forschungszeıtschrıft über alevıtentum und bektaschıtentum

forschungszeıtschrıft über alevıtentum und bektaschıtentum

$5'$+$1<g5(6ø'$0$/$/(9ø/(5ø1'(³+$..$<h5h0((5.Æ1,´
g/h0/(ø/*ø/øø1$1,ù9(8<*8/$0$/$5
$%675$&7
<5''2d'5=(.ø8<$1,.
gö5*g5$5ø).$/$
$OWKRXJKGHDWKLVDXQLYHUVDOIDFWIRUDOOKXPDQEHLQJVUHDFWLRQVWRGHDWKDQGSHUFHSWLRQVRIGHDWKE\SHRSOHV
PD\YDU\DFFRUGLQJWRWKHFXOWXUDOHQYLURQPHQWV7RJHWKHUZLWKELUWKDQGPDUULDJHGHDWKLVDPRQJWKHWXUQLQJ
SRLQWV RI KXPDQ OLIH /LNH RWKHU WXUQLQJ SRLQWV GHDWK DQG FHUHPRQLHV RI IXQHUDO DUH DOVR SUDFWLFHG DORQJ
ZLWKDQXPEHURIWUDGLWLRQDQGULWXDOV,QWKLVVWXG\ZHIRFXVHGRQEHOLHIVDQGUHOLJLRXVSUDFWLFHVRI$OHYL
FRPPXQLW\LQ$UGDKDQ3UHSDUDWLRQRIWKHERG\IRUEXULDOEXU\LQJWKHERG\WUDGLWLRQVUHODWLQJWRDIWHUEXULDO
DQGEHYHUDPHQWLQ$UGDKDQ$OHYLVDUHPDLQGLPHQVLRQVRIWKHVWXG\0DLQPHWKRGVRIWKLVVWXG\DUHSDUWLFLSDQW
REVHUYDWLRQV DQG LQGHSWK LQWHUYLHZV ,QGHSWK LQWHUYLHZV ZHUH FRQGXFWHG ZLWK UHOLJLRXV OHDGHUV GHGH RI
$OHYLVZKRDUHOLYLQJLQ'DPDODVXESURYLQFHRI$UGDKDQPDLQO\LQKDELWHGE\$OHYLV,QDGGLWLRQWRWKH
LQWHUYLHZVIXQHUDOFHUHPRQ\RIDPHPEHURI$OHYLFRPPXQLW\ZDVDWWHQGHG%HFDXVHRIWKHIDFWWKDWWKHUHLVQR
SUHYLRXVUHVHDUFKLQWKLVVXEMHFWRXUVWXG\LVDSLRQHHULQJVWXG\2XUVWXG\LVLPSRUWDQWIRUDOVRLWVHPSKDVLV
RQWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQ$OHYLVDQG6XQQLVLQWHUPVRIGHDWKDQGIXQHUDOV
Keywords 3ULQFLSOHVRI+DNND<UPHGHDWKIXQHUDO$OHYLVRI$UGDKDQ'DPDO
35,1&,3/(62)³+$..$<h5h0(´,1
$/(9,62)$5'$+$1'$0$/%(/,()6
$1'35$&7,&(6&21&(51,1*72'($7+
ÖZET
gOP HYUHQVHO ELU ROJX ROVD GD EX ROJXQXQ ELUH\VHO
YH WRSOXPVDO G]H\GH DOJÕODQÕú ELoLPOHUL |OPH NDUúÕ
WDNÕQÕODQ VRV\DO WDYÕUODU YH JHOLúWLULOHQ WHSNLOHU LoLQGH
EXOXQXODQNOWUHOoHYUHYHVDKLSROXQDQLQDQoVLVWHPL
JLEL ELU GL]L ED÷ODPVDO IDNW|UQ HWNLVL\OH IDUNOÕOÕN
J|VWHUPHNWHGLU gOP GR÷XP YH HYOHQPH LOH ELUOLNWH
LQVDQ KD\DWÕQÕQ HQ |QHPOL G|QP QRNWDODUÕQGDQ
ELULQL ROXúWXUPDNWDGÕU 'L÷HU G|QP QRNWDODUÕ JLEL
|OP GH ELU GL]L DGHW D\LQ YH W|UHQ HúOL÷LQGH WHFUEH
HGLOPHNWHGLU %X WU ³JHoLú´ DúDPDODUÕQGD \HULQH
JHWLULOHQ X\JXODPDODU W|UHQOHU YH D\LQOHU WRSOXPVDO
JUXSODUÕQ NOWUHO \DSÕODUÕQÕQ |QHPOL ELU ER\XWXQX
PH\GDQD JHWLUPHNWHGLU %XUDGDQ KDUHNHWOH EX
oDOÕúPDGD $UGDKDQ $OHYLOHULQGH |OPQ DOJÕODQÕúÕ
|OQQ GHIQH KD]ÕUODQPDVÕ GHIQHGLOPHVL YH GH¿Q
VRQUDVÕDGHWYHX\JXODPDODUÕHOHDOÕQDFDNWÕUdDOÕúPDGD
\DSÕODQGÕUÕOPÕúJ|UúPHYHNDWÕOÕPFÕJ|]OHPWHNQLNOHUL
NXOODQÕOPÕúWÕU$UGDKDQ¶ÕQ'DPDOøOoH¶VLQGHNL$OHYLGLQL
'LH *ODXEHQVYRUVWHOOXQJHQ XQG 3UDNWLNHQ GHV
7RGHVVULWXDOVGHU$OHYLWHQLQGHU5HJLRQYRQ$UGDKDQ
'DPDO)
Zeki UYANIK1$ULIKALA2
=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ
$XFK ZHQQ GHU 7RW HLQ XQLYHUVHOOHV (UHLJQLV LVW KlQJW
GLH LQGLYLGXHOOH XQG JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH 5HDNWLRQ DXI GHQ
7RG GHVVHQ :DKUQHKPXQJ XQG GDV VR]LDOH 9HUKDOWHQ LP
$QJHVLFKW GHV 7RGHV YRQ HLQHU 5HLKH YRQ )DNWRUHQ DE
GLHYRQGHQNXOWXUHOOHQXQGUHOLJL|VHQ8PZHOWLQGHUZLU
OHEHQJHSUlJWVLQG6RZLHGHU7RGVWHOOHQDXFK*HEXUWXQG
+RFK]HLWHLQHQ:HQGHSXQNWLP/HEHQGHU0HQVFKHQGDU
:LHDOOH:HQGHSXQNWLPPHQVFKOLFKHQ/HEHQZLUGDXFKGHU
7RGPLWHLQHU5HLKHYRQ5LWXDOHQXQG=HUHPRQLHQEHJOHLWHW
'LHVH 5LWXDOH XQG )HLHUOLFKNHLWHQ GLH GHQ &KDUDNWHU
HLQHV³hEHUJDQJV³KDEHQELOGHQHLQHQZLFKWLJHQ7HLOGHV
NXOWXUHOOHQ *HELOGHV YRQ PHQVFKOLFKHQ *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ
/HKUEHDXIWUDJWHUDQGHU:LUWVFKDIWVZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ)DNXO
/HKUEHDXIWUDJWHUDQGHU:LUWVFKDIWVZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ)DNXO
WlWGHU8QLYHUVLWlW$UGDKDQ7UNHL
2/HKUEHDXIWUDJWHUDP6HPLQDUIU6R]LRORJLHDQGHU)DNXOWlW
IU$QWKURSRORJLHXQG/LWHUDWXUGHU8QLYHUVLWlW$UGDKDQ7UNHL
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
|QGHUOHUOH GHGHOHUOH \DSÕODQ J|UúPHOHUH HN RODUDN
$OHYL FHPDDWLQH ED÷OÕ \DúOÕ ELU PHUKXPXQ FHQD]HVLQH
LúWLUDNHGLOHUHNGR÷UXGDQJ|]OHP\DSÕOPÕúWÕU$UGDKDQ
$OHYLOHUL\OH LOJLOL |OP YH FHQD]H W|UHQOHUL\OH LOJLOL
GDKD|QFHVLQGHQoDOÕúPD\DSÕOPDGÕ÷ÕQGDQEXoDOÕúPD
DODQÕQGDLONROPD|]HOOL÷LWDúÕPDNWDGÕU&HQD]HYHGH¿Q
NRQXODUÕQGD$OHYL YH 6QQL JHOHQHNOHU DUDVÕQGDNL ELU
NÕVÕP IDUNOÕOÕNODUD LúDUHW HGLOPHVL GH oDOÕúPDQÕQ GL÷HU
|QHPOLELUER\XWXQXROXúWXUPDNWDGÕU
$QDKWDU.HOLPHOHU+DNND<UPHgOP&HQD]H
7|UHQL$UGDKDQ$OHYLOHUL'DPDO
*ø5øù
*HQHORODUDNKDONELOLPLQNRQXVXRODQJHoLúDúDPDODUÕ
GR÷XPHYOLOLNYH|OPD\QÕ]DPDQGDVRV\RORMLQLQ
GH oDOÕúPD DODQÕQD JLUPHNWHGLU %X VRV\DO ROJXODU
NOWUOHULQ GRNXVX KDNNÕQGD ELOJL YHUPHNOH ELUOLNWH
VRV\DO \DúDPOD LOJL WXWXP DOJÕ YH WHSNLOHULQ GH DQD
QHGHQOHUL RODUDN NOWUHO \DSÕGDNL IDUNOÕODúPDODUÕQ
JQFHOKD\DWWDQHJLELSUDWLNOHUDUDFÕOÕ÷ÕLOH\DQVÕGÕ÷ÕQÕ
J|VWHUPHVLEDNÕPÕQGDQ|QHPOLGLU.DoÕQÕOPD]YHJHUL
G|QúROPD\DQELUVRV\DOROJXRODQ|OPGR÷XPYH
HYOHQPHLOHELUOLNWHLQVDQKD\DWÕQÕQHQ|QHPOLG|QP
QRNWDODUÕQGDQ ELULQL ROXúWXUPDNWDGÕU 'L÷HU G|QP
QRNWDODUÕQGD ROGX÷X JLEL |OP ROJXVX HWUDIÕQGD GD
X\JXODQJ|]HWLOHQ ELU GL]L DGHW D\LQ YH W|UHQOHULQ
YDUOÕ÷Õ ELOLQPHNWHGLU gUQHN¶LQ ³JHoLú´
RODUDN DGODQGÕUGÕ÷Õ EX G|QP QRNWDODUÕ HWUDIÕQGD
\R÷XQODúDQD\LQYHDGHWOHULQDPDFÕLQVDQÕQEX\HQL
GXUXPXQXNXWODPDNNXWVDPDND\QÕ]DPDQGDGDEX
VÕUDGD\R÷XQODúWÕ÷ÕQDLQDQÕODQWHKOLNHOHUGHQYH]DUDUOÕ
HWNLOHUGHQNRUXQPDNWÕU%XWU³JHoLú´DúDPDODUÕQGD
\HULQH JHWLULOHQ X\JXODPDODU W|UHQOHU YH D\LQOHU
WRSOXPVDO JUXSODUÕQ NOWUHO \DSÕODUÕQÕQ |QHPOL ELU
ER\XWXQXPH\GDQDJHWLUPHNWHGLU
gOPH YH FHQD]H W|UHQLQH GDLU KHPHQ hemen
ELOLQHQ WP NOWUOHULQ NHQGLOHULQH KDV NXUDOODUÕ
YH QRUPODUÕ RODJHOPLúWLU %XUDGDQ KDUHNHWOH EX
oDOÕúPDGD $UGDKDQ $OHYLOHULQGH |OPQ DOJÕODQÕúÕ
|OQQ GHIQH KD]ÕUODQPDVÕ GHIQHGLOPHVL YH GH¿Q
VRQUDVÕ DGHW YH X\JXODPDODUÕ HOH DOÕQDFDNWÕU 6RV\DO
QRUPODUÕQ YH SUDWLNOHULQ E\N ELU NÕVPÕQGD úDKLW
ROGX÷XPX]PRGHUQLWHQLQGH÷LúWLULFLYHG|QúWUF
$XVJHKHQG KLHUYRQ EHKDQGHOW GLHVHU $UWLNHO GLH
7RGHVYRUVWHOOXQJHQXQGGLH3UDNWLNHQLP=XVDPPHQKDQJ
PLW GHU 9RUEHUHLWXQJ DXI GLH %HVWDWWXQJ GHU %HVWDWWXQJ
VHOEVW XQG GHU =HLW QDFK GHU %HVWDWWXQJ GHU $OHYLWHQ
>DXV GHU 5HJLRQ@ YRQ $UGDKDQ 'LH $UEHLW KDW KLHUEHL
*HEUDXFK YRQ %HREDFKWXQJV XQG 3DUWL]LSDWLRQVVWXGLHQ
XQG ,QWHUYLHZV JHPDFKW 1HEVW DXVIKUOLFKHQ ,QWHUYLHZV
PLWUHOLJL|VHQ)KUHUQGHGHVLP.UHLV'DPDOLQ$UGDKDQ
ZDU HV DXFK P|JOLFK GLH %HVWDWWXQJ HLQHV YHUVWRUEHQHQ
*HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGV JHQDXHU ]X EHREDFKWHQ 'D YRUKHU
NHLQH 6WXGLHQ EHU GDV 7RGHV XQG %HVWDWWXQJVULWXDO GHU
$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQV JHPDFKW ZXUGH VWHOOW GLH YRUOLHJHQGH
6WXGLH HLQH 3LRQLHUDUEHLW GDU (LQH DQGHUH :LFKWLJNHLW
EHVLW]W XQVHUH 6WXGLH DXIJUXQG GHU 7DWVDFKH GDVV HV DXI
GLH8QWHUVFKLHGHEHLGHQ7RGHVXQG%HVWDWWXQJVULWXDOHQ
GHU$OHYLWHQXQGGHU6XQQLWHQHLQJHKW
6FKOVVHOZ|UWHU 7RG >³KDNND \UPH³ Z|UWO ³]X *RWW
JHKHQ³@%HVWDWWXQJVULWXDO$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQV'DPDO
(LQIKUXQJ
hEHUJlQJHZLH*HEXUW+RFK]HLWXQG7RGGLHJHPHLQKLQ
*HJHQVWDQG GHU 9RONVNXQGH VLQG ZHUGHQ DXFK YRQ GHU
6R]LRORJLH HUIRUVFKW 'LHVHV VR]LRORJLVFKH *HELOGH JLEW
$XIVFKOXVV EHU GLH *UXQGVWUXNWXUHQ GHU .XOWXUHQ (V
LVW GDUEHU KLQDXV VHKU EHGHXWHQG GD HV XQV .HQQWQLVVH
YHUPLWWHOWZLHVLFKGLHNXOWXUHOOHQ8QWHUVFKLHGHLQ%H]XJ
DXI 3UDNWLNHQ LP DOOWlJOLFKHQ /HEHQ PDQLIHVWLHUHQ GLH
YRQ GHQ (LQVWHOOXQJHQ XQG GHU 5HDNWLRQHQ LQ %H]XJ DXI
GDV VR]LDOH 9HUKDOWHQ UKUHQ 'HU XQYHUPHLGOLFKH 7RG
VWHOOW QHEHQ GHU *HEXUW XQG GHU +HLUDW KLHUEHL DOV HLQ
VR]LRORJLVFKHV 3KlQRPHQ HLQHQ :HQGHSXQNW LP /HEHQ
GHU0HQVFKHQGDUXQGHVJLEW±ZLHDXFKEHLGHQDQGHUHQ
:HQGHSXQNWHQ ± HLQH 5HLKH YRQ %UlXFKHQ 5LWXDOHQ
XQG =HUHPRQLHQ LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW GHP 7RG 'HU
=ZHFN GHU %UlXFKH XQG 5LWXDOH LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW
GLHVHQ :HQGHSXQNWHQ GLH ÖRNEK ³hEHUJlQJH³ QHQQW3
LVWHVGDVVGHU0HQVFKGLHVHQHXHQ*HJHEHQKHLWHQIHLHUW
E]Z KHLOLJW XQG VLFK JOHLFK]HLWLJ YRU GHQ *HIDKUHQ XQG
GHP hEHO YRQ GHQHQ PDQ JODXEW GDVV VLH LQ VROFKHQ
0RPHQWHQ ]XQHKPHQ VFKW]W $OOH +DQGOXQJHQ
=HUHPRQLHQ XQG 5LWXDOH LQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW GLHVHU
$UWYRQ³hEHUJlQJHQ³VWHOOHQHLQHQZLFKWLJHQ$VSHNWGHV
NXOWXUHOOHQ*HELOGHVYRQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQGDU
3 ÖRNEK 6HGDW 9H\LV $QDGROX )RONORUXQGD gOP '7&)
<D\ÕQODUÕ$QNDUD6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
HWNLVLQL |OPH LOLúNLQ DOJÕODUGD QRUPODUGD YH
SUDWLNOHUGHGHJ|]OHPOHPHNPPNQRODELOPHNWHGLU
gOPQ PH\GDQD JHOGL÷L WDULKVHO G|QHPOHULQ
YH VRV\DO ED÷ODPODUÕQ GH÷LúPHVLQH ED÷OÕ RODUDN
|OP HWUDIÕQGD \DSÕODQDQ DGHW YH W|UHQOHULQ GH
|QHPOL GH÷LúLNOLNOHUH X÷UDGÕ÷Õ J|VWHULOPLúWLU %N]
*ODVHU YH 6WUDXV %X oHUoHYHGH $UGDKDQ
$OHYLOHULQLQ |OP ROJXVX HWUDIÕQGD \R÷XQODúDQ
DGHW YH SUDWLNOHULQGH \DV úHNLOOHUL GH¿Q LúOHPL
|OPQGX\XUXOPDVÕYE]DPDQODQHJLELGH÷LúLPOHU
\DúDQGÕ÷Õ QH WU XQVXUODUÕQ GH÷LúPHGHQ YDUOÕ÷ÕQÕ
VUGUG÷ oDOÕúPDQÕQ |QHPOL ER\XWODUÕQGDQ ELULQL
ROXúWXUPDNWDGÕU$OHYLOLNJHQHORODUDNøVODPoHUoHYHVL
LoHULVLQGH GH÷HUOHQGLULOHELOHFHN ELU LQDQo VLVWHPL
ROPDVÕQDUD÷PHQøVODP¶ÕQKHWHURGRNVELU\RUXPXQD
WHNDEO HWPHNWHGLU %X \]GHQ $OHYLOLNOH øVODP¶ÕQ
RUWRGRNV \RUXPX RODQ 6QQLOLN DUDVÕQGD |OPOH YH
FHQD]HW|UHQLLOHLOJLOLQRUPODUYHSUDWLNOHUNRQXVXQGD
ELUWDNÕPIDUNOÕOÕNODUPHYFXWWXUdDOÕúPDPÕ]ÕQ|QHPOL
D\DNODUÕQGDQELULVLQLGHEXIDUNOÕOÕNODUÕQEHOLUOHQPHVL
ROXúWXUPDNWDGÕU
/LWHUDWUGH |OP NRQXVX ]HULQH H÷LOHQ NDSVD\ÕFÕ
WHRULN ELU \DNODúÕP ROGX÷X V|\OHQHPH] %XQXQOD
ELUOLNWH(PLOH'XUNKHLPVSHVL¿NELU|OPúHNOLRODQ
LQWLKDU]HULQHJHoHUOLOL÷LQLE\N|OoGHJQP]H
GHN VUGUHQ |QHPOL oDOÕúPDODU \DSPÕúWÕU 'LQLQ YH
GLQL W|UHQOHULQ WRSOXP LoLQGH VRV\DO GD\DQÕúPD\Õ
DUWÕUÕFÕ |]HOOLNOHULQH GLNNDW oHNHQ 'XUNKHLP¶GHQ
HWNLOHQHQ IRQNVL\RQDOLVW HNRO oHUoHYHVLQGH GLQL
W|UHQOHULQ ELUOHúWLULFL LúOHYOHUL ]HULQGH |QHPOL
oDOÕúPDODU\UWOPúWUgUQH÷LQ0HUWRQEXWUGHQ
W|UHQOHULQDoÕNYHNDSDOÕROPDN]HUHLNLWULúOHYLQGHQ
EDKVHWPLúWLU 'XUNKHLP¶GHQ EX \DQD LúOHYVHOFLOHU
³NXUXPODúPÕúYH\HUOHúPLúELUGLQLQRUWDNGH÷HUOHU
\DUDWPDN YH WRSOXOXNOD |]GHúOHúWLUPHN VXUHWL\OH
WRSOXPXEWQOHúWLUHELOHFH÷LQLEHOLUWPHNH÷LOLPLQGH
ROPXúWXU´:DOODFHYH:ROI%XDQODPGD
$OHYLOHUGHNLFHQD]HW|UHQOHULYHEXW|UHQOHUHWUDIÕQGD
\D\JÕQOÕN J|VWHUHQ DGHWOHULQ FHPDDW \HOHULQL ELU
DUD\D JHWLUPH YH FHPDDW LoL GD\DQÕúPD\Õ DUWÕUÕFÕ
LúOHYOHUL ROGX÷XQX V|\OHPHN \DQOÕú ROPD\DFDNWÕU
1LWHNLP %DOÕNHVLU dHSQLOHUL ]HULQH oDOÕúPD \DSDQ
ùDKLQELUFDQÕQKDNND\UG÷QGX\DQ
KHUNHVLQ WP PHúJXOL\HWLQL ELU NHQDUD EÕUDNDUDN
FHQD]H W|UHQLQH YH GH¿Q LúOHPOHULQH NDWÕOPDNOD
\NPO ROGX÷XQX EHOLUWPHVL EX GXUXP LoLQ L\L
:LU KDEHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ EHU IDVW DOOH 5HJHOXQJHQ XQG
1RUPHQ LQ %H]XJ DXI GDV 7RGHV XQG %HVWDWWXQJVULWXDO
YRQGHQXQVEHNDQQWHQ.XOWXUJHPHLQVFKDIWHQ,PZHLWHUHQ
9HUODXI ZHUGHQ XQV LQ GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ $UEHLW GHU
9RUVWHOOXQJYRP7RGGHU9RUEHUHLWXQJDXIGLH%HVWDWWXQJ
GHU %HVWDWWXQJ XQG GHQ 3UDNWLNHQ QDFK GHU %HVWDWWXQJ
EHL GHQ $OHYLWHQ $UGDKDQV ZLGPHQ :LU ZHUGHQ DXFK
GHQ YHUZDQGHOQGHQ XQG XPIRUPHQGHQ (LQÀXVV GHU
0RGHUQHDXI9RUVWHOOXQJHQ5HJHOXQJHQXQG3UDNWLNHQLP
=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGVHKHQN|QQHQ$XVGLHVHP
*UXQG ELOGHQ GLH )UDJHQ LQZLHZHLW GLH %UlXFKH XQG
3UDNWLNHQ GHU$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQV LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW
GHP7RGZLH]%LKUH$UW]XWUDXHUQGLH%HVWDWWXQJGLH
%HQDFKULFKWLJXQJEHUGHQ7RGHLQHV0HQVFKHQVLFKEHU
GLH=HLWYHUlQGHUWKDEHQXQGZHOFKH(OHPHQWVLFKQLFKW
YHUlQGHUWKDEHQXQGELVKHXWHEHVWHKHQHLQHQZLFKWLJHQ
7HLOGLHVHU$UEHLW
2EZRKOGDV$OHYLWHQWXPHLQ*ODXEHQVV\VWHPLVWGDVVPDQ
LQQHUKDOE GHV ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQVKRUL]RQWHV GHU LVODPLVFKHQ
5HOLJLRQ GHXWHQ NDQQ JLEW HV MHGRFK DXFK KHWHURGR[H
(OHPHQWH $XV GLHVHP *UXQG EHVWHKHQ HLQH 5HLKH YRQ
8QWHUVFKLHGHQ ]ZLVFKHQ GHP $OHYLWHQWXP XQG GHU
RUWKRGR[HQ$XIIDVVXQJ GHV ,VODPVGHP6XQQLWHQWXPLQ
%H]XJ DXI 5HJHOXQJHQ XQG 3UDNWLNHQ LQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ
PLW GHP 7RGHV XQG %HVWDWWXQJVULWXV (LQ DQGHUHU
ZHVHQWOLFKHU7HLOXQVHUHU$UEHLWEHVWHKWHEHQGDULQGLHVH
8QWHUVFKLHGHKHUDXV]XDUEHLWHQ
0DQ NDQQ QLFKW EHKDXSWHQ GDVV HV LQ GHU /LWHUDWXU HLQH
XPIDVVHQGH WKHRUHWLVFKH +HUDQJHKHQVZHLVH DQ GDV
7KHPDGHV7RGHVJHEHQZUGH>$EHU@(PLOH'XUNKHLPV
$UEHLWHQ EHU GHQ 6HOEVWPRUG HLQHU VSH]LHOOHQ )RUP
GHV 7RGHV ± GLH ]X GHQ ZLFKWLJVWHQ$UEHLWHQ LQ GLHVHP
=XVDPPHQKDQJJHK|UHQKDEHQLKUH*OWLJNHLWELVKHXWH
QLFKW YHUORUHQ 9RQ GHU YRQ 'XUNKHLP EHHLQÀXVVWHQ
IXQNWLRQDOLVWLVFKHQ6FKXOHZXUGHQZLFKWLJH$UEHLWHQEHU
GHQ YHUHLQLJHQGHQ &KDUDNWHU YRQ UHOLJL|VHQ =HUHPRQLHQ
JHPDFKW GLH GHQ I|UGHUQGHQ (LQÀXVV GHU 5HOLJLRQ XQG
UHOLJL|VHQ =HUHPRQLHQ DXI GLH 6ROLGDULWlW LQQHUKDOE
GHU *HVHOOVFKDIW EHWRQHQ 6R KDW ]% MERTON YRQ ]ZHL
GLUHNWHQ XQG LQGLUHNWHQ )XQNWLRQHQ YRQ GLHVHU $UW YRQ
=HUHPRQLHQ JHVSURFKHQ 6HLW 'XUNKHLP ZDU HV GDV
9JO GLASER % *STRAUS$ / $ZDUHQHVV RI '\LQJ 1HZ
<RUN$OGLQH
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
ELU |UQHNWLU $OHYL WRSOXPXQXQ IHUWOHULQLQ FHQD]H
NRQXVXQGDNL GLQL LQDQo ND\QDNOÕ GX\DUOÕOÕNODUÕ YH
|OP ROD\ÕQÕQ PH\GDQD JHOPHVLQLQ JUXS ]HULQGH
\DUDWWÕ÷Õ GD\DQÕúPD GX\JXVX EX oDOÕúPD\D \|QHOLN
RODUDN \UWOHQ NDWÕOÕPFÕ J|]OHPOHUOH GH WHVSLW
HGLOPLúWLU
.DWÕOÕPFÕ J|]OHP YH \DSÕODQGÕUÕOPÕú PODNDW
EX oDOÕúPDGD NXOODQÕODFDN EDúOÕFD \|QWHPVHO
DUDoODUGDQGÕU.RQXQXQQLWHOL÷LQLWHOLNVHO\|QWHPOHUOH
oDOÕúPD\Õ]RUXQOXNÕOPDNWDGÕU%X NRQXGDGDKD|QFH
oRN D] VD\ÕGD DUDúWÕUPD \DSÕOPÕú ROPDVÕ QLWHOLNVHO
\|QWHPOHU NXOODQÕOPDVÕQÕQ HQ |QHPOL VHEHELGLU
%X \D]ÕGD XODúÕODQ ELOJLOHULQ ELU NÕVPÕ $UGDKDQ
$OHYLOHULQLQ\R÷XQRODUDN\DúDGÕNODUÕ<XNDUÕ*QGHú
YH (VNLNÕOÕo N|\OHULQGH IDUNOÕ ]DPDQODUGD \DSÕODQ
GH¿Q W|UHQOHULQH GR÷UXGDQ NDWÕOPDN VXUHWL\OH HOGH
HGLOPLúWLU .DWÕOÕPFÕ J|]OHPLQ \DQÕ VÕUD LNL $OHYL
GHGHVL\OH $OL (NEHU *|JWHNLQ YH 0XVD 0úWHNLQ
FHP HYL J|UHYOLVL |O \ÕND\DQ NLúL \X÷XFX øVPDLO
$NGHPLU YH 'DPDO PHUNH]GH PXKWDU $OL (NEHU
ÇalhanLOHGHULQOHPHVLQHPODNDWJHUoHNOHúWLULOPLúWLU
$UGDKDQ'R÷X$QDGROX%|OJHVL¶QLQNX]H\GR÷XVXQGD
EXOXQXU 6RV\RORMLN RODUDN IDUNOÕ HWQLNNOWUHO
YH GLQVHO JUXSODUÕ EDUÕQGÕUPDNWDGÕU $UGDKDQ
$OHYLOHUL |]HOOLNOH 'DPDO YH +DQDN LOoHOHULQGH
\R÷XQODúPÕúODUGÕU %XQXQ GÕúÕQGD $UGDKDQ 0HUNH]
YH *|OH LOoHVLQGHNL ED]Õ N|\OHUGH GH $OHYLOHU
EXOXQPDNWDGÕU 'DPDO YH +DQDN LOoHOHULQGHNL
$OHYLOHULQNHQGLOHULQL7UNPHQRODUDNWDQÕPODGÕNODUÕ
YH .DKUDPDQPDUDú¶GDQ 0DUDú$OWÕQ EX E|OJH\H
JHOGLNOHUL |QFHNL oDOÕúPDODUGD RUWD\D NRQPXúWXU
.LU]LR÷OX (UFLODVXQ <ÕOPD] *|OH¶GHNL $OHYLOHU KDNNÕQGD GDKD |QFH oDOÕúPD
\DSÕOPDGÕ÷ÕQGDQ VD÷OÕNOÕ ELOJL PHYFXW GH÷LOGLU
<DSÕODQ ELU DODQ DUDúWÕUPDVÕQGD 'DPDO YH +DQDN
$OHYLOHULQLQ 0DUDú$OWÕQ¶GDQ JHOHQ 7UNPHQOHU
ROGX÷X *|OH $OHYLOHULQLQ LVH 7XQFHOL YH 0Xú
9DUWR¶GDQ JHOGLNOHUL WHVSLW HGLOPLúWLU 8\DQÕN YH
.DOD
$QOLHJHQGHU)XQNWLRQDOLVWHQ]X]HLJHQGDVV³5HOLJLRQHQ
GLHVLFKLQVWLWXWLRQDOLVLHUWHQXQG)X‰IDVVWHQLQGHU/DJH
VHLHQGLH*HPHLQVFKDIW]XHLQHQLQGHPVLHJHPHLQVDPH
:HUWHVFKDIIHQXQGVLHLQGLH*HPHLQVFKDIWLQWHJULHUHQ³
,Q GLHVHP 6LQQH LVW HV QLFKW IDOVFK ]X EHKDXSWHQ GDVV
GLH %HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLHQ XQG GLH GDPLW YHUEXQGHQHQ
%UlXFKHGLH)XQNWLRQKDEHQGLH*HPHLQVFKDIWVPLWJOLHGHU
HLQDQGHU QlKHU ]X EULQJHQ XQG GLH 6ROLGDULWlW LQQHUKDOE
GHU*HPHLQVFKDIW]XVWlUNHQ 'DVVGLHÇepniLQ%DOÕNHVLU
GLH ù$+,1 XQWHUVXFKW KDW LKUH$UEHLW VWHKHQ XQG OLHJHQ
ODVVHQXQG]XU%HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLHHLOHQZHQQMHPDQG
DXV LKUHU *HPHLQVFKDIW YHUVWRUEHQ LVW XQG HV DOV 3ÀLFKW
EHWUDFKWHQ GHQ %HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ EHL]XZRKQHQ LVW HLQ
JXWHV%HLVSLHOGDIU,QXQVHUHQ%HREDFKWXQJHQZDUHQZLU
=HXJH GHU DXV UHOLJL|VHQ:XU]HOQ JHVSHLVWHQ 6HQVLELOLWlW
LP%H]XJDXI%HVWDWWXQJHQXQGGHP6ROLGDULWlWVJHIKOLP
$QJHVLFKWGHV7RGHVGHUDOHYLWLVFKHQ0HQVFKHQ
7HLOQHKPHQGH %HREDFKWXQJ XQG ,QWHUYLHZV ZDUHQ GDV
PHWKRGLVFKH :HUN]HXJ GLHVHU 8QWHUVXFKXQJ XQG GLH
(LJHQKHLWHQ GHV 7KHPDV KDEHQ HLQH TXDOLWDWLYH $QDO\VH
JHIRUGHUW 'HU *UXQG ZDUXP ELVKHU ZHQLJ ]X GLHVHP
7KHPD JHIRUVFKW ZXUGH LVW GLH 7DWVDFKH GDVV YRUKHU
NHLQH TXDOLWDWLYHQ 0HWKRGHQ DQJHZHQGHW ZXUGHQ (LQHQ
7HLO GHU (UJHEQLVVH GLHVHU 8QWHUVXFKXQJ ZXUGHQ GXUFK
GLH 7HLOQDKPH DQ YHUVFKLHGHQHQ %HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLHQ
LQ GHQ YRQ GHQ $OHYLWHQ $UGDKDQV VWDUN EHVLHGHOWHQ
'|UIHUQ *QGHú XQG (VNLNÕOÕo JHZRQQHQ 1HEHQ
GHQ WHLOQHKPHQGHQ %HREDFKWXQJHQ ZXUGHQ DXFK
DXVJHGHKQWH*HVSUlFKHPLW]ZHLDOHYLWLVFKHQ*HLVWOLFKHQ
GHGHV $OL (NEHU *|JWHNLQ XQG 0XVD 0úWHNLQ GHP
9HUDQWZRUWOLFKHQIUGLHFHP=HUHPRQLH,VPDLO$NGHPLU
GHU DXFK GLH /HLFKHQZDVFKXQJHQ GXUFKIKUW XQG GHP
%H]LUNVYRUVWHKHUYRQ'DPDO$OL(NEHUÇalhanJHIKUW
$UGDKDQ LVW LP 1RUGRVWHQ YRQ $QDWROLHQ JHOHJHQ (V
EHKHLPDWHW YHUVFKLHGHQH HWKQLVFKH NXOWXUHOOH XQG
UHOLJL|VH *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ 'LH $OHYLWHQ $UGDKDQV VLQG
YRU DOOHP LQ GHP .UHLV 'DPDO XQG +DQDN DQ]XWUHIIHQ
XQGHVJLEWGDUEHUKLQDXVDXFK$OHYLWHQLQGHQ'|UIHULP
6WDGWJHELHW$UGDKDQVXQGLP.UHLV*|OH$XVYRUKHULJHQ
$UEHLWHQ ZLVVHQ ZLU GDVV GLH $OHYLWHQ DXV GHP .UHLV
WALLACE5XWK$WOLF$OLVRQdD÷GDú6RV\RORML.XUDPODUÕ
hEHUVHW]WYRQ/H\OD(OEXU]XQG05DPL$\DV3XQWR<D\ÕQODUÕ
ø]PLU6
ù$+,1 +DOLO øEUDKLP %DOÕNHVLU dHSQLOHULQGH 'H¿Q YH 'H¿Q
6RQUDVÕ%D]ÕøQDQÕúYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWUYH+DFÕ
%HNWDúÕ9HOL%QG66
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
$OHYLOL÷LQGL÷HUELUoRNER\XWXQGDROGX÷XJLEL|OPOH
LOJLOL QRUPODU YH X\JXODPDODUGD GD 7UNL\H¶QLQ
GH÷LúLN E|OJHOHULQGH \DúD\DQ $OHYLOHU DUDVÕQGD ELU
NÕVÕPIDUNOÕOÕNODUROGX÷XELOLQPHNWHGLUgQFO
³GLQL H÷LWLP YHUHQ ELU NXUXPXQ EXOXQPDPDVÕ
GHGHOLN NXUXPXQXQ ND\EROPDVÕ YH EXQODUD ED÷OÕ
RODUDN FHPOHULQ \DSÕOPDPDVÕQÕQ VRQXFX RODUDN
D\QÕ DLOH YH \HUOHúLP ELULPLQGH GDKL ELUELULQGHQ
IDUNOÕ GúQFH YH NDEXOOHULQ´ RUWD\D oÕNPDVÕQÕ
$OHYLOHUGHNL|OPOHLOJLOLLQDQÕúYHX\JXODPDODUGDNL
IDUNOÕODúPDODUÕQ QHGHQOHUL RODUDN EHOLUWLU $NWDú¶GD
\DúDQÕODQ\HUOHúLPDODQÕQÕQNHQW\DGDNÕUVDO
ROPDVÕQÕQ |÷UHQLP GXUXPXQXQ |OP DOJÕVÕQÕQ YH
\DNÕQODUÕQÕND\EHGHQOHULQJ|VWHUGLNOHULWHSNLOHULQ|O
J|PPH ELoLP YH JHOHQHNOHULQGH ED]Õ IDUNOÕOÕNODUD
QHGHQRODFD÷ÕQÕV|\OHU%XIDUNOÕOÕNODUDUD÷PHQ(QJLQ
$OHYLOHUGHNL |OPOH LOJLOL X\JXODPDODUÕ
LNL DúDPDGD HOH DOPD\Õ |QHUPHNWHGLU gOPQ
JHUoHNOHúPHVLQGHQ FHQD]H QDPD]ÕQÕQ NÕOÕQGÕ÷Õ DQD
NDGDURODQVUHoLONDúDPDKD]ÕUOÕNDúDPDVÕFHQD]H
QDPD]ÕQGDQ VRQUDNL VUHo LVH VRQUDNL DúDPD RODUDN
HOH DOÕQPDNWDGÕU hONHPL] JHQHOLQGH |OP ]HULQH
\DSÕODQ oDOÕúPDODUÕQ E\N ELU NÕVPÕQGD |OP LOH
LOJLOLLQDQoYHULWHOOHU³|OP|QFHVL´³|OPVÕUDVÕ´
YH ³|OP VRQUDVÕ´ ROPDN ]HUH o DQD VDIKDGD HOH
DOÕQPDNWDGÕU
$OHYL YH 6QQL NHVLPOHULQ |OPOH LOJLOL RODUDN
X\JXODGÕ÷Õ EHQ]HU SUDWLNOHU V|] NRQXVXGXU
³$OHYLOHUGH WHONLQLQ \DSÕOÕúÕ EDúODQJÕo YH ELWLú
FPOHOHUL GÕúÕQGD 6QQLOHUGH ROGX÷X JLELGLU +RFD
WHONLQH EDúODUNHQ ³%LVPLOODK \D GD %LVPL ùDK«´
ELWLULUNHQ GH ³øPDPÕP ùkKÕ 9HOk\HW $OL\\H¶O
0XUWD]D¶GÕU´ GHU YH WHONLQ VRQD HUHU´ <ÕOGÕ]
<LQH \DSÕODQ ED]Õ oDOÕúPDODUGD FHQD]H
QDPD]ÕQÕQ NÕOÕQÕú úHNOLQGH GH 6QQL NHVLPOH ELU
D\UÕOÕ÷ÕQ EXOXQPDGÕ÷ÕQÕ V|\OHQHELOLU ùDKLQ &HP HYLQGH NÕOÕQDQ FHQD]H QDPD]ÕQD ³KDOND
'DPDOXQG+DQDNVLFKDOV³7XUNPHQHQ³EHWUDFKWHQXQG
EHKDXSWHQ GDVV VLH DXV .DKUDPDQPDUDú 0DUDú$OWÕQ
GRUWKLQ JHNRPPHQ VHLQ VROOHQ hEHU GLH $OHYLWHQ DXV
*|OH KDEHQ ZLU NHLQH JHVLFKHUWHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ GD VLH
ELVKHU QLFKW HUIRUVFKW ZXUGHQ ,Q HLQHU )HOGVWXGLH ZXUGH
IHVWJHVWHOOW GDVV GLH$OHYLWHQ DXV 'DPDO XQG +DQDN >LQ
GHU 7DW@ DXV 0DUDú$OWÕQ VWDPPHQGH ³7XUNPHQHQ³ VLQG
XQG GLH $OHYLWHQ DXV *|OH DXV 7XQFHOL XQG 0Xú 9DUWR
HLQJHZDQGHUWVLQG
(V LVW EHNDQQW GDVV HV MH QDFK 5HJLRQ 8QWHUVFKLHGH EHL
GHQ5HJHOXQJHQXQG3UDNWLNHQLQQHUKDOEGHUDOHYLWLVFKHQ
*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ LP =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW GHP 7RG JLEW ±
GLHVEHWULIIWDXFKDQGHUH(OHPHQWHGHV$OHYLWHQWXPV$OV
8UVDFKHIUGLHVH8QWHUVFKLHGHQHQQWÖNCÜL GHQ8PVWDQG
³GDVVHVDXIJUXQGGHV1LFKWYRUKDQGHQVHLQVHLQHU,QVWLWXWLRQ
IU UHOLJL|VH 8QWHUZHLVXQJ GHV 9HUIDOOV GHV $PWHV GHV
DOHYLWLVFKHQ *HLVWOLFKHQ GHGH XQG GHU 7DWVDFKH GDVV
keine FHP=HUHPRQLHQ PHKU LQ GHU *HJHQZDUW GLHVHU
GHGH JHPDFKW ZXUGHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH 9RUVWHOOXQJHQ
XQG.RQ]HSWLRQHQLQHLQXQGGHPVHOEHQ6LHGOXQJVJHELHW
MDVRJDULQHLQXQGGHUVHOEHQ)DPLOLHJLEW³8QG$.7$ù
EHPHUNWGDVVHVMHQDFK6LHGOXQJVJHELHW6WDGWRGHU/DQG
GHP %LOGXQJVQLYHDX GHU 9RUVWHOOXQJ YRP 7RG XQG GHU
5HDNWLRQDXIGHQ7RGHLQHV1DKHVWHKHQGHQ8QWHUVFKLHGH
LQGHU$UWXQG:HLVHZLHPDQGLH7RWHQEHVWDWWHWJHEHQ
ZLUG 7URW] GLHVHU 8QWHUVFKLHGH HPS¿HKOW ENGIN GLH
+DQGOXQJLQ%H]XJDXIGLH%HVWDWWXQJEHLGHQ$OHYLWHQLQ
]ZHL3KDVHQ]XXQWHUWHLOHQ'HU=HLWUDXPYRP7RGELV
]XU 9HUULFKWXQJ GHV 7RGHVJHEHWHV 9RUEHUHLWXQJVSKDVH
'LH =HLW QDFK GHU9HUULFKWXQJ GHV7RGHVJHEHWHV11 ,Q
GHPJUR‰HQ7HLOGHU6WXGLHQGLHLQXQVHUHP/DQG>7UNHL@
GHQ7RG]XP*HJHQVWDQGKDEHQZHUGHQGLH9RUVWHOOXQJHQ
XQG3UDNWLNHQLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGDQDO\VLHUW
LQGHPPDQGUHL3KDVHQXQWHUVFKHLGHWGLH=HLW³YRUGHP
7RG³ GLH =HLW ³ZlKUHQG GHV 7RGHV³ XQG GLH =HLW ³QDFK
GHP7RG³
.,5=,2ö/8ERCILASUNYILMAZ>YROOVWlQ
GLJH/LWHUDWXUDQJDEHQIHKOHQ@
UYANIK=HNLXQG.$/$$ULI$UGDKDQøOL$OHYLOHULQGH.HQGL
QL7DQÕPODPDøEDGHWYHÖteki$OJÕVÕ,Q$NDGHPLN$UDúWÕUPDODU
'HUJLVL$XVJDEH6
ÖNCÜL .UúDW .DUV 7UNPHQOHULQGH gOPH %D÷OÕ øQDQÕúODU
$QODWÕODUYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWUYH+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ9HOL
$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL$XVJDEH66
$.7$ù$OL$OHYLOHUGHgOPOH øOJLOL5LWHOOHU,Q+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ
9HOL$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL6
11 ENGINøVPDLO7DKWDFÕODU $QW<D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO6
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
QDPD]Õ´PH]DUOÕNWDNÕOÕQDQQDPD]DLVH³VDIQDPD]Õ´
DGÕQÕQ YHULOGL÷LQL EHOLUWLU$\UÕFD |OQQ \ÕNDQPDVÕ
NHIHQOHQPHVL FHQD]H QDPD]Õ JLEL 6QQL DNLGHOHU
oHUoHYHVLQGH JHUoHNOHúWLULOHQ LúOHPOHULQ EHQ]HULQLQ
GH¿Q HVQDVÕQGD GD J|UOG÷Q V|\OHQHELOLU
$ODQGDNL J|]OHPOHUGHQ YH OLWHUDWUGHQ DQODúÕOGÕ÷Õ
]HUH $OHYL YDWDQGDúODUÕ .... YH
D\GÕQODUÕJHQHORODUDN$OHYLGH¿QLúOHPOHULQLQ6QQL
DNLGHOHUHEHQ]HUúHNLOGH\DSÕOPDVÕQÕHOHúWLUPHNWHGLU
%R]NXUW¶D J|UH FHQD]H LúOHPOHUL \UWHQ GHGHOHULQ
VRQ G|QHPGH VD\ÕODUÕQÕQ D]DOPDVÕQGDQ GROD\Õ
$OHYLOHU GHYOHWWHQ FDPL YH 6QQL KRFD LVWHPHN
]RUXQGD NDOPÕúODUGÕU EX GD$OHYL YH 6QQL FHQD]H
ULWHOOHULQLQ ELUELUOHULQH EHQ]HPHVLQH \RO DoPÕúWÕU
<LQH%R]NXUW¶DJ|UHFHQD]HQDPD]ÕWDPDPHQ6QQL
JHOHQH÷H DLW ELU X\JXODPDGÕU *HoPLúWH FHQD]H
QDPD]ÕQÕ KLo X\JXODPDPÕú $OHYL WRSOXOXNODUÕ
NHQGL GH¿Q X\JXODPDODUÕQÕ ROXúWXUPXúWXU gUQH÷LQ
(JH¶GH \DúD\DQ 7DKWDFÕ 7UNPHQOHU ³øVPL $]DP
GXDVÕ´%R]NXUWLOHùDK+DWD\L¶GHQ
RNXGXNODUÕ GH\LúOHUOH GH¿Q W|UHQOHULQL \DSPÕúODUGÕU
%R]NXUW¶WXQ]LNUHWWL÷LGXDQÕQELUNÕVPÕúXúHNLOGHGLU
*HOJ|QORNX\DOÕPøVPL$]DP'XDVÕQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
<DNÕQELOVLOHOLPJ|QOSDVÕQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
%L]GHoÕ÷UÕúÕUÕ]³<D0XKDPPHG<D$OL´
2QODUGDLNLFLKDQÕQVHUYHUL
%XGXDLOHGUVWROGXGLQLLPDQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
0XVD7XU'D÷Õ¶QGD+DNN¶DçokQL\D]H\OHGL
(KOL+DNLGL1HPUXWEXQDøEUDKLP¶HQHOHUH\OHGL
(UHQOHUHYOL\DODUEXGXD\ÕV|\OHGL
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$VODQGRQXQDJLUGL\ROD\DWWÕùDK0HUGDQ
2QXQD÷]ÕQDPKUQDWWÕROSH\JDPEHU
%XGXD\ÕRNXU6XOWDQùDK+DWD\¶LPKHPHQ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
……
'LH 3UDNWLNHQ GHU DOHYLWLVFKHQ XQG VXQQLWLVFKHQ
*HPHLQVFKDIWHQLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGVLQG>DQ
GLHVHU 6WHOOH@ *HJHQVWDQG XQVHUHV 7KHPDV 'LH :RUWH
GLHGHP9HUVWRUEHQHQRGHUGHU9HUVWRUEHQHQHLQJHÀVWHUW
ZHUGHQ VLQG EHL GHQ $OHYLWHQ XQG 6XQQLWHQ LGHQWLVFK
DX‰HU GHQ$QIDQJV XQG (QGVlW]HQ 1DFK GHP GHU KRFD
>LVODPLVFKHU 5HOLJLRQVJHOHKUWHU@ GLH:RUWH ³%LVPLOODK \D
GD%LVPLùDK«´DP$QIDQJXQGGLH:RUWH³øPDPÕP
ùkKÕ9HOk\HW$OL\\H¶O0XUWD]D¶GÕU³JHVSURFKHQKDWHQGHW
GLH (LQÀVWHUXQJ LQ GLH 2KUHQ GHV 9HUVWRUEHQHQ E]Z
GHU 9HUVWRUEHQHQ12 $XV HLQLJHQ 6WXGLHQ JHKW DX‰HUGHP
KHUYRUGDVVHVNHLQH8QWHUVFKHLGHLQGHU$UWXQG:HLVH
ZLHGDV7RWHQJHEHWYHUULFKWHWZLUGEHLGHQ$OHYLWHQXQG
GHQ6XQQLWHQJLEW13'DUEHUKLQDXVJHKWDXVGLHVHU6WXGLH
KHUYRU GDVV GDV 7RWHQJHEHW LQ GHP =HUHPRQLHQKDXV
GHU $OHYLWHQ ³FHP HYL³ ³*HPHLQVFKDIWVJHEHW³ ³KDOND
QDPD]Õ³ JHQDQQW ZLUG ZlKUHQG GDV DXI GHP )ULHGKRI
YHUULFKWHWH *HEHW ³VDI QDPD]Õ³ ³5HLKHQJHEHW³ JHQDQQW
ZLUG$X‰HUGHP LVW ]X VDJHQ GDVV HV *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ
EHL GHQ $OHYLWHQ LP +LQEOLFN DXI %HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ ZLH
]% GLH /HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ GLH (LQNOHLGXQJ GHU /HLFKH
LQ HLQ /HLFKHQWXFK RGHU GDV 7RWHQJHEHW LQ HLQHP
VXQQLWLVFKHQ5DKPHQJLEW:LHDXFKDXVGHQ(UJHEQLVVHQ
GHU)HOGIRUVFKXQJXQGGHU/LWHUDWXUKHUYRUJHKWNULWLVLHUHQ
GLH$OHYLWHQ3HUVRQ333XQGDXFKDOHYLWLVFKHQ
*HOHKUWHGDVVGLH%HVWDWWXQJHQGHU$OHYLWHQDXI$UWXQG
:HLVH GHU 6XQQLWHQ JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ BOZKURT ]XIROJH
VLQGGLH$OHYLWHQDXIJUXQGGHV8PVWDQGHVGDVVGLH=DKO
GHUMHQLJHQGHGHGLHLQGHU/DJHVLQGGLH%HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ
GXUFK]XIKUHQ LQ GHU OHW]WHQ =HLW HUKHEOLFK
]XUFNJHJDQJHQ LVW JH]ZXQJHQ JHZHVHQ EHLP 6WDDW
0RVFKHHQXQGVXQQLWLVFKHKRFDDQ]XIUDJHQ±XQGGLHVKDW
]XU )ROJH JHKDEW GDVV GLH %HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ GHU$OHYLWHQ
VLFKPHKUXQGPHKUDQGLHVXQQLWLVFKHQ%HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ
DQJHJOLFKHQKDEHQ
BOZKURT ]XIROJH LVW DXFK GDV 7RWHQJHEHW HLQ JHQXLQ
VXQQLWLVFKHU 5LWXV $OHYLWLVFKHQ *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ
GLH GDV 7RWHQJHEHW QLFKW NHQQHQ KDEHQ LKUH HLJHQHQ
%HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ 6R KDEHQ ]% GLH 7DKWDFL LQ GHU bJlLV
LKUH %HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLHQ PLW GHP øVPL$]DP*HEHW
HLQHP*HGLFKWùDK+DWD\LVDXVJHIKUW'DVYRQBOZKURT
HUZlKQWH*HGLFKWODXWHWLQ$XV]JHQIROJHQGHUPD‰HQ
12 YILDIZ +DUXQ $OHYL *HOHQH÷LQGH gOP YH gOP 6RQUDVÕ
7|UHQYH5LWHOOHU8OXVODUDUDVÕ7UN.OWUQGHgOP6HPSR
]\XPX1RYHPEHUøVWDQEXO6
13 ù$+,1 (2006), S.68
>33XVZEHGHXWHW3HUVRQ3HUVRQXVZXQGZHLVWDXI
>33XVZEHGHXWHW3HUVRQ3HUVRQXVZXQGZHLVWDXI
GLH,QWHUYLHZSDUWQHULQGLHVHU6WXGLHKLQ@
>4XHOOHQQDFKZHLVHIHKOHQ@
BOZKURT )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO %R\XWODUÕ Tekin
<D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
*HORNXEXGXD\ÕJLWVLQNDOELQGHQNLELULOHNLQ
2NXUGXEXGXD\ÕKHU]DPDQLPDQLOHGLQ
2NXGXGLUHNWXWXDVXPDQX]HPLQ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$OHYL YH 6QQL FHPDDWOHU D\QÕ NXWVDO NLWDS
.XUDQÕ .HULP UHIHUDQVÕ\OD GLQVHO SUDWLNOHULQL
JHUoHNOHúWLUPHOHULQGHQ
GROD\Õ
ELoLP
YH
DGODQGÕUPDODUÕIDUNOÕROVDGD|]LWLEDUL\OHD\QÕWHRORMLN
\|QHOLPOHUH VDKLSWLU $QODP YH \RUXPVDO ER\XWWD
IDUNOÕODúWÕNODUÕ WDULKVHO YH VRV\RORMLN ELU JHUoHN
ROPDNOD ELUOLNWH ND\QDN RODUDN D\QÕ GLQL UHIHUDQVÕQ
oHúLWOHQPHVLRODUDNRNXQDELOLUµ<ROELUVUHNELQELU¶
LIDGHVL GH EXQX J|VWHUPHNWHGLU 6RQXo RODUDN GL÷HU
GLQVHO SUDWLNOHU JLEL |OP ROJXVX GD D\QÕ ND\QD÷ÕQ
IDUNOÕ \RUXPODQPDVÕQD ED÷OÕ RODUDN RUWDN |]HOOLNOHU
J|VWHUHELOPHNWHGLU
gOPQ$OJÕODQÕúÕKDNND\UPHNYH\D
|OPHGHQ|QFH|OPHN
gOP \RN ROPDN RODUDN DOJÕODQPDGÕ÷ÕQGDQ GROD\Õ
|OP V|]F÷ $OHYLOHUGH LQVDQÕQ NHQGLQL $OODK¶ÕQ
YDUOÕ÷ÕQGD \RN HWPHVL úHNOLQGH DQODP ND]DQPÕúWÕU
$QDGROX $OHYLOHULQLQ LQDQFÕQD J|UH $OODK¶ÕQ NHQGL
QXUXQGDQ \DUDWWÕ÷Õ YH EX \]GHQ 7DQUÕVDO ELU |]
WDúÕ\DQ LQVDQ |OP\OH ELUOLNWH \HQLGHQ $OODK¶D
NDYXúDFDN RQXQOD EWQOHúHFHN \DQL ³+DNN¶D
\U\HFHNWLU´..
+HU úH\GHQ |QFH WDQUÕ NDYUDPVDOODúWÕUPDVÕQD ED÷OÕ
RODUDN $OHYLOHU WDQUÕ NRUNXVX \HULQH WDQUÕ VHYJLVLQL
HVDVDOÕU$OHYLOHULQVDQÕQ7DQUÕVDOELU|]HVDKLSRODUDN
\DUDWÕOGÕNODUÕQD LQDQGÕNODUÕ LoLQ |OP DQFDN |]H
G|Qú RODUDN GH÷HUOHQGLULOPHNWHGLU %XQGDQ GROD\Õ
³$]UDLOLoLQFDQDOÕFÕGH÷LOFDQÕFDQDXODúWÕUÕFÕRODUDN
EDKVHGLOPHNWHGLU´ $NWDú gOPHGHQ HYYHO
|OPHN$]UDLO¶HFDQEÕUDNPDPDNWÕUdQN$]UDLO¶LQ
DOGÕ÷ÕFDQPXUGDUROXU³%L]OHUVRUJXPX]XGDPDKúHUH
EÕUDNPDGDQ J|UJ FHPLQGH SLU KX]XUXQGD YHULUL]´
.. %X NDYUDPVDOODúWÕUPDQÕQ VRQXFX RODUDN
|OP NDYUDPÕ \HULQH ³+DNN¶D \UPHN JHUoHNOHUH
NDYXúPDN NDOÕS GH÷LúWLUPHN NDOÕEÕ GLQOHQGLUPHN
*HOJ|QORNX\DOÕPøVPL$]DP'XDVÕQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
<DNÕQELOVLOHOLPJ|QOSDVÕQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
.RPP RK +HU] ODVV XQV GDV %LWWJHEHW GHV +|FKVWHQ
1DPHQ>*RWWHV@VSUHFKHQ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU17
%HWUDFKWHHVDOVJHZLVVXQGOD‰XQVGHQ5RVWGHV+HU]HQV
EHVHLWLJHQ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$OLED÷ODGÕGHYLQED÷ÕQÕ
<UH÷LQHçektiKLFUDQGD÷ÕQÕ
+XUPDNDSÕLOHED÷ODGÕNDEÕQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$OLZDUHVGHUGHQ5LHVHQEH]ZDQJ
XQGLKPYLHOH:XQGHQ]XIJWH
>8QG@HUZDUHVGHUGDV'DWWHOWRUHLQQDKP>"@
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
%L]GHoÕ÷UÕúÕUÕ]\D0XKDPPHG\D$OL
2QODUGDLNLFLKDQÕQVHUYHUL
%XGXDLOHGUVWROGXGLQLLPDQÕ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$XFKZLUUXIHQ2K0XKDPPHGRK$OL
6LHEHLGHVLQGGLH+HUUHQGHUEHLGHQ:HOWHQ>'LHVVHLWVXQG
-HQVHLWV@
0LWGLHVHP%LWWJHEHWZXUGHGHU*ODXEHQUHLQ
ODIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
0XVD1XU'D÷ÕQGD+DNNDçokQL\D]H\OHGL
(KOL+DNLGL1HPUXWEXQDQHOHUH\OHGL (UHQOHUHYOL\DODU
EXGXD\ÕV|\OHGL
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
0RVHVZDUIVLFKVRRIWDXIGHP6LQDLLQ$QEHWXQJYRU*RWW
QLHGHU
2EZRKO HU >JHPHLQW LVW $EUDKDP@ ]X *RWWHV .QHFKWHQ
JHK|UWHKDWLKQ1LPURGYLHOHVDQJHWDQ
'LH+HLOLJHQVSUDFKHQDOOHVDPWGLHVHV%LWWJHEHW
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
«
>³
>³(VJLEWNHLQHQKHOGHQPWLJHUHQDOV$OLXQGNHLQ6FKZHUW
ZLHGDV6FKZHUW=O¿NDU³GDV6FKZHUW$OLV@
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
VÕUROPDNHPDQHWLWHVOLPHWPHN&HPkO¶HYH'vGkU¶D
NDYXúPDNGRQGH÷LúWLUPHN´JLELGH\LPOHUNXOODQÕOÕU
.D\DDNWDUDQ<ÕOGÕ]
$VODQGRQXQDJLUGL\ROD\DWWÕùDK0HUGDQ
2QXQD÷]ÕQDPKUQDWWÕROSH\JDPEHU
%XGXD\ÕRNXU6XOWDQùDK+DWD\LPKHPHQ
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
$OHYLOHUGH |OP DOJÕVÕ VDGHFH EL\RORMLN |OPOH
VÕQÕUODQPDPDNWDGÕU $OHYL |÷UHWLVLQGHNL WDVDYYX¿
GLQVHOLOHUOHPHGH'|UWNDSÕ.ÕUNPDNDPøNUDU&HPL
|QHPOLX÷UDNODUGDQELULQL ROXúWXUPDNWDGÕUøNUDU1DVLS
&HPLQLQ DQD NRQXVX ³|OPHGHQ |QFH |OPHN´ .
olarak NDYUDPVDOODúWÕUÕODQYHLUDGLELUELoLPGHGHGHQLQ
YH FHPDDWLQ |QQGH WDOLELQ \ROD EDú NR\PDVÕGÕU %X
LNUDUGDQ VRQUD WDOLS DUÕQPÕú YH LNLQFL PDVXPL\HWLQL
ND]DQPÕúRODUDNEXQGDQVRQUDNLKD\DWÕQGDHQJ]HOLQL
\DúDPD\D YH \DúDWPD\D NR\XOXU %X GD DQFDN QHIVLQ
|OGUOPHVL YH EHGHQL LVWHNOHULQ VÕQÕUODQPDVÕ\OD
PPNQGU .. %XUDGDNL ³gOPHGHQ |QFH
|OPHN´PHFD]LYHQHIVLQ|OGUOPHVLDQODPÕQDDOÕQGÕ÷Õ
LoLQEL\RORMLN|OPHGHQIDUNOÕELUDQODPWDúÕU
'HU )UVW GHU 5HFKWVFKDIIHQHQ QDKP GLH *HVWDOW HLQHV
/|ZHQDQXQGYHUVSHUUWHGHQ:HJ18
XQGGHU3URSKHWZDUILKPVHLQHQ6LHJHOULQJLQGHQ5DFKHQ
8QGùDK+DWD\VSULFKWGLHVHV%LWWJHEHWLPPHUIRUW
/DIHWDLOOD$OLODVH\IHLOOD=O¿NDU
<HQLGHQ EL\RORMLN |OPH LoLQ \DSÕODQ ULWHOOHUH
G|QHUVHN |OPHN ]HUH RODQ ELU KDVWDQÕQ \DQÕQGD
EXOXQDQODU KDVWD\D VDEÕUODU GLOH\HUHN $OODK¶D
VÕ÷ÕQPDVÕQÕ $OODK¶WDQ NHQGLVL KDNNÕQGD KD\ÕUODU
GLOHPHVLQL YH W|YEH HWPHVLQL WHONLQ HGHUOHU %XQX
KDVWD\Õ LQFLWPHGHQ YH JFHQGLUPHGHQ \DSDUODU
\DQÕQGDKDVWDQÕQGX\DFD÷ÕNDGDUVHVOLRODUDN.XUDQ
RNXQXU W|YEH LVWL÷IDU HGLOLU .HOLPHL úHKDGHW
JHWLULOLU7HYKLGYH6DOkYDWÕúHULIHRNXQXU+DVWD\D
³6HQ GH RNX´ GHQLOPH] øVWHUVH KDVWD NHQGLVL RNXU
+DVWDQÕQ EDúÕQGD .XUDQ RNX\DQ NLPVH KDVWDQÕQ
GX\DPD\DFD÷Õ úHNLOGH \DYDú VHVOH ³<D 5DEEH¶O
$OHPL\Q %X RNXGX÷XP .XU¶DQ KUPHWLQH EX
KDVWD\DKD\ÕUODúLIDODULKVDQH\OH(÷HU|PUWDPDP
ROPXúVDVDQDG|QúQNROD\ODúWÕU(KOLEH\W¶LQDúNÕ
KUPHWLQHNXVXUODUÕQÕDIH\OH<DUDEEL´GL\HGXDHGHU
.. gOP JHUoHNOHúWLNWHQ VRQUD LVH FHQD]H\L
EHNOHWPHGHQ HQ NÕVD ]DPDQGD WRSUD÷D YHUPHN
ONHPL] $OHYL WRSOXOXNODUÕQGD J|UOHQ |QHPOL ELU
JHOHQHNWLU %XUDGD KHU úH\GHQ |QFH ³gO\ \HUGH
EÕUDNPDPDN LoLQ HUNHQ J|PPH´ GúQFHVL HVDVWÕU
7Dú÷ÕQ%XGúQFH'DPDO$OHYLOHULQGH
GHJ|]HWLOPHNWHGLU
$XFK ZHQQ HV 8QWHUVFKLHGH ]ZLVFKHQ GHQ UHOLJL|VHQ
3UDNWLNHQGHU$OHYLWHQXQGGHQHQGHU6XQQLWHQJLEWKDEHQ
VLHLP*UXQGHJHQRPPHQGLHVHOEHWKHRORJLVFKH*UXQGODJH
GDVLHGHQ.RUDQDOVKHLOLJHV%XFKDOV*UXQGODJHKDEHQ
QDFK GHP VLH LKUH 3UDNWLNHQ DXVULFKWHQ 0DQ NDQQ GLH
KLVWRULVFKHQXQGVR]LRORJLVFKHQ%HGLQJXQJHQDOV8UVDFKH
IU GLH 8QWHUVFKLHGH LQ GHU 'HXWXQJ JHOWHQ ODVVHQ GLH
HLQH1HXLQWHUSUHWDWLRQGHVVHOEHQUHOLJL|VHQ)XQGDPHQWHV
]XU)ROJHKDW'HU$XVGUXFN³'HU:HJLVWHLQHUGRFKGLH
0HWKRGH>E]ZGHU3UR]HVV@LVWWDXVHQGIDFK³PDFKWKLHUDXI
DXIPHUNVDP (V JHKW DEHU OHW]WHQGOLFK GDUXP GDVV PDQ
LQGHU/DJHLVWWURW]GHUXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ$XVSUlJXQJHQ
LP=XJHGHV'HXWXQJVSUR]HVVHVGHU*UXQGSULQ]LSLHQGLH
*HPHLQVDPNHLWHQLP+LQEOLFNDXIGLHUHOLJL|VHQ3UDNWLNHQ
LP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGGHXWOLFKPDFKW
'LH9RUVWHOOXQJYRP7RG³KDNND\UPHN³³]X*RWW
JHKHQ³E]Z
³VWHUEHQEHYRUPDQVWLUEW³
'DIUGLH$OHYLWHQGHU7RGQLFKWJOHLFKEHGHXWHQGLVWPLW
GHU$XVO|VFKXQJGHV0HQVFKHQKHUUVFKWGLH9RUVWHOOXQJ
GDVVGHU0HQVFKEHLVHLQHP7RGLP6HLQ*RWWHVDXIJHKHQ
ZLUG 'HP$QDWROLVFKHQ$OHYLWHQWXP ]XIROJH ZXUGH GHU
0HQVFKDXVGHP/LFKW*RWWHVHUVFKDIIHQXQGKDWGHVKDOE
HLQHQJ|WWOLFKHQ.HUQ$XVGLHVHP*UXQGZLUGGHU0HQVFK
QDFKVHLQHP7RGZLHGHUPLW*RWWYHUHLQWZHUGHQHUZLUG
³]X*RWWJHKHQ³33)UGLH$OHYLWHQVWHKW>GDUEHU
KLQDXV@QLFKWGLH*RWWHVIXUFKWVRQGHUQGLH*RWWHVOLHEHLP
9RUGHUJUXQG'DGHU0HQVFKGHQ$OHYLWHQ]XIROJHHLQHQ
J|WWOLFKHQ .HUQ EHVLW]W PLW GHP HU HUVFKDIIHQ ZXUGH
ZLUG GHU 7RG GHV 0HQVFKHQ GDKHU DOV HLQH 5FNNHKU ]X
*RWW EHWUDFKWHW $XV GLHVHP *UXQG EHWUDFKWHW PDQ GHQ
7RGHVHQJHO $]UDHO QLFKW DOV MHPDQGHQ ³GHU ³ /HEHQ
QLPPW³ VRQGHUQ DOV MHPDQGHQ GHU ³GLH 6HHOH ]XP
>$QVSLHOXQJDXIGLH/HJHQGHQXPGLH+LPPHOVUHLVHGHV
>$QVSLHOXQJDXIGLH/HJHQGHQXPGLH+LPPHOVUHLVHGHV
3URSKHWHQ0XKDPPHG@
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
$UGDKDQ$OHYLOHULQGH'H¿QH+D]ÕUOÕN
|OPQGX\XUXOPDVÕ\ÕNDPDNHIHQOHQPH
FHQD]HQDPD]Õ
gOHQNLúL\HLONDQGD\DSÕODQúH\OHULQEDúÕQGDQDE]ÕQ
NRQWURO HGLOPHVL YH |OG÷QGHQ HPLQ ROXQPDVÕ
JHOPHNWHGLU gOHQ NLúL H÷HU \DQ ]HUL \DWÕ\RUVD VÕUW
VW \DWÕUÕOÕU *|] NDSDNODUÕ HOOH \DYDúoD NDSDWÕOÕU
$\DN EDúSDUPDNODUÕ ELUELULQH ED÷ODQÕU (OOHUL
\DQODUÕQD X]DWÕOÕU 8\JXQ J|UOUVH VWQGHNLOHU Lo
oDPDúÕUÕ KDULo VR\XOXU %LU HúDUS YH\D EHQ]HUL\OH
oHQHVLED÷ODQÕUdHQHDOWÕQGDQVDUÕODQHúDUSWHSHVLQGHQ
ED÷ODQDUDN D÷]ÕQ DoÕN NDOPDPDVÕ VD÷ODQÕU ³hU\DQ
JHOGL U\DQ JLGHFHN´ . LQDQÕúÕ JHUH÷L ]L\QHW
Hú\DODUÕVDDWNRO\H\]NYVYDUVDoÕNDUÕOÕUgOP
DQÕQGD UXKXQ EHGHQGHQ D\UÕODUDN XoXS JLWPHVLQH
NROD\OÕNVD÷ODPDNLoLQoR÷X]DPDQ|OPDQÕQGDNDSÕ
YH SHQFHUHOHULQ DoÕOPDVÕ ROD\Õ $\DWD $UGDKDQ $OHYLOHULQGH EXOXQPDPDNWDGÕU ..
..
8]DNWDQJHOHQ\DNÕQDNUDEDODULoLQFHQD]HLúOHPOHUL
EHNOHWLOHELOLU %HNOHWPH |]HOOLNOH NÕú PHYVLPOHULQGH
\DSÕOÕUNHQ \D]ÕQ JHUHNPHGLNoH WHUFLK HGLOPH]
%XQXQODELUOLNWHFHPHYOHULQLQPRUJODUDYHVR÷XWPD
FLKD]ODUÕQD VDKLS ROPDVÕ VD\HVLQGH DUWÕN \D]ÕQ
GD FHQD]H EHNOHWLOHELOPHNWHGLU ....
%X |UQHNWH J|UOG÷ ]HUH PRGHUQ ]DPDQODUGD
WHNQRORMLN JHOLúPHOHULQ VD÷ODGÕ÷Õ LPNkQODU
oHUoHYHVLQGH JHOHQHNVHO GDYUDQÕú NDOÕSODUÕQGD
IDUNOÕOÕNODUJ|]OHQPHNWHGLU
gOP ROD\ÕQÕQ GX\XUXOPDVÕQGD 6QQL SUDWLNOHUGHQ
IDUNOÕRODUDNVDODYHUPH\ROXWHUFLKHGLOPHPHNWHGLU
(VNL G|QHPOHUGH |OPQ PH\GDQD JHOGL÷L
\HUOHúLP \HULQGHNL WP KDQHOHU GRODúÕODUDN \DSÕODQ
GX\XUPD LúOHPL JQP]GH KRSDUO|U NXOODQÕODUDN
\DSÕOPDNWDGÕUYHJHQHOGHEHOHGL\HOHULQDQRQVVLVWHPL
GHYUH\HVRNXOPDNWDGÕU..gO\ÕNDPDLúOHPL
PHIWD HUNHNVH EX LúOHP EX LúL ELOHQ HUEDEÕ RODQ
HUNHNOHUWDUDIÕQGDQ\DSÕOÕU.DGÕQPHYWDODUÕLVHNDGÕQ
*HOLHEWHQ IKUW³ ³=X VWHUEHQ EHYRU PDQ VWLUEW³ KHL‰W
VHLQH6HHOHQLFKWGHP>7RGHVHQJHO@$]UDHO]XEHUODVVHQ
GDGLH6HHOHGLHYRQLKPJHQRPPHQZLUG]XJUXQGHJHKW
>(VKHL‰WEHLGHQ$OHYLWHQ@³:LUJHEHQ5HFKHQVFKDIW>EHU
XQVHUH7DWHQ@LQGHU*HJHQZDUWXQVHUHV0HLVWHUVEHLGHU
J|UJFHP=HUHPRQLH >HLQH =HUHPRQLH ]XU (UQHXHUXQJ
GHU 9HUEXQGHQKHLW ]XP 0HLVWHU ]XP 2UGHQ XQG ]XU
*HPHLQVFKDIW@QLFKWHUVWDP7DJGHV-QJVWHQ*HULFKWHV³
3 3 0DQ VSULFKW GHVKDOE QLFKW YRP 7RG VRQGHUQ
EHQXW]W$XVGUFNHZLH³]X*RWWJHKHQ³³]XU:LUNOLFKNHLW
JHODQJHQ³³GLH*HVWDOWlQGHUQ³³GLH+OOHUXKHQODVVHQ³
³GDVDQYHUWUDXWH*XW]XUFNJHEHQ³³]XPVFK|QHQ$QWOLW]
JHODQJHQ³E]Z³GDV*HZDQGZHFKVHOQ³
'HU7RGLVWIUGLH$OHYLWHQQLFKWQXUDXIGHQELRORJLVFKHQ
7RGEHJUHQ]W>'HU7RGLVWYRQLPPHQVHU%HGHXWXQJGD@
GLH (LQZHLKXQJV]HUHPRQLH LNUDU FHPL HLQH ZLFKWLJH
(WDSSH DXI GHP VX¿VFKUHOLJL|VHQ (QWZLFNOXQJVSUR]HVV
7RUH :HJVWDWLRQHQ GDUVWHOOW 'DV +DXSWWKHPD
GHU (LQZHLKXQJV]HUHPRQLH LVW >GDV 0RWLY@ ³VWHUEHQ
EHYRU PDQ VWLUEW³ 3 >%HL GLHVHU =HUHPRQLH@ JLEW
GHU 2UGHQVDQZlUWHU DXV IUHLHQ :LOOHQ VHLQHQ .RSI LQ
*HJHQZDUWGHVGHGHXQGHU*HPHLQVFKDIWKLQ1DFKGLHVHU
(LQZHLKXQJ >XQG GHQ GDPLW YHUEXQGHQHQ *HO|EQLVVHQ
GHV 2UGHQVDQZlUWHUV@ LVW GHU 2UGHQVDQZlUWHU³JHUHLQLJW³
XQG KDW VHLQH ³]ZHLWH 8QVFKXOG³ ZLHGHUHUODQJW XQG HU
JHOREWYRQQXQDQVHLQ/HEHQDXIVFK|QVWHU$UWXQG:HLVH
]X IKUHQ 'LHV LVW ZLHGHUXP QXU GDGXUFK P|JOLFK GDVV
PDQVHLQH7ULHEVHHOHQHIVDEW|WHWXQGVHLQHN|USHUOLFKHQ
%HGUIQLVVHLQGLH6FKUDQNHQZHLVW33
'LH0HQVFKHQDQGHU6HLWHGHV6WHUEHQGHQZQVFKHQLKP
.UDIWXQG$XVGDXHU6LHVDJHQLKPGDVVEHL*RWW=XÀXFKW
VXFKHQP|JHGDVVHU*RWWHV*XQVWIUVLHHUEHWHQP|JH
XQGGDVVHUEHUHXHQVROOWHGLHVWXQVLHRKQHGDEHLGHQ
6WHUEHQGHQ]XNUlQNHQ0DQOLHVWGHQ.RUDQODXWVRGDVV
GHU 6WHUEHQGH HV K|UHQ NDQQ ELWWHW XP 9HUJHEXQJ XQG
VSULFKWGDV*ODXEHQVEHNHQQWQLV0DQEHVWlWLJWGLH(LQKHLW
*RWWHV XQG VSULFKW 6HJHQVVSUFKH DXI GHQ 3URSKHWHQ
0DQ HUZDUWHQ QLFKW GDVV GHU 6WHUEHQGH HV JOHLFKWXQ
VROOWHHUNDQQVLFKGHPDQVFKOLH‰HQZHQQHUHVZQVFKW
'LH 3HUVRQ GLH DP 7RWHQEHWW GHV 6WHUEHQGHQ GHU .RUDQ
UH]LWLHUW VSULFKW PLWOHLVHU6WLPPH GDV *HEHW ³2K +HUU
$.7$ù$OL>6HLWHQDQJDEHIHKOW@
KAYA+D\GDU$OHYL%HNWDúL(UNkQÕ(YUkG¶ÕYH(GHEL\DWÕ(Q
JLQ<D\øVWDQEXO6
=LWLHUWYRQYILDIZ+DUXQ$OHYL*HOHQH÷LQGHgOPYH
gOP6RQUDVÕ7|UHQYH5LWHOOHU8OXVODUDUDVÕ7UN.OWUQGH
gOP6HPSR]\XPX1RYHPEHUøVWDQEXO6
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
J|UHYOLOHU \ÕNDU *|UHYOL FHQD]H\H |QFH DEGHVWLQL
DOGÕUÕU VRQUD \ÕNDPD LúOHPL EDúODU 9H |OHQ NLúLQLQ
\DNÕQODUÕQD ELUHU VX G|NWUOU &HP HYOHULQGHQ
|QFH\ÕNDPDLúOHPL|OHYLQGHNLNDSDOÕELUPHNkQGD
\ÕNDQÕUNHQEXJQEXLúOHPoR÷XQOXNODFHPHYOHULQLQ
FHQD]H\ÕNDPDLúOHPLLoLQD\UÕOPÕú|]HOE|OPOHULQGH
\DSÕOPDNWDGÕU...
<ÕNDPD LúOHPLQGHQ VRQUD NHIHQOHPH LúOHPL
EDúODU .HIHQ UHQJL EH\D]GÕU .HIHQOHPH LúOHPL
VRQUDVÕQGD WDEXWD NRQXU 7DEXWXQ VWQH \HúLO ELU
|UW |UWOU %D]Õ \|UHOHUGH WDEXWXQ VWQH |UWOHQ
\HúLO |UWGHQ EDúND o NDW VDUÕODQ NHIHQLQ VRQ NDWÕ
GD \HúLO UHQNWH RODELOPHNWHGLU YH EX \HúLO UHQN +]
+VH\LQ¶LQ HOELVHVLQLQ \HúLO UHQNWH ROGX÷X LQDQFÕQD
GD\DQPDNWDGÕU .HVNLQ gOHQ NLúL úHKLW
LVH7UN%D\UD÷Õ|UWOU.....HIHQOHPH
LúOHPLQGH NDGÕQODU HUNHNOHUGHQ ELU NDW GDKD ID]OD
NHIHQOHVDUÕOÕU$\UÕFDNDGÕQODUÕQPH]DUÕHUNHNOHUHJ|UH
GDKDGHULQND]ÕOÕU%XQXQVHEHELNDPHWED÷ODPD\D11
J|UH ROPDVÕGÕU (UNHNOHUGH ³NDPHW ED÷ODPD´ J|EHN
KL]DVÕQGD ROGX÷XQGDQ PH]DUÕ GD J|EHN KL]DVÕ
GHULQOL÷LQGHND]ÕOÕU.DGÕQODUGDLVH³NDPHWED÷ODPD´
J|÷V KL]DVÕQGD ROGX÷X LoLQ PH]DUÕ GD J|÷V
KL]DVÕQGDND]ÕOÕUgO\\ÕND\DQYHNHIHQOH\HQD\QÕ
YH\DIDUNOÕNLúLOHURODELOLU...
&HQD]HHYLQGHYH\DFHPHYLQGH\ÕNDQÕSNHIHQOHQLS
WDEXWDNRQGXNWDQVRQUDFHQD]HQDPD]ÕLoLQoÕNDUÕOÕU
0HNkQGDQ \HGL DGÕP X]DNODúWÕNWDQ VRQUD 'HGH
KDONWDQ FHPDDWWHQ ³UD]ÕOÕN´ LVWHU ³(\ FHPDDW %X
FDQGDUÕIHQDGDQGDUÕEHND\DLQWLNDOHWPLúJLGL\RU
.RPúX KDNNÕQÕ WX] HNPHN KDNNÕQÕ DKLUHW KDNNÕQÕ
KDNNÕQÕ]Õ HPH÷LQL]L KHODO HGL\RU PXVXQX]" +HODO
(GL\RU PXVXQX]" +HODO (GL\RU PXVXQX]" +HODO
(GL\RUPXVXQX]"´GL\HVRUDU*HQHOGHFHPDDW³KHODO
HGL\RUX]´ úHNOLQGH \DQÕWODU gOHQ ³FDQ´ GD KDNNÕ
ROGX÷XQX V|\OH\HQ ROXUVD PHYWDQÕQ KD\DWWD RODQ
PXVDKLEL EX KDNNÕQÕ |GHU 'HGH EX LúOHPL o GHID
1$OHYLOHUFHPHYLQGHQL\D]HGHUOHUNHQHUNHNOHULQHOOHULQLJ|
$OHYLOHUFHPHYLQGHQL\D]HGHUOHUNHQHUNHNOHULQHOOHULQLJ|
EHN KL]DVÕQGD NDGÕQODUÕQ LVH J|÷V KL]DVÕQGD VW VWH NR\DUDN
ED÷ODPDVÕQDµNDPHWED÷ODPD¶GHQLU
GHU:HOWHQ(UZHLVHGHP.UDQNHQXPGHU.RUDQUH]LWDWLRQ
ZLOOHQ 'HLQH *XQVW 'HLQH +HLOXQJ )DOOV VHLQ 7DJ
JHNRPPHQVHLQP|JHVRPDFKHLKPVHLQH5FNNHKU]X
'LU OHLFKWHU 2K +HUU YHUJHEH LKP XP GHU /LHEH ]X GHU
)DPLOLH GHV 3URSKHWHQ ZLOOHQ VHLQH 9HUJHKHQ³ 3 3
(V LVW HLQH EHUDXV JHOlX¿JH XQG ZLFKWLJH 7UDGLWLRQ GHU
$OHYLWHQ LQ XQVHUHP /DQG GHQ 9HUVWRUEHQ QDFK GHVVHQ
9HUVFKHLGHQ VR VFKQHOO ZLH P|JOLFK ]X EHVWDWWHQ 'DEHL
LVWGHU*HGDQNH³GHQ/HLFKQDPQLFKWDXIGHP%RGHQ]X
ODVVHQ XQG IUK ]X EHVWDWWHQ³ YRQ JU|‰WHU :LFKWLJNHLW21
$XFKEHLGHQ$OHYLWHQDXV'DPDOLVWGLHV]XEHREDFKWHQ
'LH9RUEHUHLWXQJ DXI GLH %HVWDWWXQJ EHL GHQ$OHYLWHQ
$UGDKDQV
GLH %HQDFKULFKWLJXQJ EHU GHQ 7RG GHU 3HUVRQ GLH
/HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ GLH (LQNOHLGXQJ LQ GDV /HLFKHQWXFK
GDV7RWHQJHEHW
=X GHQ HUVWHQ 'LQJHQ GLH PDQ QDFK GHP 7RG HLQHV
0HQVFKHQ PDFKW JHK|UW GDVV PDQ VHLQHQ 3XOV IKOW
XQG VLFKHUJHKW GDVV GLH 3HUVRQ JHVWRUEHQ LVW :HQQ GLH
YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ DXI GHU 6HLWH OLHJW GDQQ GUHKW PDQ
VLHVRGDVVHURGHUVLHDXIGHP5FNHQOLHJW>'DUDXIKLQ@
VFKOLH‰WPDQGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQYRUVLFKWLJGLH/LGHU
XQG OHJW LKUH )‰H VR ]XVDPPHQ GDVV VLFK GLH GLFNHQ
=HKHQEHUKUHQ0DQOHJWLKUGLH+lQGHDQGLH6HLWHXQG
ZHQQ HV DQJHEUDFKW LVW HQWNOHLGHW PDQ VLH ELV DXI GLH
8QWHUZlVFKH0LWHLQHU$UW6FKDOE]ZHLQHP7XFK¿[LHUW
PDQ>[email protected]|IIQHW'HU
9RUVWHOOXQJZRQDFKPDQ³QDFNW>DXIGLH:HOW@NRPPWXQG
QDFNWZLHGHU>DXVGHU:HOW@JHKW³3HQWVSUHFKHQG]LHKW
PDQ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ GLH 6FKPXFNJHJHQVWlQGH
ZLH]%GLH8KU.HWWHQRGHU5LQJHDXVIDOOVYRUKDQGHQ
%HLGHQ$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQVLVWGHU%UDXFKYHUEUHLWHWGDVV
PDQGLH7UHQXQG)HQVWHU|IIQHWGDPLWGLH6HHOHGLHVLFK
YRP.|USHUJHWUHQQWKDWOHLFKWHUDXIVHLQH5HLVHPDFKHQ
NDQQ333322
(V LVW GXUFKDXV EOLFK GDVV PDQ GLH %HVWDWWXQJVULWHQ
UXKHQ OlVVW GDPLW 9HUZDQGWH DXV GHU )HUQH HLQWUHIIHQ
N|QQHQREZRKOHVLQGHQ6RPPHUPRQDWHQQXUJHPDFKW
ZLUG ZHQQ HV DXVGUFNOLFK JHZQVFKW LVW 'D DEHU
>KHXW]XWDJH@ GLH FHP+lXVHU EHU /HLFKHQKlXVHU RGHU
21 7$ùö,1$KPHW(UH÷OLYHdHYUHVLQGHNL$OHYLOHUGH6RV\DOYH
'LQL+D\DW0DVWHUDUEHLWYRUJHOHJWIUGDV,QVWLWXWIU6R]LDOZLV
VHQVFKDIWHQ6HOoXN8QLYHUVLWlW.RQ\D6
22 AYATA 6DLP .ÕUúHKLU <|UHVL $EGDOODUÕQÕQ 'LQL øQDQoODUÕ
h]HULQH %LU $UDúWÕUPD 9HU|IIHQWOLFKWH 'RNWRUDUEHLW YRUJHOHJW
GHP,QVWLWXWIU6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU(UFL\HV8QLYHUVLWlW.D\
VHUL6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
WHNUDUODU%|\OHFHFHQD]HQDPD]ÕLoLQPXVDOODWDúÕQD
J|WUOU &HQD]H QDPD]ÕQGD VDI WXWDQODUD GHGH
VHVOHQHUHN ³0úNO KDOL RODQ úDKÕV \DQL DEGHVWL
ROPD\DQ\DGDGúNQRODQELULOHULYDUVDGúNQOHU
QDVÕO NL FHP HYLQH DOÕQPD]VD FHQD]H QDPD]ÕQD GD
DOÕQPD] FHQD]H QDPD]ÕQD GXUPDVÕQ´ GHU .
.. %D\DQODU LVWHUOHUVH FHQD]H QDPD]ÕQD
GXUDELOLUOHU)DWLKDRNXQXUYHGXDHGLOLU
'úNQ YH\D LNUDU YHUPH\HQ NLúLOHULQ GH FHQD]H
QDPD]Õ NÕOÕQÕU $PD JHQHO RODUDN \HPH÷L \HQLOPH]
GXDVÕ NXUDQÕ RNXQPD] øQWLKDU $OHYLOLNWH GH JQDK
VD\ÕOÕU $PD LQWLKDU HGHQ NLúLQLQ FHQD]H QDPD]Õ
NÕOÕQÕU GH¿QL \DSÕOÕU .. 6QQL FHQD]H
W|UHQOHULQGHQ IDUNOÕ RODUDN GHGH \D GD SLU WDEXWXQ
|QQGHFHPDDWOHVDIWXWDUNHQLPDPWDEXWODFHPDDWLQ
DUDVÕQGD VDI WXWPDNWDGÕU <LQH 6QQL JHOHQHNWHQ
IDUNOÕ RODUDN QDPD]Õ NÕOGÕUDQ NLúLQLQ 'HGH ROPDVÕ
GXUXPXQGDQL\HWLQ³X\GXPLPDPD´úHNOLQGHGH÷LO
³X\GXP2QøNLLPDPD´úHNOLQGH\DSÕOÕ\RUROPDVÕGÕU
.HVNLQ
gOQQPH]DUDNRQXOPDVÕ
&HQD]H QDPD]Õ NÕOÕQGÕNWDQ VRQUD GH¿QH J|WUOU
'H¿Q LúOHPLQL \DNÕQ DNUDEDODUÕ GD \DSDELOLU NRPúX
YH\D R LúLQ HUEDEÕ ELOHQOHU GH \DSDELOLU 7DEXWWDQ
oÕNDUÕODUDN PH]DUD NRQXOXU /HQW YXUXOPD KHVDEÕQÕ
\DSDUODU/HQWYXUXOPDND]ÕODQPH]DUÕQ]HPLQLQGHQ
NÕEOH WDUDIÕQD JHOHQ NÕVPÕQÕQ LoHUL GR÷UX FHQD]HQLQ
VÕ÷DFD÷Õ NDGDU R\XOPDVÕGÕU 0H]DUÕQ NÕEOH WDUDIÕQD
DoÕODQ EX oXNXU FHQD]HQLQ NRQXODFD÷Õ \HUGLU .
&HQD]HNÕEOH\HGR÷UXLoHULDOÕQÕSVD÷WDUDIÕQD\DWÕUÕOÕU
.ÕEOH\HGR÷UXYHULOPHNLoLQ\XPXúDNWRSUDNPH]DUÕQ
DOWÕQD NR\XOXU YH NHIHQLQ \] NÕVPÕ DoÕOÕU %DúÕ
EDWÕ\D D\DNODUÕ GR÷X\D |Q JQH\H JHOLU<DNÕQODUÕ
WDUDIÕQGDQ J|]QH ELU WXWDP WRSUDN NRQXOXU 'H¿Q
LúOHPLQGHDFHOHHGLOPH]7DKWDVÕRWX|UWOU$NúDP
GH¿Q LúOHPL \DSÕOPD] g÷OHQ YH\D LNLQGL \DSÕOÕU
'DKD VRQUD YHIDW HGHQOHU LoLQ VRQUDNL JQ EHNOHQLU
0H]DUÕQ EDúÕQD PH]DU EDú WDKWDVÕ WDKWDGDQ ELU
SDUoDNRQXOXULVPLGR÷XPYH|OPWDULKOHUL\D]ÕOÕU
YH ELU \ÕO VRQUD PH]DU \DSÕOÕU %LU \ÕO LoLQGH PH]DU
WRSUD÷Õ WDP \HUOHúWL÷LQGHQ GROD\Õ JHQHOOLNOH ELU \ÕO
VRQUDPH]DUÕ\DSÕOÕU...
gOQQ DUGÕQGDQ \DNÕQODUÕ WDUDIÕQGDQ \DSÕODQ GXD
DQGHUH0|JOLFKNHLWHQ]XU.KOXQJYHUIJHQLVWPDQQLFKW
JH]ZXQJHQGLH/HLFKHLQGHQ6RPPHUPRQDWHQVRIRUW]X
EHVWDWWHQ3333+LHUDQNDQQPDQHUNHQQHQZLH
GLH WUDGLWLRQHOOHQ 3UDNWLNHQ HLQH DQGHUH )RUP DQJHVLFKWV
GHU WHFKQLVFKHQ (QWZLFNOXQJ GHU PRGHUQHQ :HOW
DQQHKPHQ
'LH%HNDQQWPDFKXQJGHV7RGHVHLQHV0HQVFKHQEHLGHQ
$OHYLWHQLVWYRQGHUGHU6XQQLWHQXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKXQGPDQ
]LHKWHVYRUGHQ7RGHLQHV0HQVFKHQEHNDQQW]XPDFKHQ
LQGHPPDQHLQH$QNQGLJXQJYRP0LQDUHWWPDFKW)UKHU
JLQJ PDQ KLHUEHL YRQ +DXV ]X +DXV DEHU KHXW]XWDJH
PDFKW PDQ YRQ GHQ /DXWVSUHFKHUQ GHV 0LQDUHWWV RGHU
GHP'XUFKVDJH6\VWHPGHU6WDGW*HEUDXFK33'LH
/HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ ZLUG YRQ HLQHP 0DQQ JHPDFKW ZHQQ
GLHYHUVWRUEHQH3HUVRQPlQQOLFKLVW±PHLVWHLQ$QJHK|ULJHU
GHV9HUVWRUEHQHQGHUVLFKGDPLWDXVNHQQWXQGZHQQGLH
YHUVWRUEHQH3HUVRQZHLEOLFKLVWGDQQYRQHLQHU)UDX'LH
3HUVRQGLHGLH/HLFKHQZDVFKXQJGXUFKIKUWZlVFKWGHQ
/HLFKQDPHUVWQDFKLVODPLVFKHP5LWXVXQGVHW]WGDQQHUVW
GLH:DVFKXQJ IRUW 'DUDXIKLQ ZHLVW VLH GLH$QJHK|ULJHQ
DQDXFKHLQZHQLJ:DVVHUDXIGHQ/HLFKQDP]XJLH‰HQ
)UKHU ZXUGH GLH /HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ LP +DXV GHU
YHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQJHPDFKWKHXW]XWDJHDEHUIKUWPDQ
GLH /HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ LQ HLQHP H[WUD GDIU DXVHUVHKHQHQ
5DXPLQGHQFHP+lXVHUQGXUFK3331DFKGHU
:DVFKXQJZLUGGHU/HLFKQDPLQGDV/HLFKHQWXFKJHNOHLGHW
± GDV /HLFKHQWXFK LVW ZHL‰ 'DUDXIKLQ ZLUG GLH /HLFKH
LQ GHQ 6DUJ JHOHJW XQG GHU 6DUJ ZLUG PLW HLQHP JUQHQ
7XFK EHGHFNW ,Q HLQLJHQ 5HJLRQHQ ZLUG GHU /HLFKQDP
GUHL 0DO PLW HLQHP 7XFK XPZLFNHOW ZlKUHQG GLH GULWWH
6FKLFKW JUQ LVW 'LH JUQH )DUEH UKUW GDKHU GDVV GLH
.OHLGXQJGHV+VH\LQ>GHU6RKQ$OLV@JUQJHZHVHQVHLQ
VROO23 :HQQ GLH YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ HLQ 0lUW\UHU LVW
GDQQEHGHFNWPDQGHQ6DUJPLWGHUWUNLVFKHQ)ODJJH3
3 3 3 %HL GHU %HNOHLGXQJ GHV /HLFKQDPV ZHUGHQ
)UDXHQPLWHLQHU6FKLFKWPHKUXPZLFNHOW'DUEHUKLQDXV
LVW GDV *UDE GHU )UDXHQ WLHIHU DOV GDV GHU 0lQQHU 'LHV
VWHKWLQ9HUELQGXQJGDPLWGDVVEHLGHU(KUHQYHUEHXJXQJ
ZlKUHQGGHUFHP=HUHPRQLHGHQ0lQQHUQDXI%DXFKK|KH
XQGGHQ)UDXHQDXI%UXVWK|KHHLQH6FKlUSHXPJHEXQGHQ
ZLUGZDVPDQ³NDPHWED÷ODPD³QHQQW$XVGLHVHP*UXQG
UHLFKW GDV *UDE GHU )UDXHQ ELV ]XU %UXVWK|KH ZlKUHQG
GDV*UDEGHU0lQQHUELV]XP%DXFKUHLFKW'LH3HUVRQ
GLHGLH/HLFKHZlVFKWNDQQDXFKGLH3HUVRQVHLQGLHGHQ
/HLFKQDPPLWGHP/HLFKHQWXFKXPZLFNHOW333
1DFKGHPGHU/HLFKQDPJHZDVFKHQPLWGHP/HLFKHQWXFK
XPZLFNHOW XQG LQ GHQ 6DUJ JHOHJW ZXUGH WUlJW PDQ GHQ
/HLFKQDP KLQDXV XP LQ *HJHQZDUW GHV /HLFKQDPV GDV
7RWHQJHEHW YHUULFKWHQ ]X N|QQHQ 'HU GHGH tritt sieben
23 KESKIN<DK\D0XVWDID6DUÕ6DOWÕN2FD÷ÕQD%D÷OÕ$OHYLOHUGH
gOPLOHøOJLOL øQDQoYH5LWHOOHU,Q=HLWVFKULIWGHU6R]LDOZLV
VHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ )DNXOWlW GHU )ÕUDW 8QLYHUVLWlW$XVJDEH 6
>GDPLWVLQGMXQJH6ROGDWHQJHPHLQWGLHLQGHU7UNHLLP
>GDPLWVLQGMXQJH6ROGDWHQJHPHLQWGLHLQGHU7UNHLLP
.DPSIJHJHQGHQ7HUURUJHW|WHWZHUGHQ@
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
³(\ \DUDGDQ |OP]H GLULPL]H HUOHULQ SLUOHULQ
JHoPLúOHULQSH\JDPEHUOHULQYHOLOHULQQHELOHULQ\]
VX\X KUPHWLQH EX +DNN¶D \U\HQ FDQÕPÕ]Õ GD
\DQÕQD DO \DUGÕPFÕVÕ RO´. úHNOLQGHGLU gOQQ
DUGÕQGDQD÷ÕW\DNÕOÕUDPDGXDRNXQGX÷XQGD.XUDQYH
JOEHQN RNXQGX÷XQGD VHVVL] D÷ODPDODUÕ NRQXVXQGD
X\DUÕOÕU gOQQ DUGÕQGDQ D÷ODPDN GR÷DO NDUúÕODQÕU
+DWWDJ|]\DúÕ|OHQNLúLOHULQDNUDEDODUÕQÕUDKDWODWPDVÕ
DoÕVÕQGDQ|QHPOLGLU..
7DONÕQ'XDVÕPHOHNOHULQ|OHQNLúL\H\DUGÕPHGLOPHVL
için HGLOHQGXDPH]DUGDHQVRQRNXQDQGXDGÕU ³(\
)DWPD¶GDQ GR÷PD 6OH\PDQ 'Q\D PHQ]LOL
IDQLGLUDKUHWPHQ]LOLEDNLGLU<FH7DQUÕ¶QÕQKNP
\UG GQ\D JQOHULQLQ VRQXQGD DKUHW JQOHULQLQ
EDúÕQGDVÕQ 5DEELQ NDWÕQGD VDQD 5DEELQL GLQLQL
SH\JDPEHULQL NLWDEÕQÕ NÕEOHQL LPDPÕQÕ VRUDUODU
<DúDPÕQGDLQDQGÕ÷ÕQJLELNRUNPDGDQVHUEHVWoHV|\OH
NL5DEE¶LP$OODK¶WÕU'LQLPøVODP¶GÕU3H\JDPEHULP
+] 0XKDPPHG¶GLU .LWDEÕP .XUDQ¶GÕU .ÕEOHP
0DNDPÕ øEUDKLP¶GLU øPDPÕP +] $OL¶GLU (KOL
%H\W¶LQ EHQGHVL\LP 2QODUD LQDQGÕP 2QODUD LNUDU
YHUGLP$OODK¶DKDPGROVXQ2QODUÕQVR\XQDVDODWYH
VHODPROVXQ´..
'H¿QVRQUDVÕøúOHPOHU
ND]PDWDNÕUWÕVÕ\DVDQPDJQOHULGHYUL\H
GDUGDQLQGLUPH
&HQD]H GHIQHGLOGLNWHQ VRQUD ³ND]PD WDNÕUWÕVÕ´
DGÕQGD KHOYDVÕ GD÷ÕWÕOÕU %XQXQOD ELUOLNWH EWQ
FHQD]HVDKLSOHULFHQD]HOHULQDUGÕQGDQ\HPHNGD÷ÕWÕU
FDQDúÕ....&HQD]HLúOHPLQGHQVRQUD
³FDQODU KDNND \U\HQ FDQÕPÕ] LoLQ YHULOHQ ORNPD´
.LoLQGDYHWHGLOLU(YGH\DGDFHPHYLQGH\HPHN
YHULOLU/RNPDRNXQXUGXDHGLOLU
³(YYHO $OODK GL\HOLP .DGLPL %LOODK GL\HOLP
*HOGL UÕ]D ORNPDVÕ +DN YHUVLQ EL] \L\HOLP
GHPLQH + GL\HOLP (OKDPGOLOODK (OKDPGOLOODK
(OKDPGOLOODK 1LPHWL FHOLO EHUHNHWL +DOLO +DELEL
+XGD 5HVXO¶X NLEUL\D VHUYHU (QEL\D 0XKDPPHG
0XVWDID ùDKÕ 9HOD\DW $OL\\O 0UWD]D ùHKLGL
6FKULWWH EHLVHLWH XQG IUDJW GLH *HPHLQGH QDFK GHUHQ
³JHJHQVHLWLJHP (LQYHUVWlQGQLV³ ³UÕ]DOÕN³ >(U VSULFKW@
³2K*HPHLQGHGLHVHU0HQVFKKDWGLHCYHUJlQJOLFKH:HOWC
YHUODVVHQ XQG UHLVW ]XU CHZLJHQ:HOWC *|QQW XQG VHJQHW
LKU GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ LKU 1DFKEDUVFKDIWVUHFKW
LKU 6DO] XQG LKU %URW LKU $QUHFKW LP -HQVHLWV XQG HXUH
0KHQ"*|QQWXQGVHJQHWLKUHV"*|QQWXQGVHJQHWLKUHV"
*|QQWXQGVHJQHWLKUHV"³>$XIGLHVH)UDJH@DQWZRUWHWGLH
*HPHLQGHLQGHU5HJHOPLW³-DZLUJ|QQHQXQGVHJQHQHV
LKU³:HQQHVHLQH3HUVRQJLEWGHUHQ5HFKWQLFKWYHUJROWHQ
LVWVRJOHLFKWGLHVGHU:HJEUXGHUE]ZGLH:HJVFKZHVWHU
>³PVDKLS³@ GHV9HUVWRUEHQHQ DXV 'HU GHGH ZLHGHUKROW
GLHVHV 5LWXDO GUHL 0DO 'DUDXIKLQ ZLUG GHU 6DUJ DXI GHQ
VRJ ³PXVDOOD6WHLQ³ JHOHJW XP GDV 7RWHQJHEHW ]X
YHUULFKWHQ 'HU GHGH ZDUQW GLH *HPHLQGH GLH VLFK IU
GDV *HEHW LQ 5HLKHQ DXIJHVWHOOW KDW XQG VSULFKW ³:HQQ
MHPDQG XQWHU HXFK QLFKW ULWXHOO UHLQ LVW >GK GLH ULWXHOOH
:DVFKXQJQLFKWYROO]RJHQKDW@RGHUHLQ³$XVJHVWR‰HQHU³
³GúNQ³ LVW >GLH ³$XVJHVWR‰HQHQ³ GUIHQ DXFK QLFKW
DQ GHU FHP=HUHPRQLH WHLOQHKPHQ@ VR VROO HU >RGHU VLH@
QLFKWDP7RWHQJHEHWWHLOQHKPHQ³333'LH)UDXHQ
N|QQHQDP7RWHQJHEHWWHLOQHKPHQZHQQVLHHVZQVFKHQ
'DQDFKZLUGGLH)DWLKD UH]LWLHUWXQGPDQVSULFKW*HEHWH
$XFKIUGLH³$XVJHVWR‰HQHQ³XQGGLH1LFKWHLQJHZHLKWHQ
VSULFKWPDQGDV7RWHQJHEHWMHGRFKJLEWPDQQRUPDOHUZHLVH
PDQ NHLQ 7RWHQPDKO ]X GHUHQ (KUHQ XQG PDQ UH]LWLHUW
DXFK QLFKW GHQ .RUDQ IU VLH 6HOEVWPRUG ZLUG LP
$OHYLWHQWXP DOV 6QGH EHWUDFKWHW MHGRFK YHUULFKWHW PDQ
DXFK IU GLH 6HOEVWP|UGHU GDV 7RWHQJHEHW XQG EHVWDWWHW
VLH DXFK WUDGLWLRQVJHPl‰ 3 3 ,P *HJHQVDW] ]X GHQ
%HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLHQGHU6XQQLWHQEHLGHQHQGHU,PDP
VLFKEHLP7RWHQJHEHW]ZLVFKHQGHQ6DUJXQGGLH*HPHLQGH
HLQUHLKWVWHKWGHU0HLVWHUE]ZGHUGHGHYRUGHP6DUJ(LQ
DQGHUHU 8QWHUVFKLHG ]XU VXQQLWLVFKHQ 7UDGLWLRQ LVW GDVV
ZHQQGHUGHGHGDV7RWHQJHEHWOHLWHWPDQQLFKWGLH:RUWH
³,FKIROJHGHP,PDP³VRQGHUQGLH:RUWH³,FKIROJHGHQ
=Z|OI,PDPHQ³VSULFKW
'LH%HHUGLJXQJGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQ
1DFKGHP GDV 7RWHQJHEHW YHUULFKWHW ZXUGH EULQJW PDQ
GHQ /HLFKQDP ]XU %HHUGLJXQJ 'LH %HHUGLJXQJ N|QQHQ
DXFK QDKH 9HUZDQGWH 1DFKEDUQ RGHU %HNDQQWH GLH
(UIDKUXQJGDPLWKDEHQGXUFKIKUHQ'HU/HLFKQDPZLUG
DXVGHP6DUJJHKROWXQGLQGDV*UDEJHOHJW>«@(UZLUG
DXI GLH UHFKWH 6HLWH JHOHJW XQG JHQ 0HNND DXVJHULFKWHW
8PGHQ/HLFKQDPJHQ0HNNDDXVULFKWHQ]XN|QQHQOHJW
PDQHWZDVZHLFKH(UGHXQWHUGHQ/HLFKQDP0DQGHFNW
>GDUDXIKLQ@GDV*HGLFKWGHV/HLFKQDPVDXI'HU.RSIZLUG
JHQ:HVWHQGLH)‰HJHQ2VWHQXQGGLH%UXVWJHQ6GHQ
DXVJHULFKWHW'LHGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQQDKH6WHKHQGHQ
>PHLVWHLQ0DUPRUEORFNLP+RIGHU0RVFKHHZRUDXIPDQ
>PHLVWHLQ0DUPRUEORFNLP+RIGHU0RVFKHHZRUDXIPDQ
GHQ6DUJOHJWXPGDV7RWHQJHEHW]XYHUULFKWHQ@
>GLHHUVWH6XUHGHV.RUDQ@
>GLHHUVWH6XUHGHV.RUDQ@
KESKIN6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
øPDP +VH\Q¶L GHúWL .HUEDOD¶QÕQ KUPHWL KDNNÕ
LoLQ+DNN¶D\U\HQ««&DQ¶ÕQDGÕQDYHULOHQEX
ORNPDODUÕGHUJDKÕL]]HWLQGHNDEXOH\OH´..
<DVÕ GDKD oRN DLOH \DNÕQODUÕ WXWDU *HQo YH\D DQL
|OPOHUGH \D GD úHKLW ROXUVD EXQODUÕQ \DVÕ X]XQ
ROXU'R÷DO|OPOHULQ\DVÕGDKDNÕVDROPDNWDGÕU<DV
VUHVLQFHúHQOLN\DSÕOPD]%LUG÷QYDUVDHUWHOHQLU
.LUYHOLN \DSÕOPD] (UWHOHQHPH\HFHN ELU GXUXP
ROXUVDGDFHQD]HHYLQGHQUÕ]DOÕNDOÕQÕU³RGD$OODKÕQ
HPUL EX GD$OODKÕQ HPUL GL\H´ .. GúQOU
*HOHQHNVHOOL÷LQ D÷ÕU EDVWÕ÷Õ \HUOHUGH WRSOXPXQ
DGHWOHUL \HULQH JHWLUPHVL LoLQ FHQD]H HYLQH ELU oHúLW
EDVNÕ\DSWÕ÷ÕQÕEHOLUWHQgUQHN\DNÕQÕQÕ
ND\EHWPLú DLOHQLQ WRSOXPGD VD\JÕQOÕ÷ÕQÕQ GHYDP
HGHELOPHVL YH \DVOD LOJLOL DGHWOHUL \HULQH JHWLUPHVL
LoLQ\HVLQLND\EHWPLúDLOHQLQYHFHPDDWLQWRSOXP
WDUDIÕQGDQGHQHWOHQGL÷LQLV|\OHU
gOHQ NLúLQLQ \DNÕQODUÕ LVWH÷H ED÷OÕ RODUDN GH¿QGHQ
VRQUDPH]DUDJLGHELOLU0H]DUNDELU]L\DUHWOHULLVH
SHUúHPEH YH oR÷XQOXNOD NXWVDO NDEXO HGLOHQ &XPD
JQOHULGLU.dHUDKPXP\DNÕOPD]YHPH]DUODUGD
PXP\DNPDNLoLQD\UÕ\HUEXOXQPD]YH\D\DSÕOPD]
gOQQNÕUNÕRNXWXOXU.XUDQPHYOLW<DVLQRNXQXU
JOEHQN oHNLOLU GXD HGLOLU<HPHN YHULOHU YH ELULQFL
\ÕOG|QPQGH \ÕOOÕN KD\UDWÕ PH]DUÕ \DSÕOÕU YH
\HPHN FDQ DúÕ YHULOLU 0H]DU \DSÕPÕ HNVHUL\HWOH
ELULQFL \ÕO G|QPQGH ROPDNOD EHUDEHU HNRQRPLN
GXUXPDJ|UHLVWH÷HED÷OÕRODUDNKHUKDQJLELU]DPDQGD
\DSÕODELOLU 1HYUX] +] ÆOLQLQ GR÷XP JQ ROPDVÕ
GROD\ÕVÕ\ODNXWVDOVD\ÕOÕUYHPH]DU]L\DUHWL\DSÕODELOLU
...
$UGDKDQ$OHYLOL÷LQGHKDNND\U\HQNLúLQLQKD\DWWD
LNHQ LOLúNL LoLQGH ROGX÷X Hú GRVW DNUDED YH GL÷HU
WDQÕGÕNODUÕ\OD KHODOOHúPHVL DPDFÕQD \|QHOLN RODUDN
³GDUGDQLQGLUPHFHPL´GDUFHPLYH\DGDUÕ0DQVXU
RODUDNGDELOLQHQFHP\DSÕOÕUgOHQFDQÕQ³LVWLUDKDWÕ
UXKX´ LoLQ EX GDUGDQ LQGLUPH HUNkQÕ DoÕOÕ\RU .
WXQHLQH+DQGYROO(UGHDXIGLH$XJHQGHV/HLFKQDPV%HL
GHU %HHUGLJXQJ OlVVW PDQ NHLQH (LOH DXINRPPHQ 0DQ
EHHUGLJW GLH 7RWHQ QLFKW DEHQGV HQWZHGHU PRUJHQV RGHU
PLWWDJV:HQQHV]XVSlWLVWZDUWHWPDQGHQQlFKVWHQ7DJ
DE0DQJUlEWHLQ+RO]EUHWWPLWGHP1DPHQGHP*HEXUWV
XQG7RGHVGDWXPGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQDQGDV.RSIHQGH
GHV*UDEHVHLQ>(UVW@QDFKHLQHP-DKUHUULFKWHWPDQHLQ
>RUGHQWOLFKHV@ *UDE GDPLW VLFK GLH (UGH DXI GHP *UDE
IHVWLJHQ NDQQ 3 3 3 'LH GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ
1DKHVWHKHQGHQVSUHFKHQIROJHQGHV*HEHW³2K6FK|SIHU
QLPP'LFKXPGHU0HLVWHU3URSKHWHQXQG+HLOLJHQZLOOHQ
XQVHUHV YHUVWRUEHQHQ *HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGHV DQ XQG KHOIH
LKU³3 0DQZHKNODJW]ZDUEHUGHQ7RGDEHUZlKUHQG
GHU .RUDQUH]LWDWLRQ XQG GHU 5H]LWDWLRQ YRQ /LWDQHLHQ
PDKQWPDQGLH$QZHVHQGHQOHLVH]XZHLQHQ'DV:HLQHQ
EHU GHQ 7RG ZLUG >MHGRFK@ DOV QDWUOLFK EHWUDFKWHW ±
>PDQ LVW GHU 0HLQXQJ GDVV@ GDV :HLQHQ ]XU VHHOLVFKHQ
%HUXKLJXQJGHU+LQWHUEOLHEHQHQZLFKWLJLVW33
7DNOÕQ>"@LVWGDVOHW]WH*HEHWZDVPDQDP*UDEVSULFKWHLQ
*HEHWGDVVPDQVSULFKWGDPLWGLH(QJHOGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ
3HUVRQ KHOIHQ P|JHQ >(V ODXWHW IROJHQGHUPD‰HQ@
³2K >9HUVWRUEHQHU E]Z 9HUVWRUEHQH@ « 'LH :HOW LVW
YHUJlQJOLFK>QXU@GDV-HQVHLWVYRQ%HVWDQG'HU7DJGHV
+HUUQLVWDQJHEURFKHQXQGDP(QGHGHLQHULUGLVFKHQ7DJH
EHJLQQHQ QXQ GHLQH 7DJH LP -HQVHLWV ,Q GHU *HJHQZDUW
GHLQHV +HUUQ IUDJW PDQ GLFK QDFK GHLQHP +HUUQ GHLQHU
5HOLJLRQGHLQHP3URSKHWHQGHLQHP%XFKGHLQHU.LEOD
GHLQHP,PDP6SUHFKHIXUFKWORVXQGIUHLVRZLHGXHV]X
/HE]HLWHQJHWDQKDVWGHQQGHLQ+HUULVW*RWWC'HU,VODP
LVW PHLQH 5HOLJLRQ 0XKDPPHG LVW PHLQ 3URSKHW 0HLQ
%XFKLVWGHU.RUDQ0HLQH.LEODLVWGDV+DXV$EUDKDPV
>0HNND@0HLQ,PDPLVW$OL,FKELQHLQ'LHQHUGHU)DPLOLH
GHV 3URSKHWHQ 0HLQ *ODXEH JDOW LKQHQ 0HLQ *HO|EQLV
JDOWLKQHQ*RWWJHEKUWGHU'DQN*HSULHVHQXQGJHVHJQHW
VHLLKU*HVFKOHFKWC33
5LWXHOOH +DQGOXQJHQ QDFK GHU %HHUGLJXQJ ND]PD
WDNÕUWÕVÕ :HKNODJHQ *HGHQNWDJH GHYUL\H GDUGDQ
LQGLUPH
1DFKGHPGHU/HLFKQDPEHHUGLJWZXUGHWHLOWPDQ+DOYD
>WUNLVFKHU +RQLJ@ DXV GDV ³ND]PD WDNÕUWÕVÕ³ JHQDQQW
ZLUG 'DQDFK WHLOHQ GLH $QJHK|ULJHQ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ
HLQ (VVHQ DXV > ZDV ³FDQ DúÕ³ ³/HEHQVVSHLVH³ E]Z
³6HHOHQVSHLVH³JHQDQQWZLUG@3333$OOHVLQG
]X GLHVHU 6SHLVXQJ ]X (KUHQ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ
>HLQH$UWGHU7RWHQVSHLVXQJ@
>HLQH$UWGHU7RWHQVSHLVXQJ@
>'HU*ODXEHDQGLHVRJ³GHYUL\H³GHUIlOVFKOLFKHUZHLVHPLW
GHU6HHOHQZDQGHUXQJVOHKUHJOHLFKJHVHW]WZLUGEHVFKUHLEWGHQ
$XIXQG$EVWLHJGHUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ6HLQVVWXIHQLQ=XVDPPHQ
KDQJPLWGHU(PDQDWLRQVOHKUHGHV*|WWOLFKHQ6HLQV@
>'LH
>'LHGDUGDQLQGLUPH=HUHPRQLHZDVZ|UWOLFK³YRP*DOJHQ
KlQJHQ³EHGHXWHWLVWHLQ5LWXDO]XU/RVVSUHFKXQJGHUYHUVWRUEH
QHQ3HUVRQZlKUHQGGHUFHP=HUHPRQLH@
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
gOHQ NLúLQLQ \HULQH PXVDKLEL GDUÕ 0DQVXU¶D GXUXU
DPDo |OHQ FDQ NXO KDNNÕ LOH KDNND \UPúVH R
KDNNÕ|GHPHNWLUgOHQLQERUFXYDUVDLQFLWWL÷LNLúLOHU
YDUVD KHVDSODúÕU EX KHVDSODúPD\Õ KDNND \U\HQLQ
PXVDKLELVWOHQLU..'DUGDQLQGLUPHFHPLQLQ
]DPDQÕ \|UH\H J|UH GH÷LúLNOLN J|VWHUHELOPHNOH
EHUDEHU 'DPDO¶GD |OP ROD\ÕQÕQ NÕUNÕQFÕ JQ
\DSÕOPDNWDGÕU..
'DUFHPLJHQHOKDWODUÕ\ODú|\OHGLU%LUNXUEDQNHVLOLU
YH ORNPDVÕ GD÷ÕWÕOÕU 'HGH FHPGH KDNND \U\HQ
FDQÕQ GDUGD GXUDQ PXVDKLELQH YH DLOHVLQH VRUDU
³(\YDOODK FDQODU úX DQGD KDNND \UPú RODQ
FDQÕQ GDUÕQD GXUPXú EXOXQX\RUVXQX] KDNNÕQ YH
KDONÕQ KX]XUXQGD EL] VL]H VRUX\RUX] µ%X FHPGHQ
GÕúDUÕGDQYH\DVRQUDGDQELULJHOVHKDNND\U\HQEX
\DNÕQÕQÕ]GDQKDNYHKXNXNWDOHSHGHUVHYHKDNNÕQGD
GDKDNOÕLVHKHODOOHúPH\HUD]ÕPÕVÕQÕ]"¶.'DUGD
GXUDQODU GD ³(\YDOODK SLULP (÷HU G|NW÷ YDUVD
GROGXUDFD÷Õ] D÷ODWWÕ÷Õ YDUVD JOGUHFH÷L] \ÕNWÕ÷Õ
YDUVD NDOGÕUDFD÷Õ] %X \DNÕQÕPÕ]Õ NXO KDNNÕ LOH XOX
GLYDQGD EÕUDNPDN LVWHPL\RUX]´ GHUOHU . 'HGH
FHPDDWHKLWDEHQ³'DUDGXUDQODUÕGX\GXQX]KDNND
\U\HQ FDQÕPÕ]GDQ UD]Õ PÕVÕQÕ]"´ GHU &HPDDW
³+HODO ROVXQ´ GL\HUHN o NHUH WHNUDU HGHU +DNND
\U\HQ NLúLGHQ KDN WDOHS HGHQ ROXUVD EX NLúL\L
PXVDKLEL UD]Õ HWPHN ]RUXQGDGÕU *HoPLúWH NDSDOÕ
WRSOXPVDO JUXSODU KDOLQGH \DúD\DQ $OHYLOHULQ JUXS
LoLGD\DQÕúPDVÕDoÕVÕQGDQPXVDKLSOLNoRN|QHPOLELU
\HUHVDKLSWLUYH|OHQNLúLQLQJHULGHNDODQPXVDKLELQLQ
\RO DUNDGDúOÕ÷Õ VRUXPOXOX÷X |OP ROD\ÕQGDQ VRQUD
ELOHGHYDPHWPHNWHGLU
'HYUL\H LQDQFÕ 1XVD\ULOHUGH \R÷XQ RODUDN LQDQÕODQ
ELUROJXGXUgQFO.DUV$OHYLOHULQGH
GHYUL\H ¿NULQLQ YDUOÕ÷ÕQD LúDUHW HWPLúWLU $UGDKDQ
$OHYLOHULQGH GH GHYUL\H LQDQÕúÕ PHYFXWWXU gOHQ ELU
³FDQ´ UXKODU DOHPLQH JLGHU JQDKÕQÕQ VHYDEÕQÕQ
KHVDEÕQÕ RUDGD YHULU .ÕUNÕQFÕ JQQGH UXK LVWHUVH
WHNUDU IDUNOÕ ELU EHGHQGH GQ\D\D JHOHELOLU .|W
ELU \DúDP \DúDPÕúVD YH\D JQDKNkUVD VUQJHQ ELU
KD\YDQGDYFXWEXODELOLU..
HLQJHODGHQ'LHV¿QGHWHQWZHGHU]X+DXVHRGHULPFHP
+DXVVWDWW0DQVSULFKW*HEHWHXQGGDV*HEHW]XU6HJQXQJ
GHU 6SHLVHQ >GDV IROJHQGHUPD‰HQ ODXWHW@ ³(YYHO $OODK
GL\HOLP .DGLPL %LOODK GL\HOLP *HOGL UÕ]D ORNPDVÕ +DN
YHUVLQ EL] \L\HOLP GHPLQH + GL\HOLP (OKDPGOLOODK
(OKDPGOLOODK(OKDPGOLOODK1LPHWLFHOLOEHUHNHWL+DOLO
+DELEL+XGD5HVXO¶XNLEUL\DVHUYHU(QEL\D0XKDPPHG
0XVWDID ùDKÕ 9HOD\DW $OL\\O 0UWD]D ùHKLGL øPDP
+VH\Q¶L GHúWL .HUEDOD¶QÕQ KUPHWL KDNNÕ LoLQ +DNN¶D
\U\HQ « &DQ¶ÕQ DGÕQD YHULOHQ EX ORNPDODUÕ GHUJDKÕ
L]]HWLQGHNDEXOH\OH´33
(V WUDXHUQ HKHU GLH )DPLOLHQDQJHK|ULJHQ :HQQ HLQ
MXQJHU 0HQVFK VWLUEW HV HLQHQ SO|W]OLFKHQ7RG JLEW RGHU
MHPDQG]XHLQHPúHKLWZLUGGDQQGDXHUWGLH7UDXHUOlQJHU
:lKUHQG GHU 7UDXHU]HLW ¿QGHQ NHLQH )HVWH RGHU DQGHUH
)HLHUOLFKNHLWHQ VWDWW ± +RFK]HLWHQ ZHUGHQ YHUVFKREHQ
« :HQQ PDQ +RFK]HLW QLFKW YHUVFKLHEHQ NDQQ JHKW
PDQ ]XU )DPLOLH GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ XQG ELWWHW XP
(LQYHUVWlQGQLV0DQKDQGHOWGDQQQDFKGHP:RUW³VRZLH
GHU7RGLVWDXFKGLHVGHU:LOOH*RWWHV³33ÖRNEK
ZHLVWGDUDXIKLQGDVVHVLQ*HELHWHQZRGLH7UDGLWLRQQRFK
VHKUGRPLQDQWLVWHLQH$UWYRQ'UXFNDXIGLH)DPLOLHGHU
YHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQDXVJHEWZLUGGDPLWGLH7UDGLWLRQHQ
DXFKEHIROJWZHUGHQ6RZHUGHQGLH)DPLOLHQDQJHK|ULJHQ
GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ XQG GLH *HPHLQVFKDIW VHLWHQV
GHU*HVHOOVFKDIWLP$XJHEHKDOWHQGDPLWGLH)DPLOLHGHU
YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ LKUHQ 3ODW] LQ GHU *HPHLQVFKDIW LQ
(KUHQZDKUHQNDQQXQGGLH7UDXHUVLWWHQEHIROJWZHUGHQ31
'LH GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ 1DKHVWHKHQGHQ N|QQHQ
QDFK GHU %HHUGLJXQJ GDV *UDE EHVXFKHQ ZHQQ VLH HV
ZQVFKHQ0DQEHVXFKWGDV*UDEPHLVW'RQQHUVWDJRGHU
DP)UHLWDJGHUZHLWJHKHQGDOVHLQKHLOLJHU7DJEHWUDFKWHW
ZLUG3(VZLUGNHLQ/lPSFKHQRGHUNHLQH.HU]HDP
*UDE DQJH]QGHW XQG HV JLEW DXFK NHLQHQ JHVRQGHUWHQ
2UWXPGLHV]XWXQ9LHU]LJ7DJHQDFKGHP7RGZLUGGHU
YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ HLQ EHVRQGHUHU 7DJ JHZLGPHW 0DQ
UH]LWLHUWGHQ.RUDQYRUDOOHPGLH6XUH<ƗVLQPDQUH]LWLHUW
/LWDQHLHQVSULFKW*HEHWHXQGJLEW>HUQHXW@HLQ7RWHQPDKO
1DFKHLQHP-DKUZLUGLQGHU5HJHOGDV*UDEHUULFKWHWXQG
PDQ JLEW HUQHXW HLQ 7RWHQPDKO >ZDV ³FDQ DúÕ³ JHQDQQW
ZLUG:HQQHVGLH¿QDQ]LHOOHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQHVQLFKW]X
ODVVHQ NDQQ GDV *UDE DXFK VSlWHU HUULFKWHW ZHUGHQ $Q
GHP1HYUX])HVWZDVDOV*HEXUWVWDJ$OLVJLOWXQGGHVKDOE
DOV KHLOLJ EHWUDFKWHW ZLUG LVW HV EOLFK GHQ *UlEHUQ HLQ
%HVXFK]XHUVWDWWHQ333
%HLGHQ$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQVZLUGGLHVRJGDUGDQLQGLUPH
=HUHPRQLHDXFKEHNDQQWDOVGDUFHPLRGHUGDUÕ0DQVXU
DEJHKDOWHQGDPLWGHU(KHSDUWQHUGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQ
GLH)UHXQGH9HUZDQGWHQXQGGLHEULJHQ1DKHVWHKHQGHQ
GLH YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ ³IUHLVSUHFKHQ³32 NDQQ 0DQ IKUW
31 ÖRNEK 6HGDW 9H\LV $QDGROX )RONORUXQGD gOP '7&)
<D\ÕQODUÕ$QNDUD6
>'HUKLHUJHEUDXFKWH%HJULII³
>'HUKLHUJHEUDXFKWH%HJULII³KHODOOHúPH³LVWQLFKW]X
EHUVHW]HQXQGVFKOLH‰W%HGHXWXQJHQZLH]%³YHU]HLKHQ³
³YHUJHEHQ³³J|QQHQ³³ORVVDJHQ³XQG³YRQHLQHU6FKXOGIUHL
VSUHFKHQ³@
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
&HQQHWFHKHQQHPLQDQFÕYHDKLUHWLQDQFÕYDUGÕU³%LQ
ELUD\HWELUDUD\DJHOLQFH.HYVHUÕUPD÷ÕQÕQEDúÕQGD
+]0XKDPPHG¶LQVDQFD÷ÕQÕQDOWÕQGDWRSODQÕODFDNWÕU
ùHIDDW NDSÕPÕ] +] 0XKDPPHW¶WLU +DNOÕ KDNVÕ]
VRUXODFDNELOLQHFHNWLU´..
6RQXoYH'H÷HUOHQGLUPH
.HQWOHúPH YH XOXVODúPD JLEL HWPHQOHUH ED÷OÕ
RODUDNIRQNVL\RQXQX\LWLUHQGHGHOLNNXUXPXVRQ
\ÕOGÕU \HQLGHQ FDQODQPD\D EDúODPÕúWÕU %X GXUXP
FHQD]HOHULQ DUWÕN FDPLGHQ GH÷LO GH FHP HYLQGHQ
NDOGÕUÕOPDVÕQÕJQGHPHJHWLUPLúWLU%XVUH]DUIÕQGD
$OHYLOL÷LQ |]HOOLNOHGH FHQD]H LúOHPOHULQLQ 6QQL
DNLGHOHU LOH \DSÕOPDVÕ oR÷X $OHYL YDWDQGDúÕ YH
a\GÕQÕQÕHOHúWLUHOELUWXWXPJHOLúWLUPH\H\|QHOWPLúWLU
dDOÕúPD ER\XQFD $OHYL 6QQL FHQD]H LúOHPOHULQLQ
EHQ]HUOLNYHIDUNOÕOÕNODUÕQÕQDQDL]OHNOHUROGX÷XJ|]
|QQH DOÕQGÕ÷ÕQGD EX KXVXVODUÕQ GHULQOHúWLULOPHVL
D\UÕFD|QHPDU]HWPHNWHGLU
$UGDKDQ $OHYLOHULQGH |OQQ GHIQH KD]ÕUODQÕúÕ
J|POPHVL YH EX VÕUDGD RNXQDQ GXDODU øVODP
GLQLQLQ JHQHO NXUDOODUÕQD X\XODUDN \DSÕOPDNWDGÕU
%X DQODPGD 6QQL JUXSODUOD |QHPOL SDUDOHOOLNOHU
J|]H oDUSPDNWDGÕU *|UúW÷P] ED]Õ $OHYL
GHGHOHUL |OPOH LOJLOL W|UHQOHULQ DúÕUÕ GHUHFHGH
6QQL X\JXODPDODUD EHQ]HúWL÷LQL LOHUL VUHUHN EX
GXUXPGDQ UDKDWVÕ]OÕNODUÕQÕ GLOH JHWLUPLúOHUGLU 7P
EHQ]HUOLNOHUH UD÷PHQ$UGDKDQ$OHYLOHULQGH |OPOH
LOJLOLX\JXODPDODUFHQD]HQDPD]ÕQDNDWÕOPDVÕ\DVDN
RODQODUÕQGúNQOHULQYDUOÕ÷Õ|OPQGX\XUXOPDVÕ
GH¿Q VRQUDVÕ \DSÕODQ |]HO D\LQL FHP W|UHQOHUL YH
KHSVLQGHQ |QHPOLVL |OPQ DOJÕODQÕúÕ YH GHYUL\H
LQDQÕúÕ JLEL ELU WDNÕP NRQXODUGD 6QQL JHOHQHNWHQ
D\UÕOPDNWDGÕU
6RV\DO GH÷LúLP VUHoOHULQH SDUDOHO RODUDN |OPOH
LOJLOL X\JXODPDODUGD GD NÕVPL GH÷LúLNOLNOHU J|]H
oDUSPDNWDGÕU *HOHQHNVHO G|QHPGHNL ³|O\ \HUGH
EÕUDNPDPDN LoLQ HUNHQ J|PPH´ GúQFHVL GHYDP
GLHVHV 5LWXDO IU GLH ³6HHOHQUXKH³ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ
3HUVRQ GXUFK 3 'LH YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ ZLUG KLHUEHL
YRQ VHLQHP ³:HJEUXGHU³ E]Z VHLQHU ³:HJVFKZHVWHU³
³PVDKLS³ YHUWUHWHQ 'HU 6LQQ XQG =ZHFN LVW GDVV
ZHQQ GLH YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ HLQH XQEHJOLFKHQH 6FKXOG
KDW>GLHQLFKW]ZDQJVOlX¿J¿QDQ]LHOOHU1DWXUVHLQPXVV@
GLHVH 6FKXOG EHJOLFKHQ ZLUG :HQQ GLH YHUVWRUEHQH
3HUVRQ 6FKXOGHQ KDWWH ZHUGHQ VLH EH]DKOW :HQQ GLH
YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ MHPDQGHQ YHUOHW]W KDW VR ZLUG DXFK
GLHVH6FKXOGEHJOLFKHQ'LH6FKXOGEHJOHLFKXQJLVWKLHUEHL
GLH$XIJDEHGHV³:HJEUXGHUV³E]ZGHU³:HJVFKZHVWHU³
³PVDKLS³33'HU7DJDQGHPGLHVRJGDUGDQ
LQGLUPH=HUHPRQLHDEJHKDOWHQZLUGNDQQMHQDFK5HJLRQ
YDULLHUHQ,Q'DPDO¿QGHWVLHYLHU]LJ7DJHQDFKGHP7RG
VWDWW33
Die GDUFHPL=HUHPRQLH ZLUG LQ JUREHQ =JHQ LQ
IROJHQGHU :HLVH DEJHKDOWHQ >=X $QIDQJ@ ZLUG HLQ
2SIHUWLHUJHVFKODFKWHWZDVDQGLH7HLOQHKPHQGHQYHUWHLOW
ZLUG 'HU ³:HJJHIlKUWH³ PVDKLS XQG GLH )DPLOLH
GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ 3HUVRQ WUHWHQ LQ $QZHVHQKHLW GHU
*HPHLQVFKDIWYRUGHQGHGHGHUVLHPLWIROJHQGHQ:RUWHQ
DQVSULFKW³2K*HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGHULKUVWHKWYRU*RWWXP
5HFKHQVFKDIW IU GLH YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ DE]XJHEHQ ,Q
*HJHQZDUW*RWWHVXQGGHU*HPHLQGHIUDJHLFKHXFKC6HLG
LKU HLQYHUVWDQGHQ XQVHU YHUVWRUEHQHV *HPHLQGHPLWJOLHG
YRQ VHLQHU 6FKXOG ORV]XVSUHFKHQ ZHQQ MHPDQG YRU XQV
WULWW GHU HLQH 6FKXOG PLW GHP 9HUVWRUEHQHQ >E]Z GHU
9HUVWRUEHQHQ@ ]X EHJOHLFKHQ RGHU HLQ 5HFKW JHJHQEHU
GHP 9HUVWRUEHQHQ JHOWHQG ]X PDFKHQ KDW"C³ 3 'LH
%HIUDJWHQ DQWZRUWHQ >GDUDXIKLQ@ ³6R *RWW ZLOO PHLQ
0HLVWHU:HQQHVHWZDVJLEWZDVHU>RGHUVLH@YHUVFKWWHW
KDW VR ZHUGHQ ZLU HV ZLHGHU IOOHQ :HQQ HU MHPDQGHQ
]XP :HLQHQ JHEUDFKW KDW VR ZROOHQ ZLU GLHVH 3HUVRQ
ZLHGHU]XP/DFKHQEULQJHQ:HQQHVHWZDVJLEWZDVHU
QLHGHUJHULVVHQ KDW VR ZHUGHQ ZLU HV ZLHGHU DXIULFKWHQ
:LU P|FKWHQ XQVHUHQ 1DKHVWHKHQGHQ QLFKW PLW HLQHP
XQYHUJROWHQHQ5HFKW>Z|UWOGDV5HFKWHLQHV'LHQHUV@DXI
GLHVHPHUKDEHQHQ5LFKWSODW]DOOHLQHODVVHQ³3'HUGHGH
VSULFKW GDUDXIKLQ GLH *HPHLQGH >PLW IROJHQGHQ :RUWHQ@
DQ ³,KU KDEW GLH %HIUDJWHQ JHK|UW 6HLG LKU PLW GHP
9HUVWRUEHQHQ >E]Z GHU 9HUVWRUEHQHQ@ ]XIULHGHQ"³ 8QG
GLH*HPHLQGHDQWZRUWHWGUHL0DO>PLWGHQ:RUWHQ@³+HODO
ROVXQ³ >³(V P|JH JHVHJQHW E]Z ZRKOJHJ|QQW VHLQ³@
:HQQMHPDQGHLQ5HFKWJHJHQEHUGHUYHUVWRUEHQHQ3HUVRQ
HLQ]XIRUGHUQKDWVRLVWHVGLH$XIJDEHGHV³:HJJHIlKUWHQ³
GLH 3HUVRQ ]XIULHGHQ ]X VWHOOHQ )U GLH $OHYLWHQ GLH
IUKHULQJHVFKORVVHQHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQOHEWHQVSLHOWGLH
³:HJJHIlKUWHQVFKDIW³³PVDKLSOLN³HLQHZLFKWLJH5ROOH
IU GLH 6ROLGDULWlW LQQHUKDOE GHU *HPHLQVFKDIW 8QG GLH
9HUDQWZRUWXQJGHU³:HJJHIlKUWHQVFKDIW³UHLFKWVRJDUELV
EHUGHQ7RG
'LH 9RUVWHOOXQJ GHU ³GHYUL\\H³ LVW HLQ .RQ]HSW GDV EHL
GHQ 1XVDLULHUQ VHKU YHUEUHLWHW LVW ÖNCÜL KDW DXI GLH
([LVWHQ]GHU9RUVWHOOXQJGHU³GHYUL\\H³EHLGHQ$OHYLWHQ
LQGHU5HJLRQ.DUVDXIPHUNVDPJHPDFKW33$XFKEHLGHQ
33 .h5ù$7gQFO.DUV7UNPHQOHULQGHgOPH%D÷OÕøQDQÕúODU
$QODWÕODUYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWUYH+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ9HOL
$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL$XVJDEH66
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
HWPHNOH ELUOLNWH X]DNWDNL DNUDEDODUÕQ JHOHELOPHVL
DPDFÕ\OD EHNOHWLOHELOPHNWHGLU gOQQ GHIQH
KD]ÕUODQPDVÕYHGH¿QLúOHPLQHNDGDUEHNOHWLOPHVLQGH
FHPHYLPRUJYH|O\ÕNDPDE|OPOHUL\OHELUOLNWH
WDPDPHQ PRGHUQ ELU XQVXU RODUDN VUHFH GkKLO
ROPXúWXUgOPQGX\XUXOPDVÕYHFHQD]HQLQPH]DUD
WDúÕQPDVÕQGD PRGHUQ WHNQRORMLGHQ ID\GDODQÕOÕ\RU
ROPDVÕ LON SODQGD J|]H oDUSDQ GL÷HU \HQL
X\JXODPDODUGDQGÕU
gOP ROD\ÕQÕQ NHQGLVL YH FHQD]H W|UHQL oHYUHVLQGH
JHOLúPLú RODQ JHOHQHNOHU YH X\JXODPDODU
|QHPVHQPHNWH ROXS KHU DúDPDVÕ WLWL]OLNOH \HULQH
JHWLULOPHNWHGLU gOP ROD\Õ VRQUDVÕQGD FHPDDWLQ
ELUH\OHUL PHYWDQÕQ \DNÕQODUÕQD KHU DQODPGD
\DUGÕP HGLS \DNÕQOÕN J|VWHUPHNWHGLU EX GD JUXS LoL
GD\DQÕúPDQÕQ SHNLúPHVL VRQXFXQX GR÷XUPDNWDGÕU
6RV\DOKD\DWÕQELUoRNDODQÕQGDJHOHQHNVHORWRULWHOHUL
DúÕQPD\D X÷UD\DQ $OHYL GHGHOHUL |OQQ GHIQH
KD]ÕUODQPDVÕYHJ|POPHVLV|]NRQXVXROXQFDVUHFLQ
LúOH\LúLQLEHOLUOH\HQWHPHODNW|UKDOLQHJHOPHNWHGLU
4XHOOHQQDFKZHLV
1. /LWHUDWXUKLQZHLVH
$.7$ù$OL $OHYLOHUGH gOPOH øOJLOL 5LWHOOHU +DFÕ
%HNWDúÕ9HOL$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL
$<$7$ 6DLP .ÕUúHKLU <|UHVL $EGDOODUÕQÕQ 'LQL
øQDQoODUÕ h]HULQH %LU $UDúWÕUPD 9HU|IIHQWOLFKWH
'RNWRUDUEHLW YRUJHOHJW IU GLH ,QVWLWXW IU
6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU(UFL\HV8QLYHUVLWlW.D\VHUL
%2=.857 )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO %R\XWODUÕ
7HNLQ<D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO
(1*,1 øVPDLO 7DKWDFÕODU $QW <D\ÕQODUÕ øVWDQEXO
*/$6(5 % *675$86 $ / $ZDUHQHVV RI '\LQJ
1HZ<RUN$OGLQH
.$<$ +D\GDU $OHYL %HNWDúL (UNkQÕ (YUkG¶Õ YH
(GHEL\DWÕ(QJLQ<D\øVWDQEXO
$OHYLWHQ $UGDKDQV LVW VLH YHUEUHLWHW :HQQ HLQ 0HQVFK
VWLUEW VR JHKW VHLQH 6HHOH LQ GLH ³6HHOHQZHOW³ ZR EHU
VHLQH6QGHQXQG:RKOWDWHQJHULFKWHWZLUG1DFKYLHU]LJ
7DJHQ NDQQ GLH 6HHOH ZHQQ VLH HV P|FKWH LQ HLQHP
DQGHUHQ.|USHUZLHGHU]XU:HOWNRPPHQ:HQQPDQHLQ
VFKOHFKWHV/HEHQJHIKUWKDWRGHUVQGKDIWZDUZLUGVLH
LQGHQ/HLEHLQHV5HSWLOVJHNOHLGHW33(VH[LVWLHUW
>DXFK@GLH9RUVWHOOXQJYRQ+LPPHOXQG+|OOH³:HQQGLH
WDXVHQGXQGHLQVD\ƗW]XVDPPHQNRPPHQYHUVDPPHOWPDQ
GLFKXQWHUGHP%DQQHUGHVHKUHQZHUWHQ0XKDPPHGDQGHU
4XHOOHGHV.HYVHU)OXVVHV'DV7RUXQVHUHU)UVSUDFKHLVW
GHUHKUHQZHUWH0XKDPPHG(VZLUGJHIUDJWXQGHVZLUG
GHXWOLFKZHUGHQZHUUHFKWVFKDIIHQJHZHVHQLVW³33
6FKOXVVIROJHUXQJ
'DV$PWGHVGHGHGDVZHJHQ)DNWRUHQZLHGHU8UEDQLVDWLRQ
XQG GHU 6WDDWHQELOGXQJ VHLQH )XQNWLRQ HLQJHE‰W KDW
HUOHEWVHLW-DKUHQHLQH:LHGHEHOHEXQJ'LHVZLUG>DXFK@
DQ GHU 7DWVDFKH GHXWOLFK GDVV GLH PLW GHU %HHUGLJXQJ
]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGHQ 5LWXDOH LQ FHP+lXVHUQ XQG QLFKW
PHKU LQ 0RVFKHHQ JHPDFKW ZHUGHQ 'LHV KDW GD]X
JHIKUWGDVVGLHPHLVWHQ0HQVFKHQDOHYLWLVFKHQ*ODXEHQV
XQGDOHYLWLVFKH*HOHKUWHLQGHQOHW]WHQ-DKUHQLKUH.ULWLN
GDUEHU JHlX‰HUW KDEHQ GDVV YRU DOOHP GLH 7RGHVULWXDOH
GHV$OHYLWHQWXPV LQ GHU 7UDGLWLRQ GHU 6XQQLWHQ JHPDFKW
ZHUGHQ 'DV +DXSWDXJHQPHUN XQVHUHU $UEHLW ODJ GDULQ
GLH 8QWHUVFKLHGH XQG *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ GHU 7RGHVULWXDOH
GHU$OHYLWHQXQGGHU6XQQLWHQLP$XJH]XEHKDOWHQXQG
$QEHWUDFKWGHVVHQLVWHVZLFKWLJGDUDXIKLQ]XZHLVHQGDVV
HVZLFKWLJLVWGLHVHV7KHPDQRFK]XYHUWLHIHQ
%HLGHQ$OHYLWHQ$UGDKDQVZHUGHQGLH9RUEHUHLWXQJDXIGLH
%HHUGLJXQJGLH%HHUGLJXQJVHOEVWXQGGLH5H]LWDWLRQGHU
GDPLWYHUEXQGHQHQ*HEHWHQDFKGHQ*UXQGSULQ]LSLHQGHU
LVODPLVFKHQ7UDGLWLRQJHPDFKW'HVKDOEIDOOHQEHVRQGHUV
GLH 3DUDOOHOHQ PLW GHQ VXQQLWLVFKHQ *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ
DXI (LQLJH GHGHV PLW GHQHQ ZLU VSUDFKHQ ZLHVHQ
GDUDXIKLQ GDVV GLH 7RGHVULWXDOH LQ HLQHP EHUWULHEHQHQ
0D‰H GHQHQ GHU 6XQQLWHQ JOLFKHQ XQG EHWRQWHQ LKUHQ
8QPXW GDUEHU 7URW] HLQLJHU *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ JLEW HV
HLQLJH 8QWHUVFKLHGH EHL GHQ $OHYLWHQ LQ %H]XJ DXI GLH
7RGHVULWXDOH 6R >]%@ GLH 7DWVDFKH GDVV GLHMHQLJHQ
GHQHQ HLJHQWOLFK GLH7HLOQDKPH DP7RWHQJHEHW XQWHUVDJW
LVWGLHVRJ$EWUQQLJHQDP7RWHQJHEHWWHLOQHKPHQGLH
9HUEUHLWXQJ EHU GLH 1DFKULFKW GDVV MHPDQG YHUVWRUEHQ
LVWGLHEHVRQGHUHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQQDFKGHU%HHUGLJXQJ
XQGZDVDPZLFKWLJVWHQLVWGLH7RGHVYRUVWHOOXQJXQGGHU
*ODXEHDQGLH³GHYUL\H³
(VIlOOW>DX‰HUGHP@DXIGDVVSDUDOOHO]XPVR]LDOHQ:DQGHO
DXFKGLH3UDNWLNHQLQ%H]XJDXIGHQ7RGHLQH9HUlQGHUXQJ
HUIDKUHQ 'LH LQ IUKHUHU =HLW YRUKHUUVFKHQGH *HZRKQKHLW
GHQ 7RWHQ VR VFKQHOO ZLH P|JOLFK ]X EHJUDEHQ LVW GHU
0|JOLFKNHLWJHZLFKHQGHQ7RWHQZDUWHQ]XODVVHQGDPLWDXFK
GLH 1DKHVWHKHQGHQ LQ GHU )HUQH DP %HJUlEQLV WHLOQHKPHQ
N|QQHQ%HLGHU9RUEHUHLWXQJGHU/HLFKHDXIGLH%HHUGLJXQJ
XQG GHU $XIEHZDKUXQJ GHU /HLFKH LVW GDV FHP+DXV
JHPHLQVDP PLW GHP /HLFKHQKDXV XQG HLQHP JHVRQGHUWHQ
2UW IU GLH /HLFKHQZDVFKXQJ ]X HLQHP QHXHQ %HVWDQGWHLO
GHV7RGHVULWXDOV JHZRUGHQ$XFK GLH (UUXQJHQVFKDIWHQ GHU
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
.(6.,1<DK\D0XVWDID 6DUÕ6DOWÕN2FD÷ÕQD%D÷OÕ
$OHYLOHUGH gOP LOH øOJLOL øQDQo YH 5LWHOOHU ,Q
=HLWVFKULIWGHU6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ)DNXOWlWGHU
)ÕUDW8QLYHUVLWlW$XVJDEH
g1&h/.UúDW .DUV7UNPHQOHULQGHgOPH%D÷OÕ
øQDQÕúODU$QODWÕODUYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWU
YH +DFÕ %HNWDúÕ 9HOL $UDúWÕUPD 'HUJLVL $XVJDEH
6
g51(. 6HGDW 9H\LV $QDGROX )RONORUXQGD gOP
'7&)<D\ÕQODUÕ$QNDUD
ù$+,1+DOLOøEUDKLP%DOÕNHVLUdHSQLOHULQGH'H¿QYH
'H¿Q6RQUDVÕ%D]ÕøQDQÕúYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN
.OWUYH+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ9HOL%QG6
7$ù*,1 $KPHW (UH÷OL YH dHYUHVLQGHNL $OHYLOHUGH
6RV\DOYH'LQL+D\DW0DVWHUDUEHLWYRUJHOHJWIUGDV
,QVWLWXWIU6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ6HOoXN8QLYHUVLWlW
.RQ\D
8<$1,. =HNL YH .$/$ $ULI $UGDKDQ øOL
$OHYLOHULQGH .HQGLQL 7DQÕPODPD øEDGHW YH gWHNL
$OJÕVÕ,Q$NDGHPLN$UDúWÕUPDODU'HUJLVL$XVJDEH
<,/',= +DUXQ $OHYL *HOHQH÷LQGH gOP YH gOP
6RQUDVÕ 7|UHQ YH 5LWHOOHU 8OXVODUDUDVÕ 7UN
.OWUQGHgOP6HPSR]\XPX1RYHPEHU
øVWDQEXO
:$//$&(5XWK$:2/)$OLVRQ dD÷GDú6RV\RORML
.XUDPODUÕhEHUVHW]WYRQ/H\OD(OEXU]XQG05DPL
$\DV3XQWR<D\ÕQODUÕø]PLU
2. 0QGOLFKH4XHOOHQ
3HUVRQ
9RUQDPH$OL(NEHU$XVGHPGHGH*HVFKOHFKWGHV
6XOWDQ*|].Õ]ÕO2FDN
1DPH*|JWHNLQ
*HERUHQ UHJLVWULHUW LP 'RUI (VNLNÕOÕo LP
.UHLV'DPDOLQ$UGDKDQ
%LOGXQJVVWDQG*UXQGVFKXOH
3HUVRQ
7HFKQLNVHLHQHVGLH/DXWVSUHFKHUIUGLH%HQDFKULFKWLJXQJ
EHUGHQ7RGHLQHV0HQVFKHQRGHU)DKU]HXJH]XP7UDQVSRUW
GHU /HLFKH VLQG PRGHUQH (OHPHQWH GLH LQ GLH 3UD[LV GHU
$OHYLWHQ(LQ]XJJHQRPPHQKDEHQ
'LH %UlXFKH XQG 3UDNWLNHQ LQ =XVDPPHQKDQJ PLW GHP
7RG XQG GHU %HVWDWWXQJV]HUHPRQLH ZHUGHQ VHKU HUQVW
JHQRPPHQ XQG DOOH +DQGOXQJHQ ZHUGHQ PLW lX‰HUVWHU
6RUJIDOWDXVJHIKUW'LH0HQVFKHQODVVHQLKUHDOOH%HODQJH
XPIDVVHQGH +LOIH GHQ 9HUEOLHEHQHQ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ
3HUVRQ]XNRPPHQZDVGD]XIKUWGDVVVLFKGLH6ROLGDULWlW
LQQHUKDOE GHU *HPHLQVFKDIW IHVWLJW 'LH GHGH GLH >]ZDU@
LKUH WUDGLWLRQHOOH $XWRULWlW LQ YLHOHQ %HUHLFKHQ GHV
VR]LDOHQ/HEHQVGHU0HQVFKHQYHUORUHQKDEHQEHVWLPPHQ
WURW]GHPDNWLYGHQ$EODXIGHU9RUEHUHLWXQJGHV7RWHQDXI
GLH%HVWDWWXQJXQGGLH%HVWDWWXQJVHOEVW
4XHOOHQQDFKZHLV
a)
/LWHUDWXUKLQZHLVH
$.7$ù $OL $OHYLOHUGH gOPOH øOJLOL 5LWHOOHU ,Q +DFÕ
%HNWDúÕ9HOL$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL
AYATA6DLP.ÕUúHKLU<|UHVL$EGDOODUÕQÕQ'LQLøQDQoODUÕ
h]HULQH %LU $UDúWÕUPD 9HU|IIHQWOLFKWH 'RNWRUDUEHLW
YRUJHOHJWGHP,QVWLWXWIU6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWGHU(UFL\HV
8QLYHUVLWlW.D\VHUL
BOZKURT )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO %R\XWODUÕ 7HNLQ
<D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO
ENGINøVPDLO7DKWDFÕODU $QW<D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO
GLASER % *STRAUS $ / $ZDUHQHVV RI '\LQJ 1HZ
<RUN$OGLQH
KAYA+D\GDU$OHYL%HNWDúL(UNkQÕ(YUkG¶ÕYH(GHEL\DWÕ
(QJLQ<D\øVWDQEXO
KESKIN <DK\D 0XVWDID 6DUÕ 6DOWÕN 2FD÷ÕQD %D÷OÕ
$OHYLOHUGHgOPLOHøOJLOL øQDQoYH5LWHOOHU,Q=HLWVFKULIW
GHU6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ)DNXOWlWGHU)ÕUDW8QLYHUVLWlW
$XVJDEH
ÖNCÜL .UúDW .DUV 7UNPHQOHULQGH gOPH %D÷OÕ
øQDQÕúODU$QODWÕODUYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWUYH
+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ9HOL$UDúWÕUPD'HUJLVL$XVJDEH
6
ÖRNEK 6HGDW9H\LV $QDGROX )RONORUXQGD gOP '7&)
<D\ÕQODUÕ$QNDUD
ù$+,1+DOLOøEUDKLP%DOÕNHVLUdHSQLOHULQGH'H¿QYH'H¿Q
6RQUDVÕ%D]ÕøQDQÕúYH8\JXODPDODU,Q7UN.OWUYH
+DFÕ%HNWDúÕ9HOL%QG6
7$ùö,1$KPHW(UH÷OLYHdHYUHVLQGHNL$OHYLOHUGH6RV\DO
YH'LQL+D\DW0DVWHUDUEHLWYRUJHOHJWIUGDV,QVWLWXWIU
6R]LDOZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ6HOoXN8QLYHUVLWlW.RQ\D
UYANIK =HNL YH .$/$ $ULI $UGDKDQ øOL $OHYLOHULQGH
.HQGLQL7DQÕPODPDøEDGHWYHÖteki$OJÕVÕ,Q$NDGHPLN
$UDúWÕUPDODU'HUJLVL$XVJDEH
YILDIZ+DUXQ$OHYL*HOHQH÷LQGHgOPYHgOP6RQUDVÕ
7|UHQ YH 5LWHOOHU 8OXVODUDUDVÕ 7UN .OWUQGH gOP
6HPSR]\XPX1RYHPEHUøVWDQEXO
WALLACE 5XWK $ WOLF $OLVRQ dD÷GDú 6RV\RORML
.XUDPODUÕ hEHUVHW]W YRQ /H\OD (OEXU] XQG 0 5DPL
$\DV3XQWR<D\ÕQODUÕø]PLU
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
9RUQDPH 0XVD $XV GHP GHGH*HVFKOHFKW GHV
6XOWDQ*|].Õ]ÕO2FDN
1DFKQDPH0úWHNLQ
*HERUHQ UHJLVWULHUW LP 'RUI %XUPDGHUH LP
.UHLV'DPDOLQ$UGDKDQ
%LOGXQJVVWDQG*UXQGVFKXOH
3HUVRQ
9RUQDPHøVPDLO
1DFKQDPH$NGHPLU
*HERUHQLQ'DPDO
%LOGXQJVVWDQG.DQQOHVHQXQGVFKUHLEHQ
3HUVRQ
$GÕ$OL(NEHU
1DFKQDPHÇalhan
*HERUHQLQ+DQDN
%LOGXQJVVWDQG6HNXQGDUVWXIH,,
1.
0QGOLFKH4XHOOHQ
3HUVRQ
9RUQDPH$OL(NEHU$XVGHPGHGH*HVFKOHFKWGHV6XOWDQ
*|].Õ]ÕO2FDN
1DPH*|JWHNLQ
*HERUHQ UHJLVWULHUW LP 'RUI (VNLNÕOÕo LP .UHLV
'DPDOLQ$UGDKDQ
%LOGXQJVVWDQG*UXQGVFKXOH
3HUVRQ
9RUQDPH 0XVD $XV GHP GHGH*HVFKOHFKW GHV 6XOWDQ
*|].Õ]ÕO2FDN
1DFKQDPH0úWHNLQ
*HERUHQUHJLVWULHUWLP'RUI%XUPDGHUHLP.UHLV
'DPDOLQ$UGDKDQ
%LOGXQJVVWDQG*UXQGVFKXOH
3HUVRQ
9RUQDPHøVPDLO
1DFKQDPH$NGHPLU
*HERUHQLQ'DPDO
%LOGXQJVVWDQG.DQQOHVHQXQGVFKUHLEHQ
3HUVRQ
$GÕ$OL(NEHU
1DFKQDPHÇalhan
*HERUHQLQ+DQDN
%LOGXQJVVWDQG6HNXQGDUVWXIH,,
3sUPEDMWMD
9GHNMDHGKHSVHsVKWsQMsIHQRPHQXQLYHUVDOPsQ\UDWHNXSWLPLWLQGLYLGXDORVHNROHNWLYLNsWLMIHQRPHQL
DSRTsQGULPHWVRFLDOHGKHSDUDSULWMHWH]KYLOOXDUDNXQGUHMWYGHNMHVMDQsWsYDUXUDQsSsUJMLWKsVLMQJD
NXOWXUDHFLODLUUHWKRQEHVLPLIHWDUNsVKWXTsQJDQGLNLPLYGHNMDVLIHQRPHQQGU\VKRQQGsUPMHWQMHUs]YH
9GHNMDOLQGMDGKHPDUWHVDMDQSLNDWN\oHTsQGLNRMQsQsQGsULPLQHMHWsVVsQMHULXW6LNXUVHOLQGMDGKH
PDUWHVDHGKHSsUYGHNMHQsVKWsNULMXDUQMsULWXDUORVHQMsULWVLPEDVWUDGLWsV.sWDSLNDNDOXHVHTsMDQs
WsUsQGsVLVKPHGKHJMDWs]KYLOOLPLWWsULWXDOHYHWsW\UHJUXSHWHQGU\VKPHWUHJRMQsGKHNXOWXUsQHW\UH
.sVKWXTsN\SXQLPGRWsPDUUsQsGRUs³NXSWLPLQHYGHNMHV´Vs$OHYLYHWs$UGDKDQLWVHVLHSUHJDGLVLQWs
YGHNXULQULWXDOHWJMDWsYDUULPLWRVHPEDVYDULPLWGRWsMHQs7HPDWNU\HVRUHWsNsWLMSXQLPLW1sNsWsSXQLP
MDQsSsUGRUXUWHNQLNDHELVHGLPLWGKHHYsVKWULPLWWsULWXDOHYH1sUHWKLQH$UGDKDQLWQsYHQGLQHTXDMWXU
'DPDONHPL]KYLOOXDUWDNLPHWPHOLGHUsWH$OHYLYHGHGHOHUGKHJMLWKDVKWXPDUUsSMHVsGUHMWSsUGUHMWQs
YDULPLQHQMsSHUVRQLWsPRVKXDU3sUPEL$OHYLWsHDUGDKDQLWPsKHUsWQXNsVKWsEsUsQGRMQsSXQLPSsUPEL
NsWsWHPsNsVKWXTsN\SXQLPSsUPEDQUsQGsVLMQsNsWsWHPs.\SXQLPWUHJRQYHoRULWsGKHGDOOLPHWSsUPEL
&HUHPRQLWsHYDUULPLWQGsUPMHW$OHYLYHGKH6XQLYHTssVKWsHGKHQMsUsQGsVLMWMHWsUHNsWLMSXQLPL
)MDOsWN\oH1GsUULPMHWH9GHNMHFHUHPRQLMDH)XQHUDOLW$OHYLWsH$UGDKDQLW'DPDO
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ