNRQWUROæHGHQæWLS /X vYU ^O\MSR ONSVOX cKXWK ÀOUVS U¾]¾^VKWKV¾ ^SZ OXTOU^\ WOWO]S SVO ]KâVKX¾\ +c\¾MK L_ ^SZ WOWO SVO NSdOV `_\_X^_]_ XVOXS\ `O cKU¾^ ]K\PScK^¾ NÀ\V\ Eæ3VNUWPHæ%DVçQoææææææææ $\DUçQçQæ*HUHéL /XTOU^\ Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ WY^Y\K Q\O NOâSÀS\ ,_ NOâO\ Z]U\^VOX cKU¾^¾X RK`K SVO ScSMO UK\¾ÀWK]¾XK `O WWUX YVKX OX U¾]K ]\ONO cKXKLSVWO]SXO Q\O ]OvSVS\ /âO\ Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ _cQ_X NOâSV]O Z]U\^WO dKWKX¾ `O WSU^K\¾ dK\K\ `O\SMS O^USVO\O XONOX YV_\ L_ ]OLOZVO Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ NYâ\_ KcK\VKXWKV¾N¾\ /XTOU^\ Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ KcK\ ÀSWSXSX UKV¾XV¾â¾X¾X NOâSÀ^S\SVWO]S SVO KcK\VKX¾\ /âO\ ÀSW NKRK UKV¾X LS\ ÀSW SVO NOâSÀ^S\SVS\]O Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ K\^K\ >O\]SXO NKRK SXMO LS\ ÀSW SVO NOâSÀ^S\SVS\]O Kv¾VWK LK]¾XM¾ KdKV¾\ L_ ÀSWVO\ RO\ WY^Y\K Q\O vOÀS^VS UKV¾XV¾UVK\NK cONOU ZK\vK YVK\KU ^OWSX ONSVS\VO\ 28 .ç]GçUPDæEXMLVL 7HNæGHOLNOLæWLS .çVçWODPDOçæWLS dRNæGHOLNOLæWLS .çVçWODPDVç]æWLS .çVçWODPDOçæWLSæPHPH ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý <NVHNæ$ëçQPDæ'D\DQçPOçæ %RUædHOLéLæ3URILOL kKV¾ÀWK ÀK\^VK\¾ `O Z\OX]SZVO\S NSUUK^O KV¾XN¾â¾XNK /U]UK`K^\ `O CUVOcSMSVO\SX OX vYU KÀ¾XWKcK WK\_d UKVKX NYXKX¾WVK\¾X¾X UOZvOVO\ YVN_â_ Q\VOMOU^S\ :KVO^VS c\cÀ ]S]^OWSXO ]KRSZ WKUSXKVK\NK ZKVO^SX NO KcX¾ O^US KV^¾XNK YVN_â_ LSVSXWOU^ONS\ .K\LO `O KÀ¾XWK O^US]S KV^¾XNKUS L_ NYXKX¾WVK\¾ UY\_WKU NOâSÀSW ZO\ScY^VK\¾X¾X WWUX YVN_â_ UKNK\ _d_X ^_^WKU `O L_ ]KcONO SÀVO^WO QSNO\VO\SXS OX KdK SXNS\WOU CU]OU +À¾XWK .KcKX¾WV¾ ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\S SVO WWUXN\ 1. Mekanik Özellikler ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\SXSX cU]OU NK\LO `O KÀ¾XWK NKcKX¾W¾ ZO\PY\WKX]¾X¾ NOâO\VOXNS\OLSVWOU SvSX ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾XNK KcX¾ KWKvVK U_VVKX¾VKX NSâO\ WKVdOWOVO\SX WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\SXO NOâSXWOU cK\K\V¾ YVKMKU^¾\ <DSçæ dHOLNOHUL RO\ XO UKNK\ L_ KWKvVK \O^SVWOWSÀ YV]KVK\ NK ZScK]KNK cKcQ¾X `O cU]OU KÀ¾XWK NKcKX¾WV¾ vOVSUVO\O Q\O NKRK OUYXYWSU YVWKVK\¾ XONOXScVO ^O\MSR ONSVWOU^ONS\ CKZ¾ kOVSâS =^ :VKUKX¾X +UWK .KcKX¾W¾ kOUWO .KcKX¾W¾ # 8WW =O\^VSâS ,\SXOVV ]O`ScO]SXNONS\ EG 'ìNæ $ODìçPOçæ dHOLNOHU ]O\^VOÀ^S\SVOLSVWO `O L_X_X ]KâVKN¾â¾ YV_WV_ WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\S ]KcO]SXNO KÀ¾XWK `O NK\LO NKcKX¾W¾ K\KXKX cO\VO\NO ^O\MSR ONSVS\VO\ +XMKU USWcK]KV UYWZYdS]cYXVK\¾XNKUS NÀU 5K\LYX SvO\SâS .ÀU +VKÀ¾WV¾ kOVSUVO\SX UKcXKU dOVVSUVO\SXS YV_W]_d O^USVO\ 5K\LYX SvO\SâS ]O`ScO]SXNO ^_^_VK\KU `O SvO\SâSXNOUS NSâO\ LKd¾ KVKÀ¾W OVOWOX^VO\SXSX Y\KXVK\¾ NOâSÀ^S\SVO\OU .ÀU +VKÀ¾WV¾ kOVSUVO\SX UKcXKU dOVVSUVO\S ScSVOÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ `O ]O\^VOÀ^S\SVOLSVWO dOVVSUVO\S UY\_XKLSVS\ ,_ ScSVOÀ^S\WOVO\SX _cQ_VKXN¾â¾ vOVSUVO\ =+/ =YMSO^c YP +_- ^YWY^S`O /XQSXOO\] 3X^O\XK^SYXKV =^KXNK\^VK\¾XNK CU]OU .KcKX¾WV¾ .ÀU +VKÀ¾WV¾ 2=6+ YVK\KU ]¾X¾PVKXN¾\¾V¾\ WW UKV¾XV¾âK ]KRSZ =+/ 2=6+ ]¾X¾P¾ kOVSU ZVKUKVK\¾X +UWK .KcKX¾W¾ " kOUWO .KcKX¾W¾ " 8WW ]O`ScO]SXNONS\ EG dHOLNOHUæ '|NPOHU SÀ WKUSXKVK\¾ KÀ¾XWK ZK\vKVK\¾ \O^SWSXNO U_VVKX¾VKX LS\ NSâO\ cX^OW kOVSU .UWN\ kOVSU .UW +UWK `O kOUWO .KcKX¾W¾ NOâO\VO\S LKU¾W¾XNKX CKZ¾ kOVSUVO\SXO Q\O NKRK ScS ]O`ScONONS\ KXMKU KcX¾ cY\_W_ ]O\^SU NOâO\VO\S SvSX cKZWKU WWUX NOâSVNS\ n\XOâSX +=>7 +# cOXS RrVScVO +=>7 + =^KXNK\N¾XNKUS ¾]¾V SÀVOW Q\WÀ ]_ `O\SVWSÀ kOVSU .UWX ]O\^VSâS ,\SXOVV ]O`ScO]SXNONS\ kOVSU .UWNOX \O^SVOX UY\_c_M_ ZK\vKVK\¾X K`KX^KT¾ WYX^KTK `OcK U_VVKX¾WK RKd¾\ RKVNO YVWKVK\¾N¾\ +XMKU L_ \XVO\SX RKNNOVOXWSÀ ZVKUKVK\K Q\O NKRK U¾\¾VQKX LS\ cKZ¾cK ]KRSZ YVN_â_ LSVSXWOU^ONS\ EG $NPDæ'D\DQçPç dHNPHæ'D\DQçPç 8]DPDæ<]GHVL 'DUEHæ'D\DQçPç Sertlik <: 8WW <7 8WW += > - 5@ 4 2,A 7DEORæææ%ULQHOOæVHUWOLéLQGHNLæ%RUædHOLéLæ3URILOOHULQLQæ0HNDQLNæg]HOOLNOHUL C Si Mn 3 S V Cr Ni B CEV ! # " 7DEORææ¥ææ%ULQHOOæVHUWOLéLQGHNLæ%RUædHOLéLæ3URILOOHULQLQæ.LP\DVDOæ.RPSR]LV\RQX $NPDæ'D\DQçPç dHNPHæ'D\DQçPç 8]DPDæ<]GHVL Sertlik <: 8WW <7 8WW += 2, æ+%æ%RUædHOLéL æ+%æ3ODND dHOLNæ'|NPæ>@ # 6Wæ>@ # ² TDEORæææ%ULQHOOæVHUWOLéLQGHNLæ%RUædHOLéLæ3URILOOHULQHæDLWæPHNDQLNæ|]HOOLNOHULQæD\QçæDPDoODæNXOODQçODQæ GLéHUæUQOHUOHæNDUëçODëWçUçOPDVç 30 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Rockwell C Brinell HB .SVL kg/mm² MALZEME kOVSU .UW ² =^ " " ! "" # # # " #" # ! " # " 2, :VKUK =O\^VSU.KcKX¾W ^KLVY]_ ^OY\SU NOâO\VO\O NKcKV¾ YVK\KU RKd¾\VKXW¾À^¾\ 0K\UV¾ WO^Y^VK\VK VvVOX ]O\^VSU NOâO\VO\SXSX NXÀW WK^OWK^SU]OV YVK\KU NOâSV NOXOc]OV YVK\KU LOVS\VOXWOU^ONS\ 2, ,Y\ kOVSâS 7DEORæææ)DUNOçæ6HUWOLNægOoHNOHULQHæ*|UHæ'HéHUOHU dHOLNæ SODNDODUæ +À¾XWK .KcKX¾W¾ ]KâVKWKU SvSX dOV YVK\KU \O^SVOX kOVSU :VKUKVK\ cKcQ¾X YVK\KU ,\SXOVV ]O\^VSU NOâO\VO\SXO ]KRSZ^S\ ,\SXOVV ]O\^VSâSXNOUS KÀ¾XWK ZVKUK]¾X¾X +UWK .KcKX¾W¾ kOUWO .KcKX¾W¾ 8 WW% =O\^VSâS ,\SXOVV ]O`ScO]SXNONS\ .SâO\ \XVO\VO UK\À¾VKÀ^¾\¾VN¾â¾XNK L_ \XO KS^ WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\SX NSâO\VO\SXO Q\O ]^XVâ Y\^KNKN¾\ <NVHNæ $ìçQPDæ 'D\DQçPOçæ %RUæ dHOLéLæ 3URILOOHULQLQ +UWK .KcKX¾W¾ kOUWO .KcKX¾W¾ 8WW .218 ]O`ScO]SXNONS\ ,_ Z\YPSVVO\ RKNNOVOWO `O ¾]¾V SÀOW PKdVK\¾XNKX QOvO\ `O \O^SW ]YX_XNK ,\SXOVV ]O\^VSâSXO _VKÀ¾\ kOUWO `O .K\LO .KcKX¾W¾ vYU cU]OU YVKX L_ \XVO\SX K]¾V XMO v¾UKX dOVVSâS KÀ¾XWK NKcKX¾W¾N¾\ 7KXXROSW ?cQ_VKWKV¾ ,SVSWVO\ oXS`O\]S^O]S >\SLYVYTS ]\^XWO KÀ¾XWK `O cKáVKWK UYX_VK\¾X¾ SXMOVOcOX LSVSW `O ^OUXYVYTS NKV¾ /X]^S^]·XX cO\OV kOVSU \O^SMSVO\S SvSX cKZ^¾â¾ `O 9MKU ·NO Kv¾UVKN¾â¾ K\KÀ^¾\WK \KZY\_XK Q\O cU]OU KÀ¾XN¾\¾M¾V¾âK ]KRSZ KcX¾ WKVdOWOcO UK\À¾ EN STANDARDI 2, ]O\^VSâSXNOUS kOVSU ZVKUKX¾X 2, ]O\^VSâSXNOUS ZVKUKcK Q\O UK^ 2, ]O\^VSâSXNOUS ZVKUKcK Q\O Y\KX¾XNK NKRK _d_X W\V YVN_â_ NOXOc]OV YVK\KU LOVS\VOXWSÀ^S\ EG 2. Geometrik Özellikler YHæ6WDQGDUWODU kOVSU ZVKUKNKX \O^SVOX ZK\vKVK\ S]^OXOX PY\W_ KVWKVK\¾ SvSX LS\ NSdS SWKVK^ cX^OWSXO ^KL} ^_^_V_\ n\XOâSX% vOVSU ZVKUKNKX UOZvO Kâ¾d L¾vKâ¾ \O^WOU 7h5.æ67$1'$5',æ.$5ê,/,è, >YVO\KX]VK\ /8 # >= /8 # =¾MKU 2KNNOVOXWSÀ WW @OcK .KRK 5KV¾X kOVSU 6O`RKVK\ nVv ¿OUSV `O 5^VO >YVO\KX]VK\¾ CdOc ndOVVSUVO\S /8 >= /8 kOVSU CK]]¾ 7KW_VVO\=¾MKU 2KNNOVOXWSÀ 6O`RK 1OXSÀ CK]]¾VK\ `O :\YPSVVO\ ½vSX >O]VSW ¿K\^VK\¾,VW $6O`RK `O 1OXSÀ CK]]¾VK\ /8 3=9 >= /8 3=9 7O^KVSU WKVdOWOVO\ ,\SXOVV ]O\^VSU NOXOcS ,VW $ .OXOc WO^YN_ /8 3=9 >= /8 3=9 7O^KVSU WKVdOWOVO\ ,\SXOVV ]O\^VSU NOXOcS ,VW $ .OXOc MSRKdVK\¾X¾X NYâ\_VKXWK]¾ `O UKVSL\K]cYX_ /8 " >= /8 " EG =_ @O\SVWSÀ `O >OWZO\VOXWSÀ kOVSUVO\,VW $ +VKÀ¾WV¾ kOVSUVO\SX >OUXSU >O]VSW ¿K\^VK\¾ 5KVS^O 5YX^\YV EG >OUXSU >O]VSW ¿K\^VK\¾ EG >= /8 " =_ @O\SVWSÀ `O 7OXO`SÀVOXWSÀ kOVSUVO\ 3]VKR kOVSUVO\S ,VW $ ,Y\V_ kOVSUVO\SX >OUXSU >O]VSW ¿K\^VK\¾ ]^KXNK\N¾ cO\SXO QOvWSÀ `O " ^K\SRSXNO c\\VâO QS\WSÀ^S\ EG 5KVS^O 5YX^\YV RO\ \X Q\_L_ SvSX Kc\¾ Kc\¾ cKZ¾VWKU^K `O ]YX_vVK\¾ UKc¾^ KV^¾XK KV¾XWKU^KN¾\ 7DEORæææ<NVHNæ$ëçQPDæ'D\DQçPOçæ%RUædHOLéLæ3URILOOHULQLQægOoPæYHæ7HVOLPæ6WDQGDUWODUç 31 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý SvSX ZVKUK S]^OXOX VvNO UO]SVS\ LS\ UÀO]SXO LYcNKX LYcK \KWZK cKZ¾V¾\ .SâO\ LS\ UÀO]SXO NO WYX^KT¾ UYVKcVKÀ^¾\WKU KWKM¾cVK UKcXKU Kâd¾ Kv¾V¾\ 2O\ SUS SÀVOW NO cU]OU ]¾MKUV¾U KV^¾XNK QO\vOUVOÀ^SâS SvSX ZVKUKX¾X WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\S ^OUXSU ^O]VSW ÀK\^VK\¾X¾ LOVS\VOcOX ]^KXNK\^VK\¾X KV^¾XK NÀWÀ YV_\ +N¾XNKX NK KXVKÀ¾VKMKâ¾ QSLS CU]OU +À¾XWK .KcKX¾WV¾ ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\S ZVKUK RKVSXNO NOâSV U_VVKX¾W KWKM¾XK _cQ_X Z\YPSVVO\ RKVSXNO \O^SVWOU^ONS\ n\XOâSX +â¾d ,¾vKâ¾ :\YPSVS \KWZKV¾ `O UKcXKU Kâd¾ Kv¾VW¾À YVK\KU RKNNOVOXS\ ½]^OXOX _d_XV_âK UO]SVS\ `O L_ RKVScVO U_VVKX¾WK RKd¾\N¾\ :\YPSVSX KÀ¾XWKcK O^US]S KV^¾XNK UKVKX cdOcVO\S \O^SWNOX v¾U^¾â¾ KXNKUS ]^X WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\SXS UY\_\ CU]OU +À¾XWK .KcKX¾WV¾ ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\SXSX QOYWO^\SU dOVVSUVO\S ^OUXSU ^O]VSW ÀK\^VK\¾ \O^SW UYX^\YVVO\S LS\ NSdS _V_]VK\ K\K]¾ ]^KXNK\^ vO\vO`O]SXNO QO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVS\ æ%DëOçFDæ3URILOOHUæ.XOODQçPæ $ODQODUçæ YHæ $YDQWDMODUçææ (NVNDYDW|Uæ YHæ <NOH\LFLOHUæ ìoLQæ$éç]æ%çoDéçæ3URILOL +â¾d ,¾vKUVK\¾ ZVKUKNKX \O^SVWONSâS +â¾d ,¾vKâ¾ Z\YPSVSXNO RKNNOVOXNSâS `O L_ ÀOUSVNO ¾]¾V SÀVOW Q\Nâ SvSX ]^X QOYWO^\SU `O WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\O ]KRSZ^S\ (NVNDYDW|Uæ YHæ <NOH\LFLOHUæ ìoLQæ<DUçPæ2Næ$ëçQPDæ%çoDéçæ3URILOL ,_ Z\YPSVVO\% .d +â¾d ,¾vKUVK\¾XK UKcXKUVK LKâVKXKX +À¾XWK ,¾vKâ¾ 5OZvO cKX ]KM¾XK UKcXKUVK LKâVKXKX cKX L¾vKU% 5KdWK+NKZ^\ K\KVK\¾XK UKcXKUVK `OcK M¾`K^KcVK LKâVKXKX ]OQWOX^^O \O^SVWOU^ONS\ %DëOçFDæ$YDQWDMODUçæ +â¾d ,¾vKâ¾ :\YPSVSXSX X ]^ `O ^KLKX U¾]W¾X¾ UY\_\ UOZvO UKZK]S^O]SXS K\^^¾\¾\ WKVdOWOcVO ^OWK] ONOX cdOcSX NKRK UO]USX YVWK]¾X¾ ]KâVK\ ½]^OXOX _d_XV_U^K `O UOZvO cKX ]KM¾XK _cQ_X ÀOUSVNO RKd¾\VKXKLSVS\ 2KNNOVOXWSÀ ,Y\ kOVSâSXNOX \O^SVNSâS SvSX KcX¾ QOYWO^\SNOUS vOVSU NUW \XVO\O Q\O vYU NKRK _d_X W\VN\ 7Pæìëæ0DNLQDODUçææ ìoLQæ$ëçQPDæ%DQWODUç +À¾XWK LKX^VK\¾ KÀ¾XWK NKcKX¾W¾ S]^OXOX NSâO\ ^W LVQOVO\NO U_VVKX¾VKLSVS\ /U]UK`K^\ 5OZvOVO\S ]¾\^ ]KMVK\¾X¾ UY\_WKU SvSX OX O^USVS vdWN\ ,_ Z\YPSVVO\VO ^W LOUYV_ cUVOcSMSVO\ SvSX NYdO\ L¾vKâ¾ \O^SVOLSVS\ 5OZvO QOXSÀVSâSXO Q\O S]^OXOX _d_XV_U^K QOXSÀVSU^O `O KÀ¾XWK cYâ_XV_â_XK LKâV¾ YVK\KU S]^OXOX UKV¾XV¾U^K U_VVKX¾VKLSVS\ WW·NOX ! WW UKV¾XV¾âK UKNK\ PK\UV¾ Z\YPSV ]OvOXOUVO\S SVO S]^OXOX LYcNK UO]SVWO]S N¾À¾XNK RSvLS\ WOUKXSU SÀVOWO QO\OU]SXSW N_cWKNKX U_VVKX¾WK RKd¾\N¾\ 32 dHOLNæ3DOHWOLæ0DNLQDODUæìoLQ 3DOHWæ3DEXoæ7çUQDNODUç +À¾XKX :KVO^VO\SX ]KNOMO ^¾\XKU LVWXX cOXSVOXWO]ScVO LcU ^K]K\\_P ]KâVK\ ?cQ_X Z\YPSVNO S]^OXOX _d_XV_U^K RKd¾\VKXKLSVS\ æìPDODWæ<|QWHPOHUL .D\QDNæ3URVHGU ,\SXOVV =O\^SVSâSXNOUS ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\S LXcO]SXNO NÀU Y\KXNK KVKÀ¾W OVOWOX^VO\SXO `O L_ ]KcONO NÀU 5K\LYX /ÀVOXSU .OâO\SXO -/@ ]KRSZ^S\ ,_ dOVVSâSXNOX NYVKc¾ L^X CKZ¾ kOVSUVO\SXO cKcQ¾X YVK\KU U_VVKX¾VKX ^W UKcXKU cX^OWVO\ScVO LKâVKXKLSVS\ .ÀU 5K\LYX /ÀVOXSâS 2SN\YTOX vK^VKUVK\¾X¾X YV_ÀWK \S]USXS KdKV^KX LS\ PKU^\N\ ,_ \S]U KÀKâ¾NKUS XVOWVO\VO WSXSWSdO ONSVWOVSNS\$ 7KVdOWOVO\SX UKcXKU SÀVOWSXNOX XMO ¾]¾^¾VWK]¾ cKXS ^K`VKXWK]¾ ,S\VOÀWO cdOcVO\SXSX ^OWSd LYcK]¾d `O U_\_ YVWK]¾ ,S\VOÀWO cdOcVO\SXSX NdQX LS\ ÀOUSVNO RSdKVKXWK]¾ NOXQOVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO UKcXK^¾VWK]¾ .ÀU 2SN\YTOX 2. ) W6 Q SvO\OX NYVQ_ WKVdOWO]S ^O\MSR ONSVWO]S 5KcXKU SÀVOWSXNOX XMO cKZ¾VKMKU X ¾]¾^WK ^K`VKWK UKcXK^¾VKX cdOcVO\SX NKRK cK`KÀ ]Yâ_WK]¾X¾ ]KâVKcK\KU L_ LVQOVO\NO YV_ÀKLSVOMOU KÀ¾\¾ ]O\^ `O ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Örtülü Elektrot +A= =0+ / "" +A= =0+ 0!+b ² /b 7R]DOWç +A= =0+ / " +A= =0+ " /< "= ² b MIG / MAG FCAW Özlü Tel +A= =0+ 0"+b ² /b +A= =0+ # / "b> ² b ,_XVK\¾X N¾À¾XNK >= " /8 =^KXNK\N¾XK _cQ_X .ÀU +VKÀ¾WV¾ =1 `O =1 731 7+1 5KcXKU ^OVVO\S NO U_VVKX¾VKLSVS\ 7DEORæææ.D\QDNæWUQHæJ|UHæ|QHULOHQæ\NVHNæDODëçPOçæ$:6æ$PHULFDQæ:HOGLQJæ6RFLHW\æVçQçIçæHOHNWURWODU U¾\¾VQKX cKZ¾c¾ XVOcOMOU^S\ ,_ \XVO\ SvSX UKcXKU NSUSÀSXNOX ! WW WO]KPOcO UKNK\ RO\ SUS WKVdOWOXSX NO SVO ! -·cO UKNK\ ¾]¾^¾VWK]¾ `O 5KcXKU SÀVOWS LS^SWSXNO UKcXKU cdOcS WWUX YVN_â_ UKNK\ cK`KÀ LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]Yâ_^_VWKV¾N¾\ XK Q\O \O^SVWSÀ NÀU 2SN\YTOX 2. ) W6 Q SvO\OX +UWK .KcKX¾W¾ 8WW·NOX NÀU c_W_ÀKU LKdSU OVOU^\Y^VK\ U_VVKX¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,_ \XVO\SXSX UKcXKâ¾XNK +\U /XO\TS]S U4WW·NOX PKdVK YVWKWKV¾N¾\ â_^_VWK]¾ XO\SVS\ ,_ :\YPSVVO\ ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾XNK U_VVKX¾VKX +â¾d `O +À¾XWK ,¾vKUVK\¾ :KVO^ :KL_v >¾\XKUVK\¾ QSLS dOV KWKvVK\VK \O^SVNSâS SvSX ]KNOMO S]^OXOX _d_XV_â_ OVNO ONSVWOU KWKM¾cVK UO]SVWOU^ONS\ ,_ XONOXVO Z\YPSVVO\SX ]^X WOUKXSU dOVVSUVO\S UY\_XWKU^KN¾\ $OHYæYHæ3OD]PDæìOHæ.HVPH .D\QDNæGROJXæPDO]HPHVLæVHoLPLæ YHæ$UNæ(QHUMLVL ,_ \XVO\SXSX UKcXKâ¾XNK >= /8 3=9 # 5KcXKU `O SVQSVS SÀVOWVO\ 0O\\S^SU kOVSU K\U UKcXKU WO^KVSXNOUS RSN\YTOX W_R^O`K]¾X¾X ^KcSXS ]^KXNK\N¾- ,\SXOVV =O\^SVSâSXNOUS ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\S +VO`VO `O :VKdWK SVO UO]SVWONOX XMO UO]SVOMOU LVQOXSX SVO ! -·cO UKNK\ ¾]¾^¾VWK]¾ `O UO]SW SÀVOWS LS^SWSXNO UO]SVOX cdOcVO\SX WWUX YVN_â_ UKNK\ cK`KÀ LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]Y- 0HNDQLNæ.HVPHæ%NPH ,_ \XVO\SX WOUKXSU YVK\KU UO]SVWO]S `O`OcK LUVWO]S XO\SVWOd Delme ,\SXOVV =O\^SVSâSXNOUS ,Y\ kOVSâS :\YPSVVO\S \XVO\S _cQ_X QOYWO^\ScO ]KRSZ CU]OU 2¾d kOVSâSXNOX SWKV ONSVWSÀ ^KU¾WVK\VK _cQ_X UO]WO ]¾`¾VK\¾ U_VVKX¾VK\KU NOVSXOLSVS\ .OVWO SÀVOWSXNOX XMO NOVSXOMOU UYX_WVK\¾X SVO ! -·cO UKNK\ ¾]¾^¾VWK]¾ `O WWUX YVN_â_ UKNK\ cK`KÀ LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]Yâ_^_VWK]¾ NKRK ]YX\K NOVWO SÀVOWSXSX LKÀVK^¾VWK]¾ XO\SVS\ EG .D\QDNoD 1. .38 ! 1OXOV 5_VVKX¾W +WKvV¾ CKZ¾ kOVSUVO\S =^KXNK\N¾ 2. 9LO\Q /% O^ KV ## 7KMRSXO\c] 2KXNLYYU ^R ONS^SYX ON 3XN_]^\SKV :\O]] 3XM ] 3. 6cYX] ASVVSKW - KXN :VS]QK 1K\c 4 ON] =^KXNK\N 2KXNLYYU YP :O^\YVO_W 8K^_\KV 1K] /XQSXOO\SXQ /V]O`SO\ 4. >Rc]]OX5\_ZZ =^OOV +1 1^OX _XN /SQOX]MRKP^OX ! ] 5. CX^O\ ,K\KX =A/.9B CU]OU +À¾XWK .KcKX¾WV¾ ,Y\ kOVSUVO\S >OUXSU ndOVVSUVO\ ?cQ_VKWKVK\ " ] Baran YÖNTER <ROæ0DNLQDæ/WG 34 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Basit Uygulamalar ææææLOHæ0DNLQDQçQæææææææ ææææææææì\LOHëWLULOPHVLæYH Enerji Tüketiminin Günümüz teknolojisinde üretim KVKXVK\¾XNKUS \OUKLO^% PS\WKVK\¾X UK\V¾V¾UVK\¾X¾ UY\_cKLSVWO]S SvSX vOÀS^VS K\Kc¾ÀVK\ SvO\S]SXO ]\UVOWOU^ONS\ 0S\WKVK\¾X cKZ^¾UVK\¾ SÀ^OX UK\ Y\KXVK\¾X¾ K\^^¾\KLSVWOVO\S SvSX QOXOV QSNO\VO\SXS KdKV^WKU OX XOWVS RONOPVO\S YVW_À^_\ ndOVVSUVO NO U\SdVO\ ]YX\K]¾XNK LS\ ^KU¾W QO\vOUVO\ NKRK vK\Z¾M¾ LSvSWNO Y\^KcK v¾UWKU^KN¾\ ,_ QO\vOUVO\ PS\WKVK\ SvSXNOUS WK]\KPVK\¾X KdKV^¾VWK]¾ OUYXYWSU U_VVKX¾W SX]KXNKX dKWKXNKX `O cKZ¾VKX SÀVO\NOX ^K]K\\_P ÀOUVSXNO UOXNSVO\SXS Q]^O\S\VO\ <OUKLO^ Y\^KW¾X¾X dY\V_UVK\¾ XONOXScVO UK\V¾V¾U Y\KX¾ QX QOv^SUvO NÀWOU^ONS\ 7KUSXK \O^SMSVO\S NO L_ cdNOX vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾XK WO`M_^ R¾dVK\¾ K\^- 36 $]DOWçOPDVç ^¾\KX OUYXYWSU K`KX^KT ]KâVKcKX `O `OcK OXO\TSNOX ^K]K\\_P cKZKX OVOWKX `OcK ]S]^OWVO\ dO\SXO +\1O vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾XK cXOVWSÀVO\NS\ 7KVScO^ KXKVSdVO\SXNO dKWKX `O cKU¾^ OX XOWVS QSNO\ UKVOWVO\SXS YV_À^_\WKU^KN¾\ ,^X S]^K^S]US vKV¾ÀWKVK\ À_X_ Q]^O\WSÀ^S\ US 7KUSXK KV¾WVK\¾XNK OX XOWVS U\S^O\ LS\SW ]\ONO cKZ¾VKX SÀSX WKVScO^ KXKVSdSNS\ ½USXMSV LS\SXMS NO\OMO XOWVS YVWK]¾ QO\OUS\UOX >\UScO·NO SUSXMS ZVKXNK UKVKX XOWVS R_]_] S]O WKUSXK vKV¾ÀWK Q`OXVSâSNS\ 1`OXVSU dKWKX `O OXO\TS `O\SWVSVSâSXS K\^^¾\KX KcX¾ O]XKNK LK]S^ cKZ¾VKNKUS OVOWKXVK\¾X \O^SWS ROZSWSdSX SVQS]SXS vOUWOU^ONS\ ½À WKUSXKVK\¾ SvSXNO dOVVSUVO OU]UK`K^\VO\ WKUSXK ZK\UVK\¾X¾X LcU `O XOWVS U¾]W¾X¾ YV_À^_\_\ 1XWdNO OU]UK`K^\ R¾dVK\¾ RO\ cOXS WYNOVNO NKRK NK K\^WKU^KN¾\ /U]UK`K^\ vKV¾ÀWK R¾dVK\¾X¾X K\^^¾\¾VWK]¾ XY\WKV ÀK\^VK\NK ]KNOMO ZYWZK NOLS]SXSX `OcK WY^Y\ R¾dVK\¾X¾X K\^^¾\¾VWK]¾ SVO ]KâVKXKLSVWOU^ONS\ 7Y^Y\ R¾dVK\¾ ZYWZK \O^SMSVO\SXSX `O\NSâS XY\WVK\K Q\O NSdKcX ONSVNSâS SvSX `O ]Yâ_U RK`K ÀK\^VK\¾XNK UK`S^K]cYX Z\YLVOWSXSX K\^WK]¾XNKX NYVKc¾ ZYWZKX¾X R¾d¾ NKRK PKdVK cU]OV^SVOWOWOU^ONS\ 7KUSXK R¾dVK\¾X¾ K\^^¾\KLSVWOU SvSX% ZYWZK NOLS]SXSX Lc^VWO]SXONKRK LcU RY\^_W `O LY\_ vKZVK\¾XK `O NKRK LcU `KVP- ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý VO\O SR^ScKv N_c_VWKU^KN¾\ .YâKV YVK\KU WY^Y\ QMXX K\^WK]¾ QO\OUS\ ,_ NK cKU¾^ ^UO^SWSXSX K\^WK]¾ NOWOU^S\ +XMKU SNOKV YVKX OX Kd ^UO^SW SVO OX cU]OU `O\SWVSVSâSX ]KâVKXWK]¾N¾\ C_UK\¾NK LKR]ONSVOX SR^ScKvVK\¾X QSNO\SVOLSVWO]S SvSX ^OU LS\ LVYU SvSXNO LS\NOX vYU SÀVO`O ]KRSZ `KVPVO\ SWKV ONSVO\OU ZKdK\¾X SR^ScKM¾XK MO`KZ `O\OLSVWOU^ONS\ ,_ `KVPVO\SX QOXOV YVK\KU dOVVSUVO\S 5YVKc WYX^KT ONSVOLSVWO dOVVSâS <OTOXK\K^SP vKV¾ÀKLSVWO dOVVSâS 7KUSXK Q`OXVSU QO\OU]SXSWVO\S- XS UK\À¾VKcKLSVWO]S RY\^_W ²LY\_ ZK^VKWK O]XK]¾XNK LYW_X NÀWO]SXS XVOWO QSLS ¿YU LK]¾XvVK\¾XK UK\À¾ WKUSXKc¾ UY\_cKLSVWO 2K]]K] UYX_W UYX^\YV ]KâVKcKLSVWO /U]UK`K^\VO\ SvSX \O^SVOX LYW `O UYV ]SVSXNS\VO\S dO\SXO ^KU¾VK\KU vKV¾ÀKX L_ LK]S^ OVOWKXVK\ OXO\TS ]K\PScK^¾X¾X NÀWO]S dKWKXNKX ^K]K\\_P `O Q`OXVSU ]KâVKW¾À^¾\ ,_ `KVP LVYâ_X_X vKV¾ÀWK ÀOUVS cX NOXO^SW O]XK]¾XNK NÀU LK]¾XvVK\NK ^KXUK QS^WOU^O YVKX cKâ¾X tekrar sisteme döndürülmesi ile enerjiXSX QO\S UKdKX¾W¾X¾ ]KâVKW¾À^¾\ <OTOXO\K^SP `KVP LVYâ_% WO`M_^ ZYWZK `O cX NOXO^SW `KVPVO\SXNO NOâSÀSUVSU cKZWKcK QO\OU UKVWKNKX ]SVSXNS\ SVO RY\^_W K\K]¾XK ^KU¾VWKU^KN¾\ ,YW `O UYV ]SVSXNS\VO\S WKUSXKX¾X vKV¾ÀWK]¾ O]XK]¾XNK cK\¾ cK\¾cK YVKX LS\ Y\KXNK cUV `O cU]d vKV¾ÀWK UYX_W_XK ]KRSZ^S\ CKXS UKdWK `O cUVOWO SÀVOWSXNO SUOX cU]OU LK]¾XvVK L_ SÀVOWVO\ ]YX_XNK LKÀVKXQ¾v UYX_W_XK 37 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý +RUWXPæSDWODPDæYDOILæLoæNHVLWL A.æ6HNRQGHUæEDVçQoæD\DUæYDOIL B. æ+RUWXPæSDWODPDæYDOILæ C. Pilot piston grubu vOU `KVP cKc¾ " ]\Q LKVKX] ZSWS KXK ZS]^YX ]\Q cKc¾ # KvWK ZS]^YX_ LKVKX] NOVSâS KXK ZS]^YX ]\Q cKc¾ KvWK ZS]^YX_ KcK\ Z_V_ ]OUYXNO\ `KVP KcK\ `SNK]¾ ]^\YU KcK\ Z_V_ ]OUYXNO\ `KVP ]\Q] ]OUYXNO\ `KVP cKc UKZKâ¾ KXK ]\Q ]OUYXNO\ `KVP cKc¾ ! ZSVY^ UYX^\YV ]\Q] QOVS\UOX S]O NÀU LK]¾Xv SVO vKV¾À^¾â¾ ]\Ov^S\ .ÀU LK]¾Xv SVO O]US UYX_W_XK QOVS\UOX cX NOXO^SW `KVPS ]SVSXNS\SX NSâO\ RK^^¾XNKX QOVOX cKâ¾ ^KXUK cXVOXNS\S\ =SVSXNS\ SVO RY\^_W K\K]¾XK ^KU¾VKMKU YVKX L_ `KVP SVO ]SVSXNS\SX ^KXU RK^^¾XK QXNO\WOU^O YVN_â_ cKâ¾ ^KU¾VKMKU YVKX `KVP dO\SXNOUS ]S]^OW ^KXU cO\SXO ]SVSXNS\SX NSâO\ SÀ cKZKX LVWXO QXNO\O\OU cOXSNOX UKdKX¾W ]KâVK\ ,_ SÀVOW ^KU¾VKMKU `KVP cO\SXO cX NOXO^SW `KVPS SVO NO cKZ¾VKLSVS\ +XMKU RY\^_W `O LY\_ RK^^¾ dO\SXNO LK]¾Xv UKc¾ZVK\¾ NKRK NK K\^KMKU^¾\ ,_ N_\_W RY\^_WVK\¾X SvSXNO US KU¾ÀUKX¾X R¾d¾X¾X K\^WK]¾ SVO OVOWKXVK\¾X W\VO\SXSX U¾]KVWK]¾XK XONOX YV_\ 38 CKXS KU¾ÀUKX R¾d¾X¾X K\^WK]¾ SVO VKWSXO\ KU¾W¾ ^\LVKX]K NXÀ^\WÀ YV_\_d +c\¾MK RY\^_W ZK^VKWK N_\_W_XNK OWXScO^ ]KâVKXKWKd COXSNOX UKdKX¾VKX cKâ SVO ]SVSXNS\SX R¾d¾ ZYWZK NOLS]SXO U¾cK]VK KVKX Y\KX¾ UKNK\ K\^K\ 7KUSXK R¾d¾XNK WY^Y\ `O ZYWZKNKX LKâ¾W]¾d YVK\KU SUSXMS LS\ R¾dVKXN¾\¾M¾ ZYWZK O^US]S OVNO ONSVS\ /U]UK`K^\VO\SX cKZ¾VK\¾ QO\OâS LYW ]SVSXNS\VO\S SUS KNO^ YVKLSVWOU^ONS\VO\ =SVSXNS\VO\ dO\SXNO YV_ÀKX U_``O^ PK\UV¾V¾â¾XNKX NYVKc¾ WOcNKXK QOVOX ]SVSXNS\VO\SX PK\UV¾ RK\OUO^VO\SXS XVOWOU SvSX TYc]^SUVO\NOX QOVOX ]SXcKV RK^VK\¾X¾X RO\ LS\ ]SVSXNS\O ^KU¾VKMKU YVKX `KVP LVYâ_XK ZK\KVOV LKâVKX^¾ cKZ¾VK\KU LKVKX] ]Y\_X_ NK QSNO\SVS\ CKZ¾VKX SXMOVOWOVO\NO OXO\TSXSX QO\S UKdKX¾W¾XNKX cO cKU¾X LS\ ^K]K\\_P ]KâVKX¾VN¾â¾ ^O]ZS^ ONSVWSÀ^S\ >KU¾VKMKU YVKX `KVP LVYâ_ R¾dVKXN¾\WK SÀSXS cKZK\UOX RY\^_W `O LY\_ ZK^VKWKVK\¾XK UK\À¾ cU KV^¾XNK SUOX LSVO OWXScO^S ]KâVKWKU^K YV_Z LYW_X NÀWO]SXS OXQOVVOWOU^ONS\VO\ :SVY^ LK]¾XvVK\¾ SVO vKV¾ÀKX L_ `KVPVO\NO NSUUK^ ONSVOMOU XOWVS XYU^K S]O `KVPVO\SX ZSVY^ KvWK Y\KXVK\¾N¾\ ,_ Y\KXVK\ NÀU YVN_â_ dKWKX LK]¾Xv UKc¾ZVK\¾ K\^WKU^K LcU YVN_â_ dKWKX S]O LYW UYV ]SVSXNS\VO\SXNO ^S^\OWOVO\ YV_ÀWKU^KN¾\ ,_X_X OX LcU ]OLOZVO\SXNOX LS\S]S S]O TYc]^SU SVO `KVP KvWK Y\KXVK\¾X¾X _cQ_X YVWKc¾À¾N¾\ @KVPVO\SX cU KV^¾XNK vKV¾ÀWK RK]]K]ScO^- ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý VO\S `O LK]¾Xv UKc¾ZVK\¾ vYU XOWVSNS\ +c\¾MK _X_^_VWKWK]¾ QO\OUS\ US cU]OU LK]¾Xv UKc¾ZVK\¾ SVO vKV¾ÀWK cKU¾^ ^UO^SWSXS K\^^¾\KX XOWVS LS\ PKU^\N\ =OvSVOX `KVPVO\SX UKVS^O]SXSX WKUSXK ZO\PY\WKX]¾XK cKXS cKU¾^ ^UO^SWSXO NS\OU O^US]S YVN_â_ cKZ¾VKX K\KÀ^¾\WKVK\ SVO OVNO ONSVOX SVQSXv LS\ XYU^KN¾\ ,K]¾Xv UKc¾ZVK\¾X¾X ^YZVKW¾ cKU¾^ ^UO^SWSXSX VSU LS\ NSVSWSXS YV_À^_\WKU^KN¾\ ,_ `KVPVO\NO NSâO\ LS\ K`KX^KT S]O dOVVSUVO\SXNOX NYVKc¾ cU ^KÀ¾WK `O ZYdS]cYX RK]]K]ScO^SXO ]KRSZ YVWKVK\¾N¾\ ,_ dOVVSUVO\S ]KcO]SXNO LY\_ RK^VK\¾XNKUS LKÀK\¾VK\¾ Qd K\N¾ ONSVOWOd ?d_X ]\OVS cU KV^¾XNK LOUVOWO SÀVOWVO\SXNO ]¾dN¾\WKdV¾U cO^OXOUVO\SXNOX NYVKc¾ cX NOXO^SW `KVPVO\SXNOX NKRK RK]]K] UYX_WVKWK cKZWKU- 40 ^KN¾\VK\ CX NOXO^SW `KVPVO\S ]SVSXNS\SU ]\Q SVO UYX^\YV ONSVS\VO\ =SVSXNS\SU cKZ¾NK c_`KNKUS ^YVO\KX]¾ cKâ¾X `S]UYdS^O]ScVO SVQSVS K\^WKU^K `OcK KdKVWKU^KN¾\ 2Y\^_W ZK^VKWK `O \OTOXK\K^SP dOVVSU^OUS `KVP UYXSU Y^_\WK cdOcSXNOX NYVKc¾ ]¾dN¾\WKdV¾U NS\OXMSXO ]KRSZ^S\VO\ ,_ dOVVSU L_ `KVPVO\S RK]]K] UYX_W UYX^\V `O cU KV^¾XNK vKV¾ÀKLSVWO UKLSVScO^VO\SXS \KUSZ]Sd U¾VWKU^KN¾\ 1`OXVSU XONOXS SVO ]SVSXNS\O NS\OU LKâVKWK dY\_XV_V_â_ YVKX L_ `KVP dO\SXNO ¾]¾NKX QOXVOÀWO `O NK\LOVO\O UK\À¾ YV_ÀKX ÀYUVK\K SUSXMS OWXScO^ `KVPS SVO UY\_XWK ]KâVKXW¾À^¾\ +`\_ZK NK U_VVKX¾VWKU^K YVKX 2Y\^_W ZK^VKWK `KVPS SVO SVQSVS LKd¾ XOWVS LSVQSVO\ `O cXO^WOVSUVO\S ÀcVO ]¾\KVKcKLSVS\Sd% =^KXNK\^VK\$ /8 !$## 3=9 " `O /8 #"$## ,_XVK\NKX XOWVS YVKX KV¾X^¾VK\ S]O ÀcVONS\% /U]UK`K^\ LYW ]SVSXNS\S ÀKcO^ UQ NKX PKdVK Kâ¾\V¾U UKVN¾\¾cY\ S]O W_^VKUK RY\^_W ZK^VKWK `KVPS U_VVKX¾VWK]¾ QO\OUVSNS\ =SVSXNS\ NÀWO R¾d¾ RY\^_W ZK^VKWK O]XK]¾XNK OX PKdVK SUS UK^¾X¾ QOvScY\ S]O =SVSXNS\ cU KV^¾XNK WW]X NOX PKdVK UKv¾\¾cY\ S]O `KVP ^KU¾VWK]¾ dY\_XV_N_\ CU KV^¾XNKUS vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK UYX^\YVNO cK`KÀVKWK `O UK\K\V¾V¾U cK`KÀV¾cY\ S]O `KVP ^KU¾VWK]¾ dY\_XV_N_\ CU KV^¾XNK vKV¾ÀKX ]SVSXNS\O `KVP K\KNK RY\^_W `OcK LY\_ LKâVKX^¾]¾ cKZ¾VWKNKX ^KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ =¾\KVKWK ]SVSXNS\ `KVP RY\^_W `OcK LY\_ ÀOUVSXNO YVWKV¾N¾\ C_UK\¾NK ]^KXNK\^VK\NKX KV¾X^¾ cKZ¾VK\KU `O\SVOX LSVQSVO\NO ]KNOMO XOWVS YVKX LKd¾ U\S^SU XYU^KVK\K NSUUK^ vOUSVWSÀ^S\ ,_ XYU^KVK\NKX NK KXVKÀ¾VKMKâ¾ QSLS QdVOW cKZ¾VN¾â¾ dKWKX LS\ vYU _cQ_VKWKX¾X cKXV¾ÀV¾â¾ v¾ZVKU QdVO Q\VWOU^ONS\ ,S\vYU _cQ_VKWKX¾X ]SVSXdi\ SVO K\KNK RK^ LY\_]_ `O NKRK ]YX\K `KVP ]S]^OWSXNOX YV_À^_\_VN_â_ `O L_X_X Q`OXVSU ]^KXNK\^VK\¾X¾ UK\À¾VKWKN¾â¾ KXVKÀ¾VWKU^KN¾\ 6XDWæ'(0ì5(5ææ(UNDQæ7$ê.,5$1 Mak. Müh. Mak. Müh. Demirer Teknolojit Sistemleri ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Lastiklerin Tamir Edilmesi 6K]^SâSX RK`K]¾ vOÀS^VS XONOXVO\VO U¾]WOX cK NK ^KWKWOX LYÀKVKLSVS\ ,_ N_\_WNK K\Kv ROWOX N_\N_\WKV¾ ZK^VKU N_\_WNK VK]^SU dO\SXNO c\XWOWOVS `O ROWOX cONOU VK]^SU ^KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,_X_XVK LS\VSU^O SR^ScKv YVN_â_XNK U_VVKX¾VKLSVS\ N_\_WNK YVN_â_XNKX OWSX YVWKU SvSX cONOU VK]^SâSX RK`K LK]¾XM¾X¾ NdOXVS YVK\KU UYX^\YV ONSVWOVSNS\ :K^VKU VK]^SâSX dO\SXNO c\WOU VK]^SâSX cKZ¾]¾X¾ LYdKMKâ¾XNKX `O VK]^SâS U_VVKX¾VKWKd RKVO ]YUKMKâ¾XNKX K]VK ZK^VKW¾À LS\ VK]^SUVO cYVK NO`KW ONSVWOWOVSNS\ CONOU VK]^SâSXSdS ^KU^¾U^KX ]YX\K VK]^SU ^KWS\S UYX_]_XNK _dWKX LS\ VK]^SU ]O\`S]SXNO dK\K\ Q\OX VK]^SU SXMOVOXWOVS ^K- 46 WS\S WWUX S]O ^KWS\ ONSVWOVSNS\ ,_\KNK OX XOWVS R_]_] VK]^SâSX _dWKX USÀSVO\MO SXMOVOXWO]S ]YX_M_XNK OU]SU]Sd LS\ SXMOVOWO cKZ¾VN¾U^KX ]YX\K ^KWS\ ONSVSZ ONSVOWOcOMOâSXO UK\K\ `O\SVWO]SNS\ ¿OUSVNO WK`S \OXU SVO Q]^O\SVOX ]¾\^ LVQO]SXNOX RK]K\ Q\WÀ VK]^SUVO\ ]^KXNK\^ dOVVSUVO WKX^K\ cKWK cX^OWS U_VVKXK\KU ^KWS\ ONSVWOVSNS\ kYâ_ VK]^SU ZK^VKâ¾ vS`S NOVSâS cK NK 6K]^SU R¾d ]OWLYV 2 UW]KK^ `O KV^¾ S]O NOVSU vKZ¾ KdKWS WW `O VK]^SU NKRK XMO ^KWS\ ONSVWOWSÀ S]O OâS^SWVS LS\ USÀS ^K\KP¾XNKX ^KWS\ ONSVOLSVS\ WWNOX QOXSÀ NOVSUVS VK]^SUVO\ cK NK cKXKU^KUS NOVSUVO\ ^KWS\ ONSVWOWOVSNS\ 6SXOO\ ^KLKUKNK ^_LOVO]] VK]^SUVO\NO YVKX `O RK`K ]¾dN¾\WKdV¾â¾ ]KâVKcKX ^KLKUK vK^VKWK `O UO]SVWO U¾\¾VWK `O ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý SÀK\O^VOXWOVS CKWKX¾X NKRK ScS cKZ¾ÀWK]¾ SvSX VK]^SâSX SvS d¾WZK\KcVK ^OWSdVOXWO]S QO\OUVSNS\ >KWS\NO ^OWSdVSU vYU XOWVSNS\ CK\K ^KWS\ WKVdOWO]S ]KNOMO ^OWSd cdOcO cKZ¾À¾\ CK\K LVQO]SXSX Sv^OX N¾À^KX UYXSU LS\ d¾WZK\K ^KÀ¾cVK ScSMO ^OWSdVOXWO]S `O cK\K SvSXNOUS ]O\LO]^ UKVKX vOVSU U_ÀKU ^OV _vVK\¾X¾X OVWK] _vV_ LS\ WK^UKZVK KV¾XWK]¾ QO\OUS\ ,_ SÀVOW ScS cKZ¾VWKd]K SVO\NO vOVSU U_ÀKU _vVK\¾ vKV¾ÀWK cKZK\KU ZK]VKXKLSVS\ `O cK\K ^KWS\ WKVdOWO]SXO RK]K\ `O\O\OU VK]^SâS RSdWO^ N¾À¾ L¾\KUKLSVS\ .KRK ]YX\K VK]^SâSX ^KWS\ ONSVOMOâS LVQOcO dOV cKZ¾À^¾\¾M¾ ]\VZ LS\UKv NKUSUK U_\_WKcK L¾\KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ KÀ¾\¾ NOPY\WK]cYX `K\]K ^KWS\ cKZ¾VWKWKV¾ `O VK]^SU UO]SXVSUVO cOXS]ScVO NOâSÀ^S\SVWOVSNS\ 6K]^SâSX ZK^VKWK]¾ SVO LO\KLO\ RK`K]¾ LYÀKV¾\ .YVKc¾]¾ SVO TKX^ cO\O LK]K\ L_ N_\_WNK K\Kv RK\OUO^ O^^S\SVS\ S]O TKX^ dO\SXNO c\X\]O VK]^SU U_VVKX¾VKWKd RKVO QOVOMOU^S\ #"VS c¾VVK\¾X LKÀ¾XK UKNK\ ZK^VKcKX VK]^SUVO\ Sv VK]^SUVO\NOX UO]SVOX ZK\vKVK\¾X ]¾MKU ^ _cQ_VKWK]¾cVK cKZ¾À^¾\¾VWK]¾cVK YXK\¾V¾cY\N_ =YX\KUS c¾VVK\NK Sv VK]^SU ZK\vKVK\¾X¾X cO\SXS U_ÀSXQKW KN¾ `O\SVOX RKd¾\ UK_v_U UK\¾À¾W ^KLKUKVK\NKX UO]SVOX ZK\vKVK\K L¾\KU¾\UOX NKRK ]YX\K NK VK]^SU ^KWS\S SvSX dOV YVK\KU \O^SVOX Y`KV NKS\O `OcK NSUN\^QOX PY\WV_ cKWKVK\ U_VVKX¾VWKcK LKÀVKXN¾ nXMOVO\S ]KNOMO ]¾MKU YVK\KU _cQ_VKXKLSVOX L_ cKWKVK\ QOVSÀ^S\SVO\OU ]Yâ_U U_VVKX¾WK NK _cQ_X RKVO QO^S\SVNS 6K]^SU YXK\¾W¾XNKUS L_ QOVSÀWOVO\ WKX^K\ cKWK KN¾ `O\SVOX `O ]Yâ_U YVK\KU _cQ_VKXKX WYNO\X cKWKVK\VK QXWdNO VK]^SU \O^SMSVO\SXS NO XO\NSâS YXK- \¾W ÀOUVSXS KVN¾ 7KX^K\ cKWK RKVOX ^W NXcKNK VK]^SU \O^SMSVO\S ^K\KP¾XNKX LSXOU K\KvVK\¾X VK]^SU ^KWS\SXNO XO\SVOX `O UKL_V ONSVOX ^OU ]S]^OW YVK\KU UK\À¾W¾dK v¾UWKU^KN¾\ ,_ ]¾\KNK VK]^SâSX ^KWS\S SvSX NOVSâSX LcUVâ `O ÀOUVSXO _cQ_X WKX^K\ cKWKX¾X ]OvSVWO]S QO\OUVSNS\ >KWS\ WKVdOWO]SXSX U_VVKX¾VKMKâ¾ cO\NOUS UK_- >OUO\VOU K\Kv^KX VK]^SU TKX^^KX ]UV\ 6K]^SâSX ZK^VKWK]¾XK XONOX YVKX ]OLOZ ^O]ZS^ ONSVO\OU VK]^SU ^KWS\ ONSVOLSVOMOU ]¾X¾\VK\ SvO\S]SXNO S]O ^KWS\ ONSVWO KÀKWK]¾XK QOvSVS\ :K^VKWKcK ]OLOZ YVKX UO]SMS `OcK NOVSMS MS]SW ¿OUSVNO Q\VNâ QSLS _cQ_X LS\ ZOX]O cK\N¾W¾cVK v¾UK\^¾VWKV¾ `O L_ LVQO SÀK\O^VOXWOVSNS\ >KWS\SX cKZ¾VKLSVWO]S SvSX NOVSXOX U¾]W¾X U_\_ YVWK]¾ QO\OUVSNS\ ,_ ^OWSX ONSVNSU^OX ]YX\K cK\KX¾X O^\KP¾ LS\ ^OV P¾\vK d¾WZK\K ^\Z `OcK UO]SMS LS\ KVO^ SVO SZVSUVO\ `O ^OVVO\ dK\K\ `O\WONOX ^OWSdVOXS\ .OVSU O^\KP¾XNK YXK\¾VKWKcKMKU LS\ Q`NO cK\K]¾X¾X YV_Z YVWKN¾â¾ UYX^\YV ONSVS\ 6K]^SU^OUS NOVSU WKX^K\ cKWKcK _cQ_X YVK\KU QOXSÀVO^SVWOVS 2K]K\V¾ LVQOXSX dO\SXNO cKWKX¾X UKZVKcKMKâ¾ cO\ v_UVK UO]SXVSUVO LOXdO\ dOVVSUVO\ ^KÀ¾WK]¾ QO\OUS\ /âO\ U_VVKX¾VKX WKVdOWO UK_v_U O]K]V¾ NOâSV]O O]XOWO]S QO\SVWO]S `O VK]^SU LXcO]SXNO YV_ÀKX ¾]¾cK ^OZUS dOVVSâS PK\UV¾ YVKMKâ¾XNKX Kc\¾VWK cKZKLSVS\ CK\KX¾X LcUVâXO Q\O ¿OUSV·NO Q\VOX _cQ_X WKX^K\ cKWKVK\NKX LS\S ]OvSVWOVSNS\ ?cQ_X WKX^K\ cKWK ]OvSVNSU^OX ]YX\K cKWKX¾X cKZ¾ÀUKX U¾]W¾XNKUS UY\_c_M_ ^KLKUK v¾UK\¾VK\KU WKX^K\ cKWKX¾X _v U¾]W¾ VK]^SâSX Sv U¾]W¾XNKX QOvS\SVWOVS WKX^K\ cKWKX¾X cdOcSXO OV NOâNS\WONOX `O _v U¾]¾W NOVSU SvSX- 47 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý NOXScVO vOVSU ^OVVO\SX U¾\¾VKLSVWO]S `O ^KLKX UKcWK]¾ NOXSVOX N_\_W_X Y\^KcK v¾UWK]¾ o]^OVSU PS^SVSX NOVSâS ^KW YVK\KU UKZK^WKWK]¾ `O VK]^SU LK]¾XM¾X¾ UY\_cKX VSXOO\ ^KLKUKcK cKZ¾ÀWKWK]¾ VK]^SU SvSXNOUS RK`K `O XOWSX U_ÀKUVK\K QOvWO]ScVO NO Kc\¾VWK `O ^KLKXNK ÀOUSV LYd_UV_UVK\¾ WOcNKXK QOVScY\ +c\¾MK PS^SVVO cKZ¾VKX ^KWS\ ]¾\K]¾XNK VK]^SU TKX^^KX v¾UK\¾VWKN¾â¾ SvSX VK]^SâSX Sv cdOcSXNO WOcNKXK QOVWSÀ YVKLSVOMOU NSâO\ c¾\^¾U cK NK RK]K\VK\ Q\VOWONSâSXNOX ^ORVSUO ]\cY\ ¿OUSVNO Q\VNâ QSLS PS^SV cKWK K\KdS ÀK\^VK\¾XNK NKRS VK]^SâO UYVKcMK _cQ_VKXKLSVWOU^ONS\ NOX QOvS\SVO\OU ^KLKX cdOcSXNOX v¾UKX U¾]¾W ÀOUSV NO Q\VNâ QSLS LS\ ZOX]O cK\N¾W¾cVK ScSMO QO\SVSXMOcO UKNK\ vOUSVWOVS LcVOMO cKWKX¾X ^KW YVK\KU Y^_\WK]¾ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ 7KX^K\ cKWK _cQ_X LS\ ZOX]O cK\N¾W¾ SVO N¾ÀK NYâ\_ vOUSVO\OU VK]^SâSX cKWKcK Y^_\WK]¾ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ CKWKX¾X VK]^SâSX Sv U¾]W¾XNK YVKX LVW Y\^KNKX LKÀVKWKU UKcN¾cVK LS\ \_VY cK\N¾W¾cVK OdSVO\OU cKZ¾À^¾\¾V¾cY\ >KWS\ SÀVOWSXNOUS ]YX KÀKWKc]K cKWKX¾X N¾ÀK\¾NK UKVKX _M_X_X UO]SVWO]SNS\ ,cVOMO YXK\¾W¾ ^KWKWVKXKX VK]^SU LKVKX] KcK\¾ cKZ¾VN¾U^KX ]YX\K Y^YWYLSVO ^KU¾VWKcK RKd¾\ RKVO QOVWOU^ONS\ 6çUWæYHæ<DQDNæ%|OJHVLQGHNLæ %\Næ7DPLUDWODU ,cU OLK^V¾ cYV N¾À¾ RSdWO^ VK]^SUVO\S vYU ZKRKV¾ YVN_â_ SvSX OX XOWVS RK\MKWK UKVOWVO\S K\K]¾XNK cO\ KVWKU^KN¾\ CYV N¾À¾ VK]^SUVO\ YVN_UvK cK`KÀ `O ndOV vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK U_VVKX¾VN¾â¾ SvSX ^KWS\K^¾ NK dOVVSUVO\ ^KÀ¾WKU^KN¾\ ,_ ^\ ^KWS\K^VK\ ¿OUSVNO Q\VNâ QSLS XMOVSUVO L^X U¾\¾VW¾À QO`ÀOWSÀ UY\N `OcK vOVSU ^OVVO\ ^¾\KÀVKXK\KU ^OWSdVOXO\OU cO^USVS ]O\`S]VO\SX _cQ_X Q\OMOâS SXMO LS\ ^KWS\ UK_v_â_ SVO NYVN_\_VWKV¾N¾\ >KWS\K^ cKZ¾VKWKcKMKU YVKX LVQO]SXSX ^YZVKW _d_XV_â_ VK]^SU OLKN¾XK Q\O WW K\K]¾XNK NOâSÀS\ 6K]^SâSX Sv U¾]W¾XK ¿OUSVNO Q\VOX ^KWS\ WKVdOWOVO\S _cQ_VKX¾\ ,_ ^\ WKVdOWOVO\ LS\vYU \KcYX UK^VK\NKX YV_À^_â_ SvSX U_VVKX¾VWK O]XK]¾XNK dO\SXNOUS YU SÀK\O^SXO NSUUK^ ONO\OU _cQ_VKXWKV¾N¾\ =KNOMO KMSV N_\_WVK\NK `O WOML_\ScO^ RKVSXNO U_VVKX¾VWK]¾ QO\OUOX PS^SVVS YXK\¾W¾X SÀSX _dWKX¾ LS\ VK]^SU ^KWS\MS]S L_V_XN_â_XNK ^OWSdVO^SVSZ cO\SXO WKX^K\ cKWK SVO cOXSVOXWOVSNS\ +MSV N_\_WVK\ N¾À¾XNK PS^SV SVO VK]^SU ^KWS\K^¾ cKZ¾VWKWKV¾N¾\ ½VU P¾\]K^^K PS^SV cKWK WKX^K\ cKWK SVO cOXSVOXWOVSNS\ $FLOæ'XUXPGDæ)LWLOæìOHæ<DSçODQæ*HoLFLæ/DVWLNæ7DPLUDWç ½v VK]^SUVS Y^YWYLSV VK]^SUVO\SXSX cO\SXS \O^SVOX L^X Y^YWYLSV WYNOVVO\SXNO ^_LOVO]] VK]^SUVO\O L¾\KUWK]¾cVK VK]^SU ^KWS\SXNO PS^SVVS YXK\¾W cX^OWS _cQ_VKXWKcK LKÀVKN¾ /UYXYWSU YVWK]¾ `O vKL_U _cQ_VKXKLSVWO]ScVO \KâLO^ Q\O\OU cKcQ¾X YVK\KU U_VVKX¾VWKcK LKÀVKXKX PS^SVVS YXK\¾W cX^OWS PS^SVSX VK]^SU dO\SXNOUS NOVSâO cO\VOÀ^S\SVWO]S O]K]¾XK NKcKXWKU^KN¾\ ¿OUSVNO Q\VOX ^KWS\ US^VO\S SVO UYVKcMK _cQ_VKXKLSVWOU^ONS\ 0S^SVS VK]^SU dO\SXNOUS NOVSâO QOvS\WONOX XMO WK^UKZ _M_ cK NK ^Y\XK`SNK QSLS ]S`\S _vV_ LS\ KVO^VO NOVSU LVQO]S QOXSÀVO^SVNSâSXNOX OX XOWVS RK^K NK L_ KÀKWKNK cKZ¾V¾cY\ 1OXSÀVO^WO vKV¾ÀWK]¾ ]¾\K]¾XNK U_ÀKU^KUS vOVSU ^OVVO\SX _vVK\¾ KV¾XWKN¾â¾XNKX NOVSU vO`\O]SXNOUS ^Yd `O XOW PS^SVVO LS\VSU^O VK]^SâSX SvSXO QS\ScY\ ,_ XOWVOXWOXSX OX `KRSW ]YX_M_c]K SVO\VOcOX NXOWNO ^OVVO\NOUS ZK]VKXWK XO- 2QDUçOPDPDVçæ*HUHNHQæ /DVWLNOHU 6K]^SUVO\SX cKXKUVK\¾XNK YV_ÀW_À LKVYXVK\ cK NK NOVSUVO\ YXK\¾VWKWK]¾ QO\OUOX RK]K\VK\¾X LKÀ¾XNK QOVWOU^ONS\ kYU U¾]K ]\O SvSX LSVO YV]K ZK^VKW¾À VK]^SâSX dO\SXNO RK`K]¾d YVK\KU SVO\VOXWO]S UK\UK]^KUS UY\N SZVSUVO\SXO dK\K\ `O\OLSVScY\ >_LOVO]] VK]^SUVO\NO RK`K ]¾dN¾\WKdV¾â¾ ]KâVKcKX VSXOO\ ^KLKUKNK vK^VKWK `OcK UO]SVWO UK\UK]^K c¾\^¾VWK `OcK Kc\¾VWK ^YZ_U^K UO]SVWO U¾\¾VWK `O KÀ¾\¾ NOPY\WK]cYX WOcNKXK QOVWSÀ]O VK]^SâSX UO]SXVSUVO cOXS]ScVO NOâSÀ^S\SVWO]S QO\OUWOU^ONS\ ,_ UYX_NK cKÀKW Q`OXVSâS ]d UYX_]_ YVN_â_ SvSX K\Kv ]KRSLSXSX NO SXS]ScK^SP U_VVKXWK]¾ QO\OUVSNS\ 6K]^SâSX NSÀ NO\SXVSâS WSXSW_W NSÀ NO\SXVSâS YVKX WW·XSX KV^¾XK NÀWÀ S]O UO]SXVSUVO ^KWS\ ONSVWOWOVS cOXS]S SVO NOâSÀ^S\SVWOVSNS\ ¿OUSVNO Q\VOX ^KWS\ VSWS^VO\SXS KÀKX ]¾\^ K\¾dKVK\¾ cKXKU `O ^YZ_U·^K YV_ÀKX K\¾dKVK\ SVO dO\SXNO c\XOX VK]^SUVO\ ^KWS\ ONSVWOWOVSNS\ 2UKDQæ*(5('(/ì2è/8 0DNLQDæ<NVHNæ0KHQGLVL 48 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Rengine *|UHæ<DéçQæ Durumunu 'HéHUOHQGLUPHN <DéæGHéLëLPæGXUXPXQXæDQODPDNæLoLQæUHQNæWDEORVX 5HQNæWDEORVXæLOHæNç\DODPDæLPNDQçæEXOXQPX\RUVDæELUæ|QFHæDOGçéçQç]æ\DéæQXPXQHVLæYHææYH\DæWHPL]æ\DéæQXPXQHVLæLOHæNç\DVOD\çQç] CKâ \OXQSXS LS\ MKW ^Z SvSXNO ¾À¾âK ^_^K\KU Q\OLSVS\]SXSd CKâ¾X \OXQS cYâ_XV_â_XK SvSXNO ]]ZKX]ScYX YVK\KU K]¾V¾ RKVNO L_V_XKX WKNNOVO\O LKâV¾ YVK\KU \OXU PK\UV¾V¾UVK\¾ Q]^O\S\ ,_ PK\UV¾ \OXUVO\NOX YV_ÀKX \OXU ^KcP¾ U¾cK]VKWK \OPO\KX]¾ YVK\KU U_VVKX¾V¾\ 5_VVKX¾VWKW¾À cOXS cKâ¾X cU]OU `S]UYdS^O Y\KX¾ XONOXS SVO cKâ¾X NYâKV \OXQSXS Q\OLSVS\Sd 8KP^KXSU LKdV¾ cU]OU ]VP\V K\YWK^SUVO\ SvO\OX cKâVK\¾X \OXQS NKRK UYc_N_\ 5_VVKX¾VKX cKâVK\¾X US\VOXWO]S `O `S]UYdS^O]SXSX NOâSÀWO]S \OXU NOâSÀSWS `O ]KcNKW Q\X^]XX UKcLYVWK]¾ ÀOUVSXNO Y\^KcK v¾UK\ 52 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 7Y^Y\_X cKXWK YNK]¾XNK Y\^KcK v¾UKX cU]OU ¾]¾ `O UK\LYX vdOV^SVO\S XONOXS SVO cKâ UK\K\¾\ +c\¾MK PK\UV¾ dOVVSUVO\NO cKâ OUVOXWO]S RKVSXNO cKNK NSâO\ UK^U¾VK\ XONOXS SVO NO cKâ¾X \OXQS UYc_VKÀKLSVS\ +c\¾MK cKâNK L_V_XKX NO^O\TKX UK^U¾VK\¾X¾X v¾UKX U_\_W_ `O ^OWK] O^^SâS RK`KNKUS K]¾V¾ ZK\vKM¾UVK\¾ ^YZVKWK]¾ ]YX_M_ NK \OXU NOâSÀSWS `O cKâ¾X ZK\VKUV¾â¾X¾X UKcLYVWK]¾ ]d UYX_]_ YVKMKU^¾\ 1XOÀ ¾À¾XVK\¾XK NYâ\_NKX WK\_d UKVKX cKâVK\ ?@ _V^\K`SYVO ¾À¾XVK\¾X¾X XONOX YVN_â_ PY^YUK^KVS^SU \OKU]ScYXVK KÀ¾\¾ \OXU NOâSÀSWSXO _â\K\ 2NVLWOHQHQæ\DéæQDVçOæNDUDUçU" CKâNK \OXU NOâSÀSWS `O UK\K\WKX¾X ]¾UvK \K]^VKXKX XONOXS cKâ¾X YU]S^VOXWO]SNS\ CU]OU ]VP\V K\YWK^SUVO\ SvO\OX cKâVK\NK \OXU NOâSÀSWS NKRK UYVKc PK\U ONSVS\ CU]OU ¾]¾VK\NK YV_ÀKX YU]S^VOXWOVO\VO K\YWK^SUVO\ `O ]VP\ LSVOÀOXVO\S K\K]¾XNK cKâ dOVVSUVO\SXS LYdWKcK cXOVSU LS\ ]SXO\TS `K\N¾\ ,_NK \OXU NOâSÀSWSXS Y\^KcK v¾UK\¾\ <DéçQæUHQJLQLQæGHéLëPHVL 9VKâKX N¾À¾ \OXU NOâSÀSWS vYâ_XV_UVK cKâ¾X LYd_VN_â_X_X OX ScS Q]^O\QO]SNS\ CKZ¾VKX K\KÀ^¾\WKVK\NK KÀ¾\¾ UYc_ \OXUVS cKâVK\¾X # ¶¾X¾X S]^OXOX dOVVSUVO\SXS UKcLO^WSÀ YVN_â_ KXVKÀ¾VW¾À^¾\ +XMKU LKd¾ N_\_WVK\NK UYc_ \OXU cKâ¾X LYd_VN_â_X_ Q]^O\WOcOLSVS\ ,_X_X Kc\¾W¾XK `K\KLSVWOU SvSX NdOXVS K\KV¾UVK\VK cKâ KXKVSdS cKZ¾VWK]¾ QO\OU^SâS ^OM\LOVO\VO S]ZK^VKXW¾À^¾\ <DéæUHQJLQLQæNR\XODëPDVçæUHQNæGHéLëLPL 2NVLWOHQPHæ ,VçVDOæ'HéLëLPæ .LUOLOLN $VçOæQHGHQæ =VP\ LSVOÀOXVO\SX K]S^O NXÀW 2K`K UKLK\M¾UVK\¾ cU]OV cdOc]OV ¾]¾ 5K\¾À¾U cKâ UY]^SU NO^O\TKXVK\ USWcK]KVVK\ 'RéUXODPDæWHVWL 0>3< ]VPK^VKWK >+8 `S]UYdS^O 0>3< XS^\K^VKWK ]K`\_VWK cKWK ^O]^S /VOWOX^ KXKVSdS 0>3< `S]UYdS^O 7HUFPHææ0æ*QG]æ$7(ê ì00% .D\QDNææ0DFKLQHU\æ/XEULFDWLRQ 53 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 0DNLQDODUçQæ7DVDUçPçæYHæêPDOLæLOHæ êOJLOLæ7HPHOæ6DéOçNæYHæ*YHQOLNæ .XUDOODUçæ æ6D\çQçQæGHYDPç ´7KUSXKVK\¾X _]_VXO _cQ_X ÀOUSVNO U_\_VN_â_XNK LKU¾W¾ cKZ¾VN¾â¾XNK `O UOXNSXNOX LOUVOXOX KWKvVK\ NYâ\_V^_]_XNK U_VVKX¾VN¾â¾XNK SX]KX ]KâV¾â¾XK `O Q`OXVSâSXO `O N_\_W_XK Q\O O`MSV RKc`KXVK\K `O WKVVK\K dK\K\ `O\WScY\]K ZScK]KcK K\d ONSVWOVO\SXS `O RSdWO^O ]_X_VWKVK\¾X¾ ^OWSXOX ^K]K\¾W `O SWKVK^ KÀKWK]¾XNK _c_VWK]¾ QO\O- UOX ^OWOV OWXScO^ ÀK\^VK\¾ SVO ^KUSZ ONSVWO]S QO\OUOX _cQ_XV_U NOâO\VOXNS\WO Z\Y]ON\VO\SXS `O _cQ_XV_U NOâO\VOXNS\WO]S cKZKMKU YXKcVKXW¾À U_\_V_ÀVK\¾X Q\O`VOXNS\SVWO]SXNO NSUUK^O KV¾XKMKU K]QK\S U\S^O\VO\S NdOXVOWOUµ +WKM¾ SVO =KXKcS `O >SMK\O^ ,KUKXV¾â¾·X¾X # ^K\SR `O !" ]Kc¾V¾ \O]WS QKdO^ONO cKc¾WVKXKX ´7KUSXK /WXScO- æ%DNçPææ æ0DNLQDODUçQæEDNçPç +cK\ `O LKU¾W XYU^KVK\¾ ^ORVSUO LVQOVO\SXSX N¾À¾XK cO\VOÀ^S\SVWSÀ YVWKV¾N¾\ +cK\ LKU¾W YXK\¾W ^OWSdVSU `O ]O\`S] SÀVOWVO\S WKUSXK N_\_cY\UOX cKZ¾VKLSVWOVSNS\ >OUXSU XONOXVO\VO c_UK\¾ ÀK\^VK\NKX LS\SXS cK NK NKRK PKdVK]¾X¾ cO\SXO QO^S\WOU WWUX YVKW¾cY\]K L_ SÀVOWVO\SX Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO cKZ¾VKLSVWO]S SvSX ^ONLS\VO\ KV¾XWKV¾N¾\ X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KPK LKU¾VWKV¾N¾\ 9^YWK^SU WKUSXKVK\NK `O QO\OU^SâSXNO NSâO\ WKUSXKVK\NK K\¾dK ^OÀRS] MSRKd¾ ^KU¾VWK]¾ SvSX LS\ LKâVKX^¾ ^O\^SLK^¾ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ =¾UvK NOâSÀ^S\SVWO]S QO\OUOX Y^YWK^SU WKUSXK KU]KWVK- 56 ^S CXO^WOVSâSµXSX ]OU^\Wd NYâ\_NKX SVQSVOXNS\OX ]OU^\ vKV¾ÀKXVK\¾W¾dMK LSVSXWO]S QO\OUOX /U ´7KUSXKVK\¾X ^K]K\¾W¾ `O SWKVS SVO SVQSVS ^OWOV ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSU U_\KVVK\¾µ U¾]W¾X¾ ]SdVO\VO ZKcVKÀWKU S]^ONSU ½VU LVWX # ]Kc¾NK `O\NSâSWSd cXO^WOVSâSX SUSXMS U¾]W¾X¾ cKc¾XV¾cY\_d ì00%æ \¾ UYVKc `O Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]UVZ ^KU¾VKLSVWOVSNS\ ,_ KU]KWVK\K O\SÀSW LOVS\^SVOX LS\ vKV¾ÀWK cX^OWSXO _cQ_X YVK\KU L_ Q\O`VO\SX QO\OUVS ^OUXSU K\KvVK\VK cKZ¾VKLSVWO]SXO SWUrX ^KX¾WKV¾N¾\ ædDOçëPDæNRQXPODUçQDæYHæVHUYLVæQRNWDODUçQDæHULëLPææ 7KUSXKVK\ WKUSXKVK\¾X vKV¾ÀWK]¾ KcK\VKWK]¾ `O LKU¾W¾ O]XK]¾XNK WNKRKVOXSX QO\OUVS YVKX L^X KVKXVK\¾XK Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO O\SÀSWSXO SWUrX `O\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\VKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ æ(QHUMLæND\QDNODUçQçQæ\DOçWçOPDVçææ 7KUSXKVK\ L^X OXO\TS UKcXKUVK\¾XNKX cKV¾^¾W¾ ]KâVKXKMKU ÀOUSVNO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ ,_ ^\ cKV¾^¾M¾VK\ SdYVK^\VO\ Kv¾U LS\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ÀOUSVNO ^KX¾WVKXWKV¾N¾\ COXSNOX LKâVKX^¾ USÀSVO\ dO\SXNO LS\ ^ORVSUO YV_À^_\KMKU]K L_XVK\ USVS^VOXOLSVS\ ^K\dNK YVWKV¾N¾\VK\ CKV¾^¾M¾VK\ YZO\K^\X O\SÀOLSVNSâS RO\RKXQS LS\ XYU^KNKX OXO\TSXSX RKVK UO]SU YVN_â_X_ UYX^\YV O^WO SWUrX¾ L_V_XWKWK]¾ N_\_W_XNK NK USVS^VOXOLSVWOVSNS\ ,S\ OVOU^\SU UKcXKâ¾XK PSÀVO ^KU¾VKLSVOX WKUSXKVK\ SvSX YZO\K^\X O\SÀOLSVNSâS RO\ XYU^KNK OVOU^\SU PSÀSXSX Z\SdNOX vOUSVS YVN_â_X_ UYX^\YV ONOLSVWO]S UYÀ_V_cVK PSÀSX Z\SdNOX vOUSVWO]S cO^O\VSNS\ /XO\TS UO]SVNSU^OX ]YX\K WKUSXKVK\¾X NO`\OVO\SXNO XY\WKV YVK\KU UKVKX `OcK NOZYVKXKX OXO\TS USÀSVO\O \S]U YV_À^_\WKcKMKU ÀOUSVNO cYU ONSVOLSVWOVSNS\ nXMOUS P¾U\KVK\NK LOVS\^SVOX ÀK\^K LS\ S]^S]XK YVK\KU \XOâSX ZK\vKVK\¾ ^_^WKU LSVQScS UY\_WKU Sv U¾]W¾X KcN¾XVK^¾VWK]¾ QSLS XONOXVO\VO LKd¾ NO`\OVO\ OXO\TS UKcXKâ¾XK LKâV¾ UKVKLSVS\ ,_ N_\_WNK YZO\K^\X Q`OXVSâSXS ]KâVKWKcK cXOVSU dOV XVOWVO\ KV¾XWKV¾N¾\ æ2SHUDW|UQæPGDKDOHVLææ 7KUSXKVK\ YZO\K^\X WNKRKVO]SXO SR^ScKv ]¾X¾\V¾ YVKMKU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ SWKV ONSVWOVS `O ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ 9ZO\K^\X WNKRKVO]S UKv¾X¾VWKd]K L_ WNKRKVOVO\ UYVKcMK `O Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO cKZ¾VKLSVWOVSNS\ æ'DKLOLæSDUoDODUçQæWHPL]OHQPHVLææ 7KUSXKVK\ ^ORVSUOVS WKNNO cK NK Z\OZK\K^ SR^S`K O^WSÀ NKRSVS ZK\vKVK\ SvO\S QS\WONOX ^OWSdVOXOLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\% LVYUKT¾X UKVN¾\¾VWK]¾ QO\OUVS YVN_â_XNK L_ SÀVOW NO N¾ÀK\¾NKX cKZ¾VKLSVWOVSNS\ 7KUSXKX¾X SvSXO QS\WOU UKv¾X¾VWKd SO WKUSXK ^OWSdVSU SÀVOWS Q`OXVS LS\ LSvSWNO cKZ¾VKLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ æ%LOJLOHQGLUPHææ æ0DNLQDæ]HULQGHNLæELOJLæYHæX\DUçODU 7KUSXKVK\ dO\SXNO cO\ KVKX LSVQS `O _cK\¾VK\ ^O\MSROX RrVSRKd¾\NK UYVKcMK KXVKÀ¾VKLSVOX ]OWLYV `OcK ÀOWKVK\NKX YV_ÀWKV¾N¾\ 2O\RKXQS LS\ cKd¾V¾ `OcK ]dOV LSVQS `O _cK\¾VK\ >\UvO RKd¾\VKXWKV¾N¾\ æ%LOJLOHQGLUPHæYHæELOJLOHQGLUPHæWHUWLEDWODUçææ 7KUSXKX¾X U_WKXNK]¾ SVO SVQSVS SR^ScKv N_c_VKX LSVQSVO\ LOVS\]SdVSâO cO\ `O\WOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO `O UYVKc KXVKÀ¾VKX LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ ,_XVK\ YZO\K^\ KÀ¾\¾ cY\KMKU NO\OMONO PKdVK YVWKWKV¾N¾\ 1\X^V OU\KXVK\ `OcK WKUSXK SVO YZO\K^\ K\K]¾XNKUS NSâO\ SX^O\KU^SP SVO^SÀSW K\KvVK\¾ UYVKcMK KXVKÀ¾VKLSVWOVS `O U_VVKX¾W¾ UYVKc YVWKV¾N¾\ æ8\DUçæWHUWLEDWODUçææ 7KUSXKVK\¾X NOXO^SW]Sd LS\ ÀOUSVNO vKV¾À¾\UOX WOcNKXK QO- VOLSVOMOU LS\ RK^K ]YX_M_XNK USÀSVO\SX ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSâSXSX ^ORVSUOcO QS\OLSVOMOâS N_\_WVK\NK WKUSXKVK\ _cK\¾ YVK\KU _cQ_X LS\ ]O] `OcK ¾À¾U ]SXcKVS `O\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ 7KUSXKVK\ _cK\¾ ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWO]S N_\_W_XNK L_ ^O\^SLK^VK\ LOVS\QSX YVWKV¾ `O UYVKcMK KVQ¾VKXKLSVWOVSNS\ 9ZO\K^\ RO\ dKWKX L_ ^\ _cK\¾ ^O\^SLK^VK\¾X vKV¾ÀWK]¾X¾ UYX^\YV ONOMOU SWUrXVK\K ]KRSZ YVWKV¾N¾\ <OXUVO\ `O Q`OXVSU ]SXcKVVO\S SVO SVQSVS cXO^WOVSUVO\SX ÀK\^VK\¾XK _c_VWKV¾N¾\ æ*LGHULOHPH\HQæULVNOHUOHææLOJLOLæX\DUçODUææ CKZ¾]KV Q`OXVS ^K]K\¾W ^ONLS\VO\SXO _cQ_VKXKX UY\_c_M_ `O ^KWKWVKc¾M¾ UY\_WK ^ONLS\VO\SXO \KâWOX \S]UVO\SX QSNO\SVOWONSâS N_\_WVK\NK _cK\¾ ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ NKRSV YVWKU dO\O QO\OUVS _cK\¾VK\ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ æ0DNLQDODUçQæLëDUHWOHQPHVLææ ,^X WKUSXKVK\ KÀKâ¾NKUS K]QK\S dOVVSUVO\ Qd XXNO ^_^_VK\KU Q\X\ YU_X_\ `O ]SVSXOWOd LS\ ÀOUSVNO SÀK\O^VOXWOVSNS\$ ½WKVK^v¾X¾X `O SVQSVS YVN_â_XNK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]SXSX ^SMK\S _X`KX¾ `O ^KW KN\O]S 7KUSXKX¾X ^KX¾W¾ -/ ½ÀK\O^VOWO]S /U 333 =O\S `OcK ^SZ ^KX¾WVKWK]¾ @K\]K ]O\S X_WK\K]¾ ½WKVK^ c¾V¾ cKXS SWKVr^ SÀVOWSXSX ^KWKWVKXN¾â¾ c¾V 7KUSXKcK -/ SÀK\O^S SVSÀ^S\SVS\UOX ^K\SR XO `OcK SVO\ScO KV¾XKWKd ,_X_X cKX¾ ]¾\K W_R^OWOV ZK^VKc¾M¾ Y\^KWVK\NK U_VVKX¾VWKU dO\O ^K]K\¾WVKXW¾À `O SWKV ONSVWSÀ WKUSXKVK\ L_XK Q\O SÀK\O^VOXWOVSNS\ 7KUSXKVK\ ^SZS `O Q`OXVS U_VVKX¾W SvSX O]K] YVKX L^X LSVQSVO\S NO ^KÀ¾WKV¾N¾\ ,_ ^SZ LSVQSVO\ ! X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP^K `O\SVOX U_\KVVK\NK OVO KV¾XW¾À^¾\ 7KUSXK ZK\vKVK\¾X¾X UKVN¾\WK OUSZWKX¾ SVO U_VVKX¾VK\KU SÀVOW Q\WO]S RKVSXNO L_XVK\¾X U^VO]S YU_X_\ ]SVSXWOd `O LOVS\QSX YVK\KU Q]^O\SVWOVSNS\ æ7DOLPDWODUææ ,^X WKUSXKVK\NK >\UvO RKd¾\VKXW¾À ^KVSWK^VK\ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ 7KUSXKVK\¾X LO\KLO\SXNO cO\ KVKX ^KVSWK^VK\ cK ¶9\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\· YVWKV¾ cK NK Y\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\¾X >\UvO YVWKWK]¾ RKVSXNO ¶9\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\¾X ^O\MWO]S· YVWKV¾N¾\ L_ N_\_WNK Y\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\ NK vO`S\SVO\S SVO LS\VSU^O `O\SVWOVSNS\ ½]^S]XK YVK\KU SWKVr^v¾ `OcK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]S ^K\KP¾XNKX Q\O`VOXNS\SVOX _dWKX ZO\]YXOVSX U_VVKX¾W¾ KWKM¾cVK RKd¾\VKXKX LKU¾W ^KVSWK^VK\¾ >\UvOXSX cKX¾ ]¾\K _dWKX ZO\]YXOVSX KXVKcKLSVOMOâS >YZV_V_U NSVSXNO `O\SVOLSVS\ 57 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý >KVSWK^VK\ KÀKâ¾NK NdOXVOXOX SVUOVO\ NYâ\_V^_]_XNK RKd¾\VKXWKV¾N¾\ æ7DOLPDWODUçQæKD]çUODQPDVçæLOHæLOJLOLæJHQHOæLONHOHUææ D >KVSWK^VK\ >\UvO RKd¾\VKXWKV¾ Y\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\¾X LKÀUK LS\ NSVNO YVWK]¾ RKVSXNO LO\KLO\SXNO >\UvOcO vO`S\S]S cO\ KVWKV¾N¾\ ½WKVK^v¾ `OcK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]S ^K\KP¾XNKX NYâ\_VKXKX NSV `O\]ScYX_ `O\]ScYXVK\¾ dO\SXNO ¶9\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\· SLK\O]S Q\VWOVSNS\ E 7KUSXKVK\¾X U_VVKX¾VKMKâ¾ VUOXSX \O]WS NSVSNSVVO\SXNO ¶9\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\¾X· L_V_XWKN¾â¾ N_\_WVK\NK SWKVr^v¾ `OcK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]S `OcK L_ WKUSXKc¾ QO^S\OX USÀS ^K\KP¾XNKX ]d UYX_]_ LVQONOUS QOvO\VS NSVO vO`S\S ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ kO`S\S ¶9\STSXKV ^KVSWK^VK\¾X vO`S\S]S· SLK\O]SXS ^KÀ¾WKV¾N¾\ F >KVSWK^VK\¾X SvO\SâS cKVX¾dMK WKUSXKVK\¾X KWKvVKXKX U_VVKX¾WVK\¾X¾ NOâSV KcX¾ dKWKXNK WKU_V LS\ ÀOUSVNO XQ\VOLSVOX YVK]¾ cKXV¾À U_VVKX¾WVK\¾X¾ NK SvO\WOVSNS\ G :\YPO]cYXOV YVWKcKX YZO\K^\VO\ ^K\KP¾XNKX U_VVKX¾VWK]¾ NÀXVOX WKUSXKVK\ SvSX U_VVKX¾W ^KVSWK^VK\¾X¾X cKd¾VWK]¾ `O NdOXVOXWO]SXNO L_ ^\ YZO\K^\VO\NOX WKU_V YVK\KU LOUVOXOLSVOMOU QOXOV OâS^SW ]O`ScOVO\S `O cK\Q¾NK L_V_XKLSVWO NdOcVO\S NO Qd XXNO L_V_XN_\_VWKV¾N¾\ æ7DOLPDWODUçQæLoHULéLææ 2O\ LS\ U_VVKX¾M¾ OV US^KL¾ SVQSVS YVN_â_ ÀOUSVNO OX Kd¾XNKX KÀKâ¾NKUS LSVQSVO\S SvO\WOVSNS\$ D ½WKVK^v¾ `O cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]SXSX KN¾ `O ^KW KN\O]S E =O\S X_WK\K]¾ RK\Sv YVWKU dO\O WKUSXK dO\SXNO SÀK\O^VOXWSÀ RKVNO WKUSXKX¾X ^KX¾W¾ ! X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP F +> ?cQ_XV_U ,OcKX¾ `OcK +> ?cQ_XV_U ,OcKX¾ SvO\SâSXS Q]^O\OX WKUSXKX¾X dOVVSUVO\SXS `O\OX `O ]O\S X_WK\K]¾ `O SWdKX¾X L_V_XWK]¾X¾X QO\OUVS YVWKN¾â¾ LS\ LOVQO G 7KUSXKX¾X QOXOV ^K\SPS H 7KUSXKX¾X U_VVKX¾W LKU¾W `O YXK\¾W¾ `O NYâ\_ vKV¾À¾Z vKV¾ÀWKN¾â¾X¾X UYX^\YV SvSX QO\OUVS vSdSWVO\ ÀOWKVK\ ^K\SPVO\ `O Kv¾UVKWKVK\ I 9ZO\K^\VO\SX L_V_XKMKUVK\¾ W_R^OWOV SÀ S]^K]cYXVK\¾X¾X ^K\SPS N 7KUSXKX¾X RSdWO^O ]_X_VWKVK\¾ `O U_VVKX¾VWKVK\¾ SVO SVQSVS ^KVSWK^VK\ `O QO\OUVS S]O YZO\K^\VO\SX OâS^SWS SVO SVQSVS ^KVSWK^VK\ O CKZ¾]KV YVK\KU Q`OXVS ^K]K\¾W ^ONLS\VO\S UY\_WK `O _cQ_VKXKX ^KWKWVKc¾M¾ UY\_c_M_ ^ONLS\VO\O \KâWOX QSNO\SVOWOcOX \S]UVO\ RKUU¾XNK LSVQSVOXNS\WO P ?cQ_X YVKX N_\_WVK\NK USÀS]OV UY\_c_M_ OUSZWKX NK NKRSV YVWKU dO\O U_VVKX¾M¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX KV¾XWK]¾ QO\OUOX UY\_c_M_ ^ONLS\VO\ RKUU¾XNK ^KVSWK^VK\ Q7KUSXKcK ^KU¾VKLSVOMOU ^KU¾WVK\¾X ^OWOV UK\KU^O\S]^SUVO\S R 7KUSXKX¾X U_VVKX¾W XKUVScO WYX^KT RSdWO^ N¾À¾ SUOX ]UWO ^O]^ O^WO `O XQ\VOLSVS\ K\¾dKVK\ ]¾\K]¾XNK UK\K\V¾V¾U ÀK\^¾X¾ UK\À¾VKN¾â¾ UYÀ_VVK\ S >KÀ¾WK OVVOvVOWO `O NOZYVKWK SÀVOWVO\SXSX Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO cKZ¾VWK]¾X¾ ^OWSXOX WKUSXKX¾X `O `K\]K Kc\¾ YVK\KU ^KÀ¾XWK]¾ QO\OUOX ZK\vKVK\¾X¾X U^VO]SXS `O\OX ^KVSWK^VK\ T 5KdK `OcK K\¾dK N_\_W_XNK SdVOXOMOU vKV¾À^¾\WK cX^OWS% LVYUKT YV_À_W_ W_R^OWOV S]O OUSZWKX¾X Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO LVYUKTNKX U_\^K\¾VWK]¾ SvSX SdVOXOMOU vKV¾À^¾\WK cX^OWS U 5_VVKX¾M¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX cKZ¾VKMKU YVKX KcK\VKWK `O LKU¾W vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾X `O _c_VWK]¾ QO\OUOX UY\_c_M_ LKU¾W ^ONLS\VO\SXSX ^K\SPS V +cK\VKWK `O LKU¾W vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾X Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO cKZ¾VWK]¾ KWKM¾cVK ^K]K\VKXW¾À L_ SÀVOWVO\ ]¾\K]¾XNK KV¾XKMKU UY\_c_M_ ^ONLS\VO\S SvO\OX ^KVSWK^VK\ W 9ZO\K^\X ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSâSXS O^USVONSâS N_\_WVK\NK U_VVKX¾VKMKU cONOU ZK\vKVK\¾X dOVVSUVO\S X 2K`K SVO ^KÀ¾XKX Q\V^ OWS]cYXVK\¾ SVO SVQSVS KÀKâ¾NKUS LSVQSVO\$ ! N, +· c¾ KÀ¾cY\]K SÀ S]^K]cYXVK\¾XNKUS +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ OWS]cYX ]O] LK]¾Xv ]O`ScO]S% L_ NdOcSX ! N, +· c¾ KÀWKWK]¾ RKVSXNO LOVS\^SVWOVSNS\ :K·¾ KÀ¾cY\]K SÀ S]^K]cYXVK\¾XNKUS -Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ KXV¾U ^OZO ]O] LK]¾Xv NOâO\S :K·K Q\O N, ½À S]^K]cYXVK\¾XNKUS +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ OWS]cYX ]O] LK]¾Xv ]O`ScO]S " N , +· c¾ KÀ¾cY\]K WKUSXKX¾X cKcN¾â¾ +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ ]O] Qv ]O`ScO]S K 7KUSXKX¾X NOXOcSWVO\VO Y\^KcK v¾UWK]¾ W_R^OWOV YVN_â_ ^O]ZS^ ONSVOX cKXV¾À U_VVKX¾W ÀOUSVVO\S SVO SVQSVS _cK\¾VK\ ,_ NOâO\VO\ ]d UYX_]_ WKUSXKNK VvVOX PSSVS NOâO\ YVWKV¾ `OcK \O^SVOMOU WKUSXKc¾ ^OW]SV ONOX ^OUXSU YVK\KU U¾cK]VKXKLSVS\ WKUSXKNKX KV¾XKX VvWVO\O Q\O YV_À^_\_VKX NOâO\VO\ YVWKV¾N¾\ L kSdSWVO\ ÀOWKVK\ `O LKâVKX^¾ K\KvVK\¾ NKRSV WYX^KT ^KUWK `O LKâVKWK ^KVSWK^VK\¾ SVO WKUSXKX¾X WYX^O ONSVOMOâS ^O]S]K^ `OcK ÀK]SXSX ^KX¾WVKWK]¾ kYU LcU WKUSXKVK\NK +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ ]O] Qv ]O`ScO]S cO\SXO WKUSXK O^\KP¾XNK LOVS\VS UYX_WVK\NKUS +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ OWS]cYX ]O] LK]¾Xv ]O`ScOVO\S Q]^O\SVOLSVS\ J 7KUSXKX¾X U_VVKX¾W KWKM¾X¾X ^K\SPS 58 M 1\V^ `OcK ^S^\OÀSWVO\SX KdKV^¾VWK]¾XK cXOVSU U_\_V_W `O WYX^KT SVO SVQSVS ^KVSWK^VK\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ?c_WVKÀ^¾\¾VW¾À ]^KXNK\NVK\¾X _cQ_VKXWKN¾â¾ N_\_WVK\NK ]O] ]O`ScOVO\S WKUSXK SvSX OX _cQ_X cX^OW U_VVKX¾VK\KU VvVWOVSNS\ =O] OWS]cYX NOâO\VO\S Q]^O\SVNSâSXNO L_ NOâO\VO\O KS^ LOVS\]SdVSUVO\ NO LOVS\^SVWOVSNS\ nVvWOVO\ ]¾\K]¾XNK WKUSXKX¾X vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾ SVO U_VVKX¾VKX VvWO cX^OWS NO Kv¾UVKXWKV¾N¾\ kKV¾ÀWK S]^K]cYXVK\¾X¾X ^KX¾WVKXWKW¾À YVN_â_ cK NK ^KX¾WVKXKWKN¾â¾ N_\_WVK\NK +Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ ]O] LK]¾Xv NOâO\VO\S WKUSXK cdOcSXNOX WO^\O WO]KPONO `O dOWSXNOX `OcK O\SÀSW ZVK^PY\W_XNKX WO^\O cU]OUVSU^O VvVWOVSNS\ +dKWS ]O] LK]¾XM¾X¾X UYX_W_ `O NOâO\S LOVS\^SVWOVSNS\ ^K\SRVS `O # ]Kc¾V¾ <O]WS 1KdO^O·NO cKc¾WVKXKX +v¾U +VKXNK 5_VVKX¾VKX >OvRSdK^ >K\KP¾XNKX 9V_À^_\_VKX kO`\ONOUS 1\V^ /WS]cYX_ SVO ½VQSVS CXO^WOVSU^O +> ]O] LK]¾Xv ]O`ScOVO\SXSX `OcK Qv ]O`ScOVO\SXSX VvW SvSX LKÀUK ÀK\^VK\¾X XQ\VWO]S N_\_W_XNK L_ ZK\KQ\KP¾X ! SVQSVS RUWVO\S cO\SXO KX¾VKX cXO^WOVSU _cQ_VKXWKV¾N¾\ Y 7KUSXKX¾X USÀSVO\O dOVVSUVO NO `M_NK cO\VOÀ^S\SVOX KU^SP cK NK KU^SPYVWKcKX MSRKdVK\ ^KÀ¾cKX USÀSVO\O dK\K\ `O\OLSVOMOU ScYXSdOYVWKcKX ¾À¾WK cKcWK]¾ W_R^OWOV S]O YZO\K^\ `O WK\_d UKVKX USÀSVO\ SvSX cKc¾VKX ¾À¾WK SVO SVQSVS LSVQSVO\ æ6DWçëæGRNPDQODUçææ 7KUSXKVK\¾ ^KX¾WVKcKX ]K^¾À NYUWKXVK\¾ ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSU R_]_]VK\¾ LKU¾W¾XNKX ^KVSWK^VK\K KcU¾\¾ YVWKWKV¾N¾\ 7KUSXKX¾X ZO\PY\WKX] UK\KU^O\S]^SUVO\SXS ^KX¾WVKcKX ]K^¾À NYUWKXVK\¾ ^KVSWK^VK\NK cO\ KVKXVK\VK KcX¾ OWS]cYX LSVQSVO\SXS SvO\WOVSNS\ æ%HOLUOLæPDNLQDNDWHJRULOHULæLoLQæLODYHæ WHPHOæVDéOçNæYHæJYHQOLNæJHUHNOHULææ 1¾NK WKUSXKVK\¾ UYdWO^SU `O OMdKM¾V¾U \XVO\SXO cXOVSU WKUSXKVK\ OVNO ^_^_VKX `OcK OV SVO cXVOXNS\SVOX WKUSXKVK\ ^KÀ¾XKLSVS\ ^O]ZS^ `OcK NSâO\ NK\LOVS WKUSXKVK\ KRÀKZ `OcK LOXdO\S PSdSU]OV dOVVSUVO\O ]KRSZ WKVdOWOVO\S SÀVOWO WKUSXKVK\¾ L_ LVWNO 1OXOV ½VUOVO\ 7KNNO ^KX¾WVKXKX L^X ^OWOV ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSU Q\OUVO\SXS UK\À¾VKWKV¾N¾\ æ(OGHæWDëçQDELOHQæYHYH\DæHOæLOHæ \|QOHQGLULOHQæPDNLQDODUææ æ*HQHO /VNO ^KÀ¾XKLSVOX `O`OcK OV SVO cXVOXNS\SVOX WKUSXKVK\ $ 7KUSXKX¾X ^SZSXO LKâV¾ YVK\KU WKUSXKX¾X RONOPVOXOX vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK NOXQO]SXS ]KâVKcKMKU ÀOUSVNO NdOXVOXWSÀ cO^O\VS LcUVU^O LS\ ^KÀ¾c¾M¾ cdOc SVO cO^O\VS ]Kc¾NK ^_^KWKâK `O _cQ_X LcUVU^O NO]^OUVO\O ]KRSZ YVWKV¾ >OUXSU YVK\KU WWUX YVWKcKX N_\_WVK\ `OcK W]^KUSV LS\ U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^¾X¾X L_V_XWK]¾ N_\_WVK\¾ RK\Sv YVWKU dO\O ^_^KWKUVK\ ^KWKWOX Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO L¾\KU¾VKWKN¾â¾ N_\_WVK\NK YZO\K^\X ^_^KWKUVK\¾ L¾\KUWKU]¾d¾X vKV¾À^¾\KLSVOMOâS ÀOUSVNO NdOXVOXWSÀ OV SVO U_WKXNKV¾ vKV¾À^¾\WK `O N_\N_\WK U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVS 9ZO\K^\ ^_^KWKUVK\¾ L¾\KU^¾U^KX ]YX\K RSvLS\ ÀOUSVNO cKXV¾ÀV¾UVK vKV¾ÀWKcK LKÀVKWK `O`OcK vKV¾ÀWKcK NO`KW O^WO \S]US ^KÀ¾WKWKV¾N¾\ ,_ ÀK\^ ^OUXSU YVK\KU cKZ¾VKLSVS\ NOâSV]O OÀNOâO\ ^ONLS\VO\ KV¾XWKV¾N¾\ 1O\OUVS N_\_WVK\NK ^ORVSUO LVQO]SXSX `O SÀVOXOX WKVdOWO SVO ^KU¾W¾X RK\OUO^SXSX QdVOXWO]SXO SdSX `O\WOVSNS\ >KÀ¾XKLSVS\ WKUSXKVK\¾X ^_^KWKUVK\¾ vKV¾À^¾\WK `O N_\N_\WKc¾ NYâ\_NKX cKZKLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ æ7DOLPDWODUææ >KVSWK^VK\ OVNO ^KÀ¾XKLSVOX `O`OcK OV SVO cXVOXNS\SVOLSVOX WKUSXKVK\¾X SVO^^SâS ^S^\OÀSWVO\VO SVQSVS YVK\KU KÀKâ¾NKUS LSVQSVO\S `O\WOVSNS\$ W] cS KÀK\]K OVUYV ]S]^OWSXSX WK\_d UKVN¾â¾ ^YZVKW ^S^\OÀSW NOâO\S W] cS KÀWKWK]¾ N_\_W_XNK L_ N_\_W LOVS\^SVWOVS nVvWO LOVS\]SdVSâS ,_ NOâO\VO\ ]d UYX_]_ WKUSXK SvSX PSSVOX VvVOX NOâO\VO\ YVWKV¾ `OcK \O^SVOMOU WKUSXKc¾ ^OW]SV ONOX ^OUXSU YVK\KU U¾cK]VKXKLSVS\ WKUSXKVK\ SvSX cKZ¾VKX VvWVO\O Q\O YV_À^_\_VKX NOâO\VO\ YVWKV¾N¾\ ?c_WVKÀ^¾\¾VW¾À ]^KXNK\NVK\ _cQ_VKXW¾cY\]K ^S^\OÀSW NOâO\VO\S WKUSXKVK\ SvSX OX _cQ_X VvWO cX^OWS U_VVKX¾VK\KU VvVWOVSNS\ nVvWVO\ ]¾\K]¾XNK WKUSXKVK\¾X vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾ SVO U_VVKX¾VKX VvW cX^OWVO\S `OcK _cQ_VKXKX _c_WVKÀ^¾\¾VW¾À ]^KXNK\NVK\¾X K^¾PVK\¾ LOVS\^SVWOVSNS\ æ7DëçQDELOLUæWHVSLWæPDNLQDODUçææYHæGLéHUæ GDUEHOLæPDNLQDODUææ æ*HQHO >KÀ¾XKLSVS\ ^O]ZS^ WKUSXKVK\¾ `O NSâO\ NK\LOVS WKUSXKVK\ KÀKâ¾NKUS R_]_]VK\ NSUUK^ KV¾XK\KU ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\$ /XO\TS NK\LOcO WK\_d OVOWKXK ^O\^SLK^^KX Kc\¾VWKcKX LS\ K\K KU]KW `K]¾^K]¾cVK SVO^SVWOVS ,S\ RK\OUO^O QOvS\SMS ^O\^SLK^ WKUSXK O]K] WKVdOWO dO\SXO cO^O\VS LS\ LK]U¾ SVO NYâ\_ LS\ ÀOUSVNO UYX_WVKXN¾\¾VWKN¾UvK NK\LOcS XVOWOVS ½]^OW N¾À¾ ^O^SUVOWO XVOXWOVS% QO\OU^SâSXNO LS\ NK\LOcS ^O^SUVOWOU SvSX RK\OUO^O QOvS\SMS ^O\^SLK^ SVO U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^¾ dO\SXNO LS\ NSdS SÀVOW cKZ¾VWK]¾ QO\OUWOVS 59 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ¿YU N_\_W_XNK `O ^KÀ¾WK ]¾\K]¾XNK cKXV¾ÀV¾UVK ^O^SUVOWO XVOXWOVS CUVOWO `O LYÀKV^WK SÀVOWVO\S UYVKc `O Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO cKZ¾VWKV¾N¾\ 1O\OU^SâSXNO ^O\^SLK^K ^KVKÀ WKRPKdK]¾WKRPKdKVK\¾ ^KU¾VKLSVWOVS `O WKUSXKX¾X SWKVr^v¾]¾ ^K\KP¾XNKX _cQ_X WKRPKdK WKRPKdKVK\ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ æ7DOLPDWODUææ >KVSWK^VK\ KÀKâ¾NKUS R_]_]VK\VK SVQSVS QO\OUVS LSVQSVO\S `O\WOVSNS\$ 7KUSXK SVO LS\VSU^O U_VVKX¾VKLSVOMOU KU]O]_K\VK\ `O NOâSÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ ^OvRSdK^ 7KUSXK SVO LS\VSU^O U_VVKX¾VKMKU _cQ_X ^O]ZS^ OVOWKXVK\¾ `O NSâO\ NK\LOVS OVOWKXVK\ ?cQ_X YVN_â_XNK U_VVKX¾VKMKU _cQ_X UK\^_ÀVK\ æ0DNLQDODUçQæKDUHNHWOLOLéLææQHGHQL\OHæ PH\GDQDææJHOHELOHFHNæWHKOLNHOHULææ |QOHPHNæDPDFç\ODææJHUHNOLæLODYHæWHPHOæ VDéOçNæYHæJYHQOLNæNXUDOODUç 2K\OUO^VS YVWKVK\¾ XONOXScVO ^ORVSUO K\d ONOX WKUSXKVK\ L_ LVWNO 1OXOV ½VUOVO\ 7KNNO ^KX¾WVKXKX L^X ^OWOV ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSU U_\KVVK\¾X¾ UK\À¾VKWKV¾N¾\ æ*HQHOææ æ7DULIOHU D2K\OUO^VS YVWK]¾ XONOXScVO ^ORVSUO K\d ONOX WKUSXO% kKV¾À¾\UOX RK\OUO^ O^WOcS `OcK ]KLS^ SÀ S]^K]cYXVK\¾ K\K]¾XNK ]\OUVS `OcK cK\¾ ]\OUVS RK\OUO^ QO\OU^S\OX WKUSXKc¾ `OcK 2K\OUO^ O^^S\SVWONOX vKV¾À^¾\¾VKX KXMKU LS\ cO\NOX LKÀUK LS\ cO\O NKRK UYVKc LS\ ÀOUSVNO RK\OUO^ O^^S\SVOLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^OvRSd ONSVOLSVOX WKUSXKc¾ SPKNO ONO\ E =\M 7KUSXKX¾X RK\OUO^SXNOX ]Y\_WV_ YVKX YZO\K^\ =\M WKUSXK SVO ^KÀ¾XKLSVS\ `OcK WKUSXKcK OÀVSU ONO\OU cKcK QSNOLSVS\ `OcK WKUSXKcK _dKU^KX U_WKXNK ONO\OU cXVOXNS\OLSVS\ ædDOçëPDæNRQXPODUçææ æ6UëæNRQXPX =\À UYX_W_XNKX Q\VOLSVS\VSU ]\MXX WKUSXKc¾ `O ^KU¾WVK\¾X¾ XQ\VOX U_VVKX¾W UYÀ_VVK\¾ SvO\S]SXNO UOXNS]S `O WK\_d UKVKLSVOMOU USÀSVO\ SvSX ^KW LS\ Q`OXVSU SvO\S]SXNO vKV¾À^¾\KLSVOMOâS ÀOUSVNO YVWKV¾N¾\ 1O\OUVS N_\_WVK\NK NYâ\_NKX Q\ÀX cO^O\VS YVWKWK]¾ XONOXScVO Y\^KcK v¾UK LSVOMOU ^ORVSUOVO\S QSNO\WOU KWKM¾cVK _cQ_X ^O\^SLK^ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ odO\SXNO ]\MXX ^KÀ¾XN¾â¾ WKUSXKVK\ ]\À UYX_W_XNKX ^OUO\VOUVO\O `O ZKVO^VO\O cKXV¾ÀV¾UVK ^OWK] XONOXScVO ]\M SvSX LS\ ^ORVSUO YV_À^_\WKcKMKU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ 60 7KUSXKX¾X ]^XO LSXWSÀ ]\MXX ]\À UYX_W_ LS\ \S]US K\^^¾\WKWK]¾ `O cO^O\VS cO\ L_V_XWK]¾ UYÀ_V_ SVO ]\M UKLSXS ^KU¾VKLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ 5KLSXNO ]\M SvSX SR^ScKv N_c_VKX ^KVSWK^VK\¾X UYXKMKâ¾ LS\ cO\ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ æ.ROWXNODUææ 9ZO\K^\ `OcK ^KÀ¾XKX NSâO\ ZO\]YXOVSX dOVVSUVO NO X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP^K `OcK X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP^K LOVS\^SVOX LS\ UY\_c_M_ cKZ¾ SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWSÀ WKUSXKVK\ SvSX WKUSXKX¾X c_`K\VKXWK]¾ `OcK NO`\SVWO]S XONOXScVO WKUSXK ZK\vKVK\¾ SVO dOWSX K\K]¾XNK OdSVWO \S]USXSX YVN_â_ N_\_WVK\NK L_ WKUSXKVK\¾X Y^_\KUVK\¾ L_ ZO\]YXOVS SÀVOWVO\ SvSX QO\OUVS RK\OUO^VO\SXS cK NK Y^_\KUVK\¾X ]]ZKX]ScYXVK\¾X¾X Q`NOcO Q\O XONOX YVKMKâ¾ Q\OMOVS RK\OUO^VO\SXS OXQOVVOWOcOMOU ^K\dNK cO\VO\SXNO ^_^KMKU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `OcK LS\ LKâVKWK NdOXOâS SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\VO\ <S]US K\^¾\WKVK\¾ N_\_W_XNK L_ ^\ LKâVKWK ]S]^OWVO\S ^KU¾VWKWKV¾N¾\ æ'LéHUæNLëLOHUæLoLQæNRQXPODUææ 5_VVKX¾W UYÀ_VVK\¾ ]\MNOX LKÀUK USÀSVO\SX dKWKX dKWKX `OcK NdOXVS YVK\KU WKUSXK SVO ^KÀ¾XWKVK\¾X¾ cK NK WKUSXK dO\SXNO vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾ QO\OU^S\ScY\]K L_XVK\¾X ^ORVSUO]Sd YVK\KU ^KÀ¾XWKVK\¾X¾ `OcK WKUSXK dO\SXNO vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾ ]KâVKcKMKU _cQ_X UYX_WVK\ ^OWSX ONSVWOVSNS\ X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP¾X SUSXMS `O vXM P¾U\KVK\¾ ]\M N¾À¾XNKUS USÀSVO\ SvSX UYXKX cO\VO\ SvSX NO QOvO\VSNS\ æ.XPDQGDæVLVWHPOHULææ 1O\OUScY\ S]O U_WKXNKVK\¾X SdSX]Sd U_VVKX¾VWK]¾X¾ XVOWOU SvSX QO\OUVS XVOWVO\ KV¾XWKV¾N¾\ ?dKU^KX U_WKXNK YVWK]¾ N_\_W_XNK RO\ LS\ U_WKXNK LS\SWS L_ LS\SWNOX UYX^\YV ONSVOMOU WKUSXKc¾ Kv¾U LS\ LSvSWNO LOVS\^WOVSNS\ ?dKU^KX U_WKXNK ]S]^OWS cKVX¾dMK KÀKâ¾NKUSVO\S O^USVOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\$ ½VQSVS WKUSXKc¾ ½VQSVS SÀVO`VO\S ?dKU^KX U_WKXNK ONSVOX WKUSXKVK\ ]KNOMO KWKvVKXKX U_WKXNK LS\SWSXNOX QOVOX ]SXcKVVO\O MO`KZ `O\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\VKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ æ.XPDQGDæWHUWLEDWODUçææ =\M cKVX¾dMK LKÀUK cO\VO\NO L_V_XKX U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾X¾ U_VVKXWKU ]_\O^ScVO Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO vKV¾À^¾\KLSVOMOU SÀVO`VO\ RK\Sv WKUSXKVK\¾ ]\M UYX_W_XNKX vKV¾À^¾\WKU SvSX QO\OUVS L^X U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾X¾ vKV¾À^¾\KLSVWOVSNS\ ,_ SÀVO`VO\ dOVVSUVO ]\MNOX LKÀUK YZO\K^\X ]Y\_WV_ YVN_â_ `OcK ]\MXX L_XVK\¾ Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO U_WKXNK O^WOU SvSX ]\M UYX_W_X_ ^O\U O^WO]S QO\OUOX SÀVO`VO\S UKZ]K\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý :ONKV L_V_XKX N_\_WVK\NK ZONKVVK\ ]\MXX K]QK\S RK^KV¾ vKV¾ÀWK \S]US SVO Q`OXVS LS\ LSvSWNO vKV¾ÀWK]¾XK SWUrX `O\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ SWKV ONSVWOVS `O ^KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,_XVK\ UKcWKcK NS\OXvVS LS\ cdOcO ]KRSZ YVWKV¾ `O UYVKcMK ^OWSdVOXOLSVS\ YVWKV¾N¾\ 5_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾X¾X NSUUK^O NOâO\ ^ORVSUOVS RK\OUO^VO\O cYV KvKLSVOMOâS N_\_WVK\NK XMONOX KcK\VKXW¾À UYX_WK ]KRSZ YVKXVK\ RK\Sv YVWKU dO\O YZO\K^\ ^K\KP¾XNKX ]O\LO]^ L¾\KU¾VN¾U^KX ROWOX ]YX\K NO\RKV SVU UYX_WVK\¾XK NXWOVSNS\VO\ >OUO\VOUVS WKUSXKVK\NK NS\OU]ScYX ]S]^OWS U¾VK`_d ^OUO\VOUVO\SX WK\_d UKVN¾â¾ ÀYUVK\¾X WOcNKXK QO^S\NSâS NS\OU]ScYX ]SWSNS cK NK NXÀ U_WKXNK VO`cO]SXSX UYV_X_X KXS RK\OUO^VO\SXSX U_``O^SXS KdKV^KMKU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ .SPO\KX]ScOVS USVS^VOcOX RO\RKXQS LS\ U_WKXNK WKUSXK RK\OUO^ O^^SâS dKWKX NSPO\KX]ScOVSX USVS^VOWONOX v¾UWK]¾XK SdSX `O\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP¾X ]O]VS `O`OcK Q\]OV _cK\¾ ]SXcKVVO\S SVO SVQSVS YVKX KV^¾XM¾ P¾U\K]¾ ]KNOMO QO\S cXNO RK\OUO^ SvSX QOvO\VSNS\ ædDOçëWçUPDKDUHNHWæHWWLUPHææ odO\SXNO ]\MXX L_V_XN_â_ UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\¾X L^X QOdSX^S RK\OUO^VO\S ]KNOMO ]\M U_WKXNK LKÀ¾XNK SUOX WWUX YVWKV¾N¾\ kKV¾ÀWK KWKvVK\¾cVK WKUSXKVK\K vKV¾ÀWK LVQO]SXS KÀKX ^O\^SLK^VK\ ^KU¾VN¾â¾ N_\_WVK\NK \XOâSX ]^KLSVSdK^\ L_WLK QSLS ]\M SvSX WKUSXKc¾ RK\OUO^ O^^S\WONOX XMO L_ ^O\^SLK^¾X Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO RK\OUO^ O^WOcO SWUrX `O\OMOU LOVS\VS LS\ UYX_WNK YVN_UVK\¾X¾ UYVKcMK UYX^\YV ONOLSVOMOâS K\KvVK\ ^OWSX ONSVWOVSNS\ ,_ N_\_W Q`OXVS LS\ RK\OUO^O SdSX `O\WOU dO\O LOVS\VS UYX_WVK\NK YVWK]¾ QO\OUS\]O L_ UYX_WVK\NK USVS^VOXWO]S QO\OUOX NSâO\ L^X ZK\vKVK\ SvSX NO QOvO\VSNS\ ,KÀUK \S]UVO\O cYV KvWKWK]¾ N_\_W_XNK WKUSXKVK\¾X RK\OUO^S c_UK\¾NK LOVS\^SVOX ZK\vKVK\¾X Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO UYX_WVKXWKVK\¾XK LKâV¾ YVWKV¾N¾\ 7Y^Y\ vKV¾À^¾\¾V¾\UOX WKUSXK S]^OW N¾À¾ RK\OUO^ ONOWOWOVSNS\ æ6H\LUæLëOHYLææ 5K\KcYV_ ^\KPSU U_\KVVK\¾X¾ SRVKV O^WOU]SdSX UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\ `O L_XVK\¾X \WY\UVK\¾ L^X W]KKNO ONSVOX vKV¾ÀWK cU R¾d dOWSX `O \KWZK UYÀ_VVK\¾ KV^¾XNK cK`KÀVKWK N_\WK P\OXVOWO RK\OUO^]Sd UKVWK U_\KVVK\¾ UK\À¾VKWKV¾N¾\ =\M UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\¾ LS\ KXK ^O\^SLK^ `K]¾^K]¾cVK cK`KÀVK^KLSVWOVS `O N_\N_\KLSVWOVSNS\ 1`OXVSâSX QO\OU^S\NSâS N_\_WVK\NK KXK ^O\^SLK^¾X K\¾dKVKXWK]¾ RKVSXNO `OcK KXK ^O\^SLK^¾ vKV¾À^¾\WKU SvSX QO\OUOX OXO\TS LO]VOWO]SXSX YVWKWK]¾ N_\_W_XNK cK`KÀVK^WKU `O N_\N_\WKU SvSX ^KWK- 62 W¾cVK LKâ¾W]¾d `O UYVKc LS\ ÀOUSVNO O\SÀSVOLSVS\ U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^¾XK ]KRSZ LS\ KMSV N_\_W ^O\^SLK^¾ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ 1`OXVSâSX QO\OU^S\NSâS N_\_WVK\NK N_\KX WKUSXKc¾ RK\OUO^]Sd ^_^KLSVWOU SvSX LS\ ZK\U ^O\^SLK^¾ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ ,_ ^O\^SLK^ ^KWKWOX WOUKXSU YVWK]¾ UYÀ_V_cVK SUSXMS ZK\KQ\KP^K LOVS\^SVOX ^O\^SLK^VK\NKX LS\S]S SVO LS\VOÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ ?dKU^KX U_WKXNKV¾ WKUSXKVK\ vKV¾ÀWKc¾ Y^YWK^SU YVK\KU `O NO\RKV N_\N_\KMKU `O KÀKâ¾NKUS N_\_WVK\NK ^ORVSUOVS vKV¾ÀWK SR^SWKVSXS XVOcOMOU ^O\^SLK^VK\VK ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\$ =\M UYX^\YV UKcLO^^SâSXNO 7KUSXK N_\N_\WK ]SXcKVS KVN¾â¾XNK =S]^OWSX Q`OXVSUVO SVQSVS LS\ U¾]W¾XNK LS\ RK^K ^O]ZS^ ONSVNSâSXNO ,OVS\VOXWSÀ LS\ ]\O SvO\S]SXNO RSvLS\ YXKc ]SXcKVS ^O]ZS^ ONSVWONSâSXNO X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP ]OcS\ SÀVO`S SvSX QOvO\VS NOâSVNS\ æ<D\DæNXPDQGDOçæPDNLQDODUçQæKDUHNHWLææ CKcK YVK\KU U_WKXNK ONSVOX UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\¾X RK\OUO^VO\S ]\MXX SVQSVS U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^¾ dO\SXNO ]\OUVS O^US _cQ_VKWK]¾ SVO WWUX YVWKV¾N¾\ ndOVVSUVO WY^Y\ vKV¾À^¾\¾V¾\UOX RK\OUO^SX WOcNKXK QOVWO]S WWUX YVWKWKV¾N¾\ CKcK YVK\KU U_WKXNK ONSVOX WKUSXKVK\K KS^ U_WKXNK ]S]^OWVO\S WKUSXKX¾X cKXV¾ÀV¾UVK RK\OUO^ O^WO]SXNOX NYâKX ]\McO cXOVSU \S]UVO\S dOVVSUVO NO$ /dSVWO .XO\ ^KU¾WVK\NKX NYVKc¾ cK\KVKXWK \S]UVO\SXS K]QK\ScO SXNS\OMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXW¾À YVWKV¾N¾\ 7KUSXKVK\¾X ]OcS\ R¾d¾ ]\MXX cKcK YVK\KU RK\OUO^ R¾d¾ SVO _c_WV_ YVWKV¾N¾\ .XO\ LS\ ^KU¾W¾X ^KU¾VKLSVOMOâS WKUSXKVK\NK QO\S NXÀ U_WKXNK]¾ NO`\OcO QS\NSâSXNO WKUSXKX¾X RK\OUO^S ^KU¾W¾X RK\OUO^SXNOX UKcXKUVKXWK]¾ N¾À¾XNK ^KU¾W¾ RK\OUO^ O^^S\WOU WWUX YVWKWKV¾N¾\ 1O\S NXÀ U_WKXNK]¾ NO`\OcO QS\NSâSXNO QO\S cXNO RK\OUO^ R¾d¾ ]\M SvSX ^ORVSUO YV_À^_\WKcKMKU ÀOUSVNO YVWKV¾N¾\ æ.XPDQGDæGHYUHVLæDUç]DVçææ >KU¾V¾ YVWK]¾ RKVSXNO Qv NO]^OUVS LS\ NWOXVOWO ]S]^OWSXSX Qv LO]VOWO]SXNOUS LS\ K\¾dK WKUSXKX¾X WKUSXKc¾ N_\N_\WKU SvSX QO\OUVS ]\O LYc_XMK NWOXVOXWO]SXS OXQOVVOWOWOVSNS\ æ0HNDQLNæWHKOLNHOHUHæNDUëçæNRUXQPDææ æ.RQWUROV]æKDUHNHWOHU 7KUSXKVK\ RK\OUO^ O^^SUVO\SXNO Kâ¾\V¾U WO\UOdVO\SXSX UYX^\YV]d ]KV¾X¾WVK\¾ Y]SVK]cYX UK\K\V¾V¾UVK\¾X¾ O^USVOWOcOMOU `OcK cKZ¾]¾ dO\SXNO KÀ¾\¾ QO\SVWOVO\ WOcNKXK QO^S\WOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ SWKV ONSVWOVS `O _cQ_X YVN_â_XNK RK\OUO^VS NO]^OUVO\S dO\SXO cO\VOÀ^S\SVWOVSNS\VO\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý æ+DUHNHWOLæDNWDUPDæSDUoDODUçææ " X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KPK S]^S]XK YVK\KU WY^Y\VK\ SvSX WY^Y\ LVWO]SXNOUS RK\OUO^VS ZK\vKVK\K O\SÀSWS XVOcOX RK\OUO^VS WKRPKdKVK\¾X LS\ KVO^ cK NK KXKR^K\ U_VVKX¾VK\KU `OcK ]\À UYX_W_XNK L_V_XKX LS\ UYX^\YVVO Kv¾VWKVK\¾ QO\OUScY\]K L_ UYX^\YVX SdSX]Sd O\SÀSWS OXQOVVOcOMOU LS\ USVSNS L_V_XKX ^KWKWOX UKZKV¾ LS\ UKLSX SvSXNO YVWK]¾ UKcN¾cVK LS\LS\SXS USVS^VOcOX ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ L_V_XWK]¾ QO\OUWOd æ<XYDUODQPDæYHæGHYULOPHææ odO\SXNO ]\M YZO\K^\YZO\K^\VO\ cK NK LKÀUK USÀSXSXUSÀSVO\SX YVN_â_ UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\NK c_`K\VKXWK cK NK NO`\SVWO \S]US YVN_â_XNK \S]US K\^¾\WKWK]¾ UYÀ_V_cVK WKUSXKcK _cQ_X LS\ UY\_c_M_ cKZ¾ ^KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,_ cKZ¾ UOXNS]S dO\SXO c_`K\VKXWK `OcK NO`\SVWO N_\_W_XNK WKUSXK dO\SXNOUS USÀSUSÀSVO\ SvSX cO^O\VS LS\ ]KZWK ]¾X¾\VKc¾M¾ RKMSW ]KâVKWK]¾ QO\OUS\ ,_ cKZ¾X¾X SUSXMS ZK\KQ\KP^K LOVS\^SVOX ÀK\^VK\K _cQ_X YVN_â_X_ NYâ\_VKWKU SvSX SWKVr^v¾ `OcK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]S SVQSVS RO\ LS\ cKZ¾ ^SZS SvSX _cQ_X ^O]^VO\ cKZWKV¾ `OcK cKZ^¾\WKV¾N¾\ æ'ëHQæQHVQHOHUæ æ=\M YZO\K^\YZO\K^\VO\ cK NK NSâO\ USÀSUSÀSVO\SX dO\SXNO YVN_â_ UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKVK\NK NÀOX XO]XOVO\ `OcK WKVdOWOVO\ XONOXScVO \S]U YVN_â_XNK WKUSXK L_ \S]U Qd XXNO L_V_XN_\_VK\KU ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVS `O VvVO\S SWUrX `O\ScY\]K _cQ_X LS\ UY\_c_M_ LS\ cKZ¾ SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ ,_ cKZ¾ LS\ XO]XO `OcK WKVdOWO NÀWO]S N_\_W_XNK WKUSXK dO\SXNOUS USÀSUSÀSVO\ SvSX cO^O\VS LS\ ]KZWK ]¾X¾\VKc¾M¾ RKMSW ]KâVKWK]¾ QO\OUS\ ,_ cKZ¾X¾X SUSXMS ZK\KQ\KP^K LOVS\^SVOX ÀK\^K _cQ_X YVN_â_X_ NYâ\_VKWKU SvSX SWKVr^v¾ `OcK cO^USVS `OcK cO^USVS ^OW]SVMS]S SVQSVS RO\ LS\ cKZ¾ ^SZS SvSX _cQ_X NOXOcVO\S cKZWKV¾ `OcK cKZ^¾\WKV¾N¾\ æ(ULëLPæYDVçWDODUçææ /V ^_^KWKUVK\¾ `O LK]KWKUVK\ YZO\K^\X L_XVK\¾ SvQN]OV LS\ ÀOUSVNO U_VVKXKLSVOMOâS `O O\SÀSWO cK\N¾W O^WOU SvSX U_WKXNK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾X¾ U_VVKXWKcK QO\OU UKVWKcKMKâ¾ ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\VKXWKV¾ SWKV ONSVWOVS `O NdOXVOXWOVSNS\VO\ ædHNPHæWHUWLEDWODUçææ kOUWO `OcK vOUSVWO KWKM¾cVK U_VVKX¾VKX L^X WKUSXKVK\ UYVKc `O Q`OXVS LS\ LKâVKWK `O vdWOcS ]KâVKcKMKU `O U_VVKX¾W ]¾\K]¾XNK S]^OXWOcOX vdVWOcS XVOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXW¾À SWKV ONSVWSÀ `O NdOXVOXWSÀ vOUWO `OcK UK`\KWK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ SVO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ kOUWO v_L_â_ cU QO\OU^S\NSâSXNO L_ ^\ WKUSXKVK\K cUO `O dOWSXO _cQ_X ^KÀ¾WK cdOcSXO ]KRSZ LS\ NO]^OU ^KU¾VWKV¾N¾\ 64 æ.HQGLQGHQæWDKULNOLæPDNLQDæYH\DæoHNLFLæLOHæ oHNLOHQæPDNLQDæDUDVçQGDNLæJoæDNWDUçPçææ 5OXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKc¾ `OcK vOUSMScS vOUSVOX WKUSXKX¾X SVU ]KLS^ cK^Kâ¾XK LKâVKcKX ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ vKV¾ÀWK O]XK]¾XNK RK\OUO^ ONOX LS\ ZK\vK L^X _d_XV_â_ LYc_XMK UY\_XKMKU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ 5OXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXK `OcK vOUSMS ^K\KP¾XNK ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾X¾X LKâVKXN¾â¾ Qv v¾U¾À¾ cK UOXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS WKUSXKcK `OcK vOUSMScO ^O]ZS^ ONSVSZ LKâVKXKX LS\ WKRPKdK SVO cK NK OÀNOâO\ LS\ UY\_WKc¾ ]KâVKcKMKU LKÀUK LS\ ^O\^SLK^ SVO UY\_XWKV¾N¾\ =UVOLSVS\ KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾XK O\SÀSW SvSX L_ WKRPKdK Kv¾VKLSVWOVSNS\ ,S\ UOd cO\VOÀ^S\SVNSâSXNO WKUSXK `OcK vOUSMS RK\OUO^ ONO\UOX ^KR\SU WSVSXSX WKRPKdKcK RK]K\ `O\WO]SXS XVOWOU SvSX cO^O\VS KVKX L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ >KR\SU ONSVOX WKUSXK ^K\KP¾XNK QS\SÀ WSVS WKUSXKcK ^O]ZS^ ONSVWSÀ YVKX UY\_c_M_ LS\ W_RKPKdK SvO\S]SXO UYX_VWKV¾N¾\ oXS`O\]KV WKP]KVV¾ KU^K\WK OVOWKXVK\¾XK ^Y\U ]¾X¾\VKc¾M¾VK\ `OcK K`K\K ^O\^SLK^¾ ]KNOMO ^KR\SU ONOX WKUSXKc¾ LS\VOÀ^S\OX ^K\KP^KX ^KU¾VKLSVS\ =UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾ L_XK _cQ_X YVK\KU SÀK\O^VOXWOVSNS\ 5OXNSXNOX ^KR\SUVS LS\ WKUSXKcK `OcK vOUSMScO LKâVKX^¾ SvSX ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾ QO\OU^S\OX L^X vOUSVOX WKUSXKVK\ WKUSXK Kc\¾VN¾â¾ dKWKX ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾X¾X `O WKRPKdK]¾X¾X dOWSXO `OcK WKUSXK ZK\vKVK\¾XK ^OWK] ONO\OU RK]K\ Q\WO]SXS XVOWOU KWKM¾cVK ]UVOLSVS\ LS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾XK LKâVKX^¾ ]S]^OWSXO ]KRSZ YVWKV¾N¾\ 7KRPKdKX¾X N¾À ^K\KP¾XNKUS ZK\vKVK\ ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾ SVO LS\VSU^O NXWOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ SWKV ONSVWOVS `O NdOXVOXWOVSNS\ 7KRPKdK LK]S^ XS`O\]KV WKP]KV U_VVKX¾VN¾â¾XNK KU^K\WK OVOWKX¾X¾ Sv vOXO _vVK\¾XK UKNK\ QOXSÀ Kv¾V¾ XS`O\]KV WKP]KV U_VVKX¾VN¾â¾XNK S]O OX Kd¾XNKX N¾À WKP]KV cK NK WKP]KVVK\¾X Y\^K XYU^K]¾XK UKNK\ UKZK^WKV¾N¾\ kKV¾ÀWK UYX_WVK\¾XK O\SÀSW K\KvVK\¾ ]UVOLSVS\ WOUKXSU KU^K\WK ^O\^SLK^¾XK cKU¾X LS\ cO\O UYXW_À S]O L_XVK\ L_ KWKvVK\VK ^K]K\¾WVKX¾Z SWKV ONSVWONSUVO\S ]\OMO ÀKP^ WKRPKdKVK\¾X¾X WO\NS`OX YVK\KU U_VVKX¾VKWKcKMKâ¾ ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ æ'LéHUæWHKOLNHOHUHNDUëçæNRUXQPDææ æ$NOHU +UVO\SX Q`NOVO\S c_`K\VKXWK `OcK NO`\SVWO ]¾\K]¾XNK YZO\K^\X dO\SXO OVOU^\YVS^ ]¾v\KWKcKMKU `O YZO\K^\X L_V_XN_â_ KVKXVK\NK L_RK\ LS\SUWO]SXS XVOcOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ 7KUSXKVK\ L_ KWKvVK UYXW_À YVKX UYVKcMK O\SÀSVOLSVS\ LS\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ^O\^SLK^ cK\N¾W¾cVK KU LKâVKX^¾]¾ UO]SVOLSVOMOU ÀOUSVNO ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ VKÀ¾VWK]¾X¾ OXQOVVOWOU SvSX _cK\¾VK\ UYX_VWKV¾N¾\% WKUSXK vO`\O]SXNO L_V_XKX USÀSVO\SX Q`OXVSUVO\SXS ]KâVKWKU SvSX SÀK\O^VO\ cO^O\VS LS\ WO]KPONOX YU_XKLSVWOVSNS\ æ<DQJçQææ ½WKVK^v¾X¾X XQ\OLSVOMOâS ^ORVSUOVO\O LKâV¾ YVK\KU WKUSXKVK\ LYc_^_ SdSX `O\WO]S RKVSXNO$ 5YVKcMK O\SÀSVOLSVOX cKXQ¾X ]XN\MVO\SX ^KU¾VWK]¾XK SdSX `O\WOVS `OcK 7KUSXKcVK L^XVOÀSU cKXQ¾X ]XN\M ]S]^OWVO\VO ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ æ7HKOLNHOLæPDGGHæHPLV\RQODUçæ æ7KUSXKX¾X ^OWOV SÀVO`S \XVO\SX Z]U\^VWO]S S]O X_WK\KV¾ ZK\KQ\KP¾X SUSXMS `O vXM P¾U\KVK\¾ QOvO\VS NOâSVNS\ ,_X_XVK LS\VSU^O YZO\K^\ L_ ^\ dK\K\V¾ OWS]cYXVK\K WK\_d UKVWK \S]USXO UK\À¾ UY\_XWKV¾N¾\ æ%LOJLOHQGLUPHæYHæJ|VWHULPOHUææ æìëDUHWOHUæVLQ\DOOHUæYHæX\DUçODU ,^X WKUSXKVK\NK QO\OUVS YVKX cO\VO\NO USÀSVO\SX ]KâV¾U `O Q`OXVSâS ]KâVKWKcK cXOVSU YVK\KU U_VVKXWK KcK\VKWK `O LKU¾W SVO SVQSVS SÀK\O^VO\ `O`OcK ^KVSWK^ ZVKUKVK\¾ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ ,_XVK\ Kv¾UvK Q\VOLSVS\ `O ]SVSXOWOd LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]OvSVWOVS ^K]K\¾WVKXWKV¾ `O cKZ¾VWKV¾N¾\ 5K\K cYV_ ^\KPSU U_\KVVK\¾X¾ SRVKV O^WOU]SdSX vKV¾ÀWK ]¾\K]¾XNK ]\MXX dO\SXNO ]\O\OU U_VVKXN¾UVK\¾ WKUSXKVK\NK KÀKâ¾NKUS OUSZWKXVK\ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\$ 5SÀSVO\S _cK\WKU SvSX ]O]VS LS\ _cK\¾ ^O\^SLK^¾ +WKvVKXKX U_VVKX¾W UYÀ_VVK\¾ SVO SVQSVS ¾À¾UV¾ ]SXcKV ]S]^OWS% L_ ÀK\^ ]KNOMO cO\KV^¾ vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾XNK U_VVKX¾VKX `O OVOU^\SU Qv UKcXKâ¾ L_V_XWKcKX WKUSXKVK\ SvSX QOvO\VS NOâSVNS\ 1O\OU^SâSXNO \WY\U SVO WKUSXK K\K]¾XNK ]SXcKVO\SX vKV¾ÀWK]¾ SvSX _cQ_X LS\ LKâVKX^¾ YVWKV¾N¾\ 8Y\WKV U_VVKX¾W UYÀ_VVK\¾XNK USÀSVO\S vK\ZWK `O OdSVWO \S]UVO\SXO WK\_d L¾\KUKX _dKU^KX U_WKXNKV¾ WKUSXKVK\ WKUSXKX¾X RK\OUO^VO\SXS LSVNS\OMOU K\KvVK\VK cK NK USÀSVO\S L_ \S]UVO\O UK\À¾ UY\_cKMKU K\KvVK\VK ^OvRSd ONSVWOVSNS\ +cX¾ N_\_W U_VVKX¾W RKVSXNO SUOX ^OU\K\VKWKV¾ LS\ ÀOUSVNO ^OU OU]OX dO\SXNO SVO\S QO\S RK\OUO^ ONOX WKUSXKX¾X K\UK]¾XNK UKVKX KVKX¾X ]\M ^K\KP¾XNKX NYâ\_NKX Q\VOWONSâS WKUSXKVK\ SvSX NO QOvO\VSNS\ 7KUSXKVK\ _cK\¾ `O ]SXcKV ^O\^SLK^VK\¾ cKXV¾ÀV¾UVK NO`\ONOX v¾UK\¾VKWKcKMKU ÀOUSVNO SWKV ONSVWOVSNS\ Q`OXVSU SvSX dY\_XV_ YVWK]¾ RKVSXNO L_ ^O\^SLK^VK\NK NdQX vKV¾À^¾UVK\¾X¾ UYX^\YV O^WO K\KvVK\¾ L_V_XWKV¾ `O L_XVK\¾X K\¾dK]¾ YZO\K^\O LSVNS\SVWOVSNS\ 7KUSXKVK\¾X `OcK ^KU¾WVK\¾X¾X RK\OUO^VO\SXSX dOVVSUVO ^ORVSUOVS YVN_UVK\¾ N_\_WVK\NK WKUSXKcK WKUSXK vKV¾À¾\UOX cKU- 66 æìëDUHWOHPHææ +ÀKâ¾NKUSVO\ YU_XKUV¾ `O ]SVSXOWOd LS\ ÀOUSVNO L^X WKUSXKVK\ dO\SXNO Q]^O\SVWOVSNS\$ 5SVY`K^ 5A MSX]SXNOX KXWK QM 5SVYQ\KW UQ MSX]SXNOX OX vYU U_VVKX¾VKX UYXPSQ\K]cYX_X U^VO]S `O ?cQ_X YVN_â_XNK$ 8Oa^YX 8 MSX]SXNOX LKâVKX^¾ UKXMK]¾XNKUS KdKWS vOUWO v_L_â_ vOUWO U_``O^S 8Oa^YX 8 MSX]SXNOX LKâVKX^¾ UKXMK]¾ dO\SXNOUS KdKWS NÀOc cU æ7DOLPDWODUææ æ7LWUHëLPOHU >KVSWK^VK\ WKUSXK ^K\KP¾XNKX OV UYV ]S]^OWSXO `OcK ^W `M_NK SVO^SVOX ^S^\OÀSWVO\VO SVQSVS YVK\KU KÀKâ¾NKUS LSVQSVO\S `O\WOVSNS\$ W] cS QOvScY\]K OV UYV ]S]^OWSXSX WK\_d UKVN¾â¾ ^YZVKW ^S^\OÀSW NOâO\S ,_ NOâO\SX W] cS QOvWONSâS N_\_WNK L_X_X LOVS\^SVWO]S QO\OUS\ W] cS QOvScY\]K L^X `M_N_X WK\_d UKVN¾â¾ Kâ¾\V¾UV¾ S`WOVOXWOXSX OX cU]OU UU Y\^KVKWK UK\O NOâO\S ,_ NOâO\SX W] cS QOvWONSâS N_\_WNK L_X_X LOVS\^SVWO]S QO\OUS\ nVvWO LOVS\]SdVSâS ,_ NOâO\VO\ ]d UYX_]_ WKUSXK SvSX PSSVOX VvVOX NOâO\VO\ YVWKV¾ `OcK \O^SVOMOU WKUSXKc¾ ^OW]SV ONOX ^OUXSU YVK\KU U¾cK]VKXKLSVS\ WKUSXKVK\ SvSX cKZ¾VKX VvWVO\O Q\O YV_À^_\_VKX NOâO\VO\ YVWKV¾N¾\ ?c_WVKÀ^¾\¾VW¾À ]^KXNK\NVK\ _cQ_VKXW¾cY\]K ^S^\OÀSW NOâO\VO\S WKUSXKVK\ SvSX OX _cQ_X VvWO cX^OWS U_VVKX¾VK\KU VvVWOVSNS\ nVvWVO\ ]¾\K]¾XNK WKUSXKVK\¾X vKV¾ÀWK UYÀ_VVK\¾ SVO U_VVKX¾VKX VvW cX^OWVO\S Kv¾UVKXWKV¾N¾\ ædRNOXæNXOODQçPODUææ 5_VVKX¾VKX OUSZWKXK LKâV¾ YVK\KU vYUV_ U_VVKX¾WK SWUrX `O\OX WKUSXKVK\¾X ^KVSWK^VK\¾ SVO NOâSÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ OUSZWKX ^KVSWK^VK\¾XNK KXK WKUSXK SVO L_XK ^KU¾VKLSVOMOU NOâSÀ^S\SVOLSVS\ OUSZWKXVK\¾X Q`OXVS LS\ ÀOUSVNO WYX^O ONSVSZ U_VVKX¾W¾XK cXOVSU QO\OUVS LSVQSVO\ L_V_XWKV¾N¾\ 'HYDPçææ6D\çGDæ\D\çQODQDFDNWçU ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 0DNLQDæ3DUNçæ 1XPDUDODQGçUçOPDVç 7KUSXO SÀVO^WOMSVSâSXSX ^OWOV UYX_VK\¾XNKX LS\S]S ZK\U^K L_V_XKX WKUSXKVK\¾X X_WK\KVKXN¾\¾VWK]¾N¾\ 7KUSXK `O ½UWKV Q\_L_ SvSX X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK QO\OU LKU¾W `O ^KWS\VO\SX cKZ¾VWK]¾XNK cKU¾^ cKâ VK]^SU dSXMS\ QSLS cU]OU WKVScO^VO\S ^OÀUSV ONOX `OcK WKUSXO PKKVScO^VO\SXS LOVS\VOcOX PSV^\O ^¾\XKU `L NSâO\ ]K\PVK\¾X U_VVKX¾WVK\¾X¾X ^KUSZ ONSVOLSVWO]S QO\OU]O WKUSXKVK\¾X SÀ Z\YQ\KWVK\¾X¾X RKd¾\VKXWK]¾ SvSX OVdOWNS\ n^ONO cKXNKX ÀS\UO^ W_RK]OLO]SXNO c¾Z\KXWK ZKc¾ KWY\^S]WKX `O WKVScO^ W_RK]OLO]S ^KUSLS SvSX SVO^SÀSWNO LS\ UYNVKWK SÀVO`S Q\\ 7KUSXKVK\¾X QO\OU SÀVO^WO WKVScO^VO\SXSX QO\OU]O WKUSXK LKU¾W^KWS\ UKc¾^VK\¾X¾X ^_^_VN_â_ ]SMSV NY]cKVK- 68 \¾X¾X ^K]XSPVO\SXNO WKUSXK X_WK\KVK\¾ ]¾\KVKWK `KdSPO]S Q\\ 7KUSXK ]SMSV NY]cKVK\¾XNK L_V_XWK]¾ QO\OUOX LSVQSVO\ Kc\¾ LS\ cKc¾X UYX_]_ YVKMKU NO^KcK ]KRSZ^S\ ½ÀVO^WOVO\NO X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK ]S]^OWK^SâSXSX U_\_VWK]¾XNK PK\UV¾ cKUVKÀ¾WVK\ Q\VWOU^ONS\ =Kc¾]KV YVK\KU Kd `O vOÀSNS PKdVK YVWKcKX WKUSXO ZK\U¾XK ]KRSZ NK\ UKZ]KWV¾ vKV¾ÀKX SÀVO^WOVO\ SVO vYU ÀKX^ScOVS `O c_\^SvSc_\^N¾À¾ W^OKRRS^VSU RSdWO^S `O\OX `O vYU PK\UV¾ Z\YTOVO\S c\^OX UKW_ `OcK dOV SÀVO^WOVO\SX WKUSXK ZK\UVK\¾X¾ X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK]¾X¾X ]OvSW U¾]^K]VK\¾ PK\UV¾ YVWKV¾N¾\ ½]^O\ NK\ UKZ]KWV¾ S]^O\]O QOXSÀ LS\ WKUSXK ZK\U¾ YV]_X ]OvSVOX X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK ]S]^OWS O]XOU YVWKV¾ `O NKRK ]YX\K KV¾- XKMKU WKUSXKVK\¾X X_WK\KVKXN¾\¾VWK]¾XNK ]¾U¾X^¾ cK\K^WKWKV¾N¾\ @O\SVOMOU X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK ]O\`S] `O LKU¾WVK\¾ cKZKX ^KWS\MSLKU¾WM¾VK\ SVO WKUSXKc¾ U_VVKXKX YZO\K^\VO\NO cKXV¾À KXVKÀ¾VWKVK\K ]OLOLScO^ `O\OMOU WKRScO^^O UK\WKÀ¾U `O dY\ YVWKWKV¾N¾\ 5KW_ U_\_V_ÀVK\¾XNK WKUSXK X_WK\KVKXN¾\¾VWK]¾XNK WKUSXKX¾X ]K^¾X KV¾XWK ^K\SRSXS SR^S`K ONOX QOXOVNO \KUKWNKX YV_ÀKX LS\ X OUS ^KUSZ ONOX `O Y ]OXO UKv¾XM¾ KV¾XKX WKUSXK S]O YXK KS^ ]¾\K XY·]_XNKX YV_À_\ >-5 NK _cQ_VKXKX ]S]^OWNO SÀ WKUSXKVK\¾ `O XKUVScO ^\KPSU ZVKUKV¾ K\KvVK\ SvSX \XOâSX ##" ]OXO]SXNO 7KUSXO YVK\KU KV¾XKX LS\ LSXOU K\KM¾ X_WK\K]¾ #" YVWKU- ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý WKUSXO X_WK\KVKXN¾\¾VWK]¾ XOW K\d O^WOU^ONS\ =OvSVOX X_WK\KVKXN¾\WKNK ÀS\UO^SX Y KX WKUSXO ZK\U¾XNK L_V_XWKcKX PKUK^ SVO\NO ]K^¾X KV¾XKLSVOMOU WKUSXKVK\K NK X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK SWUrX¾ `O\WOVSNS\ 8_WK\KVKXN¾\WKNK UKL_V Q\WÀ LS\UKv PK\UV¾ _cQ_VKWK KÀKâ¾NK \XOUVS YVK\KU KXVK^¾VKMKU^¾\ <KUKW `O KVPKLO^SU UK\KU^O\VO\SX WÀ^O\OU U_VVKX¾VWK]¾XNKX YV_ÀWKU^KN¾\ ¿S\UO^ LKd¾XNK ^OU LS\ ]S]^OWK^SU^O X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK WKUSXKX¾X ÀKX^ScOVO\ `O LS\SWVO\ K\K]¾ cO\ NOâSÀ^S\WO]SXNO SdVOXOLSVS\VSâSXS `O NO WKUSXO QOvWSÀSXO KS^ LSVQSVO\SX ^KUSZ ONSVOLSVWO]SXS ]KâVK\ ^KN¾\ /VOU^\SU RK`K `OcK WY^Y\V_ YV_Z NOWS\LKÀ YVK\KU U_VVKX¾VKX WKVdOWOVO\ S]O X OUS ^KUSLOX RKXOVS YVWKU^KN¾\ ,Kd¾ SÀVO^WOVO\NO S]O WKUSXKX¾X ^KX¾W¾X¾X LKÀ RK\PS `O WKUSXKX¾X ]K^¾X KV¾XWK ]¾\K]¾ SVO WKUSXO UYN_ ^OÀUSV ONSVWOU^ONS\ n\XOâSX UKWcYXVK\NK 5 QSLS X_WK\KVKXN¾\WKNK SÀVO^WOXSX ]K^¾X KV¾XKX SÀ WKUSXK]¾X¾X YVN_â_X_ KXVKcKLSVScY\_d ,_ ^K\d X_WK\KVKXN¾\WKVK\NK KWY\^S]WKX ^KUSLS `O XQ\VOX ]\O ]YX_XNK RSdWO^ N¾À¾ L¾\KUWK KXVKc¾À¾ YVN_â_ SvSX `O NO WKUSXK vOÀS^VSVSâS PKdVK YVWKN¾â¾ SvSX SR^ScKMK cO^O\VS YVWKU^KN¾\ ndOV ]OU^\NO L_V_XKX PS\WKVK\ W^OKRRS^VSU WKNOXMSVSU VSWKX SÀVO^WOMSVSâS `O cK NOâSÀSU SÀVO\S LS\VSU^O cKZ^¾UVK\¾XNKX >OU ÀKX^ScO NS]SZVSXSXNO vKV¾ÀKX +^K^\U LK\KT ÀKX^ScO]SXNO U_VVKX¾VKX L^X WKUSXKVK\¾X ]O`U `O SNK\O]S ^OU OVNOX cKZ¾VWKW¾À^¾\ 7KUSXKV¾ vKV¾ÀWKc¾ O]K] KVKX LS\SWVO\NOX UKd¾NYVQ_ Q\_L_X_X WKUSXKVK\¾XK WKUSXK `O SUWKV Q\_L_ LKUK\UOX LO^YX Q\_L_XK KS^ LO^YX ]KX^\KVVO\S WSU]O\ UKWcYX `O ZYWZKVK\ LO^YX Q\_L_XK LKâV¾ vKV¾ÀKX Kc\¾ LS\ WKUSXK Q\_L_ ^K\KP¾XNKX ]YXNKT `O OXTOU]ScYX Q\_L_ S]O NYâ\_NKX UOXNS WKUSXKVK\¾ SVO SVQSVOXWSÀ^S\ 7KUSXO `O ½UWKV Q\_L_ RKP\ScK^ Q\_L_ NOVSMS WKUSXKVK\ `SXvVO\ LSXOU `O RSdWO^ Q\_L_ UKWcYXVK\NKX ^OÀUSV YVKX `O cKUVKÀ¾U KNO^ WKUSXKNKX WOcNKXK QOVOX LS\ ZK\U^KX ]Y\_WV_ YVN_â_ SvSX \KUKWNKX YV_ÀKX LS\ X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK cO^O\VS YVW_À^_\ ½VU SUS \KUKW WKUSXKX¾X MSX]S `O WYNOVS SvSX LSVQS `O\S\UOX ^KUSZ ONOX NSâO\ \KUKW S]O ]¾\K ]Kc¾]¾X¾ `O\S\ CYV N¾À¾ UKWcYXVK\¾X LcU Q\_L_XNKUS -K^O\ZSVVK\ !!! UKWcYXVK\¾X ]Kc¾]¾ NOX PKdVK YVN_â_ SvSX `O SVO LKÀVKcKX ]O\S ^OÀUSV ONSVWSÀ^S\ +XUK\K1O\ONO Y^YcYV `O +XUK\K vO`\O cYVVK\¾ Z\YTO]SXNO vKV¾ÀKX LS\ WÀ^O\OU Y\^KUV¾U ÀS\UO^SXNO Z\YTO LKÀ¾XNK WKUSXO ]Kc¾]¾X¾ LOVS\VS YVWKWK]¾ `O KV^cKZ¾]^ cKZ¾ SXÀKK^¾X¾X ^KWKW¾X¾ Y\^KUV¾U WKUSXKVK\¾ SVO cKZ¾VWK]¾XNKX `O Z\YTO QSNSÀK^¾XK Q\O ^OU\K\ ONOX KV¾WVK\ ]d UYX_]_ YVN_â_ SvSX UK\KU^O\VS LS\ X_WK\KVKXN¾\WK XQ\VWÀ^\ ½VU SUS UK\KU^O\ \KUKWNKX YV_À_\ `O L_XVK\ WKUSXKX¾X Q\_L_X_MSX]SXS Q]^O\S\UOX 5K\KU^O\ KVPKLO^SU YV_Z WKUSXK LcUVâWYNOVSXS SPKNO O^WO SWUrX¾X¾ `O\WSÀ^S\ =YX QOVOX `O \KUKWNKX YV_- ÀKX @O UK\KU^O\VO\ SVQSVS WKUSXKX¾X ]¾\K XY ]_ LOVS\VOWOU^ONS\ n\XOU YVK\KU , WKUSXO X_WK\K]¾ LSdO 7KMU WK\UK ^YX NKWZO\VS UKWcYX_ SPKNO O^WOU^ONS\ ,_ ^K\d X_WK\KVKXN¾\WKNK ## NOâSÀSU KXK Q\_ZVKWK SvSXNO NOâSÀSU WYNOVNOX ## WKUSXKcK QOXSÀ LS\ KVKXNK NOâO\VOXNS\WO cKZWK SWUrX¾ `K\N¾\ ,S\ LKÀUK ÀS\UO^^O _cQ_VKXKX ]S]^OWNO S]O WKUSXKX¾X KXK SÀVO`SXS ^K\SP ONOX LS\ KVPKLO^SU UK\KU^O\NOX ]YX\K WKUSXKcK dOV SÀVO`S SvSX LS\ XWO\SU UK\KU^O\ NKRK ]YX\K ^SMK\S WK\UK]¾X¾ RK^¾\VK^WK SvSX SUS KVPKLO^SU UK\KU^O\ `O WKUSXO ]Kc¾]¾X¾ SPKNO ONOX SUS \KUKW UK\KU^O\S SVO ]S]^OWK^SU ^OÀUSV ONSVWSÀ^S\ n\XOâSX 26+ UYNVKWK]¾X¾X NO^Kc¾XNK 2 2KP\ScK^ Q\_L_X_ 8 XKUVScO Q\_L_ UKWcYXVK\¾ . .OVSMS WKUSXKVK\¾ @ @SXvVO\S ² /U]UK`K^\VO\S .YdO\VO\S cUVOcSMSVO\S Q\KcNO\VO\S 6+ 6 6SOLRO\\ WK\UK]¾X¾ + RK\PS S]O ZKVO^VS # WYNOVSXS NO ]O\S]SXNOUS SVU WKUSXK YVN_â_X_ Q]^O\S\ 5K\K cYV_XK v¾UKX `OcK UK\KcYV_ SVO SVSX^SVS vKV¾ÀKX WKUSXKVK\NK ]YX c¾VVK\NK ^\KPSU UKX_XNKUS dY\_XV_V_U^KX NYVKc¾ QOVSÀOX LS\ Z\K^SU^O PS\WKX¾X UKc¾^V¾ YVN_â_ SV ^SMK\O^ YNKVK\¾XNKX KV¾XKX ZVKUKVK\ `O ^\KPSU^O ]Oc\ONOX LSXOU UKWcYX `] SvSX ^\KPSU ZVKUKVK\¾ WKUSXO UYN_ cO\SXO LKd¾ ÀS\UO^VO\NO U_VVKX¾VWKU^KN¾\ 0HVOHNWDìODUçPç]æLoLQæELUæ KDWçUODWPDæ ROPDVçæ DoçVçQGDQæ ILQLìHUæ DVIDOWæ VLOLQGLULæ JUD\GHUæ \NOH\LFLæ æ YVæ JLELæ\ROæ\DSçPæPDNLQDODUçQçQæWUDILNæND]DODUçQDæ XéUDPDæ LKWLPDOLæ ROPDVçQGDQæ GROD\çæLìæPDNLQDæUXKVDWODUçæYHæSODNDODUçQçQæoçNDUçOPDVçQçæPXKDNNDNæVXUHWOHæWHPLQæHWPHOHULæJHUHNPHNWHGLUæ ndO^VO SXÀKK^ ÀS\UO^VO\SXNO SÀ WKUSXK]¾ UYNVKWK]¾ `KdQOvSVWOd LS\ SR^ScKv YVN_â_ L_ X_WK\KVKXN¾\WKX¾X KU¾VNK UYVKc ^_^_VWK]¾ QXNOVSU U_VVKX¾WNK Kd OâS^SWVS SX]KXVK\¾X U_VVKX¾WVK\¾XNK LSVO cKX¾VWKVK\K ]OLOZ YVWKWKVK\¾ `O\SVO\SX SÀVOXWO]S O]XK]¾XNK LSVQS]KcK\ UK\KU^O\VO\SXO _cQ_X YVWKVK\¾ QO\OUWOU^ONS\ <D]DQæ0XVWDIDæ6ì/3$è$5 Mak.Yük.Müh. ì00%æ<|Qæ.UOæ%ëNæ9HN 69 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Sel ve Korunma 7O^OY\YVYTSU KPO^ SvSX LS\ O\UOX _cK\¾ LS\SWS S`ONSVSUVO YV_À^_\_VWKV¾N¾\ 1XWdNO cKâ¾À KVKXVK\¾ `O cKâ¾À cYâ_XV_UVK\¾X¾X LOVS\VOXWO]SXNO YVN_UvK O^USVS LS\ LSvSWNO U_VVKX¾VKX .YZZVO\ <KNK\ =S]^OWVO\S `O _cN_ NK^KVK\¾ SVO vKV¾ÀKX O\UOX _cK\¾ LS\SWVO\S ^OÀUSV ONSVWOVSNS\ 72 CO\OV LOVONScOVO\MO NO\O `O XORS\ cK^KUVK\¾XK cO\VOÀSW UYX_]_XNK ^S^SdVSU Q]^O\SVWOVS L_\KVK\NK cO\VOÀSWSX XVOXWO]SXSX cKX¾ ]¾\K YV_ÀKMKU OXQOVVO\ NdOXVS YVK\KU ^OWSdVOXWOVSNS\ Pratik Ö Önlemler .O\O `O XORS\VO\SX NOXSdVO LS\VOÀ^SâS UKXKVVK\ NdOXVS YVK\KU ^OWSdVOXO\OU Kv¾U YVWKVK\¾ ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ =OV LVQO]SXS ROWOX ^O\U O^WOVS]SXSd PKUK^ K]VK ]_NK UK\À¾NKX UK\À¾cK QOvWOcO vKV¾ÀWKWKV¾]¾X¾d 5KXKV ¾]VKR¾ cKZ¾VWKV¾N¾\ =OV ]¾\K]¾XNK K\KLKX¾dNKc]KX¾d K]VK ]_ SVO UKZV¾ cYVNKX QS^WOcO vKV¾ÀWKWKV¾]¾X¾d +XS ]OVVO\SX WOcNKXK QO^S\NSâS VWVO\SX cK\¾]¾ K\KLK SVO SVSÀUSVS YVN_â_XNKX K]VK ]OV ]_VK\¾X¾X L_V_XN_â_ LVQOVO\NO K\KLK U_VVKX¾VWKWKV¾ N¾\ ,_ _cK\¾ LS\SWS SVO UYY\NSXOVS YVK\KU vKV¾ÀKMKU SV `O SVvOVO\NO U_\^K\WK LS\SWVO\S YV_À^_\_VWKV¾N¾\ 5Y\_c_M_ ]O^ `O QVO^ cKZ¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,VQO]OV \KNcYVK\ RO\RKXQS LS\ ^ORVSUO KX¾XNK RKVU¾ LSVQSVOXNS\O\OU _cQ_VKcKMKUVK\¾ cX^OWVO\ UYX_]_XNK _cK\¾NK L_V_XWKV¾N¾\VK\ CO\VOÀSW KVKXVK\¾ NYâ\_ LS\ ÀOUSVNO ]OvSVWOVSNS\ =OV XQ\] SvSX dOXVS S]^K^S]^SU} vKV¾ÀWKVK\ cKZ¾VWKV¾N¾\ 2KVU¾X `O Q\O`VSVO\SX L_ ^\ UYX_VK\NK OâS^SWS ]KâVKXWKV¾N¾\ 9\WKXV¾U KVKX UY\_XWKV¾ `O K\^^¾\¾VWKV¾N¾\ .YâKV KPO^VO\O UK\À¾ ]SQY\^K ]S]^OWS QOVSÀ^S\SVWOVSNS\ /`SX N¾À¾XNK L_V_X_cY\]KX¾d ROWOX cU]OU LS\ cO\O v¾UWKV¾]¾X¾d =_ cK^Kâ¾ `OcK v_U_\ LVQOVO\S ROWOX ^O\U O^WOVS]SXSd +\KLKX¾dNK RO\RKXQS LS\ K\¾dK YV_À^_c]K ROWOX ^O\U ONO\OU cU]OU LS\ cO\O v¾UWKV¾]¾X¾d CYVVK\ KUKX ]_VK\ ^K\KP¾XNKX NYVN_\_VK- ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý MKâ¾ SvSX OâO\ K\KLKX¾d MW cU]OUVSU^OUS RK\OUO^ ONOX ]_NK UKVW¾À]K ]_ YX_ UKVN¾\¾Z ]\UVOcOLSVOMOU^S\ DKWKX¾X¾d `K\]K N¾ÀK\¾ v¾U¾X nXOWVS ÀOcVO\S PK\UV¾ LS\ NOZYcK KU^K\¾X =OV ]_VK\¾XNKX _dKU N_\_X kXU ^ORVSUOVS WKNNOVO\ SvO\S\VO\ 2K\OUO^VS ]_VK\NK c\cÀ cKZWKc¾X +cKUVK\¾X¾d dK\K\ Q\OLSVS\ 7_^VKUK c\WOXSd QO\OUScY\]K N_\Q_X ]_VK\NK c\cX `O XXd LS\ LK]^YX cK\N¾W¾ SVO UYX^\YV ONO\OU c\cX /VOU^\SU UKcXKUVK\¾XNKX _dKU N_\_X OVOU^\SU vK\ZKLSVS\ CKX¾X¾dK W_^VKUK LS\ ZSVVS \KNcY KV¾X \KNcYNKX KVKMKâ¾X¾d RKLO\ `O ^KVSWK^VK\K Q\O RK\OUO^ ONOLSVS\]SXSd ,S\ WSU^K\ U_\_ Q¾NK `O SvOMOU NOZYVKc¾X ½VU cK\N¾W WKVdOWOVO\S `O KSVOXSdSX SR^ScKv N_cKLSVOMOâS `OcK U_VVKXN¾â¾ SVKvVK\¾ L_V_XN_\_X =OV ]_VK\¾X¾X ^OWK] O^^SâS cScOMOUVO\S cOWOcSX =_ UKcXKUVK\¾ ]OV XONOXS SVO US\VOXWSÀ YVKLSVS\ 5_c_VK\NKX KV¾XKX ]_ cO^USVSVO\MO ^O]^ ONSVNSU^OX ]YX\K U_VVKX¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,YN\_W `O dOWSX UK^¾ ]OV ]_VK\¾ SVO NYV_c]K NO\OMO NO\OMO ZYWZKVKcK\KU Y\^KVKWK QXNO Y\KX¾XNK ]_ LYÀKV^¾X ,cVOMO RK]K\¾X XXO QOvOLSVS\]SXSd kO`\OXSdNOUS ^YZ\KU RKVK ]_ KV^¾XNKcUOX LYN\_WdOWSX UK^¾XNKUS ]_ LYÀKV^¾V¾\]K N_`K\VK\ vUOLSVS\ NÀOWOVO\ Oâ\SVOLSVS\ ,SXKVK\¾ UYX^\YV O^WOU SvSX ZSVVS POXO\ U_VVKX¾X +XMKU LSXKNK QKd ]¾d¾X^¾]¾ YVN_â_X_ NÀXcY\]KX¾d RO\RKXQS LS\ ^\NO ¾À¾U U_VVKXWKc¾X 3À¾â¾X UOXNS]S LS\ ZK^VKWKX¾X ^ORNSNS YVKLSVS\ ndOVVSUVO QOMOVO\S ]OVSX ^ORVSUOVO\SXS Q\WOU QvVOÀOMOâSXNOX NKRK NSUUK^VS YVWKV¾]¾X¾d 6HOGHæYHæ6XGDæ%RéXOPDNWDæ 2ODQæ.LëLQLQæ.XUWDUçOPDVçæ =OVNO `O ]_NK LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀSVO\SX U_\^K\¾VWK]¾XNK% CdWO LSVOX `O L_ UYX_NK OâS^SW Q\WÀ USÀSVO\SX Q\O` KVWK]¾ NYâ\_ YVKX¾N¾\ +U]S RKVNO U_\^K\¾M¾X¾X NK LYâ_VKLSVOMOâS _X_^_VWKWKV¾N¾ \ =_ NK LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀScO ]YZK SZ cK NK SZO LKâV¾ ´-KX ]SWSNSµ `OcK K\KLKVK\¾X cONOU Vr]^SâS K^¾VK\KU _VKÀ¾VWKcK vKV¾À¾VWKV¾N¾\ =_NK LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀSXSX L_ ÀOUSVNO UYVKcMK `O OWSX YVK\KU UK\KcK v¾UWK]¾ ]KâVKXKLSVS\ 5¾c¾NKX W UKNK\ _dKU^K LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀSXSX U_\^K\¾VWK]¾ SvSX _d_X LS\ vKWKÀ¾\ SZSXSX _M_XK LS\ ^Y\LK LKâVKXWKV¾ SvSXO ]_NK LK^WKcKX LS\ MS]SW WKX^K\ `L `O ^Y\LKX¾X _dKâK K^¾VWK]¾X¾ ]KâVKWKU KWKM¾ SVO NO LS\ Kâ¾\V¾U ^KÀ U_\À_X `L UYXWKV¾ N¾\ +âd¾ LKâVKXKX ^Y\LK P¾\VK^¾VWKV¾ LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀS L_X_ ^_^WKV¾N¾\ 5_\^K\¾M¾ SZS vOUO\OU USÀSXSX U¾c¾cK NYâ\_ QOVWO]SXS ]KâVKWKV¾N¾\ ,_ _cQ_VKWKcK ´2KcK^ SZS SVO vOUO\OU U_\^K\WKµ NOXS\ ,Yâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀSXSX L_V_XN_â_ cO\ UK\KcK _dKU S]O U_\^K\¾M¾ cKX¾XK ´-KX ]SWSNSµ XS KVK\KU cdWOVS LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀSXSX ^_^_XWK]¾X¾ `O cdO\OU UK\KcK v¾UWK]¾X¾ ]KâVKWKV¾N¾\ CKVX¾d YVK\KU UKc¾U^K L_V_XKX `O ]_cK NÀOX USÀS UKc¾U U\OâSXS cKUKVKWKV¾ UYV^_U KV^¾XK KVK\KU U¾c¾cK NYâ\_ cdWOcO vKV¾ÀWKV¾N¾\ ½cS cdWO LSVOX U_\^K\¾M¾X¾X LYâ_VWKU^K YVKX USÀScS U_\^K\WK]¾ RKVSXNO ]_NK LYâ_VKX USÀScS cd c_UK\¾ QOVOMOU ÀOUSVNO NXN\WOVS LSVOâSXNOX cK NK ]Kv¾XNKX ^_^K\KU vOUWOVSNS\ =OVNO `O ]_NK LYâ_VKXVK\¾X c_^^_â_ ]_c_X LS\ U¾]W¾ RK`K cYVVK\¾X¾ KUMSâO\S `O RK`K UO]OMSUVO\SXS NYVN_\_\ `O USÀS XOPO] KVKWKd +cX¾ dKWKXNK KUMSâO\VO\O QS\OX ]_ UKX¾ O\S^S\ ,_ XONOXVO ]_NKX v¾UK\¾VKX USÀSXSX XMOVSUVO c_^^_â_ ]_ v¾UK\¾VWKV¾N¾\ ,_X_ ]KâVKWKU SvSX ScS cdWO LSVSXScY\]K ]_ SvSXNOX v¾UK\¾V¾\UOX cYU]K v¾UK\¾VN¾U^KX ]YX\K ]_X·S ]YV_X_W _cQ_VKXWKV¾N¾\ ì00% 73 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 7O`M_^ K\KLKX¾d¾X K\^KX K\¾dKVK\¾ `O QSNO\OU NÀOX NOâO\ScVO cOXS KV¾XKMKU K\KLKX¾X L^vOXSdNO cK\K^KMKâ¾ ]¾U¾À¾UV¾U ]SdS K\KLKc¾ cOXSVOWOU SVO O]US]ScVO NO`KW O^WOU K\K]¾XNK UK\K\]¾d L¾\KU¾cY\ ,SVSXNSU LS\ RSUKcO% U_\LKâK ]Yâ_U ]_ NYV_ UKdKX¾X SvSXNONS\ UKdKX KV^^KX ¾]¾^¾V¾cY\ ncVO LS\ KX QOVS\ US U_\LKâKX¾X ]¾v\Kc¾À¾ SvSX ]YX ÀKX] ]¾v\KWKd]K ]¾MKâK ^O]VSW YVKMKU Yeni Kulvar C_UK\¾NKUS \XOUVO\S LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À `O cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ UK`\KWVK\¾X¾ KXVKcKLSVWOXSd SvSX `O\NSW 7O`M_^ U_V`K\NK NYâ\_ `O dKWKX¾XNK cKZ¾VKX UvU ]¾v\Kc¾ÀVK\ NKRK Kd \S]U `O _d_X W\ ]KâVK\ ,S\SXMS \XOU^OUS ]¾v\KWK cOXS LS\ K\KLK `O YX_X ]KâVKcKMKUVK\¾XK NSâO\SXNO RKcK^K NO`KWK O]K] YV_cY\ ½À RKcK^¾XNK NKRK ScScS QO\vOUVOÀ^S\WOU SvSX cKZ¾VKX K^KUVK\K UvU ]¾v\Kc¾ÀVK\ NScOVSW ,_ K^KUVK\¾X SRWKVS cKXV¾À UK\K\VK\ N¾À^KX YV_W]_d QOVSÀWOVO\O UK\À¾ cO^O\]SdVSU SÀVO^WOVO\SX W\X R¾dVK U¾]KV^¾\ ,_ ]YXNKX U_\^_VWKU S]O LcU ]¾v\KWKc¾ QO\OU^S\S\ kXU UvU ]¾v\KWKVK\ K\^¾U ]YX_v `O\WOcOMOU^S\ ]SQWK ^YZVKW UKVS^O cXO^SWS SXY`K]cYXOV vKV¾ÀWK `O LOXdO\S _cQ_VKWKVK\ ]KâV¾UV¾ UvU ]¾v\Kc¾À \XOUVO\SNS\ 9^_d c¾V XMO vKV¾ÀWKcK LKÀVKW¾À YVKX LS\ _X PKL\SUK]¾X¾ NÀXOVSW 9 NXOW LVQO]SXNO ^OU YVKX PKL\SUK dK- 76 WKX SvSXNO _cQ_VKXKX ^OÀ`SU _cQ_VKWKVK\¾cVK ]Kc¾VK\¾ K\^KX cOXS ^OUXYVYTSVS PKL\SUKVK\¾X LK]U¾]¾ KV^¾XNK UKV¾cY\ ½VU PKL\SUKX¾X PS\O]S PKdVK OVOU UKVS^O]S cO^O\]Sd <OUKLO^ `K\YVKX UKZK]S^OXSX vYU KV^¾XNK vKV¾ÀWKcK dY\V_cY\ 0ScK^VK\ R¾dVK NÀcY\ ,cVO NO`KW ONO\]OXSd ]YX cKU¾X ½À^O LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À SvSX UK\K\ `O\SVWO]S QO\OUOX N_\_W .SâO\ LcU ]¾v\KWK _cQ_VKWK]¾ S]O SÀVO^WOVO\NO WO`M_^ SÀVO\ ScS QSNScY\ `K\]Kc¾W¾X¾X QOvO\VS YVN_â_ N_\_WVK\NK XQ\] cU]OU ÀS\UO^ cXO^SWVO\SXMO UK\K\ `O\SVSZ cKZ¾VKXN¾\ >YcY^K Y^YWK^SU ^OU]^SV WKUSXOVO\S U_\_V_À_X_X #V_ c¾VVK\NK K\KLK \O^OX U_\_V_À N_\_W_XK NXÀ^\VWO]S% 8YUSKX¾X UKâ¾^ UKLVY `O VK]^SU SÀVO\SXS ##V¾ c¾VVK\¾X LKÀVK\¾XNK L¾\KUK\KU MOZ ^OVOPYX_ \O^WOcO LKÀVKWK]¾% SÀVO^WOVO\NO SÀVO\ ScS NO\UOX cOXS U_V`K\K LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À _cQ_VKWKVK\¾N¾\ ,cU ]¾v\Kc¾À QXNOWO QOVNSU^OX ]YX\K dKWKX YV_W]_dK vKV¾ÀWKcK LKÀVK\ 1OvOX ]\O dOWSXSX dKc¾PVKN¾â¾ RONOPSX _dKUVKÀ^¾â¾ `O ]¾v\Kc¾À¾X dY\VKÀ^¾â¾ ]\Ov^S\ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 1OMSUWO XONOXScVO RONOP U_V`K\NKX _dKUVKÀWKU NKRK Kd vKLKcVK ]¾v\KXKMKU cOXS LS\ U_V`K\¾X LOVS\VOXWO]SXS QO\OU^S\S\ =¾v\Kc¾À^K LKÀK\¾]¾dV¾U \S]US L_ ]KcONO KdKV^¾V¾\ COXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À¾ QO\OU^S\S\ 0KUK^ RO\ LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀS ]KâVKWKd COXS U_V`K\NK UKV¾M¾V¾U S]O LKÀK\¾V¾ UvU ]¾v\Kc¾ÀVK\VK YV_\ =\N\VOLSVS\ LcWO `O\SVO\S S]O cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀSX LKÀK\¾VN¾â¾X¾ Q]^O\S\ >YcY^K ^OU]^SV WKUSXOVO\S \O^SWSXNOX K\KLK \O^SWSXO LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À¾ cKZW¾À^¾\ >YcY^KX¾X cOXS U_V`K\¾XNK WÀ^O\S WOWX_XScO^SXS cKUKVKWK]¾ `O ]\N\VOLSVS\ LcWO `O\SVO\SXS ]KâVKWK]¾ cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀSX ^KWKWVKXN¾â¾X¾ UKX¾^VKW¾À^¾\ =K\K\¾X O\UOU QScSWSXSX cKX¾ ]¾\K LKcKX QScSWS SÀSXO cSXO KcX¾ WK\UK `O KcX¾ WOUKXVK\NK QS\WO]SXS MSNNS LS\ ^W]OU cK\K^WK YVK\KU Q\cY\_W >¾ZU¾ _d_X c¾VVK\N¾\ LKÀK\¾V¾ ]^ Q\_Z YPS] WYLSVcK]¾ \O^SMS]S YVKX +VZK\NKX¾X O` WYLSVcK]¾ SÀSXO QS\O\OU UK\À¾]¾XK UOXNS ^W]OâSXS v¾UK\WK]¾ `O ]YX\K O` WYLSVcK]¾ SÀSXNOX v¾UK\KU K]¾V SÀSXO cYâ_XVKÀWK]¾ QSLS .SâO\ LS\ \XOU S]O 781XSX UK\QY ^KÀ¾WKM¾V¾â¾ SÀScVO LS\VSU^O c\^WOcO vKV¾À^¾â¾ cYVM_ ^KÀ¾WKM¾V¾â¾XNKX vYU QOv YVWKNKX ]¾c\¾VWK]¾N¾\ 5_V`K\ ]KZWKVK\¾X¾ `O ^W]OUVO\S QOv YVWKNKX NdOV^WOU ]KâV¾UV¾ UvU ]¾v\Kc¾À \XOUVO\SNS\ ½ÀVO^WOVO\ U_V`K\VK\¾XNK c\\UOX vOÀS^VS XONOXVO\VO UOXNSVO\SXO OXQOVVO\ NO cK\K^¾\ ,_ OXQOVVO\ Qv UKcL¾XK QOVSÀWOXSX cK`KÀVKc¾Z RK^^K QO\ScO QS^WO]SXO XONOX YVKLSVS\ 8YUSKcK XO NOWOVS) -OZ ^OVOPYX_ SÀSXNO XMVO\NOX YV OX QdOV ^K]K\¾WV¾ OX ScS cO\OV cKd¾V¾WV¾ ^OVOPYXVK\¾ \O^^SU^OX ]YX\K L_V_XN_â_X cO\S LOâOXSZ Y\KNK UKVWKcK UK\K\ `O\ ?d_X c¾VVK\ 8YUSK U_VVKX¾M¾]¾cN¾W +\^¾U ,VKMULO\\c U_VVKX¾cY\_W /ÀSW NO cOâOXSXSX XO\S]ScVO =KW]_XQ KVN¾ .ONSUVO\SXO Q\O ^K]K\¾W¾ QdOV PScK^¾ _cQ_XW_À ,OVUS ]YX YX c¾VNK 8YUSK vYU LKÀK\¾V¾ \KUKWVK\K _VKÀW¾À^¾\ ZKdK\ NOâO\S vYU c_UK\¾VK\K _VKÀW¾À^¾\ KWK LOX cSXO NO L_ ]YX YX c¾VNK cO\SXO UYX_VKWKcKMKU LKd¾ P¾\]K^VK\¾X UKv¾\¾VN¾â¾ LKd¾ QOMSUWOVO\SX cKÀKXN¾â¾ Q\ÀXNOcSW =YUKU^KUS SX]KX SvSX À_ KXNK 8YUSK XOcS KXVK^¾cY\) /X RKPSP) /X QdOV ^K]K\¾W) /X _cQ_X PScK^) +`\_ZKV¾ YVWK]¾ `O S]WSXNOX LKÀUK =KW]_XQNKX PK\U¾ XONS\) 1OVSÀWOVO\SX vYU R¾dVK YV_À^_â_ cKU¾X NXOWNO 8YUSK OX Kd UOXNS UKNK\ LOVUS NO UOXNSXNOX NKRK ScS \O^SWVO\O ]KRSZ SÀVO^WOVO\SX v¾UKMKâ¾X¾ NÀXWÀ YV]K QO\OU 8YUSK +ZZVOSX S:RYXO K^Kâ¾XK LOXdO\ LS\ ]¾v\Kc¾ÀVK LKWLKÀUK LS\ \X v¾UK\KLSVOMOU LS\SUSW SvSX cK^¾\¾W cKZKLSVS\NS ,_X_X YVWKc¾À¾ ROW 8YUSKX¾X ROW NO ^UO^SMSXSX UKcL¾N¾\ =KLKXM¾·X¾X Q¾NK SÀVO\SXNO K^KâK QOvWO]S `O ]YX\K L_ UYX_NK ¾]\K\¾X cKXV¾À YVN_â_X_ Q\O\OU Q¾NK ]OU^\XNOX v¾UWK]¾ L_XK QdOV LS\ \XOU^S\ ½À WKUSXOVO\S \O^SWSXNO NXcK VSNO\S -K^O\ZSVVK\¾X KcKUUKL¾ WK\UK]¾ YVWK]¾ KXVKW `O\OWONSâSW LS\ QS\SÀSWNS\ ,OXMO _cQ_X YVKX¾ -K^O\ZSVVK\¾X UK\V¾ LSVO YV]K KcKUUKL¾ SÀSXS L¾\KUWK]¾N¾\ +XK SÀSXSX vYU N¾À¾XNK -K^O\ZSVVK\K LOXdO\ PKKVScO^^O L_V_XKX LKÀUK LS\ PS\WKc¾ \XOU YVK\KU `O\WOU QO\OUS\]O :Y\]MRO .O]SQX KN¾cVK QOXSÀ US^VOcO K\KLK]¾X¾ NOâSV PKUK^ WK\UKc¾ _VKÀ¾VKLSVS\ cKZKX :Y\]MRO :Y\]MROXSX @YVU]aKQOXSX UYX^\YV_ SvSX cKZ^¾â¾ K^KU SVO :Y\]MRO .O]SQX _c_W SvSXNO +MKLK NKRK QOXSÀ LS\ US^VOcVO L_V_ÀWKU @YVU]aKQOX·NO RS]]OVO\SX UYX^\YVXNO NKRK PKdVK UYVKcV¾U ]KâVKcKMKU _X]_\VK\NKX LS\S YV_\ NScO NÀXWÀ YVKLSVS\VO\ WS) +XMKU :Y\]MRO .O]SQX¾X cKcQ¾XV¾â¾ :Y\]MRO Y^YWYLSV RONOP WÀ^O\S US^VO]SXSX ^O\MSRVO\SXS dKWKX SvSXNO YV_W]_d O^USVOcOMOU^S\ 1YYQVO ]Kâ ]^_X \OUVKWVK\¾ ^W]OU^S\ 1YYQVO L_XVK\¾X UKcL¾X¾ UK\À¾VKcKMKU UvU ]¾v\Kc¾ÀVK\¾ cKZKMKU LS\SUSWO ]KRSZ^S\ ,_XVK\NKX LS\S SVU ]KcPKNK Y ]KK^ `OcK Y QX SvSX OX cU]OU \KUKW¾ `O\OX cKVX¾dMK LS\ PS\WKX¾X \OUVKW LKXN¾X¾ cKc¾XVKWKU XONOX YVWK]¾X .ÀX]OXSdO 1YYQVO SVU ]KcPKNK ^OU \OUVKW¾X cK\K^KMKâ¾ RK`Kc¾ 1YYQVO·NKUS \OUVKWVK\¾X K\KWK cKZKXVK\K RKU]¾dV¾U YVN_â_X_ NÀXWOcO LKÀVKN¾W 1YYQVO LOXSW SvSX ]YX_MK OX O\UOX _VKÀKLSVNSâSW U^ZRKXO Q\O`S Q\cY\ 0KUK^ À_ ]¾\KVK\ dOVVSUVO K\^KX ]Kâ ]^_X \OUVKWVK\¾XK QdW ^KU¾VN¾â¾ SvSX `KUS^ UKcL¾ cKÀKWKcK LKÀVKN¾W ,KXK dKWKX SVQS UKcL¾ `O UKPK UK\¾À¾UV¾â¾ cK\K^WKcKMKU SVU ]OvOXOU 1YYQVO cO\SXO QOvOMOU +cX¾ UYX_NK PK\UV¾ U_V`K\K QOvSÀ NScOMOâSWSd LS\ OMdKXO ]KRSLSXSX SVKv ^YZ^KX ]K^¾M¾V¾â¾ SÀSXO QS\WO]S% SÀVOU MKNNO ]^XNO LOcKd OÀcK ]K^¾M¾]¾X¾X KSVO]SXSX QO\OU]SXSWS SvSX OVSXNOUS WKVVK\¾ ZK\KcK vO`S\O\OU WO`M_^ cO\SXS ]SWS^ UKR`O]SXO NXÀ^\WO]S% 9]^SWNO ]SZK\SÀVO vOVSU KU]KW cKZKX PS\WK ]KRSLSXSX ]KâV¾U ]Y\_XVK\¾ XONOXScVO LS\ ]KRSV UK]KLK]¾XNK RKV¾ WKâKdK]¾ KvWK]¾ UvU SÀVO^WOVO\NO cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ YVK\KU Q]^O\OLSVS\Sd 77 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý ,S\ NSâO\ \XOU NO LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À¾X vYU LKÀK\¾V¾ cKZ¾VWK]¾XK UK\À¾X cOXS U_V`K\NK ^W]OU YV_À^_\KMKU O]UScS ¾]\K\VK ^KÀ¾WKU^¾\ DS^\YX PS\WK]¾ # V¾ c¾VVK\NK UW\ WKNOXS OUSZWKXVK\¾ \O^O\OU cO\OV ZKdK\NK LKÀK\¾V¾ YVW_À^_\ .KRK ]YX\K RK`KVKXN¾\WK PKXVK\¾ \O^SWSXO LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À cKZW¾À `O LS\ vYU ZKdK\NK VSNO\ YVK\KU vYU ]KcQ¾X _V_]VK\K\K]¾ LS\ PS\WK N_\_W_XK QOVWSÀ^S\ ,cU ]¾v\Kc¾À ]YX\K]¾ cOXS U_V`K\¾ RK`KVKXN¾\WK PKXVK\¾ SÀSXNO ]\OUVS QOVSÀOX LS\ PS\WK YVWK]¾XK UK\À¾X RKVK ]K^¾ÀVK\¾X¾X vYU UvU LS\ U¾]W¾ YVKX WKNOX OUSZWKXVK\¾ \O^SWSXS ]\N\WOU^ONS\ DS^\YX_X L_ N_cQ_]KVV¾â¾X¾ L¾\KUK\KU RK`KVKXN¾\WK ]S]^OWVO\S SÀSXO ^WcVO YNKUVKXWK]¾ ScS YVKMKU^¾\ :O^\YV SÀVOWO `O ZO^\YV \XVO\S NKâ¾^¾W SÀS 5Yv Q\_L_XNK Kâ¾\V¾âK ]KRSZ N_\_WK QOVNS ¿KcO^ L_ LS\ cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ QS\SÀSWS S]O cOXS ]K^¾X KVWKVK\ `O cK^¾\¾WVK\ QO\OUVSNS\ ¿_ KXNK OVNOX v¾UK\N¾UVK\¾ NÀU MS\YV_ SÀVO\VO ]K^WKU S]^ONSUVO\S 7SQ\Y]_X cKX¾ ]¾\K ]^\K^OTSU NScO KNVKXN¾\N¾UVK\¾ Y^YWY^S` `O LOcKd OÀcK SÀVO\SXS NO _cQ_X \KUKWVK\K L¾\KUK\KU ONSXNSUVO\S UKcXKâ¾ cOXS U_V`K\ QOvSÀSXO KU^K\WKVK\¾ QO\OUS\ ,Sd L_ SÀS cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ YVK\KU Q\WcY\_d ScS UK\ QO^S\OMOU MS\Y NO]^OUVOcSMS]S LS\ SÀ YVK\KU Q\cY\_d NScY\VK\]K YNKUVKXWKc¾ +\vOVSU ]^XO cKZKLSVS\VO\ :OUS XONOX Y^YWY^S` YVWK]¾X) 0K\UV¾ Y^YWY^S` PS\WKVK\¾ SVO LKÀK\¾V¾ \O^SW QOvWSÀVO\S `K\ +cX¾ PS\WKVK\VK cOXS ZKdK\VK\NK Y\^KU \O^SW QS\SÀSWVO\S `O NKRK ]YX\K YXVK\ SvSX L^X \O^SWS ]^VOXWOU YVKWKd W¾) 9NKU UYX_ YVK\KU NXcK vKZ¾XNK QOVSÀSVOMOU LS\ UYX_X_X ]OvSVWO]O NO 5Yv Q\_L_ cSXO LcâW NO\ 9X c¾V SvSXNO S]O LS\ NKRK NXWOWOU dO\O À_ KXNK L_V_XN_â_ SVU PS\WK VS]^O]SXO `ONK ONOLSVS\ ,cUVU U\O]OV YVWKU^KX QOvScY\ DY\V_ Q\_L_ O` ^OU]^SVS \O^SWSXO NKcKX¾UV¾ ^UO^SW WKVVK\¾ \O^SWSXS OUVONSâS dKWKX ]YX ^UO^SMScO cXOVSU LKÀK\¾V¾ \O^SW `O ZO\KUOXNO NOXOcSWS `O K^KU cKZ¾]¾ XONOXScVO LSdSW 35/+ X¾X NYâKMKâ¾X¾ RKcKV O^^SW DY\V_ Q\_L_ U¾]K ]\ONO LcU LOMO\S Q]^O\O\OU LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À¾cVK PK\UV¾ UYX_VK\NK P¾\]K^VK\¾ NO- 78 âO\VOXNS\O\OU Sv ZKdK\ RYVNSXQS YVN_ ,KÀK\¾ LcU :OUS SVU ]OvOXOU NKRK LcU LKÀK\¾c¾ ]KâVKWK QMX LK\¾XN¾\W¾cY\ W_) =KLKXM¾ Q\_L_ LOÀ ]^\K^OTSU ]OU^\Wd `K\ NScY\ ,OX L_X_ LS\ ^\V L¾\KUWKcK U¾cKWKN¾â¾W¾d MO]K\O^ ONOWONSâSWSd cO\SXO XO UYcKMKâ¾W¾d¾ L_VKWKN¾â¾W¾d _cQ_X PScK^K OVNOX v¾UK\WKc¾ LOUVONSâSWSd ]OvOXOUVO\SXNOX LS\SXS `OcK NKRK PKdVK]¾X¾ LK\¾XN¾\KX LOÀ ]OU^\NO vKV¾À¾cY\_d NScO ^O\MWO ONScY\_W CO\OV UKV¾XN¾â¾XNK VUO OUYXYWS]SXSX cK`KÀVKN¾â¾ KXNK L_ Q\_ZVK\ NXcK OUYXYWS]SXNO S]SW YVWKc¾ NÀVOcOWOcOMOU N_\_WK QS\OMOUVO\ =KW]_XQ_X cOXS U_V`K\ QOvSÀSXNO ^W Kâ¾\V¾â¾X¾ MOZ ^OVOPYX_X_ NK SvO\OX ^UO^SMS OVOU^\YXSâS SÀSXO `O\WO]S Kâ¾\ OXN]^\S `O LOXdO\S PK\UV¾ SÀVO\S OVNOX v¾UK\WK]¾ _cQ_X YVKLSVS\ 2_XNKS ÀKcO^ SÀ WKUSXOVO\S \O^SWS `O LOXdO\ SÀVO\SXS ]K^¾Z Y^YWY^S`O NKRK vYU UKcXKU ]KâVK\]K NKRK PKdVK Qv `O ]KcQ¾ ^YZVK\ 7ROXNS]VSU `O cXO^SW NORK]¾ YVKX .\2O\\OXUXOMR^ Y^_d c¾V QSLS U¾]K LS\ ]\ONO ZKdK\¾ vYU NK\ YVKX ^XOV WKUSXOVO\S SÀSXNO WSVcK\ +`\YV_U LS\ NO` cK\K^W¾À^¾\ 9X_ ]\OUVS LKÀK\¾X¾X KN\O]S ^_^KMKU SÀSXSX cKX¾ ]¾\K WO^\OcO SXOLSVOX TOY^O\WKV `O ZO^\YV U_c_]_ WKUSXO]S `O LOXdO\S \O^SWVO\O QS\WO]SXS cKN¾\QKW¾cY\_W kXU SÀ cO\KV^¾XNK _VKÀ¾W UKXKVVK\¾ KvKX ]S]^OWVO\ YVK\KU NO`KW ONScY\ ½VU QXNOX L_QXO U_``O^VS YVN_â_ XYU^K ^KVOZVO\SX XO\ONOc]O "·S dQX WKUSXO \O^SWS 0K\UV¾ ^SZ WKUSXOVO\ PK\UV¾ OXN]^\SVO\O ]_X_V_cY\ ,_ N_\_W_cVK 2O\\OXUXOMR^O UOXNS OXN]^\S]SXSX 1OXO\KV /VOM^\SMS NScOLSVS- \Sd 0K\UV¾ OXN]^\SVO\NO QOXSÀVOcOX U\O]OV `O R¾\]V¾ 9NKUVKXWK SÀVO\ cYV_XNK QSNScY\]K dY\_XV_V_U^KX v¾UK\ >O\MSR UYX_]_ YV_\ 5Yv `O =KLKXM¾ Q\_ZVK\¾ YNKUVKXWKU dY\_XNK NOâSVVO\ ½v :KdK\ 2YVNSXQVO\S 5YRVLO\Q 5\K`S] <YLO\^] `OcK -O\LO\_] QSLS LcU cK^¾\¾W PYXVK\¾XK LOXdScY\ ½v ZKdK\NK vYU LKÀK\¾V¾ \XOUVO\ LS\SUSWVO\SXS ScS cXO^O\OU LKÀK\¾V¾ PSXKX]KV Y\KXVK\ cKUKVKN¾UVK\¾ ]\OMO LS\ UYX_cK Kâ¾\V¾U `O\WOcS QO\OU]Sd LS\ ]O\`OX YVK\KU Q\OMOUVO\NS\ ½v :KdK\ RYVNSXQVO\SXSX% K\KNK LS\ v¾UKX ]^\K^OTSU UYX_VK\¾W¾d¾ LOVS\VONSU PKKVScO^ UYX_VK\¾W¾d¾ KdKV^¾cY\_d RKLO\VO\SXS ´LKÀK\¾V¾ YVN_â_W_d `OcK YVKMKâ¾W¾d SÀVO\ OU UKcXKU QO\OU^S\OMOâS SvSX LKd¾ SÀVO\S OVNOX v¾UK\KMKâ¾dµ NScO ^O\MWO ONO\Sd +â¾\V¾U `O\WOU% LSd L_ c¾V LKd¾ QOXSÀVOWO `O QOVSÀ^S\WO cK^¾\¾WVK\¾ cKZKMKâ¾d LS\ `OcK SUS PKL\SUK KVKMKâ¾d NOWOU NOâSVNS\ ,Sd cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ SvSX L^X dKWKX¾W¾d¾ `O UKcXKUVK\¾W¾d¾ KNKcKMKâ¾d NScO\OU L_ NOXSVOXS cKZWKU^¾\ ,_\KNK PK\UV¾ `OcK LOXdO\ ÀOUSVNO cK NK RSv U_VVKX¾VWKW¾À LKd¾ NOcSWVO\O UYX_cVK SVSX^SVS KXVKWVK\ cUVONSW Kv¾UVKWKVK\ QO^S\NSW n\XOâSX LcU ]¾v\Kc¾À UvU ]¾v\Kc¾À Kâ¾\V¾U `O\WOU Sv ZKdK\ RYVNSXQS cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ QSLS ½ÀVO^WOVO\SX WO`M_^^K NO`KW¾ S]\KPVK OÀ NOâO\ RKVSXS KV¾cY\]K OâO\ % cOXS U_V`K\K QOvSÀ UKcXKUVK\¾X cYU YVWK]¾X¾ XVOcOMOU QMX K\^K\KU NO`KW¾X¾ ]KâVKcKMKU^¾\ .DGLUæ7(//ì2è/8 Endüstri Mühendisi 7HFUEHPæ5RWDæ<D\çQODUçæ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý Biz Büyüdük ve ææææææææ.LUOHQGLæ'Q\D +DYDæNLUOLOLéLQLQæDUWPDVçæ R]RQæWDEDNDVçQçQæ LQFHOPHVLQHæ\ROæDoç\RUæ %XæJHUoHéLæKHSLPL]æ ELOL\RUX]æ%HONLæGHæ ELOGLéLPL]æLoLQæoRNWDQæ DOçìWçNæYHæDUWçNæHVNLVLæ NDGDUæ|QHPVHPL\RUX]æ 3HNLæ\DæVRQXoODUçQçæ KDWçUOD\DQæYDUæPç" 2K`K US\VSVSâS NYâKV NOXQOcS LYdKMKU RO\RKXQS LS\ WKNNOXSX K^WY]PO\O UK\¾ÀWK]¾cVK WOcNKXK QOVS\ 9dYX .XcK·X¾X K^WY]PO\SXSX ^KWKW¾XNK L_V_XKX LS\ QKd `O YdYX ^KLKUK]¾ SvO\NSâS QKd WYVOUVVO\S SVO dK\K\V¾ cU]OU OXO\TSVS QXOÀ ¾À¾XVK\¾X¾X cO\cdXO _VKÀWK]¾X¾ OXQOVVScY\ 8O cKd¾U US _d_X c¾VVK\ XMO LSVSW KNKWVK\¾ YdYX ^KLKUK]¾X¾X SXMOVWOcO LKÀVKN¾â¾X¾ `O L_ SXMOVWOXSX QSNO\OU NO`KW O^^SâSXS ^O]ZS^ O^^SVO\ 9dYX ^KLKUK]¾ SXMOVWOcO NO`KW ONO\]O« ½X]KX cKZ¾W¾ QKdVK\¾X SvSXNOUS WKNNOVO\SX K^WY]PO\NO cU]OVO\OU YdYX ^KLKUK]¾X¾ ZK\vKVKN¾â¾X¾ NÀXOX LSVSW KNKWVK\¾ L_ ^KLKUK SXMOVWOcO NO`KW ONO\]O QSNO\OU NKRK vYU dK\K\V¾ ¾À¾X¾X cO\cdXO _VKÀKMKâ¾X¾ `O cU]OU OXO\TSVS L_ ¾À¾XVK\¾X NK MSV^ UKX]O\SXO cYV KvKMKâ¾X¾ NÀXcY\ 2]RQæWDEDNDVçæQDVçOæLQFHOGL" # cdc¾VNK ^OUXYVYTSXSX QOVSÀWOcO LKÀVKWK]¾cVK UK^¾ `O ]¾`¾ cKU¾^VK vKV¾ÀKX WKUSXOVO\SX UW\ `O ZO^\YV vOÀS^VO\S ]Kc¾]¾ K\^¾XMK RK`K US\VSVSâS NO K\^WKcK LKÀVKN¾ 2K`K US\VSVSâS ]¾`¾ cKU¾^VK\¾X OQdYd QKd¾ YVK\KU K^WY]PO\O K^¾VWK]¾ UK^¾ cKU¾^VK\¾X S]O LKMKVK\NKX v¾UKX N_WKXVK\¾X¾X vO`\OcO NKâ¾VWK]¾ SVO YV_À^_ 2K`K US\VSVSâSXSX LS\ NSâO\ XONOXS NO U_\À_X_X U_VVKX¾W¾ ,SVSW KNKWVK\¾ KÀ¾\¾ WSU^K\NK U_\À_X_X SX]KX LOcXSXNO \KRK^]¾dV¾UVK\K cYV KvKMKâ¾X¾ LOVS\^ScY\ 2K`K US\VSVSâSXO cYV KvKX U_\À_X WSU^K\¾X¾ KdKV^WKU KWKM¾cVK NK K\^¾U U_\À_X]_d LOXdSX ]K^¾V¾cY\ 80 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý # cdc¾VNK ^OUXYVYTSXSX QOVSÀWOcO LKÀVKWK]¾cVK UK^¾ `O ]¾`¾ cKU¾^VK vKV¾ÀKX WKUSXOVO\SX UW\ `O ZO^\YV vOÀS^VO\S ]Kc¾]¾ K\^¾XMK RK`K US\VSVSâS NO K\^WKcK LKÀVKN¾ $VLWæ\DéPXUODUç 2K`K US\VSVSâSXSX LS\ NSâO\ ]YX_M_ NK K]S^ cKâW_\VK\¾ kYâ_ cKâW_\ ]_c_ vYU Kd WSU^K\NK K]S^ SvO\ScY\ +XMKU cKâW_\ ]_c_ LKd¾ US\VSVSU cK\K^KX WKNNOVO\VO LS\VOÀ^SâSXNO \XOâSX OQdYd N_WKX¾ NKRK K]S^VS LS\ RKVO QOVScY\ `O ´K]S^ cKâW_\_µ KN¾ `O\SVOX dK\K\V¾ cKâW_\ YV_À_cY\ ndOVVSUVO XORS\ `O QVVO\NO cKÀKcKX LS\vYU RKc`KX ^\ L_ K]S^ WSU^K\¾XNK cKÀKcKW¾cY\ +âKvVK\ NK K]S^ cKâW_\_XNKX dK\K\ Q\cY\ LMOUVO\SX ]KVN¾\¾]¾XK NS\OXv Q]^O\OWScY\ +]S^ cKâW_\_ dO\SXO cKâN¾â¾ UKcK QSLS cdOcVO\S O\S^SZ Yc_cY\ ,_X_X ]YX_M_XNK NK dK\K\V¾ WSXO\KVVO\ Y\^KcK v¾U¾cY\ `O L_ WSXO\KVVO\ RKc`KX `O LS^USVO\O dK\K\ `O\ScY\ .LUOLOLéLæ|QOHPHæoDEDODUç ,SVSW KNKWVK\¾ ^W L_ dK\K\VK\¾ ^O]ZS^ O^^SU^OX ]YX\K RK`K US\VSVSâSXS XVOcOLSVWOU KN¾XK vOÀS^VS vKV¾ÀWKVK\ c\^WOcO LKÀVKN¾VK\ 2K`K US\VSVSâSXO ]OLOZ YVWKcKX cKU¾^ K\Kc¾À¾ ]YX_M_XNK RK`K US\VSVSâS cK\K^WKcKX XUVOO\ OXO\TS `O vO`\O SvSX OX dK\K\]¾d YVKX NYâKVQKd L_V_XN_ 0KUK^ XUVOO\ OXO\TSXSX NO SX]KX ]KâV¾â¾ Kv¾]¾XNKX \KNcK]cYX ^ORVSUO]S ^KÀ¾WK]¾ vYU NSUUK^VS U_VVKX¾VWK]¾X¾ QO\OU^S\ScY\ .SâO\ ^K\KP^KX UK^¾ `O ]¾`¾ cKU¾^VK\NKUS dK\K\V¾ K^¾UVK\K OXQOV YVWKU SvSX PSV^\O ]S]^OWVO\S QOVSÀ^S\SVO\OU RK`K US\VSVSâS WSXSW_W NdOcO SXNS\SVWOcO vKV¾À¾V¾cY\ +DYDæNLUOLOLéLQLQæVRQXoODUç 5S\VOXWOXSX SX]KX ]KâV¾â¾X¾ ^ORNS^ O^^SâS K\^¾U LSVSXOX LS\ QO\vOU ndOVVSUVO ]YV_X_W cYVVK\¾ LYd_UV_UVK\¾ vYM_UVK\¾X cKÀV¾VK\¾X `O UKVZ]YV_X_W ]¾U¾X^¾]¾ vOUOXVO\SX RK`K US\VSVSâSXNOX U^ O^USVOXWOVO\S LcU ÀORS\VO\NO ]YV_X_W cYVVK\¾ \KRK^]¾dV¾UVK\¾X¾X KUMSâO\ UKX]O\VO\SXSX LKd¾ KVO\TSU RK]^KV¾UVK\¾X `O cY\Q_XV_U RKVSXSX ]¾UV¾UVK Q\VWO]S NO cSXO RK`K US\VSVSâSXSX ]YX_vVK\¾ K\K]¾XNK cO\ KV¾cY\ +DYDæNLUOLOLéLQLæD]DOWPDNæLoLQæ QHOHUæ\DSçODELOLU" ndOVVSUVO ]KXKcS WO\UOdVO\S `O LcU cO\VOÀSW KVKXVK\¾ dO\SXNO NKRK vYU RS]]ONSVOX RK`K US\VSVSâSXSX KdKV^¾VWK]¾ SvSX vOÀS^VS XVOWVO\ KV¾XKLSVS\ ,_ XVOWVO\S À_ ÀOUSVNO ]¾\KVKWKU WWUX$ =KXKcS `O SÀ WO\UOdVO\SXSX WWUX YVN_â_ UKNK\ cO\VOÀSW WO\UOdVO\S N¾À¾XK KV¾XWK]¾ 5YX_^VK\NK cKU¾^ cKUWK ^OUXSUVO\SXSX QOVSÀ^S\SVWO]S `O dOVVSUVO ]KXKcS KVKXVK\¾XNKUS LKMKVK\K RK`K PSV^\OVO\SXSX ^KU¾VWK]¾ Kc\¾MK cKU¾^ YVK\KU NYâKVQKd U_VVKX¾W¾X¾X cKcQ¾XVKÀ^¾\¾VWK]¾ ¿ORS\ WO\UOdVO\SXNOUS cYâ_X ^\KPSâSX vO`\O cYVVK\K KU^K\¾VWK]¾ 5SÀS]OV `K]¾^K U_VVKX¾W¾ cO\SXO ^YZV_ ^KÀ¾WKM¾V¾â¾X cKcQ¾XVKÀ^¾\¾VWK]¾ `O OVOU^\SUVS ^KÀ¾WK K\KvVK\¾X¾X QOVSÀ^S\SVWO]S `O U_VVKX¾W¾X¾X K\^¾\¾VWK]¾ +\KvVK\NK vO`\OcO NKRK Kd dK\K\ `O\OX ^OUXYVYTSVO\SX U_VVKX¾VWK]¾ NSdOV WY^Y\ ]S]^OWVO\S `L +âKvVKXN¾\WK vKV¾ÀWKVK\¾X¾X K\^¾\¾VWK]¾ dOVVSUVO RK`K US\VSVSâSXSX cYâ_X YVN_â_ cO\VO\NO cOÀSV KVKXVK\¾X cKcQ¾XVKÀ^¾\¾VWK]¾ ¿ORS\ cO\VOÀSW ZVKXVK\¾XNK WO^OY\YVYTSU PKU^\VO\SX dOVVSUVO \dQr\ N_\_W_X_X Qd XXNO L_V_XN_\_VWK]¾ 2KVU¾X RK`K US\VSVSâS UYX_]_XNK LSVSXvVOXNS\SVWO]S SvSX SVUâ\O^SWNOX LKÀVKWKU dO\O ^W YU_VVK\NK `O ]S`SV ^YZV_W \Q^VO\SXMO L_ KWKMK cXOVSU OâS^SW Z\YQ\KWVK\¾X¾X RKd¾\VKXWK]¾ .D\QDNæ%26&+æ/LIH 81 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý oVUOWSd SX]KX¾X¾ SXÀKK^ `O SÀ WKUSXKVK\¾ KVKX¾XNK ^OUXYVYTScVO `O WYNO\X SÀVO^WO ]S]^OWVO\ScVO ^KX¾À^¾\KX Z\YTO +^K^\U ,K\KT¾ :\YTO]SNS\ ½XÀKK^ ]¾\K]¾XNK +XKNYV_ LYdU¾\¾XNK cK\K^¾VKX L_ NO`K]K vKV¾ÀWK Y\^KW¾XNKX O^USVOXOX LS\ vKV¾ÀKX¾X N_cQ_VK\¾X¾X SPKNO]S YVKX L_ ÀSS\S NO\QSWSdNO NO\QSWSdNO cKc¾XVKcK\KU ]OU^\WdO vYU LcU UK^U¾ ]KâVKcKX L_ Z\YTOcS KXWKU S]^ONSU ì00% Doğudan Doğan Destan 82 1 7 13 !4!4]2+"=N=Fv{J@EJHAUEJ>EV@AJ 3=y3=DEH@A3KH3=DEH@ACa?aIaV 3QCaJA}D=R=UH=PKLN=G?`IANPPEN 6=NH{G>EVEI9KGHQG>EVEI!V>EVEI $AN@EIEVA$ANI=JKH@Q=?{I{V 6=NH{GE_EJ@AGEUKGHQGEHHAPPEN 95.53vH=N{9QJQO=N=N$AJEVv@AJ "EVAUKHC`OPANAJ>EVEI`J?aIaV &=U@=O{V"=}!U=GH=N=VEHHAPPEN 'AIE>EVEI+=LP=J>EVEI'`V>EVEI +KR=J>EVEI0APAG>EVEI3aV>EVEI -=G=J>EVEI-ARGE>EVEI+KV>EVEI 2 8 14 !N{H=N9aGHAJIE}}=JH{DEVIAPE #!@=O{"!@=O{G=UJ{UKN 9{HH=N`J?A>QG{R=I=CENOAU@EG -EHHAPEI=@{J=U=L=NVEJIAPE |=DEJ4ALAOEJ@A>=yN{IC`UJaUKN "QE}HANEJIaNaRAPEJC`NOAU@EG 9QN@QOARAJHANEJ+QPO=HDEIIAPE 2/+vH=NEHAUANUANEJ@AJKUJQUKN "KV@=yH=N=>`UHA'`yaOCANOAU@EG 6E?@=J>EVEI$QUCQ>EVEI`V>EVEI $ANA>EVEI4ALA>EVEI4KV>EVEI +KHH=N>EVEI%HHAN>EVEI$EV>EVEI 3 9 15 "Q_=>=KHO=U@{9{HH=N`J?AOE $KHQO=R=GE}EJVKNHQVKNQJ@= '`JaHHANGQNPQHOQJU=OP=JIAN=GP=J 9KGKHQN@Q9KGOQHHQyQJG=J?=O{ zJE}[{G{}+AOGEJREN=F>QNJQJ@= 3QOQV4KLN=GGQNPQH=?=G_KN=GP=J $KyQUKN$KyQvJQJDANCaRAJ?AOE #!4vH=NR{V{NR{V{N4QI>=UKHQJ@= "QJ?=U{H@{NG=J=yH=@{GGQN=GP=J -AROEI>EVEIzGHEI>EVEI9=V>EVEI !N=_>EVEI'ANA_>EVEI0KV>EVEI &{N=P>EVEI$E?HA>EVEI"aV>EVEI 4 10 16 'aI>aNPaIaV"KV=R=U{EJHAPEN 4=}K?=y{O=}_AHEG>EHAGHE #=J=H{N#=JRANEN-QG=@@AOE}HAN "EVE"EV@AJ=H{L(=GG=EHAPEN |`B`N/LAN=P`N_=P=HUaNAGHE 6=P=JC`NAREJ@APANPAIEV|}HAN |=JH{&{N=P.AHANO`UHAN@EJHAPEN %GIAGP=}P=CEVHE$AIENAHAGHE (=ONAPUKHH=N{J@=$Q=H=N@E}HAN 3ARCE>EVEI3AR@=>EVEI(=V>EVEI !VEI>EVEI'=UNAP>EVEI({NO>EVEI !J=>EVEI'AHEJ>EVEI+{V>EVEI 5 11 17 .=O{NH{AHHANEJRANEIE>QN@= -a@aNva!IENvE-aDAJ@EOvHANE !HPI{}UA@EzHv@AJCAHELPKLH=J@{G 9{G{L>KV@=yH=N{AUHA@EGDQN@= z}_EUAD{VRANENUa?ADEOANE $=y=4=}=(=J_ANCE>EO=LH=J@{G "EN]IEPU=U{H@{UQN@= 4KV$QI=JE_EJ@A"=NQPOAOHANE 'A?ACaJ@aV=UJ{D{VH=}=NPH=J@{G 3AREJ_>EVEI+{R=J_"EVEI(=V>EVEI !PA}>EVEI$QI=J>EVEI+`V>EVEI %GIAG>EVEI"QHCQN>EVEI4QV>EVEI 6 12 18 $=yH=N{AHA@EG4QI>=vH=NGQN@QG %H=_I{}>AGHEUKN(=NN=JKR=O{ "Q?AJJAP6=P=J{JG`HAOE@Ky@QG 4=}H=NH=CaNA}PEGV=I=J{UKN@QG 4aJAHHAN@AJOQE_A?AG@KU=O{ %PEHA+AIEGPAJ+=HAOEKH@QG 'AIP=G{L&{N=Pv{J`JaJA@QN@QG &AND=P=@=U=JI=V4=}{G=U=O{ $a}I=J=!,,!(v{J>AH=O{@Ky@QG 4QNJ=>EVEI\N@AG>EVEI+=V>EVEI +=VI=>EVEI+aNAG>EVEI'aNV>EVEI 3aJCa>EVEI3EH=D>EVEI'AV>EVEI ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 19 26 34 "EN>A@AJ>ENUQINQGKH@QGRQNQ}P= 4aNG/yHQUQIO=J=PG=N{IE}_EUEI "QUANGKLI=@{G_=R=P=J>`HaJIAV |`B`N/LAN=P`N4ANVE!}_{U{I !@{I!.$)-9=O=I!OH=@AHEJIAV $AIEN?E+=H{L_{$QR=N4=}_{U{I 6=P=JO{VU=}=JI=VD=PP=`HaJIAV (=V=N@=3ABAN@A3QHDP=>=N{}P= "aPaJE}_E>EN>ENEUHAU=N{}P= zJE}>EVEI9KGQ}>EVEI$aV>EVEI 20 "KU=>EVEI3{R=>EVEI$ANV>EVEI 27 $KyQ@==_{H@{%GIAGG=L{O{ zI=I>EVEI4AHGEJ>EVEI"AV>EVEI 35 [=H{}=H{IDALUa?AHOEJ@ARHAPEI "QHQJI=VA}EIEV#=JL=V=N{J@= $ARHAPEJ=@{J='!0v{JP=L{O{ 9=|ADEPU='!:z(!+.=V=N{J@= 4=}+=U=aOPaJ@AC`R@AU=L{O{ |KH!N}{J=HP{J@=!NVaVANEJ@A !G{H>EVEI&EGEN>EVEI(EO>EVEI zJO=JH{y=`NJAG#QIDQNEUAPEI |ANAB>EVEI.=IQO>EVEI)NV>EVEI 28 "=UN=G>EVEI3=J?=G>EVEI3AO>EVEI 21 !HPQJv@=J@=yGQN@QG(=NN=Jv@=:aINaP [=PH=O{J'A>ANOEJ>EJHAN?A.AINQP 0=OH{UaNAGHANAOaNAHEIRANIQP $ARHAP3Qz}HANEE}EJ>=}{J@= 36 &==HEUAPN=LKNQPKLN=GP=}{J@= &=PEDHAN9=RQVH=N!P=PaNGvHANEJ zGE>EJU{HH=N{J}KGO=R=}{J@= 3{NN{_=H{}I=GP=UANEJC`GHANEJ +Q}=G>EVEI+AIAN>EVEI\NO>EVEI 29 3aJJAP>EVEI6=?E>>EVEI&=NV>EVEI "=>=IR=NU=UH=@=@=y@=P=NH=@= 22 !J=IR=NK?=GP==}P=OKBN=@= !23,!.vH=NCE>EUEV%PPAJG=BAOPA '=|HKHI=GEIHEyEJEG=RN=@= 3=>{NH=U=}=N{VDAN>ENJABAOPA 3%#$%v@AJ!,,!(!9aGOAHAJOAOPA z-!.>EVEIzJ=_>EVEIzV>EVEI $EJEICE>E>=GEG=HO{JIEHHAPEI [=yH=N{@ARENAJ.QNHQ_=NGH=N{J 9AHE>EVEI3AHE>EVEI({V>EVEI 37 [K>=J@=J"=}G=Jv==UJ{CAIE@A 4`NA>EVEI9`NA>EVEI4=NV>EVEI GQH=GH=N=NG=@=C`VEHANE@A 30 ]_"A}{NV{C{N{GR=NO=OaNa@A &AJ4AGJEGUaGOAH@EANE}PE!Uv= 4AG@EN>EVEI+`PAG>EVEI%V>EVEI 23 %:!.)@EJHAPPE!342/./4"=Uv= 38 2%3],]-"52!+vH=_{GP{OAI=U= "=>=J$A@AJ>`H@aNIA@ER=P=J{ "AGHAUEJGKNQUQJ>KOP=J{J{V{ !N}{>EVEI+aNOa>EVEI!NV>EVEI +=LG=N=CaJHAN@AC`N@aJ!P=J{ 31 !NOH=JH=N@KyQN=J=NOH=J{J{V{ 5JQPI=3AJE_EJ|ADEPU=P=J{ !PKIU=N{}{J=CEN@EOaLANHAN |ADEP>EVEI'=VE>EVEI(=NO>EVEI 9{H@{VO=R=}{J=_{GP{OELANHAN 24 +=RC=I{VUKGOQHHQGR=NH{GG=RC=O{ -=EHEIE}@aJU=@=?=J{JUKJC=O{ 9QN@QI@=`PAIAVU=>=JG=NC=O{ |=DEJ>EVEI+=NP=H>EVEI"=V>EVEI 25 9{G{HO{JAJCAHHANG=HGO{JREN=FH=N [=HO{JB=>NEG=H=N#K}OQJ"=N=FH=N zJO=JO{VE}HAIAVDE_>EN!N=_H=N !Ga>EVEI+KJP=G>EVEI|=NV>EVEI (ANCaJ>EJHAN?A?=JGAOELG{NL=NH=N +{>HA>EVEI3A?@A>EVEI9aV>EVEI 32 #ED=J=_=yN{I{V>=N{}P=JU=J= "KN=V=J`PaJ?A>=GI=U{V?=J= "Q6=P=J>KU=J@{G=_OABANG=J= 4=NED>EVEI$ARHAP>EVEI$KV>EVEI 33 $KOP=@KOPQI$a}I=JH=N=zDP=N{I 9QN@=U=J>=G=J{J=yV{JU{NP=N{I 6QNQHOQJG`OHANEI[=HO{J-ADPANEI 3EVEJ!}{GU=V@{$AOP=J{J{V{ 4ELE>EVEI"KN=J>EVEI"QV>EVEI 39 '\:]"%.,z-$!$!,/x,5PKNQJQ 4KNKO@=yH=N{J@=JUa?AOKNQJQ 9AJIAGE_EJ@Ky@QGVKNQJVKNQJQ !UAP>EVEI(=@EO>EVEI3`V>EVEI -QOP=B=\.$%2 !4!4]2+"!2!*)#!4|\&\2] !4!3z#z,./4!|/#!x) "/:/6!|!.,)52&! q (KN=J>EVEI(=H=U>EVEI3=V>EVEI 83 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý '2è$/*$=æ.8//$1,/$1æê(+ì5/(5'(.ìæ6$1$<ì'(ææNFDOææVDDWæ,6,æì+7ì<$&,æ*(5(./ìæ 2/$1æ7h0æ<$.,7æ7h5/(5ì1ì1æ.(1'ìæìdì1'(æ0$/ì<(7æ.$5ê,/$ê7,50$æ7$%/268 æ1LVDQææWDULKLQGHæEHOLUOHQPLëæ.'9æ+DULoæIL\DWODUOD NOTLAR: ,_ ^KLVY cKU¾^VK\¾X cKUVKÀ¾U SÀVO^WO WKVScO^VO\S RKUU¾XNK PSUS\ `O\OLSVWOU SvSX RKd¾\VKXW¾À YV_Z LS\SW PScK^VK\K " 5.@ 2+<½k>½< ½ÀVO^WO `O\SWSXSX LS\ LVW Y\^KVKWK `O\SW NOâO\VO\SXSX SvO\S]SXNO YV_Z cKU¾^ RKd¾\VKWK NOZYVKWK SÀVO^WO QSNO\VO\S `L cKU¾^ cKUWK cKX WKVScO^VO\S NO L_ NOâO\S O^USVOWSÀ^S\ 9^YWK^SU UYX^\YV U_VVKX¾W¾ LKU¾W `O SÀVO^WO UKVS^O]S QSLS XONOXVO\VO `O\SW cU]OV^SVSZ NKRK _cQ_X WKVScO^VO\ YV_À^_\_VKLSVS\ ½]^KXL_VNK ½1.+¿ ,_\]KNK ,?<=+1+D /]USÀORS\NO /=1+D 5YMKOVSXNOUS ½D1+D¾X +XUK\KNKUS ,+¿5/8>1+D¾X NYâKVQKd PScK^VK\¾ # 8S]KX ^K\SXNOUS ÀORS\ QKd NKâ¾^¾W NKâ¾^¾W ÀS\UO^SXSX ^K\SPOVO\SXNO LOVS\^SVOX PScK^VK\N¾\ US KcV¾U o0/ Y\KXVK\¾X¾X NOâSÀSWSXO Q\O LOVS\VOXWOU^ONS\ =O\LO]^ >UO^SMS 9VKX NYâKVQKd U_VVKX¾M¾VK\¾X¾X LS\SW PScK^VK\¾ c¾VV¾U WSVcYX W QKd U_VVKX¾W¾X¾X ]^XNO U_VVKXKXVK\ SvSX YV_Z =O\LO]^ >UO^SMS 9VWKcKXVK\¾X LS\SW PScK^VK\¾ S]O UYX_^ `O ^SMK\S SÀcO\VO\SXNO U_VVKXKXVK\VK KcX¾N¾\ 681=¾`¾VKÀ^¾\¾VW¾À NYâKVQKd LS\SW PScK^VK\¾ ½]^KXL_V ,YâKdSvS NOXSd QOvSÀS WKVScO^VO\S dOV `O LOVONScO PO\SLY^VK\¾XK Q\O LcU PK\UV¾V¾UVK\ K\dO^^SâSXNOX L_ LONOV OUVOXWONOX `O +`\_ZK `O +XKNYV_ cKUK]¾ Kc\¾W¾ cKZ¾VWKNKX Y\^KVKWK YVK\KU `O\SVWSÀ # 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO QOvO\VS YVKX ½:<+1+D PScK^VK\¾N¾\ 6:1 ^ZQKd `O NUWOQKd PScK^VK\¾ # 8S]KX ^K\SRS S^SLK\ScVO ½Z\KQKd `O +cQKdNKX KV¾XW¾À PScK^VK\¾X Y\^KVKWK]¾N¾\ UQV¾U ]KXKcS ^ZXX 5.@ NKRSV # >6KNO^ PScK^¾ U_VVKX¾VW¾À^¾\! /VOU^\SU PScK^¾ 9MKU ^K\SRSXNO cKc¾WVKXKX `O # 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO QOvO\VS YVKX >/.+¿¾X .SâO\ >W .Kâ¾^¾W =S]^OWS 5_VVKX¾M¾VK\¾ SvSX .Kâ¾^¾W ¿S\UO^SXNOX /XO\TS +VKX >UO^SMSVO\O >OU >O\SWVS `O >OU DKWKXV¾ ^K\SPONO LOVS\^SVOX +VvKU 1O\SVSW LS\SW PScK^¾XK% ]KXKcS U_VVKX¾W¾XNK ><> ZKc¾ `O OXO\TS PYX_ SvSX ,OVONScO /VOU^\SU >UO^SW @O\QS]S SvSX S]O SVK`O ONSVWSÀ 5.@]Sd PScK^^¾\ " /VOU^\SU U_VVKX¾W¾XNKUS ¾]¾^WK MSRKd¾ OVOU^\SUVS ¾]¾^¾M¾ YV_Z ¾]¾ ZYWZK]¾ U_VVKX¾W¾XNK MSRKd¾X -9: ]S]^OW `O c¾VV¾U NOâO\VO\S U_VVKX¾VWKV¾N¾\ # 7Y^Y\SX LS\SW PScK^¾ >6UQ =2/66SX # 8S]KX ^K\SRVS ZYWZK ]K^¾À PScK^VK\¾ ]S\UVO\SXNOUS >6VS^\O NOâO\S " NXÀW UK^]Kc¾]¾XK LVXO\OU L_V_XW_À^_\ +UK\cKU¾^ PScK^VK\¾ /:.5 ^K\KP¾XNKX Kv¾UVKXKX =2/66 ^K\KP¾XNKX ^K`]ScO ONSVOX # 8S]KX ^K\SRVS ½]^KXL_V +`\_ZK CKUK]¾ WKRKVVS KUK\cKU¾^ 5.@VS ]K^¾À PScK^VK\¾ KV¾XW¾À^¾\ 3]¾^WK `O Z\Y]O]^O U_VVKX¾VKX cKU¾^ ^\ YVK\KU 7Y^Y\SX 5¾\]KV ^SZS ^O\MSR ONSVNSâS SvSX WY^Y\SX cKU¾^¾XNK L_ ^SZSX PScK^VK\¾ NSUUK^O KV¾XWKU^KN¾\ +UK\cKU¾^ KV^ ¾]¾V NOâO\VO\S >Z\KÀ >OUXSU =O\`S]VO\ 7N\VâXNOX 7K\^ ^K\SXSXNO `O\SVOX NOâO\VO\NS\ CO\VS VSXcS^ UW\ PScK^¾ # 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO QOvO\VS YVKX >5½ /6½XSX 5¾]\KUNO\O c¾UKXW¾À " WW ZK\vKV¾ ^Y\LK MSX]S SvSX +\KV¾U " ^K\SRVS 3]¾XWK +WKvV¾ >Y\LKVKXW¾À 5W\VO\SX ,KcS .OZY =K^¾À 0ScK^VK\¾ VS]^O]SXNOX KV¾XW¾À YV_Z ½]^KXL_V SvSX ! >6^YX YV_Z \O^SW cO\S PScK^¾XK% " UWVSU ½]^KXL_V=YWK K\K]¾ _dKUV¾â¾X XKUVScO LONOVS >6^YX `O LKcS UK\ WK\T¾ SvSXNO YVKX 5.@]Sd PScK^^¾\" c¾V¾XNKUS VS]^OVO\NOUS LS\SW PScK^VK\ XKUVScO RK\Sv^S ½^RKV ]SLS\cK UW\ PScK^VK\¾ 2KUKX 5W\ ÀS\UO^SXSX% # 8S]KX ^K\SRVS MO`Sd ^SZS VSXcS^ SvSX XKUVScO M\O^S `O 5.@ .+2½6 ^KU]S^VS ]K^¾À PScK^¾ YVKX >6^YX P¾XN¾U ^SZS " WW VSXcS^ SvSX XKUVScO M\O^S ½]^KXL_V vO`\O SVvOVO\SXO `O 5.@ .+2½6 ]K^¾À PScK^¾ YVKX ^YX YVK\KU KV¾XW¾À^¾\ 7SU] NUWOQKd¾X U_VVKX¾W¾XNK L_RK\VKÀ^¾\¾M¾ QO\OUWOU^ONS\ ½ÀVO^WO WKVScO^VO\S QdXXO KV¾XWKW¾À^¾\ ,9>+¿ ¾X 9=, `O =KXKcScO ]K^^¾â¾ NYâKVQKd¾X LS\SW PScK^¾XK >6=W YVKX n>@ NKRSV ONSVWSÀ # 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO QOvO\VS YVKX ]S\UVO\NOUS PScK^VK\N¾\ 84 Etkinliklerimiz ve Haberler ´¾Á0DNLQDODU¿0KHQGLVOHUL%LUOL½L¾00%%LOJL3D\ODÁ¿P¿¾oLQ'H½LÁLN6HPLQHU2UJDQL]DV\RQODU¿ ¾OHh\HOHULQLYH6HNW|U7HPVLOFLOHULQL%LUDUD\D*HWLUPH\H'HYDP(GL\RUµ 6$3æ§$QDKWDU¨æ(WNLQOLéL ½À 7KUSXKVK\¾ 7ROXNS]VO\S ,KÀK\¾V¾ CXO^SWSX ´+XKR^K\¾X¾µ +VN¾VK\ ½77, `O =+: +V^¾X ½À 9\^Kâ¾ kdWO`S .KX¾ÀWKXV¾U ^K\KP¾XNKX LS\VSU^O Y\QKXSdO ONSVOX =+: ´+8+2>+<µ O^USXVSâS # ¿_LK^ ^K\SRSXNO +XUK\K +^V¾ =ZY\ 5V_L·XNO QO\vOUVOÀ^S ½À `O SXÀKK^ WKUSXKVK\¾ ]OU^\XX _dWKXVK\¾X¾ LS\ K\KcK QO^S\OX ]OWSXO\O SVQS vYU PKdVKcN¾ ]OWSXO\ ]YX_XNK ½77, cOVO\S `O ]OU^\ ^OW]SVMSVO\S KUÀKW cOWOâSXNO kdWO`S .KX¾ÀWKXV¾U PS\WK]¾X¾X UYX_â_ YVN_VK\ kdWO`S .KX¾ÀWKXV¾U SXÀKK^^KKRR^WROXNS]VSU `O YZO\K]cYXVK\¾ ÀS\UO^VO\S SvSX ]_XN_â_ OX^OQ\O cKd¾V¾W YVKX =+:·XSX KXKR^K\ UKZ]KW¾X¾ ]OU^\ _dWKXVK\¾XK KU^K\N¾ =OU^\X UKc¾ZVK\¾X¾X XXO QOvWOU `O UYX^\YV ]KâVKWKU dO\O QOVSÀ^S\SVOX =+: vdW ´+8+2>+< µ 5/C ]KcO]SXNO% ^W OUSZWKXVK\ WKUSXKVK\ ]K^¾XKVWKVK\ `O KWLK\VK\ OX^OQ\O LS\ LSvSWNO `O ^OU WO\UOdNOX ^KUSZ KV^¾XK KV¾X¾cY\ kdWO`S 1OXOV 7N\ 2KUKX kYVKU ½XÀKK^ ÀS\UO^VO\SXSX LKÀV¾MK ]¾U¾X^¾]¾ YVKX WSVcYX NYVK\V¾U WKUSXKVK\¾X ^KUSLSXSX ]K^¾XKVWK ]SZK\SÀVO\SXSX `O YXKcVK\¾X¾X cXO^SVWO]SXSX L_XK LKâV¾ YVK\KU KWLK\VK\¾X WKVdOWO N_\_W_ `O RK\OUO^VO\SXSX ´+XKR^K\µ ]\OvVO\ YVK\KU KNVKXN¾\¾VN¾â¾X¾ SPKNO O^^S `O ]dUYX_]_ ]S]^OWSX L_ ]\OvVO\SX OX ScS ÀOUSVNO ^KUSZ ONSVWO]SXO P¾\]K^ `O\NSâSXS LOVS\^^S =OWSXO\NO =+:·XSX NXcK cKd¾V¾W ZKdK\¾XNKUS VSNO\ ZYdS]cYXNKUS ZKc¾XNKX `O >\UScO·NOUS \XOU _cQ_VKWKVK\NKX ]d ONOX kdWO`S .KX¾ÀWKXV¾U :KdK\VKWK `O =K^¾À 7N\ +dKNO kO\UOdYâV_ S]O ÀS\UO^VO\SX OX^OQ\O ]S]^OWO QOvWONSUVO\S RO\ QXX WKNNS LS\ UKc¾Z YVN_â_XK NSUUK^ vOU^S 5HNDEHWæhVWQOéæYHæ0DUNDODìPDæ 6HPLQHULªQHæ.DWçOGçNæ +`\_ZK ½ÀVO^WOVO\ +â¾ :\YQ\KW¾ UKZ]KW¾XNK 59=1/, 9=>½7 ½ÀVO^WO 1OVSÀ^S\WO 7O\UOdS `O <OUVKW`O\OXVO\ .O\XOâS SÀLS\VSâSXNO " 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO ,SVUOX^ 9^OV `O 5YXQ\O 7O\UOdSXNO ´<OUKLO^ o]^XVâ `O 7K\UKVKÀWK 5YXPO\KX]¾µQO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVWSÀ^S\ 59=1/, `O <@. XSX U_\_W]KV LSVQSVO\SXS ZKcVKÀWKU `O 59,½·VO\O KU^K\WKU SvSX NdOXVONSâS UYXPO\KX] 59=1/, ,KÀUKX¾ 7_]^KPK 5+:6+8 `O <@. ,KÀUKX¾ +RWO^ :?<+·X¾X Kv¾V¾À UYX_ÀWKVK\¾ SVO LKÀVKN¾ 5YXPO\KX]^K +\vOVSU·^OX >\U >OVOUYW·K >OUXY]K·NKX :\YM^O\ 1KWLVO `O ½À ,KXUK]¾·XK NXcK vKZ¾XNKUS LS\vYU WK\UK \OUKLO^vS ZKdK\NK WK\UKVKÀWKU SVO SVQSVS UOXNS ^OM\LOVO\SXS 59,½·VO\ SVO ZKcVKÀ^¾ ´<OUKLO^ o]^XVâ `O 7K\UKVKÀWKµ UYX_V_ UYXPO\KX]^K WK\UKVKÀWK UK^U¾VK\¾ YVK\KU% \X `O ÀS\UO^VO\ Kv¾]¾XNK Kc\¾À^¾\¾M¾ Q`OX `O\SMS KVQ¾ `O SVQS cK\K^WK]¾ ^O\MSR ]OLOLS YVWK]¾ cU]OU UK\ WK\T¾ `O ÀS\UO^ NOâO\SXS cU]OV^WO]S QSLS dOVVSUVO\O NSUUK^ vOUSVNS 86 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý $OIDWHNæ*UXSæ§æ0RELOæ.çUçFçODU¨ ½77, `O +60+>/5 1<?: ^K\KP¾XNKX LS\VSU^O Y\QKXSdO ONSVOX ´ 7YLSV 5¾\¾M¾VK\µ UYX_V_ O^USXVSU # 7K\^ ^K\SRSXNO +XUK\K +^V¾ =ZY\ 5V_L·XNO cKZ¾VN¾ SEKTÖRDEN HABERLER 7HNQRPDNæ$ê XSX ½]^KXL_V 5K\^KV·NKUS cOXS YPS] LSXK]¾ 7Kc¾] NK Q\UOWVS LS\ ^\OXVO Kv¾VN¾ >OUXYWKU +¿ CX5\,À =K\_RKX =K\¾YâV_·X_X SÀ^S\KU O^^SâS Kv¾V¾À^K% >OUXYWKU vKV¾ÀKXVK\¾X¾X cKX¾]¾\K MS`K\¾XNKUS NK`O^VSXSX NO cO\ KVWK]¾ NSUUK^VO\S vOU^S =37 Q\_Z +X^YXSY .·KWSMY SVO .cXKZKM `O +^VK] -YZMY Q\_Z NK LKÀ^K >RYWK] 2Y\XPOVN YVWKU dO\O OX ]^ NdOc UK^¾V¾WVK >OUXYWKU·¾X cKX¾XNKcN¾ ½]^KXL_V QSLS LS\ WO^\YZYVNO K\^¾U WÀ^O\SVO\SXSX cKX¾ LKÀ¾XNK RSdWO^ `O\OMOU YVWKX¾X ROcOMKX¾ >OUXYWKU cO^USVSVO\SXSX XO\ONOc]O QdVO\SXNOX YU_XN_ =KXN`SU PS\WK]¾X¾X ´2SN\YVSU 5KcK 5¾\¾M¾VK\ `O 7YLSV 5¾\¾M¾VK\µ ¶¾X >\UScONOUS ]K^¾À `O ]K^¾À ]YX\K]¾ RSdWO^VO\ SVO SVQSVS PKKVScO^VO\SXS LKÀK\¾cVK c\^WOU^O YVKX +60+>/5 1<?: ]OWSXO\S PS\WKVK\¾X ^KX¾^¾W UYX_ÀWKVK\¾ SVO LKÀVKN¾ +VPK^OU `O =KXN`SU PS\WKVK\¾X¾X ^KX¾^¾WVK\ ]¾\K]¾cVK +VPK^OU 1\_Z +XUK\K ,VQO =K^¾À 7N\ 2KVS 5/=5½8 `O =KXN`SU 7KNOXMSVSU `O ½XÀKK^ 1OXOV 7N\ <¾dK >9:<+5k3 ^K\KP¾XNKX cKZ¾VN¾ ´7YLSV 5¾\¾M¾VK\¾X 5_VVKX¾VN¾UVK\¾ CO\VO\ `O .XcKNKUS 1OVSÀSWSµ SVO ´=KXN`SU 7YLSV 5¾\¾M¾VK\¾X¾X ndOVVSUVO\Sµ ]¾\K]¾cVK /\OX +VZ nD96 =K^¾À 7N\ =KXN`SU `O 7O]_^ 1½<½> ½]^KXL_V ,VQO =K^¾À 7N\ +VPK^OU 1\_Z ^K\KP¾XNKX cKZ¾VKX QdOV ]_X_WVK\VK UK^¾V¾WM¾VK\VK ZKcVKÀ¾VN¾ ½77, cOVO\S `O ]OU^\ ^OW]SVMSVO\SXSXSX YVN_UvK cYâ_X LS\ UK^¾V¾W ]KâVKN¾â¾ `O SVQScVO SdVONSâS ]OWSXO\ ]YX\K]¾ `O\SVOX cOWOU^O NK`O^VSVO\ +VPK^OU 1\_Z PS\WK]¾X¾X UYX_â_ YVN_VK\ +v¾V¾À >\OXS >\UScO·XSX XNO QOVOX UK\KcYV_ W^OKRRS^VO\SXS LS\ K\KcK QO^S\S\UOX% LS\vYâ_X_X NK CXO^SW 5_\_V_ ,KÀUKX¾ ]O`ScO]SXNO UK^¾VN¾â¾ QdVOXNS .cXKZKM -+ " . WYNOV ^YZ\KU -- 20 WYNOV K]PKV^ -- WYNOV ^KXNOW cKWK ]SVSXNS\VO\S `O =. - WYNOV K]PKV^ PSXSÀO\SXSX NO ]O\QSVOXNSâS Kv¾V¾À¾X K]¾V Qd UKWKÀ^¾\KX c¾VN¾d¾ S]O =37 =, WYNOV K]PKV^ ZVOX^S YVN_ >OUXYWKU cO^USVSVO\S ]YX c¾VVK\NKUS K]PKV^ ZVOX^S ZKdK\¾XNKUS VSNO\VSUVO\SXO cKU¾À¾\ ÀOUSVNO YPS]VO\SXSX XXO U_\N_UVK\¾ ZVOX^ SVO NK`O^VSVO\O MSNNS LS\ ÀYU cKÀK^^¾ ½]^KXL_V ]K^¾À YPS]VO\SXSX >OUXYWKU +¿ XO `O K]PKV^ ]OU^\XO RKc¾\V¾ YVWK]¾X¾ NSVO\Sd 87 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý SEKTÖRDEN HABERLER .$581æ§1HGHQæ7UHQoHU"¨ DHUQHNæ\HPL]ææ6Qæ.HQDQæ6$5$d2è/8 +âK- YâV_ 1\_Z LXcO]SXNO cO\ KVKX +UNOXSd ½XÀKK^ PS\WK]¾XNK WKUSXK SUWKV WN\ YVK\KU Q\O`O LKÀVKN¾ =X =+<+k9»6?·XK cOXS Q\O`SXSX RKc¾\V¾ `O _â_\V_ YVWK]¾X¾ NSVO\Sd+âKYâV_ 1\_Z ´CKÀKW 7SWK\¾µ ]VYQKX¾cVK VU] UYX_^ `O ]YX c¾VVK\NK OXO\TS ]OU^\XNO cK^¾\¾W cKZWKU^KN¾\ 3]^KXL_V_X RO\ SUS cKUK]¾XNK 7c AY\VN /V^O] 1YVN 7c <Y]O`SVVO LS^S\NSâS 7c >YaO\VKXN 7c >YaX NO`KW ONOX Z\YTOVO\SXNOXNS\ +UNOXSd SXÀKK^ L^X SXÀKK^ PKKVScO^VO\SXS c\^OX KV^ PS\WK]¾N¾\ ìOHWLëLPæ%LOJLOHUL $GUHV +UNOXSd SXÀKK^ `O /âS^SW 2SdWO^VO\S +¿ +âKYâV_ 7c AY\VN ! ,K^¾ +^KÀORS\ 3]^KXL_V 7HOæ "! 0KU]$ ""! :(% aaaKQKYQV_MYW^\ (SRVWD UOXKX]K\KMYQV_*KQKYQV_MYW^\ *60æ! !# .O\XOU cOWSd 6Qæ 6HGDWæ ë(.(5 ,+Ck/6 SXÀKK^ `O >KKRR^ +¿ NO WKUSXK SUWKV WN\ YVK\KU 5K\]>SPVS],KU .OWS\cYV_ SXÀKK^¾X¾X ! UW·VSU >\UScO UO]SWS Q\O`O LKÀVKN¾ =X ¿/5/<· O cOXS Q\O`SXSX RKc¾\V¾ `O _â_\V_ YVWK]¾X¾ NSVO\Sd ,KcL_\^ 1\_Z `O kOVSUVO\ 2YVNSXQ +¿ " c¾V¾XNK LS\ K\KcK QOVO\OU ,+Ck/6 SXÀKK^ `O >KKRR^ +¿· cS U_\N_ ,+Ck/6 1\_Z% ½XÀKK^ ]OU^\XNO% 9^YcYV 5Z\ .OWS\cYV_ ,SXK 5YX_^ 5KXKVSdK]cYX CKâW_\ ]_c_ SvWO]_c_ +^¾U]_ .O\O 3]VKR¾ 1VO^ .OUKZKT 2Kd¾\ ,O^YX 7KNOXMSVSU ]OU^\XNO% 5W\ `O WO\WO\ \O^SWS >_\SdW ]OU^\XNO% 9^OV SÀVO^WOMSVSâS /XO\TS ]OU^\XNO% 2SN\YOVOU^\SU =KX^\KVVO\SXNOX OVOU^\SU \O^SWS cKZWKU^KN¾\ ìOHWLëLPæ%LOJLOHUL ,+Ck/6 1<?: $GUHV$ kYLKX C¾VN¾d¾ =U 8Y$! kKXUKcK +85+<+ 7HOæ ! " )D[æ " # :(%æaaaLKcMOVQ\_ZMYW^\ (SRVWDæSXPY*LKcMOVQ\_ZMYW^\ =ONK^ ¿/5/< $GUHV ,+Ck/6 1\_Z 5K\]>SPVS] .OWS\cYV_ ½XÀKK^¾ 5+<= 7HO ! " )DNV ! " ! *60 ## (SRVWDæ]OUO\]ON*cKRYYMYW ]OUO\]ONK^*RY^WKSVMYW 88 ½77,·XSX 8S]KX ^K\SRVS ^YZVKX^¾]¾ ´>\OXvO\ >OUXYVYTS]Sµ QXNOWS SVO >/=7/- WWO]SVS 5+<?8 ]ZYX]Y\V_â_XNK cKZ¾VN¾ 5+<?8 0S\WK]¾ 1OXOV 7N\ 4OYVYTS CU]OU 7ROXNS]S 9\U_X nd^_XK ^K\KP¾XNKX ]_X_VKX ´8ONOX >\OXvO\µ LKÀV¾UV¾ ]_X_W ]OvUSX 377, cOVO\S `O NK`O^VSVO\ ^K\KP¾XNKX SVQS SVO SdVOXNS =_X_W ]YX\K]¾ `O\SVOX cOWOU^O YVN_UvK cYâ_X LS\ ]Y\_ ^\KPSâS SVO UK\À¾VKÀKX 5+<?8 0S\WK]¾ cO^USVSVO\S Q]^O\SVOX SVQSNOX ½77, cOVO\S `O NK`O^VSVO\ S]O UYX_X_X vYU Z\YPO]cYXOVMO OVO KV¾XWK]¾XNKX YVN_UvK WOWX_X Q\XcY\N_ ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 7UNL\Hææ$YXVWXU\Dæ<DSçæ6HNW|Uæ 2UWDNOçéçædDOçìWD\ç +`_]^_\cK +XUK\K >SMK\O^ 7]^OÀK\V¾â¾ `O ½¿½7 5WO]S Y\^KU vKV¾ÀWK]¾cVK LKÀVKcKX Y\QKXSdK]cYX 9]^SW59=1/, ½1/7 `O .O\XOâSWSdSX NO]^OâScVO NdOXVOXNS .dOXVOXOX Z\YQ\KW¾X KWKM¾% +`_]^_\cK `O >\UScO·NOX ½¿½7 5WO]S·XNOX +V^cKZ¾ ² ½À `O ½XÀKK^ 7KUSXOVO\S ² ½XÀKK^ 7KVdOWOVO\S ² :\YTOVOXNS\WO ]OU^\XNOUS PS\WKVK\¾X K\KVK\¾XNK SÀLS\VSUVO\S YV_À_W_X_ ]KâVKWKU^¾ +`_]^_\cK·NKX L_ ]OU^\NO L_V_XKX cONS PS\WK `O +`_]^_\cK +XUK\K >SMK\O^ 7]^OÀK\V¾â¾ UK^¾V¾\UOX +XUK\K·NKX KcX¾ ]OU^\NO LS\vYU 59,S `O SVQSVS U_\_WVK\ vKV¾À^KcK cYâ_X SVQS Q]^O\NS 0_K\ KVKX¾XNK +`_]^_\cKNKX `O +XUK\K 9]^SW·NOX UK^¾VKX PS\WKVK\ UOXNSVO\SXO KS^ ]^KXNVK\NK PS\WKVK\¾X¾ `O \XVO\SXS ^KX¾^^¾VK\ ½USVS Q\ÀWOVO\SX cKZ¾VN¾â¾ KVKXNK YVK]¾ SÀLS\VSUVO\SXSX NO ^OWOVS K^¾VW¾À YVN_ .O\XOâSWSdSX NO ]^KXN¾ SVO UK^¾VN¾â¾ UYXPO\KX] O^USXVSVO\S vO\vO`O]SXNO ^KX¾^¾W NYUWKXVK\¾W¾d `O PKKVScO^VO\SWSd +`_]^_\cK ^OW]SVMSVO\S `O SÀSW UWO]S cO]S PS\WKVK\VK ZKcVKÀ¾VN¾ SEKTÖRDEN HABERLER .O\XOU cOWSd 6QæêUIDQæ.2'$/ 1V]KX =S\UO^VO\ 1\_L_·XNK =_NKX4_LK WKUSXK SUWKV WN\ YVK\KU Q\O`O LKÀVKN¾ =X 59.+6·K cOXS Q\O`SXSX RKc¾\V¾ `O _â_\V_ YVWK]¾X¾ NSVO\Sd CYV Y^YcYV cKZ¾ RKd¾\ LO^YX UZ\ `ScKNU `O Z\OUK]^ cKZ¾ OVOWKXVK\¾ cKZ¾W ]OU^\VO\SXNO PKKVScO^ Q]^O\OX 1V]KX 1\_Z c¾V¾XNKX S^SLK\OX _V_]VK\K\K]¾ KVKXNK vKV¾ÀWKVK\ LKÀVK^W¾À YV_Z% +PQKXS]^KX 3\KU 5KdKUS]^KX 6SLcK =¾\LS]^KX =__NS +\KLS]^KX ?U\KcXK `O LKd¾ 5\POd VUOVO\SXNO PKKVScO^O QOvWSÀ^S\ ,_XVK\¾X cKX¾ ]¾\K 1V]KX cOXS cKZ¾VKXWK]¾X¾X ZK\KVOVSXNO cOXSVOXOLSVS\ OXO\TS QKd LO^YX `O WKNOX QSLS KVKXVK\NK NK cK^¾\¾W ]\OMS SvSXNONS\ ìOHWLëLP%LOJLOHUL $GUHV 1V]KX :VKdK<dQK\V¾ ,KRvO 7KR -_WR_\ScO^ -KN8Y$ 5K`KM¾U,OcUYd ½]^KXL_V 7HOæ " )D[æ " #! :(% aaaQ_V]KXMYX]MYW^\ (SRVWD S\PKXUYNKV*Q_V]KXMYX]MYW^\ &HSæ ! $QNDUDæ%|OJHæ3URMHæ7DEDQOçæ%HFHULæ <DUçëPDVçægGOOHUL 7/, /\UOU >OUXSU nâ\O^SWS 1X 7N\VâXX UYY\NSXO]SXNO ]S cKZ¾VKX # â\O^SW c¾V¾ +XUK\K ,VQO :\YTO >KLKXV¾ ,OMO\S CK\¾ÀWK]¾ ]YX_XNK NO\OMOcO QS\OX YU_V `O U_\_WVK\K NVVO\S 7K\^ -_WK QX 1o ½U^S]KNS `O ½NK\S ,SVSWVO\ 0KUV^O]S C¾V 5YXPO\KX] =KVYX_·XNK QO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVOX LS\ ^\OXVO `O\SVNS ½USVS Q\ÀWOVO\SX K\N¾XNKX +`_]^_\cK·NKX QOVOX UK^¾V¾WM¾VK\ +XUK\K 9=, =SXMKX 9=,·NO cO\ KVKX ½¿½7 5WO]S cO]S +]PKV^ :VOX^S \O^SWS cKZKX kO]KX·¾ `O kKU¾M¾ `O =YXNKT 7KUSXKVK\¾ cKZKX ndUKXVK\ 7KUSXK· c¾ dScK\O^ O^^SVO\ 7O]VOUS `O ^OUXSU OâS^SWS ^KX¾^WKU cKcQ¾XVKÀ^¾\WKU XS^OVSâSXS K\^^¾\WKU `O WO]VOUS OâS^SW `O\OX YU_VVK\NK Z\YTO \O^SVWO]SXS ]KâVKWKU KWKM¾cVK c\^VOX vKV¾ÀWKVK\NK â\OXMSVO\SX â\O^WOXVO\S QdO^SWSXNO \O^^SUVO\S Z\YTOVO\VO UK^¾VN¾UVK\¾ cK\¾ÀWK UK^OQY\SNO QO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVNS ,KÀUKXV¾â¾X¾ À_LO WN\ CKÀK\ ,KUS +6>?8,+¿·¾X cKZ^¾â¾ NV ^\OXSXO vYU ]Kc¾NK NK`O^VS UK^¾VW¾À 7/, /\UOU ^OUXSU â\O^SW QX WN 2]OcSX +-3< `O +XUK\K 7/7 `OUSVS +RWO^ :+6+ LS\O\ UYX_ÀWK cKZW¾ÀVK\N¾\ /^USXVSâO NO]^OU `O\OX .O\XOâSWSdS NV ^\OXSXNO 7O]VOU 5_\]_ 7N\Wd =X 7_]^KPK =+<+6 ^OW]SV O^WSÀ^S\ (WNLQOLNOHULQL]Læ'HUQHéLPL]OHæSD\ODëDUDNæGHUJL PL]LQæ§6HNW|Uæ+DEHUOHUL¨QGHæ\HUæDODELOLUVLQL] 89 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 'HUQHéLPL]LQææ*HQHOæ.XUXOXæ*HUoHNOHìWLæææ1LVDQæ ! 9VKâKX 1OXOV 5_\_V_W_d 8S]KX >K\SRSXNO .O\XOâSWSdSX ?dKcvKâ¾ -KNNO]S ! 9]^SW+85+<+ KN\O]SXNOUS WO\UOdSXNO LKÀK\¾cVK QO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVNS 1OXOV 5_\_V_W_d .S`KX ,KÀUKXV¾â¾ ]OvSWS SVO LKÀVKN¾ .O\XOU cOWSd `O .XOW CXO^SW 5_\_V_ ,KÀUKX¾W¾d 7_dKPPO\ 5nC6o NS`KX LKÀUKX¾ 7_\K^ -9¿1?8 LKÀUKX cK\N¾WM¾]¾ <¾dK ,+53< cKdWKX cO ]OvSVNS =KcQ¾ N_\_]_XNKX ]YX\K QXNOW Yc LS\VSâS SVO UKL_V ONSVNS .XOW CXO^SW 5_\_V_ ,KÀUKX¾W¾d ._\KX 5+<+k+C `O .OXO^SW 5_\_V_ ,KÀUKX¾W¾d 0KSU =9C6? ]¾\K]¾cVK .O\XOU `O SU^S]KNS ½ÀVO^WO PKKVScO^ `O NOXO^SW \KZY\VK\¾X¾ YU_N_VK\ ocOVO\SX Yc LS\VSâS SVO .O\XOU `O ½U^S]KNS ½ÀVO^WO CXO^SW `O .OXO^SW U_\_VVK\¾X¾X SL\K ONSVWO]SXNOX ]YX\K cKZ¾VKX ]OvSWVO\NO ]OvSVOX K]¾V `O cONOU cOVO\S SVO cXO^SW `O NOXO^SW U_\_V_ Q\O` NKâ¾V¾WVK\¾ 8S]KX ^K\SRSXNO cKZ¾VKX SVU cXO^SW U_\_V_ ^YZVKX^¾]¾XNK KÀKâ¾NKUS ÀOUSVNO YV_À^_ ocOVO\SWSdSX `O ]OU^\ vKV¾ÀKXVK\¾W¾d¾X NK NO]^OâScVO _VKÀ^¾â¾W¾d L_ XYU^KNKX cSXO YXVK\¾X UK^U¾VK\¾ SVO .O\XOâSWSdS NKRK SVO\ScO ^KÀ¾cKMKâ¾W¾dK SXKX¾cY\_d ì00%æ<|QHWLPæ.XUXOXææ ._\KX 5+<+-+C ,KÀUKX 7_]^KPK =36:+1+< ,KÀUKX `OUSVS =OVKWS -+6½=5+8 ,KÀUKX `OUSVS ,Kc\KWKVS 5n=+ 7_RK]SZ ocO 2KVSV 965+8 CKdWKX ocO 7_\^KdK ,?<1+D ocO 7_RS^^SX ,o5/< ocO ì00%æ'HQHWLPæ.XUXOX 0KSU =9C6? ,KÀUKX >_\QKc 5+<138 ocO >_âLK ./73<,+1 ocO 90 ì00%æ<|QHWLPæ.XUXOXæ <HGHNæh\HOHUL =KL\S +D½D9»6? 2KVSNO <+=½7 0O\\_R -/<½>9»6? 7_R]SX o8+6 +V^KX Co5=/6 7 +USP 3<536+>+ -OXU nD0½.+8 ì00%æ'HQHWLPæ.XUXOXæ <HGHNæh\HOHUL - -OW .9<5/8 =OLKRK^^SX +538 7_\K^ -9¿1?8 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLPOHUL .DP\RQæ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLPL +XK^YVSKWSXK\KV] PS\WK]¾X¾X ½VSv /\dSXMKX·NKUS +V^¾X 7KNOXS ÀKX^ScO]SXNO cUVOXSMS PS\WK YVK\KU vKV¾ÀKX k½0>+C ½8¿ + ¿·XSX ]Y]cKV ]Y\_WV_V_U Z\YTO]ScVO c\ONOX S]^SRNKW ONOMOâS UKWcYX ÀPY\VO\SXO cXOVSU ´CYV .¾À¾ 5KWcYX 9ZO\K^\µ OâS^SWS 8S]KX ^K\SRVO\S K\K]¾XNK v RKP^KV¾U OâS^SW Z\Yâ\KW¾ QO\vOUVOÀ^S\SVNS 0S\WKX¾X PSVY]_XK cOXS UK^^¾â¾ 7/<-/./= UKWcYXVK\K cXOVSU OâS^SWVO\ ^OY\SU `O _cQ_VKWKV¾ YVK\KU cKZ¾VN¾ æêXEDWæ2SHUDW|UæHéLWLPL æ0DUWæ2SHUDW|UæHéLWLPL 91 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý æ0DUWæ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP æ0DUWæ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP æ1LVDQæ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP 92 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý æ0DUWææ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP æ0DUWæ1LVDQææ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP æ1LVDQææ2SHUDW|Uæ(éLWLP 93 ýö0$.ý1$/$5,0h+(1'ý6/(5ý%ý5/ýûý'(51(ûý 0HVOHNæ(éLWLPOHUL æêXEDWææææ0DUWææ0HVOHNLæ(éLWLPL æ0DUWææ0HVOHNLæ(éLWLPL æ1LVDQææ0HVOHNLæ(éLWLPL 94 æ1LVDQææ0HVOHNLæ(éLWLPL
Benzer belgeler
+LGUROLNو<Déو7HPL]OLN .ç\DVODPDODUç
.D\QDNæNRQWUROæWDKULEDWOçæWDKULEDWVç]æWHVWOHUæìHNOLQGHæ\DSçOPDNWDGçUæ7DKULEDWOçæNRQWUROOHUæND\QDNæ\HWHUOLOLNæWHVWæSDUoDODUçæND\QDNoçæYH\Dæ
RSHUDW|UæVHUWLILNDODQGçUPDVçæWHVWæSDUoDODUçQGDæ\DæGDæ...
istatistik - sem - Mimar Sinan Güzel Sanatlar Üniversitesi
içe r isind e te k stil üre tim in i n g e l i ş i mi ve d ön e mi n s osyal , e ko n omi k ve
siya si o lay la r ın e tk isiy le mod an ı n o l u ş u mu , 1 9 0 0 ’ l e rd e n 1 9 80 ’ l i yı l l ...