PDF İndir - Alevilik-Bektaşilik Araştırmaları Dergisi

72.$7¶7$<$ù$<$1$/(9ø/(5ø1&(05ø7h(//(5ø1'(
ø&5$('ø/(10h=ø.g51(./(5ø
'5*$1ø3(.ù(1
$%675$&7
7RNDWDQGLQWKHSURYLQFHDQGGLVWULFWVH[HPLQHGWKHWUDGLWLRQIRONPXVLFVSHFL¿FWKHUHSOD\LQJDQGVLQJLQJ
EHORQJVWRDUHD$VZLWKRWKHUFLWLHVDQGRXWOL\QJWRZQVRI$QDWROLDVWLOH[LVWVLQGLIIHUHQWFRORXUV 7RNDWOLYLQJ
WKHFRORXUVDUHDOVRVHHQLQWKHVHEHOLHIV)RUH[DPSOH5HúDGL\HIRONPXVLFRIIHDWXUHVVLQJLQJDQGSOD\LQJ
OLNHWKDWPDLQWDLQKDVEHHQVLQJLQJ³$\HW%H\LW6HPDK´LQFHP/RFDOOD\NQRZQDV³)DGLND÷]Õ´OLNHWKDW
H[SHUVVHGLQIURPRIGLVFRXUVH
6XUYH\SDSHUVWKDWZHKDYHGRQHDVDUHVXOWRIWKHGLVWULFWDQGWKHYLOODJHVRI7RNDWZKHQZHJRWWKHHVHQFH
RIWKHUHJLRQNQRZQDVWKHÀDPHUHJLRQEXWZKLFHKDV³6ÕUDF$OHYLOHUL+XE\DU¶OÕODU´IURPFDPHWKHRWKHU
YLOODJHVOLYLQJ$OWKRXJKLWVHHPVWKDWWKHVDPHVHQVLWLYHVLQWKHORFDOUHHGDQGDXGLRSOD\EDFN
)RUH[DPSOHDOWKRXKLQ7RNDWLQWKHIURPIRONVSHHFKLQJHQHUTDOFHUWDLQPRGHVVRPHRIWKHJUDQGIDWKHUVQRW
LPSRUWDQW7KHVHIHDWXUHVFDQFRQWXQLW\DQGLWVRZQFXOWXUHULFKQHVVRIOLYLQJWKHUH)RUH[DPSOHLVVDLGWREH
VDPHVRQJ0DODW\D$UJXYDQGLIIHUQW$UDSNLUGLIIHUHQW$\GÕQZKLOHGLIIHUQWWKHRWKHUDSSHDUVWRVD\DOPRVW
WKHVDPHIURPWRGD\)RONVRQJVSHRSOHRXWVLGHVWKHUHJLRQLQRUGHUWRSUD\DWFHUWDLQWLPHWKH\HDULQ&HP
3RVWWRSLFWKHSDUWLFXOVWDJHRIWKHOHJXHRISURSHUWLHVLQWKLVUHJLRQZKLFKLQFKDUJHNQRZQDVFHPkúÕNODUÕOLNH
VRQJWKHUHVWROLQJVKHHWVWKDWGXD]ÕLPDPPLKUDoODPDSHUYD]WHYKLGHWFWKDW
,QWKHUHJLRQRXWVLGHRIIRONVRQJVSHRSOHDWFHUWDLQWLPHVRI\HDULQRUGHUWRZRUVKLS&HP¶VSHUIRUPULWXDO
$FFRUGLQJWRWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKLVULWXDOELQGLQJSOD\DFHUWDLQVRQJWHOOVWKHSHUVRQLQFKDUJHGXULQJ
WKLVULWXDOOLNHWKDW%H\LW'XD]ÕøPDP0LKUDoODPD3HUYD]7HYKLG*|QOOHU6HPDKÕHWF«
,QRXUDUHDRIZRUNLGHQWLI\WKHVHWXQHVSOD\HGDQGVRQJHGDQGUHVHDUFKRILQYROYHVWKHLQVWUXPHQWKRZWR
SOD\LQWKLVDUHD
.H\ZRUGV $\HW%H\LW'XD]ÕLPDP0LKUDoODPD*|QOOHU6HPDKÕ
'U*DQL3(.ù(1
Ege ÜQLYHUVLWHVL'HYOHW7UN0XVLNLVL
.RQVHUYDWDXDUÕ
0XVLNDOLVFKH %HLVSLHOH DXV GHP FHP5LWXDO GHU
$OHYLWHQDXV7RNDW
'U*DQL3(.ù(11
=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ
g=(7
7RNDW YH LOoHOHUL JHOHQHNVHO KDON P]LNOHULQL
LQFHOHGL÷LPL]GH \|UH\H KDV oDOÕS V|\OHPH ELoLPL
EXOXQPDNWDGÕU $QDGROX¶QXQ GL÷HU LO YH LOoHOHULQGH
ROGX÷X JLEL 7RNDW¶WD GD IDUNOÕ UHQNOHU \DúDWÕOPDNWD
EX UHQNOHU LQDQoODUÕQ \DúDWÕOPDVÕQGD GD NHQGLQL
J|VWHUPHNWHGLU gUQH÷LQ 5HúDGL\H WUNOHULQGHNL
8QVHUH8QWHUVXFKXQJGHUWUDGLWLRQHOOHQ9RONVPXVLN
LQ 7RNDW XQG LQ GHQ /DQGNUHLVHQ KDW HUJHEHQ GDVV
HV KLHU HLQH HLJHQH UHJLRQDO JHSUlJWH 6SLHO XQG
*HVDQJVDUW JLEW :LH LQ DQGHUHQ DQDWROLVFKHQ
6WlGWHQXQG/DQGNUHLVHQEOLFKSÀHJWPDQDXFKLQ
7RNDWYHUVFKLHGHQH1XDQFHQGLHVLFKZLHGHUXPEHL
GHU $XIUHFKWHUKDOWXQJ GHU *ODXEHQVYRUVWHOOXQJHQ
]HLJHQ
1 .QVWOHU /HKUEHDXIWUDJWHU GHV 6WDDWOLFKHQ .RQVHUYDWRULXPV
IU.ODVVLVFKH7UNLVFKH0XVLNGHU(JH8QLYHUVLWlW
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
oDOÕS V|\OHPH |]HOOL÷LQL FHPOHUGH V|\OHQHQ ³D\HW
EH\LW VHPDKODU´GD GD J|UPHNWH\L] <HUHO RODUDN
³)DGLND÷]Õ´RODUDNLIDGHHGLOHQEXV|\OHPHELoLPL
FHPOHUGHGHNDUúÕPÕ]DoÕNPDNWDGÕU
7RNDW LOoH YH N|\OHULQGH \DSPÕú ROGX÷XPX]
DUDúWÕUPDODUVRQXFXQGD\|UHGH$OHYLRODUDNELOLQHQ
DQFDN GDKD |]H LQGL÷LPL]GH LVH E|OJH\H KDV RODQ
³6ÕUDo$OHYLOHUL+XE\DU¶OÕODU´ÕQGÕúÕQGD%HNWDúLOHU
YH IDUNOÕ LOOHUGHQ JHOHQ $OHYLOHU \DúDPDNWDGÕU
*HQHOLQGH \DSÕODQ FHP ULWHOOHUL D\QÕ J|]NVH GH
|]GHIDUNOÕOÕNODUEXOXQPDNWDGÕU
%\N úHKLUOHUGH ROGX÷X JLEL 7RNDW YH LOoHOHULQGH
GH FHP ULWHOOHUL EHQ]HUOLN J|VWHUPHNWH \ROXQ
GHYDPOÕOÕ÷Õ NRQXVXQGD KDVVDVL\HW J|VWHUHQ $OHYLOHU
FHPOHUGHNL\HUHOVHVOHQGLUPHYHVD]oDOPDNRQXVXQGD
D\QÕKDVVDVL\HWOHULJ|VWHUPHPHNWHGLUOHU
gUQH÷LQ 7RNDW LOLQGH WUNOHUL VHVOHQGLUPH ELoLPL
JHQHO RODUDN EHOOL NDOÕSODUGD ROPDVÕQD UD÷PHQ
ED]Õ FHP kúÕNODUÕ YH ED]Õ GHGHOHU LoLQ |QHP DU]
HWPHPHNWHGLU +kOEXNL NOWUQ GHYDPOÕOÕ÷Õ YH
\|UHQLQ NHQGLQH DLW EX |]HOOLNOHU RUDGD \DúD\DQ
NOWUHO]HQJLQOL÷LLIDGHHWPHNWHGLUgUQH÷LQ0DODW\D
$UJXYDQ¶GDoDOÕQÕSV|\OHQLOHQD\QÕEH\LW$UDSNLU¶GH
IDUNOÕ $\GÕQ¶GD IDUNOÕ 6LYDV¶WD 0DUDú¶WD 7RNDW¶WD
IDUNOÕ LNHQ JQP]GH KHPHQ KHPHQ D\QÕ V|\OHPH
ELoLPLLOHNDUúÕPÕ]DoÕNPDNWDGÕUøOHWLúLPDUDoODUÕQÕQ
\D\JÕQOÕ÷ÕSRSOHUNOWUQEDVNÕQoÕNPDVÕLQVDQODU
]HULQGHROXPVX]HWNL\LX\DQGÕUPDNWDGÕU
<|UHGH WUNOHULQ GÕúÕQGD LQVDQODU \ÕOÕQ EHOOL
]DPDQODUÕQGD LEDGHW HWPHN DPDFÕ\OD FHP ULWHOOHUL
\DSDUODU <DSÕODQ EX FHPOHULQ |]HOOLNOHULQH J|UH
FHPLQ EHOOL DúDPDVÕQGD J|UHYOL RODQ YH EX E|OJHGH
FHP DúÕ÷Õ RODUDN DGODQGÕUÕODQ NLúL VD] oDODUDN
EH\LWOHUGXD]ÕLPDPPLKUDoODPDSHUYD]WHYKLGYH
J|QOOHUVHPDKÕoDODU
%HLVSLHOVZHLVH EHJHJQHQ XQV GLH (LJHQKHLWHQ GHU
9RONVOLHGHUYRQ5HúDGL\HPLWLKUHU6SLHOXQG*HVDQJVNXQVW
DXFKLQGHQEHLGHQ*RWWHVGLHQVWHQJHVXQJHQHQ´.RUDQ
9HUVHQD\HW'RSSHOYHUVHQEH\LWULWXHOOHQ*HEHWVWlQ]HQ
VHPDK´'LHVHLQGHU5HJLRQDOV´)DGLND÷]Õ´
´)DGLN0XQGDUW JHQDQQWH *HVDQJVDUW SUlVHQWLHUW VLFK
XQVDXFKEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQ
8QVHUH 6WXGLHQ LQ 7RNDW GHU JOHLFKQDPLJHQ 6WDGW GHQ
GD]XJHK|ULJHQ /DQGNUHLVHQ XQG '|UIHUQ KDEHQ ]X GHP
6FKOXVVJHIKUWGDVVLQGHU5HJLRQDEJHVHKHQYRQGHQVRJ
´6ÕUDo$OHYLWHQ´E]ZGLH´+XE\DU´GLH]XGLHVHU5HJLRQ
JHK|UHQ DXFK %HNWDúL XQG$OHYLWHQ DXV DQGHUHQ 6WlGWHQ
JLEW :HQQ DXFK GLH GXUFKJHIKUWHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ LP
$QVFKHLQQDFKlKQOLFKVLQGJLEWHVLP*UXQGHJHQRPPHQ
DEHU8QWHUVFKLHGH
bKQOLFKZLHLQGHQ*UR‰VWlGWHQZHLVHQDXFKLQ7RNDWXQG
LQ/DQGHVNUHLVHQ7RNDWVGLH
FHP=HUHPRQLHQ HEHQIDOOV *HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ DXI
ZRKLQJHJHQ GLH $OHYLWHQ IU GLH GLH .RQWLQXLWlW GHV
>DOHYLWLVFKHQ@ :HJHV E]Z GHU >DOHYLWLVFKHQ@ /HKUH YRQ
EHVRQGHUHU :LFKWLJNHLW LVW QHKPHQ GLH ORNDOHQ *HVlQJH
XQG GDV 6SLHOHQ GHV VD] EHL GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ QLFKW
VRHUQVW
%HLVSLHOVZHLVHVSLHOHQGLH*HVDQJVDUWGHU9RONVOLHGHUGHU
6WDGW7RNDWGLHLQGHU5HJHOHLQHEHVWLPPWH)RUPKDWIU
HLQLJH9RONVVlQJHUEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQVRZLHIUHLQLJH
GHGHV NHLQH JUR‰H 5ROOH ,Q :LUNOLFKNHLW EULQJHQ MHGRFK
GLH %HZDKUXQJ GHU .XOWXU VRZLH GLH (LJHQWPOLFKNHLWHQ
GLHVHU 5HJLRQ HLQHQ NXOWXUHOOHQ 5HLFKWXP ]XP$XVGUXFN
GHU GRUW YRUKDQGHQ LVW %HLVSLHOVZHLVH SUlVHQWLHUW VLFK
XQV JHJHQZlUWLJ GHUVHOEH 'RSSHOYHUV EH\LW GHU LQ
0DODW\D$UJXYDQ JHVSLHOW XQG JHVXQJHQ ZLUG XQG LQ
$UDSNLU$\GÕQ6LYDV0DUDúXQG7RNDWYHUVFKLHGHQLVW
DXIHLQHVHKUlKQOLFKH*HVDQJVDUW'LHZHLWH9HUEUHLWXQJ
GHU .RPPXQLNDWLRQVPHGLHQ VRZLH GLH 9RUKHUUVFKDIW GHU
SRSXOlUHQ.XOWXUKDEHQHLQHQHJDWLYH$XVZLUNXQJDXIGLH
0HQVFKHQ
1HEHQGHQ9RONOLHGHUQLQGHU5HJLRQIKUHQGLH0HQVFKHQ
]X EHVWLPPWHQ =HLWHQ GHV -DKUHV IU GLH *RWWHVDQGDFKW
FHP=HUHPRQLHQGXUFK-HQDFK(LJHQKHLWHQGLHVHUFHP
=HUHPRQLHQVSLHOWHLQH3HUVRQGLHLQGHU5HJLRQDOVFHP
0XVLNHUEHNDQQWLVWXQGZlKUHQGHLQHUEHVWLPPWHQ3KDVH
GHU=HUHPRQLHHLQH$XIJDEHDXVIKUWVD]XQGVLQJWGD]X
9HUVH EH\LW +\PQHQ IU GLH ,PDPH GXD]Õ LPDP
2'LH´VD]´LVWHLQH/DQJKDOVODXWHGLHIUGLHDOHYLWLVFKH.XOWXU
YRQLPPHQVHU%HGHXWXQJLVW$Gh
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
%L]LP oDOÕúPD DODQÕPÕ] LVH FHP DúÕ÷ÕQÕQ oDOÕS
V|\OHGL÷L EX H]JLOHUL WHVSLW HWPHN \|UHGH oDOÕQPD
ELoLPLLOHLOJLOLDUDúWÕUPD\DSPDNWÕU
$QDKWDU NHOLPH $\HW %H\LW 'XD]Õ LPDP
0LKUDoODPD*|QOOHU6HPDKÕ
$QDGROX \]OHUFH \ÕO PHGHQL\HWOHUH HY VDKLSOL÷L
\DSPÕúE\NKNPGDUOÕNODUÕQKNPVUG÷ELU
FR÷UDI\D ROPXúWXU %X FR÷UDI\DGD IDUNOÕ NOWUOHU
ELUELUOHULLOHLoLLoH\DúDPÕúELUELUOHULQGHQHWNLOHQHUHN
EX JQH NDGDU JHOPLúOHUGLU øQVDQODU \DúDGÕNODUÕ
E|OJHOHUGH E|OJHQLQ FR÷UD¿N |]HOOLNOHULQH
X\XP VD÷ODGÕNODUÕ JLEL RUDGD \DúDWÕODQ PDGGL YH
PDQHYL GH÷HUOHULQGH HWNLVL DOWÕQGD NDOPÕúODUGÕU
TUNOHULPL]GH R\XQODUÕPÕ]GD JHOHQHN YH
J|UHQHNOHULPL]GHNL IDUNOÕOÕNODU LQDQo ELoLPLQL GH
HWNLOHPLú NOWUQ ROXúPDVÕQGD YH \DúDPDVÕQGD
HWNLQROPXúWXU
7UNOHULPL]GHNL \HUHO oDOÕSV|\OHPH IDUNOÕOÕNODUÕ
ONHPL]GHNL NOWU ]HQJLQOL÷LQL LIDGH HWPHNWHGLU
%X ]HQJLQOLNOHU DUDúWÕUÕOGÕNoD RUWD\D oRN GH÷LúLN
NOWUHOUQOHUortaya oÕNPDNWDGÕU2UWD\DoÕNDUÕODQ
EX UQOHU GH÷LúLN \|QWHPOHUOH ELOLP GQ\DVÕQD
YH LQVDQOÕ÷ÕQ KL]PHWLQH GH VXQXOPDNWDGÕU %LOLP
GQ\DVÕQD ND]DQGÕUÕODQ |UQHNOHULQ EDúÕQGD GD LQDQo
NOWUJHOPHNWHGLUøQDQoELoLPOHULQLQ\DNÕQWDULKH
NDGDU V|]O RODUDN \DúDWÕOÕS \D]Õ\D DNWDUÕOPDPDVÕ
D\UÕFDEX\DúD\ÕúELoLPOHULQLQGÕúDUÕ\DNDSDOÕROPDVÕ
QHGHQL\OH GH ELUoRN UQOHU WHVSLW HGLOHPHPLú \RN
ROXS JLWPLúWLU %X DPDoOD $QDGROX¶QXQ GH÷LúLN
\|UHOHULQGH \DúDWÕODQ EX NOWUOHULQ DUDúWÕUÕOÕS
GHUOHQLOHUHNJQÕúÕ÷ÕQDoÕNDUPDNYHELOLPHVXQPDN
LQVDQOÕ÷ÕQHQ|QHPOLJ|UHYOHULQGHQGLU
7RNDW YH LOoHOHULQLQ JHOHQHNVHO KDON P]LNOHULQL
LQFHOHGL÷LPL]GHEXUDQÕQNHQGLQHKDVoDOÕSV|\OHPH
JHOHQH÷L EXOXQPDNWDGÕU $QDGROX¶QXQ GL÷HU LO YH
LOoHOHULQGH ROGX÷X JLEL 7RNDW¶WD GD IDUNOÕ UHQNOHU
GLH PLKUDoODPD3 HLQ SHUYD] HLQ WHYKLG4 XQG >*HGLFKW
IU@ GDV VRJ J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ >´VHPDK GHU +HU]HQ´@
8QVHU8QWHUVXFKXQJVJHJHQVWDQGKDWMHGRFKGDV=LHOGLH
YRQ GHP 0XVLNHU LQ GHU FHP=HUHPRQLH JHVSLHOWHQ XQG
JHVXQJHQHQ 0HORGLHQ ]X EHVWLPPHQ XQG GLH UHJLRQDOH
6SLHODUW]XXQWHUVXFKHQ
6FKOVVHOEHJULIIH .RUDQYHUV D\HW 9HUVH EH\LW
+\PQHQ IU GLH =Z|OI ,PDPH GXD] LPDP PLUDoODPD
GDVJ|QOOHUVHPDKÕ
$QDWROLHQZDU-DKUKXQGHUWHODQJ+HLPDWIU=LYLOLVDWLRQHQ
DXI GHVVHQ %RGHQ PlFKWLJH 5HLFKH KHUUVFKWHQ $XI
GLHVHP *HELHW KDEHQ GLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKVWHQ .XOWXUHQ
PLWHLQDQGHU JHOHEW VLFK JHJHQVHLWLJ EHHLQÀXVVW XQG VR
GLH*HJHQZDUWHUUHLFKW'LH0HQVFKHQSDVVWHQVLFKQLFKW
QXUDQGLHJHRJUDSKLVFKHQ(LJHQKHLWHQGHU5HJLRQDQLQ
GHU VLH OHEWHQ VLH VWHKHQ DXFK XQWHU GHP (LQÀXVV MHQHU
PDWHULHOOHQXQGJHLVWLJHQ:HUWHGLHGRUWJHSÀHJWZHUGHQ
6R KDEHQ VLFK GLH XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 9RONVOLHGHU 7lQ]H
7UDGLWLRQHQ XQG %UlXFKH QLFKW HLQHQ (LQÀXVV DXI GLH
*ODXEHQVIRUP JHKDEW VRQGHUQ VLH ZDUHQ DXFK ZLUNVDP
EHLGHU(QWVWHKXQJXQG%HZDKUXQJGHU.XOWXU
'LHXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH$UWZLHXQVHUH9RONVOLHGHUJHVXQJHQ
XQG JHVSLHOW ZHUGHQ LVW $XVGUXFN GHU .XOWXUYLHOIDOW LQ
XQVHUHP/DQG%HLGHU8QWHUVXFKXQJGLHVHU>NXOWXUHOOHQ@
5HLFKWPHU NRPPHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH NXOWXUHOOH
(U]HXJQLVVH]XP9RUVFKHLQ'LHVHNXOWXUHOOHQ(U]HXJQLVVH
ZHUGHQ GDQQ GHU :LVVHQVFKDIW XQG GHU 0HQVFKKHLW PLW
XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 0HWKRGHQ SUlVHQWLHUW 'LH UHOLJL|VH
.XOWXU]lKOWGDEHL]XGHQHUVWHQ%HLVSLHOHQGLHVHU$UWGLH
IU GLH :LVVHQVFKDIWVZHOW EHZDKUW ZXUGHQ (V NRQQWHQ
MHGRFKYLHOHNXOWXUHOOH(U]HXJQLVVHQLFKWEHZDKUWZHUGHQ
XQGVLQGYHUORUHQJHJDQJHQZHLOGLH*ODXEHQVIRUPHQELV
LQ GLH IUKH 9HUJDQJHQKHLW PQGOLFK JHSÀHJW XQG QLFKW
VFKULIWOLFK IHVWJHKDOWHQ ZXUGHQ XQG GLHVH /HEHQVIRUPHQ
DX‰HUGHP QRFK NHLQHQ .RQWDNW ]XU $X‰HQZHOW KDWWHQ
'DKHU JHK|UW HV ]X GHQ ZLFKWLJVWHQ $XIJDEHQ GHU
0HQVFKKHLW GLHVH LQ GHQ XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKHQ 5HJLRQHQ
YRQ $QDWROLHQ JHSÀHJWHQ .XOWXUHQ ]X XQWHUVXFKHQ
]X VDPPHOQ EHNDQQW]XPDFKHQ XQG LQ GHQ 'LHQVW GHU
:LVVHQVFKDIW]XVWHOOHQ
:HQQ PDQ GLH WUDGLWLRQHOOH 9RONVPXVLN LQ GHU 6WDGW
7RNDWXQGGHQ/DQGHVNUHLVHQ7RNDWVXQWHUVXFKWEHPHUNW
PDQGDVVHVHLQHHLJHQH6SLHOXQG*HVDQJVDUWLQGLHVHU
5HJLRQJLEWbKQOLFKZLHLQDQGHUHQDQDWROLVFKHQ6WlGWHQ
XQG /DQGHVNUHLVHQ EOLFK JLEW HV DXFK LQ 7RNDW HLQH
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHU+LPPHO
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHU+LPPHO
UHLVHGHV3URSKHWHQ0XKDPPHG@
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWGDVYRQGHU(LQKHLW*RWWHVE]ZGHU
P\VWLVFKHQ(LQKHLWKDQGHOW@
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
\DúDWÕOPDNWDGÕU%XUHQNOHULQDQoODUÕQ\DúDWÕOPDVÕQGD
GD NHQGLQL J|VWHUPHNWHGLU 7ÕSNÕ \HUHO RODUDN
5HúDGL\H WUNOHULQGHNL oDOÕS V|\OHPH |]HOOL÷LQL
FHPOHUGH V|\OHQHQ ³D\HW GH\Lú VHPDKODU´GD
GD J|UPHNWH\L] <HUHO ³)DGLN D÷]Õ´ RODUDN LIDGH
HGLOHQ EX V|\OHPH ELoLPL FHPOHUGH GH NDUúÕPÕ]D
oÕNPDNWDGÕU %X |UQHNOHULQ \D]ÕOÕ ND\QDNODUGD
|UQHNOHULQLQ ROPDPDVÕ QHGHQL\OH DODQ DUDúWÕUPDVÕ
\DSÕOÕSEXLOYHLOoHOHUGH\DúDWÕODQJHOHQH÷LQNOWUHO
|]HOOLNOHULRUWD\DoÕNPDNWDGÕU
JUR‰H9LHOIDOW'LHVH9LHOIDOW]HLJWVLFKZLHGHUXPEHLGHU
3ÀHJH GHU UHOLJL|VHQ hEHU]HXJXQJHQ ZLHGHU :LU VHKHQ
GLH%HVRQGHUKHLWGHU6SLHOXQG*HVDQJVDUWGLHUHJLRQDO
LQ GHQ 9RONVOLHGHUQ GHU 5HúDGL\H YRUNRPPHQ JHQDXVR
DXFK LQ GHQ 9HUVHQ D\HW GHU UHOLJL|VHQ /LHGHU GH\Lú
LQ GHQ ULWXHOOHQ *HEHWVWlQ]HQ VHPDK GLH ZlKUHQG GHU
FHP=HUHPRQLHJHEUDXFKWZHUGHQ'LHVHDOV´)DGLND÷]Õ´
JHQDQQWH UHJLRQDOH *HVDQJVDUW EHJHJQHW XQV >IROJOLFK
DXFK LQ GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ 'D GLHVH *HVlQJH XQG
7lQ]H QLFKW LQ GHQ VFKULIWOLFKHQ 4XHOOHQ ¿[LHUW ZXUGHQ
ZLUGHLQH)HOGIRUVFKXQJLQGLHVHU5HJLRQJHPDFKWXPGLH
NXOWXUHOOHQ%HVRQGHUKHLWHQGLHVHU7UDGLWLRQKHUDXVDUEHLWHQ
]XN|QQHQ
%\N úHKLUOHUGH ROGX÷X JLEL 7RNDW YH LOoHOHULQGH
GH FHP ULWHOOHUL EHQ]HUOLN J|VWHUPHNWH \ROXQ
GHYDPOÕOÕ÷ÕNRQXVXQGDKDVVDVL\HWJ|VWHUHQ$OHYLOHU
FHPOHUGHNL\HUHOVHVOHQGLUPHYHVD]oDOPDNRQXVXQGD
D\QÕKDVVDVL\HWOHULJ|VWHUPHPHNWHGLUOHU
bKQOLFKZLHLQGHQ*UR‰VWlGWHQZHLVHQDXFKLQ7RNDWXQG
LQ /DQGHVNUHLVHQ 7RNDWV GLH FHP=HUHPRQLHQ HEHQIDOOV
*HPHLQVDPNHLWHQ DXI ZRKLQJHJHQ GLH $OHYLWHQ IU
GLH GLH .RQWLQXLWlW GHV >DOHYLWLVFKHQ@ :HJHV E]Z GHU
>DOHYLWLVFKHQ@ /HKUH YRQ EHVRQGHUHU :LFKWLJNHLW LVW
QHKPHQGLHORNDOHQ*HVlQJHXQGGDV6SLHOHQGHVVD] bei
GHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQQLFKWVRHUQVW
gUQH÷LQ 7RNDW LOLQGH WUNOHUL VHVOHQGLUPH ELoLPL
JHQHO RODUDN EHOOL NDOÕSODUGD ROPDVÕQD UD÷PHQ
ED]Õ FHP kúÕNODUÕ YH ED]Õ GHGHOHU LoLQ |QHP DU]
HWPHPHNWHGLU +kOEXNL NOWUQ GHYDPOÕOÕ÷Õ YH
\|UHQLQ NHQGLQH DLW EX |]HOOLNOHU RUDGD \DúD\DQ
NOWUHO]HQJLQOL÷LLIDGHHWPHNWHGLUgUQH÷LQ0DODW\D
$UJXYDQ¶GDoDOÕQÕSV|\OHQLOHQD\QÕGH\Lú$UDSNLU¶GH
IDUNOÕ $\GÕQ¶GD IDUNOÕ 6LYDV¶WD 0DUDú¶WD 7RNDW¶WD
IDUNOÕLNHQJQP]GHKHPHQKHPHQD\QÕV|\OHPH
ELoLPLLOHNDUúÕPÕ]DoÕNPDNWDGÕUøOHWLúLPDUDoODUÕQÕQ
\D\JÕQOÕ÷ÕSRSOHUNOWUQEDVNÕQoÕNPDVÕLQVDQODU
]HULQGHROXPVX]HWNL\LX\DQGÕUPDNWDGÕU
%HLVSLHOVZHLVH VSLHOHQ GLH *HVDQJVDUW GHU 9RONVOLHGHU
GHU 6WDGW 7RNDW GLH LQ GHU 5HJHO HLQH EHVWLPPWH )RUP
KDW IU HLQLJH 9RONVVlQJHU EHL GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ
VRZLHIUHLQLJHGHGHVNHLQHJUR‰H5ROOH,Q:LUNOLFKNHLW
EULQJHQ MHGRFK GLH %HZDKUXQJ GHU .XOWXU VRZLH GLH
(LJHQWPOLFKNHLWHQ GLHVHU 5HJLRQ HLQHQ NXOWXUHOOHQ
5HLFKWXP ]XP $XVGUXFN GHU GRUW YRUKDQGHQ LVW
%HLVSLHOVZHLVH SUlVHQWLHUW VLFK XQV JHJHQZlUWLJ GHUVHOEH
'RSSHOYHUVEH\LWGHULQ0DODW\D$UJXYDQJHVSLHOWXQG
JHVXQJHQZLUGXQGLQ$UDSNLU$\GÕQ6LYDV0DUDúXQG
7RNDWYHUVFKLHGHQLVWDXIHLQHVHKUlKQOLFKH*HVDQJVDUW
'LHZHLWH9HUEUHLWXQJGHU.RPPXQLNDWLRQVPHGLHQVRZLH
GLH9RUKHUUVFKDIWGHUSRSXOlUHQ.XOWXUKDEHQHLQHQHJDWLYH
$XVZLUNXQJDXIGLH0HQVFKHQ
<|UHGH WUNOHULQ GÕúÕQGD LQVDQODU \ÕOÕQ EHOOL
]DPDQODUÕQGD LEDGHW HWPHN DPDFÕ\OD FHP ULWHOOHUL
\DSDUODU <DSÕODQ EX FHPOHULQ |]HOOLNOHULQH J|UH
FHPLQ EHOOL DúDPDVÕQGD J|UHYOL RODQ YH EX E|OJHGH
FHPkúÕ÷ÕRODUDNDGODQGÕUÕODQNLúLVD]oDODUDNEH\LWOHU
GXD]Õ LPDP PLKUDoODPD SHUYD] WHYKLG YH semah
oDODU
1HEHQGHQ9RONOLHGHUQLQGHU5HJLRQIKUHQGLH0HQVFKHQ
]X EHVWLPPWHQ =HLWHQ GHV -DKUHV IU GLH *RWWHVDQGDFKW
FHP=HUHPRQLHQ GXUFK -H QDFK (LJHQKHLWHQ GLHVHUFHP
=HUHPRQLHQ VSLHOW HLQH 3HUVRQ GLH LQ GHU 5HJLRQ DOV
FHP0XVLNHU EHNDQQW LVW XQG ZlKUHQG HLQHU EHVWLPPWHQ
3KDVHGHU=HUHPRQLHHLQH$XIJDEHDXVIKUWVD]XQGVLQJW
GD]X 'RSSHOYHUVH EH\LW +\PQHQ IU GLH ,PDPH
GXD]Õ LPDP GLH PLKUDoODPD HLQ SHUYD] HLQ WHYKLG
XQG >*HGLFKW IU@ GDV VRJ J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ >´VHPDK GHU
+HU]HQ´@
7RNDW $PDV\D dRUXP <R]JDW YH 6LYDV¶ÕQ ED]Õ
E|OJHOHULQGH \DúD\DQ $OHYLOHUH ³6ÕUDo $OHYLOHUL´
GHQPHNWHGLU %X WRSOXOXNODUÕQ E\N ELU oR÷XQOX÷X
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHU+LPPHO
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWLQ=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHU+LPPHO
UHLVHGHV3URSKHWHQ0XKDPPHG@
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWGDVYRQGHU(LQKHLW*RWWHVE]ZGHU
P\VWLVFKHQ(LQKHLWKDQGHOW@
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
KHPHQ KHPHQ ¶L +XE\DU¶D ED÷OÕGÕU +XE\DU
7RSOXOXNODUÕ NHQGL LoOHULQGH ELUELUOHULQH 6ÕUDoODU
GHPHNWH LVH GH E|OJHGH EXOXQDQ GL÷HU $OHYL
JUXSODUÕ WP +XE\DU PHQVXSODUÕQÕ 6ÕUDoODU RODUDN
QLWHOHQGLUPHNWHGLUOHU
6ÕUDo V|]FN RODUDN ELUOHúLN ELU NHOLPHGLU 6ÕU JL]
JL]OL DQODPÕQGDGÕU $o V|]F÷ LVH DoPDN ¿OLQGHQ
JHOPHNWHGLU 6ÕUDo JL]OLOL÷L NDOGÕU Do DQODPÕQD
JHOPHNWHGLU 7DVDYYX¿ DQODPGD LVH 6ÕUDo LNL úH\L
LIDGHHWPHNWHGLU%LULQFLVL6ÕUDoVÕUUDYDNÕIRODQVÕUUÕ
LIúDHWPH\HQNHWXPDQODPÕQGDGÕUøNLQFLVL6ÕUDç+DN
0XKDPPHG$OL\ROXQGDVÕUSHUGHVLQLDoÕSNDOGÕUDQ
J|QO J|] DoÕN U\DQ RODQ J|QO J|] LOH +DNN¶Õ
J|UHQGHPHNWLU2VPDQOÕ7DSX7DKULU'HIWHUOHUL¶QGH
6DUDF VÕUDF &HPDDWL¶QLQ 7RNDW E|OJHVLQGH ROGX÷X
EHOLUWLOPHNWHGLU
$OHYLOLN ELU \DúDP ELoLPLGLU %X \DúDP ELoLPLQL
ROXúWXUDQ NOWUHO GH÷HUOHU YH ELULNLPOHUGLU
(GHEL\DW P]LN EX NOWUHO ELULNLPLQ EDúÕQGD
JHOPHNWHGLU .OWUHO ELULNLPOHULQ \DúDQGÕ÷Õ \HUOHU
LVHPHFOLVVRKEHWOHULYHWRSODQWÕODUÕGÕU%XWRSODQWÕODU
LVH FHPOHUGLU &HP LQVDQODUÕQ J|QO ELUOL÷L LOH ELU
DUDGDROGX÷XWRSODQWÕODUGÕU$ULÀHULQJ|QOQHJLUPHN
VRKEHWHGDKLOROPDNLODKLVDUKRúOX÷X\DúDPDNQHIVLQ
N|WO÷QGHQDUÕQÕSLODKL]HYNHPXKDEEHWHGDOPDN
J|QOOHUH JLUPHNWLU *|QOOHUH JLUHELOPHN LoLQGH
NHQGLVLQLELOPHVLJHUHNPHNWHGLU.HQGLVLQLELOPHQLQ
VÕUUÕGD|OPHGHQ|QFH|OPHNWLUgOPHGHQ|QFH|OHQ
GR÷DU
øQVDQÕQ NHQGLVLQL WDQÕPDVÕ NLUOLOL÷LQGHQ DUÕQÕS
NHQGL KDNLNDWLQL ELOPHVL JHUHNPHNWHGLU &DKLOOLNWHQ
XOYLOL÷H JLGHQ \RO LOLPGLU LUIDQGÕU LODKL ]HYNWLU
kúNWÕU PXKDEEHWWLU %X PXKDEEHWOHU FHPOHUGH
JHUoHNOHúLU=DDIWDQEHQOLNWHQNXUWXOXSVDÀDúPDNWÕU
<DQL GHOLOLNWHQ NXUWXOXS 9HOLOL÷H KDNND XODúPDN
+DNLOHQHVQH\HNDYXúPDNWÕU
'LH $OHYLWHQ GLH LQ 7RNDW $PDV\D dRUXP <R]JDW
XQG HLQLJHQ 5HJLRQHQ YRQ 6LYDV OHEHQ EH]HLFKQHW PDQ
DOV ´6ÕUDo$OHYLWHQ´ :RKLQJHJHQ VLFK GLHVH +XE\DU
*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ XQWHUHLQDQGHU DOV 6ÕUDo 6ÕUDoODU
EH]HLFKQHQ ZHUGHQ DOOH +XE\DU YRQ GHQ EULJHQ
DOHYLWLVFKHQ*HPHLQVFKDIWHQLQGHU5HJLRQ6ÕUDoJHQDQQW
'HU%HJULII³sÕUDo´LVW:RUWZDVDXV´VÕU´´*HKHLPQLV´
XQG ´Do´ ´|IIQHQ´ ´OIWHQ´ ]XVDPPHQJHVHW]W LVW
XQG GLH %HGHXWXQJ ´OIWH GDV *HKHLPQLV´ WUlJW ,Q
VHLQHU P\VWLVFKHQ %HGHXWXQJ EULQJW HV ]ZHL 'LQJH ]XP
$XVGUXFN (UVWHQV EH]HLFKQHW HV MHPDQGHQ GHU ´GDV
*HKHLPQLV QLFKW SUHLVJLEW QLFKW RIIHQEDUW´ =ZHLWHQV
EH]HLFKQHW HV MHPDQGHQ GHU ´PLW GHQ *HKHLPQLVVHQ GHU
VSLULWXHOOHQ :HJHV YRQ *RWW0XKDPPHG$OL YHUWUDXW
LVW GHVVHQ +HU]HQVDXJH JH|IIQHW LVW XQG HU PLW VHLQHP
+HU]HQVDXJH*RWWHUEOLFNHQNDQQ´$XFKLQGHQ(LQWUlJHQ
GHV*UXQGEXFKDPWHVGHU2VPDQHQ2VPDQOÕ7DSX7DKULU
'HIWHUOHULZLUGEHPHUNWGDVVGLH*HPHLQVFKDIWGHUsÕUDo
LQGHU5HJLRQYRQ7RNDW]X¿QGHQLVW
'DV $OHYLWHQWXP LVW HLQH /HEHQVDUW XQG HV VLQG GLH
NXOWXUHOOHQ :HUWH XQG GLH NXOWXUHOOH 7UDGLWLRQ GLH GLHVH
/HEHQVDUW NRQVWLWXLHUHQ 'LH /LWHUDWXU XQG GLH 0XVLN
ELOGHQGDVZLFKWLJVWH(OHPHQWGLHVHUNXOWXUHOOHQ7UDGLWLRQ
'HU 2UW DQ GHP GLHVH NXOWXUHOOH7UDGLWLRQ JHSÀHJW ZLUG
VLQGKLHUEHLGLH/HKUJHVSUlFKHXQGGLH=XVDPPHQNQIWH
'LHVH =XVDPPHQNQIWH QHQQW PDQ ´FHP´ 'DV FHP
LVW HLQH 9HUVDPPOXQJ LQ GHU 0HQVFKHQ LQ (LQWUDFKW
]XVDPPHQNRPPHQ >(V LVW HLQH =XVDPPHQNXQIW LQ GHU
PDQ@GLH$QHUNHQQXQJGHU:HLVHQJHZLQQHQVLFKDQGHQ
/HKUJHVSUlFKHQ EHWHLOLJHQ GLH VFKOHFKWHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQ
GHU1DIV>7ULHEVHHOH@DEOHJHQVLFKGHUJ|WWOLFKHQ:RQQH
XQG GHU P\VWLVFKHQ /LHEH KLQJHEHQ XQG GLH +HU]HQ GHU
DQGHUHQHUREHUQNDQQ(VEHGDUIDEHUGHU6HOEVWHUNHQQWQLV
XP GLH +HU]HQ GHU DQGHUHQ HUREHUQ ]X N|QQHQ XQG GDV
*HKHLPQLV GHU 6HOEVWHUNHQQWQLV LVW ´]X VWHUEHQ EHYRU
PDQ VWLUEW´ 'HUMHQLJH GHU VWLUEW EHYRU HU VWLUEW ZLHGHU
ZLHGHUJHERUHQ
(VLVWQRWZHQGLJGDVVGHU0HQVFK6HOEVWHUNHQQWQLVHUODQJW
VLFK YRQ VHLQHQ YHUZHUÀLFKHQ &KDUDNWHUHLJHQVFKDIWHQ
EHUHLQLJWXQGVRGLH:LUNOLFKNHLWEHUVLFKVHOEVWHUNHQQW
'HU:HJYRQGHU8QZLVVHQKHLW]XU(UKDEHQKHLWIKUWEHU
GHQ:HJGHV:LVVHQVGHVP\VWLVFKHQ:LVVHQVJ|WWOLFKHU
:RQQHGHU/LHEHXQGGHU*WH'LH*WHNRPPWLQGHQ
FHP=HUHPRQLHQEHUGLH*RWWHVDQGDFKWHQ]XP9RUVFKHLQ
>(VKHL‰W@VLFKYRQGHU6FKOHFKWLJNHLWXQGGHP(JRLVPXV
]XEHIUHLHQXQGUHLQ]XZHUGHQ(VKHL‰WVLFKYRP,UUVLQQ
]X EHIUHLHQ XQG HLQ *RWWHVIUHXQG ]X ZHUGHQ *RWW ]X
HUUHLFKHQXQGPLW*RWWGLH6FK|SIXQJ]XXPDUPHQ
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
&HPWHULPLQLQN|NHQLLQFHOHQGL÷LQGHWRSODQPDNELU
DUDGD ROPDN DQODPÕQÕ WDúÕPDNWDGÕU ³.DSÕGDQ LoHUL
JLUHQKHUFDQNDGÕQROVXQHUNHNROVXQELUGLU'ÕúDUÕGD
WRSOXPVDOQYDQÕQHROXUVDROVXQKHUNLúLFHPHUHQOHUL
PHFOLVLQGH HúLWWLU´1 <ÕOÕQ EHOOL G|QHPOHULQGH
|]HOOLNOH WDUÕP YH KD\YDQFÕOÕNOD \DúDPÕQÕ VD÷OD\DQ
LQVDQODU LúOHULQLQ ROPDGÕ÷Õ ]DPDQ GLOLPLQGH ELU
DUD\D JHOHUHN FHP W|UHQOHULQL JHUoHNOHúWLULUOHU %X
]DPDQGLOLPLJHQHOOLNOHVRQEDKDULOHNÕúD\ODUÕGÕU%X
G|QHPOHUGH\ÕOOÕNJ|UQPHGHGL÷LPL]E\NFHPOHUL
\DSDUODU 3HUúHPEH DNúDPÕ GD ELU DUD\D JHOHUHN
+DONDUDVÕQGD&XPDJHFHVLGHUOHUVRKEHWFHPOHULQL
JHUoHNOHúWLULUOHU
³*HQHO RODUDN UHWLP ]DPDQODUÕ GÕúÕQGD EHOOL ELU
G]HQ LoHULVLQGH JHUoHNOHúWLULOHQ $OHYL%HNWDúL FHP
W|UHQOHULEHOOLELUJHOHQHNVHOoL]JLYHW|UHQLOLúNLOHUL
oHUoHYHVLQGHELUoHúLW³WRSOXPVDO\DúDPÕG]HQOHPH
YHGHQHWOHPHDODQÕ´DOJÕODQDELOLU&HPW|UHQOHULQGH
EWQQ RQD\Õ\OD RUWD\D NRQXODQ NXUDO EHOLUOHQHQ
NRQXP YH oL]LOHQ oHUoHYH EHOLUOH\LFLGLU YH NHVLQ
X\XPXJHUHNWLULU%X\DSÕLQVDQODUDUDVÕQGDNLNRQXP
IDUNOÕOÕ÷ÕQÕQ|WHVLQHJHoHUHNELUoHúLWNRQXPVDOHúLWOLN
VD÷ODU´$OHYL%HNWDúLFHPOHULQGHHQ|QHPOLHVDV
KL]PHWLQ\UWOPHVLGLU%XUDGD\UWOHQKL]PHW
VLPJHVHOGLU %X VLPJHOHU ELUHU LúDUHWWLU øúDUHWOHU
DQFDNVDPLPL\HWOH\RODOÕQGÕ÷ÕQGD\ROVUHNOLOL÷LQLQ
KDNLNDWOHULQHJ|WUU
KL]PHW $QDGROX¶GD LOOHUH J|UH GH÷LúNHQOLN
J|VWHUPHNWHGLU$PDoFHP\DSÕOÕUNHQJ|UHYE|OP
LOH LKWL\DoODUÕ NDUúÕODPDN LoHULGHNL KL]PHWOHUL
HNVLNVL] RODUDN \HULQH JHWLUPHNWLU *HQHO RODUDN ELU
FHPGH 0UúLW3LU 'HGH 5HKEHU 3H\LN ø]QLNoL
%HNoL*|]F'HOLOFL=DNLU.XUEDQFÕ/RNPDFÕYH
6SUJHFL EXOXQPDNWDGÕU %X KL]PHW VDKLSOHULQLQ
DGODUÕ ED]HQ IDUNOÕ RODUDN GD V|\OHQLOPHNWHGLU %X
KL]PHW VDKLSOHUL J|UHY VÕUDVÕ JHOGLNoH KL]PHWOHULQL
JHUoHNOHúWLUPHNWHGLUOHU
1 &HPDOùHQHU%HQLP.kEHPøQVDQGÕU$'<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXO
V
2 $OL+D\GDU$YFÕ2VPDQOÕ*L]OL7DULKLQGH3LU6XOWDQ$EGDOYH
%WQ'H\LúOHUL1RNWD.LWDSøVWDQEXOV
:HQQ PDQ GLH +HUNXQIW GHV %HJULIIHV ´FHP´ JHQDXHU
DQVFKDXW EHPHUNW PDQ GDVV GHU %HJULII GLH %HGHXWXQJ
´VLFKYHUVDPPHOQ´E]Z´]XVDPPHQNRPPHQ´WUlJW´-HGHV
*HPHLQGHPLWJOLHG>Z|UWO´6HHOH´´FDQ´@GLHGXUFKGLH
7UHUHLQNRPPWRE0DQQRGHU)UDXLVWJOHLFKZHUWLJ$OOH
3HUVRQHQVLQGLQGHU*HJHQZDUWGHU(UOHXFKWHWHQ>Z|UWO
´GLHMHQLJHQ GLH GDV =LHO HUUHLFKW KDEHQ´ ´HUHQOHU´@
JOHLFKZHUWLJXQJHDFKWHWGHVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ7LWHOVGDV
GLHVH3HUVRQLQGHU:HOWEHVLW]HQ´,QEHVWLPPWHQ=HLWHQ
GHV -DKUHV NRPPHQ LQVEHVRQGHUH 0HQVFKHQ GLH VLFK
PLW GHU /DQGZLUWVFKDIW XQG9LHK]XFKW EHIDVVHQ XQG =HLW
KDEHQ ]XVDPPHQ XP FHP=HUHPRQLHQ GXUFK]XIKUHQ
'LHVHIlOOWPHLVWDXIGLH)UKOLQJXQG:LQWHUPRQDWH,Q
GLHVHQ=HLWHQZLUGDXFKGLHVRJ´J|UQPH´GXUFKJHIKUW>
eine FHP=HUHPRQLH ]XU (UQHXHUXQJ GHV *HO|EQLVVHV
XQG GHU 7UHXH ]XP DOHYLWLVFKHQ *ODXEHQ XQG GHVVHQ
/HKUHQ@ >$XFK@ 'RQQHUVWDJDEHQGV LP 9RONVPXQG DOV
)UHLWDJQDFKW EH]HLFKQHW NRPPHQ VLH GDQQ ]XVDPPHQ
XPGHQVRJ´VRKEHWFHP´>FHP=HUHPRQLHQLQGHQHQGLH
/HKUJHVSUlFKHLP9RUGHUJUXQGVWHKHQ@]XPDFKHQ
'LHDOHYLEHNWDúL FHP=HUHPRQLHQGLHPHLVWDX‰HUKDOEGHU
=HLWHQLQGHQHQPDQIUGHQODQGZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHQ%HWULHE
DUEHLWHWLQUHJHOPl‰LJHQ$EVWlQGHQGXUFKJHIKUWZHUGHQ
NDQQ PDQ LP +LQEOLFN DXI GLH %H]LHKXQJ YRQ 7UDGLWLRQ
XQG UHOLJL|VHQ )HVWHQ DOV ´HLQ %HUHLFK LQ GHP GDV
JHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH /HEHQ RUJDQLVLHUW XQG EHUZDFKW ZLUG´
EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ 'LH PLW DOOJHPHLQHP (LQYHUVWlQGQLV
DN]HSWLHUWH5HJHOGHU$QODVVXQGGHUIHVWJHVHW]WH5DKPHQ
GHU FHP=HUHPRQLHQ VLQG EHVWLPPHQG XQG HUIRUGHUQ
HLQH VWULNWH %HIROJXQJ 'LHVH ,QVWLWXWLRQ WUDQV]HQGLHUW
GLH EHVWHKHQGH 2UGQXQJ XQG VWHOOW HLQH *OHLFKKHLW XQWHU
GHQ 0HQVFKHQ KHU (V JHKW LQ GHQ FHP=HUPHRQLHQ GHU
$OHYLWHQ XQG %HNWDúL LQ HUVWHU /LQLH GDUXP GLH >VRJ@
´]Z|OI 'LHQVWH´ ]X HUIOOHQ GLH HLQHQ V\PEROLVFKHQ
&KDUDNWHU KDEHQ 'LHVH V\PEROKDOWLJHQ 'LHQVWH ZHLVHQ
DXIHWZDVKLQXQGIKUHQQXUGDQQ]XGHQ:DKUKHLWHQDXI
GHP´:HJ´ZHQQPDQGHQ´:HJ´PLW$XIULFKWLJNHLWJHKW
'LH´]Z|OI'LHQVWH´KDEHQMHZHLOVUHJLRQDOH8QWHUVFKLHGHLQ
$QDWROLHQ'DV+DXSW]LHOLVWHVZlKUHQGGHUFHP=HUHPRQLHQ
GXUFK$UEHLWVWHLOXQJGLH$QIRUGHUXQJHQ]XHUIOOHQXQGGLH
´'LHQVWH´ OFNHQORV ]X YHUULFKWHQ ,P $OOJHPHLQHQ VLQG
ZlKUHQG HLQHU FHP=HUHPRQLH HLQ ´0HLVWHU´ ´PUúLG´
E]Z´SLU´HLQGHGH>HLQUHOLJL|VHV2EHUKDXSWDOHYLWLVFKHU
*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ@ HLQ ´:HJIKUHU´´UHKEHU´ HLQ %RWH
´SH\LN´HLQ´L]QLNoL´>´MHPDQGGHUGLH6FKXKHEHZDFKW´@
HLQ $XISDVVHU ´EHNoL´ HLQ :lFKWHU ´J|]F´ HLQ
´GHOLOFL´>´MHPDQGGHUIUGDVULWXHOOH/LFKWYHUDQWZRUWOLFK
ù(1(5&HPDO%HQLP.kEHPøQVDQGÕU$'<D\ÕQFÕOÕN
øVWDQEXO6
AVCI$OL+D\GDU2VPDQOÕ*L]OL7DULKLQGH3LU6XOWDQ$EGDO
YHEWQGH\LúOHUL1RNWD.LWDSøVWDQEXO6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
'HGH
'HGH FHPL \|QHWLU 'HGH¶QLQ \DUGÕPFÕVÕ LVH
rHKEHUGLU³+] 0XKDPPHG´i temsilen ³$KPHGL
0XKWDU´ SRVWX \D GD PDNDPÕGÕU 7DVDYYXID J|UH
PUúLG\DGDSLUKHPPONQYDUOÕ÷ÕQKHPJ|QOQ
UXKXQ VXOWDQÕGÕU´3 ³$OHYLOLNWH GLQVHO KL\HUDUúLQLQ
EDúÕQGDGHGHYDUGÕU'HGHOLNGLQVHO\DSÕQÕQGLUH÷LGLU
$QDGROX¶GD \DNOkúÕN \ÕOGÕU GHPLU DVD GHPLU
oDUÕN LOH N|\ N|\ GRODúDQODU +RUDVDQ HUHQOHUL RODQ
EXJ|QOGHUYLúOHULGLU$QDGROX¶GDGLQVHO|UJWOHQPH
HVDV RODUDN LNL NROGDQ \U\RU %XQODUGDQ ELULQFLVL
+DFÕ%HNWDú9HOLGHUJkKÕQDED÷OÕ\DSÕODQPDøNLQFLVL
LVHELUNÕVPÕQÕQ$QDGROX¶\DJHOLúWDULKL+DFÕ%HNWDú
9HOL |QFHVLQH X]DQDQ 2FDN]kGH GHGHOLNOHUGLU
+DFÕ %HNWDú¶GDNL GHUJkKD ED÷OÕ +DFÕ %HNWDú 9HOL
JHOHQH÷LQHED÷OÕRFDNWDQROXúDQdHOHELOHUYH%DEDODU
+DFÕ %HNWDú 9HOL GHUJkKÕQD ED÷OÕGÕU +DFÕ %HNWDú
9HOL GHUJkKÕ GÕúÕQGDNL $QDGROX YH %DONDQODU¶GDNL
$OHYLOHULQGLQL|UJWOHQPHELoLPOHUL³GHGHRFDNODUÕ´
WDU]ÕQGDNLROXúXPODUGÕU´
KL]PHWL \UWHQLQ LONL 'HGH¶GLU 'HGH FHPLQ
\UWOPHVLQH PUúLWOLN HGHU %X KL]PHWLQ VDKLEL
RODUDN +] 0XKDPPHG +] $OL YH +QNkU +DFÕ
%HNWDúL 9HOL DQÕOÕU 'HGH 0XKDPPHG VR\XQGDQ
JHOPHNWHGLU%XQGDQGROD\ÕGDGHGHVH\LWWLU'HGHOLN
EDEDGDQ R÷XOD DNWDUÕODQ DLOHGH EX LúL \DSDELOHFHN
ELOJHROJXQRODQNLúLGHGHOLNNXUXPXQX\DúDWDQGÕU
(YLQ HQ NoF÷ GH ROVD YH ELOJLOL LVH EX LúL
\DSDELOHFHNVH GHGH RQX \|QOHQGLULU YH GHGHOL÷L R
NLúL \DSDU %HNWDúLOLNWH LVH GHGHEDED WDUDIÕQGDQ HO
YHULOHUHNFHPGHEDEDRODFDNNLúL\HEHUDWÕQÕYHUHUHN
EHOJHOHUYHFHPEXNLúLWDUDIÕQGDQ\|QHWLOLU
³$OHYLOLNWH GHGH KHP WRSOXPVDO |QGHU KHP GLQVHO
|QGHUKHPGHELOJHOL÷LNLúLOL÷LQGHWRSOD\DQoRN\|QO
\ROJ|VWHULFLNDUL]PDWLNELUNLúLOLNWLU´5
3 $OL.HQDQR÷OXøVPDLO2QDUOÕ+XE\DU6XOWDQ2FD÷ÕYH%H\GLOL
6ÕUDo7UNPHQOHUL.HOHEHN0DWEDDVÕ1LVDQV
&HPDOùHQHU%HQLP.kEHPøQVDQGÕU$'<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXO
V
&HPDOùHQHU%HQLP.kEHPøQVDQGÕU$'<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXO
V
ist´@ HLQ 0XVLNHU ´]DNLU´ PHLVW HLQ VD]6SLHOHU HLQ
´NXUEDQFÕ´>MHPDQGGHUIUGDV2SIHUYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW@
HLQ´ORNPDFÕ´>MHPDQGGHUIUGLH9HUWHLOXQJGHU6SHLVHQ
YHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW@XQGHLQ´VSUJHFL´>MHPDQGGHUIUGHQ
'LHQVWGHVULWXHOOHQ)HJHQVYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW@DQZHVHQG
'HU1DPHGLHVHU'LHQVWKDEHQGHQNDQQDXFKDQGHUVODXWHQ
XQGGLH'LHQVWKDEHQGHQYHUULFKWHQLKUHQ'LHQVWVREDOGVLH
DQDXIJHIRUGHUWZHUGHQ
'HUdede>GDVJHLVWLJVSLULWXHOOH2EHUKDXSWDOHYLWLVFKHU
*HPHLQVFKDIWHQ@
Der GHGH OHLWHW GLH FHP=HUHPRQLH DQ ZlKUHQG GHU
UHKEHU GHU *HKLOIH LVW ,Q 9HUWUHWXQJ GHV 3URSKHWHQ
0XKDPPHGQLPPWHUGHQ6LW]SODW]>Z|UWOGDV6FKDIVIHOO@
GHV´$KPHGL0XKWDU´HLQ,P6X¿VPXVLVWGHU0HLVWHU
VRZRKO *HELHWHU EHU ZHOWOLFKH %HVLW]H DOV DXFK GHV
+HU]HQV >GK VSLULWXHOOH 'LQJH@ ,P $OHYLWHQWXP VWHKW
GHU GHGH LQ GHU UHOLJL|VHQ +LHUDUFKLH DQ HUVWHU 6WHOOH HU
LVW GLH 6WW]H GHV UHOLJL|VHQ *HELOGHV (V ZDUHQ GLHVH
´'HUZLVFKHGHV+HU]HQV´DXV.KRUDVƗQGLHLQ$QDWROLHQ
VHLW IDVW -DKUHQ PLW LKUHQ :DQGHUVWlEHQ YRQ 'RUI
]X 'RUI JLQJHQ 'LH UHOLJL|VH 2UJDQLVDWLRQ HUIROJWH LQ
$QDWROLHQ KDXSWVlFKOLFK GXUFK ]ZHL ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ 'LH
HUVWH ,QVWLWXWLRQ ZDU PLW GHP 'HUZLVFKNORVWHU GHV +DFL
%HNWDú9HOLYHUEXQGHQXQGGLH]ZHLWH,QVWLWXWLRQELOGHWHQ
GLHVRJ´RFDN]kGH´>1DFKNRPPHQGHU)DPLOLHQGHURFDN
DOHYLWLVFKH*HPHLQVFKDIWHQGLHVLFKPHLVWXPHLQH3HUVRQ
JHELOGHWKDEHQ@GHUHQ(LQZDQGHUXQJLQ$QDWROLHQJDUYRU
+DFL%HNWDú9HOLHUIROJWH$XFKGLHÇelebiXQGGLHbaba
>VSLULWXHOOH/HKUHUGHU%HNWDúL@VLQGGHP'HUZLVFKNORVWHU
GHV +DFL %HNWDú 9HOL YHUEXQGHQ XQG VWHKHQ LQ GHVVHQ
7UDGLWLRQVOLQLH 'LH UHOLJL|VH 2UJDQLVDWLRQ GHU $OHYLWHQ
LQ$QDWROLHQ XQG DXI GHP %DONDQ GLH QLFKW DQ GDV +DFÕ
%HNWDú 9HOL 'HUZLVFKNORVWHU JHEXQGHQ VLQG ZLUG GXUFK
GLHRFDNJHZlKUOHLVWHW11
'HU 'LHQVW GHV GHGH >GK@ ZLUG DOV (UVWHV YHUULFKWHW
XQG GHP GHGH REOLHJW GLH JHLVWLJVSLULWXHOOH )KUXQJ LQ
GHU FHP=HUHPRQLH $OV 6FKXW]KHUUHQ GLHVHV 'LHQVWHV
JHGHQNW PDQ GHP 3URSKHWHQ 0XKDPPHG ,PDP $OL
XQG+QNkU+DFÕ%HNWDú9HOL'LHGHGHVLQG1DFKIDKUHQ
GHV 3URSKHWHQ 0XKDPPHG ZHVKDOE VLH DXFK VH\LG
>1DFKNRPPHQ GHV 3URSKHWHQ 0XKDPPHG@ JHQDQQW
'DV ´6FKDIVIHOO GHV $KPHGL 0XKWDU´ ´$KPHGL 0XKWDU
3RVWX´ LVW HLQH DUDELVFKSHUVLVFKH :RUW]XVDPPHQVHW]XQJ GLH
YRQGHQ%HNWDúLJHEUDXFKWZLUG´$KPHGL0XKWDU´EH]HLFKQHW
LP 6X¿VPXV GHQ 3URSKHWHQ 0XKDPPHG ZlKUHQG ´SRVW´ GDV
6FKDIVIHOODXIGHPGHU0HLVWHUVLW]WEH]HLFKQHW'LHVHV6FKDIV
IHOOYHUOHLKWGHPGHGH$XWRULWlWXQG/HJLWLPDWLRQXQGZLUGLP
=HUHPRQLHQUDXPDXVJHEUHLWHW$Gh>"@
.(1$12ö/8$OLONARLIøVPDLO+XE\DU6XOWDQ2FD÷ÕYH%H\
GLOL6ÕUDo7UNPHQOHUL.HOHEHN0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXO6
11 ù(1(56
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
ÆúÕN=kNLU
$QDGROX¶QXQWHOOLVD]ÕQGDGLOHJHWLULOHQFRúNXODUGD
$QDGROX $OHYL%HNWDúL JHOHQH÷LQLQ HQ |QHPOL
WDúÕ\ÕFÕODUÕ RODQ GHGHOHU FHPOHUGH \D GD GRVW
VRKEHWOHULQGH kúND GúS EH\LW RNXGXNODUÕQGD
GH\LúOHUH HúOLN HGHQ WHOLQ QDPHVL NXWVDOGÕU 6D]
$QDGROX¶GD\DOQÕ]FDELUHQVWUXPDQGH÷LOkúÕNRODQÕQ
WDQÕ÷ÕYHKDWWDLQVDQR÷OXJLELkúNDGúHQGLU
6DQDW ROPDNVÕ]ÕQ GX\DUOÕN JHOLúPH] GX\DUOÕOÕN
JHOLúPHGLNoHVDQDWÕQNDOLWHVL\NVHOPH]+DWD\L3LU
6XOWDQ$EGDO 1HVLPL YE KHSVL VDQDWÕQ GRUXNODUÕQD
JHOPLúLQVDQODUGÕU
=DNLU]LNUHGHQGHPHNWLU&HPOHUD\HWEH\LWGXD]
PLKUDoODPD WHYKLG VHPDK JLEL LQDQFD \|QHOLN
V|]OHULQYHH]JLOHULLFUDHGLOGL÷L\HUOHUGLU&HPOHUGH
EX J|UHYOHUL \DSDQ NLúL $QDGROX¶GD \D\JÕQ RODUDN
DQODúÕODQNLúL=DNLU¶GLU\DQLVD]oDODQNLúLGLU$QFDN
ED]ÕE|OJHOHULPL]GH|UQH÷LQ0DODW\D0DUDú6LYDV
(U]LQFDQ .D\VHUL 7XQFHOL JLEL LO YH EXQODUD ED÷OÕ
LOoHYHN|\OHUGHGHGHD\QÕ]DPDQGDVD]oDOGÕ÷ÕLoLQ
]DNLUOLN J|UHYLQL GH VWOHQPHNWHGLU $QFDN JHQHO
RODUDNFHPGHVD]oDODQNLúL=DNLU¶GLU%XDGODQGÕUPD
ED]HQ$QDGROX¶GD \DúD\DQ IDUNOÕ ER\ODUGD GD IDUNOÕ
LVLPOHU DGÕ LOH NDUúÕPÕ]D oÕNPDNWDGÕU dHSQL¶OHUGH
³.DQEHU´+XE\DUYH6ÕUDo¶ODUGD“ÆúÕN´7DKWDFÕ¶ODU
GDLVH³6D]DQGDU´RODUDNLVLPOHQGLULOPHNWHGLU)DUNOÕ
LVLPOHUGH GH ROVD DPDo oDOGÕNODUÕ VD] LOH FHPOHUGH
J|UHYOHULQL \HULQH JHWLULUOHU =DNLU QHUHGH YH QH
]DPDQ EH\LW GH\Lú PHUVL\H PLKUDoODPD VHPDK
YH WHYKLG oDODFD÷ÕQÕ ELOLU YH RQD J|UH SRVWD RWXUDQ
SLU¶H \DUGÕPFÕ ROXU %|\OHFH ]DNLU FHPGH LOPLQ
WHPVLOFLVLGLUøOPLQWHPVLOFLVLROGX÷XLoLQRQXQSLUL
øPDP&DIHUL6DGÕN¶WÕUGHQLOLU
³$OHYL%HNWDúL WRSOXPXQGD \D\JÕQ ELU JHOHQHN RODQ
kúÕNOÕN JHOHQH÷L GH $OHYL%HNWDúL.Õ]ÕOEDú NOWU
YH GúQVHO ELULNLPLQLQ DQD GDPDUODUÕQGDQ ELULGLU
YH NÕUVDO DODQGDN|\ WRSOXPXQGD FHP W|UHQL JLEL
WRSOXPVDO \DúDPÕQ úHNLOOHQPHVL DoÕVÕQGDQ E\N
ZHUGHQ'DV$PWGHVGHGHZLUGYRP9DWHUDXIGHQ6RKQ
EHUWUDJHQZREHLGDV$PWGHVGHGHYRQGHUMHQLJHQ3HUVRQ
DP /HEHQ JHKDOWHQ ZLUG GLH GLHVHU$XIJDEH JHZDFKVHQ
LVWZHLVHXQGUHLIJHQXJLVW6HOEVWZHQQGLH3HUVRQGDV
MQJVWH0LWJOLHGGHU)DPLOLHLVWEHUQLPPWHVGLHVHV$PW
ZHQQ VLH JHQXJ :LVVHQ EHVLW]W QDFKGHP VLH YRQ HLQHP
GHGH XQWHUULFKWHW ZXUGH ,P %HNWDVFKLWHQWXP KLQJHJHQ
NDQQ GLH FHP=HUHPRQLH YRQ MHGHP 2UGHQVDQJHK|ULJHQ
JHOHLWHW ZHUGHQ GHU GXUFK GHQ GHGHEDED12 GLH (UODXEQLV
EHNRPPHQ KDW DQGHUH EHL GHU DXI GHP :HJ ]X IKUHQ
´,P$OHYLWHQWXPLVWGHUGHGHVRZRKOHLQHJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH
XQGUHOLJL|VH)KUXQJVSHUVRQDOVDXFKHLQHFKDULVPDWLVFKH
3HUV|QOLFKNHLWGLHLQVLFK:HLVKHLWYHUHLQWXQGYLHOVHLWLJH
)KUXQJVTXDOLWlWHQEHVLW]W´13
ƗúÕN]kNLU >:|UWOGHU´/LHEHVHQWEUDQQWH´±GHUULWXHOOH
0XVLNHU@
Die GHGH VLQG GLH ZLFKWLJVWHQ 7UlJHU GHU 7UDGLWLRQ GHU
$OHYLWHQXQG%HNWDúLLQ$QDWROLHQ,QGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQ
XQG GHQ )UHXQGHVPDKOHQ ZHUGHQ VLH YRQ GHU /LHEH
EHUPDQQWXQGIDQJHQDQLQ%HJOHLWXQJGHUDQDWROLVFKHQ
VDLWLJHQ VD] OHLGHQVFKDIWOLFK ]X VLQJHQ ZREHL GLH
HQWVWHKHQGHQ 0HORGLHQ DOV KHLOLJ EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ ,Q
$QDWROLHQ ZLUG GLH VD] QLFKW DOV HLQIDFKHV ,QVWUXPHQW
EHWUDFKWHW VLH WHLOW YLHOPHKU GLH (UIDKUXQJHQ XQG /LHEH
GHV DúÕN 2KQH .XQVW NDQQ NHLQH 6HQVLELOLWlW JHGHLKHQ
VRODQJH GLH 6HQVLELOLWlW VLFK QLFKW HQWZLFNHOW NDQQ GLH
.XQVW NHLQHQ 4XDOLWlWVVFKXE HUIDKUHQ XQG 6lQJHU XQG
'LFKWHUZLH+DWD\L3LU6XOWDQ$EGDO1HVLPLXQGDQGHUH
ZDUHQ 0HQVFKHQ GLH GHQ *LSIHO GHU .XQVW HUNORPPHQ
KDEHQ
Der ]DNLU LVW MHPDQG GHU VLFK GHP *RWWHVJHGHQNHQ
´]LNU´ ZLGPHW 'LH FHP=HUHPRQLH ELHWHW GHQ 5DKPHQ
GDIU UHOLJL|VH :RUWH XQG 0HORGLHQ ZLH .RUDQYHUVH
*HGLFKWYHUVH +\PQHQ DQ GLH =Z|OI ,PDPH GLH
PLUDoODPD GHQ WHYKLG XQG GHQ VHPDK ± ]X UH]LWLHUHQ
E]Z]XVLQJHQ'LH3HUVRQGLHEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQ
GLHVH $XIJDEHQ HUIOOW DOVR VD] VSLHOW LVW LQ $QDWROLHQ
JHPHLQKLQGHU>VRJ@]DNLU'DMHGRFKGHUGHGHLQHLQLJHQ
XQVHUHU 5HJLRQHQ ZLH EHLVSLHOVZHLVH LQ GHQ 6WlGWHQ
0DODW\D0DUDú6LYDV(U]LQFDQ.D\VHUL7XQFHOLXQGLQ
GHQGD]XJHK|ULJHQ/DQGHVNUHLVHQXQG'|UIHUQDXFKLQGHU
/DJHLVWVD]]XVSLHOHQEHUQLPPWHU>]XZHLOHQ@DXFKGLH
$XIJDEHGHV]DNLU0HLVWLVWHVGRFKGHU]DNLUGHUEHLGHQ
FHP=HUHPRQLHQ GLH VD] VSLHOW (U LVW MHGRFK DXFK XQWHU
DQGHUHQ1DPHQXQWHUGHQLQ$QDWROLHQOHEHQGHQ6WlPPHQ
EHNDQQW%HLGHQÇepniQHQQWPDQLKQ´NDQEHU´EHLGHQ
´´GHGHEDED´ LVW HLQ 7LWHO GHU GHP 2EHUKDXSW GHV %HNWDúL
2UGHQVYHUOLHKHQZLUG$Gh
13 ù(1(56
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
|QHPWDúÕ\DQELUNXUXPXQHQWHPHOXQVXUXGXU6D]ÕQ
YHV|]Q±YHGHVHPDKÕQ\HUDOPDGÕ÷ÕELUFHPW|UHQL
GúQPHN ELU \DQD V|] NRQXVX ELOH HGLOHPH] g\OH
NL W|UHQLQ KHU HYUHVLQGH ³QHIHV´OHU YH VD]ED÷ODPD
GHYUH\H JLUHU ³7HOOL .XUDQ´ GHQLOHUHN NXWVDQDQ
VD]DoDOPD\DYHV|\OHPH\HEDúODPDGDQ|QFHQL\D]
HGLOLU2QHGHQOHHWNLQYHVD\JÕOÕELU\HUHVDKLSRODQ
EX JHOHQH÷LQ WDúÕ\ÕFÕVÕ GXUXPXQGDNL kúÕNODU $OHYL
WRSOXPXQGDE\N|QHPWDúÕPDNWDGÕU´
&HPGHøFUD(GLOHQ0]LNgUQHNOHUL
&HP¶OHUGHVRUJXJ|UJELWWLNWHQ\DQLVRKEHWELWWLNWHQ
VRQUDkúÕNVD]ÕQDQL\D]HGHUYHNHQGLJ|UHYLQHEDúODU
6RKEHWNRQXVXQHLVHRQXQODLOJLOL|UQHNOHPHOHUoDODU
YH V|\OHU ÆúÕN¶ÕQ oDOÕS V|\OHGL÷L H]JLGH DQODWÕOPDN
LVWHQHQNRQX\XkúÕNELOL\RULVHDoÕNODUELOPL\RULVH
GHGHDoÕNODU+HULOGHROPDVDGD7RNDWYHFLYDUÕQGD
FHPH³6HIDODPD´LOHEDúODQÕU
6HIDODPD
&HPEDúOD\ÕSED]ÕKL]PHWVDKLSOHULKL]PHWLQL\HULQH
JHWLULS J|UHYLQL WDPDPODGÕNWDQ VRQUD 'HGH¶GHQ
GXD DOÕUODU 'HGH KL]PHW VDKLSOHULQH GXD RNXGXNWDQ
VRQUD=DNLUJ|UHYLQHEDúODU$QDGROX¶QXQKHU\HULQGH
ROPDVD GD ED]Õ \HUOHUGH =DNLU FHPH VHIDODPD LOH
EDúODU 'HGH\H PUúLGH YH FHPGH EXOXQDQ FDQODUD
KRúJHOGLQDQODPÕQGDV|\OHQHQGH\LúOHUH³VHIDODPD´
GHQLU=DNLU¶LQoDOÕSV|\OHGL÷LVHIDODPD\DXVWDPDOÕ
\DGDNHQGLQHDLWRODQúLLUL\|UHVLQLQPHORGLN\DSÕVÕ
LOHoDOÕSV|\OHU
%LUQXUGR÷GXNDUúÕPÕ]GDGXUX\RU
.DUúÕPGDRWXUDQFDQODUPHUKDED
dRNDYD]HúLWWLPKD\DWGLQOHGLP
.DUúÕPGDRWXUDQFDQODUPHUKDED7
*HOHQHNWHGHVWHED÷ODPDNRODUDNLIDGHHGLOHQ'XYD]
øPDPYH$\HWELUELULQHED÷ODQDUDNRNXQXU
$OL+D\GDU$YFÕ2VPDQOÕ*L]OL7DULKLQGH3LU6XOWDQ$EGDOYH
%WQ'H\LúOHUL1RNWD.LWDSøVWDQEXOV
<|UH7RNDW0HUNH].RFDFÕNN|\.D\QDNNLúL7XUDQ
.D\D'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL'HUOHPHWDULKL
+XE\DU XQG GHQ 6LUDo QHQQW PDQ LKQ ´aúÕN´ ZlKUHQG
HU EHL GHQ 7DKWDFÕ GHQ 1DPHQ ´VD]DQGDU´ WUlJW$XFK
ZHQQHUXQWHUYHUVFKLHGHQHQ1DPHQEHNDQQWLVWKDEHDOOH
]DNLUGLH$XIJDEHEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQVD]]XVSLHOHQ
Der ]DNLU ZHL‰ ZDQQ XQG DQ ZHOFKHP =HLWSXQNW GHU
FHP=HUHPRQLH ZHOFKHV UHOLJL|VH *HGLFKW E]Z ZHOFKH
0HORGLH ]X VSLHOHQ KDW XQG LVW KLHUEHL GHP DXI GHP
6FKDIVIHOO VLW]HQGHQ 0HLVWHUV +LOIH OHLVWHW $XV GLHVHP
*UXQG UHSUlVHQWLHUW HU VRPLW GDV >ULWXHOOH XQG NXOWXUHOOH@
:LVVHQEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQZHVKDOEPDQVDJWGDVV
VHLQ0HLVWHU,PDP&DIHUL6DGÕNVHL
´'LH 7UDGLWLRQ GHV 9RONVVlQJHUV XQG GHV 'LFKWHUV GLH
DXFK EHL GHQ$OHYLWHQ XQG %HNWDúL YHUEUHLWHW LVW LVW GLH
+DXSWVFKODJDGHU GHU .XOWXU XQG GHU NXOWXUHOOHP :LVVHQ
GHU.XOWXUGHU$OHYLWHQ%HNWDúLXQG.Õ]ÕOEDúXQGLVWGLH
ZHVHQWOLFKHV(OHPHQWHLQHU2UJDQLVDWLRQGLHLP+LQEOLFN
DXIGLH*HVWDOWXQJGHVJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKHQ/HEHQVDXIGHP
/DQGHGHQ'|UIHUQJUR‰H:LFKWLJNHLWEHVLW]W0DQNDQQ
VLFKHLQHFHP=HUHPRQLHLQGHUNHLQHVD]JHVSLHOWNHLQH
*HGLFKWH UH]LWLHUW XQG NHLQH /LHGHU JHVXQJHQ XQG NHLQ
VHPDKJHPDFKWZHUGHQNDXPYRUVWHOOHQ(VLVWYLHOPHKU
VRGDVVMHGH3KDVHGHU=HUHPRQLHPLWUHOLJL|VHQ/LHGHUQ
QHIHV XQG GHP 6SLHOHQ VD] E]Z GHU ED÷ODPD >HLQH
EHVRQGHUH)RUPGHUVD]@HLQJHOHLWHWZLUG'HUDOV´.RUDQ
PLW6DLWHQ´´WHOOLNXUDQ´YHUHKUWHQVD]]HLJWPDQVHLQH
(KUHUELHWXQJ EHYRU PDQ DQIlQJW ]X VSLHOHQ$XV GLHVHP
*UXQGH VSLHOHQ GLH 9RONVVlQJHU XQG GLFKWHU GLH DOV
7UlJHUGLHVHU7UDGLWLRQHLQHQZLFKWLJHQXQGUHVSHNWDEOHQ
3ODW]HLQQHKPHQHLQHJUR‰H%HGHXWXQJLQGHUDOHYLWLVFKHQ
*HVHOOVFKDIW´
(LQLJH %HLVSLHOH YRQ 0XVLNVWFNHQ GLH LQ GHU FHP=HUHPRQLHJHEUDXFKWZHUGHQ
1DFK %HHQGLJXQJ GHV 6QGHQEHNHQQWQLV5LWXDOV EHL GHQ
FHP=HUHPRQLH GDVV KHL‰W QDFKGHP GLH *HVSUlFKH HLQ
(QGHJHQRPPHQKDEHQ]HLJWGHUƗúÕNVHLQH(KUHUELHWXQJ
XQG EHJLQQW PLW VHLQHU $XIJDEH (U VSLHOW VR GDQQ GHP
7KHPDGHV*HVSUlFKVHQWVSUHFKHQGHLQ0XVLNVWFN:HQQ
GHUƗúÕNHWZDVEHUGDVJHVXQJHQH*HGLFKW]XVDJHQKDW
VDJW HU HWZDV GDUEHU ZHQQ QLFKW GDQQ VDJW GHU GHGH
HWZDVGD]X,QGHU5HJLRQ7RNDWIlQJWGLHFHP=HUHPRQLH
PLW GHP VRJ ´VHIDODPD´ DQ ZDV LQ DQGHUHQ 5HJLRQHQ
DQGHUVVHLQNDQQ
-D¶IDU$V6DGLT>WUNLVFK&DIHUL6DGÕNVFKLL
-D¶IDU$V6DGLT>WUNLVFK&DIHUL6DGÕNVFKLL
WLVFKHU,PDPXQG%HJUQGHUGHUGVFKD¶IDULWLVFKHQ5HFKWVFKXOH
$Gh
´
´NÕ]ÕOEDú´5RWVFK|SIHLVWHLQH%H]HLFKQXQJIUDOHYLWLVFKH
7XUNPHQHQ$Gh
$YFÕ6
$YFÕ6
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
'XYD]øPDP
%D]ÕLOOHUGH]DNLUNHQGLQHVÕUDJHOGL÷LQGHGXD]LPDP
LOH EDúODQJÕFÕ \DSDU (Q D] o GXD] LPDP V|\OHU YH
DUGÕQD $\HWL EH\LWL ED÷ODU &HP¶OHUGH PXWODND
GXD]LPDPoDOÕQÕUYHV|\OHQLU<HUHOP]LNNDOÕSODUÕ
LoHULVLQGH EHOOL XVOXSOD VHVOHQGLULOLU 'XYD] LPDP
GDRQLNLLPDPODUÕQDGODUÕJHoHUøOODRQLNLLPDPÕQ
DGÕQÕQ JHoPHVL GH JHUHNPHPHNWHGLU ³ %DúWD +]
0XKDPPHG¶LQ DGÕ GD JHoHU %D]ÕODUÕQGD øPDP
0HKGL¶GHQVRQUD+]+DWLFH¶QLQ+])DWPD¶QÕQ3LU
+DFÕ%HNWDú9HOL¶QLQDGODUÕQGDQVRQUDúDLULQNHQGL
PUúLGLQLQDGÕJHoHU2QG|UW0D¶VXPX3DNLOH2Q
\HGL.HPHUEHVW¶OHULWRSWDQDQDQODUGDYDUGÕU´8
+HUVDEDKKHUVDEDK|WúUNXúODU
$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLGL\HUHN
%OEOGHJOLoLQ¿JDQDEDúODU
$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLGL\HUHN9
$\HW%H\LW
³$OHYLKDONÕQÕQHQ|QHPOL|]HOOLNOHULQGHQELULúLLUYH
P]L÷H\DWNÕQROXúODUÕGÕU$OHYLOHUDUDVÕQGDP]LNYH
úLLURODQFDJF\OHLúOHQPLúWLU%XEDNÕPGDQVDUD\GD
LúOHQHQP]L÷HYHúLLUHNDUúÕJHUoHNKDONP]L÷LYHúLLUL
DOHYLOHUDUDVÕQGD\DúDPÕúWÕU7UNoHQLQER]XOPDGDQ
\DúDPDVÕQDYHLúOHQPHVLQH\DUGÕPFÕROPXúODUGÕU´10
$OHYL%HNWDúLOHUGH VD]OÕV|]O VRKEHW JHOHQH÷LQ
YD]JHoLOPH] |]HOOLNOHULQGHQGLU &HPOHUGH VRUJX
LNUDUELWLQFHDUWÕNP]LNE|OPEDúODU%XE|OPGH
DUWÕN $\HW%H\LW oDOÕQPD\D EDúODU ³$\HW .XU¶DQ
VUHOHULLoLQGHNLEHOLUOLSDUoDODUGDQKHUELUL$ODPHW
EHOLUWL GHOLO $OODK¶ÕQ YDUOÕ÷ÕQD NXGUHWLQH GHODOHW
HGHQ KHU úH\ %X VRQ PDQDGD EWQ YDUOÕN D\HWOHU
RODUDNNDEXOHGLOLUùDKÕVODU\HUOHUGHYLUOHUROD\ODU
*DQL3HNúHQ$QDGROX'HUOHPHOHULP(JHhQLYHUVLWHVL%DVÕ
PHYLø]PLUV
<|UH7RNDW0HUNH].RFDFÕNN|\.D\QDNNLúL7XUDQ
.D\D'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL'HUOHPHWDULKL
3URI'U)XDW%R]NXUW
3URI'U)XDW%R]NXUW$OHYLOL÷LQ7RSOXPVDO%R\XWODUÕ<D\
ODFÕN0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXOV
'DV6HIDODPD
1DFKGHP GLH FHP=HUHPRQLH DQJHIDQJHQ KDW XQG HLQLJH
'LHQVWKDEHQGH LKUHQ 'LHQVW YHUULFKWHW LKUH $XIJDEHQ
HUIOOWKDEHQZHUGHQVLHYRPGHGHPLW*HEHWHQJHVHJQHW
1DFKGHP GHU GHGH IU GLH 'LHQVWKDEHQGHQ Gebete
JHVSURFKHQ KDW IlQJW GHU ]DNLU PLW VHLQHU $XIJDEH DQ
:HQQ DXFK QLFKW EHUDOO LQ $QDWROLHQ EOLFK IlQJW GHU
]DNLU LQ PDQFKHQ *HJHQGHQ GLH FHP=HUHPRQLH PLW GHU
>VRJ@ VHIDODPD DQ 'LH UHOLJL|VHQ /LHGHU GLH GHU ]DNLU
VLQJW XP GHQ GHGH GHQ 0HLVWHU XQG GLH DQZHVHQGHQ
*HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGH>EHLGHUFHP=HUHPRQLH@ZLOONRPPHQ
]XKHL‰HQQHQQWPDQVHIDODPD'LHYRP]DNLUJHVXQJHQ
*HGLFKWHXPDOOHZLOONRPPHQ]XKHL‰HQVLQGHQWZHGHU
(LJHQWXPHLQHVEHNDQQWHQ'LFKWHUVRGHUZLUGGLHHLJHQHQ
*HGLFKWHGHV]DNLUGLHQDFKGHUPHORGLVFKHQ(LJHQDUWGHU
5HJLRQJHVXQJHQXQGJHVSLHOWZHUGHQ>(LQ%HLVSLHO@
%LUQXUGR÷GXNDUúÕPÕ]GDGXUX\RU
.DUúÕPGDRWXUDQFDQODUPHUKDED
ÇokDYD]HúLWWLPKD\DWGLQOHGLP
.DUúÕPGDRWXUDQFDQODUPHUKDED
>(LQ/LFKWLVWDXIJHJDQJHQXQGVFKHLQWYRUPLU
:LOONRPPHQ KHL‰H LFK GLH *HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGHU GLH PLU
JHJHQEHUVLW]HQ
9LHOH/LHGHUKDEHLFKJHK|UWYLHOHVYRP/HEHQHUIDKUHQ
:LOONRPPHQ KHL‰H LFK GLH *HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGHU GLH PLU
JHJHQEHUVLW]HQ@
'LH LQ GHU 7UDGLWLRQ ´GHVWH ED÷ODPDN´ ´HLQ 6WUDXFK
]XVDPPHQELQGHQ´JHQDQQWHQGXD] LPDPXQGD\HWZHUGHQ
QDFKHLQDQGHUYRUJHWUDJHQ
'XD]øPDP +\PQHQDQGLH=Z|OJ,PDPH
,Q HLQLJHQ /DQGNUHLVHQ PDFKW IlQJW GHU ]DNLU ZHQQ HU
DQGHU5HLKHLVWPLWGHPVRJ´GXD]LPDP´DQ(UVLQJW
PLQGHVWHQVGUHLGXD]LPDPXQGVFKOLH‰WVHLQH5H]LWDWLRQ
GDQQD\HWDE(LQGXD]LPDPPXVVXQEHGLQJWEHLGHQFHP
=HUHPRQLHQJHVXQJHQZHUGHQXQGZLUGQDFKGHUUHJLRQDOHQ
6SLHODUW JHVXQJHQ %HLP GXD] LPDP ZHUGHQ GLH 1DPHQ
GHU =Z|OI ,PDPH JHQDQQW REZRKO HV QLFKW XQEHGLQJW
QRWZHQGLJ LVW DOOH ]Z|OI QDPHQWOLFK ]X HUZlKQHQ ´$OV
HUVWHVZLUGGHU1DPHGHV3URSKHWHQ0XKDPPHGJHQDQQW
(LQLJH6lQJHUQHQQHQQDFKGHP1DPHQGHV,PDP0HKGL
GHU]Z|OIWH,PDPGLH1DPHQYRQ)DWLPDGHV0HLVWHUV
+DFL%HNWDú9HOLXQGGHQ1DPHQLKUHVHLJHQHQ0HLVWHUV
(LQLJHHUZlKQHQDXFKGLH>VRJ@´RQG|UWPD¶VXPXSDN´
XQGGLH>VRJ@´RQ\HGLNHPHUEHVW´
5HJLRQ6WDGW7RNDW.RFDFÕN'RUI4XHOOH7XUDQ.D\D=X
5HJLRQ6WDGW7RNDW.RFDFÕN'RUI4XHOOH7XUDQ.D\D=X
VDPPHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL
9JO
9JO3(.ù(1*DQL$QDGROX'HUOHPHOHULP(JHhQLYHUVLWHVL
%DVÕPHYLø]PLU6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
úH\OHU YV´11 %D]Õ \|UHOHUGH |]HOOLNOH ELU NXúDN
|QFHVL LQVDQODU ³'H\Lú´ yerine ³$\HW´ kelimesini
NXOODQPDNWDGÕUODU $QFDN SRSOHU NOWUQ \D\JÕQ
RODUDNGH÷LúWHULPLQLNXOODQPDVÕLOHNHOLPHLQVDQODU
]HULQGH \HU EXOPXúWXU +DOEXNL FHPOHUGH oDOÕQDQ
VD] NXWVDOGÕU YH ³7HOOL .XUDQ´ RODUDN DGODQGÕUÕOÕU
7HOOLNXUDQLOHGHD\HWoDOÕQÕUV|\OHQLUYHGLOOHQGLULOLU
+HUVDEDKKHUVHKHU|WúUNXúODU
$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLGL\HUHN
%OEOGHJOLoLQ¿JDQDEDúODU
$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLGL\HUHN
³0XKDEEHWOHUGH kúÕN VD]Õ oRN NXWVDO YH GH÷HUOLGLU
6|\OHQLUNHQ.XU¶DQRNXQX\RUPXúJLELGDYUDQÕODUDN
VD\JÕLOHGLQOHQLOPHVLJHUHNHQQHIHVOHUEXVD]ODRNXQXU
6D]ÕoDODQVD]DKDNDUHWHWWLUPH]2]DQVD]ÕQÕQL\D]
HGHUHNDOÕUQL\D]HGHUHNEÕUDNÕU6D]]HULQH\D]ÕOPÕú
úLLUOHUGHKHSRQXQNXWVDOOÕ÷ÕYH|QHPLDQODWÕOPÕúWÕU´
$OHYL%HNWDúL JHOHQH÷LQGH NXWVDO RODUDN oDOÕQDQ
VD] LOH NXWVDO úLLUOHU P]LN HúOL÷LQGH GLOOHQGLULOLU
%XUDGD $OHYLOL÷LQ %HNWDúLOL÷LQ \ROX \RUGDPÕ
DQODWÕOÕU%LUH\LQWRSOXPLoHULVLQGHQDVÕOGDYUDQPDVÕ
JHUHNWL÷LQL LQVDQÕQ HUGHPOLOL÷L YH LQVDQÕ Nkmil
RODELOPHQLQ|]HOOLNOHULDQODWÕOÕU³7ÕSNÕ7DQUÕ¶\DGXD
HGHQ\DúDQDQROD\ODUÕNRSX]X\ODDQODWDQELUúDPDQ
JLEL+DNkúÕ÷ÕGDED÷ODPDVÕLOHGH\LúOHUHVHVYHUPLú
7DQUÕ¶\D \DOYDUPÕú \DúDQDQODUÕ JHOHFHN NXúDNODUD
DQODWPÕúWÕU .LPL GL]HVLQGH LEDGHWL GL]HVLQGH GH
LGHDO LQVDQ LOLúNLOHULQL EXODELOLUL] %X |]HOOL÷L LOH
GH\LúOHU WDVDYYX¿ QLWHOL÷LQH |÷UHWLFLOLN QLWHOL÷LQL
GH HNOHU <DúDPGDNL J|UJOHUGHQ GHQHPHOHUGHQ
HGLQLOHQELOJLOHULYHRQGDQoÕNDUÕODQGHUVOHULDQODWDQ
EXDUDGDNLPL]DPDQ7DQUÕ¶\DVHVOHQHQNLPL]DPDQ
NDUD EDKWWDQ IHOHNWHQ |OPGHQ \DNÕQDQ \HULQH
J|UH VDGHFH J|UJVQ \HULQH JHWLUHQ ELU DQODWÕP
V|]NRQXVXGXU´13+DWD\L3LU6XOWDQ$EGDO1HVLPL
9LUDQL )X]LOL 'HUWOL 'HUYLú 0XKDPPHG 6H\UDQL
øEUHWL YG JLEL PXWDVDYYÕI R]DQODUÕQ úLLUOHUL VÕNoD
NXOODQÕOÕU YH EX R]DQODU JHOHQHNWH NXWVDO ELU \HUOHUL
YDUGÕU
'HUD\HWEH\LW
´(LQHU GHU ZLFKWLJVWHQ (LJHQVFKDIWHQ GHV DOHYLWLVFKHQ
9RONHVLVWGDVVVLHHLQH1HLJXQJ]XU'LFKWXQJXQG0XVLN
KDEHQ 0XVLN XQG 'LFKWXQJ IDQGHQ EHL GHQ $OHYLWHQ
HLQH DX‰HURUGHQWOLFKH 9HUZHQGXQJ $XV GLHVHP *UXQG
NRQQWHGLHHFKWH9RONVPXVLNXQGGLFKWXQJLP9HUJOHLFK
]XU 0XVLN XQG 'LFKWXQJ GLH LP +RIH JHSÀHJW ZXUGH
XQWHU GHQ $OHYLWHQ ZHLWHUOHEHQ 'LH $OHYLWHQ KDOIHQ
>VRPLW@GDEHLGDVVGLHWUNLVFKH6SUDFKHZHLWHUH[LVWLHUHQ
XQG ZHLWHUHQWZLFNHOW ZHUGHQ NRQQWH RKQH GDVV VLH
GHJHQHULHUHQ NRQQWH´ %HL GHQ $OHYLWHQ%HNWDVFKLWHQ
VWHOOHQ GLH /HKUJHVSUlFKH PLW LKUHP *HVDQJ XQG GHUVD]
HLQHGHUXQYHU]LFKWEDUHQ(LJHQVFKDIWHQGHU7UDGLWLRQGDU
%HL GHQ 8QWHUKDOWXQJHQ ZLUG GLH VD] GHV 'LFKWHUV XQG
6lQJHUV DOV EHVRQGHUV ZHUWYROO XQG KHLOLJ EHWUDFKWHW
:lKUHQG GHV *HVDQJV YHUKlOW PDQ VLFK ZLH EHL GHU
.RUDQUH]LWDWLRQ XQG GLH UHOLJL|VHQ *HGLFKWH XQG /LHGHU
QHIHVGLHPLW5HVSHNW]XK|UHQVLQGZHUGHQPLWGLHVHU
sa] JHVSLHOW -HPDQG GHUVD] VSLHOW ZLUG QLFKW ]XODVVHQ
GDVV PDQ GHU VD] JHJHQEHU UHVSHNWORV LVW %HYRU GHU
øVPDLOg]PHQ
øVPDLOg]PHQ$OHYL%HNWDúLùLLUOHUL$QWRORMLVL&
77.XUXPX%DVÕPHYL$QNDUDV
øOKDQ&HP(UVHYHQ
øOKDQ&HP(UVHYHQ
(UVHYHQ$OHYLOHUGH6HPDK$QW<D\ÕQODUÕ$QND
UDV
*DQL3HNúHQ
*DQL3HNúHQ$QDGROX'HUOHPHOHULP(JHhQLYHUVLWHVL
%DVÕPHYLø]PLUV
5HJLRQ7RNDW=HQWUXP.RFDFÕNN|\4XHOOH7XUDQ
5HJLRQ7RNDW=HQWUXP.RFDFÕNN|\4XHOOH7XUDQ.D\D
=XVDPPHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL
BOZKURT )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO %R\XWODUÕ <D\ODFÕN
0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXO6
21 ÖZMENøVPDLO$OHYL%HNWDúLùLLUOHUL$QWRORMLVL%QG6
6D\SD<D\ÕQ'D÷ÕWÕPYH.LWDEHYL$QNDUD6
>-HGHQ0RUJHQVLQJHQGLH9|JHO
C$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLC
8QGGLH1DFKWLJDOONODJWZHJHQGHU5RVH
´$OODKELU0XKDPPHG$OLC@
1DFK %HHQGLJXQJ GHU 6QGHQEHNHQQWQLV5LWXDOH XQG
GHU (LQZHLKXQJVULWXDOHEHL GHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQEHJLQQW
VFKOLH‰OLFKGHUPXVLNDOLVFKH7HLO+LHUEHLZHUGHQD\HWE]Z
EH\LWJHVXQJHQXQGUH]LWLHUW'LH>VRJ@D\HWVLQGEHVWLPPWH
.RUDQVWHOOHQ 0LW GHU %HGHXWXQJ GHV :RUWHV ´D\HW´ DOV
´=HLFKHQ´´+LQZHLV´E]Z´%HZHLV´EH]HLFKQHQGLHD\HW
DOOHV ZDV DXI *RWWHV 6HLQ XQG VHLQH .UDIW KLQZHLVW ,Q
GLHVHP6LQQHNDQQGHVKDOEDXFKGLHJHVDPWH6FK|SIXQJ
als D\HW EHWUDFKWHW ZHUGHQ ± >VR ]%@ 0HQVFKHQ 2UWH
(UHLJQLVVH *HJHQVWlQGH XVZ´21 ,Q PDQFKHQ 5HJLRQHQ
JHEUDXFKWPDQ>GHVKDOE@EHVRQGHUVGLHlOWHUH*HQHUDWLRQ
± DQVWDWW GHV 7HUPLQXV ´GH\Lú´ >Z|UWO ´$XVGUXFN´@ GHQ
7HUPLQXV ´D\HW´ 'D MHGRFK GLH 3RSXOlUNXOWXU RIW GHQ
%HJULII GH\Lú EHQXW]W YHUZHQGHQ GLH PHLVWHQ 0HQVFKHQ
GLHVHQ %HJULII 'LH VD] GLH EHL GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ
JHVSLHOWZLUGLVWDEHULQ:LUNOLFKNHLWKHLOLJXQGZLUGDOV
´.RUDQDXV6DLWHQ´EH]HLFKQHW8QGPLWGHP´.RUDQDXV
6DLWHQ´VSLHOWXQGK|UWPDQ>DEHU@D\HW
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
<HULJ|÷LQVFLQQL\DUDWWÕQ
6HQH\PLPDUEDúÕH\YDQFÕPÕVÕQ
$\ÕJQoDUKÕEXUFXYDUHWWLQ
(\PHNkQVDKLEL5DKúDQFÕPÕVÕQ14
0LUDoODPD
6|]FN ³ 0HUGLYHQ *|÷H oÕNPD´15 DQODPÕQÕ
WDúÕPDNWDGÕU øVODPL\HW¶WH +D]UHWL 0XKDPPHG¶LQ
0HVFLGL$NVD¶GDQ J|NOHUH \NVHOHUHN 7DQUÕ NDWÕQD
oÕNPD ROD\ÕQÕ DQODWPDN LoLQ NXOODQÕOÕU øNUDU YHULS
QDVLSDOPDGD+DN\]QJ|UPHDQODPÕQGDDOJÕODQÕU
$OHYLOLN%HNWDúLOLN LQDQFÕQGD LVH PLUDo WDQVÕ÷Õ oRN
IDUNOÕGÕU 2QODUD J|UH &HEUDLO +] 0XKDPPHG¶H
+DNN¶ÕQ GDYHWLQL ELOGLULU YH 2¶QD UHKEHUOLN HGHU
6HPDGD |QOHULQH ELU DVODQ oÕNDU YH ELU VHV ³$VODQ
VHQGHQ ELU QLúDQ LVWHU \]÷Q YHU´ GHU +]
0XKDPPHG \]÷Q DVODQÕQ D÷]ÕQD DWDU \ROXQD
GHYDPHGHUEXDUDGDLoLQGHQ³$PFDPR÷OX$OLEXUDGD
ROVD\GÕEXDVODQÕQKDNNÕQGDQJHOLUGL´GL\HGúQU
6RQXQGD +] 0XKDPPHG¶H +DN WHFHOOL HGHU YH
+DNN¶ÕQ\]QJ|UUVHVVL]YHV|]V]RODUDNGRNVDQ
ELQVÕUV|\OHúLUOHU+]0XKDPPHGPLUDoG|QúQGH
.ÕUNODU¶ÕQVRKEHWWHFHPGHROGXNODUÕHYHX÷UDULoHUL
JLUPHVLQHL]LQYHUPH]OHUELUNDoNH]JD\EWHQX\DUÕODU
VRQXFXDQFDN³<RNVXOODUÕQKL]PHWoLVL\LP´GHGL÷LQGH
EX\XU HGHU LoHUL DOÕUODU 6HOPDQ )DULVL GÕúDUÕGD
J|UHYOLROGX÷XQGDQLoHULGHNLúLYDUGÕU+]$OL¶QLQ
\DQÕQGDRWXUDQ+]0XKDPPHG³VL]OHUNLPOHUVLQL]´
GL\HVRUDURQODUGD³%L]NÕUNODUÕ]KHSLPL]ELUJ|QO
ELU FLKHWL] ELULPL] QH LVH YDUÕPÕ] RGXU´ GHUOHU +]
0XKDPPHG NDQÕW GHOLO LVWH\LQFH +] $OL NROXQX
QHúWHUOH \DUDODU KHSVLQLQ NROXQGDQ D\QÕ DQGD NDQ
DNDU ELU GDPOD NDQGD oDWÕGDQ GúHU EX 6HOPDQ¶ÕQ
NDQÕGÕU 'DKD VRQUD 6HOPDQ HOLQGH ELU ]P WDQHVL
LOH LoHUL JLUHU +] 0XKDPPHG¶H ³(\ \RNVXOODUÕQ
KL]PHWoLVL EX ]P WDQHVLQL EL]H SD\ HW´ GHU +]
<|UH7RNDW7XUKDOdD\OÕ.DVDEDVÕ.D\QDNNLúL$KPHW
<|UH7RNDW7XUKDOdD\OÕ.DVDEDVÕ.D\QDNNLúL$KPHW
$VDQ'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQ$OL2UKDQ'|QPH]6HUFDQ<ÕO
GÕ]'HUOHPHWDULKL
)HULW'HYHOLR÷OX
)HULW'HYHOLR÷OX2VPDQOÕFD7UNoH$QVLNORSHGLN/€JDW
$\GÕQ.LWDEHYL$QNDUDV
9RONVGLFKWHU R]DQ VHLQH VD] LQ GLH +DQG QLPPW E]Z
DEOHJW ]HLJW HU LKU YRUKHU VHLQH (KUHUELHWXQJ 0DQ KDW
EHUGLHVD]JHVFKULHEHQXQGGLH*HGLFKWHKDQGHOWHQVWHWV
YRQ LKUHU +HLOLJNHLW XQG :LFKWLJNHLW22 ,Q GHU 7UDGLWLRQ
GHU $OHYLWHQ XQG %HNWDúL ZHUGHQ GLH KHLOLJHQ *HGLFKWH
LQ %HJOHLWXQJ GHU DOV KHLOLJ EHWUDFKWHWHQ VD] JHVXQGHQ
0DQVSULFKWEHUGHQ5LWXVXQGGLH5HJHOQXQG1RUPHQ
GHV$OHYLWHQWXPVXQGGHV%HNWDVFKLWHQWXPV0DQVSULFKW
GDUEHUZLHGHU(LQ]HOQHVLFKLQGHU*HVHOOVFKDIWYHUKDOWHQ
VROO XQG ZDV GLH (LJHQVFKDIWHQ GHU PHQVFKOLFKHQ
7XJHQGKDIWLJNHLWXQGGHU9ROONRPPHQKHLWVLQG´*HQDXVR
ZLHGHU6FKDPDQHPLWVHLQHU´NRSX]´23]X*RWWEHWHWXQG
PLWLKUGLH(UHLJQLVVHLQVHLQHP/HEHQVFKLOGHUWVRVLQJW
DXFK GHU /LHEHQGH *RWWHV PLW VHLQHU ED÷ODPD UHOLJL|VH
*HGLFKWHXQG/LHGHUÀHKW]X*RWWXQGHU]lKOWGHUQlFKVWHQ
*HQHUDWLRQ GDV (UOHEWH ZHLWHU ,Q HLQLJHQ VHLQHU 9HUVH
¿QGHQ ZLU GDV *HEHW LQ DQGHUHQ9HUVHQ JHKW HV XP GDV
LGHDOH =XVDPPHQOHEHQ GHU 0HQVFKHQ 6RPLW HUKDOWHQ
GLH UHOLJL|VHQ *HGLFKWH XQG /LHGHU QHEHQ GHU VX¿VFKHQ
%HGHXWXQJDXFKHLQHGLGDNWLVFKH(EHQH
6LHKDQGHOQYRQGHPZDVPDQLP/HEHQEHREDFKWHWKDW
YRQGHQ(UIDKUXQJHQLP/HEHQXQGGHQGDUDXVJH]RJHQHQ
/HKUHQ =XZHLOHQ ZHQGHQ VLH VLFK DQ *RWW ]XZHLOHQ
NODJHQ VLH EHU GDV 8QKHLO GLH +HLPVXFKXQJ XQG GHQ
7RG=XZHLOHQDEHUVLQGVLHQXUHLQH$XVGUXFNVIRUPXP
GLH 7UDGLWLRQ ]X ZDKUHQ >"@´ 'LH *HGLFKWH YRQ 6X¿
'LFKWHUQZLH]%+DWD\L3LU6XOWDQ$EGDO1HVLPL9LUDQL
)X]LOL'HUWOL'HUYLú0XKDPPHG6H\UDQLøEUHWLZHUGHQ
RIW JHEUDXFKW ZREHL GLHVH 9RONVGLFKWHU LQ GHU 7UDGLWLRQ
HLQHKHLOLJH6WHOOXQJEHVLW]HQ
<HULJ|÷LQVFLQQL\DUDWWÕQ
6HQH\PLPDUEDúÕH\YDQFÕPÕVÕQ
$\ÕJQoDUKÕEXUFXYDUHWWLQ
(\PHNkQVDKLEL5DKúDQFÕPÕVÕQ
'LHVRJPLUDoODPD
'DV :RUW ´PLUDoODPD´ EHGHXWHW ´7UHSSH´ E]Z
´+LPPHOIDKUW´(VZLUGJHEUDXFKWXPLQGHULVODPLVFKHQ
7UDGLWLRQGLH+LPPHOIDKUWYRQ0XKDPPHGYRQ-HUXVDOHP
DXV]X*RWW]XEHVFKUHLEHQ%HLP(LQWULWWLQHLQHQ2UGHQ
ZLUGHVDOVHLQH´6FKDXGHVJ|WWOLFKHQ$QWOLW]´YHUVWDQGHQ
,Q GHU *ODXEHQVYRUVWHOOXQJ GHU $OHYLWHQ XQG %HNWDúL
ZLUG GDV :XQGHU GHU +LPPHOIDKUW PLUDo JDQ] DQGHUV
DXIJHIDVVW ,KUHP *ODXEHQ QDFK LQIRUPLHUW GHU (U]HQJHO
22 ERSEVEN øOKDQ &HP $OHYLOHUGH 6HPDK $QW \D\ÕQODUÕ
øVWDQEXO6
23´.RSX]´LVWHLQGUHLVDLWLJHV=XS¿QVWUXPHQWGDVYRQGHQ$OW
WUNHQJHVSLHOWZXUGHXQGDOV9RUOlXIHUYRQ
VD]JLOW$Gh>"@
3(.ù(16
5HJLRQ7XUKDOdD\OÕ 7RNDW 4XHOOH$KPHW$VDQ =XVDP
PHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQ$OL
2UKDQ'|QPH]6HUFDQ<ÕOGÕ]
'(9(/,2ö/8 )HULW 2VPDQOÕFD7UNoH $QVLNORSHGLN /€JDW
$\GÕQ.LWDEHYL$QNDUD6
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
0XKDPPHG R VÕUDGD &HEUDL¶H JHWLUGL÷L QXU WDEDNWD
]PWDQHVLQLH]HUHNúHUEHW\DSDU+HSVLEXúHUEHWOH
VDUKRú ROXU YH D\D÷D NDONÕS ³<D $OODK´ GL\HUHN
VHPDKG|QPH\HEDúODUODU
*HOGL&HEUDLOEX\XUGX
+DN0XKDPPHG0XVWDID¶\D
+DNVHQLPLUDFDRNXU
'DYHWLQHNDGLU+GD17
3HUYD]
7RNDWLOoHYHN|\OHULQGHHYOHQPHPLúJHQoELUNÕ]ÕQ
WHN EDúÕQD G|QG÷ \DOQÕ]FD EX LOOHUGH G|QOHQ
VHPDKÕQDGÕGÕU$\QÕ]DPDQGD$QDGROX¶GDVHPDKODU
HQ D] LNL E|OPO ROXS \XUGXPX]GD LNLGHQ ID]OD
E|OPORODQVHPDKODUGDEXOXQPDNWDGÕU6HPDKODUÕQ
EX E|OPOHUL KDON DUDVÕQGD IDUNOÕ LVLPOHQGLUPH
LOH NDUúÕPÕ]D oÕNPDNWDGÕU $÷ÕUODPD <HOGLUPH
3HUYD] dDUN YE LVLPOHU JLEL ³)LLOL RODUDN NDQDW
DoPDN XoPDN DQODPÕQD JHOLU $\UÕFD XoDQ XoXFX
DQODPÕQGDGÕU´ 7RNDW¶WD E|OP DGODQGÕUÕOPDVÕQÕQ
GÕúÕQGD HYOHQPHPLú JHQo NÕ]ÕQ WHN EDúÕQD G|QG÷
VHPDKSHUYD]VHPDKÕRODUDNDGODQGÕUÕOPDNWDGÕU
0XKDPPHG$OLQXUXPX]
7HVOLPROXUNOOYDUÕPÕ]
+DVDQ+VH\LQKXE\kULPL]
øPDP=H\QHOVÕUUÕPÕ]GÕU19
*|QOOHU6HPDKÕ
<|UHOHUHKDVNHQGL\HUHOE|OJHOHUHDLWELUoRNGH÷LúLN
VHPDK |UQHNOHUL EXOXQPDNWDGÕU 0LUDo¶ODPD YH\D
.ÕUNODUVHPDKÕQGDQVRQUDoDOÕQÕSG|QOHQVHPDKODU
ELU DQODPGD J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ RODUDN ELOLQPHNWHGLU
øVPDLOg]PHQ
øVPDLOg]PHQ$OHYL%HNWDúLùLLUOHUL$QWRORMLVL&
<\6D\SD<D\ÕQ'D÷ÕWÕPYH.LWDEHYL$QNDUDV
<|UH7RNDWùHKLWOHUN|\.D\QDNNLúL6DGÕN<DOoÕQ'HUOH
<|UH7RNDWùHKLWOHUN|\.D\QDNNLúL6DGÕN<DOoÕQ'HUOH
ùHKLWOHUN|\.D\QDNNLúL6DGÕN<DOoÕQ'HUOH
N|\.D\QDNNLúL6DGÕN<DOoÕQ'HUOH
\HQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL'HUOHPHWDULKL
0HKPHW$\GR÷PXú
0HKPHW$\GR÷PXú+DONWDQ+DNN¶DJLGHQ\RO6(0$+/$5
<D]ÕW<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXOV
<|UH$PDV\D'DPXGHUH.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
<|UH$PDV\D'DPXGHUH.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQ6HUFDQ<ÕOGÕ]1HFGHW.XUW'HUOHPH
7DULKL
*DEULHO0XKDPPHGEHUGLH(LQODGXQJ*RWWHVXQGGLHQW
LKPGDEHLDOV:HJIKUHU,P+LPPHOWUHIIHQVLHDXIHLQHQ
/|ZHQXQGHLQH6WLPPHVDJW]X0XKDPPHG´'HU/|ZH
YHUODQJW HLQ =HLFKHQ YRQ GLU JLE LKP GHLQHQ 5LQJ´
0XKDPPHG ZLUIW GHQ 5LQJ LQ GHQ 5DFKHQ GHV /|ZHQ
XQGVHW]WVHLQHQ:HJIRUWZREHLHU]XVLFKVDJW´:HQQ
GHU6RKQPHLQHV2QNHOV$OLKLHUJHZHVHQZlUHKDWWHHU
GHQ /|ZHQ EHUZlOWLJW´ 6FKOLH‰OLFK RIIHQEDUW VLFK *RWW
GHP0XKDPPHG(UHUEOLFNW*RWWHV$QWOLW]XQGRIIHQEDUW
LKP LQVJHKHLP QHXQ]LJWDXVHQG *HKHLPQLVVH $XI GHU
5FNUHLVHYRQGHU+LPPHOIDKUWNRPPWHU]XHLQHP+DXV
LQGHPVLFKGLH´9LHU]LJ´]XUFHP=HUHPRQLHHLQJHIXQGHQ
KDEHQ 0DQ HUODXEW LKP MHGRFK QLFKW GDV +DXV ]X
EHWUHWHQ (UVW QDFKGHP HU DXV GHU ´YHUERUJHQHQ :HOW´
HLQH 9HUZDUQXQJHQ EHNRPPW XQG VLFK VFKOLH‰OLFK DOV
´'LHQHUGHU$UPHQ´YRUVWHOOWJLEWPDQLKPGLH(UODXEQLV
HLQ]XWUHWHQ(VVLQGQHXQXQGGUHL‰LJ3HUVRQHQ]XJHJHQGD
6HOPDQL)DUVLGUDX‰HQHLQHQ'LHQVW]XYHUULFKWHQKDWWH
0XKDPPHG VHW]W VLFK QHEHQ $OL XQG IUDJW ´:HU VHLG
LKU"´ 'DUDXIKLQ JLEW PDQ LKP GLH $QWZRUW ´:LU VLQG
GLH 9LHU]LJ :LU VLQG DOOH HLQ +HU] XQG HLQH 6HHOH «
:DVGHUHLQHLVWGDVLVWDXFKGDV*DQ]H´$OV0XKDPPHG
HLQHQ%HZHLVGDIUVHKHQP|FKWHVFKQHLGHWPDQ$OLPLW
HLQHP'ROFKLQGHQ$UPXQG>VLHKHGD@GDV%OXWEHJLQQW
DXV GHP$UP DOOHU$QZHVHQGHQ ]X WURSIHQ (LQ7URSIHQ
%OXWWURSIWYRP'DFKKHUXQWHUZHOFKHVGDV%OXW6HOPDQV
LVW ,P ZHLWHUHQ 9HUODXI EHWULWW 6HOPDQ PLW HLQHU HLQ]LJH
7UDXEH LQ GHU +DQG GDV +DXV XQG VDJW ]X 0XKDPPHG
´2K'LHQHUGHU$UPHQWHLOHGLHVH7UDXEHXQWHUXQVDXI´
0XKDPPHG ]HUGUFNW KLHUDXIKLQ GLH 7UDXEH DXI HLQHP
7HOOHUDXV/LFKWGHQ*DEULHOLKPJHEUDFKWKDWXQGPDFKW
GDUDXV HLQ 6FKHUEHWW 6RUEHWW $OOH ZHUGHQ GDUDXIKLQ
WUXQNHQ QDFKGHP VLH GLHVHV 6FKHUEHWW JHWUXQNHQ KDEHQ
XQG HUKHEHQ VLFK YRQ LKUHQ 3OlW]HQ XQG IDQJHQ DQ ´2K
$OODK´VDJHQG]XWDQ]HQ´
*HOGL&HEUDLOEX\XUGX
+DN0XKDPPHG0XVWDID¶\D
+DNVHQLPLUDFDRNXU
'DYHWLQHNDGLU+GD
3HUYD]
,VWGLH%H]HLFKQXQJIUHLQVHPDKGDVLQGHQ/DQGNUHLVHQ
XQG'|UIHUQYRQ7RNDWYRQHLQHPQLFKWYHUKHLUDWHWHQMXQJHQ
0lGFKHQDOOHLQHJHWDQ]WZLUG'LHVHVVHPDKNRPPWQXULQ
GLHVHU 5HJLRQ YRU 'DV VHPDK EHVWHKW PHLVWHQV DXV ]ZHL
7HLOHQ ZlKUHQG HV DEHU DXFK VHPDK$UWHQ LQ XQVHUHP
/DQGJLEWGLHDXVPHKUDOVDXV]ZHL7HLOHQEHVWHKHQ'LHVH
7HLOHGHVVHPDKKDEHQXQWHUGHU%HY|ONHUXQJYHUVFKLHGHQH
1DPHQ VR ]% ´a÷ÕUODPD´ ´\HOGLUPH´ ´SHUYD]´ RGHU
´çDUN´ >'DV :RUW ´SHUYD]´@ WUlJW GLH %HGHXWXQJ YRQ
´)OJHO DXIVSDQQHQ´ E]Z ´ÀLHJHQ´ 'DUEHU KLQDXV
ÖZMEN6
5HJLRQùHKLWOHU'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH6DGÕN<DOoÕQ=XVDP
5HJLRQùHKLWOHU'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH6DGÕN<DOoÕQ=XVDP
ùHKLWOHU'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH6DGÕN<DOoÕQ=XVDP
'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH6DGÕN<DOoÕQ=XVDP
PHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
*|QOOHU VHPDKÕ ELU DQODPGD FHPH \HQL NDWÕODQ
JHQoOHULQ\ROX|÷UHQPHVLEXUDGDoDOÕQÕSV|\OHQLOHQ
VHPDKODUÕ |÷UHQPHOHUL LoLQ ELOLQHQ VHPDKODUGÕU
7RNDW YH FLYDUÕQGD J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ RODUDN ELOLQHQ
EX VHPDKODU \DúOÕJHQoOHU WDUDIÕQGDQ G|QOU
%XUDGD oDOÕQÕS V|\OHQLOHQ EX VHPDKODU WDEL NL \HUHO
|]HOOLNOHU NDSVDPÕQGD NHQGLQH KDV oDOÕS V|\OHPH
ELoLPLQGHGLU ³*HQoOHUL VHPDKD DOÕúWÕUPD VHPDKÕ
GHQLOHQ *HQoOHU YH *|QOOHU VHPDKÕ |÷UHWLOLU %X
VHPDKODUÕ |÷UHQHQ JHQoOHU GDKD VRQUD YH ]DPDQOD
E\N YH ]RU VHPDKODUÕ |÷UHQLU %|\OHFH FHP YH
PXKDEEHWWRSODQWÕODUÕQGDVHPDKR\QD\DELOLU´
EH]HLFKQHWHVDXFKGLH3HUVRQGLHÀLHJWE]ZÀLHJHQNDQQ
1HEHQGHU%H]HLFKQXQJHLQHV7HLOVGHVVHPDKEH]HLFKQHW
´SHUYD] VHPDKÕ´ HLQHQ VHPDK GDV YRQ HLQHP MXQJHQ
XQYHUKHLUDWHWHQ0lGFKHQJHPDFKWZLUG
0XKDPPHG$OLQXUXPX]
7HVOLPROXUNOOYDUÕPÕ]
+DVDQ+VH\LQKXE\kULPL]
øPDP=H\QHOVÕUUÕPÕ]GÕU
>0XKDPPHG$OLLVWXQVHU/LFKW
*HRSIHUWVHLXQVHUJHVDPWHV+DEXQG*XW
+DVDQXQG+VH\LQVLQGXQVHUHKROGHQ*HOLHEWHQ
XQG,PDP=H\QHOLVWXQVHU*HKHLPQLV@
0HUVL\H
$QDGROX YH JHQLú ELU FR÷UDI\DGD \DúD\DQ 7UN
N|NHQOLWRSOXPODUGD|OHQNLúLQLQDUNDVÕQGDQ\DNÕQODUÕ
WDUDIÕQGDQ D÷ÕWODU \DNÕOÕU |OHQ NLúLQLQ |]HOOLNOHUL
EX D÷ÕWODUGD GLOH JHWLULOLU +DWWD $QDGROX¶QXQ
dDQDNNDOH¶GHQ EDúOD\ÕS NÕ\Õ úHULGLQGH GHYDP HGHQ
*|QOOHU6HPDKÕGDV´VHPDKGHU+HU]HQ´
(V JLEW XQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH $UWHQ GHV VHPDK GLH QXU LQ
EHVWLPPWHQ 5HJLRQHQ YRUNRPPHQ XQG HLQHQ UHJLRQDOHQ
&KDUDNWHU EHVLW]HQ 'DV VHPDK GD QDFK GHU PLUDoODPD
XQG GHP >VRJ@ ´NÕUNODU VHPDKÕ´ JHPDFKW ZLUG LVW DXFK
DOV ´VHPDK GHU +HU]HQ´ ´J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ´ EHNDQQW
'DV >VRJ@ ´J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ´ LVW LP JHZLVVHQ 6LQQH HLQ
VHPDKGDVJHPDFKWZLUGGDPLWGLHMXQJHQ0HQVFKHQGLH
QHX GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ EHLZRKQHQ GHQ >DOHYLWLVFKHQ@
´:HJ´XQGGLHVHPDKOHUQHQ'DVLQ7RNDWXQG8PJHEXQJ
als J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ bekannte VHPDK ZLUG VRZRKO YRQ
lOWHUHQ DOV DXFK YRQ MXQJHQ *HPHLQGHPLWJOLHGHUQ
SUDNWL]LHUW1DWUOLFKKDEHQVLHYRQLKUHU)RUPKHUORNDOH
%HVRQGHUKHLWHQ´0DQOHUQWGDVVRJ´JHQoOHUYHJ|QOOHU
VHPDKÕ´ GDV ´VHPDK GHU MXQJHQ 0HQVFKHQ XQG GHU
+HU]HQ´ GDPLW GLH MXQJHQ 0HQVFKHQ PLW GHP VHPDK
YHUWUDXWZHUGHQ'LHMXQJHQ0HQVFKHQGLHGLHVHVVHPDK
OHUQHQ OHUQHQ PLW GHU =HLW DXFK QRFK XPIDVVHQGHUH XQG
VFKZLHULJHUHVHPDK'HPHQWVSUHFKHQGN|QQHQVLH>VSlWHU@
EHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQXQG/HKUJHVSUlFKHQGDVVHPDK
GXUFKIKUHQ´31
'LH 3HUVRQHQ GLH DP VHPDK teilnehmen P|FKWHQ
bestimmenGHQVRJ´J|]F´$XIVHKHUGHUHLQHQ6WRFN
LQGHU+DQGKDW'DHUZHL‰ZHULQGHU5HJLRQGDVVHPDK
JXW EHKHUUVFKW EHVWLPPW HU DXI GLHVHP :HJH DXFK GLH
Teilnehmer am VHPDK 'LH IU GDV VHPDK DXVHUNRUHQHQ
3HUVRQHQYHUEHXJHQVLFK]XHUVWYRUGHPGHGHXQG]HLJHQ
VLFK JHJHQVHLWLJH LKUH (KUHUELHWXQJ ´'DV KXE\DUVHPDK
LVWLP9HUJOHLFK]XGHQDQGHUHQVHPDKOHLGHQVFKDIWOLFKHU
XQG VFKQHOOHU 'DVV GDV KXE\DUVHPDK als 7RNDWVHPDK
EH]HLFKQHW ZLUG LVW QLFKW ULFKWLJ GD HV QLFKW QXU LQ GHU
5HJLRQ 7RNDW VRQGHUQ DXFK LQ GHQ 5HJLRQHQ 6LYDV
$PDV\D <R]JDW XQG dRUXP OHEHQGHQ +XE\DU6ÕUDo
*HPHLQGHQYHUEUHLWHWLVWXQGDXFKSUDNWL]LHUWZLUG´32
øOKDQ&HP(UVHYHQ
øOKDQ&HP(UVHYHQ$OHYLOHUGH6HPDK$QW\D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQ
EXOV
$OL.HQDQR÷OXøVPDLO2QDUOÕ
$OL.HQDQR÷OXøVPDLO2QDUOÕ+XE\DU6XOWDQ2FD÷ÕYH
%H\GLOL6ÕUDo7UNPHQOHUL.HOHEHN0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXOV
<|UH7RNDW0HUNH].RFDFÕN.|\.D\QDN.LúL7XUDQ
<|UH7RNDW0HUNH].RFDFÕN.|\.D\QDN.LúL7XUDQ
.|\.D\QDN.LúL7XUDQ
.D\QDN.LúL7XUDQ
&DQHU'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL'HUOHPH7DULKL
$<'2ö08ù0HKPHW+DONWDQ+DNN¶DJLGHQ\RO6HPDKODU
<D]ÕW<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXO6
5HJLRQ
5HJLRQ'DPXGHUH'RUI$PDV\D4XHOOH$OLUÕ]D0XWX=X
VDPPHQJHVWHOOWYRQ *DQL 3HNúHQ 6HUFDQ<ÕOGÕ] 1HFGHW .XUW
31 ERSEVEN6
32 .(1$12ö/8ONARLI6
6HPDKD NDONDFDN RODQ NLúLOHUL HOLQGH DVDVÕ RODQ YH
J|]FJ|]OHNoLRODQNLúLEHOLUOHU<|UHGHL\LVHPDK
G|QHQ NLúLOHUL ELOGL÷LQGHQ VHPDKD NDONDQODUÕ GD EX
úHNLOGH EHOLUOHU 6HPDKD NDONDQ NLúLOHU |QFH GHGH\H
VRQUDGDELUELUOHULQHQL\D]HGHUOHU³+XE\DUVHPDKÕ
GL÷HUVHPDKODULoHULVLQGHROGXNoDFRúNXOXKÕ]OÕELU
ULWPH VDKLS ELU VHPDK RODUDN QLWHOHQGLULOPHNWHGLU
+XE\DUVHPDKÕ7RNDWVHPDKÕGL\HGHDGODQGÕUÕOPDNWD
LVH GH EX \DQOÕúWÕU dQN EX VHPDK VDGHFH 7RNDW
E|OJHVLQGHGH÷LO6LYDV7RNDW$PDV\D<R]JDWdRUXP
E|OJHOHULQGH EXOXQDQ +XE\DU 6ÕUDo WRSOXOXNODUÕ
WDUDIÕQGDQELOLQPHNWHYHLFUDHGLOPHNWHGLU´
*DOLEDGQ\DQÕQVRQXQDNDOGÕN
*HOLQEHOOLGLUGHNÕ]EHOOLGH÷LO
1HQDVLKDWGX\GXNQH|÷WDOGÕN
6RKEHWEHOOLGLUV|]EHOOLGH÷LO
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
YH$GDQDKDWWD$QWHSGROD\ODUÕQGD\DúD\DQ7DKWDFÕODU
GDGDKDGD\R÷XQ\DúDQPDNWDGÕUgOPROD\ÕDNúDP
JHUoHNOHúPLú LVH |OHQLQ \DNÕQODUÕ WDUDIÕQGDQ |OQQ
EDúÕQGD D÷ÕW \DNÕOÕU YH V|\OHQLU %XUDGDNL HQ |QHPOL
IDUN LVH 7DKWDFÕ FHPOHULQGH VD] oDODQ VD]DQGDU
|OQQ EDúÕQGD EHNOHU $÷ÕW \DNDQ |OQQ \DNÕQODUÕ
\RUXOGX÷XQGD FHPGH oDOGÕ÷Õ FXUD LOH |OQQ EDúÕQGD
³gOP1HIHVL´oDODUYHV|\OHU+HP|OQQKHPGH
oDOÕQDQ VD]ÕQ V|\OHQLOHQ úLLULQ NXWVDOOÕ÷Õ YH |QHPL
EHOLUWLOLU
³$OHYL%HNWDúL¶OHUFH +LFUHW¶LQ <ÕOÕQÕQ 0XKDUUHP &XPD JQ +] $OL¶QLQ NoN R÷OX +]
0XKDPPHG¶LQWRUXQX+]+VH\LQYH\DQGDúODUÕQÕQ
³.HUEHOD¶GD´ úHKLW HGLOPHVLQGHQ GX\XODQ GHULQ
]QW YH DFÕ ³0DWHP´ RODUDN DOJÕODQÕU 0HUVL\H
|]HOOLNOHøPDP+VH\LQ¶LQúHKDGHWLKDNNÕQGD\D]ÕOPÕú
RODQúLLUOHUHGHQLU´
$OHYL%HNWDúL FHPOHULQGH VHPDKODUGDQ VRQUD VDNND
VX\X GD÷ÕWÕOÕU 6DNND VX\XQGDQ VRQUD LVH FHPGH
VD] oDODQ NLúL PXWODND PHUVL\H RNXU %D]HQ RUDGD
EXOXQDQ NLúLOHUGH WRSOX RODUDN PHUVL\HQLQ V|]OHULQH
HúOLNHGHUOHU+DWWDPHUVL\HRNXQPDGÕNFHPRODPD]
g]HOOLNOH GH PXKDUUHP D\ÕQGD PXWODND PHUVL\HOHU
RNXQXUYHVHVOHQGLULOLU
$WÕQH÷HULQGHGXUDPD]ROGX
'úW+VH\LQ¶LPGúWH\YDKH\
*|]OHULNDQGROGXJ|UHPH]ROGX
'úW+VH\LQ¶LPGúWH\YDKH\
7HYKLG
7HYKLG V|]F÷ 9DKLG¶GHQ JHOPHNWHGLU %LU úH\L
ELUOHPHN LoLQ IDUNOÕOÕNODUÕQ ROPDVÕ JHUHNPHNWHGLU
)DUNOÕOÕNODUÕQ HQ DVJDULVL LNLOLNWLU %XUDGDNL DPDo LVH
LNL\L ELU HWPHNWLU *|UQúWH LNL RODQÕQ KDNLNDWWH ELU
ROPDVÕKDNLNDWJ|]\OHJ|UQPHVLGHPHNWLUdRNOXN
kOHPLQHEDNÕS9DKGHW¶LJ|UPHNDULIROPDGHPHNWLU
*DQL3HNúHQ
*DQL3HNúHQ$QDGROX'HUOHPHOHULP(JHhQLYHUVLWHVL
%DVÕPHYLø]PLUV
<|UH7RNDW$UWRYD<HQLFH.|\.D\QDN.LúL5Õ]Dø\L
<|UH7RNDW$UWRYD<HQLFH.|\.D\QDN.LúL5Õ]Dø\L
.|\.D\QDN.LúL5Õ]Dø\L
.D\QDN.LúL5Õ]Dø\L
OHU'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL'HUOHPH7DULKL
*DOLEDGQ\DQÕQVRQXQDNDOGÕN
*HOLQEHOOLGLUGHNÕ]EHOOLGH÷LO
1HQDVLKDWGX\GXNQH|÷WDOGÕN
6RKEHWEHOOLGLUV|]EHOOLGH÷LO33
>(VVFKHLQWGDVVZLULQGHQOHW]WHQ7DJHQOHEHQ
GLH%UDXWNHQQWPDQDEHUGDV0lGFKHQLVWXQEHNDQQW
:LUKDEHQZHGHU5DWQRFK$QZHLVXQJHUKDOWHQ
GDV*HVSUlFKNHQQWPDQDEHUGLH:RUWHVLQGXQEHNDQQW@
'LHPHUVL\H7UDXHUOLHGHU
6RZRKO LQ $QDWROLHQ DOV LQ ZHLWHQ *HELHWHQ ZR
WUNLVFKVWlPPLJH *HPHLQVFKDIWHQ OHEHQ ZHUGHQ IU GLH
YHUVWRUEHQH 3HUVRQ YRQ GHQ $QJHK|ULJHQ .ODJHOLHGHU
JHVXQJHQ LQ GHQHQ GLH (LJHQVFKDIWHQ GHU YHUVWRUEHQHQ
3HUVRQEHVFKULHEHQZHUGHQ'LHVZLUGEHLGHQ7DKWDFÕVRJDU
YLHOLQWHQVLYHUJHOHEWZHOFKHLQ$QDWROLHQLQGHU5HJLRQ
GLHYRQÇanakkaleEHUGLH.VWHQVWUHLIHQELVQDFK$GDQD
UHLFKWMDVRJDULQ$QWHSOHEHQ:HQQGHU7RGDP$EHQG
HLQJHWUHWHQ LVW ZLUG LQ GHU *HJHQZDUW GHV 9HUVWRUEHQ
YRQGHQ$QJHK|ULJHQGHVVHQ7RGEHNODJWXQGHVZHUGHQ
.ODJHOLHGHU JHVXQJHQ 'HU ZLFKWLJVWH 8QWHUVFKLHG >LP
9HUJOHLFK ]X DQGHUHQ DOHYLWLVFKHQ *HPHLQGHQ@ LVW DEHU
GDVVGHUVRJ´VD]DQGDU´GHUEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQGHU
7DKWDFÕGLHVD]VSLHOWEHLP9HUVWRUEHQHQEOHLEW:HQQGLH
NODJHQGHQ$QJHK|ULJHQGHV9HUVWRUEHQHQPGHJHZRUGHQ
VLQGVSLHOWXQGVLQJWHUPLWVHLQHUFXUD>HLQHNOHLQHVD]@
GLH HU DXFK EHL GHQ FHP=HUHPRQLHQ VSLHOW GDV VRJ
´|OP QHIHVL´ >7RWHQOLHG@ +LHUEHL ZLUG GLH +HLOLJNHLW
XQG %HGHXWXQJ VRZRKO GHV 9HUVWRUEHQHQ DOV DXFK GHU
JHVSLHOWHQVD]XQGGHVYRUJHWUDJHQHQ*HGLFKWVEHWRQW
'LH WLHIH 7UDXHU XQG GHU 6FKPHU] GHQ GLH$OHYLWHQ XQG
%HNWDúLZHJHQGHU(UPRUGXQJ,PDP+VH\LQVGHV6RKQHV
YRQ$OLXQG(QNHOVGHV3URSKHWHQ0XKDPPHGXQGVHLQHU
$QKlQJHU DP )UHLWDJ GHV 0XKDUUHP GHV -DKUHV >LVODPLVFKHU =HLWUHFKQXQJ@ LQ ´.HUEHOD´ HPS¿QGHQ
QHQQWPDQ´PDWHP´>´.XPPHU´@'LH/LHGHUGLHPDQGHU
(UPRUGXQJGHV,PDP+VH\LQJHZLGPHWKDWQHQQWPDQ
´PHUVL\H´
%HL GHQ $OHYLWHQ XQG %HNWDúL ZLUG ZlKUHQG GHU FHP
=HUHPRQLHQ QDFK GHP VHPDK GDV VRJ VDNND:DVVHU
YHUWHLOW 1DFK GHU 9HUWHLOXQJ GHV VDNND:DVVHUV VLQJW
GLH 3HUVRQ GLH EHL GHU FHP=HUHPRQLH VD] VSLHOW LQ
MHGHP )DOO HLQ 7UDXHUOLHG PHUVL\H 0DQFKPDO VLQJHQ
GLHGRUWDQZHVHQGHQ0HQVFKHQJHPHLQVDPGHQ7H[WGHV
7UDXHUOLHGHVPLW(VNDQQNHLQHFHP=HUHPRQLHJHEHQLQ
GHUNHLQ7UDXHUOLHGJHVXQJHQZLUG%HVRQGHUHLP0RQDW
0XKDUUHP ZHUGHQ LQ MHGHP )DOO 7UDXHUOLHGHU PHUVL\H
UH]LWLHUWXQG
JHVXQJHQ
5HJLRQ.RFDFÕN'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH7XUDQ&DQHU=XVDP
5HJLRQ.RFDFÕN'RUI7RNDW4XHOOH7XUDQ&DQHU=XVDP
PHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU<XUWHUL
3(.ù(16
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
6HYJLYHPXKDEEHWOHIDUNOÕOÕ÷ÕQIDUNOÕOÕNODUÕQÕELUDUDGD
ROXQPD\ÕVRKEHWLDQOD\DUDNELUOL÷HJLULSWHYKLGROPD\Õ
NDYUDPDNWÕU7HYKLGKHU]DPDQ\DSÕODQFHPOHUGHGH÷LO
|]HOOLNOH+ÕGÕUHOOH]FHPOHULQGHRNXQXU
*]HO$OODKEL]HEX\UXNEX\XUGX
(\OHQKH\HUHQOHU+DN¶NDQL\D]Õ
0PLQPQDIÕNWDQ|]QD\ÕUGÕ
(\OHQKH\HUHQOHU+DNN¶DQL\D]Õ
6218d
<|UHGHYH\|UHQLQGÕúÕQGDoDOÕúWÕ÷ÕPÕ]ND\QDNNLúLOHU
NHQGL\DSWÕNODUÕ\DGDEXOXQGXNODUÕFHPOHUGHNLoDOÕQÕS
V|\OHQLOHQ WUOHUGHQ |UQHNOHPHOHU \DSPÕúODUGÕU
%X |UQHNOHPHOHUGHQ YH NDUúÕOÕNOÕ J|UúPHOHUGHQ
ELU |QFHNL \DúD\DQ QHVLO LOH JQP]GH \DúD\DQ
YH FHPOHUGH kúÕNOÕN \DSDQ NLúLOHULQGH oDOPD YH
V|\OHPHOHULQGH GH÷LúLNOLNOHULQ \DúDQGÕNODUÕ WHVSLW
HGLOPLúWLU %D]Õ ND\QDN NLúLOHU \HUHO oDOÕS V|\OHPH\L
GHYDP HWWLULUOHUNHQ ED]ÕODUÕ LVH LOHWLúLP DUDoODUÕQGDQ
HWNLOHQLS NHQGL \HUHO WDYÕUODUÕQÕ GH÷LúWLULS GÕú
HWNHQOHUGHQ HWNLOHQGL÷L YH EXQODU JLEL oDOÕS V|\OHPH
WDU]ÕQD JLWWLNOHUL J|UOPHNWHGLU 7HOHYL]\RQODUGD
J|VWHULOHQ FHP W|UHQOHULQGHQ HWNLOHQLS EX W|UHQOHUL
WDNOLW HGHQ EX W|UHQOHULQ NHQGL \HUHO W|UHQOHULQGHQ
GDKD L\L ROGXNODUÕQÕ ]DQQHGHQ ND\QDN NLúLOHUGH
EXOXQPDNWDGÕU%XWDU]NLúLOHULQPHUNH]GHYHPHUNH]H
\DNÕQ RODQ \HUOHUGH \DúDGÕNODUÕ D\QÕ ]DPDQGD GD
NHQGLLOOHULQLQGÕúÕQGDED]ÕNXUXPODUÕQ\DSWÕNODUÕFHP
W|UHQOHULQGH J|UHY \DSWÕNODUÕQGDQ GROD\Õ GD ELUoRN
GH÷LúLNOLNOHU\DúDGÕNODUÕYHNHQGL\HUHO|]HOOLNOHULQGHQ
X]DNODúWÕNODUÕJ|]OHQPLúWLU'DKDFUDQRNWDODUGD\DQL
GD÷OÕNYHPHUNH]HX]DN\DGD\DúOÕRODQND\QDNNLúLOHU
GHLVHEXGH÷LúLNOLNOHUJ|]OHQPHPLúWLU
<DSÕODQoDOÕúPDVRQUDVÕQGDWHVSLWHWWL÷LPL]GL÷HU|QHPOL
|]HOOLNOHUGHQ ELUL GH $QDGROX¶GD +DON H]JLOHULQLQ
LVWHULQDQoLOHLOJLOLROVXQLVWHUVHGHLQDQoGÕúÕH]JLOHU
ROVXQ WRSODQPDPÕú ROGX÷XQX YH KDON DUDVÕQGD XVWD
oÕUDN LOLúNLOHU LOH \DúDWÕOGÕ÷Õ J|UOPHNWHGLU %L]LP
\DSWÕ÷ÕPÕ]EXoDOÕúPD]DPDQDoÕVÕQGDQNÕVÕWOÕGDROVD
ELUoRNH]JLQLQYHW|UHQLQ\DúDWÕOPDELoLPLNRQXVXQGD
\HWHUOL ROGX÷X NDQDDWLQGH\L] %XUDGD KHP \HUHO
<|UH$PDV\D'DPXGHUH.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
<|UH$PDV\D'DPXGHUH.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
.|\.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
.D\QDN.LúL$OLUÕ]D0XWX
'HUOH\HQ*DQL3HNúHQ6HUFDQ<ÕOGÕ]1HFGHW.XUW'HUOHPH
7DULKL
$WÕQH÷HULQGHGXUDPD]ROGX
'úW+VH\LQ¶LPGúWH\YDKH\
*|]OHULNDQGROGXJ|UHPH]ROGX
'úW+VH\LQ¶LPGúWH\YDKH\
>(UNRQQWHVLFKQLFKWPHKUDXIGHP3IHUGKDOWHQ
RKZHKRKZHK+VH\LQLVWJHIDOOHQJHIDOOHQ
6HLQH$XJHQ IOOWHQ VLFK PLW %OXW HU NRQQWH QLFKW PHKU
VHKHQ
RKZHKRKZHK+VH\LQLVWJHIDOOHQJHIDOOHQ@
'DVWHYKLG
'DV :RUW ´WHYKLG´ VWDPPW YRQ GHP :RUW ´YDKLG´ ´GHU
(LQH´ 8P HWZDV ]XU (LQKHLW ]X IKUHQ PXVV HV HLQH
9HUVFKLHGHQDUWLJNHLW JHEHQ 'DV ]HLJW VLFK LQ VHLQHU
HLQIDFKVWHQ )RUP DOV =ZHLKHLW 'HU 6LQQ XQG =ZHFN
KLHUEHL GK EHL GHU +LQIKUXQJ ]XU (LQKHLW LVW GLH
=ZHLKHLW LQ GHU (LQKHLW DXIJHKHQ ]X ODVVHQ :DV DOV
=ZHLKHLW HUVFKHLQW LVW LQ :DKUKHLW HLQV 'LHV NDQQ PDQ
QXUPLWGHP$XJHGHU:DKUKHLWHUNHQQHQ(LQ*QRVWLNHU
DULI]XVHLQKHL‰WGLHPDQQLJIDOWLJH:HOW]XEHWUDFKWHQ
XQGGLH(LQKHLW]XHUNHQQHQ(VKHL‰WPLW/LHEHXQG*WH
GLH 9HUVFKLHGHQDUWLJNHLW GHU PDQQLJIDOWLJHQ 'LQJH ]X
EHUZLQGHQ GLH /HKUJHVSUlFKH ]X EHJUHLIHQ XQG LQ GLH
(LQKHLW ]X WDXFKHQ 'DV WHYKLG ZLUG QLFKW EHL GHQ VWHWV
VWDWW¿QGHQGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQVRQGHUQYRUDOOHPEHLGHU
VRJKÕGGÕUHOOH]FHP=HUHPRQLHSUDNWL]LHUW
*]HO$OODKEL]HEX\UXNEX\XUGX
(\OHQKH\HUHQOHU+DN¶NDQL\D]Õ
0PLQPQDIÕNWDQ|]QD\ÕUGÕ
(\OHQKH\HUHQOHU+DNN¶DQL\D]Õ
>8QVHUKROGH*RWWKDWXQVHWZDVDXIJHWUDJHQ
2K0HQVFKHQZHUIWHXFKQLHGHUYRU*RWW
'HU*OlXELJHVROOGHP8QJOlXELJHQIHUQEOHLEHQ
2K0HQVFKHQZHUIWHXFKQLHGHUYRU*RWW@
)D]LW
'LH3HUVRQGLHXQVDOV4XHOOHJHGLHQWXQGPLWGHQHQZLULQ
E]ZDX‰HUKDOEGHU5HJLRQ]XVDPPHQJHDUEHLWHWHQKDEHQ
OLHIHUWHQXQV%HLVSLHOHYRQ0XVLNVWFNHQGLHLQGHQFHP
=HUHPRQLHQ JHVSLHOWHQ XQG JHVXQJHQHQ DQ GHQHQ VLH
VHOEHU PLWZLUNWHQ RGHU QXU WHLOJHQRPPHQ KDEHQ $XV
GLHVHQ%HLVSLHOHQYRQ0XVLNVWFNHQXQGGHQSHUV|QOLFKHQ
*HVSUlFKHQVWHOOWHVLFKKHUDXVGDVVHV]XHLQHU9HUlQGHUXQJ
LQGHU$UWXQG:HLVHZLHGLH/LHGHUJHVXQJHQZHUGHQEHL
GHUlOWHUHQ*HQHUDWLRQXQGGHUKHXWLJHQ*HQHUDWLRQJLEW
GLHDOVƗúÕNEHLGHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQDXIWUHWHQ:lKUHQG
5HJLRQ7RNDW$UWRYD<HQLFH.|\4XHOOSHUVRQ5Õ]Dø\LOHU
5HJLRQ7RNDW$UWRYD<HQLFH.|\4XHOOSHUVRQ5Õ]Dø\LOHU
ø\LOHU
=XVDPPHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQg]JU
<XUWHUL'DWXPGHU=XVDPPHQVWHOOXQJ
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWGDVYRQGHU(LQKHLW*RWWHVE]ZGHU
>(LQEHVWLPPWHV*HGLFKWGDVYRQGHU(LQKHLW*RWWHVE]ZGHU
P\VWLVFKHQ(LQKHLWKDQGHOW@
´+ÕGÕUHOOH]´LVWHLQ)UKOLQJVIHVWGHU$OHYLWHQZHOFKHVDP
´+ÕGÕUHOOH]´LVWHLQ)UKOLQJVIHVWGHU$OHYLWHQZHOFKHVDP
0DLHUIROJW$Gh
5HJLRQ $PDV\D'DPXGHUH .|\ 4XHOOSHUVRQ $OLUÕ]D
0XWX=XVDPPHQJHVWHOOWYRQ*DQL3HNúHQ6HUFDQ
<ÕOGÕ]1HFGHW.XUW'DWXPGHU=XVDPPHQVWHOOXQJ
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ
oDOPDYHV|\OHPHELoLPL\DúDUNHQKHPGHNDGÕQODUÕQ
JHOHQHNOHULQH ED÷OÕOÕNODUÕ JL\GLNOHUL NÕ\DIHWWHQ RUWD\D
oÕNPDNWDGÕU
*QON \DúDPODUÕQÕQ GÕúÕQGD |]HOOLNOH W|UHQOHUGH
LQDQo YH\D LQDQo GÕúÕ W|UHQOHUGH EX NÕ\DIHWOHU
JL\LOPHNWHJHOHQHN\DúDWÕOPDNWDGÕU
ÆúÕNODUÕQ ED]ÕODUÕ ³%R]XN G]HQ´ oDOÕS H]JLOHUL EX
G]HQGH VHVOHQGLULUNHQ ED]ÕODUÕ GD %D÷ODPD G]HQL
LOH oDOÕS V|\OHPHNWHGLUOHU <DSWÕ÷ÕPÕ] EX oDOÕúPD
HVQDVÕQGD JQP] FHP kúÕNODUÕQÕQ EDED YH\D
GHGHOHULQLQLVHED÷ODPDG]HQLKDWWDVD]ODUÕQÕQLVH
SHUGHOLROGXNODUÕQÕEHOLUWPLúOHUGLU
$\QÕ kúÕNODU EDED YH GHGHOHULQLQ ³GH\Lú´
DGODQGÕUPDVÕQGDQ GDKD oRN ³D\HW´ terimlerinin
NXOODQGÕNODUÕQÕ EHOLUWPLúOHUGLU %D]ÕODUÕ GD %D÷ODPD
\D GD kúÕNlama G]HQL \HULQH GH ³$\HW´ G]HQL
GHPHNWHGLUOHU8]XQKDYDODUJHQHOOLNOH³'RP]WH]DG´
RODUDNoDOÕQPÕúWÕU
6HPDKODU JHQHOOLNOH LNL E|OPO ROXS $÷ÕUODPD YH
\HOGLUPHLOHDGODQGÕUÕOPDNWDGÕU$÷ÕUODPDE|OPOHULGH
]DPDQOÕROPDNWDGÕU<HOGLUPHE|OPLVHJHQHOOLNOH
¶OÕN ELULPOHUGH YH ROGXNoD KÕ]OÕGÕU *|QOOHU
VHPDKÕ 7RNDW 6LYDV $PDV\D <R]JDW YH oRUXP
LOOHULQGH ROXS EXUDGD \DúD\DQ 6ÕUDo 7UNPHQOHUL
WDUDIÕQGDQLFUDHGLOPHNWHGLU
.$<1$.d$
$9&, $OL +D\GDU 2VPDQOÕ *L]OL 7DULKLQGH 3ø5
68/7$1 $%'$/ YH %h7h1 '(<øù/(5ø Nokta
.LWDSøVWDQEXO
'(9(/ø2ö/8
)HULW
2VPDQOÕFD7UNoH
$QVLNORSHGLN/€JDW$\GÕQ.LWDEHYL$QNDUD
(56(9(1 øOKDQ &HP $OHYLOHUGH 6HPDK $QW
\D\ÕQODUÕøVWDQEXO
.(1$12ö/8 $OL21$5/, øVPDLO +XE\DU
6XOWDQ 2FD÷Õ YH %H\GLOL 6ÕUDo7UNPHQOHUL .HOHEHN
0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXO
GLH lOWHUH *HQHUDWLRQ GDEHL EOLHE LQ GHU UHJLRQDOHQ
*HVDQJVDUW]XVSLHOHQZXUGHQHLQLJH>0XVLNHU@YRQGHQ
0HGLHQ EHHLQÀXVVW lQGHUWHQ GLH LKQHQ HLJHQWPOLFKH
*HVDQJVDUW ZXUGHQ YRQ DX‰HQ EHHLQÀXVVW XQG ¿QJHQ
DQ VR ]X VSLHOHQ XQG ]X VLQJHQ QDKPHQ HLQH DQGHUH$UW
XQG:HLVH]XVLQJHQXQG]XVSLHOHQDQ(VJLEWDEHUDXFK
3HUVRQHQ GLH XQV DOV 4XHOOH GLHQWHQ GLH DQ GHQ LQ GHQ
)HUQVHKVHQGHUQDXVJHVWUDKOWHQFHP=HUHPRQLHQ*HIDOOHQ
IDQGHQGLHVHQDFK]XDKPHQEHJDQQHQXQGGLHDQ¿QJHQ]X
JODXEHQGDVVVLHEHVVHUDOVLKUHHLJHQHQZlUHQ(VZXUGH
EHREDFKWHW GDVV GLHVH $UW YRQ 0HQVFKHQ GLH VLFK YRQ
LKUHQORNDOHQ(LJHQKHLWHQHQWIHUQWHQLQ=HQWUHQ>"@RGHU
LQ *HJHQGHQ OHEWHQ GLH QDK DP =HQWUXP ODJHQ XQG GLH
]XJOHLFKDXFKEHLFHP=HUHPRQLHQHLQLJHU(LQULFKWXQJHQ
DX‰HUKDOE LKUHU 6WlGWH VHOEVW PLWZLUNW KDEHQ XQG GDKHU
YLHOH 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ PLWHUOHEWHQ 'LHVH 9HUlQGHUXQJHQ
ZXUGHQ LQ QRFK HQWOHJHQHUHQ QlPOLFK LQ EHUJLVFKHQ
RGHU YRP =HQWUXP HQWIHUQWHQ 5HJLRQHQ RGHU EHL lOWHUHQ
3HUVRQHQGLHXQVDOV4XHOOHGLHQWHQQLFKWEHREDFKWHW
(LQH GHU ZHLWHUHQ ZLFKWLJHQ (LJHQKHLWHQ GLH ZLU DP
(QGH XQVHUHU 6WXGLHQ IHVWVWHOOHQ NRQQWHQ ZDU GDVV GLH
DQDWROLVFKHQ9RONVOLHGHUXQDEKlQJLJGDYRQREVLHPLWGHP
*ODXEHQ]XWXQKDEHQRGHUQLFKWQLFKW]XVDPPHQJHWUDJHQ
ZRUGHQ ZDUHQ XQG GXUFK HLQH :HLWHUJDEH YRQ 0HLVWHU
VSLHOHUXQG6FKOHULQQHUKDOEGHU%HY|ONHUXQJDP/HEHQ
JHKDOWHQ ZXUGHQ $XFK ZHQQ ZLU EHL XQVHUHQ 6WXGLHQ
]HLWOLFKEHJUHQ]WZDUHQVLQGZLUGHUhEHU]HXJXQJGDVVGLH
%HPKXQJHQYLHOHGHU0HORGLHQXQG6LWWHQXQG%UlXFKHQ
]XHUKDOWHQDXVUHLFKHQGVLQG'LHUHJLRQDOH*HVDQJVNXOWXU
LVWOHEHQGLJXQGGLHYRQGHQ)UDXHQJHWUDJHQHQ7UDFKWHQ
PDFKHQ GLH 9HUEXQGHQKHLW ]XU 7UDGLWLRQ GHXWOLFK 'LHVH
7UDGLWLRQ>GKGDV7UDJHQGHU7UDFKWHQ@ZLUGGDGXUFKDP
/HEHQJHKDOWHQGDVVGLH7UDFKWHQVRZRKOLPDOOWlJOLFKHQ
/HEHQ DOV DXFK EHL UHOLJL|VHQ XQG QLFKWUHOLJL|VHQ
=HUHPRQLHQXQG)HVWHQJHWUDJHQZHUGHQ
:lKUHQG HLQLJH ƗúÕN LQ GHU >VRJ@ /D5H6RO6WLPPXQJ
´ER]XNG]HQ´VSLHOHQXQGVLQJHQEHQXW]HQDQGHUHGLH
>VRJ@ /D5H0L6WLPPXQJ ´ED÷ODPD G]HQL´ 8QVHUH
6WXGLHQ KDEHQ JH]HLJW GDVV ZlKUHQG GLH 9lWHU RGHU
*UR‰YlWHUGHUƗúÕNGHUFHP=HUHPRQLHQFHPkúÕNODUÕLQ
GHU/D5H0L6WLPPXQJVSLHOWHQVLHVRJDUVD]EHQXW]WHQ
GLH]Z|OI%QGHEHVD‰HQ
(V ZXUGH HEHQIDOOV GHXWOLFK GDVV VLH LP *HJHQVDW] ]X
LKUHQ 9lWHUQ XQG *UR‰YlWHUQ GLH GHQ %HJULII ´GH\Lú´
>IU GLH UHOLJL|VHQ /LHGHU XQG *HGLFKWH@ JHEUDXFKWHQ
GHQ%HJULII´D\HW´YHUZHQGHWHQ(LQLJHVSUHFKHQDQVWDWW
YRQGHUED÷ODPDE]ZDúÕNODPD6WLPPXQJYRQGHUD\HW
6WLPPXQJ 'LH >VRJ@ ´X]XQ KDYD´ ZHUGHQ JHQHUHOO DOV
´GRP]WH]DG´JHVSLHOW
Das VHPDK EHVWHKW JUXQGVlW]OLFK DXV ]ZHL 7HLOHQ GLH
´D÷ÕUODPD´XQG´\HOGLUPH´JHQDQQWZHUGHQ'LHD÷ÕUODPD
KDWHLQHHU7DNWXQJ'LH\HOGLUPHKLQJHJHQKDWPHLVWHQV
HLQH7DNWXQJXQGLVWVRPLWYLHOVFKQHOOHU'DV´VHPDK
GHU +HU]HQ´ ´J|QOOHU VHPDKÕ´ NRPPW LQ GHQ 6WlGWHQ
7RNDW 6LYDV$PDV\D <R]JDW XQG dRUXP YRU XQG ZLUG
YRQGHQKLHUOHEHQGHQ6ÕUDo7XUNPHQHQSUDNWL]LHUW
>(VKDQGHOWVLFKKLHUEHLXPQLFKWUK\WKPLVFKH/LHGHU@
>(VKDQGHOWVLFKKLHUEHLXPQLFKWUK\WKPLVFKH/LHGHU@
>"@
FORSCHUNGSZEITSCHRIFT ÜBER ALEVITENTUM UND BEKTASCHITENTUM
g=0(1 øVPDLO $OHYL%HNWDúL ùLLUOHUL $QWRORMLVL
& <\ 6D\SD <D\ÕQ 'D÷ÕWÕP YH .LWDEHYL
$QNDUD
3(.ù(1 *DQL $QDGROX 'HUOHPHOHULP (JH
hQLYHUVLWHVL%DVÕPHYLø]PLU
3URI 'U %2.857 )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO
%R\XWODUÕ<D\ODFÕN0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXO
ù(1(5 &HPDO %HQLP .kEHP øQVDQGÕU $'
<D\ÕQFÕOÕNøVWDQEXO
/LWHUDWXUYHU]HLFKQLV
AVCI $OL +D\GDU 2VPDQOÕ *L]OL 7DULKLQGH 3LU 6XOWDQ
$EGDOYHEWQGH\LúOHUL1RNWD.LWDSøVWDQEXO
'(9(/,2ö/8)HULW2VPDQOÕFD7UNoH$QVLNORSHGLN/€JDW
$\GÕQ.LWDEHYL$QNDUD
ERSEVEN øOKDQ &HP $OHYLOHUGH 6HPDK $QW \D\ÕQODUÕ
øVWDQEXO
.(1$12ö/8$OLONARLIøVPDLO+XE\DU6XOWDQ2FD÷ÕYH
%H\GLOL 6ÕUDo 7UNPHQOHUL .HOHEHN 0DWEDDVÕ øVWDQEXO
ÖZMEN øVPDLO $OHYL%HNWDúL ùLLUOHUL $QWRORMLVL %QG 66D\SD<D\ÕQ'D÷ÕWÕPYH
.LWDEHYL$QNDUD
3(.ù(1*DQL$QDGROX'HUOHPHOHULP(JHhQLYHUVLWHVL
%DVÕPHYLø]PLU
BOZKURT )XDW $OHYLOL÷LQ 7RSOXPVDO %R\XWODUÕ <D\ODFÕN
0DWEDDVÕøVWDQEXO
ùENER &HPDO %HQLP .kEHP øQVDQGÕU $' <D\ÕQFÕOÕN
øVWDQEXO
3Ë50%/('+-(
.XUVWXGMRMPsPX]LNsQWUDGLFLRQDOHWs7RNDWLWGKH]RQDYHSsUUUHWKGDOORKHWTsNDQMsPsQ\UsNDUDNWHULVWLNHQs
OXDMWMHQGKHWKsQMHQHNsQJsYH$VKWXVLGKHQs]RQDWHWMHUDWs$QDGROOLWHGKHQs7RNDWUXKHQQXDQFDWsQGU\VKPHWsFLODW
HWUHJRMQsYHWsQHW\UHGKHTsHJ]LVWRMQsHGKHQsEHVLPHWPLVWLNH3sUVKHPEXOONsQJsWSRSXOORUH5HúDGL\H5HVKDGLMH
NDQsYHoRULQsTsOXKHQGKHWKXKHQNsQGRKHQHNsWsJMsHVKRKLPHGKHQs³$MHWHW%HMWHWGKH6HPDW´TsWKXKHQQs;KHP
1sGLDOHNWLQYHQGDVNMRPsQ\UsNsQGLPLTXKHW³)DGLND÷]Õ´GKHPHNsWsPsQ\UsKDVLPHGKHQsSsUULWHWH;KHPLW
1sSsUIXQGLPWsVWXGLPHYHTsNHPLEsrsQsUUHWKLQ7RNDWSsUYHoQMsJUXSLWsQMRKXUVL$OHYLWsFLOsWSRWLVKRKLP
QsWKHOEMDQs³$OHYLWs6LUDNXW´QsNsWs]RMQsMHWRMQsHGKH%DNWDVKLQMVLGKH$OHYLWsDUGKXUQJD]RQDWsWMHUD&HPUHPRQLWs
ULWXDOHWsFHPLWQs¿OOLPGXNHQVLNXUMDQsQMsVRMSRUQJDVWXGLPLTsNHPLEsrsXYXUHVHQsWKHOENDQsQGU\VKLPH
6LQsWsJMLWKsT\WHWHWHPsGKDHGKHQs7RNDWGKH]RQDWUUHWKWLMNDQJMDVKPsULQsULWHWH[KHPLWVHSVHDOHYLWsMDQs
WsNXMGHVVKsPSsUWsVLJXUXDUYD]KGLPsVLQsHUUXJss ssW\UHGKHWUHJRMQsWsQMHMWLQNXMGHVHGKHSsUYRNDOLQGKHUsQMHVVs
6D]LWPMHWPX]LNRUTsQJMDQPHoLIWHOLQsSRUNDPsVKXPsWHODGKHsVKWsPsHPDGKH
3sU VKHPEXOO Qs T\WHWLQ H 7RNDWLW PsQ\UD H YRNDOL]LPLW Ws NsQJsYH SRSXOORUH EsKHW VLSDV GLVD VKDEOORQDYH H
PHJMLWKDWsSsUGLVDGHGHGKHDVKLNsWs[KHPLWNMRQXNsVKWsHUsQGsVLVKPH1sQMsNRKsTsSsrWsVLJXUXDUYD]KGLPsVLQs
HNXOWXUsVGKHYHoRULYHNDUDNWHULVWLNHWs]RQsVGRWsWKRWsWsVKSUHKHVKPHSDVXULWsHNXOWXUsVTsHJ]LVWRMQsDWMH3sr
VKHPEXOONRKsPsSDUsHQMHMWDEHMWHTsNsQGRKHWHOXKHWQs$UJXYDQWs0DODW\DV0DOODWMDV sVKWsQGU\VKHQD$UDSKLU
$\GÕQ $MGsQ 6LYDV DSR 0DUDú 0DUDVK SRU WDVKPs Qs Ws JMLWKD NsWR ]RQD KDVLP JDWL JDWL Ws Qs Ws QMHMWsQ PsQ\Us
NsQGLPL3sUKDSMDHPMHWsYHWsNRPXQLNLPLWGDOMDQsSDKHNXOWXUsVPRGHUQHVsPRGsVNDEsrsQMsQGLNLPQHJDWLYPEL
QMHUs]LW
1s NsWs ]RQs QMHUs]LW SsUYHo PX]LNsV SRSXOORUH Qs GLVD NRKs Ws FDNWXDUD Ws YLWLW PEOLGKHQ HGKH SsU Ws NU\HU
GHW\ULPHWHULWHWYHIHWDUH6LSDVYHoRULYHWsNsW\UH[KHPUDYHSHUVRQDWTsNDQsGHW\UDQsID]DWsQGU\VKPHWsULWXDOHYH
Ws FLOsW TXKHQ DVKLN Ws ;KHPLW PH 6D] Qs GRUs OXDMQs NsQJs SRSXOORUH Ws OORMHYH Ws QGU\VKPH VL %HMWH GXD]Õ øPDPD
PLKUDoODPD3HUYD]7HYKLGGKHNsQGRMQsVHPDWs]HPUDYH
)XVKDMRQsHVWXGLPLWNDVLTsOOLPWsLGHQWL¿NRMsPHORGLWsTsOXDMQsGKHNsQGRMQsDVKLNsWH[KHPLWGKHWsEsKHW
VWXGLPLLPsQ\UsVVsOXDMWMHVVsW\UHQsNsWs]RQs
)MDOsWN\oH$MHW%HMWL'XD]ÕLPDP0LKUDoODPD6HPDH=HPUDYH
$/(9ø/ø.%(.7$ùø/ø.$5$ù7,50$/$5,'(5*ø6ø 6D\Õ